I don't know why people are criticizing his mistakes (the boy) - it is after all a "class" not an actual performance. I think he did a fantastic job and he will be a great pianist if he keeps it up. To all those who are quick to judge and criticize, what Masterpiece did YOU play at 11 years of age?
Carmen CES Nice,I waiting your comment as long .This show the manners of western people and eastern people.They just like criticizing someone doing the mistake ,maybe including his parents like mine .They doesn't know what is art of music ,they come here not enjoy the music ,they just want to see the pro boy .
If there is no correction there is no progress. The master is doing the little chap great favor. These mistakes can only be heard by master abd not the ordinary.
Lang Lang very patient here, knowing the kids level and adjusting the masterclass to it while trying to enthusiast and relaxing the kid to keep on performing and not to be too nervous.
zakuzen You wrong ,music should playing relaxing .This song is relaxing ,don't push too much .Lang Lang is telling the truth for how playing the score clearly .
Floris Ende WOW. I was totally ignorant of that, sorry. Apparently he developed wonderful qualities in spite of his parents-or perhaps there were other aspects of their parenting which were positive.
@@florisende8015 is there a source documenting his unhappy childhood or are you just assuming that all virtuoso pianists are the product of tiger parenting
What a kind and generous man is Lang Lang. His passion and enthusiasm to help this kid shows great admiration for the young and upcoming young lad. Even I learnt a thing or two. Good on you Lang Lang . Great masterclass which had me spellbound.
What a load of nonsence. He plays it well and it IS his level. He has massive hands and "Power" as you call it is weight and not force. You don't need muscles....
Lang Lang is a wonderful teacher and role model. Meanwhile, that kid's a very bright muscian--a quick study who immediately understood the coaching he was receiving in phrasing and articulation. Beautiful to watch this.
Was very reluctant to chime in, but kudos to Lang Lang for having just the right touch in every respect. He gave very kind guidance, culminating in "don't kill yourself." It was such an honest and gentle way of saying that Thomas should grown into this piece, it's a little bit beyond his grasp right now. But he was completely encouraging, and above all supportive, while telling the boy he should focus on practicing with love, not to be a keyboard gladiator, which will only backfire. Just the right "touch." Btw, beautiful playing from Lang Lang on thd orchestra part, clearly showing his years of experience (probably a hundred performances) of this piece. What I enjoyed most about it was the freshness he played it with: clearly knows the music inside out, but this was an opportunity to be "on thd other end," and he brought out the nuances as only someone with that experience could, even more than a conductor who can only convey the interpetation through other musicians. Here you had the orchestra part refined to its purests essence that an actial orchestra would dilute. So I'm rather in agreemebt with those finding this strangely nicer than a real orchestra. This also of course made it more intimate, less bombastic than a 60 piece orchestra. So much to appreciate in this, but most of all Lang lang's gentle supportiveness and genuine caring towards a very accomplished pupil who must take care that ambition (his own or perhsps his parents') doesn't become counterproductive. "Don't break your hands." "Don't kill yourself." Seems to me those are wise, and truly caring, words.
Wonderful. And thank you Lang Lang for your contribution to young people everywhere..of course I am always enjoying your beautiful music mastery. Thank you. DeeKing USA
11 years old and already playing the tchaikovsky concerto! Amazing! I am trying to learn this now and i must say, he must be so proud of his efforts and the way he executes the music.
@@roi_k I see I tell to the opponent, there is nothing amazing of playing Tchaikovsky concerto. amazing would be if you play amazingly, but this boy at the video doesn't
@@vaxx2007 He's still learning, and besides the fact he's able to play that piece is already good enough. Yes there is some problems, but he's still learning and doing quite good.
@@e.ashton so good enough, or amazing? you say very very obvious things, I don't have a thing to add. but then you forget what I said before, and what I did not like in opponent's review.
Thomas proves he is a very good student , quickly applying direct and worthy criticism. It’s a class, Lang Lang is the master- Thomas improved his “sound” technique instantly- thanks for the upload.
Lang Lang does a fine job offering constructive suggestions to this talented lad. Correcting his overuse of the pedal will be the defining moment for his playing to make a quantum leap.
Lang LAng is such a great teacher. Good job Thomas. We're always impressed seeing the challenges you tackle. In a few years, this piece will be fit you perfectly and everything else will seem easy!
