Why Does Anything Exist?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 ส.ค. 2024
- Have you ever asked yourself why does anything exist? Why is there a Universe? Why is there something rather than nothing? This is an old question that lots of people have pondered. There could have been nothing. It might have been easier. Instead, there is something. The universe exists.
Support us on Patreon and help Cosmoknowledge become the number one destination for science: / cosmoknowledge
SUBSCRIBE ► goo.gl/PLLFPz
----
Website ► cosmoknowledge...
TikTok ► / cosmoknowledge
Instagram ► / itscosmoknowledge
Facebook ► / cosmoknowledgee
Edited by:
Ardit Bicaj
Narrated by:
Russell Archey
www.ravonmedia...
Graphics:
Space Engine
Universe Sandbox 2
Music:
The Mole - Christoffer Moe Ditlevsen
Grieving Volcano - Dew Of Light
Clearer Views - From Now On
Thank you to our Patrons:
DonPig
Joe Chappell
xX-FLuKE-Xx
-
Cosmoknowledge brings news from space.
We love you, explorers!
![[Full Episode] MasterChef Junior Thailand มาสเตอร์เชฟ จูเนียร์ ประเทศไทย Season 3 Episode 10](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/8kldrPPsDZs/mqdefault.jpg)
Yes, I've pondered on this topic before. And then slowly my thoughts started driving me crazy... Some confusing thoughts, some contradictory thoughts, some unanswered questions, some questions whose answers are unimaginable for now and some complicated thoughts came to mind. So, to keep myself mentally healthy, I left the topic right there.
OK. You start with this thought -- there is a moment within every moment, and within that moment, another moment. We think of time as linear or as marking the passage of something from existence to non-existence. This is not the way the universe works. Time is, if one has to visualize it, always spiraling "inward" -- the moment within the moment within the moment. What has existed -- the one particular configuration of objects and forces that exists "now" -- will continue to exist forever, even as we perceive it otherwise.
Anyways, that's a start.
“In the beginning... God...”
@@AtomicLobotomy Interesting...
@@draytonblackgrove that's not a good answer
@@hermionegranger7849 How is it not? The universe clearly had a beginning. Why is intelligent design not something that can be scientifically considered? Have you not ever heard of Simulation Theory? If the universe is a simulation, then that would lead one to the assumption that someone designed it.
No one:
The universe: *exists*
😍
Also The Universe: I'll make 'you' exist.
Me: 😶
Nothing:
The universe: exists
TH-cam: Confound it, you bastard!
My theory is that we came from darkness and somehow that darkness gained false consciousness and created it's own illusion of (LIGHT) and we are just an illusion of it's thoughts seeking more and more evolution constantly in an on going cycle/simulation of basically nothing but EVOLUTION seeking it's satisfaction of creating life/light take the Suns for instance they are infinity. I believe that explains why they say the cosmic web look like brain neurons carrying information (THOUGHT PROCESSING/Consciousness).... just so happen we are part of a thought processing simulation and everything it consist of is just a construct with no beginning or ending(INFINITY)...they say the BIG BANG started from a singularity out of total darkness (Cosmic Web) then the simulation started...in that case that's exactly what we are living in. That's why we have two different kinds of black holes...matter and anti matter black holes...what does a anti matter black hole do? pulls matter back to a singularity point (VANISH POINT)...planets/sun/asteroids everything is matter...AKA black holes/anti matter black holes exist because matter should have never existed...think about negative matter IT DOES NOT EXIST AT ALL SCIENTIST CALLED IT THAT BECAUSE THEY NAMED THINGS WE SEE MATTER...I can go deeper all I'm going to say is that either my theory is correct...OR WE ARE A PART OF SOMETHING NOT SOMEONE EXPERITMENT
@@krinodagamer6313 thats wrong
A vacuum isn't nothing, it's a vacuum. Space isn't nothing, it's space. Nothing is inconceivable because even the concept of nothing is something.
I know right!?
@Farhan Hassan nothing is the absense of everything
A vacuum is something my mom makes me clean the floor with to suffer
@@Ikhlashasib10 which is impossible to visualize because it cannot be percieved.
@@JNB0723 bro what? How can you visualize nothing? Theres nothing to visualize mate, go back to school bruh 🤣
I ask this question every single day 😂
It's a long way to go for us to know the answer.
Why consciousness is the other one 😂
I also think so,not every day but many times.
@@vivektripathi1489 i also think everytime
Same here
Since being in my mid twenties I’ve always wondered how did it all come to be how does it exist do we really exist? Sometimes you just have to go outside take a breath and just be grateful for what is, be happy we get to experience it
Indeed. Thank you for this. ✌
Since i gained conciousness about the world i always wondered this one question
What is the earth? Oh its a small dot in a solar system
Well what is solar system? Oh its a
the smallest spec in our galaxy
Well... What is a galaxy? Oh it an even more insignificant spiral in the universe
Woah .... Well ... What is the universe? more like
Where is the universe? Well we dont know but it started with a big bang yeeeeeaaah BUT WHERE DID THE BIG BANG HAPPENED
and
Why do i or anything exist ?
I hope i find out the next step in my life time until then i shall wonder and be absolutely be terrified with my existence until death
Sounds like a existential crisis and I have those all the time and always asking questions although when I ask my parents they say it’s a phase or something along the lines of pray but yeah.
@Grantelbart the answer is islam
I think about that everyday, it makes me feel without a purpose, but it also makes me feel alive, instead of just existing and "living", working, studying, having problems, being happy, just because... thats what I do everyday.
