Flashbacks with lots of lightning, shovels, and graves excite me. The whole mystery-of-dead-girl-buried-alive is the reason I fell in love with the show, so when scenes like this appear, I'm so happy.
Here's my theory ,(and forgive my weak english) ali and spenc were fighting at the night disappeared and spenc was about to kill ali but ali toke control ! So spenc went to sleep like ali said ! At that time ali went to talk to toby and ll etc ! At that time i think mss D buried ali but she got out of it at night ! If u rememberr at the first episode spencer got up to find ali ! But she didn't means she didn't kill her ! Either with or without being under drugs affection she wouldn't say she couldn't find her if she already found her ! So if ali got out of the grave she would think it's batheny who tried to kill her so she's almost the one who tried to kill bethany with the same way she though bethany did ! And then mellissa sow her body and buried her :) If u understood my super stupid english that would make sense to u haha
Noah Khan Alison and Bethany were hitting on the head the same night, BUT in different places by the same person, that person who Mrs Dilaurentis saw... *we don't know who's that person, we believe is -A* Bethany was buried by Melissa while Alison was burried by Mrs. Dilaurentis.
I really loved this Melissa/Bethany twist. It was one of the few death scenes in PLL that I didn't see coming. You could see Sara Harvey's death coming, you could see Wilden's death coming. But when Melissa sat down and told Spencer how she killed Bethany, I was truly shocked.
You guys see where Melissa buried her right? The working area, in season 3 i think that's when we see a hand reaching up from the grave. When Ali told that her mom buried her she wasn't around the working area. You can also see that they were not around the working area when Charlotte tells what happend that night. Alison explained in season 4 episode 24 (?) it could have been just a mistake they could have gone along with right? But when Melissa tells that she buried Bethany it shows us the exact location where we saw a hand reaching up in season 3.
Years late but it’s just a continuity error. It was Alisons hand that was reaching out because in another episode we saw another hand reach out and grab them confirming it was Mrs Grunwald pulling her out.
If u look at "Bethanys" wrist she is wearing the bracelet that has Alison's name on it. you can clearly see the "ison' on the bracelet if u pause at the right time.
that part i never understood unless Alison knew Bethany and Alison and Bethany both did a switch a rew thing like CECE and Allison did ; wear each other clothes and everything. But still it doesn't make since because if Bethany was ESCAPING radley that night then how did she get the Alison bracelet on her?? The same clothes I get because Alison mom did the same thing with cece... but dang HOW MANY CHILDREN DOES MRS. D HAVE?
Bethany tries to kill Alison. Mrs D buries Alison' s body protecting Bethany. Cece kills Bethany for killing Alison. Melissa then buries Bethany's body protecting Spencer.
kevin Smith Bethany did not kill ali cece hit ali with a rock because she thought it was Bethany cece gets upset idk Bethany was on the floor Melissa hurried her alive Alison’s grandma comes to rosewood and sees ali hands ali comes out and then ali hid for 2 years nd that is the wierdest story I ever told
kevin Smith okay here is what really happens. CeCe hit Alison thinking it was Bethany. Then Mona kills bethany with a shovel because Mona thought is was Alison. Melissa then Buried Bethany because she thought spencer killed her.
Crazy Child Mrs Grunwald wasn't Ali's grandma; she was a woman with psychic powers that Ali had been seeing to try and find out who A was. On the night Ali/Bethany was killed, she felt a huge disturbance in Rosewood and drove there as fast as she could and rescued Alison.
Yes Mona hit Bethany and Melissa found her and burried her thinking that Spencer killed her, but she was alive.That way Melissa burried her alive and then she died.By Melissa.
+Tiffany Onwudinanti I get it now. Mona had knocked Bethany with the shovel thinking it was Allison (as she was thinking about all the hateful things Allison ever said to her) and then Melissa say the body and was fearful that it was Spencer who did it so she buried her. And Melissa then came to know that it was not Allison and she had buried a different girl alive as he does from suffocation
So from previous episodes we know that Bethany was hit on the head with the shovel (remember when the girls found it in the woods and and were taken in for questioning about killing Alison? A set them up to find the shovel and take the blame). Melissa only know that Bethany was still alive because the autopsy revealed that she suffocated to death. It is obvious that whoever hit Aliso on the head (Maybe Bethany herself) or Mrs. D (who was always buying Alison outfits) put Bethany in that outfit to possibly throw off the time of death for Ali. Or she was in the outfit for the same reason Cece was, Ali was using Bethany as a decoy so she could find out who A was. Maybe A hit Bethany by accident thinking it was Ali by mistake (either before of after Ali was hit) and was confused about who was who. The other possibility is that more than one person tried to hurt Ali that night (the girl did like to piss people off). I wouldn't be surprised if two different people wanted her dead
I like your theory/observations.. What I'm confused about is the timing of it all. If we're suppose to assume that Melissa went and saw Bethany 'dead' right after seeing her, then it was a good half and hour, possibly less, before Alison was allegedly hit and buried by her mom. But it that's the case, then Alison was buried on top of Bethany or something since they were both suppose to have been buried in the same spot.. Or, what I guess would make sense is that Melissa found Bethany later on that night after Alison had been pulled out... Maybe it's a mistake on the writer's end? Or am I missing something?
Pretty Little Liars i think someone was lying about what happen that night because remember in the first season of the video of ali and ian talking and how they fell and then kissed and left. but when ali told her story they didnt kiss and walk away. none of that happened. and she didnt mention things like how cece and melissa were talking together. cause she was up all night and didnt mention things that were said had happened
no, i think bethenany is still alive, u noticed that when ali spoke about being burried alive she ever said who got her out but i remember in the earlier season there was a hand that pulled someone out of the ground, ali and bethenany were wearing the same exact outfit,BETHENANY IS STILL ALIVE, but in the flashback when ali spoke about being buried alive totally DIFFERENT OUTFIT,and maybe cece is bethenany's twin alison's mom or spencer could have been the one 2 knock bethenany out b4 she got 2 alison or try 2 hurt her,cece or bethenany's twin could have saw this and decided 2 get revenge and return the favor by burring mrs.D alive just like they did bethenany and maybe that's what they meant by spencer u killed me but spencer just knocked her out and melissa burried her thinking that she was dead.....
This is why I love Melissa She’s messy, can definitely be mean, always moving shady and just an overall menace but she’s also Spencer’s big sister who literally buried a girl to protect her sister and never used this against her, she really did love Spencer this whole time This is the character writing I love even though this show is a hot mess
I think that Bethany got killed because of a game. I feel that there is more to it than just Melissa protecting Spencer.I think she got killed because of the NAT club, the club did like video taping everyone and pulling pranks maybe she was a part of the prank, maybe somebody dared someone to kill Alison, but they didn't know it wasn't Alison because Bethany was dressed exactly like her. I know this sounds dumb but the NAT club is connected because all of the NAT members are dead except Jason.
That wouldn't make sense becuz Mona wasn't apart of the NAT club and Melissa only buried her cuz she thought Spencer killed her Mona confessed of hitting Bethany but she wasn't dead she died from being buried alive by Melissa so yeah technically Melissa and Mona are the Killers
The soundtrack is so thrilling, i have heard the tune of 2:07 during all the "revelation" moments, looks like that is the main track of PLL :). I wish that the series score was available for download.
