Ebb-ert? Boggert? Thanks to AI people too young to know Ebert and Bogart will absorb misinformation and pass it on--- like the newsman in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance says: ¨When the legend becomes fact, print the legend.¨ Ergo, when AI ¨speaks¨ the ignorant and the stupid get more ignorant and more stupid. Ebert was extremely insightful and well educated. That´s why his critiques were meaningful.
Roger Ebert was one of the critics that hailed "The Wild Bunch" as a masterpiece when it came out, and received terrible reviews from other critics. So, that western should be on this list.
Good choices. Let me add She Wore a Yellow Ribbon with its GORGEOUS COLOR, Wagon Master, Fort Apache, Two Rode Together, Rancho Notorious, Forty Guns, The Naked Spur, Winchester 73, Bend of the River, Man of the West . All of Budd Boetticher's westerns may not be masterpieces but they are ALL excellent. Have not seen Fuller's Run of the Arrow in too long a time to have an opinion.
Unlike the Dude in Liberty Valance, Jimmy Stewart was great on horseback! And with his gunplay - also totally believable! Probably the most experienced horseman to reach star status was Gary Cooper from Helena, Montana. He actually began in silent films as a cowboy extra and stunt rider. Watching him ride at full gallop is like art in motion.
Naturally one of the greatest Western Films of all time wasn't even mentioned, The Big Country, that picture is worth watching and talking about, even people today discard this Masterpiece!!!!!
Happy to say I have six of the movies on this list in my collection, and I'm very pleased that Mr. Ebert agrees with my choices. "The Man Who Shot Liberty Valence", "The Treasure Of The Sierra Madre", "The Searchers", "Stagecoach", "The Good, The Bad And The Ugly" and "Unforgiven" are all in rotation when I'm in the mood to go out West.
3 that SHOULD be on this list, at the expense of 3 others here that have no business being there, IMO are: THE WILD BUNCH, ONCE UPON A TIME IN THE WEST (with the greatest opening of them all), & RIDE THE HIGH COUNTRY. So it goes.
"Red River" is possibly the best. If it weren't for the hysterical female who appears in the last scenes it would be my no. 1. "The Good, the Bad and the Ugly." Hard to fault it.
I think The Outlaw Josey Wales should be on this list. El Topo?? Who ever heard of it? Johnny Guitar? NIX. Once Upon a Time in the West I would rate as #1, certainly better than Red River.
He was a great critic and his name was pronounced "Eeebert." And that's "Bogart" not Boggart! You lose all credibility with your constant mis-pronounciations.
I’m thankful a lot of folks like all these movies no movie can compare to the Searchers and yes every western has the true story of the west his reviews were terrible he picked a-lot of John Ford picks he was a the greatest director in western history but The outlaw JOSEY Wells was a great western and tombstone is a top ten . He left out at least 15 on his picks . Critics suck .
SHANE should replace CLEMENTIINE and RIO BRAVO should replace EL TOPO. Another unsung western is RIDE LONESOME. Maybe it should replace SIERRA MADRE, which is not a typical western genre piece.
In the title it says "Classic" Westerns. As much as I think the Good, the Bad, and the Ugly might be the "best" western (depends on mood but it's always in the top 5) it certainly isn't a "Classic Western" and neither is "El Topo", great westerns yes, great classic westerns no.
A lot left off but then if you narrow yourself down to 10, well...but Johnny Guitar does not belong on this list, if only because as Crawford said afterwards, she wished they had told her ahead of time it was a comedy (or farce)...she played it straight and ended up looking foolish.
Where is "High Noon"? John Wayne objected to this movie because Cooper throws his badge in the dirt at the end which Wayne felt was unamerican. This was at the height of red scare and John Wayne was very right wing. This western was much better than "The Greatest Show on Earth" that won the OSCAR for best picture of 1952 but the Academy wouldn't vote for it.
I know, but if I recall correctly, Ebert admitted he must have missed something because it was so well loved by audiences, myself included. I lost count of how may times I´ve seen it----well over 100. For my money, it has two out of the three best gunfights in cinema. The third is the final shoot out in Hombre: ¨Well now. Whatta you suppose Hell is gonna look like?¨ (The best lines ever spoken in a movie.) And the fourth best is the stage coach shoot out----¨Kid. Get down from there.¨ I know everyone likes the final shootout in The Good The Bad and the Ugly but I like mine to be swift, realistic and brutal----just like real violence actually is---not the melodramatic, the drawn out and the ludicrous. 😉
the author of RED RIVER was not happy with the movie ending, which was quite different from the movie ending. Nor a real big fan of it, and actally the same I feel for SEARCHERS. I have MAN WHO SHOT LIBERTY VALLANCE as my number two best, followwed by HIGH NOON. My favorite is ONCE UPON A TIME IN THE WEST.
