):??!?4??? THANK YOU SO MUCH VIBINGLEAF!!😭 AH THAT’S SUCH AN HONOR!! I really deeply appreciate it, specially since I’ve always been a massive fan of your work!! Thank you for stopping by, it’s wonderful to have the chance to talk to you!💜💟🌌🔮💜💟
I love this actually It fixed my least favorite part of the OG jokepasta: the fact that i doubt Luigi would actually hate Mario in any way the two are great brothers inseparable, even sure, i can get Luigi being jealous, feeling mistreated by others but he'd never actually hate his brother ... this is wonderful.
AHHAA THANK YOU LUIGIKID!!😭😭😭 It truly is an enormous honor to have you here!! Ah, to be fully honest I think I could do better nowadays, after all this was my first horror video like this. Nonetheless, it truly means a whole lot to me to see you here! Big fan!!💕
I like that there's a pathology to the way Luigi moves during his boss fight. Cradling himself while getting beat on before exploding into fits of rage.
the fact the final level is 1-1 hits hard man. a trip back to the first adventure. jesus christ this must be luigi's final thoughts and memories reminiscing before fully perishing
I Really like how after that brutal death, Luigi just Apologized to Mario and then goes to that Star from M64. Connecting it to L is Real! That was Actually Very Good!
Even though this is just a SMBX custom level, I still appreciate, just VERY APPRECIATE this take. The especially deep part (as for me) was at the Mario's "consciousness connection": the epileptic BG just screams in "mental carousel", the message sighs are the last words of Luigi, that reveal the final and long-awaited truth for Mario that was already right behind him, yet Mario resisted to turn around and confront it.. But also- No, if to think so, I just love the fact that you decided to overall extend the ending sequence, where Luigi confesses his suffering before stepping away from the World forever. It is, like, the fame flag of this take!!.. I also thought (or even suspended) of one thing while watching: when Mario read the last sign where Luigi confesses his last honest friendship to Mario, who eventually stands together with Luigi, I thought that Mario would eventually jump off the platform cliff(?) which will represent his suicide action in real time(A.K.A diving into lava). Buuut, at least it just ended with a well-drawn sprite of Luigi's grave from SM64... Phew, that was close..!! Nevertheless, what I wanted to say overall: you made a genuinely sensial re-imagination, which is, as you may already know, - very impressive. It shows that you are already mature and have a high level of intellect (or understanding serious spheres, in this case - psychology). There is no way I hate this. ...I even *love* this..!
Thank you very much!! I really appreciate the comment a whole bunch, I really took my time to think well on what to do with this one, and i’m really happy to see that people are enjoying it!! ♡
@@vinnaki No need to thank the truth. You knew this turned out good-enough. All of those praises you are receiving, - are like a reminders from everyone to you to open the eyes and see the bright truth of your creativeness.
2:06 I was taken by surprise by the change they made in this part, for those who don't know, there are 2 versions of this game based on the original creepypasta, one is a romhack of Super Mario World and the other is a recreation of the same game but with some differences such as the final scene (or the large number of screamers), but precisely in this recreated version there was a secret in which if you swam beyond the tube where it has to enter, the weegee meme will appear in that part , this was more of a joke on the part of the developer but the fact that they replaced the image of Weegee with a more disturbing photo of Luigi makes me see that this reimagining of the creepypasta is more serious with the theme (unlike the original creepypasta ).
The story-telling had me awe-struck, and the idea that Luigi's fight stemmed from mistreatment and anger was such a better idea than "Loogi EVILLL!!1!" You can feel the brotherly bond in Luigi's final words. My own two cents on the lore: Luigi was always second banana to his brother, and everyone treated him as such. To Mario, Luigi was the best brother he could've asked for; to everyone else, Luigi was just Mario's sidekick. Luigi's blood boiled more and more with each passing comment, and King Koopa took notice of it. Meeting up with Luigi, King Koopa managed to make Luigi believe that all of his problems stemmed from Mario and his status, and if Luigi were to kill Mario, he would be the crowned hero he so rightfully deserved to be. With Luigi's judgement clouded by anger, he agreed to the King's terms and watched as the Koopa army constructed a base for Luigi to reside in until Mario came to fight, what the red plumber thought would be, Bowser. Only in Luigi's final moments before being incinerated, did he finally realise what he was doing and who convinced him to do it. But by then, it was too late.
That really sums it up!! I’m really happy to hear that you enjoyed the video, i’ve always enjoyed Mario and Luigi as characters very, very much, so of course none of them would actually hate each other… But seeing the RPG’s and the way some people treated Luigi really just makes you think on how many feeling he has hidden, he deserves so much more love! ♡
@@vinnaki this is honestly really well made, it would be interesting to see a sort of continuation of this where mario figures out what happens and confronts bowser. Just an idea but if you ever decide to make another then I will definitely be there for it!