Let's break down this serie of events shall we? First, Mrs.D warns Ali not to go out after learning that someone got away (probably Bethany, so keep in mind that she's on her way to the house), then Spencer and Ali almost get into a fight but Spencer walks back to the barn with the shovel. Next thing you know Ali gets hit on the back of the head and Mrs.D burries her. BUT while Spencer was walking back to the barn (which takes like 2 seconds because they are neighbors) Melissa was hiding behind the bushes. HERE IS WHERE IT STARTS TO MAKE NO SENSE. Mrs. Grunwald appears out of no where and pulls Alison out of the ground. Then someone digs up the hole again and hit Bethany before Melissa gets there. AND DURING ALL THAT TIME MELISSA WAS ON HER WAY TO THE DILAURENTIS BACKYARD.
It isnt possi le because alison talked to arias dad right before she went back to the barn then she went home so melissa might be lying or the dire tors diddnt think this through, spencer dropped the shovel and went to the barn then melissa went to alis garden and saw bethany, but in 2 mins how could ali have spoken to ian, ezra toby and arias dad, she couldnt it doesnt make sense unless bethzny was burried first because someone thought she was alison but figured it wasnt then hit alison i am so confused ugh its been 2 seasons nearly, we want to know everything rhat happened that night
Ik the show is over and all but I was believing this but I jus found out that Bethany stole cece’s clothes and was planning on killing Mrs.D but Mona hit her thinking she was Ali
@@princessshug4808 Bethany’s importance is ridiculous considering we never even met the character. Her being a child and pushing toby’s mother does not count. I’m telling you now. CeCe was never the plan for A. These writers screwed up big time.
pause at 1:52 there's an A written with blood on bethany's head , bethany got pulled out from the grown just like Ali , Ali got pulled out by Mrs Grunwald , and in the flashback in the final of S3 Bethany was pulled out by someone who had red sleeves , either Mrs D or Spencer , but it looks a lot like Spencer's sleeve to me .
Looking back based on this scene? I'm guessing she told Ian what she did that night and his unhinged reaction was his way of protecting her. He robably thought that if he got rid of the Spencer problem, Melissa would be safe especially since Spencer didn't have any memories about the events of that night at that point.
Okay something is not adding up here. Melissa said she saw Spencer with the shovel. But according to Ali, that night when Spencer was chasing Ali from the barn, she then picked up the shovel, threatened Alison, dropped it and Ali found out she was taking drugs, then told Spencer to go back to the barn and sleep, Spencer was calm by then and did not have the shovel any more. So I don't get how Melissa could've seen what she did..?
I’m the kind of older sister like Melissa. I have a younger sister like Spencer who is pretty and talented in her own way, but she is abrasive and stuck up and is constantly following me around befriending my friends (even though she was 5 yrs younger), lowkey would take my personality and try to make it her own. But no matter how crazy or annoying she was to me, I will ALWAYS love and protect her over myself. Maybe it’s a sister thing or an older sibling thing but I would definitely do what Melissa did for my sister. Even though Spencer was trying to take both Ian and Wren from Melissa, she still protected her.
This is funny because even though Melissa kills Bethany we never got a scene of her actually talking or acting with any other character on the show. We should’ve had gotten Bethany & Mrs. D having an argument or something.
I think Melissa buried Cece... I mean there was a girl there that Jason saw as Cece and was wearing that outfit. Then Cece's twin may be pretending to be Cece so she can be A and get revenge on the liars for everything. Because Cece's twin most likely believes it was the liars who buried the real Cece. I'm sure Cece told her twin about the girls getting her kicked out of college. Now of course this is if they reveal Cece has a twin. Which Sasha P. has said that someone may have a twin multiple times...
nora-grace waters Bethany was still alive when Melissa buried her... Mona hit her yes but Melissa technically killed her since Bethany was still breathing when Melissa buried her alive... Melissa never checked for a pulse or looked at the person face because she said she was protecting Spencer because she saw Her with the shovel and Melissa thought Spencer killed the person Melissa buried
+Boston Marks After the finals, here is your answer: Charles is transgender, he asked Jessica (Ali's en Charles, Jason's mom) to buy him dresses. And every time she bought a outfit for Alison, she bought the same outfit for Charles. Charles had privileges to go out of Radley some time because he was studying at Upenn. Bethany found out that her dad had a affair with Mrs. DiLaurentis and she got crazy, she stole Charles her/his clothes and dressed up like him/her to get out of Radley. She went to the DiLaurentis house, got hit by Mona, and Melissa buried her. But Charles saw 'Bethany' at the DiLaurentis house and he was scared that she was gonna hurt her/his mom, so he picked up a rock and hit Bethany with it, but it was not Bethany who he hit: It was Alison. Alison and Bethany had the same shirt and clothes because originally it were Charles his/her clothes, but Bethany stole it --> Charles and Alison always have the same outfit
+RedCoatMo wow thanks for clearing that up. But wait so who did Jason see talking to Melissa that night? because as far as I remember he saw Melissa and cece talking but cece was wearing the yellow shirt too but in the final episode it's shown that cece was wearing a black hoodie and she says she never talked to melissa which is a lie because in an earlier episode she admits she talked to melissa that night. It doesn't add up.
That's the one thing i don't understand. it's one of the many plot holes from the finale. Marlene said that we MAYBE will get an answer for that, i hope so.
This scene and many others from season 5 make me wish the show had been allowed to end with the season 5 finale. The show was getting very dark and revealing long awaited secrets but then got renewed for two more full seasons! This caused season 5 to become mostly filler towards the end with season 6 being half completely useless filler and the other a brand new unrelated mystery.
I'm pretty sure that Bethany is alive, when Melissa told spencer that she buried Bethany "alive" ... It was the same spot that grunwald helped Alison from the same spot that Melissa buried Bethany... Bethany told grunwald that her name is Alison #maybe . Did you see Season 5 episode 13?!! " Jessica D. Moments " she gave Alison+Bethany the same outfits #always . That's explain why Bethany was wearing Ali's clothe the night Alison went messing. When Jessica D. Told Alison to not tell her father because he's gonna leave them if he finds out about the two yellow dresses. It means that Ali's father doesn't know that Jessica D. Has another daughter ' Bethany '. did you read that letter from Bethany that Hannah found in Ali's house... It says " I can't wait to meet you're friends.. Did you tell them that I'm coming to rosewood? And thank you so much for the clothes. Yellow is my favorite color " this letter explain why Ali's mom bought a 'yellow' dress.. Because it's Bethany's favorite color. She cares about Bethany more than Alison. Bethany was coming the night that Ali went messing 'Bethany's letter'.. She was wearing a yellow dress of course. Remember when Ali got a text from someone when she was in Ezra's car.. I believe it was Bethany ( that she's here in rosewood ) so Alison was afraid that bethany will take her spot.. she felt jealous because her mother love her more. so alison decided to kill her. Bethany hates Alison. That's why she decided to choose -A not -B... To Make it seems like Alison. When Alison got hit by rock her mother buried her and she said " what have you done. What have you done " < she was talking to Bethany... That's why she protected her and didn't tell anyway because Bethany is her daughter... And about that Alison doesn't do the dirty work #false ... Remember when Melissa's bf tried to kill spencer... Alison pushed him away #died . So yea... Oh and about Jessica D. When she told Alison "she's got a lot to show you... Pay attention" she meant -A aka: Bethany..( A is a girl ) I'm 100% sure I've watched season 1,2,3,4,5 more than once #OverAndOver Cece drake killed Mona, it's easy for her to kill someone like she did with detective W < "We don't just look alike, we think alike" ( lies are more interesting than the truth ) ... Alison lied about when Mona helped Ali to get better the night she got hit by rock and then she made Mona popular... Cause what really happened is that Mona told Hannah that she saw Alison spaying on someone and she gave Mona something to make her popular... ( Alison also can convince her self to believe things didn't happen ) ...& I don't know if she's A or not but I'm 100% sure that Bethany is alive and A is a girl. And about twins thingy... No they are not. Jessica D. Was having an affair with Bethany's father. Maybe they look alike ( same hair, same outfits ) but not twins. Jessica D. Always buys the same outfits for Alison and Bethany. Alison thought that Bethany is taking her spot because they were dressing the same outfits and stuff ... So that's why she tried to kill her ... There's an episode when Alison told Emily that she knows who A is remember?? "The rescue mission" > "Doctor S."... Anyways... Spencer and Mona found out about that tape when Bethany says "I don't know if I can trust anyone in that family... Is like mother like daughter" that's totally obvious that Alison and Bethany aren't twins. there is no such thing as twins.
