Shia or Sunni - Which Psychology i should follow? | Sahil Adeem
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ก.พ. 2025
- شیعہ یا سُنی
میں کس سائیکالوجی پر عمل کروں؟
Shia vs Sunni
Sahil Adeem Question and Answer
..............................................
Video Credits: @SahilAdeem @asimpleargument
...................................................
Video Link: • Is it halal to wish me...
#SahilAdeem #SahilAdeemMotivationalSpeaker #AsimpleArgment
Who Spread Islam: Muhammad (s.a.w.w)
Who Saved Islam: Hussain (a.s)
❤❤
Islam is and will be saved by one who sent Islam on earth.That is Allah. Hussain went to kufah for his khilafat
Well I'm a shia Muslim but we believe that we love Prophet Muhammad s.a.w, more than any one else, humari list main aaj bhi hazart Ali bahadri main dosrey number par Hain, pehla number har cheez main Meray nabi ka s.a.w, we only claim Hussain because he was Grandson of the Holly Prophet, s.a.w
baat unki bahaduri ki nhi ho rhi humari ho rhi h
@@faizanuddin. ham to KHASI hain.
People may call me a Sunni but i can honestly say that other than Allah and our beloved Prophet (SAW) i can easily sacrifice everything i have for Hussain A.H ❤☝🏻
Sahil Adeem is a scholar ahead of his times ...people will disagree with u on most terms right now but let me tell u after 10 years or 50 years or even 100 years u ll be remembered as one of the greatest scholars of Islam... 👍
May be but you cannot say scholar
Scholar nahin bhai a student who got his brain open rather than blindly following Mulahs and he is not touching anything which makes you non believer.... i too have always thought and believed as phenomenal the Creator is no doubt there are infinite science and phenomena hidden from us that we need to atleast tjink about... Wo jitna bara khaliq ha us k liye ye sababa and time n asmano k faslay kia maani rakhtay han or yakeenan jab Rab ne apnay Anbiya ko itni bari Zimadariyan sonpi tu aloom b diye hon ge coz Anbiya ne duniyawi schools or universities se tu parha nai unhein tu direct Jibrael ne ilm diya tu us ilm k agay hamara ilm kiya mani rakhta ha.... He might not be proved 100 percentright but is atleast pointing towards greater knowledge hidden in this world.
Yes u can say scholar of psycology
@@Zezu2015 tension na loo....tumay kis nay kaha molvio ko blindly follow karo ....yar medical engineering ap kud to nahee partay kisi university may lecturer say seektay ho istara quran wa hadith kay uloom sikney kay liye haq parast ulama ki talash karoo ...kud ager kitab say tafseer parogay to woo be kisi Alim nay likoo hogee na ....koi teqcher hoga na ya sirf sahil adeem say hadith ya tafseer parnee.....ap ulama ko ek taraf kerkay sida kadday may jagerogay ...blindly follow na karo sahee hay laken quran wa hadith ka ilm seeko or science ka bee....laken ager istara ki brain washing hogee kay ulama ko nikaloo beech may say pir apni khair manaoo.....
@@sherazalsaeedi2734 but ap tension zaroor lein and study languages first i clearly said "blindly following" and that too mulahs i didn't even used word scholars because scholars is a word for different categgory... thats a seperate debate but for the time being you can consider the educated people or religious field as scholars who talk with sense and reference...... I have read and mostly heard almost all scholars of all sects .... leaving and chosing according to how i found them.... n i also try to read the references they give from some authentic books like Saha Sita, Nehjul Bilagha, Ibne Kaseer etc. so i may know if they are quoting right... Bharhal Quran or Anbiya or Ehl e Bait k ikawa ghalti or kami beshi ki gunjaish har chez mein ha n i keep that in mind n this too k m too a very humble, kamfehm and gunahgar insan so i can't reach the whole truth yet i can keep looking for it.... Tu atleast apna deen samjhany ki koshish tu ha....
Respect & salute to him.
I’m Shia Muslim but I only say I’m Muslim & respect all sects.
I have subscribed this scholar , intellectual talk is need of the day.
Mee too♥️
Plz read Iqbal too you will find him better than many so called religious scholars who are actually distorting some truths to benefit their own school of thought....
That's the right approach brother
MA BROTHER PLEASE LISTEN TO ENGINEER MUHAMMAD ALI MIRZA
بات سیدھی تھی کہ نبی علیہ صلواۃ والسلام کے دین پر زندگی گزارو۔ اور ان کی مودت رکھو جن کی مودت و محبت کا حکم قرآن میں خدا نے دیا۔
بِسۡمِ اللّٰہِ الرَّحۡمٰنِ الرَّحِیۡمِ
اِنَّمَا یُرِیۡدُ اللّٰہُ لِیُذۡہِبَ عَنۡکُمُ الرِّجۡسَ اَہۡلَ الۡبَیۡتِ وَ یُطَہِّرَکُمۡ تَطۡہِیۡرًا
“Verily, verily Allah intends but to keep off from you (every kind of) uncleanness, O you the people of the House, and purify you (with) a thorough purification.” (33:33)
However, fair analysis about political dimension of religion and it's touch in geopolitical arena
ماشاءاللہ ماشاءاللہ اللّٰہ پاک ھمت دے استقامت دے سچ کا پرچم لہرایا آپ نے
Very good explanations , Sahil sahab knows the core.
