What's up with her? So far I know she only released 3 albums more than 20 years ago, but still was on tour in 2017. I haven't listened to her for some years and didn't know this concert. It's overwhelming.
I remember another extraordinary female singer from Canada, who more or less disappeared after few albums and years, about 30 years ago: Lisa Dalbello.
Omg...I thought she might dodge that final big note, thinking maybe she'd lost some of her range in the 20+ years since recording the song, but no, she took it to another level, belting it out longer and stronger! I'm blown away!
Power House does not do her justice...so happy to nave seen her perform recently in Winnipeg...she blew the roof off and we wanted more...hope she continues touring
NO COMMENTS????? THIS IS ONE OF THE MOST INCREDIBLE VOCAL PERFORMANCES OF ALL TIME ALONG WITH HEART AT THE KENNEDY CENTER DOING THE RIFF THAT SHALL NOT BE PLAYED.
Imagine if Amanda appeared on American Idol in 2017 singing that song showing her terrific talent & pipes. The judges & audience would have been blown away.
I was obsessed with this song. The ending is fire!! She is powerhouse singer. It’s the timing she holds those notes then cuts them off, just to bring one in right behind it, just as strong. Let’s not forget to mention that hair!
I have seen Amanda Marshall 3 times now. One in 1997 at the NAC, this one in 2017 at City Folk and 2 days ago with her Heavy Lifting Tour at the NAC. She is an absolutely amazing singer and I can never get tired of listening to her music!
That Amanda Marshall is dipping her toe into performing again is spectacular news. This song starts with a languid soulfulness and goes into orbit, powered by a glorious voice that rises from her shoelaces. Amanda channels this from someplace that she probably doesn’t know exists. What a performance.
This song has had a huge impact on me the last year ..moving my family, new job , saying goodbye to certain people..such a beautiful song and ill always love it for the things it makes me feel!
We had "Beautiful Goodbye" single in Veronica's top 1000 end of the year's list this afternoon. Dutch DJ Sander Lantinga, was speachless after this song. It cought my attention too, payed it loud in my car ... Holy Crap. My guess (on the record) was indeed the honorabele Mister Sklar on bass, completed with powerdrums from Mister Kenny Aronhoff, blowing it to the moon and back. Wow. And this live version, Wow, again. She is beyond amazing.
Been playing, watching and listening to every live version of Beautiful Goodbye by her for a good two weeks straight. It’s a re-discovered obsession. She. Is. Insanely good.
I'm lucky to have seen her live already & delighted to get to see her this summer! This song is the best live song I've ever had the privilege to see & hear...
I’ve seen her in concert twice and each time gave me goosebumps! She NEEDS to do a Canada tour again. I can’t believe all this talent and she just disappeared 😢
Well she has I we just saw her at Massey Hall the first night...SHE BLEW THE ROOF OFF!!! Last time I saw her was Kee To Bala...my goosbumps is putting it mildly... by jaw dropped..
I remember going into a Tower Records store in Toronto, in the 90's (when record stores existed) and she was there signing autographs around the time "Let it Rain" and "Dark Horse" was playing on the radio, and I couldn't believe that voice came out of such a tiny body. She's great! I have to say she sounds great - I just heard Dark Horse on the radio and decided to look her up on You tube, because I was curious to see if she was still out there, and it was great to see her performing in Ottawa, and that song "Beautiful Goodbye" is one of my fav's! She sounds great!
Amanda is a survivor. She got tangled up in a web of business because of an old business manager. She was smart enough to be true to herself and stand down until all of the bad business went away. She is back now and she will rise to the top. I have every confidence in her.
This is an absolutely amazing experience. Beautiful goodbye was the first song I learned on piano and to this day love it. Thank you Amanda for knocking this out of the park.
The reason this video exists is because I clipped it from the original full length concert video in order share it with my band. We want to cover this song, I had no idea the video would get such an overwhelming amount of views and likes from so many other people who are NOT in my band! LOL! Thank you all!