***** that's where detective Holbrook comes into play. Have you seen the most recent episode? He's definitely hiding something, correct? Maybe he's hiding that he found "Bethany youngs body"!!!! He was the one who announced it right? I think that's why he's hiding. Dooesnt want to get caught. I don't think he's bad at all. He's been blackmailed, probably Bethany, to fake her death. Alison faked a death before, why not Bethany, who gets mistaken for Alison all the time! The 4 little liars are mistaking Bethany for being Alison, for being A, once again. Makes sense to me.
have anyone noticed that in 2:23 we see "spencer" behind the cameras? i'm not sure it's a clue of spencer's twin.. since i don't see anyone talking about this
To make it as simple as possible: Melissa saw Spencer with the shovel the night of Ali's disappearance after fighting with her, then she saw "Ali's" body so she thought Spencer killed Ali. She buried her in order to protect Spencer, only to find out she was ALIVE and not Ali at all, but Bethany Young. I believe she was telling the truth. We still have a lot of unanswered questions though, like who hit Ali, who hit Bethany (technically Melissa killed her by burying her alive but something made her unconscious) and who changed Bethany’s clothes to make her identical to Ali?
Cece hit Alison thinking it was Bethany and Mona Hit Bethany Thinking it was Alison what Doesn’t make sense is when Jason saw Cece wearing the same yellow top they were wearing while talking to Melissa
Okay, I've realized what Jason saw -- he saw Melissa burying Bethany, but because he was high (or drunk, can't remember), he hallucinated it as Melissa talking to someone wearing the same clothes as Bethany -- and he thought it was CeCe.
Weird Mona thought Bethany was Alison and hit her with a Rock then someone else barried her alive. CeCe thought Alison was Bethany and did the same and the same happened to Alison. Except Alison was found and was dug out and lived, Bethany wasn't found and died.
I'm gonna try to watch this "flashback" and what Alison said happened cause I don't remember Alison leaving before Spencer and how did they do the switch so fast
We did not see how fast Alison left the area, but what we saw was a little bit after the flashback in 4x24 ended, mere seconds, so Alison was out of sight for Melissa. What I don't understand is if Melissa buried the girl later or immediately because if she did it right away then Alison would've been basically buried on top of Bethany. Either Alison lied about where /who buried her, or there's an error in the story since both girls were buried in the same place.
The Events of that night are all messed up because this flashback indicated that Bethany was burried first because Alison got burried some times after the fight between Ali and Spencer....? makes no sense.
After the Mrs. Cavanaugh's terrible death where Bethany accused Cece of doing (Cece was still Charles back then before she became a trans), Cece really hated Bethany and called her "crazy bitch". One day Bethany found out her dad was making out with Cece's mom and Bethany who according to Cece suffered from " Intermittent Explosive Disorder" got mad then decided to dress on Cece's cloting, went out of Radley under Cece's out previlege (Cece had out previlege si ce she was studying at UPenn) to most likely hurt Cece's mom. Cece knew it, and thought she must save her mom. She saw a blonde girl, Cece hits her with a rock thinking it was Bethany, in order to protect her mom, but it was actually Alison. Mom saw it, then buried Ali alive, protecting Cece and all of her lies about Charles' fake death and alibis about Charles' existence to Jason. Mom then called Wilden to sent Cece away because it was just better for everyone. Then Mrs.Grunwald came to save Alison, driving her to the hospital but Ali ran away. In the other side, Mona saw "Ali", hit her with a rock, without knowing it was actually Bethany in Cece's clothing (we know that Cece and Ali were always bought the same outfit). Mona left then supposedly driving to the Resort, then in the way, she met Ali who was walking unconciously covered in dirt and blood on her head. In the same time, Melissa saw a body that she thought was Alison's then buried her in the very same hole where real Alison was buried, thinking she was protecting Spencer(before Alison's hitting, Melissa saw Spencer walking with a shovel after hearing Ali and Spence had an argument about something). Edit : OK I know this is literally what Melissa is explaining in the video and I have no idea why I wrote this thing 2 years ago 🤣🤣🤣
what i dont understand about alisons story is that she said in 424 that she got hit in the back of the head with that rock but then they show her with mona at the motel and its on the side of her face... so bethany was actually the one who got hit on the back of the head and whoever did that to her probably mistook her for alison, but my point is that whole "hit in the head with a rock" story that alison told the girls in 424 was a total lie
Yes I have noticed that and if Mona killed Bethany but why Melissa buried Bethany and maybe Melissa have something to do with Bethany murder and also Melissa killed Bethany that night and the shovel was right there. I know this for a fact that Melissa pick up the shovel to killed Bethany.
Yes but in the video the girl that Melissa buried had the same type of Head injury in the same exact spot that Alison did when she was hit with the rock
What I dont understand is why Spencer didnt bring this up during Ali's trial...we know from Alison's account that she remembers her mother burying her. If Spencer made the connection, and realized the girl Melissa buried and therefore accidentally killed was Bethany, why didnt she mention it? Why let Alison go to trial for Mona's murder? I mean, I get that Alison set her up to be arrested for Bethany's murder, but she had her sister's confession.
***** No, she was unconscious for the head wound. Not only was there blood on her head in this episode but if you remember back to the coroner's report (when they thought is was Ali) she was hit on the head with the same shovel the girls found in the woods and then burred and suffocated to death. They did an autopsy.
did anyone else noticed that when alison talked about being burried alive and bethenany aren't wearing the same outfit on the night she disappeared....
Extremely old comment (I was going back to old videos to remember the good parts of the series haha) but I wish that is what happened. Having the twin involved in the story from the beginning would have made the plot so much more interesting. Although there were a lot of clues in the seventh season for the audience to piece together that Spencer had a twin, revealing that Wren discovered Alex not too long ago made the story seem so forced.
@@nicolesantiago-fq7rk they didn’t know each other, all these years later I realize it makes sense for Cece to have an Alison bracelet because they used to wear each other’s personalities so i would think Cece had a Alison bracelet prepared and Bethany stole it along with the yellow top the night she was killed
Melissa buried her ALIVE,she mentioned it.Mona didn't kill her either,because hitting her with the shovel happened before this scene.I strongly think that Bethany is alive and Uber A.I also believe that Charlotte lied about Bethany killing Toby's mother..that's why the flashback doesn't make any sense.There were scenes where we saw Emily for example standing in front of an empty grave(Alison's-Bethany's actually) and also a scene where we could see a hand raising from the grave..and we know it wasn't Alison's,because she was helped by Mrs.Grunwald.Bethany must have killed Alison's mother..we know how much she hated her.
