It’s a good theory but in Firestar’s quest one of the cats who gives Leafstar a life is her mom, and she is described looking identical to her daughter (pale cream-and-brown tabby), while Cinders (Sol’s mom) is a tortoiseshell BUUUT MAAAAYBE Sol’s sibling is Leafstar’s mom? I mean we don’t know how old either sol or Leafstar are so it’s possible?
I mean it's not impossible for Sol's sister to be Leafstar's mom. Pretty sure Leafpool was only a year or so old when she had Jay, Lion, and Holly so Sol wouldn't need to be that much older than Leafstar
@@falcon_arkaig I doubt it. Leafstar's age is vague but she's assumed to be at least 1 year old in Firestar's Quest. SkyClan and the stranger takes place roughly a year to a year and a half after that. So Leafstar would've been 2-2.5 years old at least, with a possibility that she's in fact older since we again, don't know how old she is exactly in Firestar's quest other then she's warrior aged. Now, Sol's generally portrayed as younger and less mature then Leafstar is, so i'd guess he's either about her age or younger. Not older, or at least not old enough to have a sister that could've been Leafstar's mom.
The only problem is Sol's sister has brown on her shoulders (the tabby markings on Leafstar could have developed later). But they could still be related, just not the same cats...
Leafstar's mother is seen in StarClan and she's not Cinders, but... what if they have the same father? What if the second mate Sol's dad took went on to father Leafstar? :0
@@mollyosborne4940 Isn't Mapleshade way to old for that? like Sol's granddad wouldn't have been born yet? I guess when Mapleshade's vengnce happened in the timeline isn't known but it seems to me that the cats in the alegances wouldv'e had to compleatly change also if you talking about the dad that's not how genetics work though they don't really matter for Warriors
@ThistletoungeMapleshade's Vengance's place in the timeline isnt super easy to pin down exactly, but it cant be too long before Pinestar's Choice. youre right on Sol's grandpa tho, he wouldnt have even been born yet
I love the idea of them being related, but I’m leaning more towards them being cousins. Leafstar and Sols sister don’t look completely identical, and Leaf is described as being identical to her mom (who would not be a tortie) while Cinders is a tortie. Plus if Sol can remember that much of his backstory, I think he’d recognize his sister.
I don’t know if Leafstar and Sol would be full-blood siblings, but they could be half-siblings. It is mentioned that Sol’s father dumped Cinders (his mom), and chose a new mate. Maybe they share the same father (hence why Harrybrook is gray)!
More likely in 0:54 their pelts are similar but not same, I'm sorry to tell you this, but Leafstar is not Sol's sibling, there is possibilities that they are related... eh somehow
wait what i thought everyone knew this, i think that they have a different mother since it was brought up in firestars quest, but theyre half siblings (also i think sols name when he was a kittypet was harry, so harrykit might be reflecting that) i also was googling a bunch of things and looked up who sols father was and it said that it was the same unknown tom who fathered leafstar or something
no, the harrykit thing is directly addressed in skyclan and the stranger. leafstar has her kits, but she and her kits are kidnapped by twolegs, and sol helps them escape. he was still Harry then, so to honor how he helped her, she names a kit after him. nothing to do with familial ties.
It’s a good theory but in Firestar’s quest one of the cats who gives Leafstar a life is her mom, and she is described looking identical to her daughter (pale cream-and-brown tabby), while Cinders (Sol’s mom) is a tortoiseshell
BUUUT MAAAAYBE Sol’s sibling is Leafstar’s mom? I mean we don’t know how old either sol or Leafstar are so it’s possible?
I mean it's not impossible for Sol's sister to be Leafstar's mom. Pretty sure Leafpool was only a year or so old when she had Jay, Lion, and Holly so Sol wouldn't need to be that much older than Leafstar
Oh yeah!!! that makes alot more sense 😅:)
Yeah but i mean still could possibly be Ture they could have the same father
I think itd be more interesting if Sol was Leafstars long lost son
@@falcon_arkaig I doubt it. Leafstar's age is vague but she's assumed to be at least 1 year old in Firestar's Quest. SkyClan and the stranger takes place roughly a year to a year and a half after that. So Leafstar would've been 2-2.5 years old at least, with a possibility that she's in fact older since we again, don't know how old she is exactly in Firestar's quest other then she's warrior aged.