4:58 - 5:14 Voice lines if anyone can’t hear it: Mario: “LUIGI!” Luigi: “OH GOD NOOOOOOOOOO-“ [Followed by:] Luigi: “***AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHH!!!-***” *Silence for 2 seconds.* Mario: “Weeping/crying.” Luigi: *Garbled sounds for a bit* “I HATE YOOOOOOOOOUUUUUUUU-“ Yw for helping those who couldn’t hear it-
pros: >new lore that didnt make luigi nor mario the evil ones, instead making luigi so fed up with how others (not mario) would treat him, that he went so far to do a deal with the tyrant that is bowser to kill his own brother for the sakes of jealousy, which ended up killing luigi for good, and left mario without his dear brother >the spritework was pretty on point, the boos specially look really nice looking >a boss fight that felt like an actual mario series boss fight (the og having megaman boss bars was so weird and funny that seemed more like a parody from newgrounds) >even tho its a re-take/remake, it was still very close to the og story, keeping the core and the level designs intact while getting rid of some of the major fluff cons: >while using SMBX is fine, because of how the thing looks and plays, its very on the nose that what we see is SMBX, however, since its supposed to be an .exe, a modified SMBX level pack/mod does fit still pretty well, not much of a con, just pointing it out >the whole 1-1 level was pretty unnecessary, i feel like it wouldve been more effective for luigi to come out of the lava, badly burnt, and in an act of desperation and guilt tell everything that happened to mario, and as luigi dies out from the burning, mario would start to tear up in grief, realizing what just happened and what he had done >the oblivious and unaware protag trope that vibing leaf has been doing recently while it was fresh at first, is starting to become annoying and it really throws the immersion out of the window, and it does make me a tad bit sad other content creators are starting to do that same thing, no shame to VL, absolutely LOVE their videos, just wish they would make a protag/narrator that felt like an actual person instead of billy from billy and mandy >awn man, that creepy looking mushroom being gone is kinda sad ngl, it was the most memorable thing from that og pasta :( you did an excellent job my friend! keep it up!
wow, for a reimagining of such an old creppypasta it's pretty good, I love the battle against Luigi which looks more challenging than the original hackrom you have potential :)
This ending makes me sad yet happy because sad because Luigi doesn’t have any hatred towards his brother anymore which is happy but yet sad too because it’s like Luigi is apologizing for everything he has ever done and is speaking to Mario for the final time. Also, you never see The Undead Version Of Luigi because in the original version he is all burnt and dead because the only thing keeping alive is his own hatred for his brother, while in this version you don’t see that because his hatred isn’t keeping live because, well, he doesn’t have that hatred anymore, which means that he can finally be free and not hate his own brother anymore. Overall, this is amazing Re-Imagined version of I Hate You, this also makes no one the bad guy in this version and add like a little more lore which is cool. What I’m trying to say is that you’re extremely underrated, and this is the first video I seen on your channel. Keep up the up the good work!!!
I like how this was basically the opposite of the original i hate you creepypasta. In the original, luigi hated mario, he worked with Bowser because of this. Here though, it looked like he hated everyone BUT mario, because everyone mistreated him. It looked more like he took his anger out on mario for being the CAUSE of the problem instead of wanting to kill him for BEING the problem. I dont think bowser was even mentioned here The mushroom dosnt scare or kill you, it helps you. It even ends with luigi saying "i love you" and ends with the L IS REAL fountain (i believe that is ment to be his grave) instead of his burned corpse. I feel like this implies that dispite what he did, mario forgives him. I really liked that it was more emotional than scary, and not relying on constant jump scares, unlike the original. My only complaint is that the mario corpses were too dark to see. I didn't notice them until i rewatched it
THIS IS AMAZING Seeing one of the best-known creepypastas in the Mario.exe community have a re-imagined version that manages to give a complete 180 degree turn to the original concept is something that even Too late.exe didn't managed to do Hopefully 2 things happen: 1. More people sees this 2. Someone make this a hackroom soon (Sorry if I wrote something wrong, I don't speak english so I used google traductor)
Seriously... somethings wrong with me If I had a penny for every time I've lost a heart for editing a comment... I would have 2 pennys, which isn't much but it's funny that it happened twice, right? (R.I.P. heart 😔) Edit: I just reallized I got it again, Let's go!
i REALLY REALLY love this interpretation of the story just because of how high quality this is. even the ending was really well executed in my opinion im actually impressed
gee, i wonder who treated luigi in a bad way if it wasn’t mari- *Oh, that’s right.* *S T A R L O W .* (neat video btw, just expressing my distain for starlow.)