Mona hitting Bethany happened somewhere between Grunwald saving Ali and Melissa burying Bethany since Melissa found Bethany next to an already dug hole (where Mrs D buried Ali) and I don't think 3 people (Mrs D Charlotte and Grunwald) would've just ignored a dead body.
For everyone Who is confiusd rn The Girl that was found and everyone thought it was Ali (remembre s1-3) they found out she was hit with a shovel but died by beeing burried alive. So Mona hit bethany but mellissa burried her which killed her (Bethany!) Alison (looking same as Bethany) was also hit on the head and burried alive just that CeCe hit her and that Alison survived. But Mona wanted to kill Ali but almost killed Bethany and CeCe wanted to kill Bethany but almost killed Ali.
SO GUYS actually Bethany is alive...The hand we see reaching for someone in 3x13 and 3x24 happens to be in the same area as Bethany who's been buried by Melissa. So that night, 2 girls got rescued, Alison and Bethany. This could explain 7B spoilers saying that there are some things we don't know about that night. We're still supposed to believe that in 3x24 that was Grunwald pulling out Ali...
Beautiful Chaos True...I hope she's alive though, this would connect everything to 'That Night' and to the beginning of the show😕Cops may have been paid or something Idk
Quick question, was "17 year old Bethany Young" (as she is described by the cops in the 100th episode) 17 at the time of her death two years ago or would she be 17 now? I only ask because everyone thinks that she is one half of the infamous mystery twins but no one seems to be taking her age into account. For instance many think she is either Jason or Cece's twin but were they both in college at that time (18 or 19)? I know this because Cece was angry with Ali for getting her kicked out of college. Twins do have to be the same age after all (unless they are Irish twins).
I believe she was 17 at the time of the death, so she can not be Ali's twin, nor Cece or Jason's since they're both older than that. Honestly, I think Bethany is not blood related to any character, she just knew Mrs. D and other important people
Well one thing was that was only a small reveal compared to the rest of the episode so it wouldn't have been much use changing the story to that night then back to the Charlotte flashbacks. Not surprised that Mona was there that night.
ok but one thing..Melissa is 7 years older than Spencer, I mean she would've known/noticed her mom's pregnancy, or lack thereof, when she was 7 years old. She would've known Spencer was her half sister. Another plothole Marlene ?
i dont understand, melissa found the body there but who made the hole? when we see the flashback with ali, jenna and garet didnt have a hole there. If Jessica burried ali there like we saw, how can melissa burried this other girl in the same place? The person who killed the girl made the hole?
I understood it like this, they wanted to build something, that was the hole and then the thing with Ali happened, ms grunwald pulled her out and After that bethany was buried. it would make sense with the time i think..
Grunwald pulled Ali out of the grave which made the grave vacant. Since this whole scene (Melissa burying Bethany) happens after Ali being saved, it was the most obvious choice to bury her in there (since Bethany was injured right next to the grave and also she wanted to protect Spencer thinking that Bethany was Ali who she thought Spencer killed).
Why was Bethany Young (or the girl Melissa buried) wearing Alison' s bracelet?? you can see this at 1:52....Alison was also wearing that bracelet when her mum buried her too! They were both hit in to back of the head too. There will be a twist for sure!!
so was it Melissa who buried her ? who could have possibly killed alison? Jason? Cece? Mona? SPENCER? all these are options I think they thought she was dead and buried but she appeared to them after which is why they all became A. Maybe even Jenna? But then they realize it's Bethany? But where was Alison that night. Ian filmed in the afternoon.? Did Bethany really die? are they still alive and both of them are red coat? Why does Jason keep disappearing? How is Ezra or Wren A? where they after all this? WHO IS A? IS IT ARIA :O ? man so many questions was it Bethany that threw the rock or Jason? Do Alison and Bethany get buried at the same night? did she choose --A instead of --B to make them think it's Ali?
I guess we know what Melissa meant when she told Spencer she was protecting her since it started.
Jordacious definitely
A sh
True
Melissa's goodbye was like an A+ essay
+John shao Only a Hastings can give an award winning speech XD
lol true true
Id say -A
I honestly feel for Melissa I honestly feel like Melissa loved her sister
Flashbacks with lots of lightning, shovels, and graves excite me. The whole mystery-of-dead-girl-buried-alive is the reason I fell in love with the show, so when scenes like this appear, I'm so happy.
Same i love the flashbacks of the night ali went missing, so exciting! But i wonder who hit Bethany?
Noah Khan Not fully confirmed, but we're suppose to find out next week!
Here's my theory ,(and forgive my weak english) ali and spenc were fighting at the night disappeared and spenc was about to kill ali but ali toke control ! So spenc went to sleep like ali said ! At that time ali went to talk to toby and ll etc ! At that time i think mss D buried ali but she got out of it at night ! If u rememberr at the first episode spencer got up to find ali ! But she didn't means she didn't kill her ! Either with or without being under drugs affection she wouldn't say she couldn't find her if she already found her !
So if ali got out of the grave she would think it's batheny who tried to kill her so she's almost the one who tried to kill bethany with the same way she though bethany did !
And then mellissa sow her body and buried her :)
If u understood my super stupid english that would make sense to u haha
Noah Khan Alison and Bethany were hitting on the head the same night, BUT in different places by the same person, that person who Mrs Dilaurentis saw... *we don't know who's that person, we believe is -A* Bethany was buried by Melissa while Alison was burried by Mrs. Dilaurentis.
***** that's right.... Alison is alive but Bethany is dead.
I actually felt bad for Melissa here this is how I wanted their relationship to be
I really loved this Melissa/Bethany twist. It was one of the few death scenes in PLL that I didn't see coming. You could see Sara Harvey's death coming, you could see Wilden's death coming. But when Melissa sat down and told Spencer how she killed Bethany, I was truly shocked.
My favorite scene from the entire series... the acting is phenomenal
You guys see where Melissa buried her right? The working area, in season 3 i think that's when we see a hand reaching up from the grave. When Ali told that her mom buried her she wasn't around the working area. You can also see that they were not around the working area when Charlotte tells what happend that night.
Alison explained in season 4 episode 24 (?) it could have been just a mistake they could have gone along with right? But when Melissa tells that she buried Bethany it shows us the exact location where we saw a hand reaching up in season 3.
That's what I tought too omg!
Prath Andres hey
I thought that as well
I thought the same thing. Same place.....mistake
Years late but it’s just a continuity error. It was Alisons hand that was reaching out because in another episode we saw another hand reach out and grab them confirming it was Mrs Grunwald pulling her out.
If u look at "Bethanys" wrist she is wearing the bracelet that has Alison's name on it. you can clearly see the "ison' on the bracelet if u pause at the right time.
elsa !!!!!!!!!!!!! OMG
fizza i Maybe she faked it because she wanna look like Ali
Where?
that part i never understood unless Alison knew Bethany and Alison and Bethany both did a switch a rew thing like CECE and Allison did ; wear each other clothes and everything. But still it doesn't make since because if Bethany was ESCAPING radley that night then how did she get the Alison bracelet on her?? The same clothes I get because Alison mom did the same thing with cece... but dang HOW MANY CHILDREN DOES MRS. D HAVE?