@Grantelbart Wow, me too man!
@@NyanNyanNyanNyanNyanNyanNyanN sigh
If there were no conscious agents to observe the universe, would any of it really exist?
That's where the real mystery lies.
@@Cosmoknowledge true
Well different organism understand their surroundings differently. A fly might not know what gravity is, yet it developed a way to fly.
Just like an atom exists and it doesn't know it's part of something bigger, but yet it acts according to its function.
Just like everything else in the universe exists. It only understands itself under its own context.
By this logic, we only understand the universe under our own context, our perception of reality.
By extension, everything in the universe is its own observing agent, which could be considered as the universe itself being its own observing agent.
Meaning universe only watches itself, and we are part of it, just like everything is.
@@MrFlyingKitty what a wonderful response
Solipsism 🙏
Should not have watched this before breakfast, Way to early to have my brain work this hard
😆😆... Bon Appetit!
I had my brain work as hard as I could and nothing was truly being revealed to me, until the day I partook in the sacred medicine of psylocybin and felt other civilizations pulsating with life when gazing up at the night sky... not until Alex Grey's universal mind lattice...
There is an intelligence to the cosmos, and meaning.
Highly recommended experience with the right mindset, preparation, and respect 🎉
😆😆... Bone Apple Tea!
I can’t even comprehend nothing existing before this universe, and I can’t even comprehend eternity, I wonder how some of you can get your heads around the reason for anything existing in the first place, the only thing that makes sense to me is that there should be nothing existing at all, but the fact it does at an unimaginable scale frightens me to the core especially thinking about it’s origin. Some people have it easy believing it came from nothing wish I could understand how you come to that solution.
We don't know how everything we know came from. Simple.
@@Cosmoknowledge but we know it can't come from nothing. Simple. Use your logic and rationality ffs🤦♂
I want to understand how people think everything comes from nothing (whatever nothing is) for no obvious reason
Nothingness cannot be perceived because there is nothing To perceive , it's that simple, .
What makes the most sense to me is that there must have been something that was eternally here and that eternal can’t possibly change from eternal to non eternal otherwise it was never truly eternal. Eternal means forever in that state. The eternal that was always here has to still be here in the same form unchanged & the only way this is possible is if it was eternally able to make change at will.
Real question is why anything exist the way it exist, like why exist planet,universe,people,atoms,god (imagine anything u know), imagine we are in the game and everything u know and will ever know exist only in this game, and what happens when we quit this game? And even if some species created us, why they exist the way they exist, what is this game?
I have a theory for that
I have a theory for how it came to be and where it's going but not why it came to be
I ask this question everyday before sleeping
It's a fascinating yet scary thought.
I love Space videos, weather it's Space related Physics, String Theory, Quantum Mechanics or videos like this "which are my fav" i love it all, great video CosmoKnowledge.
Always great to hear that.
@@Cosmoknowledge Mean it too.
Last question on the school exam be like:
😂😂❤️
Yes
“Sleep and wake up forever: the game”
That is why Shiva has always made sense to me. Shi-va means no-thing, the vast nothingness but it is the dimension beyond shoonya (zero), it is no-thing yet it exist. When we personified this shi-va, it becomes Shiva. He says, "I am everything, and I am nothing."
Shiva is masculine, the absolute stillness. His companion is Shakti, feminine, the movement, the life. Shakti means force or energy, English language doesn't have exact translation for these words though.
that's really interesting and informative
Wouldn’t it be a bugger if, one day, someone figured it all out then, just at that very moment, his or her antimatter equivalent just happened to be in the neighbourhood and POP! there we are back at square one.
Why do we exist
Why does the earth exist
Why do cells exist
Why does time exist
Why does space exist
Why does the universe exist
How did the big bang happen
Why does the thing that made the big bang exist?
It's crazy to think what would happen if nothing was here
Not even a endless white void
Nothing
Even nothing is nothing
Where would we be?
Nice questions.
Wow
why does my D exist and why is not not bigger?
It's a scary and fascinating thought to think about why or how anything even exists. What is anything? How does anything even exist?
These are all valuable questions.
I have all answers 🙂
Keep up the great work Cosmo, I love channels that educate people!
That's always great to hear. Thanks a lot! ❤
I do too but I get anxious
food for thought, nice topic with quality content and video, nice narration and of course the BGM is spot on!
Thank you so much, I'm really glad to hear that! ✌
I know why everything exists. But, I'm not letting you in on it. You would quit putting out these cool videos.
Wow! That's a compliment with a plot twist. I really like that! 😍❤
My theory is that we came from darkness and somehow that darkness gained false consciousness and created it's own illusion of (LIGHT) and we are just an illusion of it's thoughts seeking more and more evolution constantly in an on going cycle/simulation of basically nothing but EVOLUTION seeking it's satisfaction of creating life/light take the Suns for instance they are infinity. I believe that explains why they say the cosmic web look like brain neurons carrying information (THOUGHT PROCESSING/Consciousness).... just so happen we are part of a thought processing simulation and everything it consist of is just a construct with no beginning or ending(INFINITY)...they say the BIG BANG started from a singularity out of total darkness (Cosmic Web) then the simulation started...in that case that's exactly what we are living in. That's why we have two different kinds of black holes...matter and anti matter black holes...what does a anti matter black hole do? pulls matter back to a singularity point (VANISH POINT)...planets/sun/asteroids everything is matter...AKA black holes/anti matter black holes exist because matter should have never existed...think about negative matter IT DOES NOT EXIST AT ALL SCIENTIST CALLED IT THAT BECAUSE THEY NAMED THINGS WE SEE MATTER...I can go deeper all I'm going to say is that either my theory is correct...OR WE ARE A PART OF SOMETHING NOT SOMEONE EXPERITMENT
Let's here it then.