I will say this..and I do not care who attempts to "cancel" me or hates my comment.This LADY SHOULD have been bigger than ALL the other bullshit singers that are given a moments recognition because it is hot for a minute and either auto tuned or hip hopped up.REAL talent NEVER gets over shadowed...it just gets recognition when they try to steal from the original artists.Sorry,I do not give a fuck!!!
been a Big Fan of this artist from day one.... I do have a every CD she made.. here I am still in Dec. 2021/ 2022 Still listening. Love you Amanda. forever and many more years to come.. xoxo
OH. My. God! "Sometimes I CRYYYYYYYYYYY!!!" I'm sooo glad she's back. Amongst the most powerful voices ever. Absolutely criminal what the music biz did and tried to do to her and with her (tried to turn her into a "pop diva"). She an absolutely brilliant blues and R&B singer. Play to your strengths, Amanda.
Woooooow!! I fell in love with this song many years ago and this is the firts time i see it live.. Why didn't she break through?!! 🤔 My god what a voice!!!! 😍
I love this song...every time when I hear this song tear of emotion 😥 flow down on my face and my male gender doesn' matter. This is what it's like to be unlucky to be a sensitive person
Beautiful Goodbye ❤❤❤ Amanda Marshall I'm fed up with my destiny And this place of no return I think I'll take another day And slowly watch it burn And it doesn't really matter How the time goes by Cause I still remember you and I And that beautiful goodbye We staggered through these empty streets Laughing arm in arm The night had made a mess of me Your confessions kept me warm I don't really miss you I just need to know Do you ever think of you and I And that beautiful goodbye When I see you now I wonder how I could've watched you walk away If I let you down Please forgive me now For that beautiful goodbye In these days of no regrets I keep mine to myself And all the things we never said I can save for someone else And nothing lasts forever But we always try And I just can't help but wonder why We let it pass us by yeah When I see you now I wonder how I could've watched you walk away If I let you down Please forgive me now For that beautiful goodbye Baby what can I do Oh to get through to you And sometimes I cry yeah It's a fool's lullaby Sometimes I cry It's just a fool's lullaby Oh I'm dying inside
You prolly dont care but if you guys are stoned like me atm then you can watch pretty much all the latest series on instaflixxer. Been streaming with my girlfriend for the last few months xD
You've already discovered the 12 great videos of this concert on September 15, 2017 that Michael McMahon uploaded 5 years ago, and the complete concert contains the 9th video of Keenan Wellar from 5 years ago, but its audio quality is not very good because it was apparently filmed from a distant house on the edge of Ottowa's Lansdowne Park, and TH-cam no longer accepts the link to it. (See also as currently 152nd in my Amanda Marshall playlist.) Kind regards from Bavarian Swabia!
How this amazing singer didn’t make it huge is beyond me. This is one of my all time favourite songs. It still gives me goosebumps.
Probably because she wasn't willing to sell her soul..... glad she didn't. Just keep making music Amanda..... and man I always loved that hair😊🙏🏻💜🇨🇦
What's up with her? So far I know she only released 3 albums more than 20 years ago, but still was on tour in 2017.
I haven't listened to her for some years and didn't know this concert. It's overwhelming.
I remember another extraordinary female singer from Canada, who more or less disappeared after few albums and years, about 30 years ago:
Lisa Dalbello.
This is overwhelming, I agree 💔
Record label screwed her huge ! Too bad she’s so talented
What a voice , love this woman !!!!!!
Omg...I thought she might dodge that final big note, thinking maybe she'd lost some of her range in the 20+ years since recording the song, but no, she took it to another level, belting it out longer and stronger! I'm blown away!
This is her time again…We must spread the word she is back and stronger than ever ❤❤
She didn’t sell her soul like most of the female singers of today. That’s why she’s not mainstream
Passion
I saw her in Ottawa June 20th 2023. This woman possesses a unique talent. Her live music is even better than the studio recordings.
"Records is business. Stage is soul."
Power House does not do her justice...so happy to nave seen her perform recently in Winnipeg...she blew the roof off and we wanted more...hope she continues touring
NO COMMENTS?????
THIS IS ONE OF THE MOST INCREDIBLE VOCAL PERFORMANCES OF ALL TIME ALONG WITH HEART AT THE KENNEDY CENTER DOING THE RIFF THAT SHALL NOT BE PLAYED.
