First of all, way to be spot on with the impersonation of us. It was like looking in a mirror. Second, it's like 65 degrees in my garage and I'm literally dying right now. SO COLD. Ok now on to my pick for winner. I meaaaaaaaaaaaan. This is tough. There are arguments to make for either of you winning. On one hand, I like Jeff's picks but then, ya had to throw Twilight Struggle on there. Boyeeeee you out. Jamie wins.
Just watched Jenna and Francis do this on the board game garden!! They carried around their dog for most of it haha next video you gotta carry your big ass doggo for the whole thing 😂 work those biceps lol
Going with Jeff as #1 but Jamie's choice of a standard deck of cards was fantastic. I'm super impressed with how much y'all stuffed in each of your shelves.
First - gotta say I love Jamie's hair like this with the longer & pink in it! And love that you guys kept wanting to hate draft games for your own cubes. *chuckle* And I like Jamie's picks better!
I usually try to support you Jeff, but Jamie got Res Arcana and Brass! I don't think I can let that slide. You almost got me back with LOTR: Confrontation but Wingspan Asia and Cascadia then One Ring... she crushed it👍
Now for the vote... I'm split because Jeff took Cartographers and Scout, but ultimately I'm going to have to side with Jamie because I'm just not into the war and conflict games. If the three of us were marooned on a desert island, Jamie would get a yes more often than Jeff. Sorry, bud.
Gotta give it to Jeff! Cartographers and Confrontation with Alice is Missing is big combo. I think Jamie would have one with a racing game but Jeff wins by a nose!
I was ROOTing for you Jeff, but I'm gonna give it to Jaimie here (though I do think you should check again if the bank of her games are touching the wall!)
This is a close one, but I think I have to give it to Jamie. I am so hyped for Turing Machine. And Res Arcana, Cascadia and Brass are amazing. Also, ROVE and Friday are great. I am sad that I missed out on Food Chain Island though.
YESS! I was really excited for this one the moment I saw the Brothers Murph do this. The moment Jamie opened with Res it was a good video, loved it all!
I loved the hate drafting! This looked super fun! It's hard to pick which shelf I like more but I think I might go with Jeff's. I wanna see what I would fit in a Kallax shelf but that requires clearing out a Kallax shelf first...
Big vote for Jeff’s shelf. I was pleasantly surprised by the Innovation pick! But though it’s pretty, it’s a bigger box than the ugly version 😂 Jeff fumbled the bag by picking Twilight Struggle early though. Gotta hate draft MORE. 😂
Very good back and forth banter. Couldn’t decide who to give it to…was leaning toward Jeff and then Jamie closed the video out with a little JB tune so the winner is Jamie! 🎉 Excellent and entertaining you 2!
Jeff won it for me! Some top tier drafts there👌also bonus points for roasting those sweater and toque wearing Californias when it’s tshirt and short weather there! “It’s liikee 80 degrisse out”😂
You two always make me LOL! Jamie!! Ugh you are such a stinker, I give it to Jeff bc you remind me of my husband and how he plays games (cheat-innnn) ;D
This is super tough! Jamie has Brass (my favorite game of all time), but the challenge is about the whole collection, so I'm going to have to give it to Jeff (by the narrowest of margins).
#1 is Jamie's - there are just more games I am interested in playing. But Jeff's shelf is a perfect reflection of his style. We don't have Kallax for our games but now I want to see what my game choice would be if I could only keep what fit inside a medium moving box.🤔
Whoa! At Jamie’s first pick I knew she was up to no good. Res Arcana? Jeff, I felt the pain from that back stab. Before I watch anymore I suggest you just pick Disney Villainous.
I haven't had the chance to play any of the games you drafted, but Jeff got more games that are on my list of desired games & Jamie had a number of solo games which I'm not really into, so Jeff for the win!
This was highly entertaining. I died laughing the whole video especially at your nick and Mike Californian impressions. Both of these cubes would be a great collection. I'll side with Jeff on this one. Much love to both of you and appreciate all that you do!!
I think so clover and brass tipped it for Jaime for me. If Jeff would have gotten brass he’d have taken the crown for me but the snake strikes fast, strikes first
This is a tough vote. How do you go against Fantasy Realms, Scout, Cartographers and Awkward Guests? Then again, how do you go against Innovation, Turing Machine, So Clover, and Res Arcana? For me, one game tips the scales. Jeff has Unmatched. Jeff wins.