“Play always as if in the presence of a master.” ― Yan Ayrton Bravissimo Thomas Chan ! This is the ethernal magic from Music - solidarity, superior Beauty and excellence don't matters the limits from age.A perfect duo example, in a unique, sensible and definitive performance for the Universe.The others not-humans intelligences are receptive for this kind of man (by a child) brilliant transcendence and communion. ARS SEMPER.VITA PLENA. Very sincerely , the young&old classical composer Yan Ayrton
I'm not even going to read the comments but I already imagine people strongly opposing against this kid. To be honest I'm never too amazed by prodigies and I'm quite sceptic when I read about them but this kid was indeed quite good. I wasn't expecting an excellent performance but the kid delivered something, he wasn't perfect made few mistakes. The interpretation wasn't always great but reasonably enough, a 11 years old doesn't have too much to give, he's literally not old enough. The point is, for his age this is amazing.
kendalljazz Calm down. You expect some feeling from someone who's 20 or more. Oh yeah, I almost forgot how terrible music industry is these days, maybe this kid really is better than some "talented" adults.
The problem with perfection is that it makes us think art is easy. It is not. Thanks Lang and Thomas to reminds us, to show us that to attain perfection is such a "lang lang" road.
This quietly young boy is brilliant and has a wonderful future. It’s interesting to watch Lang Lang the master pick up those free areas which needed more attention. I’m a piano examiner and see this all the time. It’s important to practice slow and carefully and to get everything right and not blur with the pedal .
Whilst I absolutely abhorred Lang Lang as an artist, I adore what he does for the classical repertoire by bringing it to the masses as well as his work with the youth.
Everyone know Lang Lang is master, but young can win in the future International Fryderyk Chopin Piano Competition. Congratulations from Poland, homeland of Chopin for Thomas Chan.
banaantjexx164 glassy sky, if you meant by animenz then its not that hard. I'm 17 and I'm struggling with his unravel. That has notes that are hard to hit.
Well we all have to start some were, I am 16 and I’m learning Chopin’s nocturne in C# minor op posth and working my way up to complex Chopin, Liszt, and this piece.
@@firstbourne8799 its probably a little late now, but you can start by playing some easier pieces that animenz transcribed, for example aLIEz. Also it always depends on how deep you analyse the music. Just playing the notes with kind of the right volume is quite easy compared to a deep analysis of the details, rhythm, different melodies, etc.
Yo a esa edad escuchaba ésta introducción de éste concierto cómo cortina de radio novela qué transmitía la emisora. Siempre soñé con tocar el piano pero los recursos económicos fue un tremendo problema... Hasta ahora, sólo sueño y soy un simple melomano. Gracias.
Wonderful lesson by a maestro to an extremely talented youngster. I think he gets his points across expressively and the lad improves each time he intervenes. My goodness it's hard to play!
Everyone has his own favorite players. If you don't like this video, nobody is asking you to watch it. Come on, give Thomas Chan a break. After all, he is only 11 years old. For those who are casting negative comments on his playing, could you have played or have you attempted to play this difficult piece? Lang Lang admitted he did not play this piece until he was 13 years old. And for those of you who do not know this, Tchaikovsky was gay and had to keep it hidden from the public. He had a miserable and loveless marriage, and committed suicide. But what a legacy of great music he left for posterity. Gay people are born gay, and we must accept this. At least the Supreme Court has recognized them and has given them the right to marry in all 50 states.
Unless you are a world class pianist, you have no right to make a comment like this. I am a grade 8 and whilst I can play this piece its nowhere near as good as these guys!!!
Master class is suppose to be learning from the master. As such critiquing is essential so one can improve. And you need to perform so the master teacher can point out your weak points. It is a one-on-one class.
That's exactly what I was thinking during the whole performance. Bad choice, also it's challenging to make a good interpratation even for older pianists.
Actually, you saw how big his hands were . . . and he's certainly not lacking too much power. It's more the musical interpretation I guess. I don't really think it's a bad choice for him, good experience fun piece sry for bda english.
![ลองสุ่มไอโฟน 990 โกงมั้ย? [ โกงมั้ยครับ ep.101 ] | DOM](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bfsWe0j492k/mqdefault.jpg)
Lang Lang as always Very kind, Very polite, Very sweet....GREAT pianist! Respect!
myron kotaishi Sure I like Lang Lang too.He is no.1 in my heart ,his the artist ,he is the pianist .He is wonderful.