WAOW, THAT S**T GOOD!!! I LOVED the gameplay and the bossfight with Luigi. But when Luigi died, the screams felt so unsettling and creepy. Even the sprite work for the Luigi close up was INCREDIBLE!!!!! I thought it would turn for the worst, but somehow Luigi forgave Mario in the end! What a good ending!!! I'd want this to be an ACTUAL GAME!!!!! 50/10 RATING, GOOD JOB!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I always believed I Hate You was one of the better Mario creepypastas (the bar wasn't too high to begin with), and even liking it I still had problems with it. This retake, whilst it doesn't capture the mediocrity of an old creepypasta romhack (one of the things that make them so memorable imo) does an amazing job at a retelling of the story, and I prefer it infinitely. The design for the levels and the bossfight is outstanding and the choppy gameplay recording does it's job well (I may not be it's biggest fan but it helps what you're trying to do, making it a lot more immersive which is way more rewarding imo). The only part that irks me is the part with Luigi's face being burnt, but that's just me lol I'm not a big fan of those kinds of imagery, however I have to admit the spritework for it is impressive. Even though I'm not a big fan of that kinda stuff it still manages manages to keep me hooked, I'd say you've done a splendid job. And I can't skip talking about the 1-1 section, it is the highlight of this retake and it fixes what I disliked most about the original. Luigi would never hate Mario no matter the circumstances, he was just in a bad place and he absolutely would apologize for his wrongdoings. It's bittersweet, and I'm glad it ends with a proper send-off showing Luigi's grave (i guess his L is real pahahaha lol) TLDR amazing video. im excited to see what else you'll make in the future. gl!!
Without his baby bro by his side, Mario could not live on. Luigi was not his sidekick. He was his second half. The L-shaped puzzle piece that made his world complete. Mario's last great adventure would be to go with his brother on his permanent vacation to paradise, but it would take a while to get there. He kept calling Luigi just to remind him he was coming, that he loved him, too, and that he wouldn't be alone anymore. But every time he tried, every time he jumped off into nothingness, waiting for that cape to transform into wings and a halo, he'd wake up as if nothing had happened. Damn those 1-Ups.
I HATE YOU.EXE has been an amazing global phenomenon when it came to the original game by Andre Theomguy back in 2015. And after all those years, this was a global phenomenon right there! 🏆🎉🎊💰
While the immersion was a bit TOO immersive, with it being hard to watch once the framerate dropped, the visuals lowered in quality, and the audio became distorted... Really, everything else about this is great. I especially like the idea of the final, post-battle level that is Luigi's posthumous lament. Here, the immersion feels a bit less jarring, with only a few sounds and music being hearable, and some just not being there. And, if those parts that were painful were painful on purpose, then you accomplished that.
i remember the day Markiplier uploaded his "Mario.exe" video with the original game. It fucked me up bad as a kid lmfao, that ending screen is tame in comparison to other horror media i watched at the time but it always stuck with me. It all felt so surreal and unlike any other "mario but creepy" thing at the time. This brought back those feelings in a nostalgic but still unsettling and uncomfortable way, but the ending was sweet and oddly calming after the chaotic scares. The bittersweet speech trough signs against the uncomfortable but hypnotic background was closure that was needed imo, and the L is Real grave as the ending screen is so fitting for this retelling. Also the small nods to other interpretations of the story like the luigi face at 2:06 are nice! Definitely my favorite version of the story now :-)
This is a really good and emotional retake on "I HATE YOU"! Loved it to the very end but I still have some tidbits if issues with it. 1. The quality at the beginning of the video being quite poor I find to be very weird and a choice that really did not work out until the end, especislly considering it was dropped halfway thgrough 2. The flashing backgroundat 5:19 really hurts to see and I believe it should have been toned down or actually be the same background as Donut Plains 1 but with the color more desaturated and the sky grey to fit with the sadness factor of it Except of that, the rest is phenomenal! The sprite works are on point! The ones at 5:09 and the fountain at the end are really great work! The boss fight looks really fun to play and that "OH GOD NOOOOOOOO" and Luigi's scream were extremely unsettling and distressing. The signs at the last stage were really emotional and got me in the feels a bit... I believe it was the perfect way to end the story with Luigi finally admitting his wrongdoings and telling how much he loved his brother. It's really a fantastic remake of the creepypasta
Thank you sweetly for your comment and your criticism!! I really, really appreciate it, if I could ask, could you perhaps watch my "MOUSE.AVI" retake? I'm really trying to improve and get the hold on things, and this is one of the best criticisms i've gotten, I'd appreciate your freedback! ❤
Aseprite is the program I use for pixel art, I just did the base head and started getting silly with it until I managed to make a spooky luigi, then edit that same drawing to make the burnt one :)
The things i don't like is that in map screen you used the original exe version and for the rest of stuff you used SMBX. But i like the Mario19 reference.