Who conquered Syria, Iraq and Persia? Umar bin Khattab (Sunni)
Who has conquered the country of Sindi, India and the countries around the oxus river (Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan, Tajikistan and Turkmenistan.)? Muhammad bin Al-Qasim (Sunni)
Who is expanding North Africa? Qutaibah bin Muslim Al-Bahily (Sunni)
Who conquered Andalusia? Tariq bin Ziyad (Sunni) and Musa bin Nushair (Sunni)
Who was the conqueror of Konstantinovel? Muhammad Al-Fatih (Sunni)
Who conquered Sicily? Asad bin Al-Furaat (Sunni)
Who created civilization in Andalusia and made it a center of knowledge? The second Umawiyyah caliphs (Ahlus Sunnah)
Who was the Commander in Chief of the Muslims in the Battle of Hittin? Saladin Al-Ayyuby (Sunni)
Who led the Muslims in the battle of A'in Jalut and defeated the Tatars? Saifuddin Qutz (Sunni) and Ruknuddin Baibars (Sunni)
Who managed to break the arrogance of Spain in Morocco? Abdul Karim Al-Khattaby (Sunni)
Who forced Italy to leave Libya? Umar Al-Mukhtar (Sunni)
Then what is the Shia merit
Who had betrayed Al-Husein, persuaded him to come out to kufah and then defected from him in karbala? Al-Mukhtar As-saqafi (Shia)
Who betrayed the Abbasid caliph Al-Radhi billah in front of the Mongols? The Buwaihy (Shia)
Who paved the way for the Tatars to enter Baghdad? Ibn Al-Alqamy (Shia)
Who considered Hulagu Khan's actions good? Naseer Ath-Thusy (Shia)
Who helped the Tatars in their invasion of Syria? (Shia)
Who is allied with France against the Muslims? Fatimid State (Shia)
Who betrayed the Sultanate of the Seljuk? Tugril Bek al-Basasiri (Shia)
Who helped the crosses to control Baitul Maqdis? Ahmad bin Atha (Shia)
Who masterminded the murder of Sulthan Saladin Al-Ayyuby? Kanzud daulah (Shia)
Who welcomed Hulagu Khan to Syria? Kamaluddin bin badr Ath-Taflisy (Shia)
Who stole the Hajar Aswad and slaughtered the pilgrims at the Masjid al-Haram? Abu Thahir Al-Qarmathy (Shia)
Who helped Napoleon Bonaparte in his attack on Sham? (Shia)
And now,
Who stands with the Basyar
Out of context and bland argument without any context whatsoever. Also a very narrow-minded thinking. Firstly thinking these empires that tortured the family of Prophet SAWW were the representation of Islam and secondly these empires have ended and lost. They are not examples for us. And btw for your kind information the fatimids united the sunnis and the shias to fight the crusade only later for the problems of sunni-shia to be instigated again by the sunnis.
Secondly the qarmatians that u mentioned i mean just look at this deception. The qarmatians themselves were defeated by the shia. The general who defeated qarmatians in the big wars was a shia. So does that mean shiaism is on haqq now? The reality is you people will never learn until you keep blaming each other and not accepting your mistakes.
@@moosaali9371 U guys don't love prophet Muhammad SAWS u guys just a blind follower of Prophets slave Ali ibn abi talib.
the one who conquered the khyber is imam of shia the one who protect the propher s.a.w in khandaq and uhud is our imam the one who bring peace in muslim world and quit kingdom is my imam hasssn a.s the one who gave his blood to save islam is my imam hussain a.s
@@awaisarshad5915 Common Allah protected Rasulallah SAWS not Ali ra yes maybe hemAli ra did but Allah swt made him to do so..remember as a sunni myself i love ali ra.He got his brought up from Rasulullah SAWS just like son.He is like more son of Rasulullah than abi talib. Ali ra birth was a miracle of my Rasulallah SAWS..peace brother..
I am a Shia, I believe in the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him), then I believe in the Caliph Ali (peace be upon him). I would not have followed Ali (may Allah be pleased with him) if Allah and His Prophet (peace be upon him) had not commanded. I know about every enemy and friend of Allah, the Prophet, Ali and the Companions. The Shias are the real ones who know, accept and reject everything compared to the Sunnis.
Hz Ali r.a himself gave baith to the Khulafa who became khalifa before him if you don't agree with this then there is no difference between you and those khawarij who were with Hz Ali r.a initially and later turned against him when he agreed to have a truce with Hz Muaviya. how can you call yourself a follower of hz.ali when you dont' agree with his decisions?
❤❤
@@raazekunfakan If you are just gonna state statements from the text you follow than all we could say we agree to disagree. If you want to debate on it at least first read what is written by shia scholars in history. Don't just get opinionated by the stories what you heard.
For Shias, Allah swt, is the Malik Ul Mulk, Muhammad sww his final Messenger and NO ONE is above Rasool Allah sww and his Itrut a.s.
They follow Hussain a.s because he followed and exemplified Rasool Allah saw's path of success in this world and hereafter.
i respect him alot. he is a dimension of this Era
Mashallah..Sahi kaha Khuda aapko salamat rakhy muhtaram
Bro Very Deep Thoughts and Good Knowledge 👍🏻
Shias follows deen of prophet which was extended after prophet pbuh transferred to imam ali to the imam mehdi the 12th imam, the correction has to be made imam hussain was the 3rd imam all the 12 imams followed prophet Muhammads deen, this is the only significant difference between Shias and Sunnis, sunnis followed 4 Khalifs after pbuh
Jab Nabi s a w aur Sahaba karam thay tab firqa wariat Nahi thi ab hum Sunni shia Wahhabi pehlay aur muslman baad afsos hy Allah Muslim Uma ko Hidayat dy
we should unite whether its shia or Sunni!main thing is we are all Muslims.
جو بھی اللہ کے احکامات کو نبی کے طریقے پر سامنے رکھ کر اور صحابہ کرام رضوان اللہ علیہم اجمعین کے نقش قدم پر چل کر پورا کرتا ہے وہ ہی کامیاب ہے. اب وہ جس بھی راستے کو اختیار کرے. اہل سنت و الجماعت اسی کو کہا جاتا ہے
صحابہ کرام (منافقین ) کا راستہ باطل ہے ۔۔۔حق وہی ہے جس پر اہلبیت نے عمل کیا
@@chemicalengineer52
جب بھی صحابہ کرام رضوان اللہ علیہم اجمعین کی بات ہوتی ہے تو اہل بیت رضی اللہ عنہم اجمعین بھی ان میں شامل ہیں اور جو انکا انکار کرتا ہے وہ اہل بیت کا بھی منکر ہے.
جنکو اللہ نے رضی اللہ عنہ, یا ایھا الذین آمنوا, فان آمنوا بمثل ما انتم بہ فقد اھتدوا, اور اس جیسی کئی آیات کے ذریعے سند کامیابی عطا کی ہے. انکو کوئی کچھ بھی کہے ان محفوظ اور سند یافتہ ہستیوں کا تو کچھ نہیں بگڑتا مگر جو انکی شان میں گستاخی کرنے کی کوشش کرتا ہے خود کو ناجائز پیداوار ثابت کرتا ہے.
