@@felicitymabudusha4761 you are either dumb or you don't listen. man even mentioned the graduates situation and the state of black people and coloureds. He even presented facts, stats, not opinion. Listening is a skill and not a talent chief
Remember there are social media managers at most companies so they check the social media reactions hence if commentators accuse you of being bias you will be called into office for review and be advised as to how to improve (is part of KPI's) failure to change or being professional then it can amount to dismissal
No ways; today he can;t mention the name of an MP who is circulating on social media for racist remarks until the DA says so; like what the hell is that; so many times there are allegations against black people, he doesnt wait for their parties to confirm as if we are talking of a deceased person and waiting for family to confirm. This boy is biased.
It was during Zuma presidency Low tax collected Credit rating =Junk status Hyper inflation Swimming pool =fire pool State capture Cosatu split COPE and EFF breakaway Guptas landed at waterkloof Hlaudi COO Des van Royen weekend special Medupi and Kusile never completed Gadafi is executed and Swana is very very happy, that's 13:11 intelligent analysis right there 13:11
Don't get your hopes high. Remember Mbeki was living in Britain during apartheid under British protection. He came back in 1991 to be a president for the movement he never contributed in because his father was a member. Yena le ramaphosa are not different.
The narrative that the DA came from the National Party is not really fair - they came from the PFP who were stridently against apartheid… the fact that people who voted NP now vote DA and there are a few bad eggs in the DA leadership does not make DA policy ipso facto racists - look at policy outcomes and how it improves service delivery and the lives of all South Africans, especially the worst off
To add to this it was before aDemocratic Party which was made mostly by coloured people of which then came together with the National Party and a few organisations in order to fight against the ANC and other liberation movements
Helen said they will impeach if there is evidence of wrong doing. Saying you paraphrase and then only saying the stuff that works in your agenda is not ethical!
What else could have ANC done when they only got 40% of the votes? They invited every political parties to join them. Some refused. So what else? The country has to move on.
Stop making excuses here. Others refused because the ANC chose to work with colonizers, apartheid enforcers and in particular, the “enemy” aka the racist DA. They could have dropped the DA.
First thing that they should have done is RECALL RamaPhala. He failed by presiding over a 17% loss. In any self-respecting democracy,this ineffective man would be sitting at home riding his ankole cattle.
Which revolution has the ANC sold out? Roads with potholes, highest murder rate in the world and unemployment, open border policies, loadshedding and lack of water, corruption, incompetence and etc and etc? Which revolution are we accusing the ANC of having sold out? Are we just in love with the word revolution or is there any substance to it?
Do not let naivety cloud your judgement! S.A can never be highest in murder rate and crime/unemployment unless you are comparing us to EU countries. Mate stop exaggerating we have countries like Sudan/Nigeria/Niger/Zimbabwe/Somali/Ethiopia/Bangladesh/Pakistan/Burundi etc it's worse in those countries
@@nhlanhlamahlangu2895 But it does not matter. Police Statistics shows people are being killed on daily basis losing their precious lives. As long as we have people with narrow minds like you,we will never have this country right. Otherwise we can proceed without you. Government has already been established without Your MK Party.
I would have thought that Mr Swana would have made an effort to know the history of where the DA came from BEFORE stating any opinion about what their moral values are. The DA came from the DP, which came from the Progressive Party who was the direct OPPOSITION to the National Party. They were the ones who wanted apartheid to end. They were the ones who took on the NP in parliament on behalf of the others in South Africa. Please make sure of your facts before you speak!!!!
All I know DA is a racist party that holds the same policies as the one of NP and not forgetting that Tony Leon's father hunged Solomon Mahlangu for fighting for freedom for natives of this land.
DA was established for merging of Democratic Party and Freedom Alliance shortly after 1999 elections. National Party partnered with ANC in 2004 elections to deny DA in Western Cape. After success of giving ANC a western Cape, then National Party dissolved and they went on to join ANC
@@ChristFollower-oi9ycIt’s not a race card mentality. It’s the prevailing socio-economic conditions in the country. This is an elitist arrangement intended to use the votes of the poor to keep them poor, while enriching the few further. We need the poorest to earn an income and not the richest to become richer. This will explode. The ANC is losing legitimacy. I hear they say the coalition is 68% representative. In reality, masses see this gov as an illegitimate sellout administration. That is not good for stability.
While some people are busy bla bla bla, ANC,DA,IFP are busy working to make things work for SA people. l hope they continue to do so, and let this people talk talk alone there in air.
He lied about the origins of the DA, or he is not informed about their origins. In any case, the statement he made about the DA coming from the NP is untrue. The DA leadership historically comes from parties that were against the NP and their racist apartheid policies. If the analyst was wrong about this fact, what else could he be wrong about?
WHAT IMPROVEMENTS HAS THE DA DONE IN KHAYELISHA...WESTERN CAPE,,,??. WHAT IMPROVEMENT HAS ANC UNDER RAMAPHOSA HAS DONE NATIONWIDE...??.. WHAT IMPROVEMENT ARE YOU REALLY TALKING ABOUT??..
@@maynardnkambule71 it's the only province that has created more than 1% growth in employment. No other province has achieved that. What improvements has anyone else done? Who do you want to tell us to support. The EFF the mk are all anc babies and they come from the anc which has barely delivered
@@WokeDetection You're delusional. The Western Cape has a population of 7.4 mil with unemployment rate of 20%. Gauteng has a population of 15.1 mil with unemployment rate of 36%. Gauteng has twice the population of the Western Cape, which means Gauteng has an unemployment rate of about 18% compared to the Western Cape if you were comparing an apple to an apple. I'm not surprised you reiterate the DA leader narrative with only matric, John.
