The clarity is better on the S2 and dramatically better on the R2. The R2 is also playing lower than the other two, but just as high. The R2 costs over twice as much as the S2 and it shows.
You need to to put frequency blockers on them. The passive crossover doesn’t filter out enough. I have th X series components, running a X-A70F, the scream. I run hipass 600 hz filters the can NOT play lows well. They are not midrange or mid bass. They are loud speakers NOT woofers. For 5-600 hz to 100 hz you need a woofer. Knowledge….. 🎤 drop.
Not sure if I missed it but is this a high res audio song, and also is the phone capable of high res? Not to mention the audio player and whatever the equipment between the phone and speakers. In all 3 models I can hear a distortion in the high end. The S series use silkdome and don’t normally screech but I’ve found the R’s to do it in some installs. Not knocking the video. Thanks for the comparison as it helps us buyers make choices without having to buy them! Also not everyone may be using all high res gear so this would also be helpful for a general setup!
I wanted the R2 6.5 coaxials in my truck, but only pushing 50 watts per channel so was worried about them being underpowered, opted to go with the S2 since they were a better match with my output. May eventually go with a more powerful 4 channel amp and upgrade to R2 components instead of coaxials
Hello ıt was a very clear video. I have a car with stock speaker and had no resulatıon and color. Could you please give an advice. How would be the order from start to end. For exp 1 Speaker 2 amfi 3 dsp 4 subwoofer something like that
Were these played with the tweeters? If not this is an unfair comparison as a lot of the "clarity" could just be the woofer not rolling off the highs in the same spot.
@@SimplyTrashed You are missing the point of my comment. You cannot compare two drivers clarity if they don't have the same frequency response. The only way you could compare them like this is if you eq them to the same exact frequency response. Also you really need to compare them in the frequency band they are intended to be used in. One driver might have better clarity overall but the other driver might have more clarity in the frequency band it is actually used for.
All this shows is effectively the upper frequency limit of the bass drivers. These are designed as part of a system, with a crossover and tweeter. This is like choosing a sports car based on redline and little else.
Fiberglass cloth cones on the r-series will not last very long if you push them hard!! In this test he is using his iPhone or Android as signal which is nothing but Distortion to begin with so this is a completely erroneous test and is subjective to The Listener only.. .
Well iPhone and Android is what people most likely will be playing music on. Also "push them hard" makes no sense. They come with a passive crossover as long as you feed them their required watts they'll be good, and if not, there's the warranty
Great video right up until you tried to demonstrate the audio by recording the sound off your phone. Get quality mic. Leave it in one place. Don’t use your phone mic.
For the money ill take the S2!
The clarity is better on the S2 and dramatically better on the R2. The R2 is also playing lower than the other two, but just as high. The R2 costs over twice as much as the S2 and it shows.
Excellent demonstration.
They all sound good. The R-Type definitely plays lower.
Its also cleaner
I have the black alpine type s i thought they sounded pretty good but after hearing the new type r i may need to upgrade
even S2 is a lot better
You need to make more of these speaker comparison videos. good job
Wish R2 was a bit more affordable 😞 its really amazing
You need to to put frequency blockers on them. The passive crossover doesn’t filter out enough. I have th X series components,
running a X-A70F, the scream. I run hipass 600 hz filters the can NOT play lows well. They are not midrange or mid bass. They are loud speakers NOT woofers. For 5-600 hz to 100 hz you need a woofer. Knowledge….. 🎤 drop.
Not sure if I missed it but is this a high res audio song, and also is the phone capable of high res? Not to mention the audio player and whatever the equipment between the phone and speakers. In all 3 models I can hear a distortion in the high end. The S series use silkdome and don’t normally screech but I’ve found the R’s to do it in some installs.
Not knocking the video. Thanks for the comparison as it helps us buyers make choices without having to buy them! Also not everyone may be using all high res gear so this would also be helpful for a general setup!
thank you this video really helps me
Would have been nice to hear the comparison with the DP-65
It sound similar to the R
I wanted the R2 6.5 coaxials in my truck, but only pushing 50 watts per channel so was worried about them being underpowered, opted to go with the S2 since they were a better match with my output. May eventually go with a more powerful 4 channel amp and upgrade to R2 components instead of coaxials
50watts rms is plenty for those R speakers.
Type R can go hit 100watt rms. They handle
Hello ıt was a very clear video. I have a car with stock speaker and had no resulatıon and color.
Could you please give an advice. How would be the order from start to end. For exp 1 Speaker 2 amfi 3 dsp 4 subwoofer something like that
Do a test with the focal access, flax, k2
Appreciate your review well done
Were these played with the tweeters? If not this is an unfair comparison as a lot of the "clarity" could just be the woofer not rolling off the highs in the same spot.
But that’s kinda the direct point of this comparison, clarity w/o a tweeter.
@@SimplyTrashed You are missing the point of my comment. You cannot compare two drivers clarity if they don't have the same frequency response. The only way you could compare them like this is if you eq them to the same exact frequency response.
Also you really need to compare them in the frequency band they are intended to be used in. One driver might have better clarity overall but the other driver might have more clarity in the frequency band it is actually used for.
@@stimpsonjcat26 This whole "test" is bullshit, speakers will sound different in any car.
These might sound great in one car, and horrible in another.
thank you sir
Read the front of each box. One handles 80 rms and one handles 100 rms. Jeez
Is it fair to say the S2 is more efficient so if just driving off the head unit without an amp, a better choice then the R2?
I wonder the same
So out of the 2. Which is louder and provides heavy bass for an audiophile??
The third one sounds better than the first two
That is the R2-S65C
All this shows is effectively the upper frequency limit of the bass drivers. These are designed as part of a system, with a crossover and tweeter.
This is like choosing a sports car based on redline and little else.
Great video. How do the new S series compare to the G series component set?
G series are really cheap crap, hardly better than stock speakers
Thanks bro
Can you compare the old spx-17pro .
I have the S S65C and plays loud without distortion, using a focal 100watt rms per channel. What amp did you use and how many? watts.
how about R2 vs compare to DP series on the right ? is that significant defrence? thanks for comparison
Test old 6.5 x-Series vs.
is Alpine S2-S68 worth it for 70 bucks? or is there better alternatives?
70 from where ? its more like £179
@@TMCHL Here in Latvia we can get them half the price, not sure why.
Some of this speakers are Fake be careful
@@matimato6615 220 is reputable seller, all Alpine products seem to be cheaper here.
Fiberglass cloth cones on the r-series will not last very long if you push them hard!!
In this test he is using his iPhone or Android as signal which is nothing but Distortion to begin with so this is a completely erroneous test and is subjective to The Listener only.. .
Well iPhone and Android is what people most likely will be playing music on. Also "push them hard" makes no sense. They come with a passive crossover as long as you feed them their required watts they'll be good, and if not, there's the warranty
Great video right up until you tried to demonstrate the audio by recording the sound off your phone. Get quality mic. Leave it in one place. Don’t use your phone mic.
keep up the good work, love from India
The first two have no low mid. Type R’s or go home.
R is really 👍another level
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍💪💪💪💪💪
Amp
All sound garbage, harmonic distortion. Either your source is garbage.
Totally ridiculous, every speaker will sound different in every other car.
The car and the install makes the biggest difference, not the speaker.