انہی کے بارے اللہ نے فرمایا ہے کہ جو صحابہ کو نعوذ باللہ بےوقوف کہتا ہے دراصل وہ خود ہی بے وقوف ہے اور وہ اسکا علم نہیں رکھتے. البقرہ رکوع نمبر دو.
صحابہ کرام رضوان اللہ علیہم اجمعین کی شان اہل بیت رضوان اللہ علیہم اجمعین سے پوچھو اور اہل بیت رضوان اللہ علیہم اجمعین کا مقام صحابہ کرام رضوان اللہ علیہم اجمعین سے سیکھ. تب پتا چلے گا کہ اصل میں یہ سب کون تھے. رضی اللہ تعالیٰ عنہ
Beshak Allah or aus k ambeya or sahaba or ahlahy bait k rasty pa chalny wala hi haq pa ha
@@chemicalengineer52
Tum shea aj tk ahlahy bait k rasty pa nhi chaly munafiq tu tum ho
@@chemicalengineer52
Bno umeyya k sath ml k imam Hussain ko qatal kr dia or ab dramy krty ho munafqat tumhary mahb ma ha
Masha Allah ❤
حضرت حسین ابن علی رضی اللہ تعالیٰ عنہ جنت کے سردار ہیں ۔اُنکے بغیر اسلام ادھورا ہے جیسے حضرت عمر فاروق رضی اللہ تعالیٰ عنہ کے بغیر۔ حضرت ابو بکر صدیق رضی االلہ تعالیٰ عنہ کے بغیر ۔
اسلام ادھورا نہیں بلکہ ہمارا ایمان اہل بیت کی محبت سے ہی مکمل ہوتا ہیں۔
There is no shia Sunni in the Quran I called myself Muslim
You are right
Yes
I’m a Shia but I’m Muslim first & respect all sects.
There is a Word "Shia" Literally, read the Quran again
Nice to see sikhi interview sahil
Hadees ka hawala dijiye ga which book and number of Hadith?Hussain (peace be upon him) per jo aap ne bayan ki
Only those muslims who want to avoid practicing Islam talk about differences Shia sunni deobandi barailvi ahle Hadis etc
سنی مسلم نماز میں جب درودشریف پڑھتے ہیں تو ان حضرت حسین ابن علی پر بھی درود بھیجتے ہیں کیونکہ آپ حضور کی آل ہیں۔جب کوئی دین کا گستاخ سر اٹھتا ہے تو سنی علماء اور سنی نوجوان ہی مقابلے میں کھڑے ہوتے ہیں۔
Aur Banu ummaya ko bhi maantey Hain, jis ne sale rasool ko dar badar phiraya, ahlebait ke bacho aur auryon ko qaid kiya.
Maqtool aur qaatil dono sahabhi
Aur phir Yazeed Pr lanat bhejne se rokte Hain ?
Zabardst
Bohat achy Bahi.
As a Shia Muslim I witnessed something in my time I spent studying in china that in the Chinese mosque there were no Shia or sunees to be found in the mosque ,during Muharram there was Friday khutbah dedicated to Karbala . And everyone sat through it no matter there sect and even grieved . So from what I understood is that these Muslims are way better than us they do all wajaybats,5 pillars ... And they go on with the life and we see this partition between us in Islam n it's if it's dying we r being transformed into atheists day by day the next generation is going to be more out of there minds more away from Islam.
If any body who is reading this would care to explain in what way Shia's did not use Imam Hussain A.S as Mr. Sahil claimed. The question is meant for inquiry not to steer any conflict.
We are shia First of all we love our phroph Muhammad s.w and than his ahlebait ❤❤shia and suni are brothers.....
Hazrat Ali r.a was a muslim , Our Nabi Kareem S.a.w was a Muslim , I'am a Muslim we all are Muslims , there is no such thing shia or sunni. Period
With Due Respect Sir but It was very surprising to hear that you are saying that Sunni do not take the name of Hazrat Hussain RA. You really playing diplomacy here. We just love your lectures and play it everyday in our mobiles but this is surprising for us.
Yeah he's just an appeaser who aims to enhance his following by pleasing other sects.
@@muhammadonaiz6176 No its not the matter. Somehow it is our fault that we did not give our religious personalities the respect and fame they should have.
@@muhammadonaiz6176 He doesn't aim to increase his followings otherwise he would have made many youtube channel by himself just like Mirza Engineer to just gain fame and followings.
@@abeehathevlogger5229 Diplomacy has no place in our Faith. Rather one should be brutally honest in his or her views. I have observed that wannabe Islamic Scholars or narrators who employ the art of diplomacy are usually trying to build fame for themselves. If an Alim doesn't even oppose the Fitnahmongers of his age then trust me he is upto no good but is a mute Satan. I don't make any judgement on Mr Sahil Adeem but I personally believe he is overrated. And his so called idols were mostly out of the Orthodox Sunni Islamic thought.
Maududi is the guy who spread many false viewpoints about Sahaba e Kiraam and even accused Sayyidna Usman e Ghani Zun Nurain RadiAllah Anhu of nepotism MaazAllah. Maulana Ishaq also had certain problematic views which oppose the consensus of the Muslim Ummah for 1400 years.
So called scholars who don't understand the status of the Noble Sahaba e Kiraam Ridwanullah Ta'ala Ajmaeen or Noble Ahle Bayt Kareemain will never be able to revive Islam in its true essence.
@@muhammadonaiz6176 Its your perception but in truth Mr Sahil Adeem has changed many people's life. No doubt you wrote everything very well and it is also true that people disagrees on something but it doesn't mean that the person spreading Islam is doing for his fame. So If he is doing what everyone should do, then he is doing his duty very perfectly.
Sir sorry to say i strongly disagree with your sentences uttered against Sunnis.... Hussain A.S is our leader too and we remember him all the time...
Yeah
There is a lot of difference between shia and sunni. Totally different
The question was which to follow, shia or sunni. Simple as that
Its unjustice ....no one can be compared side by side with Hazrat Muhammad (S.A.W) we are the ummat of Hazrat Muhammad (S.A.W) thats the part of our imaan ... really disappointed hearing this thing
کیا بات کر رہے ہیں۔پورے سال ہر نماز میں نبی کی آل پر درود نہیں بھیجتے؟
Mr. Sahil Adeem has made a good point. As a student of the Quran coming from a shia* background, I have come to the conclusions that although the Shia beliefs are very idealistic but some of their beliefs and actions are not at all in line with the Quran and same goes with the Sunnis.
such as...