The DA said they would not work with the ANC of then protecting people for commiting corruption and crimes they then held talks with the ANC and tabled their frustrations Ekhuruleni is stolen bankrupt by EFF imagine what would happen if they took over more municipalities
I think Swana is biased against RAMAPHOSA and the ANC. He is very narrow in his analysis of the prevailing situation in SA. I didn't really get the gist of his argument besides that he is antiDA and anti ANC
In fact, his criticism borders on tribalism. He said elsewhere that the presidency seat has been vacant since the Thabo Mbeki era. He hates Cyril to the core! No presidency can be worse than that of Zuma.
Yes like it was during apartheid where black people will be neglected again so that white will become more white and black becomes more black indeed South Africa will be a better place we won't be surprised when we see places written Whites only because white people they know how to use their power once they have it they don't sugarcoat things we will see apartheid with our own eyes not hear said yes jobs will be there to convince people everything is good and they know us better than before that our current leaders like money unlike the older generation how I wish they can prove me wrong and the unthinkable things like what the ANC did and let us to enjoy our country and being Africans in the African continent that's my wish.
I talked with my heavenly Father! That's not about me I didn't need the politicians that's about people who get really need the gvrments must be worked fr those who need and to our country
Hail the new South Africa It’s not easy, we’re not out of the dark tunnel yet But a glimmer, a hope And an enlightened end People first, parties last Job creation first, corruption last The vulnerable first, the privileged last One woman man first, polygamists last
The ANC must remove Ramaphosa from within the party like they did with Zuma. He is the weakest president of all time and a sellout to his own people amd the liberation.
ANC is inviting all parties to join GNU after a deal has already been signed with DA. Is this a GNU? DA vowed to fight crime in Govt.Hence coming in to play an oversight .But morally and ethically they will protect the impeachment process. Will they push for removal of the current Deputy president?
Nonsense. Development on the backdrop of protecting criminality such as money laundering by the sitting president is laughable to claim a progressive interest of the country. Zuma put it correctly, GNU is Nonsense. This is the birth of grand scale of lawlessness. Land thieves collaborating with the modern era state looters. Moreover, it's understatement to call them land thieves. They're worse than that.
Msholozi is undeniably intelligent, he foresaw this and said the ANC needs tobe rescued and many people with shallow political knowledge labeled him bitter, see now the truth is coming out sooner than anticipated🤣🤣
Don't expect this white appeaser reporter to ask, and in the mean mood manner, the type of questions around ANC/DA marriage of convenience he would be asking had it been about EFF or MK issues?
What should he have asked? There is not a lot of dirt on the DA because they are the party with the best track record for service delivery, and their audits are clean.
@DumaM-ir7rk I've seen a lot of comments criticizing the DA, but those comments are posted on emotion and not facts. It does not seem like they are getting deleted, though.
It is time we move away from 1948 . I was born in 1958. Born in Bloemfontein with a South African citizenship. I find myself now in 2024 . I was never and never will be a racist. Let’s take hands and forget all issues and sort out our problems TOGETHER….whatever it is!!!!!
Its people like this both black and white that stop us from moving on. Lets just give each other a chance and if they mess it up we vote them out. This election made it clear our vote matters.
The analyst is biased, the way he address his sitting President has sold him out. He hold deep seeded hatred and anti ANC anti Ramaposa sentiments.. Sad indeed. We rely on any analyst to provide a balance and fair overview for us as audience to understand that crux of the subject on it pure values. Mind you, some of the views expressed are used in academic contributions....where does biased views leaves us?
Mr Swana is correct. We are in this hole because of the HORRENDOUS quality of the average ANC deployee across the board. Years and years of rubbish quality. My only hope is Squirrel uses this opportunity to clean up his own shop. It isn't going to be easy when these crooks have been eating non-stop on all levels for 20 years.
Funny how when Zulu's vote MK / IFP, its tribalism. But when Xhosa 's vote ANC, its not tribalism ; when Whites vote DA, its not tribalism. Yeah, Its hypocrisy ! DA protection of Cyril over Phala Phala is disgusting ! So the pay back to the DA must be huge !
@donaldchikudo1521 bro why you scared of it working, do you even know why your upset or just another human right to whine over your prejudices towards this direction, bro hate is ugly
Anc have not signed anything with DA it's all lies to pit people against each other. Anc are just going to spend 80mil on a innoguration that they don't deserve. No accountability.
Jacob Zuma, yesterday's man, going down slowly but surely, sinking into the deepest political pothole of them all, a humiliating fate of his own making. Goodbye Mr _Once Upon A Time._ We remember his scorn for "Khwezi". We remember the Arms Deal corruption. We remember the dishonour towards Mbeki. We remember how his Gupta masters purchased him so easily. We remember state capture. We remember the collapse of service delivery. We remember the plunder of state resources meant for the upkeep of infrastructure. We remember state money for private Nkandla upgrades. We remember his arrogance in the face of parliament's questions. We remember his brazen lies. We remember his arrogance in the face of Justice Zondo's commission report. We remember his contempt of court. We remember his contempt for the rule of law. We remember his contempt for our country's constitution. We remember his criminal record. We remember his orchestration behind the looting, arson and deaths of July 2021. We remember the sabotage of Eskom. We remember the self delusion on the night of election 2024 results. We remember the threat of violence he made if the IEC didn't submit to him.
Swana I am so so disappointed in you You know very well that the DA is not NP Stop feeding our young generation nonsense against the DA If you don't like the DA please criticise it with it's present or yes past not marrying it to the National party
Sandile Swana is a South African, he has to worry when seeing his country being sold over to the White's on a silver platter for the protection of Ramaphosa.
