Ye manish rahul gandhi ki good books me nahi hai is liye kaam ki baat kar ra jo good books me hai une rahul ki bakchodiyo se fursat mile to kuch pooche........ Or jaha tak rahi opposition ki baat to bjp sabse aachi opposition thi kam se kam satta pane k lalach me videsiyo ki god me to ni beth jati thi rahul videsi daure pe khilstaniyo se mila RO KHANNA se ..us ilaan omar se mil k photo khichvai jisne POK me ja k bola tha ki kasmir pakistan ka hai or yaha rahul k chamche uski chatne se baaz ni aate.....
He is simply talking nonsense.. PM Modi and jai Shankar visiting these countries doesn’t mean the have india first policy. Obviously they hv sidelined india
@madamsahab9808 He worked as a diplomat in past for more than 30 years so he is bound to answer like this as he is not well accustomed to domestic politics. Secondly what you expect how he should have answer that question honestly and bluntly when he knows that whole world is watching and these debates can be used by anti-India elements against India.(He is a foreign minister not Home minister he is answerable to international community as well).
Babri moshjeed has broken by Bjp😂 Bangladeshi high Commission attacked by BJP 😂 Over one years war in Monipur 😂 Boycott varor 100%❤ Freedom seven Sisters ❤
कायर है एक नंबर का यह लोडू घंटे की विदेश पालिसी , बांग्लादेश जैसे आँख दिखा रहे हैं और यह कीड़े मुंह तोड़ जबाब कड़ी निंदा अमेरिका के जूते चाटने में लगे रहते हैं ,
@@mostakfjeld3326For your kind information it's Manipur not monipur . And whatever they think or print in their map or currency it is not our problem what congress did when china showed our territory in their maps . Did congress protest . And for our seven sisters the sisters belong to us and we will look after it .
that's the great democracy where opposition asked question walking off is never been a solution no matter whether the question is right or wrong we as the people of India felt that we were questioning against foreign minister and how beautifully he answered
As Sri Lankans we're extremely greatful for people of India for the help during the 2022 crisis. Without that help I don't know where we will ended up.
Kudos, wow this is a really good and welcome change we are seeing in our parkiament. We are seeing our ministers dressed professionally, speak so calmly and professionally. This is amazing. Keep up the good work gentlemen.
This is very healthy discussion about our foreign policy in recent past. I would regard to all ministers for raising very crucial questions and our stunt with neighbors. Thank so much to all.
You are amazing Jaishanker sir. How intelligently, promptly and humbly you answers each question that has been raised by the members, how respectfully you talk, salutations to you sir. You ate indeed a star!!!!
very good questions and their good response! This interaction gives hope that our politicians still have some intellectual mindset left. I hope the sansad continues to work with dialogue and India first mindset.
These are the sort of questions we expect our opposition to ask the government. These are the kind of constructive discussions we, Indians, would like our parliamentarians to have. The government needs to do more on the Manipur issue, Myanmar drug issue and Bangladesh’s persecution of minorities!
Om Birla should not interrupt the opposition from asking important questions. Even we citizens have those questions. He was framing it extremely well and putting emphasis on what mattered but was continuously interrupted by the speaker. S. Jaishankar as always was very graceful and gave informative answers while still being very cautious which is befitting for an external affairs minister/ diplomat. His statements have the potential to cause an international crisis if not thought about carefully.🙏 Great session nonetheless!
Finally! These kinds of debates are welcome. Opposition should ask questions. Government should answer and vice-versa. Yells and fights are so filthy and irrational. We are common citizens looking for clarity, accountability and transparency. We want this kind of sanity amongst MPs. Well done. 🙏
I think putting aside all the emotions and political differences, this kind of session- well spoken MP from both sides, questions were very valid and both parties took it very well. We should respect that.. everyone acted their part. The opp raised legit q, the FM answered it very well.
@Viehere is it...thx for info.. then why they are not shouting? If they are more educated then why they are wasting time on unnecessary topics...they should do good business in parliament...