@@farahhjackson1018 bethany took ceces clothes
Bethany tries to kill Alison. Mrs D buries Alison' s body protecting Bethany. Cece kills Bethany for killing Alison. Melissa then buries Bethany's body protecting Spencer.
kevin Smith Bethany did not kill ali cece hit ali with a rock because she thought it was Bethany cece gets upset idk Bethany was on the floor Melissa hurried her alive Alison’s grandma comes to rosewood and sees ali hands ali comes out and then ali hid for 2 years nd that is the wierdest story I ever told
kevin Smith okay here is what really happens. CeCe hit Alison thinking it was Bethany. Then Mona kills bethany with a shovel because Mona thought is was Alison. Melissa then Buried Bethany because she thought spencer killed her.
Crazy Child Mrs Grunwald wasn't Ali's grandma; she was a woman with psychic powers that Ali had been seeing to try and find out who A was. On the night Ali/Bethany was killed, she felt a huge disturbance in Rosewood and drove there as fast as she could and rescued Alison.
Ok I’m so confused help
Mona killed Alison
Best scene ever! I just love it...
I thought Mona killed Bethany. In 6x10 Mona she confessed...
Yes Mona hit Bethany and Melissa found her and burried her thinking that Spencer killed her, but she was alive.That way Melissa burried her alive and then she died.By Melissa.
ohhhh thanks sooo much for the clarification ;)
+Tiffany Onwudinanti exactly I am confused too. Who killed Bethany Mona or spencer because they both confessed
+Tiffany Onwudinanti I get it now. Mona had knocked Bethany with the shovel thinking it was Allison (as she was thinking about all the hateful things Allison ever said to her) and then Melissa say the body and was fearful that it was Spencer who did it so she buried her. And Melissa then came to know that it was not Allison and she had buried a different girl alive as he does from suffocation
+Elizabeth Lizzy Mona said that she killed Bethany because she didn't know that Bethany was still alive after she attacked her
So from previous episodes we know that Bethany was hit on the head with the shovel (remember when the girls found it in the woods and and were taken in for questioning about killing Alison? A set them up to find the shovel and take the blame). Melissa only know that Bethany was still alive because the autopsy revealed that she suffocated to death. It is obvious that whoever hit Aliso on the head (Maybe Bethany herself) or Mrs. D (who was always buying Alison outfits) put Bethany in that outfit to possibly throw off the time of death for Ali. Or she was in the outfit for the same reason Cece was, Ali was using Bethany as a decoy so she could find out who A was. Maybe A hit Bethany by accident thinking it was Ali by mistake (either before of after Ali was hit) and was confused about who was who. The other possibility is that more than one person tried to hurt Ali that night (the girl did like to piss people off). I wouldn't be surprised if two different people wanted her dead
I like your theory/observations.. What I'm confused about is the timing of it all. If we're suppose to assume that Melissa went and saw Bethany 'dead' right after seeing her, then it was a good half and hour, possibly less, before Alison was allegedly hit and buried by her mom. But it that's the case, then Alison was buried on top of Bethany or something since they were both suppose to have been buried in the same spot.. Or, what I guess would make sense is that Melissa found Bethany later on that night after Alison had been pulled out... Maybe it's a mistake on the writer's end? Or am I missing something?
Pretty Little Liars i think someone was lying about what happen that night because remember in the first season of the video of ali and ian talking and how they fell and then kissed and left. but when ali told her story they didnt kiss and walk away. none of that happened. and she didnt mention things like how cece and melissa were talking together. cause she was up all night and didnt mention things that were said had happened
no, i think bethenany is still alive, u noticed that when ali spoke about being burried alive she ever said who got her out but i remember in the earlier season there was a hand that pulled someone out of the ground, ali and bethenany were wearing the same exact outfit,BETHENANY IS STILL ALIVE, but in the flashback when ali spoke about being buried alive totally DIFFERENT OUTFIT,and maybe cece is bethenany's twin alison's mom or spencer could have been the one 2 knock bethenany out b4 she got 2 alison or try 2 hurt her,cece or bethenany's twin could have saw this and decided 2 get revenge and return the favor by burring mrs.D alive just like they did bethenany and maybe that's what they meant by spencer u killed me but spencer just knocked her out and melissa burried her thinking that she was dead.....
janderson947 hey
natalie jones CeCe hit Alison over the head and Alison's mum buted Alison and then that old women pulled Ali out of the ground
Anyone else notice that "Bethany" is wearing a bracelet that clearly says "Alison". You can only see the "ison" part though.
This is why I love Melissa
She’s messy, can definitely be mean, always moving shady and just an overall menace but she’s also Spencer’s big sister who literally buried a girl to protect her sister and never used this against her, she really did love Spencer this whole time
This is the character writing I love even though this show is a hot mess
At least Melissa was honest and she told the truth about what happened that night to Bethany,
I think that Bethany got killed because of a game. I feel that there is more to it than just Melissa protecting Spencer.I think she got killed because of the NAT club, the club did like video taping everyone and pulling pranks maybe she was a part of the prank, maybe somebody dared someone to kill Alison, but they didn't know it wasn't Alison because Bethany was dressed exactly like her. I know this sounds dumb but the NAT club is connected because all of the NAT members are dead except Jason.
That wouldn't make sense becuz Mona wasn't apart of the NAT club and Melissa only buried her cuz she thought Spencer killed her Mona confessed of hitting Bethany but she wasn't dead she died from being buried alive by Melissa so yeah technically Melissa and Mona are the Killers
Destiny Loando But Everyone hated Alison,And Many people would’ve wanted to kill her.It could’ve been Nat And A Trying to kill her
The soundtrack is so thrilling, i have heard the tune of 2:07 during all the "revelation" moments, looks like that is the main track of PLL :). I wish that the series score was available for download.
this made me cry
Let's break down this serie of events shall we? First, Mrs.D warns Ali not to go out after learning that someone got away (probably Bethany, so keep in mind that she's on her way to the house), then Spencer and Ali almost get into a fight but Spencer walks back to the barn with the shovel. Next thing you know Ali gets hit on the back of the head and Mrs.D burries her. BUT while Spencer was walking back to the barn (which takes like 2 seconds because they are neighbors) Melissa was hiding behind the bushes. HERE IS WHERE IT STARTS TO MAKE NO SENSE. Mrs. Grunwald appears out of no where and pulls Alison out of the ground. Then someone digs up the hole again and hit Bethany before Melissa gets there. AND DURING ALL THAT TIME MELISSA WAS ON HER WAY TO THE DILAURENTIS BACKYARD.
It isnt possi le because alison talked to arias dad right before she went back to the barn then she went home so melissa might be lying or the dire tors diddnt think this through, spencer dropped the shovel and went to the barn then melissa went to alis garden and saw bethany, but in 2 mins how could ali have spoken to ian, ezra toby and arias dad, she couldnt it doesnt make sense unless bethzny was burried first because someone thought she was alison but figured it wasnt then hit alison i am so confused ugh its been 2 seasons nearly, we want to know everything rhat happened that night
This night is way to complicated. I don't even remember everything that happened.
Ik the show is over and all but I was believing this but I jus found out that Bethany stole cece’s clothes and was planning on killing Mrs.D but Mona hit her thinking she was Ali
@@princessshug4808 Bethany’s importance is ridiculous considering we never even met the character. Her being a child and pushing toby’s mother does not count. I’m telling you now. CeCe was never the plan for A. These writers screwed up big time.
you guys are so good at doing these movies
pause at 1:52 there's an A written with blood on bethany's head , bethany got pulled out from the grown just like Ali , Ali got pulled out by Mrs Grunwald , and in the flashback in the final of S3 Bethany was pulled out by someone who had red sleeves , either Mrs D or Spencer , but it looks a lot like Spencer's sleeve to me .