To add into what you are saying. Compare the to Presidents based on which merits...Someone took over while the economy was is a bad state and COVID was also a challenge... I sometimes don't agree with most of the Political Analysts...
@mamasmosoathu1364 someone got 570 billion covid relief fund and instead of sustaining the economy he bribed idiots with 350 grants wake up its not too late
Every Tom, Dick & Somizi has all of a sudden become the greatest political experts 🤷🏾♂️ I demand an answer to the following question: “what would’ve happened if the ANC had decided to become the official opposition? Would the rest of the parties have banded together to form a government, without the ANC? Yes, the ANC has messed up big time since 2007; however Mzantsi needs to turn around and correct the mistakes since Mbeki was sacked. How do the experts suggest we do it … should we give that task to Zuma, Malema, McKenzie and all the other parties who now lament about the ANC?
Yes...Protect a sitting Elected President who again obtained 6m vote....////Anything beside Da was going to be sue side...Say anything but we are here Now.....Mandela had the same IDEa and he could have been happy to hear this...We never asked for it but it is here and it will PASS
ANC must be careful the DA will position themselves as a successor rather that a partner of GNU and they will win the next election.The DA is good in building systems and the investors follow them.
Of course, they will try to win the election next time. That is the goal of every party. If they do win next time, though, it will be a good thing. The DA is the party with the best track record for service delivery and clean audits, and to have that at a national level will only improve the lives of all the people in this country.
Look, ANC say we are engaging with various political parties but do not put forward impeachment of Ramaphosa and the same parties which believed there was wrong doing about phalaphala not they voted for him and had signed agreement on supporting the elected against any further impeachment on a card of maintaining stability. Now you tell me if that is not about protecting Ramaphosa. The real flip flop pill forced down the throat of engaged political parties.
Are certain political uncertainties taken into considerarion before we look at who is the worst performer? COVID and taking over from someone should be considered I sometimes turn to disagree with the political Analysts...
Moral elasticity as a new concept is a bit rich Sir. We need to keep all politicians honest. We just have better odds today, than in the last thirty years.
Why blame the DA, ANC Cyril Ramaphosa knew very well how many votes he needed to stay in Power, [40+20]. The other parties would not have given Cyril Ramaphosa enough votes. Cyril will use anyone who would have him retain the presidency.
"Moral Elasticity" is part of the current national framework... It is unavoidable, anyone in government has to work with it going forwards...rooting it out is not going to be a quick fix, and other things need attention.. "unemployment must stsy below 5 percent"?? HOW....?
With stolen votes, when is this stealing gonna come to an end, land stolen , our dignity stolen, resources stolen, the list is endless and they're proud of it.
National Party was a disaster. After President MBEKI, the ANC is worse than the National party which was a disaster. We can all work together now for the interest of the entire country.
Sandile swane his got so much hate for ANC his supposed to be partial. His such typical Xhosa man who’s against the ANC. I don’t even know why they always call him his such a rubbish analysis
The problem is in your big head as you don't want to hear anything about your lovely DANC that is the reason you will look that way you actually don't want to hear the roar truth!
Unpopular opinion: there is no muscle memory of running a modern, complex economy in any liberation movement that existed anywhere on the African continent simply because there was never a cultural history of that being done. If the ANC is clever it will stay in charge of the country by playing popular politics, within reason, and let the technocrats in the DA run the state.
"Era of moral elasticity"😂😂😂😂 You seem to forget the Zondo Commission and everything levied against Pres Zuma. Did we see any accountability within ANC after Mbeki steped down?
It's not the standard of education - it's the lack of interest by African people in schools. I went to school with a majority of Africans and ~40% of them eventually dropped out and 40% of those 60% (that stayed in school), chose easy subjects that wouldn't get them far after matric. Keep in mind that this was in a top notch school I went to. Only like 20% of that 60% made it and completed matric with an equivalent pass to my own. I'm an engineer today, so let's not blame the schools, it's a culture that needs to be changed and it doesn't help when the MK and EFF encourages unlawfulness. A lot of Africans I've spoken to actually believe that education is a "white man's thing", so they don't value education at all.
NGL it’s a bit disappointing for an analyst to be speaking like this… and for the media to be pushing narratives that don’t exist Renaldo Gouws didn’t say anything unsavoury unless using the F word is unsavoury
Mr Swana you are balanced Political Analyst. Keep up the good work.
Ramaphosa a worst pres in Anc! Why? Not a single reason!
@@felicitymabudusha4761 you are either dumb or you don't listen. man even mentioned the graduates situation and the state of black people and coloureds. He even presented facts, stats, not opinion. Listening is a skill and not a talent chief
Today Xoli sounds a true journalist and a bit fair for the first time instead of pushing a certain narrative
Remember there are social media managers at most companies so they check the social media reactions hence if commentators accuse you of being bias you will be called into office for review and be advised as to how to improve (is part of KPI's) failure to change or being professional then it can amount to dismissal
No ways; today he can;t mention the name of an MP who is circulating on social media for racist remarks until the DA says so; like what the hell is that; so many times there are allegations against black people, he doesnt wait for their parties to confirm as if we are talking of a deceased person and waiting for family to confirm. This boy is biased.
Well he is govt media n all the parties he gave a tough time are part of the govt now
I think the MK address got a lot of them to reset and do self introspection.
Sorry, not this one, when he's soft, smile, laughs then he's treading carefully not to trample on some toes,, this one unwabu!
Politics is so Cruel.Phalaphala is protected by the Colonial Masters But Zuma is an Enemy.Yes a New Era.