The universe could be a minute part of some living organism for all we know.
Maybe.
Wow... didn't really plan to stay up late tonite but looks like I'm binge-watching Cosmoknowledge!!! Great stuff and so glad to be tapped into this thought stream. I really like how you take interesting and sometimes hard to comprehend material and present it in a straight forward way with good graphics and really good music! Definitely Subbed... but PLEASE don't let the "Flat Earthers" know that the Universe is flat, we will never hear the end of it. 😅
Hey, I truly appreciate your kind words. You made my day! ❤✌
@@Cosmoknowledge man universe means you and me too why everything exist but if nothing existed then that is something that's unbelievable
What if it was just there, no creator. Just there
That would be awkward as well.
My theory is that we came from darkness and somehow that darkness gained false consciousness and created it's own illusion of (LIGHT) and we are just an illusion of it's thoughts seeking more and more evolution constantly in an on going cycle/simulation of basically nothing but EVOLUTION seeking it's satisfaction of creating life/light take the Suns for instance they are infinity. I believe that explains why they say the cosmic web look like brain neurons carrying information (THOUGHT PROCESSING/Consciousness).... just so happen we are part of a thought processing simulation and everything it consist of is just a construct with no beginning or ending(INFINITY)...they say the BIG BANG started from a singularity out of total darkness (Cosmic Web) then the simulation started...in that case that's exactly what we are living in. That's why we have two different kinds of black holes...matter and anti matter black holes...what does a anti matter black hole do? pulls matter back to a singularity point (VANISH POINT)...planets/sun/asteroids everything is matter...AKA black holes/anti matter black holes exist because matter should have never existed...think about negative matter IT DOES NOT EXIST AT ALL SCIENTIST CALLED IT THAT BECAUSE THEY NAMED THINGS WE SEE MATTER...I can go deeper all I'm going to say is that either my theory is correct...OR WE ARE A PART OF SOMETHING THAT WAS NOTHING TO BEGIN WITH NOT SOMEONE'S EXPERIMENT
YOU ARE RIGHT DARKNESS IS THE ONLY THING THAT COULD EVEN EXIST IF THAT MAKE ANY SENSE BUT IT MAKES MORE SENSE THAN A SCIENTIST TELLING YOU WE ARE PART OF SOME FUCKING QUANTUM COMPUTER....UGHHHHH NOOOOO LOL
You've nailed it, I think. This is what the advaita vedantins call pure existence. There was never a time in which it WAS NOT, nor shall there ever be a time in which it SHALL NOT BE.
Did you know that there is no inherent illumination or luminosity in photons? “Light,” as such, cannot be found there. Photons are, perhaps, ‘packets’ of energy which have the properties of both spread-out waves and localized particles. Photons only take on the appearance of being luminous as they arise within consciousness, in our mind’s eye. It may be that photons are spread-out energy potentials that fill the immensity of space, and only take on the appearance of being a localized discrete particle of “light” when we become aware of them in consciousness, in this actualized awareness we call mind. Thus, you are the light of the kosmos. This “light” is only arising in us. The world outside of a mind is perfectly ‘dark,’ or empty, unactualized in any way. Of course, what else could it be? What would perceive it as illuminated, or as any “thing”?
All of our thoughts are the activity of consciousness, modulations of that consciousness, incarnations within that pure consciousness, rays shining from inside that consciousness. We are agents of that consciousness, emerging from within that consciousness. All there is to experience is the knowing of it, and that knowing is God’s own Self in us, living in us, the source of our life, the energy of consciousness itself.
We could say that God lives in us, since consciousness seems to have become localized in this particular body-mind. Or we could say that we live in God, since all that we perceive arises in that consciousness, including our body-mind. Thus, Jesus was right to say, “I am in the Father and the Father is in me” (John 14:10-11, 20). Both are true, and they are true of us as well. We are arising within God, and God is arising within us as well. Sometimes this is called “mutual indwelling,” the Father in the Son and the Son in the Father, also called perichoresis or co-inherence in Christian terminology.
God is the field of consciousness in which all knowing occurs, in which all thoughts and perceptions and feelings and sensations arise, like waves in the ocean. Our body-mind and its thoughts are like localizations within that consciousness, temporary manifestations of that Ultimate Reality, expressions of that consciousness, that being, that One.
God becomes veiled and hidden from our awareness when the thoughts that arise in and from consciousness believe they are something separate and discrete from the consciousness in which they are arising. The thoughts form a separate entity, a dualistic subjective ego, a separate self identity, an independent being, an “Adam/Eve,” which thinks it is apart from infinite nondual divine consciousness and Ultimate Reality. This seems to be the “Fall,” the beginning of duality and separateness and alienation from God’s Presence.
But how could thoughts be separate from the consciousness in which they have arisen? They can’t, but that is exactly what our thoughts and our self-identification with them think they are. It is a kind of psychological illusion. The thoughts take on their own separate identity apart from pure nondual consciousness, forming a self, a person, an entity, seemingly cut off from its own source and essence.