@@小康-q8v Your grammar is terrible
Fat Boi Thanks to correct my grammar which I commends on this video when I was young .
@@小康-q8v I didn't correct it, you corrected on your own, so good job! but your sentences still don't make sense.
Fat Boi lmfao
I don't know why people are criticizing his mistakes (the boy) - it is after all a "class" not an actual performance. I think he did a fantastic job and he will be a great pianist if he keeps it up. To all those who are quick to judge and criticize, what Masterpiece did YOU play at 11 years of age?
Carmen CES Nice,I waiting your comment as long .This show the manners of western people and eastern people.They just like criticizing someone doing the mistake ,maybe including his parents like mine .They doesn't know what is art of music ,they come here not enjoy the music ,they just want to see the pro boy .
Carmen CES Well said. "People who live in glass house should not cast stones."
Exactly! It is a class! If you critisise someone who is practising and isn’t actualy performing, it makes you an asshole.
I believe it was due to his short or small hand and weaker muscle are what causing such mistake and not on his.
If there is no correction there is no progress. The master is doing the little chap great favor. These mistakes can only be heard by master abd not the ordinary.
I admire how confident and relaxed Lang Lang is. Even him flipping the score page is stylish and in beat. 2:09
I could watch Lang Lang’s masterclasses, all day, it is so valuable to students and me!
Shirley Hare me too！
Lang Lang very patient here, knowing the kids level and adjusting the masterclass to it while trying to enthusiast and relaxing the kid to keep on performing and not to be too nervous.
zakuzen You wrong ,music should playing relaxing .This song is relaxing ,don't push too much .Lang Lang is telling the truth for how playing the score clearly .
Grammar check.
I admire the artist, but I get to admire even more the great dedicated teacher. That's when you really show your true greatness, dear Lang Lang.
At age 11 I was a great Super Nintendo player.
I wanted a pet Digimon at that age
My 10 year old kicks ass at Fortnite
And i played clash of clans (still do)
I was very good at building Minecraft houses
I play robux
Lang Lang is such a good teacher and always so encouraging to the young students.
Kudos to Lang Lang’s parents for their role in raising such an wonderful human being.
lol, yeah kudos for driving your kid to the brink of suicide. You cannot seriously say that the parenting of Lang Lang has been healthy
Floris Ende WOW. I was totally ignorant of that, sorry. Apparently he developed wonderful qualities in spite of his parents-or perhaps there were other aspects of their parenting which were positive.
@@FatherTau glad to be of help! Yes, Lang Lang turned out fine but I'm sure his childhood has been traumatical
I know it sounds terrible but perhaps his father knows that's the only way to get the best out of him.
@@florisende8015 is there a source documenting his unhappy childhood or are you just assuming that all virtuoso pianists are the product of tiger parenting
Wow how one single class changed this boy career!!! Amazing!
What a kind and generous man is Lang Lang. His passion and enthusiasm to help this kid shows great admiration for the young and upcoming young lad. Even I learnt a thing or two. Good on you Lang Lang . Great masterclass which had me spellbound.
What a load of nonsence. He plays it well and it IS his level. He has massive hands and "Power" as you call it is weight and not force. You don't need muscles....
Lang Lang is a wonderful teacher and role model. Meanwhile, that kid's a very bright muscian--a quick study who immediately understood the coaching he was receiving in phrasing and articulation. Beautiful to watch this.
Absolutely LOVE and ADMIRE Lang Lang !!! He makes this music come alive! Lots and lots and lots of love!!!
Was very reluctant to chime in, but kudos to Lang Lang for having just the right touch in every respect. He gave very kind guidance, culminating in "don't kill yourself." It was such an honest and gentle way of saying that Thomas should grown into this piece, it's a little bit beyond his grasp right now. But he was completely encouraging, and above all supportive, while telling the boy he should focus on practicing with love, not to be a keyboard gladiator, which will only backfire. Just the right "touch."