> The Shia concept of Masoom Imams is false and is not by the Quran and it also is not a reasonable argument - only Allah is perfect, and this perfection cannot be attributed to any mortal being.
> Shia actions of making all the hues and cries during Muharram has nothing to do with the Deen of Islam, its a personal choice, however, this choice should be replaced by better and suitable actions, and this can be achieved by a little bit of reflection and rethinking.
> Shias needs to reconsider if the idea behind narrating the same events over and over again such that it invokes emotions and creates a permanent rift between both sects of Islam is whether in light of the Quran which enables believers to move forward to a new beginning (Past is only "Ibrat," it teaches us what to do and what not to do in our present).
Similarly, Sunnis need to...
> Let go of some of their tyrant heroes whom they keep glorifying and start looking at them in the same light as any student of history does, assessing the actions of these personalities objectively, while weighing both the pros and cons of what the actions of their heroes resulted in, not only in the past but up until today.
> Stop insisting more on physical appearance rather instead focus more on educating themselves so that it reflects in positive changes among Muslims in general as well as for the entire humanity.
> Stop clinging to the past, the past has nothing to do with the present. People living today can't be judged by the actions of those who are not with us.
> The Sunni concept of Rashedeen is also similar to the Shia concept of Masoomeen, both ideas are flawed, it is a counter response of one group versus the other where one declared its leaders as Rashedeen the other party chose to declare their leaders as Masoomeen or vice versa. No one can be declared permanently neither as "rightly guided" nor "free from flaws". Yes, everyone performed their best based on their capabilities and capacities granted to them by Allah SWT.
And...
Believing in Allah is the fundamental for growth and progress of individuals as well as society but it seems that Muslims' belief in Allah has instead stagnated them, "because of the fundamental flaw in their belief of Taqdeer," "This is a flawed belief that Allah will do everything for them and all they need to do is sabr and wait." This belief is far from the teachings of the Quran which correctly says that "Allah helps those who help themselves" When understood properly from the Quran's perspective what it means is, that the believers are actional people who produce positive and constructive outcomes for the progress and benefit of entire humanity.
If the Quran is understood properly, then a believer "unboxes" himself rather than missing the opportunities and closing all the paths of progress that Allah SWT has created for them and for the entire humanity.
*NOTE: I would rather call myself Shia only by my social roots but not by my belief and I disassociate myself from any sect after understanding the message of the Quran.
What is the meaning of this ayat tataheer? When Allah pak is saying k ahlbait ko pak kr dia hai. To pak krny ka kia mtlb h?
@@Pakspeechcompetetion Allah ne kahin pe ye nahi kaha ke us ne Ahle bayt ko pak kar diya as in forever wo kehta hai ke wo pak karne ka irada karta hai subject to the conditions in the verses 33:30-32, please read these verses 33:30-32 to be able to better understand the so-called ayat tataheer, 33:33, pakisgi ya rijz ka hatana is subject to the conditions mentioned in 33:30-32, if these conditions are met then "Allah irada karta hai" to remove rijz from Ahle bayt, this is "as per Allah", "it is not my personal opinion."
Another example you can find in verse 5:6, here Allah ne pakisgi ko wazu ke condition se associate kiya hai - meaning agar apne wazu kiya ya kisi wajuhat ki wajeh se nahi karsakte to aapki pakisgi hai salat ke liye.
Aise hi agar aap nafs ki pakisgi chahte ho to Allah ne uske conditions rakkhe hai us conditions ko pura karna padega yaqeenan.
In the end, Allah doesn't give anyone irrespective of whether someone is a Ahle-bayt or a Sahaba a blank check from the beginning without looking at their amaal, it is against the Sunnat of Allah, no matter who you are or anyone is, every one of us has to hold true to our progressive thoughts supported by our unwavering commitment and efforts to bring changes to our lives and the lives of our families, only then will Allah change our conditions towards betterment and the same applies to all.
مطلب ایسی باتیں کرو جو ہر کوئی دیکھے.... نه ادھر کا نہ ادھر کا...بس viewers زیادہ ہونے چاہیے..
Quraan says LAA TAFARRAKOO.. firkon mein na batto. Shiaism is the first sect in which had been divided. We must be muslims not sunni nor shia. We must respect allll prophets all ashaaba but this sect made a separate way of believes which must be condemned.. so plzzz sir dont mix these believes. They took a separate path to weaken islaam by highlighting this karbala incident. There is huge difference
Wow highlighting karbla weakens islam.... Ye kon sa sect ha??? Madaam karbla na hoti tu aj islam hota hi na, hum bhi chritians type ki koi chez ban chukay hotay
@asmatariq go and read ur saha sata books ju hadeesain aap k molvi chupaty hain Rasool Allah ne farmaya tha k main apnay baad tmhary beach 2 chezain chor kr ja raha hon ek Quran or dosri apni Ahlebaith dono ko thamo gay tu kabhi gumrah nai ho gay farq srf itna hai aap ne quran thama or ahlebaith chor di is lie itni division main bat gaye hum ne dono ko thama go and read sorah alay imran waha ayat e mubahila pr lena jaha Allah ne apne deen ki gawahi k lie bhi inhi 5 ko chuna tha Allah tu apni farz namaz taq qabool nahi karta jab taq Mohammad sww k saat un ki Aal pr dorood na bheju tu agar nabi k farman k mutabiq baad e nabi sub ahlebaith ka daman thamty tu ek page pr hi hoti aap ne ahlebaith ko chor kr deen kahi or se lia Baad e Nabi Rasool Allah k haqeeqi ilmi waris ahlebaith hi hain so do research k changes kiss ne ki
@@faizkhan-rd8jr bilkul darust farmaya ap ne bhai.... but i can see now k bohat se parhay likhay log han or ulma bhi jo Shia nahin magar Ehl e bait ki shaan biyan krtay han or logon ko samjhany ki koshish b ha k Ashaba k muqaam or Ehl e Bait ki Shaan do alag chezain han or in mein koi muqabla nahin or kuch log han jin ko kuch firqay zabardasti sahabion k muqaam pe laty han or wo haqeeqtan un Sahaba k muqaam pe b nahin.... Humein ilam ki bohar zaroorat ha iss waqt, apnay concept clear krnay ki r khud research krnay ki warna shayad bohat dair ho jae gi.... Or yun b Karbla k bad do hi firqay bachay han haqeetan Hussainiyat or Yazeediyat... Jo Hussain (a.s) ka nahin wo phir afsoos k sath dosri taraf khara ha or akhri moqa ha us k pas ya tu shamil-e-lashkar-e-shimar rahy ya phir Hur ban jae....