Once we look at it like this, it seems impossible, and that is because it is. Our ‘self’ is never actually separate from the source in which it arises, thoughts are never separate from the consciousness in which they emerge, the wave is not separate from the ocean. The thoughts that make up our ‘self’ are just finite actualizations or relative localizations of the infinite potential of absolute consciousness, or Divine Being, or Ultimate Reality. In Christian symbolism we call this the incarnation of God. In Buddhism it is the Dharmakaya that incarnates as the Nirmanakaya Buddha. In Hinduism it is Brahman that manifests itself as each Atman. God becomes incarnate in reality, in the flesh, embodied, in us and all things.
There is no time, no space, nowhere we can go, nowhere we can be, that will be outside of this Presence of God, outside of this consciousness, beyond the borders of God, or the Ultimate Reality. God is always present, and is Presence itself, awareness itself, consciousness itself, the “spirit of life” within us, from which we derive all being, all knowing, all our substance, every thought, every sensation. It all arises in God. This is perhaps why, in order to pierce the veil and know God directly, contemplative practices such as meditation help train us to transcend thought, to go back to the source of thought itself, beyond all thoughts of self, to recognize that from which it all arises, this pure open vastness of nondual unitive at-one consciousness.
Do you see why we cannot “think” God? Nothing that arises in consciousness as a thought will be that consciousness in which it is arising. No relative finite manifestation in consciousness can be the absolute pure infinite consciousness, even though every manifestation or relativization or actualization of that consciousness is made up of nothing other than that consciousness. God is Present even while we are trying to comprehend God, even in the midst of that very comprehension. God is what makes that attempt at comprehension even possible. God is the very field in which we are trying to know God. When we let go of the trying, the conceptualization, surrendering the thoughts that are trying to know themselves, and rest in the pure still silent open awareness of being, that is when the realization of God may dawn on us, as us.
Its so weird that there is always something for something, you can make a literal machine to see radiation which we were never ment to see
this video seems like it could have 10 million views but only 6k ? wtf
Thanks so much for evaluating it. I really appreciate it. ✌
Its a simulation, even the afterlife.
It might be.
A simulation being run by whom/what?
Yeah but how do they exist time is the real mystery
@@TheShattenjager deep down you know who
@@TheShattenjager We'll see it one day 🙂
I just wanna get off this ride!
Children, either there has always been something, in which case there is by definition no first cause, and therefore the question "Why?" cannot be answered. OR something came from absolutely nothing, which is absurd, and again the question "Why?" cannot be answered. So you can see that rational thought is essentially bitch-slapped right out of the starting gate. But who among you will hear this? [Sighs.]
A diverse universe we see today may have resulted from cause & effect law. Real question is what was the first 'something', initial cause & effect.
MUST there be a first 'something'? Couldn't it have been 'beginningless'?
Nothing is just one option for a universe, like infinite other options. The fact that we can't exist in the nothing-universe (or others) does not mean, that it does not exist. Our noticable universe is a tiny subset of the overall omniverse. Like a real number, maybe a smal range, on the infinite real numer axis.
As there are parents and their offsprings similarly, if something created something then something has to create that something, by this rule the world was created out of infinity . This is so overwhelming that humans are nothing in this vast universe and we dont have a single percent of knowledge about it, we cannot learn everything because creation of matter is infinite going backwards, because there is always a quetion which will arise: What created that matter ? and so on.
The important thing is that we keep going on, and we keep learning. That's why the future is exciting.
It all boils down to everything came from nothing or everything came from something that always was. Neither help unboggle my mind.
Well, the true answer right now is we don't know.
@@Cosmoknowledge and so the existential crisis went on...
Is so hard to explain the feeling of thinking about the fact that at the point 0 of everything was just nothing , nothing , everything was created like a game , idk is just so hard to explain . But image that in this life ,universe , space , I DONT KNOW HOW TO CALL EVERYTHING THAT EXISTS.. was just nothing , like blank space , nothing , no parallel universes , just nothing , not even a microscophic object , no air , no gravity , so is so hard to explain the actual begin of everything
After all, the things we know today are just the things we THINK we know. There's so much to learn in the future and that's why life is exciting.
Nothing exist ,everything is illusion
Geez Russ I have asked that to myself so many times over the coarse of my life.. I have agreed with the statement "Nothing is a crazy concept" for years now.. nothing is always something.. This is the kind of thing I think about all the time.. oh and number 4 you said gravity's pull? what is gravity? is it not just warped space time? and then #2.. woof what a thought! This was another real good one Ardit! love this mind twisting stuff.. Merry Christmas my friend
Too many things to think about, Tink! 😄... Merry Christmas, man! All the best to you and your loved ones. Stay safe!
Coarse. Lol! 😂
@@SuperYtc1 folks like you really make life funny at times.. thanks for the chuckle..
It just is. Love, laugh, live and enjoy.
In other words, we don't know and never will.
I'm not so sure about the "never" part, but at the moment, we definitely don't know.
@@Cosmoknowledge never. We'll never know because existence itself doesn't make sense.
Ok, but I want to take it a step further. What is nothing. In theory it should be space, but it has stars in it so it's not nothing. But space without stars and any object would in theory be nothing. Well how would that work, what does nothing look like, or does it look like anything at all, but how is that possible. And how would it be if then that same nothing just stopped existing, if it existed at all, how would it be. I brings be to a conclusion that nothing can't be on it's own because it doesn't have any characteristics. It can't be any sort of space nor can it have anything in itself, and time can not pass there(or can it?). But if we say nothing can't exist on it's own, then how were things created? How can they just emerge from nothing. There must be something to create them, but there isn't because it was always just nothing. So things couldn't start existing. But we exist, which then is weird. And the whole idea of us being able to think is crazy. But if universe is endless then there are endless creatures that can think, so we aren't special at all. But if everything just got destroyed, that there would be an empty universe. Can that be considered as nothing? I don't think so because there is space then, but then how large is that space. If it's endless can we then really destroy everything there. If in theory could, imagine trying to go through the entire universe. No matter how fast you go, that will always be nothing, because universe is in theory endless, and that is weird. It also doesn't matter for how much time you travel because, as I said, universe is endless. But that means time is too. You can't stop time from passing. But is the time maybe a thing that only exists inside our minds?