I had a thought going into watching this video that "wouldn't it be funny if someone included a standard deck of cards?" And, so Jamie's cube wins for versatility alone.
from what i can see of your collection, my list would be wonderlands war, res arcana, root and whatever small games would fit after that but i must have those 3
Tough for me to call as I would’ve chosen games from each of their picks by it I gotta give it to Jaime; even tho Unmatched almost won it for Jeff singlehanded
I thought FOR SURE I would side with Jamie on this one; consider we tend to like a lot of the same games. But there was hardly anything on her shelf that I recognized. What surprises me; is Jeff's choices! Unmatched is one of my favourites - Cobble & Stone being my favourite set. But Jeff managed to pick so many games that are on my "game play wish list." In spite of him adding Twilight, 🤮Baseball, 🤮and Root 🤮to his shelf - I've got to give the win to him.
@@FostertheMeeple Haha fair enough! Credit goes to Jeff for the best use of space, period, with Scout. I also had never heard of Alice is Missing and am excited to try it. Love the channel! You should do this video idea again and say no-repeat picks.
I would rather have Jeff's collection with Root, unmatched, scout, and TS on it but honestly Jamie almost won it back with very consistent solid picks. If either of you went Kanban that would be an auto win (oops pun) because of the sheer audacity. Follow up question: Jeff, do you play root online? If so what's your game ID?
First of all, way to be spot on with the impersonation of us. It was like looking in a mirror. Second, it's like 65 degrees in my garage and I'm literally dying right now. SO COLD. Ok now on to my pick for winner.
I meaaaaaaaaaaaan. This is tough. There are arguments to make for either of you winning. On one hand, I like Jeff's picks but then, ya had to throw Twilight Struggle on there. Boyeeeee you out. Jamie wins.
DING DONG YOURE WRONG
Just watched Jenna and Francis do this on the board game garden!! They carried around their dog for most of it haha next video you gotta carry your big ass doggo for the whole thing 😂 work those biceps lol
Hahaha that would be a sight
I just started watching. Already knew what Jeff’s #1 was going to be, but of course Jamie in typical Jamie fashion hate drafts it with her #1 pick!!!
Of COURSE she did
Lol
"Who uses the #1 pick to hate draft?!?!" -Jeff, like 2 years ago. Shoulda been prepared for that maneuver.
Preach my man, preach
Hey Jeff, both your cubicles were great, too bad Jamie did not want to participate in this challenge! 😁
Dominant win for Jeff. Baseball and Root all the way.
LETTTSSSS GOOOOOOO
Going with Jeff as #1 but Jamie's choice of a standard deck of cards was fantastic. I'm super impressed with how much y'all stuffed in each of your shelves.
Haha honestly, I’m impressed too
Jeff.. and the only reason is that clutch move on the LOTR Confrontation! I must say tho.. Jamie killed it on her picks! You guys rock!
Haha thanks!! Glad you enjoyed it!
Loved Jamie's singing of the Arthur Song Jekyll and Hyde! Not many people know that song!
That one and “library card” are staples
First - gotta say I love Jamie's hair like this with the longer & pink in it! And love that you guys kept wanting to hate draft games for your own cubes. *chuckle* And I like Jamie's picks better!
I usually try to support you Jeff, but Jamie got Res Arcana and Brass! I don't think I can let that slide. You almost got me back with LOTR: Confrontation but Wingspan Asia and Cascadia then One Ring... she crushed it👍
Billy. You’re tearing me apart
This video was awesome but Jeff takes the cake! LoTR the confrontation, Root and Baseball Highlights!
Slam dunk really
Jeff's little boxer dance before the first game is chosen gives me the giggles. He says, "I got this, I got this."
Also, Jeff's sneezes are apparently hilarious because now I have two small boys fake-Jeff-sneezing in the next room 🙄😂
Now for the vote... I'm split because Jeff took Cartographers and Scout, but ultimately I'm going to have to side with Jamie because I'm just not into the war and conflict games. If the three of us were marooned on a desert island, Jamie would get a yes more often than Jeff. Sorry, bud.