So do Luigi he wasn't the only he said I hate you he said this is how we say oh God no he didn't actually he was the only because it happened then like he was a burn to mario crying and there was an accident at burn and Luigi's skeleton like actually the word is supposed to be my favorite my favorite this is supposed to be he is still in lovely with a that is happening this is addition it's like he was the same out that was the most to be he's talk and Luigi he said I Love You Mario like I don't know what is happening he doesn't listen to some really really sure he was an only in the side and then it is the end. He clearly he was a body in this Edition it's like I wasn't supposed to get no one to listen but it is a nation this is how it has to keep when it's all on this Luigi's in Hollywood is a burn in the sky in the Super Mario 64 so I just saw them like he doesn't just I don't know what is but I need he was always like he said because it's raining and then he just actually it's my favorite she and the divorces in the skeleton to home and light he doesn't always have been burned and Luigi just burned inside. I know when is it happening this is how old is Luigi it is the current of the side of the field he didn't look how long does this is so creepy in the pasta. Add creepypasta this is how do I hate you. EXE it doesn't like I don't know what is the problem but what happened to luigi he seeking to the whole one and and asked you this to happen. But actually this is so understanding Easter egg is weegee. But what I'm supposed to be in the system for the circuit to happen if this is supposed to be it doesn't happen to toss him and like he was a burn in the society in the Mario and this is the creepy the screen. What Luigi this is how it is in here it was a and that's what happened in this the end super mario 64. ~ Good luck R.I.P Luigi [1983 - 2024]
not major but one criticism i have is that if you used SMBX, then i feel like you shoulda ran with it, rather than making it still a hack or whatever perhaps instead of a hack, maybe having it be some weird SMBX episode? i feel like that coulda worked and made the fact it's SMBX less jarring
It's amazing how this is even less accurate than the original romhack, this one doesn't even fucking use the noteblocks, items already in Super Mario World
You meant: you love the fact that this take is so unique, that it does not use SMW standarts such as items..? Probablyy, I agree with you, aswell. But.. I did not really pay attention to it, frankly speaking...
@@siinistar7953I hope you find a re-take of a romhack that fits your standards better, i’ll kindly accept the criticism and apply it for another mario video if I do it, hopefully you try being nice next time you criticize anything! ♡
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 67 | คู่เอก "นักรบ vs ทาเกียร์"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eahGc1XmrEU/mqdefault.jpg)
That was REALLY good! :D You did an amazing job with this!
):??!?4??? THANK YOU SO MUCH VIBINGLEAF!!😭 AH THAT’S SUCH AN HONOR!! I really deeply appreciate it, specially since I’ve always been a massive fan of your work!! Thank you for stopping by, it’s wonderful to have the chance to talk to you!💜💟🌌🔮💜💟
@@vinnaki No problem at all! :D
Good luck with your future projects, I'd be looking forward to them!
@@vibingleaf hi!
is me realsansyt
And you said to yourself!
@@vinnaki
Si que tu Re-Take del Creepypasta se ve igual a la versión de @VibingLeaf y parece que cambias algunos elementos de la historia original
@@leonardofabiancazarez464 Incluso si Vibingleaf para mi es una enorme inspiración y lo admiro bastante, esta versión salió primero
I love this actually
It fixed my least favorite part of the OG jokepasta: the fact that i doubt Luigi would actually hate Mario in any way
the two are great brothers
inseparable, even
sure, i can get Luigi being jealous, feeling mistreated by others
but he'd never actually hate his brother
...
this is wonderful.
Ngl, this got to be one of the greatest Takes I've seen of I HATE YOU!
Keep up the amazing work :)
AHHAA THANK YOU LUIGIKID!!😭😭😭
It truly is an enormous honor to have you here!! Ah, to be fully honest I think I could do better nowadays, after all this was my first horror video like this. Nonetheless, it truly means a whole lot to me to see you here! Big fan!!💕
@@vinnaki Hope to see more stuff from ya in the future then :D )
Yay its the dedicated bro guy again!!!
I like that there's a pathology to the way Luigi moves during his boss fight. Cradling himself while getting beat on before exploding into fits of rage.
the fact the final level is 1-1 hits hard man.
a trip back to the first adventure. jesus christ this must be luigi's final thoughts and memories reminiscing before fully perishing
I Really like how after that brutal death, Luigi just Apologized to Mario and then goes to that Star from M64. Connecting it to L is Real!
That was Actually Very Good!
Thank you kindly! There will be a little sequel to this video, stay tuned for that! ♡
Jesus christ Luigi’s death is surprisingly brutal
"Luigi! 😲"
@@heitorsant1759” 0H G0D N0”
̵̼̂́̓̓̕Ǫ̵̡̠̤͚̟͓̗̤͍̘̤̖̎̈́H̸̛͇̝̹̜̠͔̜̿̊̓͊͆͋̎͆̓̚̚͝͝ͅ ̴̛̙͇̅̿͂͊̒͂͝Ǵ̶̛̙͍͇̣̑̓́̄͑͂͋̾̀̍̉Ô̴̡̬͉̖̱̎̈͆̽͝D̴̡̯̠͖͕̈́̇͊͊̈́̇̀̒͜ ̴̨̤̘̳̰̽̋̽́̎͑N̴̘̥̭̟̊͘O̴̞̓͆̕͘O̵̡͕̜̬̣͉̥̘̬̤̹̭͉̓͑O̶̻͐̾̀̈́͛̑̅̚͝O̵̹͊̔̓̾O̸̢̡̙̰̝͚͚̦̼̱̪̿͗̂͌̓̿͑̏͝O̸̼̻̖̼̬̰̮̦̹̜̙̞͚̙͐̃̈́͒̎̐̔͊͂́͘͜͝͝O̴͕͙͈̜͕̩͇̊͜Ȏ̸̦̱͉̮̹̹̰̆͗̈́̑̌̾́̎̈́͆̒̚͠Ǫ̵̛̫͖͉͕͇̝̹̋̽͆̔̂̀̕̚O̸̠͑̓̆͊ͅO̶̤̼͌͝Ơ̵͖̼̰̙͍̲̰̻̄͐͐̈́̅̏̊͝͝͝Ǫ̸͖̜̲̼̊̉͊̈́̈̋͗̅̅͒̄͐O̶̡̟̼͕̪̤̯̳̻̮̰̎̅̚O̷̧̨̧̤̳͖͇̰̘̥͋̔̿̇̊͘O̴͎͒̈́̐̀̌͗̍̅̀̃̚̚͠O̵̢̩͈̘̘̾̎͗̉̋͘!̸̡̤̱̐̇͆͋̿͜@@heitorsant1759
@@heitorsant1759 *sleep paralysis demon scream*
I mean, yeah, being roasted alive in lava isn't exactly a clean way to go
Even though this is just a SMBX custom level, I still appreciate, just VERY APPRECIATE this take.