Btw, beautiful playing from Lang Lang on thd orchestra part, clearly showing his years of experience (probably a hundred performances) of this piece. What I enjoyed most about it was the freshness he played it with: clearly knows the music inside out, but this was an opportunity to be "on thd other end," and he brought out the nuances as only someone with that experience could, even more than a conductor who can only convey the interpetation through other musicians. Here you had the orchestra part refined to its purests essence that an actial orchestra would dilute. So I'm rather in agreemebt with those finding this strangely nicer than a real orchestra. This also of course made it more intimate, less bombastic than a 60 piece orchestra.
So much to appreciate in this, but most of all Lang lang's gentle supportiveness and genuine caring towards a very accomplished pupil who must take care that ambition (his own or perhsps his parents') doesn't become counterproductive. "Don't break your hands." "Don't kill yourself." Seems to me those are wise, and truly caring, words.
Absolutely love this kids talent at such a young age, and absolutely love Lang Lang
Wonderful. And thank you Lang Lang for your contribution to young people everywhere..of course I am always enjoying your beautiful music mastery. Thank you. DeeKing USA
11 years old and already playing the tchaikovsky concerto! Amazing! I am trying to learn this now and i must say, he must be so proud of his efforts and the way he executes the music.
nothing amazing here. you are shocked by the fact itself? it's nonsense.
@@vaxx2007 what are you trying to say
@@roi_k I see I tell to the opponent, there is nothing amazing of playing Tchaikovsky concerto. amazing would be if you play amazingly, but this boy at the video doesn't
@@vaxx2007 He's still learning, and besides the fact he's able to play that piece is already good enough. Yes there is some problems, but he's still learning and doing quite good.
@@e.ashton so good enough, or amazing?
you say very very obvious things, I don't have a thing to add. but then you forget what I said before, and what I did not like in opponent's review.
Just because LangLang isnt a tchaikovsky specialist doesnt mean he cant teach tchaikovsky. Hes plenty good enough.
Thomas is a very talented boy and Lang Lang an excellent piano professor.
朗朗真的厉害！！！在立式琴上就弹出了整个乐队的声音
He is sincerely teaching him for an event. Lang Lang, respect !
nice teacher, lang lang. I like his outreach to the younger gen. kind person, I guess.
What a brilliant man and inspiring teacher Mr Lang Lang is
Lang Lang is so kind. He visit this gifted young child man just by himself. I like their moving gesture.
another young genius - so wonderful to hear and watch how Langlang teaches. All awesome.
oh to have had Lang Lang as my teacher when I was 11!! Wonderful to see him bring out the best from this already magnificent young pianist .
that steinway sounds absolutely beautiful and the kid is doing that amazing piano justice
He truly has an amazing teaching style. so great at inspiring his pupils!
Thomas proves he is a very good student , quickly applying direct and worthy criticism. It’s a class, Lang Lang is the master- Thomas improved his “sound” technique instantly- thanks for the upload.
The boy is very talented... it was a pleasure to listen to this class...
I could learn a lot from Lang Lang’s teaching video. Thank you for sharing!
Lang Lang does a fine job offering constructive suggestions to this talented lad. Correcting his overuse of the pedal will be the defining moment for his playing to make a quantum leap.
Lang LAng is such a great teacher. Good job Thomas. We're always impressed seeing the challenges you tackle. In a few years, this piece will be fit you perfectly and everything else will seem easy!
I've already played for 40 hours today, but this inspires me to play even more!
朗朗has a great sense of humor and he always shows that in these classes with students.
What a confident young man.
Love Lang Lang doing this
“Play always as if in the presence of a master.” ― Yan Ayrton
Bravissimo Thomas Chan ! This is the ethernal magic from Music - solidarity, superior Beauty and excellence don't matters the limits from age.A perfect duo example, in a unique, sensible and definitive performance for the Universe.The others not-humans intelligences are receptive for this kind of man (by a child) brilliant transcendence and communion. ARS SEMPER.VITA PLENA. Very sincerely , the young&old classical composer Yan Ayrton
I am inspired by the music langlang play and he is a respectful and polite pionist
Thomas Chan should be 21 by now.................Best wishes to him on Christmas.............Dec.24th 2021 ❤❤❤
I'm not even going to read the comments but I already imagine people strongly opposing against this kid. To be honest I'm never too amazed by prodigies and I'm quite sceptic when I read about them but this kid was indeed quite good. I wasn't expecting an excellent performance but the kid delivered something, he wasn't perfect made few mistakes. The interpretation wasn't always great but reasonably enough, a 11 years old doesn't have too much to give, he's literally not old enough. The point is, for his age this is amazing.