Wow your right
Polo De Mg no cause then she would have seen that is was Bethany and not Ali
what does is say?
maria benzaoual yeah
The workers found Bethany’s body remember?
This scene is so sad. I actually feel sorry for Melissa.
Looking back based on this scene? I'm guessing she told Ian what she did that night and his unhinged reaction was his way of protecting her. He robably thought that if he got rid of the Spencer problem, Melissa would be safe especially since Spencer didn't have any memories about the events of that night at that point.
Okay something is not adding up here.
Melissa said she saw Spencer with the shovel. But according to Ali, that night when Spencer was chasing Ali from the barn, she then picked up the shovel, threatened Alison, dropped it and Ali found out she was taking drugs, then told Spencer to go back to the barn and sleep, Spencer was calm by then and did not have the shovel any more.
So I don't get how Melissa could've seen what she did..?
Melissa is perfect
not bcs she killed her but like her face her voice her style omg melissa hastings is goals
Mausefell no she not died!
saaaame she is an amazing character and actress
I’m the kind of older sister like Melissa. I have a younger sister like Spencer who is pretty and talented in her own way, but she is abrasive and stuck up and is constantly following me around befriending my friends (even though she was 5 yrs younger), lowkey would take my personality and try to make it her own. But no matter how crazy or annoying she was to me, I will ALWAYS love and protect her over myself. Maybe it’s a sister thing or an older sibling thing but I would definitely do what Melissa did for my sister. Even though Spencer was trying to take both Ian and Wren from Melissa, she still protected her.
This is funny because even though Melissa kills Bethany we never got a scene of her actually talking or acting with any other character on the show. We should’ve had gotten Bethany & Mrs. D having an argument or something.
I think Melissa buried Cece... I mean there was a girl there that Jason saw as Cece and was wearing that outfit. Then Cece's twin may be pretending to be Cece so she can be A and get revenge on the liars for everything. Because Cece's twin most likely believes it was the liars who buried the real Cece. I'm sure Cece told her twin about the girls getting her kicked out of college. Now of course this is if they reveal Cece has a twin. Which Sasha P. has said that someone may have a twin multiple times...
it is Bethany body but melissa was talking to her when Jason think it was cece who he saw he met saw Bethany talking to melissa
Great job Maya 👍👌
Upload the sneak peak for 5x12, upload all of them especially the first 1.
This is one of the only good moments post-season 4
I just noticed. If you look at Bethany’s body when Melissa is burying her, she has completely different pants then Alison’s.
Jesus Christ! Melissa just buried Bethany! Mona killed her!
nora-grace waters but she was alive after Mona hit her, Melissa thought she was dead and buried her, ultimately killing Bethany for real
nora-grace waters hey
nora-grace waters Bethany was still alive when Melissa buried her... Mona hit her yes but Melissa technically killed her since Bethany was still breathing when Melissa buried her alive... Melissa never checked for a pulse or looked at the person face because she said she was protecting Spencer because she saw Her with the shovel and Melissa thought Spencer killed the person Melissa buried
shooketh teaspiller iluyow
Melissa killed her be Melissa buried her after Mona hit her, Bethany lived the hit but died of suffocation after being buri
Poor Spencer Meslisa knew that Spencer had been arrested more than once and she should have said truth then
Can someone explain why Ali and Bethany were wearing the same shirt??
***** who tf is Sarah Harvey
all of those ^^^ are just theories, no one knows yet
+Boston Marks After the finals, here is your answer:
Charles is transgender, he asked Jessica (Ali's en Charles, Jason's mom) to buy him dresses. And every time she bought a outfit for Alison, she bought the same outfit for Charles. Charles had privileges to go out of Radley some time because he was studying at Upenn. Bethany found out that her dad had a affair with Mrs. DiLaurentis and she got crazy, she stole Charles her/his clothes and dressed up like him/her to get out of Radley. She went to the DiLaurentis house, got hit by Mona, and Melissa buried her. But Charles saw 'Bethany' at the DiLaurentis house and he was scared that she was gonna hurt her/his mom, so he picked up a rock and hit Bethany with it, but it was not Bethany who he hit: It was Alison. Alison and Bethany had the same shirt and clothes because originally it were Charles his/her clothes, but Bethany stole it --> Charles and Alison always have the same outfit
+RedCoatMo wow thanks for clearing that up. But wait so who did Jason see talking to Melissa that night? because as far as I remember he saw Melissa and cece talking but cece was wearing the yellow shirt too but in the final episode it's shown that cece was wearing a black hoodie and she says she never talked to melissa which is a lie because in an earlier episode she admits she talked to melissa that night. It doesn't add up.
That's the one thing i don't understand. it's one of the many plot holes from the finale. Marlene said that we MAYBE will get an answer for that, i hope so.
this breaks my heart omfg
hey she has bracelet!!!! and there's a name check this.... ALISON
This scene and many others from season 5 make me wish the show had been allowed to end with the season 5 finale. The show was getting very dark and revealing long awaited secrets but then got renewed for two more full seasons! This caused season 5 to become mostly filler towards the end with season 6 being half completely useless filler and the other a brand new unrelated mystery.
I'm pretty sure that Bethany is alive, when Melissa told spencer that she buried Bethany "alive" ... It was the same spot that grunwald helped Alison from the same spot that Melissa buried Bethany... Bethany told grunwald that her name is Alison #maybe . Did you see Season 5 episode 13?!! " Jessica D. Moments " she gave Alison+Bethany the same outfits #always . That's explain why Bethany was wearing Ali's clothe the night Alison went messing. When Jessica D. Told Alison to not tell her father because he's gonna leave them if he finds out about the two yellow dresses. It means that Ali's father doesn't know that Jessica D. Has another daughter ' Bethany '. did you read that letter from Bethany that Hannah found in Ali's house... It says " I can't wait to meet you're friends.. Did you tell them that I'm coming to rosewood? And thank you so much for the clothes. Yellow is my favorite color " this letter explain why Ali's mom bought a 'yellow' dress.. Because it's Bethany's favorite color. She cares about Bethany more than Alison. Bethany was coming the night that Ali went messing 'Bethany's letter'.. She was wearing a yellow dress of course. Remember when Ali got a text from someone when she was in Ezra's car.. I believe it was Bethany ( that she's here in rosewood ) so Alison was afraid that bethany will take her spot.. she felt jealous because her mother love her more. so alison decided to kill her. Bethany hates Alison. That's why she decided to choose -A not -B... To Make it seems like Alison. When Alison got hit by rock her mother buried her and she said " what have you done. What have you done " < she was talking to Bethany... That's why she protected her and didn't tell anyway because Bethany is her daughter... And about that Alison doesn't do the dirty work #false ... Remember when Melissa's bf tried to kill spencer... Alison pushed him away #died . So yea... Oh and about Jessica D. When she told Alison "she's got a lot to show you... Pay attention" she meant -A aka: Bethany..( A is a girl ) I'm 100% sure I've watched season 1,2,3,4,5 more than once #OverAndOver Cece drake killed Mona, it's easy for her to kill someone like she did with detective W < "We don't just look alike, we think alike"
( lies are more interesting than the truth ) ... Alison lied about when Mona helped Ali to get better the night she got hit by rock and then she made Mona popular... Cause what really happened is that Mona told Hannah that she saw Alison spaying on someone and she gave Mona something to make her popular... ( Alison also can convince her self to believe things didn't happen ) ...& I don't know if she's A or not but I'm 100% sure that Bethany is alive and A is a girl. And about twins thingy... No they are not. Jessica D. Was having an affair with Bethany's father. Maybe they look alike ( same hair, same outfits ) but not twins. Jessica D. Always buys the same outfits for Alison and Bethany. Alison thought that Bethany is taking her spot because they were dressing the same outfits and stuff ... So that's why she tried to kill her ... There's an episode when Alison told Emily that she knows who A is remember?? "The rescue mission" > "Doctor S."... Anyways... Spencer and Mona found out about that tape when Bethany says "I don't know if I can trust anyone in that family... Is like mother like daughter" that's totally obvious that Alison and Bethany aren't twins. there is no such thing as twins.