We still need Guptas here.
@@japrosper7240And the land. Those lands thieves must bring back our forefathers properties.
Yes, the Khoi and San peoples were dispossed by the colonizers 1.0, the Ngunis. Time to shower the self appointed leaders with lots of bling a ling.
Shame that's a very naive person who see the hatred
Zuma must go to jail and face his crimes like a man not a coward hiding behind his violent supporters
It was during Zuma presidency
Low tax collected
Credit rating =Junk status
Hyper inflation
Swimming pool =fire pool
State capture
Cosatu split
COPE and EFF breakaway
Guptas landed at waterkloof
Hlaudi COO
Des van Royen weekend special
Medupi and Kusile never completed
Gadafi is executed and
Swana is very very happy, that's 13:11 intelligent analysis right there 13:11
Zuma is one person, So you really think what you wrote here makes sense...That, one person did it all this. Why was he never prosecuted, even now!!!
Vuka slima.
@@Siphe753 plain foolishness 😢
Bla bla bla😂
Rand manipulation is what you calling junk status?😊
This means ramaphosa is captured by DA using phala phala....
Black people voted 🗳 DA everyone saw Black people love DA they are people want what they want
News Room Africa can you please find President Mbeki so that we can hear his views on the DANC coalition?
Mbeki is now hiding under a rock somewhere claiming to be sick 😅😅😅 the story of a banana republic
Please find him find him🤣🤣🤣🤣
Don't get your hopes high. Remember Mbeki was living in Britain during apartheid under British protection. He came back in 1991 to be a president for the movement he never contributed in because his father was a member. Yena le ramaphosa are not different.
Agree 💯👍🏾
The narrative that the DA came from the National Party is not really fair - they came from the PFP who were stridently against apartheid… the fact that people who voted NP now vote DA and there are a few bad eggs in the DA leadership does not make DA policy ipso facto racists - look at policy outcomes and how it improves service delivery and the lives of all South Africans, especially the worst off
Correct, it is a blatant lie to try and create fear and undermine the accomplishments of the DA.
Come to Tshwane and see the nonsense the DA is doing
To add to this it was before aDemocratic Party which was made mostly by coloured people of which then came together with the National Party and a few organisations in order to fight against the ANC and other liberation movements
@@kayrams1792even areas like Khayelisha, Langa, etc in Cpt
They don't service black areas and black people period!
This analyst is not in the mood to cook, he is dishing it out raw.
true, hey......
Helen said they will impeach if there is evidence of wrong doing. Saying you paraphrase and then only saying the stuff that works in your agenda is not ethical!
Please stop calling this arrangement GNU. It's a coalition, not government of national unity.
True bcz the signature were Mbalula n aunty Zille
It's a coalition, not a GNU. Ramapgosa has been deceiving and lying to the country ever since he took power and continues forever
Yup
It is a Gov. of Nat. Unity. There are many more parties in this alliance now already than there was on Friday.
What's the difference,
What else could have ANC done when they only got 40% of the votes? They invited every political parties to join them. Some refused. So what else? The country has to move on.
move on with a corrupted ANC leader back by a white corrupted DA who will not impeach
🤡🇿🇦🤡
Stop making excuses here. Others refused because the ANC chose to work with colonizers, apartheid enforcers and in particular, the “enemy” aka the racist DA. They could have dropped the DA.
@@YT-xk5jlDA are SA as well.
@YT-xk5jl you are breeding racism!
First thing that they should have done is RECALL RamaPhala.
He failed by presiding over a 17% loss.
In any self-respecting democracy,this ineffective man would be sitting at home riding his ankole cattle.
Which revolution has the ANC sold out? Roads with potholes, highest murder rate in the world and unemployment, open border policies, loadshedding and lack of water, corruption, incompetence and etc and etc? Which revolution are we accusing the ANC of having sold out? Are we just in love with the word revolution or is there any substance to it?
ANC GOVERNMENT HAS BEEN USELESS SHAME SIESTOG SIES.
Do not let naivety cloud your judgement! S.A can never be highest in murder rate and crime/unemployment unless you are comparing us to EU countries. Mate stop exaggerating we have countries like Sudan/Nigeria/Niger/Zimbabwe/Somali/Ethiopia/Bangladesh/Pakistan/Burundi etc it's worse in those countries
Do not let naivety cloud your judgement! S.A can never be highest in murder rate and crime/unemployment unless you are comparing us to EU countries.
Well said.. I agree with you
@@nhlanhlamahlangu2895 But it does not matter. Police Statistics shows people are being killed on daily basis losing their precious lives. As long as we have people with narrow minds like you,we will never have this country right. Otherwise we can proceed without you. Government has already been established without Your MK Party.
I would have thought that Mr Swana would have made an effort to know the history of where the DA came from BEFORE stating any opinion about what their moral values are. The DA came from the DP, which came from the Progressive Party who was the direct OPPOSITION to the National Party. They were the ones who wanted apartheid to end. They were the ones who took on the NP in parliament on behalf of the others in South Africa. Please make sure of your facts before you speak!!!!
A leopard doesn't change its spots. DA = NP. Caucasians = DA = NP.
All I know DA is a racist party that holds the same policies as the one of NP and not forgetting that Tony Leon's father hunged Solomon Mahlangu for fighting for freedom for natives of this land.
What animal are you ? Dare one ask
So DA wants to share the Land equally with black people 🤷🏾♂️👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
DA was established for merging of Democratic Party and Freedom Alliance shortly after 1999 elections.
National Party partnered with ANC in 2004 elections to deny DA in Western Cape. After success of giving ANC a western Cape, then National Party dissolved and they went on to join ANC
I wish the ANC & DA could respond to some of the comments and allegations made by some of these so-called political analysts.