For any age this is amazing.
kendalljazz
Calm down. You expect some feeling from someone who's 20 or more.
Oh yeah, I almost forgot how terrible music industry is these days, maybe this kid really is better than some "talented" adults.
I love how when the kid started having memory slips near the end lang lang noticed and gave him the music.
The problem with perfection is that it makes us think art is easy. It is not. Thanks Lang and Thomas to reminds us, to show us that to attain perfection is such a "lang lang" road.
Lang Lang playing on a upright!?!?!?!?! :O
cuevaspedrocarrillo, yeah and one that sounds bl**dy awful too. Not his fault, obviously, but that upright really is horrible.
Upright grand good enough lor
Indeed! It reflects very bad on the sponsor of the event. They didn’t have another grand piano to put side by side? What a shame!
Lovely performance by student and teacher....no complaints from me
Totally !
I am totally Amazed by the kid braveness .
and I WISH he could teach me as well
Thomas a very clever boy. He absorbs Lang Lang's instructions really fast.
I agree. He improved so much
This quietly young boy is brilliant and has a wonderful future. It’s interesting to watch Lang Lang the master pick up those free areas which needed more attention. I’m a piano examiner and see this all the time. It’s important to practice slow and carefully and to get everything right and not blur with the pedal .
Whilst I absolutely abhorred Lang Lang as an artist, I adore what he does for the classical repertoire by bringing it to the masses as well as his work with the youth.
Abbhorr ed but no longer....we are so relieved.........2nd violinist
My favorite concerto.This young man is doing great.He has a wonderful teacher. Yang Yang
Yang Yang?
Everyone know Lang Lang is master, but young can win in the future International Fryderyk Chopin Piano Competition. Congratulations from Poland, homeland of Chopin for Thomas Chan.
Fantastic Lang Lang. Be blessing for others. So proud to see this video. Here I support your channel my friend. Greeting from California.
Amazing! eleven years old.And ...if Tchaikovsky was listen to this ?? ...Thank you ...this video.
ai, meu DEUSSSS!!! EU AMOOOOO ISSOOO!!! Ele é um gênio da música! E tocando Concerto N 1 de Tchaikovsky é pra me matar de vez... ♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡
Me too, as DRQ DRN - absolutly love to Lang Lang!!! Lots of love and light!!!! God bless you!
Amazing performance for 11 year old.
Lang lang is so cute kind and respectful to young pianists
Ce înseamnă să ai un mentor ca megastarul LANG LANG !
Does anyone see, how Lang Lang tries to stop the crowd at 3:30 from making photos? This flash is so anoying when you play an instrument.
Lang Lang has a beautiful smile and always looks great.
🎶Lang Lang fantastico in ogni momento.... Persona meravigliosa 🎶
AMAZING TALENT!!
This kid is 11 and plays Tchaikovsky's 1st piano concerto, I'm 16 and I'm struggling to play Glassy Sky....
banaantjexx164 glassy sky, if you meant by animenz then its not that hard. I'm 17 and I'm struggling with his unravel. That has notes that are hard to hit.
Well we all have to start some were, I am 16 and I’m learning Chopin’s nocturne in C# minor op posth and working my way up to complex Chopin, Liszt, and this piece.
Ok you are shockingly similar to me. I’ve been wanting to play that for so long, but I’m not at that level yet.
@@firstbourne8799 its probably a little late now, but you can start by playing some easier pieces that animenz transcribed, for example aLIEz.
Also it always depends on how deep you analyse the music. Just playing the notes with kind of the right volume is quite easy compared to a deep analysis of the details, rhythm, different melodies, etc.
I'm 16 and struggling to learn moonlight 3rd mvt...
Yo a esa edad escuchaba ésta introducción de éste concierto cómo cortina de radio novela qué transmitía la emisora. Siempre soñé con tocar el piano pero los recursos económicos fue un tremendo problema... Hasta ahora, sólo sueño y soy un simple melomano. Gracias.
Wonderful lesson by a maestro to an extremely talented youngster. I think he gets his points across expressively and the lad improves each time he intervenes. My goodness it's hard to play!