Maybe Bethany died and then someone might have taken her body. If this is inaccurate, I'm not an expert theorist
***** that's where detective Holbrook comes into play. Have you seen the most recent episode? He's definitely hiding something, correct? Maybe he's hiding that he found "Bethany youngs body"!!!! He was the one who announced it right? I think that's why he's hiding. Dooesnt want to get caught. I don't think he's bad at all. He's been blackmailed, probably Bethany, to fake her death. Alison faked a death before, why not Bethany, who gets mistaken for Alison all the time! The 4 little liars are mistaking Bethany for being Alison, for being A, once again. Makes sense to me.
Little Black Star hey
have anyone noticed that in 2:23 we see "spencer" behind the cameras? i'm not sure it's a clue of spencer's twin.. since i don't see anyone talking about this
I think it's meant to look like Spencer was right there and Melissa was saying it to her maybe not but that's what I think at least
Now we know why I think in the season 7 intro, Alison is by the casket, cause the one that really died was Bethany
but this scene was so sad :'(
To make it as simple as possible: Melissa saw Spencer with the shovel the night of Ali's disappearance after fighting with her, then she saw "Ali's" body so she thought Spencer killed Ali. She buried her in order to protect Spencer, only to find out she was ALIVE and not Ali at all, but Bethany Young. I believe she was telling the truth. We still have a lot of unanswered questions though, like who hit Ali, who hit Bethany (technically Melissa killed her by burying her alive but something made her unconscious) and who changed Bethany’s clothes to make her identical to Ali?
Cece hit Alison thinking it was Bethany and Mona Hit Bethany Thinking it was Alison what Doesn’t make sense is when Jason saw Cece wearing the same yellow top they were wearing while talking to Melissa
@@luisherrera7078 Jason was hallucinating, what he thought he saw didn't happen.
Okay, I've realized what Jason saw -- he saw Melissa burying Bethany, but because he was high (or drunk, can't remember), he hallucinated it as Melissa talking to someone wearing the same clothes as Bethany -- and he thought it was CeCe.
Weird Mona thought Bethany was Alison and hit her with a Rock then someone else barried her alive. CeCe thought Alison was Bethany and did the same and the same happened to Alison. Except Alison was found and was dug out and lived, Bethany wasn't found and died.
I love pretty little liars #pLLsqaud
Those poor girls😞😢😔😕💔😪
Actually she didn't kill her.She just buried her,after she was dead
What ep??
I'm gonna try to watch this "flashback" and what Alison said happened cause I don't remember Alison leaving before Spencer and how did they do the switch so fast
We did not see how fast Alison left the area, but what we saw was a little bit after the flashback in 4x24 ended, mere seconds, so Alison was out of sight for Melissa. What I don't understand is if Melissa buried the girl later or immediately because if she did it right away then Alison would've been basically buried on top of Bethany. Either Alison lied about where /who buried her, or there's an error in the story since both girls were buried in the same place.
Pretty Little Liars exactly! something doesn't add up..
The Events of that night are all messed up because this flashback indicated that Bethany was burried first because Alison got burried some times after the fight between Ali and Spencer....? makes no sense.
Maybe Melissa saw the fight and then came back later after Alison escaped and thats why there was that hole
Maybe..
Meliss was actually a really good sister
I cried :(
After the Mrs. Cavanaugh's terrible death where Bethany accused Cece of doing (Cece was still Charles back then before she became a trans), Cece really hated Bethany and called her "crazy bitch".
One day Bethany found out her dad was making out with Cece's mom and Bethany who according to Cece suffered from " Intermittent Explosive Disorder" got mad then decided to dress on Cece's cloting, went out of Radley under Cece's out previlege (Cece had out previlege si ce she was studying at UPenn) to most likely hurt Cece's mom.
Cece knew it, and thought she must save her mom. She saw a blonde girl, Cece hits her with a rock thinking it was Bethany, in order to protect her mom, but it was actually Alison. Mom saw it, then buried Ali alive, protecting Cece and all of her lies about Charles' fake death and alibis about Charles' existence to Jason. Mom then called Wilden to sent Cece away because it was just better for everyone.
Then Mrs.Grunwald came to save Alison, driving her to the hospital but Ali ran away.
In the other side, Mona saw "Ali", hit her with a rock, without knowing it was actually Bethany in Cece's clothing (we know that Cece and Ali were always bought the same outfit). Mona left then supposedly driving to the Resort, then in the way, she met Ali who was walking unconciously covered in dirt and blood on her head. In the same time, Melissa saw a body that she thought was Alison's then buried her in the very same hole where real Alison was buried, thinking she was protecting Spencer(before Alison's hitting, Melissa saw Spencer walking with a shovel after hearing Ali and Spence had an argument about something).
Edit : OK I know this is literally what Melissa is explaining in the video and I have no idea why I wrote this thing 2 years ago 🤣🤣🤣
Melissa being A would’ve been the only way to tie the show up with no potholes, but they refused to give us the that for whatever reason.
I think it would’ve been slightly predictable but it makes a lot of sense
Time goes by song should be in the show 🎵🎶😪❤🙌✨😌
Spencer's sister Melissa Hastings she just buried Alison underground.
I Can't Wait 2 Find Everything Out.. :D
what i dont understand about alisons story is that she said in 424 that she got hit in the back of the head with that rock but then they show her with mona at the motel and its on the side of her face... so bethany was actually the one who got hit on the back of the head and whoever did that to her probably mistook her for alison, but my point is that whole "hit in the head with a rock" story that alison told the girls in 424 was a total lie
PLL 5X11
that's not Spenser carring the shovel if you watch the first episode you can see Spencer is wearing a plad shirt
So Allison and Spencer are relatively?
People saying this is sister love when talking about a murder…yall weirdos
Exactly
Melissa buried ( Bethany Young ) alive she finally confessed to Spencer
does anyone know where i can find the written copy of this monolouge i really need it
did no one notice that when the camera focuses on the girl Melissa buries' head her bracelet says alison?
watch the video in hd, it doesn't clearly say Alison but it definetly finishes in "ison"
Yes I have noticed that and if Mona killed Bethany but why Melissa buried Bethany and maybe Melissa have something to do with Bethany murder and also Melissa killed Bethany that night and the shovel was right there. I know this for a fact that Melissa pick up the shovel to killed Bethany.
WAIT if beth was alive when melissa buried her, then mona just hit her. it was mellisa that killed bethany. right?