Aslam o Alaikum
Kaya kisi sunni ka imam bargah jana jaiz hai?
with due respect Ahadees came in 9th century in islam. Islam is well and truely completed by 632. and no hadees book are naration we can find till 9th century.
Shia does not celebrate shahdat of Hussain but they mourn on the shahadat. Quran clearly says shaheed are living.
Please don'r create confusion. shia does not follow the sunnah, they don't respect Abu Baker , Umer or Usman they don't like hazrat Aisha.
They don't pray in the masjid, they don't pray five prayer five times .
I am shia and you're telling lie about us.we pray in masjid.we respect Hzrat Aisha
Ap jhot bol rhe hn,,, correct byan kren
Asalaamalaikum Shahida, your 100% correct I had doubt about Sahil adeem because of his face and name. Now this video I caught him as justifying him Shia correct! May Allah protect from Fitna. Ameen. He is from them I think.
Yazeed or yazeediyat k khlaf protest kerty hein on ki mazlomiyat ka perchar Kerty hein
@@khawherasadikhashpa6191 Do you respect hazrat Umar and Abu Bakar R.A also? Do you believe in 12 imams?
This guy is confused. He is not an Islamic scholar or imam. Further he doesn't respect in one of his video's Auliya's.
If shia will fight for Islam.
I will with them.
ساحل صاحب معذرت کے ساتھ آپ نے غلط بولا کہ 10 محرم کے بعد شیعہ اور سنی امام حسین کو بھول جاتے۔۔ میں تو سمجھدار انسان سمجھتا تھا آپکو۔ مگر آپ کے اندر بھی وہ جراثیم ہیں جو شیعہ کا خلاف ہوتے۔ آپ سے گزارش ہے کہ آپ شیعہ حضرات میں بیٹھنا شروع کریں۔ آپ کو سارا سال علی علیہ سلام ، حسین علیہ السلام ، نبی پاک اور اہلیبیت کا ذکر ہی ملے گا۔ ہاں سنی حضرات بھول جاتے ہونگے 10 محرم کے بعد مگر شیعہ گھروں میں 21 صفر المظفر تک یعنی واقعہ کربلا کے چالیسویں تک سوگ منایا جاتا اور مجلسِ حسین جاری و ساری رہتی ہیں۔ لگتا ہے آپ نے اربعین کے جلوس وغیرہ کا مشاہدہ نہیں کیا کبھی۔ کیسے سکالر ہو جس کو اتنا بھی علم نہیں۔ کم از کم پوری تحقیق تو رکھو شیعوں پر ۔ اگر بات کرنی بھی ہے تو۔۔
Sir you must put nice camera پز
mujy SHIA or SUNNI conflict ny pagal kr dia or Sahil Bhai itna light lay rahy hain,,,
Pagal ku ho rhy hy bhai comparative study kre lg pata jana hy kon haq pe hy
@@ali.5.12 ki thi Thori c us ny mazeed confuse kr dia
Ap debates suna kre sunni ulama ki hassan allahyari k sath sb kuch samajh me ajaega
@@ali.5.12 wo banda to bohutt galiyan deta ha ..ghustakh ha
@@AaliyanHaadi-mm6si chalen aap mufti fazal hamdard sahb ko suna kre ahle sunnat k bht achy aalim hy ap ki sari confusion clear hojaegi
Sahil Bhai answer the question ! Don't give a illogical explanation
Please Speak the truth if you know.
You can identify shia by only a simple thing they will say Hussain A.S while muslim are saying Hussain R.A so you can see on which side he is not clear and try to be to much clear on this topic
Muslims say Hussain(as) Sunnis say Hussain (Ra)
@@ehtashamhaider203 true Muslims always say Hussain a.s even sir Sahil said Hussain a.s
@@ghulamnarjisghulamnarji3378 very true
Sons of ibn muljim and shimar and yazeed say (Ra)
Ali a.s.
Hasan a.s. Hussain a.s.
Zainul abidin a.s.
Imam baqir a.s.
Imam jafar sadiq a.s.
Musa qazim a.s.
Ali riza a.s.
Taqi a.s.
Nqi a.s.
Hasan askri a.s.
Imam mahdi alyh slam.
12 imam according hadees
Sunniism is sunism not islam
پہلی حقیقت بتا دوں کہ جو مجھے معلوم ہے کہ محرم کی پہلی تاریخ سے ایک دن پہلے ہی شیعہ غم منانا شروع کرتے ہیں اور سوا دو ماہ یعنی ربیع الاول کی 9 تک مسلسل غم کے ایام مناتے ہیں اس کے علاوہ اپنے ہر امام اور بیبی فاطمہ ع کے دنیا سے پردہ کرنے پر بھی ایام_فاطمیہ کے نام سے دس دن سوگ مناتے ہیں۔
دوسری اہم حقیقت جو مجھے معلوم ہے اور مشقاہدہ بھی کیا ہے کہ فقہ جعفریہ سے منسلک صرف حسین حسین نہیں کرتے کیونکہ انکی مجالس اور محافل میں رسول اللہ صلی اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم اور رسول اللہ ص کے اجداد کا زکر ہوتا رہتا ہے، یہاں تک کہ وہ اپنی دعاؤں میں رسول اللہ ص اور رسول اللہ ص کے اجداد کا زکر کرتے ہیں۔
پوری دنیا میں فقہ جعفریہ کی حکومت ایران میں قائم ہے اور اگر ان سے باقی ملکوں کے فقہ جعفریہ سے منسلک لوگوں کو جوڑ کر یہ کہا جائے کہ شیعوں نے اپنے اثاثوں کو نہیں اپنایا یا ان پر عمل نہیں کیا جبکہ سیاسی معالات میں جو انہیں مواقع ملے ان پر پیچھے قدم رکھے تو یہ بھی فقہ جعفریہ شیعہ کمیونٹی پر الزام ہے۔
بنیادی طوع پر ساحل عدیم آپ فقہ جعفریہ میں سیاسی معاملات سے آگاہ نہیں کیونکہ جو سیاسی ماحول دنیا بھر میں دیکھا اور پرکھا جا رہا ہے فقہ جعفریہ میں سیاسی معاملات بلکل اس سے برعکس ہیں، اس کی اہم وجہ فقہ جعفریہ میں نظریہ امامت ہے جو آپ کو معلوم نہیں
Shia Theology is strongest
Shia Sunni bhai bhai
Ghairullah ki shaamat ai
Insha allah
Great sir
Good
بہیت ہی آسان فارمولہ ہے میرے بھائیو کہ کون سا فرقہ حق پر ہے!