Fun and fresh , a wonderful song for an opening,really.
Lang Lang is made of music! Is music in himself!
Thomas Chan , BRAVÒ .!😄
him at 11 : *plays with Lang Lang*
me at 11 : *cries in a masterclass*
omg that‘s impressive, both Lang Lang and Thomas
Avec un professeur coment ne pas évoluer ?Tu es un immense pianiste ét plein d'humour THANKS.😊
When I saw this video last year I was 11 and I was barely learning to play piano and I got inspired and now I can perfectly play Tchaikovsky at age 12
Legit
Great talent.Greeting from Sweden.
Lang Lang is a gift to us all
Love u Lang Lang Sweety polite pianist
you can take pictures before the performance but not during the performance，it's courtesy.
Asian father be like: "ok son but are you doctor yet?"
MNorbert so I’m a medical student who practice every month... maybe once
Everyone has his own favorite players. If you don't like this video, nobody is asking you to watch it. Come on, give Thomas Chan a break. After all, he is only 11 years old. For those who are casting negative comments on his playing, could you have played or have you attempted to play this difficult piece? Lang Lang admitted he did not play this piece until he was 13 years old. And for those of you who do not know this, Tchaikovsky was gay and had to keep it hidden from the public. He had a miserable and loveless marriage, and committed suicide. But what a legacy of great music he left for posterity. Gay people are born gay, and we must accept this. At least the Supreme Court has recognized them and has given them the right to marry in all 50 states.
This went from not hating on a piano video to being gay is okay real quick
He is truly wonderful as was Horliono at 11, playing Beethoven at St Pancras Station...are they now the same age ?
I know this might be wrong. But I prefer double piano than a complete concert symphonie ^_^
Yes!
We all love you so much.You are os good with children.
this kid is amazing. at that age i played row row row your boat
Well..... I’m speechless, Lang Lang can stretch a twelfth so can Thomas
I can’t even stretch a perfect tenth
Its incredible how 1 note in chord can make huge diferent in sound... I start playing piano and for is abstraction but sounds amazing :P
果然郎桑气势很适合这种气场雄伟的曲子
Feel the space. Why did that make such a difference 😂 literally changed how it sounded completely
Hahaha Lang Lang completely took over the whole performance
¡¡¡UN GENIO, Y OTRO PEQUEÑO GENIO!!!!
I wish my music teacher was like this.
And your teacher’s cost gonna be around $100k-$130k per lesson
oh my god... he has super big hands
11 year old playing Tchaikovsky 1? Wow!!!
lang lang sounds so good on the upright piano Hahaha
all the haters wish they could play this lo,
lo,
Bit young for this concerto, he doesn't have the depth of feeling and emotion, but hey, I couldn't do it so good luck xxxxx
Unless you are a world class pianist, you have no right to make a comment like this. I am a grade 8 and whilst I can play this piece its nowhere near as good as these guys!!!
Lololololololol. Piano didn’t bring u the best logic.
Loved it. One must LEARN . No pansy stuff....
Lang Lang, le Génie 🎹
this is a master class and not a concert, a great teaching and learning experience, I 've attended some with equestrians and show jumping.
babsfocker I
Nice piece!
Master class is suppose to be learning from the master. As such critiquing is essential so one can improve. And you need to perform so the master teacher can point out your weak points. It is a one-on-one class.
Wonderful!!!
Poor little boy, he really has a VERY good potention and talent, but 1st of Tchaik is not a good choice for small hands and children power...
That's exactly what I was thinking during the whole performance. Bad choice, also it's challenging to make a good interpratation even for older pianists.
Actually, you saw how big his hands were . . . and he's certainly not lacking too much power. It's more the musical interpretation I guess. I don't really think it's a bad choice for him, good experience fun piece sry for bda english.
Ye I agree with you mate the inspiration of the peice for this childs age is certainly good but the peice isnt a great choice for his hand size
Very good potention-XD
Anna Luis After he performs this as good and clearly ,he will be a perfect kid !!
love it
Lang lang is nice playing
job rusli I agree but he was winking to the reporters while Thomas Chan was playing. I think he was disrespectful with the soloist...
Christian García Socas Please clarify.
+Christian García Socas I think he wants them to stop filming and taking photos with flash
+Christian García Socas I think he wants them to stop filming and taking photos with flash