Ikr. She’s absolutely incredible. Been a fan since the 90’s.
Except for the part where she was flailing her arms and spasmodically shaking her hands like a Crack Head going through withdrawals.....WTF!
@@-WhizzBang- Bitch Nah. That's passion. For the heartbreak, for the Heart and Soul of Delivery!!
Respect
Uh-huh. Ever see Joe Cocker or Janis Joplin?@@-WhizzBang-
And the "Heart - Live at KWSU TV Studio" video on TH-cam, or any version of "Wait for an Answer". But Amanda's still better.
Imagine if Amanda appeared on American Idol in 2017 singing that song showing her terrific talent & pipes. The judges & audience would have been blown away.
I was obsessed with this song. The ending is fire!! She is powerhouse singer. It’s the timing she holds those notes then cuts them off, just to bring one in right behind it, just as strong. Let’s not forget to mention that hair!
Will always hold you close to my heart. My ole friend.
"Sing like it was the last time you would sing".... Dunno who said that but still to this day, I would think it's a strong advice.
"Records is business. Stage is soul."
I have seen Amanda Marshall 3 times now. One in 1997 at the NAC, this one in 2017 at City Folk and 2 days ago with her Heavy Lifting Tour at the NAC. She is an absolutely amazing singer and I can never get tired of listening to her music!
That Amanda Marshall is dipping her toe into performing again is spectacular news. This song starts with a languid soulfulness and goes into orbit, powered by a glorious voice that rises from her shoelaces. Amanda channels this from someplace that she probably doesn’t know exists. What a performance.
biggest crime in music history. i seriously believe is that soulful angel not getting the fame she so deserved!!!
One of the best vocalists EVER. Filled with emotion, it just takes the breath away.
This song has had a huge impact on me the last year ..moving my family, new job , saying goodbye to certain people..such a beautiful song and ill always love it for the things it makes me feel!
a powerful women with a strong voice will always bring a grown man to his knees
This song of Amanda is so passionate, so powerfull and so full of love. Amazing live performance. Best voice ever.
We had "Beautiful Goodbye" single in Veronica's top 1000 end of the year's list this afternoon. Dutch DJ Sander Lantinga, was speachless after this song. It cought my attention too, payed it loud in my car ... Holy Crap. My guess (on the record) was indeed the honorabele Mister Sklar on bass, completed with powerdrums from Mister Kenny Aronhoff, blowing it to the moon and back. Wow. And this live version, Wow, again. She is beyond amazing.
One of the best songs ever
God, I wish I could have seen this, Very powerful
WOW!!!!!!!!!!! MOST POWER BEAUTIFUL VOICE IN THE WORLD. LUV YA AMANDA
One of my favorite songs by any artists. Her live performance did not disappoint! 🎵 ❤
Been playing, watching and listening to every live version of Beautiful Goodbye by her for a good two weeks straight. It’s a re-discovered obsession. She. Is. Insanely good.
Ha, me too!
Really impressed she hit all those notes at the end and sounds just like the record. Wow!! Love this song.
I'm lucky to have seen her live already & delighted to get to see her this summer! This song is the best live song I've ever had the privilege to see & hear...
I’ve seen her in concert twice and each time gave me goosebumps! She NEEDS to do a Canada tour again. I can’t believe all this talent and she just disappeared 😢
She's back!!
Jesus Mary and Joseph thank God she is back. 😱
Disagreements with her record label. She would not compromise. Stood her ground. Refused to work under their conditions.
Well she has I we just saw her at Massey Hall the first night...SHE BLEW THE ROOF OFF!!! Last time I saw her was Kee To Bala...my goosbumps is putting it mildly... by jaw dropped..
@@MaureenQuinn-o1v I wish I could have gone.
Fingers crossed this is the first of many tours. 🤞☺️
I remember going into a Tower Records store in Toronto, in the 90's (when record stores existed) and she was there signing autographs around the time "Let it Rain" and "Dark Horse" was playing on the radio, and I couldn't believe that voice came out of such a tiny body. She's great! I have to say she sounds great - I just heard Dark Horse on the radio and decided to look her up on You tube, because I was curious to see if she was still out there, and it was great to see her performing in Ottawa, and that song "Beautiful Goodbye" is one of my fav's! She sounds great!