Someone should ask some concrete questions. This is like giving class 5 questions to a college student. Questions like, -any steps to improve & regulate security of India's information space should be brought up. -whether funding & actions of foreign NGOs operating in the country is monitored n not turned a blind eye. These 2 points are crucial in the spectrum of protecting National interests, by preventing the population within to be catapulted as orchestrators of the nation's downfall. Recent events in Bangladesh is a result of these 2 matters going uncontrolled
OMG Birla's face says it all ! How he looks at one side of the House with irritation & anger writlarge on his face while the other side is favoured with fond indulnt smiles,no matter what they do. His place in History is assured.
First neighbourhood will become a disaster policy in my opinion. But see, i am not into politics it's a pure opinion. Based on my 24 years age 😅 i have never seen pak doing favour for us or atleast sri Lanka doing it😂. Pak favours usa and china Nepali also usa and china Sri lanka no need for mentioning 😂they have provided free access to Chinese and American navy. Now comes bangladesh 😅 another beauty, Just spewing venom on us. Now you want a neighborhood first policy 😂? But see my opinion my sarcastic laughter can be overturned with the wit of our leaders like amit shah ji, jaishankar ji etc, as there is a possibility for anything. I just hope for best for our country 🙏🏻. Love india ❤.
See neighborhood policy is needed Otherwise it will be win for china. China wants to be the only powerful country in Asia. We need to have good relationship with all our neighbours. In today's world military warfare is not needed much what we need is technology technological warfare is going to be the upcoming war
Once 2 friends studied in same class one topped the class one failed.... now that failed friend became jealous .... And we can see the outcomes of jealousy
These country are only friend s when they want money... Like Sri Lanka maldives and nepal... Bangladesh radical nature make Pakistan look Secular. Most of these countries want to benifit out of India china Rivalry.
This is why India needs new blood like the kind Trump has employed to deal with issues facing India instead of just spewing vomitt of useless words instead of actually taking action to plave pressure on Indias neighbour's who continues to exploit Indias studpidy of sticking to outdated exploited policies by Indias neighbour's.
When accuser starts accusing using info from tiktok and instagram videos. Lolz. On serious note, Mr. Jaishankar always impresses me with his diplomatic conversations and his knowledge. Kudos.
Plz run parliament like this. healthy discussion is what we are looking for
i know right. this is nice to see as well
This rajya sabha that's why polite
No it's taking place in lok sabha@@shub6707
@@shub6707loksabha
Reason is Rahul gandhi is not present and his unnecessary debate is not there
I love that there are still people in opposition that ask quesn instead of shouting like Holligans!!
Normally the shouting are mostly from the BJP side. It's normal for BJP 😂
Because INC is in opposition not BJP 😂
Maybe they don't find it worthwhile to do it in English 😂
That family is the only problem in INC... and that family will never give the lead to any educated individual in the party... 😓
Ye manish rahul gandhi ki good books me nahi hai is liye kaam ki baat kar ra jo good books me hai une rahul ki bakchodiyo se fursat mile to kuch pooche........ Or jaha tak rahi opposition ki baat to bjp sabse aachi opposition thi kam se kam satta pane k lalach me videsiyo ki god me to ni beth jati thi rahul videsi daure pe khilstaniyo se mila RO KHANNA se ..us ilaan omar se mil k photo khichvai jisne POK me ja k bola tha ki kasmir pakistan ka hai or yaha rahul k chamche uski chatne se baaz ni aate.....
Great Diplomat, Foreign Minister, Politician and above all a great human being a true gem of India.
He is simply talking nonsense.. PM Modi and jai Shankar visiting these countries doesn’t mean the have india first policy. Obviously they hv sidelined india
@madamsahab9808 He worked as a diplomat in past for more than 30 years so he is bound to answer like this as he is not well accustomed to domestic politics.
Secondly what you expect how he should have answer that question honestly and bluntly when he knows that whole world is watching and these debates can be used by anti-India elements against India.(He is a foreign minister not Home minister he is answerable to international community as well).