I'll leave you with that thing in mind, but there is a lot more to talk about.
Thanks for this thorough feedback.
We are living in someone's anti-matter maker of some sort and maybe were stuck inside some kind of big chamber and it's all fractals we could create our own chamber with only matter in it when we create antimatter for use in spaceships or energy powering devices and there would be matter leftover in the chamber maybe it's some kind of big science project to learn how consciousness works or to learn how to ascend into a higher consciousness and love one another. But I think it gets smaller as it goes down and I think it gets bigger as it goes up but we have the ability to access multiple dimensions in our mind if you know geometrical shapes and numbers and color patterns and stuff
Near perfect rendition of the quintessential question. The what and more importantly why of existence. Just beautiful. But it s cut short. The narrator could go longer.
Thank you so much for appreciating the video. And sorry for the short length. We are trying to lengthen the duration of videos without losing quality. ✌
Even nothing is something.. we even have a word for it.. maybe existence is 'nothing' and we are each that 'nothing' trying to experience 'something' through as many lenses as possible. We are nothingness running billions of experiments... this topic pushes me to my absolute limits... wonder why some people ponder these sorts of things and others couldn't care less
Trust me finding a job is difficult than finding answers to these questions....
😂
My best answer to that is that there might not be a reason for things for particles to come in and out of existence. It might just be because when someone says just cause, but there always is a reason for it this might be the only time that a question that there is not reason for. Every other question has a cause but this question.
I go crazy and cant sleep thinking about this
It's a head-scratcher.
Education hasn’t changed in the past 100 years or more
People think we get the answers after death. We won’t
Do you have a justification for that, or just, a hunch?
Great question 🤔
❤
it's just, fascinating. sometimes I wonder just what's the reason. why does anything matter? we're just, a tiny particles in a seemingly very orderly universe. planetary systems that host no life, an empty galaxy, a space full of nothing in between, and it's still expanding. but why? why's everything functioning in order for... no reason besides order? for what reason do universes die to be reborn? it's like going to an automated factory but it's empty inside. no one's inside but the machines are running. when humans go extinct and no ones left to observe the universe, the universe will still function orderly like we've never existed
oh God please help me it's 3 am and I'm having an existential crisis
There's a problem here. The factory is extremely big. So big it looks like it's empty, but it may be filled with life and civilizations. The future is exciting and we have so much to learn. Thank you for your feedback. ❤
Because imagine how boring it would be without one!
this is the prefect channel for me.
Oh, that's so kind of you. You made my day! 😌❤
What is reality ?
No one knows yet. 😀
We want to know 😢😢 It droves me
cosmoknowledge, i have not seen you in a while in your videos. hope to see you soon!
Maybe you will see me here and there. But I'm definitely in the comments with you guys! ❤
I think the answer is quite simple yet we don't want to acknoweldge it, people run away , people ignore it , the answer is quite unescapbable and that is that there is a nessasary existance which all things depend upon, who is at the foundaiton of reality, without a nessasary existance, reality is unexplained and many aburdaties apear such as creation ex nihlo, ifinite regress, and an eternal contingent universe which all of these are philosophical absurdities and aren't possible, the nessasary existance explains why there is somthing rather than nothign with no absurdities and that is God, weather You like it or not, it's the only possible answer!
God and religion were man-made concepts. If intelligent life exists elsewhere in the universe (which it most likely does) there is very reasonable doubt they would have similar religions as humans do if religion is something they have at all.
But instead of telling you all that (which you likely already knew), how about I ask you this. If God was the sole creator of everything, who created God? Why does God exist at all?
Why can't the universe be the necessary existence?
@@robinharwood5044 because it is made out of parts, and it could be concieved in any other way. Also modern science proves that the universe actual begain to exist from a singularity, anythong that begins to exists Definetly cannot be a nessasary existance as it's could have not existed and needs an explaintion for it's begining
@@abdulrehman6791 It looks like it is made of parts from the inside, but that could well be our misunderstanding of it. And modern science has not proven that the universe began to exist. That is the currently popular hypothesis, but that is all. Nor does a beginning need an explanation. Our usual experience is of something beginning to exist is actually one thing inside the universe changing into another thing inside the universe, with a cause for the change. We have no experience of universes beginning to exist, and there is nothing self-contradictory about the notion of them just popping into existence without cause.
my question is what was before the big bang
No one knows.
Hope this humongous mystery gets solved. This video was mind blowing!
That's what makes the future exciting. Hey, thank you so much!
We can not know ever .. nothing would have meaning if we knew ... sooo what ever made it made it to not be known and it did good job at at loll and no its not god ppl believe in lol
@@Cosmoknowledge hey thanks for replying . Beautiful video btw
Ask yourself while you're thinking how is it I'm able to form thoughts in my mind in the mind there's no space time or anything cause in the beginning there was nothing
Nothing existing is impossible
what if nothing exists ...i mean literally ....nothing also does not exist ...
it seems some unimaginable higher being thought
I think, something and nothing are relative terms. What is something? What is nothing?