The especially deep part (as for me) was at the Mario's "consciousness connection": the epileptic BG just screams in "mental carousel", the message sighs are the last words of Luigi, that reveal the final and long-awaited truth for Mario that was already right behind him, yet Mario resisted to turn around and confront it..
But also- No, if to think so, I just love the fact that you decided to overall extend the ending sequence, where Luigi confesses his suffering before stepping away from the World forever. It is, like, the fame flag of this take!!..
I also thought (or even suspended) of one thing while watching: when Mario read the last sign where Luigi confesses his last honest friendship to Mario, who eventually stands together with Luigi, I thought that Mario would eventually jump off the platform cliff(?) which will represent his suicide action in real time(A.K.A diving into lava). Buuut, at least it just ended with a well-drawn sprite of Luigi's grave from SM64...
Phew, that was close..!!
Nevertheless, what I wanted to say overall: you made a genuinely sensial re-imagination, which is, as you may already know, - very impressive. It shows that you are already mature and have a high level of intellect (or understanding serious spheres, in this case - psychology).
There is no way I hate this.
...I even *love* this..!
Thank you very much!! I really appreciate the comment a whole bunch, I really took my time to think well on what to do with this one, and i’m really happy to see that people are enjoying it!! ♡
@@vinnaki No need to thank the truth.
You knew this turned out good-enough.
All of those praises you are receiving, - are like a reminders from everyone to you to open the eyes and see the bright truth of your creativeness.
2:06 I was taken by surprise by the change they made in this part, for those who don't know, there are 2 versions of this game based on the original creepypasta, one is a romhack of Super Mario World and the other is a recreation of the same game but with some differences such as the final scene (or the large number of screamers), but precisely in this recreated version there was a secret in which if you swam beyond the tube where it has to enter, the weegee meme will appear in that part , this was more of a joke on the part of the developer but the fact that they replaced the image of Weegee with a more disturbing photo of Luigi makes me see that this reimagining of the creepypasta is more serious with the theme (unlike the original creepypasta ).
I mean, I Hate You.exe was originally meant to be a joke so
The story-telling had me awe-struck, and the idea that Luigi's fight stemmed from mistreatment and anger was such a better idea than "Loogi EVILLL!!1!"
You can feel the brotherly bond in Luigi's final words.
My own two cents on the lore:
Luigi was always second banana to his brother, and everyone treated him as such.
To Mario, Luigi was the best brother he could've asked for; to everyone else, Luigi was just Mario's sidekick.
Luigi's blood boiled more and more with each passing comment, and King Koopa took notice of it.
Meeting up with Luigi, King Koopa managed to make Luigi believe that all of his problems stemmed from Mario and his status, and if Luigi were to kill Mario, he would be the crowned hero he so rightfully deserved to be.
With Luigi's judgement clouded by anger, he agreed to the King's terms and watched as the Koopa army constructed a base for Luigi to reside in until Mario came to fight, what the red plumber thought would be, Bowser.
Only in Luigi's final moments before being incinerated, did he finally realise what he was doing and who convinced him to do it.
But by then, it was too late.
That really sums it up!! I’m really happy to hear that you enjoyed the video, i’ve always enjoyed Mario and Luigi as characters very, very much, so of course none of them would actually hate each other… But seeing the RPG’s and the way some people treated Luigi really just makes you think on how many feeling he has hidden, he deserves so much more love! ♡
@@vinnaki this is honestly really well made, it would be interesting to see a sort of continuation of this where mario figures out what happens and confronts bowser. Just an idea but if you ever decide to make another then I will definitely be there for it!
4:58 - 5:14
Voice lines if anyone can’t hear it:
Mario: “LUIGI!”
Luigi: “OH GOD NOOOOOOOOOO-“
[Followed by:]
Luigi: “***AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHH!!!-***”
*Silence for 2 seconds.*
Mario: “Weeping/crying.”
