I just bought 4 boxes (after having slammed down my first box of the peanut butter balls). Yeah, the peanut butter flavor is superior (I just tested the lucky charms) but both will get eaten.
Matt, it's funny because when you first did the dry test and gave it a good tasting review, I told myself "wait til he tries it with milk". I tried these over the weekend, during the dry test I felt similar to you, tasted great, flavorful! However, once I tried it with milk, I felt it was quite bland and chalky, but as a dry cereal snack, I genuinely enjoyed it. I should add that I am totally a subscriber to all ghost products, but I was a little disappointed in the taste when milk added. Thanks for the review, mate!
Yeah, that was a really interesting experience! I do think the peanut butter remains the same in milk for the most part. With the marshmallow one I was hoping it would be different, but I've since finished the box and definitely preferred it dry. But still solid either way!
Nice Magic Spoon bowl. I just bought the Ghost and loved the Marshmallows because I loved the Lucky Charms as a kid! I can make an exception for the artificial colors on this since I bought them for $6 a box on sale. I'm going to try PB next!
It depends on what you're looking for, but I think Three Wishes cereal is the cleanest protein cereal you'll ever find. It won't replace your favorite sugary breakfast cereal in terms of flavor, but for a plant-based cereal with extremely minimal ingredients, I think it's awesome.
Thanks for the review, While ingredients and food science changes, personally if I see a review that's more than a year or two old then I'll assume there's probably a newer version. It also helps to leave reviews or fill out surveys when they send them (Magic Spoon), the tooth stickyness isn't great. But how you describe the PB flavor has it on the try next list. I'm a sucker for Lucky Charms marshmellows so might need to try that one too, at least one box.
They're both worth trying if you don't mind dropping $20 on cereal. It's a steep price for many people to justify, but it'll only be an occasional purchase for me. The PB should definitely be at the top of the list, but the marshmallow is good enough to try. Just don't expect it to compete with the likes of ACTUAL lucky charms cereal.
This is kind of a gimmick. To pay way more for cereal fortified with protein, when it's "whey" cheaper to drink protein made of whey(which is what they use in the I cereal I beleive), and if you get enough protein in your daily diet, this is just excessive protein, which turns to fat lol. Pretty much a gimmick
@@losvstheworld and pay wayyy more for because whey is boring?! Get outta here with that. No should pay $9-$11 for a box of cereal that has Idk, 4 servings in it realistically for a cheat meal when you can literally dump a chocolate protein shake into shredded wheat, it's the same thing, just 1/5 the price. You pay idk, 3x the amount for protein infusion when how I mentioned it so much more economical. I mean, let's be real, we are living in bidens world(well not no mo soon!) and prices are already high as in, going this route just adds insult to injury.
Just sad it's full of RED #40 :,) The whole "HIGH PROTEIN" marketing has come too far, neglecting ingredients just to get more protein and look fancy for the consumers.
I mean, it's not "full" of red 40. There is red 40 in the red marshmallows specifically, which isn't very much at all. But yes, if that's an ingredient you don't want in your diet in any capacity, then this is not a cereal for you.
I just bought 4 boxes (after having slammed down my first box of the peanut butter balls). Yeah, the peanut butter flavor is superior (I just tested the lucky charms) but both will get eaten.
Matt, it's funny because when you first did the dry test and gave it a good tasting review, I told myself "wait til he tries it with milk". I tried these over the weekend, during the dry test I felt similar to you, tasted great, flavorful! However, once I tried it with milk, I felt it was quite bland and chalky, but as a dry cereal snack, I genuinely enjoyed it. I should add that I am totally a subscriber to all ghost products, but I was a little disappointed in the taste when milk added. Thanks for the review, mate!
Yeah, that was a really interesting experience! I do think the peanut butter remains the same in milk for the most part. With the marshmallow one I was hoping it would be different, but I've since finished the box and definitely preferred it dry. But still solid either way!
@@MattRosenman 100% very solid, I look forward to new flavors in the future as well, I think it can only get better!
Nice Magic Spoon bowl. I just bought the Ghost and loved the Marshmallows because I loved the Lucky Charms as a kid! I can make an exception for the artificial colors on this since I bought them for $6 a box on sale. I'm going to try PB next!
Can you try "kodiak protein french toast sticks"
Thanks for the solid research. Is there a clean, protein cereal that you like?
It depends on what you're looking for, but I think Three Wishes cereal is the cleanest protein cereal you'll ever find. It won't replace your favorite sugary breakfast cereal in terms of flavor, but for a plant-based cereal with extremely minimal ingredients, I think it's awesome.
Thanks for the review, While ingredients and food science changes, personally if I see a review that's more than a year or two old then I'll assume there's probably a newer version. It also helps to leave reviews or fill out surveys when they send them (Magic Spoon), the tooth stickyness isn't great.
But how you describe the PB flavor has it on the try next list. I'm a sucker for Lucky Charms marshmellows so might need to try that one too, at least one box.
They're both worth trying if you don't mind dropping $20 on cereal. It's a steep price for many people to justify, but it'll only be an occasional purchase for me. The PB should definitely be at the top of the list, but the marshmallow is good enough to try. Just don't expect it to compete with the likes of ACTUAL lucky charms cereal.
Honestly the PB flavor in milk loses its taste, I only eat it dry with milk as a drink instead
I work at walmart and saw this yestruday for the first time and was super confused.
Yeah, it kind of came out of out of no where
This is kind of a gimmick. To pay way more for cereal fortified with protein, when it's "whey" cheaper to drink protein made of whey(which is what they use in the I cereal I beleive), and if you get enough protein in your daily diet, this is just excessive protein, which turns to fat lol. Pretty much a gimmick
drinking whey gets boring. These things are supposed to be fun cheat meals that you can have without actually really cheating.
@@losvstheworld and pay wayyy more for because whey is boring?! Get outta here with that. No should pay $9-$11 for a box of cereal that has Idk, 4 servings in it realistically for a cheat meal when you can literally dump a chocolate protein shake into shredded wheat, it's the same thing, just 1/5 the price. You pay idk, 3x the amount for protein infusion when how I mentioned it so much more economical. I mean, let's be real, we are living in bidens world(well not no mo soon!) and prices are already high as in, going this route just adds insult to injury.
if youre struggling to not eat awful macro desserts this is perfect imo
Just sad it's full of RED #40 :,) The whole "HIGH PROTEIN" marketing has come too far, neglecting ingredients just to get more protein and look fancy for the consumers.
I mean, it's not "full" of red 40. There is red 40 in the red marshmallows specifically, which isn't very much at all. But yes, if that's an ingredient you don't want in your diet in any capacity, then this is not a cereal for you.
Who cares about red 40, you think Arnold and Jay and Ronnie cared about that shit?
@@Kingcommaalex They didn't consume that.
@@ditz3nfitness red 40 is not going to hurt you
@@Kingcommaalex Depends.