Parallels can create parallels for convenience. Because cluttering is not allowed by quantum mechanics.
(Student)When will the school bell ring? (Teacher)when the bell rings
(Student) what time?
(Teacher)when it's time
So why do we exist? We exist because we exist
Isn't that why we believe in God? There has to be something or someone to make this all happen. But yeah.. some would agree or disagree.
But what is “nothing” and where did “nothing” come from? And where did that nothing which created nothing come from????
All great questions.
It comes from existence 😊.
The question is , where did the first of every matter to begin with came from. How come there is this infinite blackness of space existing to begin with ? HOW ???
Well, this is what makes humanity excited about the future. This is what makes life worth living.
1:50 so I understand the premise, but isn't that in a vacuum *with* space? like we're not talking about the pre-bang before-space kind of emptiness right?
Because I can understand the vacuum of space being a roiling foam, but for the nothingness before the big bang... I'm having trouble seeing why there'd even be quantum foam before there was even a place (space).
I may just be rabbit-holing, but I've gotten stuck in the loop of "I accept that X could have happened, but why was there even a Z for it to happen in?".
Any christians wanting to hit me with the "because god is eternal" line, I'd like to say, I find the idea of an eternal thing unconvincing, as that thing would necessarily have no cause, and without the necessity of creating anything, would necessarily be without purpose. So a god would just be there, existing, without a reason or a thing that brought it about, in a place that doesn't exist yet, and thus sounds utterly pointless. Like why would there be a god especially that was eternal, as there'd be literally no reason or cause for one.
What I mean is that if there's a god that dreamed existence up, where were they before? I just keep coming back to a "why was there even a place, let alone anything in it" point.
god-wise, there wouldn't even be a reason for god to have any of the attributes people ascribe to them like the power to even create, like why? like how fish have gills to separate oxygen from the water to breathe, why would a thing that always existed even before a place to exist oddly came about, have "creation" powers when by necessity it doesn't even have a reason to exist or an environment to exist within at points?
I've been thinking a lot about this and I'm falling off the bandwagon of "shit is this all a simulation?" and have landed squarely in a pile of "any simulation would have an origin that I ALSO cannot make a case for; I think we don't exist"
I think about this frequently and really nothing makes sense without there being some sort of higher power or god. But then you wonder how god created themselves?
Space and time are not the same thing. Time is the "is" while space exists in it. Time will pass regardless of whats there. Time as we know it is a made up convenience. Time as we know it is only marked by how many times we think the earth has been around our sun. But what of time before our earth? It still passed. So time is the constant, and space is the variable.
You may be right. Time could be timeless.
Existence is a concept of itself. Just like everything in existence. Non-existence must be equally present, as the more real some thing is, the more no thing is.
What is nothing even?
When u try too hard thinking about nothing you'll imagine a white blank infinitely large space but that is still SOMETHING, it's just impossible to know what nothing is
Nothing is also something
More or less.
i was so high I typed this into the search expecting to find a real answer to the question
It's hard to find such answers. 😂
Oh it’s the explore with us guy
The universe came from space.
So the harder question is why does space exist ?
It was just said that even empty space is not truly empty that there are particles in it but if you truly had an area where there was literally nothing. the space itself would still exist and to have that is impossible.
Existence is eternal, Non-existence cannot exist. Note the contradiction. If non-existence existed it would be existence! An apple may not have physically manifested as material, but may have physically manifested as a concept or in sleep dream. If the apple is in concept but not in material reality, then relative to material reality, the apple exists as non-existence. Yet this is all occurring within existence.
An apple though could never occur in non-existence, because non existence does not contain the material, conceptual or sleep dream realms. It contains no realms, pure mu or nothingness.
For example, its wrong to say a pink elephant existed as non-existence throughout this entire reading, because the elephant just manifested in the concept realm as soon as this paragraph was read. There was literally no pink elephant before.
Therefore that non-existence cannot have any manifestation or form in actuality. Nothing is created or destroyed only transformed, enjoy eternity
Can’t process the fact how nothing goes to something
I know. It's all too much for our brains.
I could say if the universe ends forever but if that was the case then what’s the point of earth in the first place ?😐if the universe formed from nothing this could sound like vacuum decay everything in the universe dies and yet some how the universe was created from nothing ?
All I can say is we have so much to learn, and this makes me extremely excited about the future.
How do you know there could have been nothing? Good luck finding a good answer to that.
"If these (virtual) particles can [briefly] come into existence without a cause in the quantum realm, then the universe as well might have come into being from "nothing"." And there we have the leap of logic and faith. Virtual particles are ephemeral and the larger something is that comes into being the rarer it is and the quicker it disappears. Also, the theory presumes the existence of a quantum vacuum field, in which fluctuations may occur, and which is certainly not "nothing."
I prefer to ask "how". Because why implys a reason. But the universe does not need a reason to exist, it just does. What is the question that really is interesting is how does it exists. How did it come to be and how could that have happened in the first place.
Thanks for this.
We can't do anything with these postulates until we have the definition of time.
both quantum fields and spacetime assume a lot and don't help with the question of why is there something rather than nothing
Well, that's because the answer is not simple but science is working hard to get answers and eventually, maybe, we'll get there.
I’m just a random kid so these probably aren’t correct but here are my 2 theories on why things exist
1: If nothing exists, physics don’t exist. And “nothing comes from nothing” is a law of physics, then that rule could therefore be broken causing things to exist.