جو دس منٹ پہلے روزہ افطار کرتا ہے اس کا بھی کوئی قصور نہیں ہے اور بعد والے کا بھی۔ اور جو ہاتھ باندھ کر یا ہاتھ کھول کر نماز پڑھتا ہے اس کا بھی کوئی قصور نہیں کیونکہ اس کو اس کے امام نے کہا ہے کہ ایسا کرو اب چیک کرنا ہوگا کہ امام کس کا ٹھیک ہے؟
سورۂ بنی اسرائیل میں ہے کہ ہر کوئی آخرت کے دن اپنے امام کے ساتھ اٹھے گا۔
اور اگر اہل سنت کے چار اماموں کے ناموں پر غور کیا جائے تو امام احمد بن حنبل امام شافعی کے تابع نظر آۓ، امام شافعی امام مالک کے اور امام مالک امام ابوحنیفہ کے تابع نظر آۓ، اور امام ابوحنیفہ حضرت جعفر صادق کے شاگرد تھے دو سال اُن سے علم حاصل کیا۔
اور کہا تھا کہ اگر میں امام جعفر صادق سے دوسال نہ پڑھتا تو نعمان ہلاک ہوجاتا آپ کا نام نعمان بھی تھا۔
اب فیصلہ آپ کے ہاتھ میں ہے کہ آپ ایک استاد کی فقہ لینا چاہتے ہیں یا ایک شاگرد کی ؟
امام جعفر صادق سے پوچھا گیا کہ آپ حدیث کہاں سے لے کر ہمیں بیان کرتے ہیں؟
تو آپ نے فرمایا اپنے بابا سے اور انہوں نے اپنے بابا سے اور انہوں نے اپنے بابا امام حسین سے اور امام حسین نے اپنے بھائی امام حسن سے امام حسن نے اپنے بابا علی سے اور علی نے نبی پاک ص سے اور آپ ص نے جبرائیل سے اور جبرائیل نے لوح محفوظ سے اور لوحِ محفوظ سے قلم سے اور قلم کو حکم دیا اللّه پاک نے۔
اس میں کوئی مشکل بات یا میتھمیٹکس کا کوئی فارمولا یا پروف نہیں ہے جو آپ پریشان ہو رہے ہیں صرف دو جمع دو چار والی بات ہے جو سیدھی سی بات ہے۔
میں فرقہ بندی پسند نہیں کرتی، لیکن امت مسلمہ کی ماں ام المومنین حضرت عائشہ صدیقہ رضی ﷲ تعالیٰ عنہ پر بہتان اور گالی دینا جن ؓ کی شان میں سولہ آیات نازل ہوئیں، اور حضرت عمر فاروق رضی ﷲ تعالیٰ عنہ کو گالیاں دینے والے کو کیا آپ مسلمان کہہ سکتے ہیں ؟ تمام اہل تشیع ایسے نہیں جانتی ہوں لیکن جو ایسا بغض یا جرم کرتے ہیں صرف ان کے لئے سوال ہے
Mai b shia hon or true shia kabhi b Hazrat Ayesha or Hazrat Umar ko gali nahi dety. Han humari on se baaz mamlat per ikhtelaf hai liken gali bilkul nahi daty. Baqi har firqay mai extremists bohot hai to on k waja se pory firqay pe tag nahi lagana chaheye.
How can I join the live session?
Hussain razi tallah anhu not Ahale salam......
Ooh jahil a.S not r.a ..pehle mtlb Tu smjh lo
Same question As A Shia min apny Alama sy krta hon.. Hussaniyat k manany waly Shia Aag sy guzar Zanjeer chala ishaq jazbay min kr jaty hin... To Israel Kashmir k Muslim k liye Jihaad kiu ni kr skta.. Jawab ik he ata h.. Imam e Zamana ka intazar un k hukam k bager Jihaad ni kr skty.. Imam ka intazar to suni Shia ko h... But jihad Zalim k khelaf h phir Pakistan min zalim hakim e wqt ho ya area ka koi zalim.. Ya asrail india Army Sub pr faraz h in k khelaf jihaad
ساحل صاحب آپ نفسیات کو سامنے رکھتے ہیں. آپ انکے ساتھ عقائد کا بھی مطالعہ کریں تو آپ پر شیعہ کے عقائد واضح ہو جائیں گے.
pehkay aap apna aqeeda tu dorost kary Mohamamd sww k saat un ki aal pr dorood na bheju tu Allah apni namaz taq qabool nai karta un k baghir aap ka emaan kaha se mukamal hoga
Sahil adeem sahab ap shia ha sunni ha
قرآن و اهلبیت علیهم السلام ہی امت مسلمہ کی پہچان ہونی چاہیے کیونکہ یہ قرآن و احادیث کو متفقہ حکم ہے۔
اھلبیت اور قرآن کو چھوڑنے کی وجہ سے ہی امت مسلمہ رسوا ہو رہی ہے۔ امت نے اھلبیت کو نہ فقط چھوڑا بلکہ ان کا خون بہایا اور رسول اکرم صلی اللہ علیہ والہ کے تقدس اور وصیت کا بھی خیال نہیں رکھا جبکہ اھلبیت ہی قرآن کے حقیقی مفسر اور انسانیت کو نجات دلا سکتے ہیں
Allah humma sali ala muhammad wa aly Muhammad
بے تكا شرک اور بدترین قسم کا شرک پایا جاتا ہے شیعہ حضرات میں آپکو مزید انکو پڑھنے کی ضرورت ہے!!