You have two very intelligent boys who likely picked me. As for you picking Jamie Claire? I’m not mad. Just disappointed.
@@FostertheMeeple Yeah, I get that a lot. Sorry, Jeff. Stop picking war games ;)
Gotta give it to Jeff! Cartographers and Confrontation with Alice is Missing is big combo. I think Jamie would have one with a racing game but Jeff wins by a nose!
YESSSS LUIS
It was close, but if I had to choose a collection as my own I’d choose Jeff’s by a hair. Fun video. Thank you!
Woohoo!! Glad you enjoyed it!
The eye brows at Jeff's "gives us another inch!" 🤣🤣🤣
Hahaha I died when I saw that
I'm surprised Jamie did not pick Villainous at all!
K-lax you guyyyyys life's a beach anyway
haha I love how Jeff was already outraged at Jamie's first pick 😂 you both picked some great games but I think I have to vote for Jamie's shelf!
She was being a demon! RES at 1!! WEASEL move
Gotta give it to Jeff! Love the video! Do more of these, they were fun to watch!
Glad you enjoyed it Don!
I was ROOTing for you Jeff, but I'm gonna give it to Jaimie here (though I do think you should check again if the bank of her games are touching the wall!)
BOOOO RYAN
@@FostertheMeeple I know, I'm ashamed 😔
Love the picks… but where’s Silver Bullet ??? Weird shape box but could have been the killer pick ! 😃
This is a close one, but I think I have to give it to Jamie. I am so hyped for Turing Machine. And Res Arcana, Cascadia and Brass are amazing. Also, ROVE and Friday are great. I am sad that I missed out on Food Chain Island though.
YESS! I was really excited for this one the moment I saw the Brothers Murph do this. The moment Jamie opened with Res it was a good video, loved it all!
Haha she weaseled me Jake
I loved the hate drafting! This looked super fun! It's hard to pick which shelf I like more but I think I might go with Jeff's. I wanna see what I would fit in a Kallax shelf but that requires clearing out a Kallax shelf first...
Do it!!!
Jenna Rose needs to take note! Jeff droppin the rules, you can’t take all the button shy games😂
We will make sure to tell her!
“So Californian”😂 they say it with that valley accent😂 Caylox
CAYYY LAX
Big vote for Jeff’s shelf. I was pleasantly surprised by the Innovation pick! But though it’s pretty, it’s a bigger box than the ugly version 😂
Jeff fumbled the bag by picking Twilight Struggle early though. Gotta hate draft MORE. 😂
I’ll take the nod. HOWEVER. Ding dong you’re wrong on TS
Very good back and forth banter. Couldn’t decide who to give it to…was leaning toward Jeff and then Jamie closed the video out with a little JB tune so the winner is Jamie! 🎉 Excellent and entertaining you 2!
Glad you enjoyed it Andrew! Thanks for watching and commenting
Dump a bag of Bananagram tiles or something in there to fill up the corners. LOL!
Also we absolutely did not go to the wall we stayed in the cube Jamie out here blatantly trying to cheat
Her lack of integrity knows no bounds
Jeff won it for me! Some top tier drafts there👌also bonus points for roasting those sweater and toque wearing Californias when it’s tshirt and short weather there! “It’s liikee 80 degrisse out”😂
You get me. Thank you
I seen the buttonshy coming as soon as it was a packing efficiency puzzle
I should have also haha
Jamie has the best overall shelf IMO. I did think Jeff packed in some decent play with hanabi, 6 Nimmt and town 66
Jamie has the better shelf for a wide variety. Jeff has a lot of great games as well. Loved this video!
Glad you enjoyed James!
You two always make me LOL! Jamie!! Ugh you are such a stinker, I give it to Jeff bc you remind me of my husband and how he plays games (cheat-innnn) ;D
let’s GOOOOO TRACIE!!
This is super tough! Jamie has Brass (my favorite game of all time), but the challenge is about the whole collection, so I'm going to have to give it to Jeff (by the narrowest of margins).
I’ll take it!
#1 is Jamie's - there are just more games I am interested in playing.
But Jeff's shelf is a perfect reflection of his style.