You can't get a thumbs up if you can't even get the names right.
Humphrey Bogg Art. Sheesh.
Get a live narrator. The way the names are butchered is ludicrous.
There are more variants on pronouncing "Ebert" then Benedict Cumberbatch has for "penguin."
My goodness, can’t humans read aloud anymore? Can’t they just hire someone from a radio station?
Agreed. The first E in Roger's name is a long E, like the first syllable in seagull. How could he not know that?
I hate it when they use those AI voices to narrate.
AI is so annoying now.
High Noon and Once Upon a Time in the West are truly great films.
Ebb-ert? Boggert? Thanks to AI people too young to know Ebert and Bogart will absorb misinformation and pass it on--- like the newsman in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance says: ¨When the legend becomes fact, print the legend.¨ Ergo, when AI ¨speaks¨ the ignorant and the stupid get more ignorant and more stupid. Ebert was extremely insightful and well educated. That´s why his critiques were meaningful.
At least it didn't Waah-nuh or Fard.
I immediately turned it off and gave a thumbs down. I’m not going to waste my time on this loser.
Roger Ebert was one of the critics that hailed "The Wild Bunch" as a masterpiece when it came out, and received terrible reviews from other critics. So, that western should be on this list.
Similarly, he nailed 2004's _The Alamo_ while other critics were falling all over themselves trying clever variants of "forget the Alamo."
Top five - no argument-Shane ,the searchers,high noon, the wild bunch, the big country. Classics forever.
Good choices. Let me add She Wore a Yellow Ribbon with its GORGEOUS COLOR, Wagon Master, Fort Apache, Two Rode Together, Rancho Notorious, Forty Guns, The Naked Spur, Winchester 73, Bend of the River, Man of the West . All of Budd Boetticher's westerns may not be masterpieces but they are ALL excellent. Have not seen Fuller's Run of the Arrow in too long a time to have an opinion.
Unlike the Dude in Liberty Valance, Jimmy Stewart was great on horseback! And with his gunplay - also totally believable!
Probably the most experienced horseman to reach star status was Gary Cooper from Helena, Montana. He actually began in silent films as a cowboy extra and stunt rider. Watching him ride at full gallop is like art in motion.
Destry rides again (1939 original).. is my favourite western.. although I admit "The Searchers" is dam good on a big cinema screen..
#1: Once Upon a Time In the West
Seen all of them. All great. No DEI. No Hollywood agenda pushing. Just great acting, great plots, great directing and great production values.
I've never heard more different pronunciations of Ebert in my life.
Naturally one of the greatest Western Films of all time wasn't even mentioned, The Big Country, that picture is worth watching and talking about, even people today discard this Masterpiece!!!!!
Happy to say I have six of the movies on this list in my collection, and I'm very pleased that Mr. Ebert agrees with my choices. "The Man Who Shot Liberty Valence", "The Treasure Of The Sierra Madre", "The Searchers", "Stagecoach", "The Good, The Bad And The Ugly" and "Unforgiven" are all in rotation when I'm in the mood to go out West.
Just got my 4k copy of The Searchers today watching it for Christmas it's got snow in it so it qualifies as a Christmas movie
I "appropriated" the beginning of that that snow scene in my movie
Watch for the station wagon in the upper left when the cavalry cross the river.
3 that SHOULD be on this list, at the expense of 3 others here that have no business being there, IMO are: THE WILD BUNCH, ONCE UPON A TIME IN THE WEST (with the greatest opening of them all), & RIDE THE HIGH COUNTRY. So it goes.
"Red River" is possibly the best. If it weren't for the hysterical female who appears
in the last scenes it would be my no. 1.
"The Good, the Bad and the Ugly." Hard to fault it.
Yes the end of Red River is corny.
God, I hate AI voice overs.
EEEEEEEEEbert
I think The Outlaw Josey Wales should be on this list. El Topo?? Who ever heard of it?
Johnny Guitar? NIX. Once Upon a Time in the West I would rate as #1, certainly better than Red River.
Why isn’t Shane here? I know Ebert listed it as one of his Great Movies.
That Humfrey Boggert can sure act... oh dear..
Bog-ert?????