سب سے ذیادہ شرک کے خلاف شیعہ ہے ھاں اگر آپ نے کچھ جاہل ذاکرین کو سنا ھو ان سے تو عالم شیعہ بھی خایف ہے۔ اصل شیعوں کو انجینئر محمد علی مرزا نے پڑھا ہے جسکو آپ سب رافضی کہتے ھیں۔ آپکو ان کے وڈیوز سے شیعوں کے عقیدے کے بارے میں بہت تفصیل سے معلومات ملیں گی
وہابی مشرک ہین کہتے ہین اللہ جسم رکھتا ہے ۔۔۔۔
pehlay apna qibla dorost kr lo ju Allah alay nabi pr dorood na bheju tu apni namaz taq qabool nahi krta vo aap ka emaan kia qabool kary ga jakar apni kitabain parho kis ne haq chupaya or kis ne usay apnaya
Hamain Kiya karna chahiyay? Apart from the 5 pillars what should we do?
Achay kaam kro. Sab ki madad kro. Allah ko hamesha yaad rakho
Sahil Adeem: the person who believed & practiced the maun pilers of islam. Namaz roza zakat hajj.. Is Muslim. Don't say suni is not Muslim according to shia.. And vice versa.. 🍁
سوال کچھ تھا جواب کدھر کا کدھر لے گئے
Tu jawab dede tuje malum hai to
Beta G, Ham Sunni hn or Aksar Jummy me Hasnain Karemain ki seerah sunty hn , Alhamdulillah
Aap apna data in order karo, before commenting
bro sahil adeem but why is difference in kalma? and correct hussain R.A not A.S.
Lol. Bas kar do bhai. Nikal aao is R.A A.S say 🤦♂️
LOL go and see sahih bukhari abu dawood imams used alayhis salam with ahlul bait names. And kalma is same ..
aap na bukhary Shareef ma nhi dekha hai as hai na ki ra for ur kind information just go and read bukhri sharafe
@@MohaddisMehdiEloquent tum b nikal aao ABU BAKR RA sahe ly k baqi sahaba sahe ,tum log ki waja sahe islam kharab hua
go and read ur sahi bukhari jaha imam bukhari ne unhay a.s likha hai jin pr Allah ne apni farz namaz main dorood rakha ho vo r.z nahi a.s hoty hain ashaab r.z hain kiu k un pr namaz main dorood nahi hai and go and read sorah alay imran waha mobahilla ka waqia pr lena
Sahil bhai is right.... Global politics me zero identity he muslims (shia/suni) ki...pakistanyon ko دین (religion) or مذہب (sect) me frq hi ni pta.... hmen as muslim globally apni identity represents krni chahye na k firqawarana shia/sunii
Ajj kal agar koi muslim Tableegh ya Jahad kelie struggle ni kar raha toh kisi bhi sect se ho, kese bhi raho
Bass naam ke musalman hee ho tum
Why are you saying ya to rasool ya husain. Both are same .not separate. Please. If no husain no there was no islam no rasool .
With due respect .Mr Sahil here u indulge in diplomacy....
Ali ya hasan ya husein ne kon sa aisa karnama kiya jis se islam ko koi faida pohcha ho .
Apke comment me lehje se pata chalrha na aap sunoge ya samjhoge or doosri bat Nabi A.S ke bhai Mola Ali A.S or unke bacche joke nabi ki beti bibi fatima se hoe unka naam aese le rhe hoo jese tumhare dost yaar hai. sharam kar or darr Allah se
Apny Bilkol bi Theek explain nai kia.
Did you believe in system of khalafat or imamat , both aren't right way only one is right , how you judged I mean in knowledge, faithful , bravery or other way
I myself listened from a shia alim that Nawuzbillah Hazrat Umar Farooq RA ny Bibi Fatima RA k drwaaza mara. I mean it gave me so much pain. How can you misinterpret our Caliphs like this. To which I humbly say that He is one of the Ashra MUbashras n unko dunya main jannat ki basharat khud RASUL ALLAH SAW ny di thi.... Plz do not indulge in such debates. Yai chzn hmy alg krti hn. Yhi us wkt hua ta hmy is sb sy sbk seekhna chahye we should be united. We are Muslmans not The thekydar of sects. We should try to become Momins. Not Shia-sunni-wahabi plus many others. JazakAllah
Shia aalim ka kya qasur hai 40 sunni riwayat mei yeh waqeya sunni books mei aya hai us becharey ko dosh denay ka kya faida
@@vladimirhaider5777 KUTAAYYY KISI SUNNI BOOK MEIN YE NHI LIKHI. NA ISS WAQIYE KY KOI HAQIQAT H. HAZRAT UMER E FAROOQ ZINDABAAD HAZRAT FATIMA TUZ ZAHRA ZINDABAAD
@@vladimirhaider5777oh really then do you really know that those rawayats are zaeef or not? Secondly darwaaza jalaane Ka waqoa Kisi bhi Sunni book mein Nahi hai...
I don't think that shia and sunni different. Shia is different domain. They are completly different, some of shia sects does not have same kalima, so then what is common?
You don't know... go read the kalima and tell me the difference
@shahidarazak go and read ur saha sata books ju hadeesain aap k molvi chupaty hain Rasool Allah ne farmaya tha k main apnay baad tmhary beach 2 chezain chor kr ja raha hon ek Quran or dosri apni Ahlebaith dono ko thamo gay tu kabhi gumrah nai ho gay farq srf itna hai aap ne quran thama or ahlebaith chor di is lie itni division main bat gaye hum ne dono ko thama go and read sorah alay imran waha ayat e mubahila pr lena jaha Allah ne apne deen ki gawahi k lie bhi inhi 5 ko chuna tha Allah tu apni farz namaz taq qabool nahi karta jab taq Mohammad sww k saat un ki Aal pr dorood na bheju tu agar nabi k farman k mutabiq baad e nabi sub ahlebaith ka daman thamty tu ek page pr hi hoti aap ne ahlebaith ko chor kr deen kahi or se lia Baad e Nabi Rasool Allah k haqeeqi ilmi waris ahlebaith hi hain so do research k changes kiss ne ki
Meray nawasay ka naam hussain hai
Hm to lete hn g hussain r.a ka nam b
You can't even imagine that you will go far ahead by the grace of Allah, but in the process of growing ahead, but please don't become the second Mirza engineer.