Yup, still have her autographed CD!
So explosive, so full of power. Wow. Better than the studio version. Amazing. Thank you Amanda.
Amanda is a survivor. She got tangled up in a web of business because of an old business manager. She was smart enough to be true to herself and stand down until all of the bad business went away. She is back now and she will rise to the top. I have every confidence in her.
Simply fantastic. This should have millions of clicks.
She still ranges somewhere in my personal Top Ten of best female Pop-/Rock-Singers.
Sheesh, goosebumps, tears, sadness and joy all at the same time. This song holds a special place in my 💜
This is an absolutely amazing experience. Beautiful goodbye was the first song I learned on piano and to this day love it. Thank you Amanda for knocking this out of the park.
Amazing, fell in love with this song in the nineties, and still am in 2020. What a voice!
Thanks Amanda and Jan for this beautiful moment..
The reason this video exists is because I clipped it from the original full length concert video in order share it with my band. We want to cover this song, I had no idea the video would get such an overwhelming amount of views and likes from so many other people who are NOT in my band! LOL! Thank you all!
WOW!!! She truly sings from her feet up; an amazing singer. Thank you for entertaining us this first day of 2021.
@Klaas Vos Yes!!
At 4:17, when the bass-player looks into the public, that's pure bliss!
Same here, this song is full of emotion, so well performed, epic!
Saw her in concert back in the late 90s. Just an absolutely beautiful voice ❤
Only Amanda would have... and totally did do justice to this song!! In love since this song came out.
I'd love to see Amanda in concert. Incredible singer!
I love her dancing
Outstanding wow, not a lot of singers can pull this off live
Voice is still as amazing as ever. And what a brilliantly well crafted tune.
I will say this..and I do not care who attempts to "cancel" me or hates my comment.This LADY SHOULD have been bigger than ALL the other bullshit singers that are given a moments recognition because it is hot for a minute and either auto tuned or hip hopped up.REAL talent NEVER gets over shadowed...it just gets recognition when they try to steal from the original artists.Sorry,I do not give a fuck!!!
And I think we all agree absolutely with you!
been a Big Fan of this artist from day one.... I do have a every CD she made.. here I am still in Dec. 2021/ 2022 Still listening. Love you Amanda. forever and many more years to come.. xoxo
same for me
So So So underrated.. Amanda is GOLD!
OH. My. God! "Sometimes I CRYYYYYYYYYYY!!!"
I'm sooo glad she's back. Amongst the most powerful voices ever. Absolutely criminal what the music biz did and tried to do to her and with her (tried to turn her into a "pop diva"). She an absolutely brilliant blues and R&B singer. Play to your strengths, Amanda.
Beautiful voice and talent 👍🌹
Thanks for listening
... Amanda... you'r so Great ...No more Word's... Thank you... Great Time
Best female voices of canada!!
Such emotion this beautiful woman ❤
Amazing, strong voice, very underrated
Awesome Amanda
One of the most prolific singers of this generation.
This is her best Live version of this Amazing Classic song..
You have my heart. I’ll watch over you forever. Never stop singing
Great in the '90s . Even better today! Love her voice!
Holly S...! What a voice and what a presence on stage. Beautiful!
Still strong as ever! Amazing vocals!! Love her!
What a voice what a talent, she can wipe out any singer of today by far,
This is one of the most amazing vocal performances ever. She outdid herself. I was there! How I wish she would come back!
She has!
@@smithmann5616Yes, indeed, she's back. I saw her at the NAC last year. And she just won a Juno tonight. I am happy for her.
Wow very powerful amazing singer Canada's best
I love this live performance... breathtaking ❤
What an incredible artist, love her. This song gets to my soul.
Woooooow!! I fell in love with this song many years ago and this is the firts time i see it live.. Why didn't she break through?!! 🤔
My god what a voice!!!! 😍
She sounds the same as when she released it! Loved her then love her now love her forever
She is a sonic spectacle.
I was so happy when they released her first album on vinyl a couple years ago...brilliant.