Now, Sol's generally portrayed as younger and less mature then Leafstar is, so i'd guess he's either about her age or younger. Not older, or at least not old enough to have a sister that could've been Leafstar's mom.
The only problem is Sol's sister has brown on her shoulders (the tabby markings on Leafstar could have developed later). But they could still be related, just not the same cats...
I noticed that too.... They're probably related somehow, but maybe not siblings
Leafstar's mother is seen in StarClan and she's not Cinders, but... what if they have the same father? What if the second mate Sol's dad took went on to father Leafstar? :0
I thought the same between Sol and MapleShade since they look almost identical
@@mollyosborne4940 Isn't Mapleshade way to old for that? like Sol's granddad wouldn't have been born yet? I guess when Mapleshade's vengnce happened in the timeline isn't known but it seems to me that the cats in the alegances wouldv'e had to compleatly change also if you talking about the dad that's not how genetics work though they don't really matter for Warriors
@ThistletoungeMapleshade's Vengance's place in the timeline isnt super easy to pin down exactly, but it cant be too long before Pinestar's Choice.
youre right on Sol's grandpa tho, he wouldnt have even been born yet
I love the idea of them being related, but I’m leaning more towards them being cousins. Leafstar and Sols sister don’t look completely identical, and Leaf is described as being identical to her mom (who would not be a tortie) while Cinders is a tortie. Plus if Sol can remember that much of his backstory, I think he’d recognize his sister.
bro you cooked. holy shit. this is crazy lol. new headcanon for myself
It says that Sol’s dad mated with another she-cat. So maybe… they can be stepsibling instead????
I don’t know if Leafstar and Sol would be full-blood siblings, but they could be half-siblings. It is mentioned that Sol’s father dumped Cinders (his mom), and chose a new mate. Maybe they share the same father (hence why Harrybrook is gray)!
That’s what I was thinking!!
Nice!
I actually noticed this too. You're not alone! I was like, "BEBY LEAFSTAR?!"
Bro, WHAT THIS IS SO GOOD
I HAD THIS SAME THEORY I NOTICED IT TOOOO
More likely in 0:54 their pelts are similar but not same, I'm sorry to tell you this, but Leafstar is not Sol's sibling, there is possibilities that they are related... eh somehow
I feel like they’d recognize eachother though and recognize their shared backstory?
i am going INSANE over this i'm going to be thinking about this for weeks
I am not a warrior cats fan, I have no idea why TH-cam recommended me this but for some reason I seem to have watched through this entire video
WAIT WHAT???? :O
wait what i thought everyone knew this, i think that they have a different mother since it was brought up in firestars quest, but theyre half siblings (also i think sols name when he was a kittypet was harry, so harrykit might be reflecting that) i also was googling a bunch of things and looked up who sols father was and it said that it was the same unknown tom who fathered leafstar or something
no, the harrykit thing is directly addressed in skyclan and the stranger. leafstar has her kits, but she and her kits are kidnapped by twolegs, and sol helps them escape.
he was still Harry then, so to honor how he helped her, she names a kit after him. nothing to do with familial ties.
okay i havent read any of the manga yet so i dont rlly know this but ty
I think that sols sister could’ve been leafstars mom! So this means leafstar could possibly be sols niece
I thought the same thing but with Sol and MapleShade since they look very identical: tortoiseshell and white
I guess Redtail, Blossomfall, Spottedleaf and all of the other CALICO HAHA cats are related lawl.
YES THE SECOND I READ SOL’S BACKSTORY I RECOGNIZED HER AS LEAFSTAR
I noticed that oml ! I thought i was the only onee!
Girl i have had this theory for a while 😅
I believe thus fully now.
Yus
YES
Thank you TH-cam for showing me this video
I thought you were going to Sol and Sunbeam were siblings before actually watching the video 💀
WHAT
Just because they look similar doesn’t mean their siblings
Look at the front legz it has redish brown and white pawz. And leaf star just has white feont legs and white pawz so it couldn't be her
Yes, I know. They could still be related though. But probably not siblings