شیعہ شریعت کے ہر کام اور عمل میں نبی کریم صلی اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم اور اللہ رب العزت کی مکمل مخالفت بھی کرےاور پھر بھی" مسلمان " وہ کیسے؟؟؟
ذرا سمجھا دیا جائے نا ہمیں بھی کہ کالا کافر سفید مسلمان کیسے ہو سکتا ہے؟؟؟
جب تک وہ آللہ اور رسول علیہ سلام کا کلمہ پڑھیں گے ہم کافر نہی کہ سکتے ۔
کیوں آپ کون ہوتے ہیں مسلمانوں کو رنگوں میں بانٹھنے والے ؟ کون سفید ہے کون کالا؟ اتنا کبر تو شیطان میں بھی نہیں تھا۔ اس نے تو صرف سجدہ کرنے سے انکار کیا تھا۔
جب تک کوئی بھی مسلمان" لا الہ اللہ محمدالرسول اللہ" پڑھے اور رسول اللہ کے خاتم النبیین ھونے پہ ایمان رکھے، وہ مسلمان ہے۔ خدا نہ بنتے پھرو اور نہ دوسروں پر کفر کے فتوے لگاتے پھرو
@@k.a1388 bilkul.
تم خود پہلے اپنے اندر جا کر دیکھو تم خود کتنے فیصد مسلمان ہو
رسول ص کی سنت اصول کافی سے جائے گی نہ کہ غلط بخاری سے
Ab yeh admi muji confuse kar raha hai
Main bahut shia ko janta ho k Abubakr, Omer aur Usman ok galia deta hai
Aisha ko pasand nahe karta apne bacho ke name omer ya Aisha nahe rakte etc. aur yeh brother keh rahe hai shia suni main farq nahi hai
Please help me main gumrah nahi hona chahte ho
Kis ko Trust kro? 😔
Quran aur hadees ko follow Karo aur jo scholar Quran aur hadees ke mutabiq baat Karn wo unse Lelo aur jo usse ht kr karn wo chorh do simple
Dude there are many sects within Shias as well, just like in Sunni Islam. In Shiaism some practice beating themselves up but some don't.
oh bhai pehle tu khud tu imul momineen or sahaba ka naam tameez se le
Dear brother i am not agree on this point... sunni name their children Hussain,Ali, all ahle bait. But tell me whether sheea put their children names Umer , Abubacker , Usman? Never.
Do not say that sunni donot take names of Hussain r.a. Sunni express ahadith about Hussain r.a.
This is not definit that in all point Sahil sahib is correct.
Meray baray bhai ka name usman hai woh shia hai😂😂😂ek dost hai us ka name umar shah hai woh bhi shia hai ....chalo bhago jhoutay...
@@vladimirhaider5777 i do not believe, it's a big lie. sb say ziyada bughz sheea logon ko Hazrat Umer say hay, how they can put their names as Umer.. i chellange you. Ok tell me any of your big scholar name is Umer or Usman or Abubacker????
You are wrong in discrediting the revolution of Iran
The only nation in the world ruled by an Imam as a head of state over all politicians …
And that too is a person who did NOT elect himself.. and is not a materialist.. nor bound to or afraid by the west… being the only muslim country who stands wth Palestinians and speaks agnst injustice anywhere wthout fear of consequences.
Please admit to ur biases
No one is sating tht they are perfect and dnt hv there own issues.. but atleast recognize the good
Very confusing.... Hum daily ap k lectures sunty hain. Mgr yahan ap ne mayos kr 1 sided baat kr k... Ap ki batoon se lgta hy k ap ahl e shia mai se hain..... Ap ne kesy keh dia k sunni Muslims husain رضی اللہ ka zikr he nahi krty... Galat hy sab Muslims nabi pak صلی اللہ علیہ والہ وسلم aur un ki pori aal( آل) se muhabat krty hain, husain razi Allah ki qurbani ko salam krty hain..... Ye ap ne galat kaha aur buht galat kaha.... Nabi ki family par hamri jaan qurbaan.... Hum sab Muslims soch bhi nahi skty k hum Ali razi Allah se bhi wesy he aqeedat rkhty hain jitna hamary nabi PBUH rakhty thy.....
Yai video daikhnai k Baad sir AP to Dil sai hi otar gy.
Sir bigger picture ki bat ker rahy, mostly sunni hazraat Hazrat Hussain AS ko us tarah se yad ni karty jesy shia hazrat kerty hein... Like during Muharram ..
Good explained
Jub Allah ne Kaha Quran sharif mei tafaraqo mei Mut perhna
Aur Rasool Allah ne hamara name musalman diya na shia aur sunni
Shia aur sunni musalmano bantei
Sahil bhai here you are wrong, Prophet Muhammad SAW is the Rehmat Ul aalmin, Sardar Ul Anbia. Please don't be do a diplomatic answer. Do clear answer and Allah sobhanaho TaAllah love clear words person. Thanks
You are a good scholar and I appreciate your research but you should do your research more on sects.
Answer isn't clear. Rather, more confused after listening.
s ka hal quraan aur sahi ahadis. jo mazhab mi jo shirk aur dusri bathay jo bughaz ki waja si thasleem nahi karha yi lug mojrim hay. char amam tik hay s liyi k os ni hamari samajni ki liyi deen asan ki ya . yi s zamani ki loog hay jo apni mufaad k liyi sahi rasthay pi nahi athay . agar kees mazab mi goomrahi daki yi mazhab si na jori agar masla hal krna hay mazhab ki saath jo yi quraan our ahadees ka sar chashma hay apna hal thlash kri.
Kuch gadbad hai yahan .. Jo ye zaahir krrhe hen wo ye hen nahi .. Baaki WALLAHU AALAM .. i think hmen wo bten sunni chaiye jo bs ALLAH SWT or inke RASOOL S.A.W.W se close kren baaki saari bten nhi sunni chaiye ... JAZAKALLAH HO KHAIRAN KASEERAN KASEERA
Sometimes he goes illogical
Do not say for shiya voh bhi atse hi muslim jese sunni. In real shiya is real muslim . Sorry to say that . Do not say shiya bhi shiya bhi. Shiyas are direct relation from Rasool Allah S. A.
Sahil Sahab please pehle Shia ke bare me saheh maloomat parh len wo bhi shia kitabun se...
❤