Luigi: *Garbled sounds for a bit* “I HATE YOOOOOOOOOUUUUUUUU-“
Yw for helping those who couldn’t hear it-
pros:
>new lore that didnt make luigi nor mario the evil ones, instead making luigi so fed up with how others (not mario) would treat him, that he went so far to do a deal with the tyrant that is bowser to kill his own brother for the sakes of jealousy, which ended up killing luigi for good, and left mario without his dear brother
>the spritework was pretty on point, the boos specially look really nice looking
>a boss fight that felt like an actual mario series boss fight (the og having megaman boss bars was so weird and funny that seemed more like a parody from newgrounds)
>even tho its a re-take/remake, it was still very close to the og story, keeping the core and the level designs intact while getting rid of some of the major fluff
cons:
>while using SMBX is fine, because of how the thing looks and plays, its very on the nose that what we see is SMBX, however, since its supposed to be an .exe, a modified SMBX level pack/mod does fit still pretty well, not much of a con, just pointing it out
>the whole 1-1 level was pretty unnecessary, i feel like it wouldve been more effective for luigi to come out of the lava, badly burnt, and in an act of desperation and guilt tell everything that happened to mario, and as luigi dies out from the burning, mario would start to tear up in grief, realizing what just happened and what he had done
>the oblivious and unaware protag trope that vibing leaf has been doing recently while it was fresh at first, is starting to become annoying and it really throws the immersion out of the window, and it does make me a tad bit sad other content creators are starting to do that same thing, no shame to VL, absolutely LOVE their videos, just wish they would make a protag/narrator that felt like an actual person instead of billy from billy and mandy
>awn man, that creepy looking mushroom being gone is kinda sad ngl, it was the most memorable thing from that og pasta :(
you did an excellent job my friend! keep it up!
wow, for a reimagining of such an old creppypasta it's pretty good, I love the battle against Luigi which looks more challenging than the original hackrom
you have potential :)
This ending makes me sad yet happy because sad because Luigi doesn’t have any hatred towards his brother anymore which is happy but yet sad too because it’s like Luigi is apologizing for everything he has ever done and is speaking to Mario for the final time. Also, you never see The Undead Version Of Luigi because in the original version he is all burnt and dead because the only thing keeping alive is his own hatred for his brother, while in this version you don’t see that because his hatred isn’t keeping live because, well, he doesn’t have that hatred anymore, which means that he can finally be free and not hate his own brother anymore. Overall, this is amazing Re-Imagined version of I Hate You, this also makes no one the bad guy in this version and add like a little more lore which is cool. What I’m trying to say is that you’re extremely underrated, and this is the first video I seen on your channel. Keep up the up the good work!!!
that went from creepy to depressing..
I like how this was basically the opposite of the original i hate you creepypasta.
In the original, luigi hated mario, he worked with Bowser because of this.
Here though, it looked like he hated everyone BUT mario, because everyone mistreated him. It looked more like he took his anger out on mario for being the CAUSE of the problem instead of wanting to kill him for BEING the problem. I dont think bowser was even mentioned here
The mushroom dosnt scare or kill you, it helps you.
It even ends with luigi saying "i love you" and ends with the L IS REAL fountain (i believe that is ment to be his grave) instead of his burned corpse. I feel like this implies that dispite what he did, mario forgives him.
I really liked that it was more emotional than scary, and not relying on constant jump scares, unlike the original.
My only complaint is that the mario corpses were too dark to see. I didn't notice them until i rewatched it
Peak... I love these re-imagining creepypastas like yours ❤️
Man…You deserve much more Recognition... seriously, you really need to be more recognized...
THIS IS AMAZING
Seeing one of the best-known creepypastas in the Mario.exe community have a re-imagined version that manages to give a complete 180 degree turn to the original concept is something that even Too late.exe didn't managed to do
Hopefully 2 things happen:
1. More people sees this
2. Someone make this a hackroom soon
(Sorry if I wrote something wrong, I don't speak english so I used google traductor)
Seriously... somethings wrong with me
If I had a penny for every time I've lost a heart for editing a comment...
I would have 2 pennys, which isn't much but it's funny that it happened twice, right?
(R.I.P. heart 😔)
Edit: I just reallized I got it again, Let's go!
Dude This easily rivals some of Vinginleaf's work, simply magnificent
i REALLY REALLY love this interpretation of the story just because of how high quality this is. even the ending was really well executed in my opinion im actually impressed
rare smbx sighting
gee, i wonder who treated luigi in a bad way if it wasn’t mari-
*Oh, that’s right.*
*S T A R L O W .*
(neat video btw, just expressing my distain for starlow.)
I love Starlow but man she didn’t have to be so mean to him😭
@@vinnaki case in point:
cutscene after beating the shroobs (bowser’s inside story)
@@vinnaki This shit happened right after inside story didn't it
fact about this creepypasta:
The creepypasta itself was actually made as a joke (or parody) to the creepypastas of those years
I love how you did the sprites so good and creatively!
I did like that new ending, it gives more depth to luigi
4:57
Mario : Luigi!!
Luigi: OH GOD NOOoooo
Mario: 😢
WAOW, THAT S**T GOOD!!!
I LOVED the gameplay and the bossfight with Luigi. But when Luigi died, the screams felt so unsettling and creepy. Even the sprite work for the Luigi close up was INCREDIBLE!!!!! I thought it would turn for the worst, but somehow Luigi forgave Mario in the end! What a good ending!!! I'd want this to be an ACTUAL GAME!!!!! 50/10 RATING, GOOD JOB!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
You even added the weegee Easter egg
I always believed I Hate You was one of the better Mario creepypastas (the bar wasn't too high to begin with), and even liking it I still had problems with it.