2: There is no nothing, just a negative and a positive, matter and antimatter. Now if they collide, your left with nothing, but since nothing doesn’t truly exist, you just have matter and antimatter again, and somehow all that antimatter managed to get far away from the matter which makes up our universe. (Basically similar to what they said in the video)
Matthew 24:22-26 NKJV
And unless those days were shortened, no flesh would be saved; but for the elect’s sake those days will be shortened. “Then if anyone says to you, ‘Look, here is the Christ!’ or ‘There!’ do not believe it. For false christs and false prophets will rise and show great signs and wonders to deceive, if possible, even the elect. See, I have told you beforehand. “Therefore if they say to you, ‘Look, He is in the desert!’ do not go out; or ‘Look, He is in the inner rooms!’ do not believe it.
Sudden Destruction
1 Thessalonians 5:3
While they are saying, “Peace and safety!” then destruction will come upon them suddenly like labor pains upon a woman with child, and they will not escape.
Proverbs 6:15
Therefore his calamity will come suddenly;
Instantly he will be broken and there will be no healing.
Proverbs 24:21-22
My son, fear the Lord and the king;
Do not associate with those who are given to change,
For their calamity will rise suddenly,
And who knows the ruin that comes from both of them?
Ecclesiastes 9:12
Moreover, man does not know his time: like fish caught in a treacherous net and birds trapped in a snare, so the sons of men are ensnared at an evil time when it suddenly falls on them.
Isaiah 30:13
Therefore this iniquity will be to you
Like a breach about to fall,
A bulge in a high wall,
Whose collapse comes suddenly in an instant,
Isaiah 47:11
“But evil will come on you
Which you will not know how to charm away;
And disaster will fall on you
For which you cannot atone;
And destruction about which you do not know
Will come on you suddenly.
Jeremiah 15:8
“Their widows will be more numerous before Me
Than the sand of the seas;
I will bring against them, against the mother of a young man,
A destroyer at noonday;
I will suddenly bring down on her
Anguish and dismay.
Isaiah 30:13
Therefore this iniquity will be to you
Like a breach about to fall,
A bulge in a high wall,
Whose collapse comes suddenly in an instant,
18 The beginning of sorrows and great mournings; the beginning of famine and great death; the beginning of wars, and the powers shall stand in fear; the beginning of evils! what shall I do when these evils shall come? 19 Behold, famine and plague, tribulation and anguish, are sent as scourges for amendment. 20 But for all these things they shall not turn from their wickedness, nor be alway mindful of the scourges. 21 Behold, victuals shall be so good cheap upon earth, that they shall think themselves to be in good case, and even then shall evils grow upon earth, sword, famine, and great confusion. 22 For many of them that dwell upon earth shall perish of famine; and the other, that escape the hunger, shall the sword destroy. 23 And the dead shall be cast out as dung, and there shall be no man to comfort them: for the earth shall be wasted, and the cities shall be cast down. 24 There shall be no man left to till the earth, and to sow it. 25 The trees shall give fruit, and who shall gather them? 26 The grapes shall ripen, and who shall tread them? for all places shall be desolate of men: 27 So that one man shall desire to see another, and to hear his voice. 28 For of a city there shall be ten left, and two of the field, which shall hide themselves in the thick groves, and in the clefts of the rocks. 29 As in an orchard of olives upon every tree there are left three or four olives; 30 Or as when a vineyard is gathered, there are left some clusters of them that diligently seek through the vineyard: 31 Even so in those days there shall be three or four left by them that search their houses with the sword. 32 And the earth shall be laid waste, and the fields thereof shall wax old, and her ways and all her paths shall grow full of thorns, because no man shall travel therethrough. 33 The virgins shall mourn, having no bridegrooms; the women shall mourn, having no husbands; their daughters shall mourn, having no helpers. 34 In the wars shall their bridegrooms be destroyed, and their husbands shall perish of famine.
35 Hear now these things and understand them, ye servants of the Lord. 36 Behold the word of the Lord, receive it: believe not the gods of whom the Lord spake. 37 Behold, the plagues draw nigh, and are not slack. 38 As when a woman with child in the ninth month bringeth forth her son, with two or three hours of her birth great pains compass her womb, which pains, when the child cometh forth, they slack not a moment: 39 Even so shall not the plagues be slack to come upon the earth, and the world shall mourn, and sorrows shall come upon it on every side.
40 O my people, hear my word: make you ready to thy battle, and in those evils be even as pilgrims upon the earth. 41 He that selleth, let him be as he that fleeth away: and he that buyeth, as one that will lose: 42 He that occupieth merchandise, as he that hath no profit by it: and he that buildeth, as he that shall not dwell therein: 43 He that soweth, as if he should not reap: so also he that planteth the vineyard, as he that shall not gather the grapes: 44 They that marry, as they that shall get no children; and they that marry not, as the widowers. 45 And therefore they that labour, labour in vain: 46 For strangers shall reap their fruits, and spoil their goods, overthrow their houses, and take their children captives, for in captivity and famine shall they get children. 47 And they that occupy their merchandise with robbery, the more they deck their cities, their houses, their possessions, and their own persons: 48 The more will I be angry with them for their sin, saith the Lord. 49 Like as a whore envieth a right honest and virtuous woman: 50 So shall righteousness hate iniquity, when she decketh herself, and shall accuse her to her face, when he cometh that shall defend him that diligently searcheth out every sin upon earth.