We don't have Kallax for our games but now I want to see what my game choice would be if I could only keep what fit inside a medium moving box.🤔
You should do that! Haha
Whoa! At Jamie’s first pick I knew she was up to no good. Res Arcana? Jeff, I felt the pain from that back stab. Before I watch anymore I suggest you just pick Disney Villainous.
I know she likes Res Arcana but Brass🤔 I will have to see how the rest of this pans out ha.
SUS
I called Jeff's #1 & #2, which would be on my shelf too. Have to give the win to Jeff, without question.
LETS GOOO
I haven't had the chance to play any of the games you drafted, but Jeff got more games that are on my list of desired games & Jamie had a number of solo games which I'm not really into, so Jeff for the win!
YESSSS Eric. SOLIDARITY
Well… guess I have some new board game content to be following. Awesome stuff you guys! Love the vibe between you two
Ehhhh thanks for the kind words!! Happy you found us!
@@FostertheMeeple happy to be there! SO to the Murphs and Rodney for pointing the way!
This was highly entertaining. I died laughing the whole video especially at your nick and Mike Californian impressions. Both of these cubes would be a great collection. I'll side with Jeff on this one.
Much love to both of you and appreciate all that you do!!
Thanks Kyle!! Appreciate you!
16:07 I wasn’t expecting the taunt response in song
Such fun to watch. Tough call. Jeff ekes it out.
Great choice Matthew!
Jeff looks super pump for that challenge 😄
Like rocky!
Jamie! For Wingspan, Cascadia, Tussie Mussie, So Clover, the One Ring rpg and Turning Machine.
I think I’m gonna have to go with Jamie’s on this one. 😍 Too many faves in there!
Disappointing choice, but I understand
ohh i felt that res arcana for jeff
Finally played root today for the first time! Know I understand the love for this game. 😊
YAY!!! It’s so good
I think so clover and brass tipped it for Jaime for me. If Jeff would have gotten brass he’d have taken the crown for me but the snake strikes fast, strikes first
WHATEVER BRAD
This is a tough vote. How do you go against Fantasy Realms, Scout, Cartographers and Awkward Guests? Then again, how do you go against Innovation, Turing Machine, So Clover, and Res Arcana? For me, one game tips the scales. Jeff has Unmatched. Jeff wins.
YOU CHOSE RIGHT
I had a thought going into watching this video that "wouldn't it be funny if someone included a standard deck of cards?" And, so Jamie's cube wins for versatility alone.
Boooooo Paul!
@@FostertheMeeple Now, don't be a sore loser, Jeff! Lol.
@@Paul-hm8dd you’ve chosen wrong! ;)
from what i can see of your collection, my list would be wonderlands war, res arcana, root and whatever small games would fit after that but i must have those 3
WW would take the whole cube!
Lovely challenge. You are always so much fun to watch. I really need to do this challenge at one point. Sounds interesting.
can't believe no one picked Villainous.... what's happening?
Didn’t fit!!
@@FostertheMeeple you could have made it fit ;)
Both so good but I gotta give to Jeff for his Root pick!
My man Ryan
As a Californian I approve the impersonations lmfao
Haha glad we nailed the accent
Tough for me to call as I would’ve chosen games from each of their picks by it I gotta give it to Jaime; even tho Unmatched almost won it for Jeff singlehanded
I’m not mad, just disappointed
Jamie's cube shelf collection best in general 🙋♀️
Jeff has the Root. Can’t go without
Agreed!!
I thought FOR SURE I would side with Jamie on this one; consider we tend to like a lot of the same games. But there was hardly anything on her shelf that I recognized. What surprises me; is Jeff's choices! Unmatched is one of my favourites - Cobble & Stone being my favourite set. But Jeff managed to pick so many games that are on my "game play wish list." In spite of him adding Twilight, 🤮Baseball, 🤮and Root 🤮to his shelf - I've got to give the win to him.
You just listed off three amazing games with puke emojis. YIKES
@@FostertheMeeple haha I'm just bustin' yer chops. Maybe if you did a playthrough of those games - my mind could change. 😁
I think Jeff's collection is more to my taste, but Jamie's is very diverse.
NICE! #teamjeff
I thought I would be voting Jeff, but I think I have to go with Jamie
Jeff crushed this challenge… not even close!