Babri moshjeed has broken by Bjp😂 Bangladeshi high Commission attacked by BJP 😂 Over one years war in Monipur 😂 Boycott varor 100%❤ Freedom seven Sisters ❤
कायर है एक नंबर का यह लोडू घंटे की विदेश पालिसी , बांग्लादेश जैसे आँख दिखा रहे हैं और यह कीड़े मुंह तोड़ जबाब कड़ी निंदा अमेरिका के जूते चाटने में लगे रहते हैं ,
@@mostakfjeld3326For your kind information it's Manipur not monipur . And whatever they think or print in their map or currency it is not our problem what congress did when china showed our territory in their maps . Did congress protest . And for our seven sisters the sisters belong to us and we will look after it .
Wonderful to see our politicians having constructive debate
Dr S Jaishankar is a true philomath. This is why we need “educated” ministers. Glad we have this IFS officer^
This is a healthy discussion. Thanks for that MP asking good questions and appreciate FM's response ❤
Eloquent questions and very methodical answers!
This is the quality of Question Hour we deserve!
S jaishankar is simply awesome .
His foreign policy is a failure.
that's the great democracy where opposition asked question walking off is never been a solution no matter whether the question is right or wrong we as the people of India felt that we were questioning against foreign minister and how beautifully he answered
He is amazing !! Jaishankar ji, I dont mind seeing you as PM too.
As Sri Lankans we're extremely greatful for people of India for the help during the 2022 crisis. Without that help I don't know where we will ended up.
If only all debates and question answers were like this .
Kudos, wow this is a really good and welcome change we are seeing in our parkiament. We are seeing our ministers dressed professionally, speak so calmly and professionally. This is amazing. Keep up the good work gentlemen.
Best foreign minister ever India had. So you all know . Nothing much to say
So funny when Owaisi talks about saving Hindus in Bangladesh....
Owaisi to khud bolrahatha pehle on record ki "why do we have to care about Bangladeshi Hindu"💀
When Yogi will talk about save muslims in India?
Ye clip viral karo bhailog... owaisi ji is concerned about hindus in Bangladesh
At least he talked.
@@fadedsoul6127show one evidence yogi said or his government said that he is against or harm. Dont just put non proof quotes
This Kind of Debate we Need from opposition When congress and Other Partners would understand
Sri Lankans are eternally grateful for indian support in difficult times and the wormath shown bu Indian External affairs minister. ❤🎉😊
Kudos to the calm and composed answers of Jai Shankar Sir... Fantastic answers...🎉
8:33 Oh my god.
Did you people hear what he told ?
is that real Owaisi ?
yes very good question on minority, but the minister should now use army to tell bangadesh to behave normally
Contrary to popular belief and apart from never-ending trolling, he is not much of an extremist and usually speaks about the Rule of Law.
Buddy I heard this 3 times. was that told by Oaisy?... I'm still confused 😂
@@manash.bhaabu213 😂😂😂😂
Yeah, I got blown away. But then I realised he is just white washing, just to show muslims also care and we r also good people. So don't buy it.
Jaishankar is a great gentleman
Why it's getting hard for me to believe that it's an Indian parliament?? And Owaisi asking this question??? Greatly appreciated
This is how parliament should run.
if all parliamentary discussion would have been like this our country would be soo far ahead
Such a productive session, healthy discussions, without any shouting. May GOD keep our parliament like that, only work, no nonsense.
Jai ho JaiShankarji 🙏🙏
This is very healthy discussion about our foreign policy in recent past. I would regard to all ministers for raising very crucial questions and our stunt with neighbors. Thank so much to all.
You are amazing Jaishanker sir. How intelligently, promptly and humbly you answers each question that has been raised by the members, how respectfully you talk, salutations to you sir. You ate indeed a star!!!!
What a session of parliament! Beauty my mother India..
Come on guys! Isn't it obvious that Naveen Jindal and Owaisi switched each other's questions??? 😂😂
More such discussions in our Parliament please ❤ great questions
very good questions and their good response!
This interaction gives hope that our politicians still have some intellectual mindset left. I hope the sansad continues to work with dialogue and India first mindset.
Best foreign minister Bharat ever had......
My favorite is nirmala tai ji😅
this is the kind of paarliament discussion we the people of india look forward
It's great to see that Owaisi has raised the minority issue but the govt must concretely raise this issue & act upon it.