51 And therefore be ye not like thereunto, nor to the works thereof. 52 For yet a little, and iniquity shall be taken away out of the earth, and righteousness shall reign among you. 53 Let not the sinner say that he hath not sinned: for God shall burn coals of fire upon his head, which saith before the Lord God and his glory, I have not sinned. 54 Behold, the Lord knoweth all the works of men, their imaginations, their thoughts, and their hearts: 55 Which spake but the word, Let the earth be made; and it was made: Let the heaven be made; and it was created. 56 In his word were the stars made, and he knoweth the number of them. 57 He searcheth the deep, and the treasures thereof; he hath measured the sea, and what it containeth. 58 He hath shut the sea in the midst of the waters, and with his word hath he hanged the earth upon the waters. 59 He spreadeth out the heavens like a vault; upon the waters hath he founded it. 60 In the desert hath he made springs of water, and pools upon the tops of the mountains, that the floods might pour down from the high rocks to water the earth. 61 He made man, and put his heart in the midst of the body, and gave him breath, life, and understanding. 62 Yea, and the Spirit of Almighty God, which made all things, and searcheth out all hidden things in the secrets of the earth, 63 Surely he knoweth your inventions, and what ye think in your hearts, even them that sin, and would hide their sin. 64 Therefore hath the Lord exactly searched out all your works, and he will put you all to shame. 65 And when your sins are brought forth, ye shall be ashamed before men, and your own sins shall be your accusers in that day. 66 What will ye do? or how will ye hide your sins before God and his angels? 67 Behold, God himself is the judge, fear him: leave off from your sins, and forget your iniquities, to meddle no more with them for ever: so shall God lead you forth, and deliver you from all trouble.
I wonder 'why there is even "Nothing"?!
Don't we all wonder that!? 😄
Nothing, by its very definition, cannot exist. It’s never been able to exist. It never will exist. Nothing only exists as a cognitive construct to bound the finite duration of a singular consciousness.
Existence is eternal because non existence don’t exist in actuality only in concept, nothing is created or destroyed only transformed enjoy eternity my friend
But then why there was a vacuum and quantum laws to begin with ?
It doesnt answer the question at all. Nothing should even exist. It is so weird that there is something at all. The fact emptiness is even possible is confusing. It seems normal in appareance because we are there. But something must have created all this quantic stuff. And the stuff creating it also.. But then it is endless like an endless movement. So something must have appeared out of nowhere at somepoint. With no reasons and yet that just seems impossible 🤔
Aaah this is giving me such a headache.
I watched this in January but didn't comment, so I watched it again today, it is definitely mind bogging, BTW, what are your thoughts on Loop Quantum Gravity? And the theory of the Big Bounce? 🌍
I think both of these theories are plausible, but there's a lot that needs to be done to actually prove either of them. And it's going to take quite a lot of time, maybe generations, to prove. That's my take on it.
@@Cosmoknowledge Thank you my friend, I agree with you completely, and I pray I'll be able someday to understand all or this. 🌏
How come I was born and living peacefully then realized The universe is gonna end someday
Well, looong after we're dead. 😄
@@Cosmoknowledge True 🤣
Thanks
Of course. Thank you!
the thing that made the universe is God, but I don't know how he never had a beginning and will never have an end
just think we'll never know 🤔
Here's the short answer to this video, it's called energy distribution
i ask why i am conscious
The future will tell us.
NOTHING EXISTS WE ARE ALL IN A DREAM!!!
And who is dreaming it? Wake him/her up!
Maybe antimatter won and we just call it "matter"
Oh no, that's not the case.
@@Cosmoknowledge How do you know?
@@eustab.anas-mann9510 oof
My theory is that we came from darkness and somehow that darkness gained false consciousness and created it's own illusion of (LIGHT) and we are just an illusion of it's thoughts seeking more and more evolution constantly in an on going cycle/simulation of basically nothing but EVOLUTION seeking it's satisfaction of creating life/light take the Suns for instance they are infinity. I believe that explains why they say the cosmic web look like brain neurons carrying information (THOUGHT PROCESSING/Consciousness).... just so happen we are part of a thought processing simulation and everything it consist of is just a construct with no beginning or ending(INFINITY)...they say the BIG BANG started from a singularity out of total darkness (Cosmic Web) then the simulation started...in that case that's exactly what we are living in. That's why we have two different kinds of black holes...matter and anti matter black holes...what does a anti matter black hole do? pulls matter back to a singularity point (VANISH POINT)...planets/sun/asteroids everything is matter...AKA black holes/anti matter black holes exist because matter should have never existed...think about negative matter IT DOES NOT EXIST AT ALL SCIENTIST CALLED IT THAT BECAUSE THEY NAMED THINGS WE SEE MATTER...I can go deeper all I'm going to say is that either my theory is correct...OR WE ARE A PART OF SOMETHING NOT SOMEONE EXPERITMENT
But when there was nothing there was still an empty 3 dimentional space. Why is there empty space? Why is there anything? Why does the universe empty or not exist? What is outside the universe? PLEASE HELP ME.
There was never a time when there was nothing; there was ALWAYS something because non-existence is inconceivable, a logical and an empirical impossibility. 2. The space is never empty. Even absolute vacuum doesn't mean emptiness, it only implies absence of detectable substance. 3. Why is there anything at all? Because non-existence is impossible; there IS always something. 4. What is outside the (manifested) universe? The unmanifested universe.
These are the views I hold at the moment which,naturally, are subject to change. I hope to have been of some assistance.
big bang and god existence both makes sense
because if there is nothing before big bang then god coming from nothing also make sense ,if you get what im implying
Why do we exist? We were born...
But the question just goes on and on, so where did quantum particles come from then, and Surley it’s not nothing because they are there… ffs