I love this song...every time when I hear this song tear of emotion 😥 flow down on my face and my male gender doesn' matter. This is what it's like to be unlucky to be a sensitive person
Please Amanda--We 'believe in you' and don't want any 'beautiful goodbye'. Resume your concerts ASAP when Covid restrictions end. XO
Absolut grossartiger Song mit einer Performance und Stimme, wahnsinnig👌
Ich kenne nur wenige, die ihr das Wasser reichen können.
(Unter den sogenannten 'Pop-Queens' jedenfalls absolut keine)
.
Beautiful Goodbye ❤❤❤
Amanda Marshall
I'm fed up with my destiny
And this place of no return I think I'll take another day And slowly watch it burn
And it doesn't really matter
How the time goes by Cause I still remember you and I
And that beautiful goodbye
We staggered through these empty streets
Laughing arm in arm
The night had made a mess of me
Your confessions kept me warm
I don't really miss you I just need to know Do you ever think of you and I
And that beautiful goodbye
When I see you now
I wonder how
I could've watched you walk away
If I let you down
Please forgive me now For that beautiful goodbye
In these days of no regrets
I keep mine to myself And all the things we never said I can save for someone else
And nothing lasts forever
But we always try
And I just can't help but wonder why
We let it pass us by yeah
When I see you now
I wonder how
I could've watched you walk away
If I let you down
Please forgive me now
For that beautiful goodbye
Baby what can I do Oh to get through to you
And sometimes I cry yeah
It's a fool's lullaby
Sometimes I cry
It's just a fool's lullaby
Oh
I'm dying inside
She's always one of my fav
Its one of the most beautiful songs that i know
I was wondering What happen to Amanda Marshall ? Love your voice and classic sexy you . Great Job and nice to see you again performing 🇨🇦❤️
Yep. Still ball my face off when I watch this. Frick... the power is so incredible. 39 yr old dude... just a puddle lol.
Frick.... got me again. The power... I can't handle that power. I mean I can... but holy hell.
fucking amazing....wish i was there man i need to see her LOVE YOU AMANDA MARSHALL
How many singers sound this GREAT LIVE such an underrated talent 🥰🥰🥰🥰
Real musicianship. Wow 🔥
She's the Queen
Such a talented singer and expressions 💥🌹👍
I saw her last year and she was absolutely amazing. She actually sounded better live than her recordings.
Amazing ❤️❤️❤️ would love to see her come back with new album 💿
She has! And has been touring too!
Saw her live in northbay in 97 or 98. Amazing. I knew her guitar player Damien. He brought me back to meet her and check out her tour bus.
Awesome! You met Amanda then?
@Jan Schmitz We met briefly after her show. We were invited for the sound check as well and that was special in itself. Unforgettable night.
Great pipes. Reaches incredible heights
Wow amazing what a voice. So much emotion
Amazing woman...Amazing singer.. Amazing story teller.. ACES!
Awesome fantastic this performance
ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE
What a voice, not enough recognition for her talent!
You prolly dont care but if you guys are stoned like me atm then you can watch pretty much all the latest series on instaflixxer. Been streaming with my girlfriend for the last few months xD
@Mohammad Louis Yup, been watching on InstaFlixxer for years myself :D
@Mohammad Louis Yup, have been watching on InstaFlixxer for years myself :D
Absolute beautiful voice
I was there and took some amazing pictures! Wish your link to the whole concert would work. Sadly, only 1 song but it's still great! Thanks!
You've already discovered the 12 great videos of this concert on September 15, 2017 that Michael McMahon uploaded 5 years ago, and the complete concert contains the 9th video of Keenan Wellar from 5 years ago, but its audio quality is not very good because it was apparently filmed from a distant house on the edge of Ottowa's Lansdowne Park, and TH-cam no longer accepts the link to it. (See also as currently 152nd in my Amanda Marshall playlist.)
Kind regards from Bavarian Swabia!
Up there with songs like time in a bottle, the man with the child in his eyes
breathtaking
Amazing 😮
Absolutely incredible!
What a beautiful voice...
another AWESOME performance for the tragically under-rated Canadian Queen!!
Super fan, fantastic!!!!!