These are the sort of questions we expect our opposition to ask the government. These are the kind of constructive discussions we, Indians, would like our parliamentarians to have.
The government needs to do more on the Manipur issue, Myanmar drug issue and Bangladesh’s persecution of minorities!
I am impressed both with question and answer. This is the way it should be.
My respect for Dr S Jaishankar has increased exponentially.
Kudos to you Dr S Jaishankar 👍
His cool demeanour and maturity are unparalleled
Mr. Jaishankar❤
The right man, in the right place, at the right time, can 100% success rate accrued.
Bahuth bahuth dhanyavaad Sri Jayashankar master
ACP PRADHYUMAN sitting behind Manish ji
Kuch to gadbad hai!
Nice question
Jaishankar Ji is amazing ! Big applaud to him!
Om Birla should not interrupt the opposition from asking important questions. Even we citizens have those questions. He was framing it extremely well and putting emphasis on what mattered but was continuously interrupted by the speaker.
S. Jaishankar as always was very graceful and gave informative answers while still being very cautious which is befitting for an external affairs minister/ diplomat. His statements have the potential to cause an international crisis if not thought about carefully.🙏
Great session nonetheless!
Jaishankar is truly amazing!!!
I am from Manipur the "failed state of India". I cry everytime i listen to what is being discussed in MY parliament.
Manipur issue is a deep international conspiracy. Sadly it will take time to resolve.
Who doing this
@@bepositive5692 Kuki illegals having Zalengam wet dreams!!
We all love you guys. Manipur is never ever a failed state. You have such a lovely culture and some awesome sportspersons. Love from Haryana❤
You people change first...if you grow hatred inside for other communities, no govt can help you...
That's called parliamentary discussion ❤
Good discussion
We are proud of you S Jaishankar ji
Jayashankar ji👍👍🔥
I m smitten by him our foreign minister 🎉
Mr. Jaishankar ,
I look up to you, Sir .
Great respect 🙏
Such a constructive debate.
Super answer...
Very good discussion, looking like a mature Member with the Mature Minister. Waooow S. jaishankar ❤
Brilliant reply by Shri Jaishankar
Two very smart Gentlemen
Look who is asking about accessiblity.. congress didnt build border roads saying it will help the enemy...
Instead Congress said it will make China angry. 😂
@kamkash92 Yes... congress is surprised.. 60 years they did nothing and in 10 years lots happened
This is what parliament is for. Can listen to such sane questions and answers for a full day. Stop the theatrics and run the real show🎉
i want my wife to look at me just as shri birla ji is looking at mr jaishankar ❤
Bhai 😂😂😂😂😂
Birla bhabhi
Mere paas toh wife hi nahi hai 😢
@@D_402S sad lyf bro
💀💀
We want a person like jaysanker 🇱🇰
Finally! These kinds of debates are welcome. Opposition should ask questions. Government should answer and vice-versa. Yells and fights are so filthy and irrational. We are common citizens looking for clarity, accountability and transparency. We want this kind of sanity amongst MPs. Well done. 🙏
Very good question 👍👍👍
Great discussion. The only good discussion I saw in parliament so far.
This is a rare scene in Indian Parliament.
I absolutely love these debates… politicians please be more rational like this
I want Jaishankar to be the next priminister of india.
A tight slap of the kangress!
Well spoken jai shankar ji
I think putting aside all the emotions and political differences, this kind of session- well spoken MP from both sides, questions were very valid and both parties took it very well. We should respect that.. everyone acted their part. The opp raised legit q, the FM answered it very well.
This we want in Parliament, Opposition keeping Government on toes instead of hooliganism.
Jai...your real hero in our parliament
Our foreign minister is a true patriot 🙏God bless him. We are blessed by God to have some one like him to serve our country
Great discussion and debate..this is what we the voters and citizens expect in the parliament.
Jai Hind!
Boom great answers
As a Bangladeshi respect to Jaishankar
Best question hour witnessed so far.
Can anyone drop the link of more such parliamentary discussions?
Gem of a politician
Most of the MPs doesn't understand Mr.Jai Shankar's Deplomatic English that's why no shouting from Opposition...😅😅😅😅
😂
Opposition has more educated ministers than BJP lol good luck learning some facts
@Viehere is it...thx for info.. then why they are not shouting? If they are more educated then why they are wasting time on unnecessary topics...they should do good business in parliament...