And say what ?
@@bongimtshali7719My thoughts exactly. The DA and ANC arrangement is an elitist arrangement between the black bougousie and the white establishment
@@luthovellem865some people are jailed by the race card mentality, be careful of the inferiority complex
@@ChristFollower-oi9ycIt’s not a race card mentality. It’s the prevailing socio-economic conditions in the country. This is an elitist arrangement intended to use the votes of the poor to keep them poor, while enriching the few further. We need the poorest to earn an income and not the richest to become richer. This will explode. The ANC is losing legitimacy. I hear they say the coalition is 68% representative. In reality, masses see this gov as an illegitimate sellout administration. That is not good for stability.
@@luthovellem865 FACTS📍
While some people are busy bla bla bla, ANC,DA,IFP are busy working to make things work for SA people. l hope they continue to do so, and let this people talk talk alone there in air.
You must be ashamed of talking about rubbish
Ok Tintswalo
@@kgomotsomashilane5194 Tintswako 😂😂😂
Dream on and this dream won't last for long
@@NtokozoPearlKhaula-et3vi Zuma ☹️☹️
Swana not mixing his words and shooting straight from the hip 🫡🫡
...mincing
Do you also agree that a Grade 6 maths teacher cannot pass a Grade 6 maths test?
DA needs Cyril for continued ANC commitment to their coalition. Should Cyril go, the ANC may go 'left'
Right on the money. Without Cyril there's no ANC DA marriage
You mean communist?
I dnt think the DA hv plan to leave you knw DA want the country to be work
ANC has never been to the left and will never be.
That is excatly what going to happen. South Africa will enter civil war….
The only sober Political Analyst in the country. Keep up the good work Sir.
He lied about the origins of the DA, or he is not informed about their origins. In any case, the statement he made about the DA coming from the NP is untrue. The DA leadership historically comes from parties that were against the NP and their racist apartheid policies. If the analyst was wrong about this fact, what else could he be wrong about?
@@jacqueslandman8044He knows that we know he is right
@@phumlamazibuko3003 He was not.
We need a revote
Absolutely! The election was stolen by the ANC criminal gang.
And after that.
This is not a Mickey mouse show
Remember the EFF and Mk were not willing partners . So don’t judge those that wanted to try and improve the country.
WHAT IMPROVEMENTS HAS THE DA DONE IN KHAYELISHA...WESTERN CAPE,,,??. WHAT IMPROVEMENT HAS ANC UNDER RAMAPHOSA HAS DONE NATIONWIDE...??.. WHAT IMPROVEMENT ARE YOU REALLY TALKING ABOUT??..
@@maynardnkambule71 it's the only province that has created more than 1% growth in employment. No other province has achieved that.
What improvements has anyone else done?
Who do you want to tell us to support. The EFF the mk are all anc babies and they come from the anc which has barely delivered
The DA were the first to announce that they will not work with the MK and the EFF
@@WokeDetection You're delusional. The Western Cape has a population of 7.4 mil with unemployment rate of 20%. Gauteng has a population of 15.1 mil with unemployment rate of 36%. Gauteng has twice the population of the Western Cape, which means Gauteng has an unemployment rate of about 18% compared to the Western Cape if you were comparing an apple to an apple. I'm not surprised you reiterate the DA leader narrative with only matric, John.
The DA said they would not work with the ANC of then protecting people for commiting corruption and crimes they then held talks with the ANC and tabled their frustrations Ekhuruleni is stolen bankrupt by EFF imagine what would happen if they took over more municipalities
Truth must be told. I love it the way u spill it out. 😅
I think Swana is biased against RAMAPHOSA and the ANC. He is very narrow in his analysis of the prevailing situation in SA. I didn't really get the gist of his argument besides that he is antiDA and anti ANC
Swana bla bla bla bla
Swana is behaving as if he's an authority in government
Too bias
In fact, his criticism borders on tribalism. He said elsewhere that the presidency seat has been vacant since the Thabo Mbeki era. He hates Cyril to the core! No presidency can be worse than that of Zuma.
Ok
The GNU WILL WORK. Doesn't matter who says what ,SA is going to be a better place to live in.
We want stability in the country and the detractors are not going yo yake us anywhere.
Kak man !!!
This is NOT a GNU !!
GO read the meaning of GNU...Domkop !!!
It's a Coalition !!!
Between two Devils !!!
Yes like it was during apartheid where black people will be neglected again so that white will become more white and black becomes more black indeed South Africa will be a better place we won't be surprised when we see places written Whites only because white people they know how to use their power once they have it they don't sugarcoat things we will see apartheid with our own eyes not hear said yes jobs will be there to convince people everything is good and they know us better than before that our current leaders like money unlike the older generation how I wish they can prove me wrong and the unthinkable things like what the ANC did and let us to enjoy our country and being Africans in the African continent that's my wish.
For who
I talked with my heavenly Father! That's not about me I didn't need the politicians that's about people who get really need the gvrments must be worked fr those who need and to our country
Neutral and Independent Analyst 🎉❤
Hail the new South Africa
It’s not easy, we’re not out of the dark tunnel yet
But a glimmer, a hope
And an enlightened end
People first, parties last
Job creation first, corruption last
The vulnerable first, the privileged last
One woman man first, polygamists last
The ANC must remove Ramaphosa from within the party like they did with Zuma. He is the weakest president of all time and a sellout to his own people amd the liberation.
"Immorality in that group is not strange at all"
ANC is inviting all parties to join GNU after a deal has already been signed with DA. Is this a GNU?