If they would just not mispronounce proper names, l could tolerate them.
What do have to do to get this AIs off these postings?
Huge difference between Westerns by Clint Eastwood versus John Wayne.
Boggert? Dude
Humphrey Bagart? I'm surprised they didn't call him Humphrey Buger.
Wow, he boogered up Bogart's name by calling him Boggert! LOL. (AI, apparently)
He never knew the hunting party 1971 or blind man with Ringo Starr or scalps 1987 thanks for the list
he should have left out el topo and included Tombstone, from about 1993. other than that, I agree with all this.
He was a great critic and his name was pronounced "Eeebert." And that's "Bogart" not Boggart! You lose all credibility with your constant mis-pronounciations.
AI narration kills this otherwise good video.
Bahgot??? Try BowgArt
So the Wild Bunch didn't make the list.
I’m thankful a lot of folks like all these movies no movie can compare to the Searchers and yes every western has the true story
of the west his reviews were terrible he picked a-lot of John Ford picks he was a the greatest director in western history but The outlaw JOSEY Wells was a great western and tombstone is a top ten . He left out at least 15 on his picks . Critics suck .
I would like to see the evidence that any of the narrators are AIs. Mispronouncing a name is not solid evidence of an AI.
Ebert completely TRASHED “Home Alone “ when it was released. His opinion is no better than anyone else’s. And sometimes WORSE.
I had to turn it off a couple of minutes in over the butchering of well known names. Not recommending this channel.
Humphrey Boggert, adios...
Wonder how Back-ull would have responded to that pronunciation.
bogart... ebert... pronunciation! and more...computer generated? get a human to read a script.
SHANE should replace CLEMENTIINE and RIO BRAVO should replace EL TOPO. Another unsung western is RIDE LONESOME. Maybe it should replace SIERRA MADRE, which is not a typical western genre piece.
what about Shane??
In the title it says "Classic" Westerns. As much as I think the Good, the Bad, and the Ugly might be the "best" western (depends on mood but it's always in the top 5) it certainly isn't a "Classic Western" and neither is "El Topo", great westerns yes, great classic westerns no.
El Topo has to be the weirdest movie, much less western, that I have ever see. In the theater. That it could be someone's favorite..........
I think Dances with Wolves is the best western ever.
Racist movie. Also, the Sioux were not good Indians.
A lot left off but then if you narrow yourself down to 10, well...but Johnny Guitar does not belong on this list, if only because as Crawford said afterwards, she wished they had told her ahead of time it was a comedy (or farce)...she played it straight and ended up looking foolish.
Where is "High Noon"? John Wayne objected to this movie because Cooper throws his badge in the dirt at the end which Wayne felt was unamerican. This was at the height of red scare and John Wayne was very right wing. This western was much better than "The Greatest Show on Earth" that won the OSCAR for best picture of 1952 but the Academy wouldn't vote for it.
Usual suspects. What hidden forgotten gems would qualify? ..
Rancho Notorious and Forty Guns. Are Anthony Mann's westerns forgotten gems?. They certainly are gems.
Where's Shane
Yes one of my faorite westerns.
Shane must be in an all time top 10.
You're right. Come back, Shane!!!
interestingly, both he and Siskel did not like Butch Cassidy And The Sundance Kid.
I know, but if I recall correctly, Ebert admitted he must have missed something because it was so well loved by audiences, myself included. I lost count of how may times I´ve seen it----well over 100. For my money, it has two out of the three best gunfights in cinema. The third is the final shoot out in Hombre: ¨Well now. Whatta you suppose Hell is gonna look like?¨ (The best lines ever spoken in a movie.) And the fourth best is the stage coach shoot out----¨Kid. Get down from there.¨ I know everyone likes the final shootout in The Good The Bad and the Ugly but I like mine to be swift, realistic and brutal----just like real violence actually is---not the melodramatic, the drawn out and the ludicrous. 😉
Movie b coming lost classic
Not good
I can't stand Siskel and Ebert, but cool to see a list of westerns Ebert liked.
the author of RED RIVER was not happy with the movie ending, which was quite different from the movie ending. Nor a real big fan of it, and actally the same I feel for SEARCHERS. I have MAN WHO SHOT LIBERTY VALLANCE as my number two best, followwed by HIGH NOON. My favorite is ONCE UPON A TIME IN THE WEST.
THE SEARCHERS is the greatest movie ever made, period!
The 1960 classic film The Magnificent Seven - literally poops all over some of the movies selected in the "Top Ten"