This retake, whilst it doesn't capture the mediocrity of an old creepypasta romhack (one of the things that make them so memorable imo) does an amazing job at a retelling of the story, and I prefer it infinitely.
The design for the levels and the bossfight is outstanding and the choppy gameplay recording does it's job well (I may not be it's biggest fan but it helps what you're trying to do, making it a lot more immersive which is way more rewarding imo).
The only part that irks me is the part with Luigi's face being burnt, but that's just me lol I'm not a big fan of those kinds of imagery, however I have to admit the spritework for it is impressive. Even though I'm not a big fan of that kinda stuff it still manages manages to keep me hooked, I'd say you've done a splendid job.
And I can't skip talking about the 1-1 section, it is the highlight of this retake and it fixes what I disliked most about the original. Luigi would never hate Mario no matter the circumstances, he was just in a bad place and he absolutely would apologize for his wrongdoings. It's bittersweet, and I'm glad it ends with a proper send-off showing Luigi's grave (i guess his L is real pahahaha lol)
TLDR amazing video. im excited to see what else you'll make in the future. gl!!
4:58 “ Luigi! “ “ OH GOD N0- “
If this character is the same as kirby's malware, then he will absolutelly become a creepy game's researcher
It is!!
@@vinnaki cool!!
Im looking forward to all your new content, you are nice :>
Without his baby bro by his side, Mario could not live on.
Luigi was not his sidekick. He was his second half. The L-shaped puzzle piece that made his world complete.
Mario's last great adventure would be to go with his brother on his permanent vacation to paradise, but it would take a while to get there. He kept calling Luigi just to remind him he was coming, that he loved him, too, and that he wouldn't be alone anymore. But every time he tried, every time he jumped off into nothingness, waiting for that cape to transform into wings and a halo, he'd wake up as if nothing had happened.
Damn those 1-Ups.
Good Lore
i love how you made the smbx level
@Rotads-vf3xs why
I HATE YOU.EXE has been an amazing global phenomenon when it came to the original game by Andre Theomguy back in 2015. And after all those years, this was a global phenomenon right there! 🏆🎉🎊💰
While the immersion was a bit TOO immersive, with it being hard to watch once the framerate dropped, the visuals lowered in quality, and the audio became distorted... Really, everything else about this is great.
I especially like the idea of the final, post-battle level that is Luigi's posthumous lament. Here, the immersion feels a bit less jarring, with only a few sounds and music being hearable, and some just not being there.
And, if those parts that were painful were painful on purpose, then you accomplished that.
6:29 mario use the wrong mushroom
i love how you made the weegee easter egg relevant and actually scary
5:12 "I HATE YOOOUUUU"
Mario: Luigi Luigi: oh god nooooooo
This was awesome, deserves a lot more attention!
Really well done reimagining of the story.
Well done!
I didn't know anyone would remake a Trollpasta, ngl this is great.
Here before this blows up
But in all seriousness great job on this!
you have potential this video is FIRE (literrally)
5:13 now i know what i will fear when night is coming 😀👍🏻
The best remake this project ive ever seen
I know this was realesed a while ago, but DAME YOU HAVE SKILLS!
All that’s left to do is to put this into a playable demo with less laggy frame rate and movement
Oh, cool SM64 reference at the end.
Holy shit this is so fucking good i really love this
I love it but I didn't see I hate you for forever but now I watching thank you vinnaki
Hey Kirbufan219 im your big fan! 😆
i remember the day Markiplier uploaded his "Mario.exe" video with the original game. It fucked me up bad as a kid lmfao, that ending screen is tame in comparison to other horror media i watched at the time but it always stuck with me. It all felt so surreal and unlike any other "mario but creepy" thing at the time. This brought back those feelings in a nostalgic but still unsettling and uncomfortable way, but the ending was sweet and oddly calming after the chaotic scares. The bittersweet speech trough signs against the uncomfortable but hypnotic background was closure that was needed imo, and the L is Real grave as the ending screen is so fitting for this retelling. Also the small nods to other interpretations of the story like the luigi face at 2:06 are nice! Definitely my favorite version of the story now :-)
This is a really good and emotional retake on "I HATE YOU"! Loved it to the very end but I still have some tidbits if issues with it.
1. The quality at the beginning of the video being quite poor I find to be very weird and a choice that really did not work out until the end, especislly considering it was dropped halfway thgrough
2. The flashing backgroundat 5:19 really hurts to see and I believe it should have been toned down or actually be the same background as Donut Plains 1 but with the color more desaturated and the sky grey to fit with the sadness factor of it
Except of that, the rest is phenomenal! The sprite works are on point! The ones at 5:09 and the fountain at the end are really great work! The boss fight looks really fun to play and that "OH GOD NOOOOOOOO" and Luigi's scream were extremely unsettling and distressing. The signs at the last stage were really emotional and got me in the feels a bit... I believe it was the perfect way to end the story with Luigi finally admitting his wrongdoings and telling how much he loved his brother.