DA vowed to fight crime in Govt.Hence coming in to play an oversight .But morally and ethically they will protect the impeachment process. Will they push for removal of the current Deputy president?
Interesting times ahead in South Africa's political dynamics
This so called political analists is anti Anc.nothing credible coming from his mouth.6.3m people are not stupid like him
The marriage😂
Finally RSA has hope to develop and grow through equal opportunity and unity. Let's work on social cohesion and economic growth.
Nonsense. Development on the backdrop of protecting criminality such as money laundering by the sitting president is laughable to claim a progressive interest of the country. Zuma put it correctly, GNU is Nonsense. This is the birth of grand scale of lawlessness. Land thieves collaborating with the modern era state looters. Moreover, it's understatement to call them land thieves. They're worse than that.
Not to these geniuses in the interview.
In your dreams
DA couldn't develop WC townships and Tshwane and never will, only lip service is working overtime
@@phumlamazibuko3003 Townships are developing in the rest of South Africa and not in WC?
GNU Viva ❤ forward we move
Let's go
And Hellen is running the zoo
Msholozi is undeniably intelligent, he foresaw this and said the ANC needs tobe rescued and many people with shallow political knowledge labeled him bitter, see now the truth is coming out sooner than anticipated🤣🤣
But it can't be him to rescue ANC he is part of the demise,if this mk of his was a legitimate party with structures then we can talk.
@@mvuyimpithi8648 At least he has a plan. What is your contribution, Sir?
@@biko8229 my plan will be to continue voting BOSA. Zuma is creating chaos but carry on following.
Actually, not.The opposite is true.
@@japrosper7240 why did he not correct things when he was in charge?
In everything people who complain s are still around.
Don't expect this white appeaser reporter to ask, and in the mean mood manner, the type of questions around ANC/DA marriage of convenience he would be asking had it been about EFF or MK issues?
What should he have asked? There is not a lot of dirt on the DA because they are the party with the best track record for service delivery, and their audits are clean.
@DumaM-ir7rk I've seen a lot of comments criticizing the DA, but those comments are posted on emotion and not facts. It does not seem like they are getting deleted, though.
This government of the GNU is going to be powerful
For a very short time, yes.
@@Dubandlela1 I give it 6 months 😂😂😂
@@silaskhalishwayoI'll be hopeful and say it will be the best government to rule over South Africa ever. (Very hopeful, I know, but one can dream)
And Hellen is the supervisor 😂
It is time we move away from 1948 . I was born in 1958. Born in Bloemfontein with a South African citizenship. I find myself now in 2024 . I was never and never will be a racist. Let’s take hands and forget all issues and sort out our problems TOGETHER….whatever it is!!!!!
How can we forget the land, the abuse being called with derogatory names? How can we forgive without a n apology?
This is the GOVERNMENT of CONVENIENCE UNITY ( GCU ) Not GNU for the Anc
Mfxm, a Mkhize,what did you expect?
What's stopping these other parties to join in. I think it would be better to fight the DA from within.
Indeed Gcwabe. Its a grand coalition of corruption.
What's there to fight with DA you make it sound like they are enemies 😅
@@buyimncube2588myopic
Swana❤❤❤
So if a normal citizien commits a crime he must go to prison no the ANC and DA must go they protecting criminality
Please stop ✋️ the moral high ground argument. Let's get services to the citizens
Its people like this both black and white that stop us from moving on. Lets just give each other a chance and if they mess it up we vote them out. This election made it clear our vote matters.
Then if this is true that they'll protect wrong doing then it clearly tells you that we are in a corrupt troubled relationship.
The analyst is biased, the way he address his sitting President has sold him out. He hold deep seeded hatred and anti ANC anti Ramaposa sentiments.. Sad indeed. We rely on any analyst to provide a balance and fair overview for us as audience to understand that crux of the subject on it pure values. Mind you, some of the views expressed are used in academic contributions....where does biased views leaves us?
He is telling the truth eventhough the truth is bitter
He mentioned the word "Worst" twice about the President...Should a leader be biased like this..?
We are
Some of the Viewers are professionals...
@@mamasmosoathu1364Eh. So in your professionalism must you lack objectivity because you disagree with someone's arguments? Make your claim then.
Seems like the news station also.
They forget Mandela also understood what is at stake and consulted and was fettered by the AngloClan.
Who ever loves Ankole is either his family member or not ok upstairs 😂
I'm very excited about the new government! SA is going to be a much better place going forward! Time to rebuild!
I'm so excited about the ' new govt' soon they'll see how the cookie crumbles.
@@Sibongile-u3rdon't be so pessimistic. I believe that God can bless SA
Can't see the movie
I can't wait and see the movie
Hooe you enjoy ths lek movie😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Mr Swana is correct. We are in this hole because of the HORRENDOUS quality of the average ANC deployee across the board.
Years and years of rubbish quality.
My only hope is Squirrel uses this opportunity to clean up his own shop. It isn't going to be easy when these crooks have been eating non-stop on all levels for 20 years.
But other people are not protected
We are all alone. But take advantage if you see some light ...
From what, who are the 'other'
Very true
Yes this analyst cant be call again he is not doing what newsroom want to say
Xoli is uprising us with this interview.
Say NO to Tribalism ,Lawlessness and Poverty.DANC TO RESCUE SOUTH AFRICA😊
Nonsense
DANC 😂
Nice way to think of it 😊
Hope it brings the economic growth and stability we need as South Africans
Ok
Funny how when Zulu's vote MK / IFP, its tribalism.
But when Xhosa 's vote ANC, its not tribalism ; when Whites vote DA, its not tribalism.
Yeah, Its hypocrisy !