YESSSS
Jamie won in her first five picks. Absolute beat down. Not even close.
We all can’t be right Christian, and in this case, you are also not right. ;)
@@FostertheMeeple Haha fair enough! Credit goes to Jeff for the best use of space, period, with Scout. I also had never heard of Alice is Missing and am excited to try it. Love the channel! You should do this video idea again and say no-repeat picks.
@@appleseiter15 hahah I’m sure we will
do it again sometime!! If you have the right group, Alice is Missing is top notch RPG
Jeff's shelf has root and Jamie's has res arcana. What a match! Well...I'll vote for Jeff this time but this was a hard decision to make u.u
You chose right!
Jeff picked Unmatched so I gotta send my vote that way
You chose well John!
Jamie started out strong (to Jeff's chagrin), but I think she transitioned into "whatever fits" too early. #TeamJeff has the better collection.
JON. You chose well friend
Ooh I didn't know rolling heights came in a tin, is that the standard edition?
I don’t believe so! This was an advanced copy we received
I would rather have Jeff's collection with Root, unmatched, scout, and TS on it but honestly Jamie almost won it back with very consistent solid picks. If either of you went Kanban that would be an auto win (oops pun) because of the sheer audacity. Follow up question: Jeff, do you play root online? If so what's your game ID?
I do! It is Jeff_FTM I believe
@@FostertheMeepleSweet! I'll look for you. When do you usually play?
@@robmangham4930 I never play live games, only async!
@@FostertheMeeple just set one up. Password: ftmftw
@@robmangham4930 username?
Sympathy vote for Jeff!
I don’t need sympathy! My cube was by far the superior cube
Jamie wins, because she got one extra Button Shy in. She wins by the width of a button.
Hahaha that’s fair
Jeff gets the win for me! Root and Unmatched 🤩
LETS GOOOOO
this is an interesting video concept
It was so close! I think I prefer Jeff's shelf a little more.
Solid choice Alyssa!
Jeff has root for the win
YESSSSSS
Jamie wins. Although you should have picked Root instead of Res Arcana first to really skewer him!
Come on TYLER!!!!
Brass, Wingspan, Cascadia… Jamie clearly got this in my book. Surprised neither of you picked CoB or Silver Bullet.
We don’t own CoB!!
It was Jamie because she beat Jeff to Brass AND Res Arcana! LOL
she doesn’t even like them that much!!!
Because of res and brass, I got to go with Jamie.
Jamie’s shelf wins with me!
Who did Jaime call out to do this next at the end of the video?
Kovray!
Did you make your shelf
I have to go with Jamie's shelf. Sorry Jeff. This isn't a pity vote.
It’s fine. She needs some votes
No radlands? So much fun and in your face in one small box
Our box isn’t the small retail one unfortunately.
Jamie gets major points for the hate drafting, but Jeff wins for me. Tough since I haven’t played a lot of these so my opinion isn’t worth much 😬
Jamie loves her a good hate draft
Sorry Jamie but Jeff is the clear winner 🏆
GREAT choice
Jamie wins in my book, but Jeff had some good ones.
You guys crack me up! Sorry Jeff but I'm team Jamie🤗
We can’t all be on the winning team. #teamjeff
Im Team Jamie. More games were in my interest in her cube
This challenge gets easier if you already move a lot of your games into smaller boxes :)
Not allowed as part of the rules! Gotta repack to original boxes haha
Jamie wins. Not a pity vote. Brass, Res Arcana, Cascadia and Wingspan, come on.
PITY VOTE
Wonderland Wars is upside down! 😱
Uhoh!
Jeff for sure!
Wooooo
Jamie and Cascadia did it for me !! 😆 🤣
I knew she’d win the popular vote with cascadia
Going to give this one to Jeff but it's close!
I’ll take the W!
Did I hear a Grey Poupon reference?
I’m from Cali and say cow-Rex
I like these but I’d really like if the challenge was to then only play all these games again before playing anything else.
I don’t think that would be possible for us given the nature of what we do haha
@@FostertheMeeple I know. Especially with as many as you fit in there.
Jeff you put Root in a cube but don’t bring it with you to a deserted island!?
Those things are not the same!