Yep Melissa accidentally murdered Bethany young. Its funny how things come around, Bethany murders someone and then she was murdered.
it would probably be considered manslaughter
everyone knows cece drake Is A and she thought she killed alison and even think about she did the same thing bethany young
Mona killed Bethany
Yes but in the video the girl that Melissa buried had the same type of Head injury in the same exact spot that Alison did when she was hit with the rock
What I dont understand is why Spencer didnt bring this up during Ali's trial...we know from Alison's account that she remembers her mother burying her. If Spencer made the connection, and realized the girl Melissa buried and therefore accidentally killed was Bethany, why didnt she mention it? Why let Alison go to trial for Mona's murder? I mean, I get that Alison set her up to be arrested for Bethany's murder, but she had her sister's confession.
How would Melissa burying Bethany help in Alison’s case
The thing is Alison never set Spencer up for murder. That was cece
i strongly believe that spencer has a twin that killed bethany
***** No, she was unconscious for the head wound. Not only was there blood on her head in this episode but if you remember back to the coroner's report (when they thought is was Ali) she was hit on the head with the same shovel the girls found in the woods and then burred and suffocated to death. They did an autopsy.
***** no, Melissa thought she was dead until the body was found and the autopsy revealed she suffocated to death
did anyone else noticed that when alison talked about being burried alive and bethenany aren't wearing the same outfit on the night she disappeared....
Extremely old comment (I was going back to old videos to remember the good parts of the series haha) but I wish that is what happened. Having the twin involved in the story from the beginning would have made the plot so much more interesting. Although there were a lot of clues in the seventh season for the audience to piece together that Spencer had a twin, revealing that Wren discovered Alex not too long ago made the story seem so forced.
You was partly right
Both Ali & Bethanny would've died if Ali wasn't pulled out of the dirt.
What was mia saying in the first letter
I wish Alison ce ce drake charles jason melissa and Spencer had more scenes together❤😢😍😔😫😭
Spencer she use shovel hit Alison back her head
I swear this scene ended with Spencer crying and saying “goodbye Melissa” before it went to commercial.
How did Bethany get a Alison bracelet on her? I'm sure Cece didn't have one.
That's a good question. Bethany and Alison knew each other and that's why Bethany gave Alison the bracelet of her name.
@@nicolesantiago-fq7rk they didn’t know each other, all these years later I realize it makes sense for Cece to have an Alison bracelet because they used to wear each other’s personalities so i would think Cece had a Alison bracelet prepared and Bethany stole it along with the yellow top the night she was killed
Melissa buried her ALIVE,she mentioned it.Mona didn't kill her either,because hitting her with the shovel happened before this scene.I strongly think that Bethany is alive and Uber A.I also believe that Charlotte lied about Bethany killing Toby's mother..that's why the flashback doesn't make any sense.There were scenes where we saw Emily for example standing in front of an empty grave(Alison's-Bethany's actually) and also a scene where we could see a hand raising from the grave..and we know it wasn't Alison's,because she was helped by Mrs.Grunwald.Bethany must have killed Alison's mother..we know how much she hated her.
Mona hitting Bethany happened somewhere between Grunwald saving Ali and Melissa burying Bethany since Melissa found Bethany next to an already dug hole (where Mrs D buried Ali) and I don't think 3 people (Mrs D Charlotte and Grunwald) would've just ignored a dead body.
Alison try to stop Spencer
For everyone Who is confiusd rn
The Girl that was found and everyone thought it was Ali (remembre s1-3) they found out she was hit with a shovel but died by beeing burried alive. So Mona hit bethany but mellissa burried her which killed her (Bethany!)
Alison (looking same as Bethany) was also hit on the head and burried alive just that CeCe hit her and that Alison survived. But Mona wanted to kill Ali but almost killed Bethany and CeCe wanted to kill Bethany but almost killed Ali.
SO GUYS actually Bethany is alive...The hand we see reaching for someone in 3x13 and 3x24 happens to be in the same area as Bethany who's been buried by Melissa. So that night, 2 girls got rescued, Alison and Bethany. This could explain 7B spoilers saying that there are some things we don't know about that night. We're still supposed to believe that in 3x24 that was Grunwald pulling out Ali...
Magda Fenty I think that may be a mistake the writers made. I mean they still found the body and it was proven to be Bethany's.
Beautiful Chaos True...I hope she's alive though, this would connect everything to 'That Night' and to the beginning of the show😕Cops may have been paid or something Idk
Magda Fenty Yea probably
Quick question, was "17 year old Bethany Young" (as she is described by the cops in the 100th episode) 17 at the time of her death two years ago or would she be 17 now? I only ask because everyone thinks that she is one half of the infamous mystery twins but no one seems to be taking her age into account. For instance many think she is either Jason or Cece's twin but were they both in college at that time (18 or 19)? I know this because Cece was angry with Ali for getting her kicked out of college. Twins do have to be the same age after all (unless they are Irish twins).
I believe she was 17 at the time of the death, so she can not be Ali's twin, nor Cece or Jason's since they're both older than that. Honestly, I think Bethany is not blood related to any character, she just knew Mrs. D and other important people
why did we never saw a flashback of Mona that night ?? I'm not sure she was really here ..
Well one thing was that was only a small reveal compared to the rest of the episode so it wouldn't have been much use changing the story to that night then back to the Charlotte flashbacks. Not surprised that Mona was there that night.
relly good
ok but one thing..Melissa is 7 years older than Spencer, I mean she would've known/noticed her mom's pregnancy, or lack thereof, when she was 7 years old. She would've known Spencer was her half sister. Another plothole Marlene ?
if you look at bethany from up close you will see that the bracelet says "ison" wich is obviosly alison.
so idk if thats bethany
It wasn't Spencer, it was actually her twin
How???????????
How was alison buried there if there was someone already?
Pretty Little Liars
🙏✌maya
if this is 100% true then Ali's story doesn't completely add up to me...but no surprise there...
does anyone see what it says on the blonde girls, seeming to be bethanny young atm, bracelet says????
OMG!!!!!!
What part do you see the bracelet
i dont understand, melissa found the body there but who made the hole? when we see the flashback with ali, jenna and garet didnt have a hole there. If Jessica burried ali there like we saw, how can melissa burried this other girl in the same place? The person who killed the girl made the hole?
I understood it like this, they wanted to build something, that was the hole and then the thing with Ali happened, ms grunwald pulled her out and After that bethany was buried. it would make sense with the time i think..
Grunwald pulled Ali out of the grave which made the grave vacant. Since this whole scene (Melissa burying Bethany) happens after Ali being saved, it was the most obvious choice to bury her in there (since Bethany was injured right next to the grave and also she wanted to protect Spencer thinking that Bethany was Ali who she thought Spencer killed).
Why was Bethany Young (or the girl Melissa buried) wearing Alison' s bracelet?? you can see this at 1:52....Alison was also wearing that bracelet when her mum buried her too! They were both hit in to back of the head too. There will be a twist for sure!!
I mean I am so confused
Does anyone know the exact words Melissa whispered in her fathers ear lol
so was it Melissa who buried her ?
who could have possibly killed alison? Jason? Cece? Mona? SPENCER? all these are options I think they thought she was dead and buried but she appeared to them after which is why they all became A. Maybe even Jenna? But then they realize it's Bethany? But where was Alison that night. Ian filmed in the afternoon.? Did Bethany really die? are they still alive and both of them are red coat? Why does Jason keep disappearing? How is Ezra or Wren A? where they after all this? WHO IS A? IS IT ARIA :O ? man so many questions was it Bethany that threw the rock or Jason? Do Alison and Bethany get buried at the same night? did she choose --A instead of --B to make them think it's Ali?
hola a todos