DA protection of Cyril over Phala Phala is disgusting !
So the pay back to the DA must be huge !
@donaldchikudo1521 bro why you scared of it working, do you even know why your upset or just another human right to whine over your prejudices towards this direction, bro hate is ugly
I dont agree with Mr Swana after listining to Hellen Zille tonite on Face the Nation.They have taken Anc on a wild goose chase.Anc mampara
SA politics slowly becoming as toxic as Zimbabwean politics.
Let's hope not.
There is no GNU here...stop confusing us
What do you call it,
@@japrosper7240 DA-ANC coalition
Anc have not signed anything with DA it's all lies to pit people against each other. Anc are just going to spend 80mil on a innoguration that they don't deserve. No accountability.
@@japrosper7240
DA and ANC marriage
Stellenbosch messangers
Jacob Zuma, yesterday's man, going down slowly but surely, sinking into the deepest political pothole of them all, a humiliating fate of his own making. Goodbye Mr _Once Upon A Time._
We remember his scorn for "Khwezi".
We remember the Arms Deal corruption.
We remember the dishonour towards Mbeki.
We remember how his Gupta masters purchased him so easily.
We remember state capture.
We remember the collapse of service delivery.
We remember the plunder of state resources meant for the upkeep of infrastructure.
We remember state money for private Nkandla upgrades.
We remember his arrogance in the face of parliament's questions.
We remember his brazen lies.
We remember his arrogance in the face of Justice Zondo's commission report.
We remember his contempt of court.
We remember his contempt for the rule of law.
We remember his contempt for our country's constitution.
We remember his criminal record.
We remember his orchestration behind the looting, arson and deaths of July 2021.
We remember the sabotage of Eskom.
We remember the self delusion on the night of election 2024 results.
We remember the threat of violence he made if the IEC didn't submit to him.
etc, etc, etc. Fixed 🤙
One thing left
Anc was forced to make alliances with DA
If it wasn't for Zuma this would have never happened
Tiktok poet😂😂😂
Why is it that interviewees on news channels also sit in front of books? We know they never read them mos
Swana I am so so disappointed in you
You know very well that the DA is not NP
Stop feeding our young generation nonsense against the DA
If you don't like the DA please criticise it with it's present or yes past not marrying it to the National party
We don't have a problem to revote
Y
Engathi ngyabona. No, let them sort out this worsening mess.
Uyanya! For what? abalungise indaba zabo, thina we did our part.
Dud you vote incorrectly last time ?
What part
Constitution forces ANC into GNU. People have shown ANC contempt. Its evaporating every five years.
There's a new party in SA. It's called DANC. That A has nothing to do with Africans
Untrue. A huge block of black people voted in these parties.
Stop being negative and embrace the new balanced south africa
I hope you see how wrong you are about the DA someday.
What has the ANC done for africans hmmmm?
ANC brought us here and nothing will change under ramza
Zuma was the worst he looted and destroyed all state owned enterties, and he needs to be held accountable
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
You people are stupid yerrrr..
Sandile Swana is a cry baby like Jacob Zuma. I wonder if they were not born by the same mother.
You hate the truth
🤣🤣🤣phala phala
True bro😂😂
Sandile Swana is a South African, he has to worry when seeing his country being sold over to the White's on a silver platter for the protection of Ramaphosa.
He doesn't please the white monopoly, or anyone for that matter the fact is a fact.
😅Swana hates President Ramaposa he has never spoke positive words always comparing Zuma with our President nobody is perfect
There's nothing positive to say about Ramadollar
To add into what you are saying.
Compare the to Presidents based on which merits...Someone took over while the economy was is a bad state and COVID was also a challenge...
I sometimes don't agree with most of the Political Analysts...
@mamasmosoathu1364 someone got 570 billion covid relief fund and instead of sustaining the economy he bribed idiots with 350 grants wake up its not too late
Must Swana dance to your tune.
Phalaphala must go
Every Tom, Dick & Somizi has all of a sudden become the greatest political experts 🤷🏾♂️
I demand an answer to the following question: “what would’ve happened if the ANC had decided to become the official opposition? Would the rest of the parties have banded together to form a government, without the ANC?
Yes, the ANC has messed up big time since 2007; however Mzantsi needs to turn around and correct the mistakes since Mbeki was sacked.
How do the experts suggest we do it … should we give that task to Zuma, Malema, McKenzie and all the other parties who now lament about the ANC?
Well put
MacKenzie and Aunty Pat are in.😂
Y at CODESA they remove the word REFERENDUM and who decide on it pls answer me.
This is not end well 🥺🥺🥺
Wow❤❤❤
Xoli has a strange way of asking questions. He is always blubbering
Yes...Protect a sitting Elected President who again obtained 6m vote....////Anything beside Da was going to be sue side...Say anything but we are here Now.....Mandela had the same IDEa and he could have been happy to hear this...We never asked for it but it is here and it will PASS
Yesterday it changed to 12m😂😂😂😂frm IEC while MK needed the truth
It's now 12 million plus votes it has changed. Go and check 😂😂😂
Coalition with EFF and or MK was gonna be a suicide for South Africa
Fake news do not take them serious numbers do not add up
An interesting point of view to expect nothing to change!!
ANC must be careful the DA will position themselves as a successor rather that a partner of GNU and they will win the next election.The DA is good in building systems and the investors follow them.
Of course, they will try to win the election next time. That is the goal of every party. If they do win next time, though, it will be a good thing. The DA is the party with the best track record for service delivery and clean audits, and to have that at a national level will only improve the lives of all the people in this country.
Belongs to the others
So the deal was just to protect Ramaphosa.