Bhai ase hi parliament chalni chahiye jisse public ko samjh aaye tax ke paise ka sahi use ho desh ke mudde discuss kiye jaye
Someone should ask some concrete questions. This is like giving class 5 questions to a college student.
Questions like,
-any steps to improve & regulate security of India's information space should be brought up.
-whether funding & actions of foreign NGOs operating in the country is monitored n not turned a blind eye.
These 2 points are crucial in the spectrum of protecting National interests, by preventing the population within to be catapulted as orchestrators of the nation's downfall.
Recent events in Bangladesh is a result of these 2 matters going uncontrolled
A nice debate
Need more educated ministers like them,
OMG Birla's face says it all ! How he looks at one side of the House with irritation & anger writlarge on his face while the other side is favoured with fond indulnt smiles,no matter what they do. His place in History is assured.
way he explains is enough to understand about his personality.
BEST FM
He may be a good Lawyer but statesmanship is a different cup of tea ! With his suave manners, Jaishankar takes his opponents by horn.
👏👏
Big salute to Jai Shankar minister.
Great Question putting by opposition
All neighbours dislike India, Why?
Dr.JaiShankar is the only minister who commands such silence from opposition. When he speaks, no one dares to oppose.
A handsome debate for our country... very much interesting
Pura dhoo dala 😂 Jaishankar sir ne
Good question sir
Ironic how BJP have the best FM (foreign minister)as well the worst FM (finance minister)
First neighbourhood will become a disaster policy in my opinion.
But see, i am not into politics it's a pure opinion.
Based on my 24 years age 😅 i have never seen pak doing favour for us or atleast sri Lanka doing it😂.
Pak favours usa and china
Nepali also usa and china
Sri lanka no need for mentioning 😂they have provided free access to Chinese and American navy.
Now comes bangladesh 😅 another beauty, Just spewing venom on us.
Now you want a neighborhood first policy 😂?
But see my opinion my sarcastic laughter can be overturned with the wit of our leaders like amit shah ji, jaishankar ji etc, as there is a possibility for anything.
I just hope for best for our country 🙏🏻. Love india ❤.
Diplomacy isn't our strong suit: we should use the military to solve problems instead.
Seems like we are surrounded by usa and china proxies .
See neighborhood policy is needed
Otherwise it will be win for china. China wants to be the only powerful country in Asia. We need to have good relationship with all our neighbours. In today's world military warfare is not needed much what we need is technology technological warfare is going to be the upcoming war
Once 2 friends studied in same class one topped the class one failed.... now that failed friend became jealous ....
And we can see the outcomes of jealousy
These country are only friend s when they want money... Like Sri Lanka maldives and nepal... Bangladesh radical nature make Pakistan look Secular. Most of these countries want to benifit out of India china Rivalry.
This is why India needs new blood like the kind Trump has employed to deal with issues facing India instead of just spewing vomitt of useless words instead of actually taking action to plave pressure on Indias neighbour's who continues to exploit Indias studpidy of sticking to outdated exploited policies by Indias neighbour's.
When accuser starts accusing using info from tiktok and instagram videos. Lolz. On serious note, Mr. Jaishankar always impresses me with his diplomatic conversations and his knowledge. Kudos.
*"Open challenge to Muslims to debate and defend Islam!"*
-- @ExMuslimSahil (TH-cam Channel)
First tell him to delete the post or defend that post.
G€€T@ VS QURAN
Awaze haq uncensored
(TH-cam channel)
🎯teer tum sb ki mori dy wich.
🎯Awaze haq uncensored
Subscribe for rebuttal of bhagwa chuttad goons
Pajeet from bhiar creating fake id as exmuslim 🤣🤣
He's referencing him@@tahmidalam5612
Chuslim chutiya trying it's best to make cuina it's father 😂😂@@tahmidalam5612
Next PM of India
❤❤SPEED TRUTH THE HINDU, UN WORK........ KONGRESS MAAHAN REDER❤❤❤