It's really a fantastic remake of the creepypasta
Thank you sweetly for your comment and your criticism!! I really, really appreciate it, if I could ask, could you perhaps watch my "MOUSE.AVI" retake? I'm really trying to improve and get the hold on things, and this is one of the best criticisms i've gotten, I'd appreciate your freedback! ❤
@@vinnaki Sure will! I really hope more people get to see your stuff!
Wat animation program is dis !1!1!!1 it very good!!!
This has to be seen by luigykid
If this somehow reached to him i’s be more than happy!!
i realized this isn't vibingleaf and still you made a good remake
Finally, a creppypasta that doesn’t end bad, too bad that this is a fanon re-take and not canon. But at least in this re-take there is a good ending
oh hey, smbx!
this is actually amazing so much better then the original
This makes sense because like after smw there’s no Luigi in Mario land 2 and sm64
SMBX my beloved.
VibingLeaf be like
Is amesome
I Wonder If You Can Do Reimagined Of Strangled Red?
WHY IS THE AUDIO CRISP
crunchy!!
how did you do the luigi head sprites?
Aseprite is the program I use for pixel art, I just did the base head and started getting silly with it until I managed to make a spooky luigi, then edit that same drawing to make the burnt one :)
Huge epilepsy warning for yall
how did you make this man!!
All right it's 207 a.m. in the morning
time to see if this is going to scare me or make me laugh
The things i don't like is that in map screen you used the original exe version and for the rest of stuff you used SMBX. But i like the Mario19 reference.
this is good but Same at the time I hate you still
But you ruined my character but this is great
Why luigi mowed the lawn
Scariest than the original
good ol smbx
but does it have the weegee easter egg like that one fan made version?
replaced with a more unsettling normal Luigi face due to this not being a jokepasta this time around!
IS this animated or made in SMBX? i have to know
bro really needs to get a new emulator like deadass the lag is crazy
Imagine being the guy playing this lol
Could this be a real rom hack to run on real hardware? This looks awesome
Soundtracks?
Where can I download this?
So do Luigi he wasn't the only he said I hate you he said this is how we say oh God no he didn't actually he was the only because it happened then like he was a burn to mario crying and there was an accident at burn and Luigi's skeleton like actually the word is supposed to be my favorite my favorite this is supposed to be he is still in lovely with a that is happening this is addition it's like he was the same out that was the most to be he's talk and Luigi he said I Love You Mario like I don't know what is happening he doesn't listen to some really really sure he was an only in the side and then it is the end. He clearly he was a body in this Edition it's like I wasn't supposed to get no one to listen but it is a nation this is how it has to keep when it's all on this Luigi's in Hollywood is a burn in the sky in the Super Mario 64 so I just saw them like he doesn't just I don't know what is but I need he was always like he said because it's raining and then he just actually it's my favorite she and the divorces in the skeleton to home and light he doesn't always have been burned and Luigi just burned inside. I know when is it happening this is how old is Luigi it is the current of the side of the field he didn't look how long does this is so creepy in the pasta. Add creepypasta this is how do I hate you. EXE it doesn't like I don't know what is the problem but what happened to luigi he seeking to the whole one and and asked you this to happen. But actually this is so understanding Easter egg is weegee. But what I'm supposed to be in the system for the circuit to happen if this is supposed to be it doesn't happen to toss him and like he was a burn in the society in the Mario and this is the creepy the screen. What Luigi this is how it is in here it was a and that's what happened in this the end super mario 64.
~ Good luck
R.I.P Luigi [1983 - 2024]
oh god no
The L is Real statue at the end though..
not major but one criticism i have is that if you used SMBX, then i feel like you shoulda ran with it, rather than making it still a hack or whatever
perhaps instead of a hack, maybe having it be some weird SMBX episode? i feel like that coulda worked and made the fact it's SMBX less jarring
The HD kill me
What was underneath the bridge at 5:01
Luigi
this was supposed to be creepy, not sad
No, it was supposed to be a joke.
@@theepic1944 awhhhh......
Ugh, eye strain warning please?
no entendi
why is the quality so bad bro :(
artistic choice!
lugi h8 u
It's amazing how this is even less accurate than the original romhack, this one doesn't even fucking use the noteblocks, items already in Super Mario World
It’s meant to be a re-imagining and a re-writing, not a remaster!
@@vinnaki no I mean it's even less accurate to Super Mario World, it looks like one of those old shitty flash remakes
You meant: you love the fact that this take is so unique, that it does not use SMW standarts such as items..?
Probablyy, I agree with you, aswell.
But.. I did not really pay attention to it, frankly speaking...
@@siinistar7953I hope you find a re-take of a romhack that fits your standards better, i’ll kindly accept the criticism and apply it for another mario video if I do it, hopefully you try being nice next time you criticize anything! ♡
it's amazing how pressed you are over another interpretation of a creepypasta romhack 😭
L is real 2401 = Luigi’s resurrection
its really cool did you used smbx to do it?