In whose interest when the electorate has vehemently rejected his ANC in these elections
Who misled you because parliamentary proceedings have not yet been taking place?
Both DA and ANC likes their millions under the mattress
Protect Squirrel and in exchange DA would get both feet in the door.....
Look, ANC say we are engaging with various political parties but do not put forward impeachment of Ramaphosa and the same parties which believed there was wrong doing about phalaphala not they voted for him and had signed agreement on supporting the elected against any further impeachment on a card of maintaining stability. Now you tell me if that is not about protecting Ramaphosa. The real flip flop pill forced down the throat of engaged political parties.
Sandile the facts have changed.
The da the saviours of south africa
I heard that before "DA will rescue SA from the ANC" lies are written on the wall only a fool won't see
I got my popcorn 🍿, I am waiting for this movie to start .
Movie 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
@@nomalungelongcete5875 LOL 😆 😂 🤣 😅.
I'm joining you😂
@@phumlamazibuko3003 😆 🤣 😂 😹 😆
Are certain political uncertainties taken into considerarion before we look at who is the worst performer? COVID and taking over from someone should be considered
I sometimes turn to disagree with the political Analysts...
Have you ever asked yourself why during some presidents tenure we are faced with disasters?
There are always reasons for failure or poor performance but that never changes the outcome.
I saw it coming and the DA will later demand for the implementation of their manifesto.
Seems this whole thing is planned from the beginning
Moral elasticity as a new concept is a bit rich Sir. We need to keep all politicians honest. We just have better odds today, than in the last thirty years.
It's better for the market not the SAns
Why blame the DA, ANC Cyril Ramaphosa knew very well how many votes he needed to stay in Power, [40+20]. The other parties would not have given Cyril Ramaphosa enough votes. Cyril will use anyone who would have him retain the presidency.
Like mbalula 😢😢
Gogo Hellen is watching😳😳
And there is an issue of bank statements
he political joke and not an analyst
Look look it's over
Xoli, is a dull presenter as it has been mentioned that so-called GNU is not but a rand /business coalition but him is calling it a GNU
"Moral Elasticity" is part of the current national framework... It is unavoidable, anyone in government has to work with it going forwards...rooting it out is not going to be a quick fix, and other things need attention.. "unemployment must stsy below 5 percent"?? HOW....?
The problem is you play with big words and do what the west does best - pure deception!
Two parties forever, good enough for SA.
GNU parties vs. Crazy parties.
Don't worry the majority is coming together
With stolen votes, when is this stealing gonna come to an end, land stolen , our dignity stolen, resources stolen, the list is endless and they're proud of it.
The " colonisers" protecting the " frog boiler"😂😂😂
Never thought i would see this.
Race card alert
@@ChristFollower-oi9ycRace card ya nonsense, you lot developed racism
It's better to work together than against each other.
@@jacqueslandman8044 Does the same principle apply to the EFF and the MK or only the baas parties ?
@@jacqueslandman8044 i know that.
Time will tell .
National Party was a disaster. After President MBEKI, the ANC is worse than the National party which was a disaster.
We can all work together now for the interest of the entire country.
Sandile swane his got so much hate for ANC his supposed to be partial. His such typical Xhosa man who’s against the ANC. I don’t even know why they always call him his such a rubbish analysis
The problem is in your big head as you don't want to hear anything about your lovely DANC that is the reason you will look that way you actually don't want to hear the roar truth!
Unpopular opinion: there is no muscle memory of running a modern, complex economy in any liberation movement that existed anywhere on the African continent simply because there was never a cultural history of that being done. If the ANC is clever it will stay in charge of the country by playing popular politics, within reason, and let the technocrats in the DA run the state.
It doesn't help to hate Ramaphosa this man is anointed by God
Cult?
What surprises me is that these people always says Ramaphosa is useless but they don't have a candidate to replace Ramaphosa - what a joke
...but that does not mean that he is useful...the lack of a 'useful' candidate does not make Ramaphosa useful...simple logic
Why are you surprised coz in Zim can't remove Mnangangwa??
Coup or revolution
Mr Sandile Swana - It's President Cyril Ramaphosa !!!
MK is the ANC. Both Parties are not strong enough to rule the country.
"Era of moral elasticity"😂😂😂😂 You seem to forget the Zondo Commission and everything levied against Pres Zuma. Did we see any accountability within ANC after Mbeki steped down?
There are no solutions coming from this interview! Just baseless criticism toward the best solution currently available in the form of national unity.
5 years will lapse and we'll be watching. ANC is gone and never coming back
Not possible buddy
@@joannebottcher9779 im talking about next election
Every man and his dog in South Africa is now a political analyst.
We don't make peace with our friends
In every analysis regarding ANC Mr Ramophosa and DA is a matter of obvious to be blamed under no circumstances .
It's not the standard of education - it's the lack of interest by African people in schools.
I went to school with a majority of Africans and ~40% of them eventually dropped out and 40% of those 60% (that stayed in school), chose easy subjects that wouldn't get them far after matric. Keep in mind that this was in a top notch school I went to.
Only like 20% of that 60% made it and completed matric with an equivalent pass to my own.
I'm an engineer today, so let's not blame the schools, it's a culture that needs to be changed and it doesn't help when the MK and EFF encourages unlawfulness.
A lot of Africans I've spoken to actually believe that education is a "white man's thing", so they don't value education at all.
I disagree with your statement. It's a very delusional and racist belief. You need to relocate out of South Africa.
NGL it’s a bit disappointing for an analyst to be speaking like this… and for the media to be pushing narratives that don’t exist Renaldo Gouws didn’t say anything unsavoury unless using the F word is unsavoury