Jeremy Corbyn on Hamas, the Middle East and the super-rich
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 12 ก.ค. 2015
- Labour leadership candidate Jeremy Corbyn spoke to Channel 4 News’ Krishnan Guru-Murthy about Hamas and Hezbollah, the wider situation in the Middle East, tax, the super-rich and immigration.
Read more: bit.ly/1HDCnj7
Subscribe to Channel 4 News on TH-cam: / channel4news
Krishnan Guru-Murthy is not a good interviewer. Far too aggressive. I wanted to listen to Corbyn speak, not Murthy constantly interrupt & trying to put words in his mouth. This is what I expect from Sky News. Sort your sh*t out Channel 4.
I don't think he's "aggressive" at all. Definite, straightforward. You misinterpret his delivery.
Dick Hamilton Everytime Corbyn trys to speak for more than a few seconds he interrupts him. Keeps trying to score cheap points. Not interested in interviewing him, only interested in making him look bad.
Chris Johnson He showed us what a prick this Labour ding dong is I could never vote for some one that would make me even more out of work I lost £32,000 this year and paid no tax on £32,000 my little black baby is dead and I have lost my free range chickens and my home.
Richard Maunder prick he may be, but he is not, and has never been, in a Labour cabinet, and Labour haven't been in since 2010, so you can hardly blame him for your current situation (for which I sympathise strongly). Why aren't you blaming the Tories (and Lib Dems, though they are less responsible, I would have thought) ?
He has always been Labour and I lost £12,000 per year because of Labour also I lost £20,000 per year because I can not use my own land in Dorset both under Labour and the Tories bellends because I have owned my own land in Dorset for more than 25 years he and the others will never get my vote as my little black baby and chickens are dead.
As a Green Party member, Corbyn really shows the last embers of Labour. A Corbyn-lead Labour might just sway me, otherwise Labour are doomed.
Lewis Grace As a Green Party member, I agree.
Lewis Grace As a Green party member I can't see how you see your party outlasting Labour. It's kind of seen as a bit absurd by the majority of Britons, so I'm not sure how you reconcile this belief.
Dante Because support for the Greens is on the rise, and support for and faith in Labour is declining. If the trends continue as they are doing, Greens could become the party of the left, and Labour could be on their way to a constitutional crisis-esque destruction.
Lewis Grace I agree wholeheartedly.
Andrew Espley That's a huge if. The Green party are not really even big enough to have seen true public scrutiny, if they ever get this big this will be a disaster for the party as they have no other real appeal to anyone other than the far left. Labour have stood throughout the ages and it's premature to assume that this is going to change, while there is a clear crisis in direction once Labour supports see sense and elect someone who actually has a chance of winning it's likely they will have a good shot of winning a majority.
the Deep State sure did a job on poor Jeremy and we all suffered because of it
So so true.
there is no deep state, most of the people behind it are in clear public view and dont even bother hiding that they were trying to sabotage corbyn at every turn. please dont dip into the deep state conspiracy theory when the enemy is just capitalism
No, we didn't want him, thank-you..
@@user-sf7kl9uh7k you speak for everyone do you s---head?
@@user-sf7kl9uh7k how’s the NHS looking
Reading the comments below tells me that people in England get the governments which they deserve..
So true!
Not my choice thanks I voted JC but many voted tory because of brexit
Sadly
@@janewright2800 & @kailashpatel1706 - No we don't! The problem is that corrupt politicians have rigged the education system so we're "dumbed down" so we're easier to control & thus they can maintain a status quo where they operate @ our expense. - Been like that all my life - @ the least!
The era of Clown Corbyn 2015-2019
RIP Corbanism
Corbyn does a very good job of explaining some complicated issues in approachable terms that are accessible to everyone. Krishnan being unprofessional and resorting to bad manners to attempt to distill and dumb down a reasonable answer into a sound bite is just pathetic and does disservice to the decency and intelligence that Corbyn represents in British politics.
Alex van Beek Libtards like Corbyn measure success by explaining the problems they don't measure success by fixing the problem !
Alex van Beek What a heap of absolute nonsense. These issues are anything but "complicated". Can you imagine this bolshevik running the Labour party or - God forbid - the country? Holy shit.
***** No, seriously, Frédéric: This is what bolshevism means? Are you really that stupid to believe that others don't know that? You are a true bolshevist yourself. You truly believe that you have your facts straight and know what's best for people - the hallmark of an ignorant man, a bolshevik, a communist. Lenin would be proud of you. And Trotsky too. But more importantly, I think you would have risen high up the ranks during Stalin's times. Talk about underwhelming.
Marcel Pfister I'd say the Middle East is probably about as complicated as an issue can get.
Alex van Beek I couldn't agree more. The ME is completely complicated. If things are difficult, you need to cut the up into bite-size pieces. The issue with Corbyn here is that he's not made for public consumption. You need to keep your calm, even when facing an idiotic and biased reporter. The man's a disaster waiting to happen.
Corbyn was absolutely right, the interviewer like all interviewers constantly interrupt politicians, never allowing them to finish answering the questions. Corbyn found it irritating, I find it irritating and I'm sure most people find it irritating. Again he was right in stating that the questions were tabloid like, the interviewer was just looking for the sensational headlines at the end of the interview. "You heard it hear first folks, tune in next week for more of the same"........... YAWN!
He was being asked a question and was being evasive. You'd not have accepted a Tory leader behaving like that.
@@user-sf7kl9uh7kNo, he was not being evasive. The interviewer was hectoring him over a trivial point of the use of a word which was clearly used in a benign way as a matter of courtesy. It was, as Corbyn stated, cheap tabloid journalism and the interviewer and Channel 4 should be ashamed of themselves for descending into the tabloid media gutter.
@@douglasmacari8707 Although had he been interviewing David Cameron or Nick Clegg no doubt you'd have had no issue with it. Typical Clown Corbyn excusing exercise. ,
@@douglasmacari8707He's now gone thank goodness
Jeremy Corbyn is talking sense. Krishnan would do well to listen and stop interrupting Jeremy.
the interviewer has quite the axe to grind.
Corbyn's points about tax dodging and insecure 0hrs contracts really stand out during this pandemic.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Krishnan Guru-Murthy, I am so disappointed in your trivialising of the issues here. I think Jeremy Corbyn was correct in stating that you were creating tabloid journalism.
I have long followed channel 4 news after giving up on other mainstream news output, seeing this interview leaves me in despair, I have lost a lot of respect for you as a journalist, Krishnan.
Matt Turley
Are you still watching TV?
The only place for news now are blogs from respected individuals and counter sources.
Only use mainstream, including ch4, to find out what the official line is.
I mean, I saw them sympathetically interviewing a Al Nusra fighter the other week.
I guess their rationale was that many of their viewers wont know who they are.. And they wonder why they are losing viewers.
+Matt Turley
I'm surprised it took you that long to realize that Krishnan Guru-Murthy is an obnoxious gobshite.
Corbyn's version of a free press would make Pravda in the USSR look like a relentless teller of truth to power!
Well Krishnan made himself look a right prat! Let the man speak! When he finally was allowed to reply fully, sounds like a good guy. Good guys always finish last they say, so I doubt anything will come of it, but how refreshing to hear a Labour representative espousing socialist policies. I hope that the party will give this guy a chance, I would absolutely vote for him.
This Corbyn thing was waffling, trying to answer questions with questions, and attempting to seize the moral high ground with his idealistic drivel.
Our shame as a Nation is that the majority of people say I’m alright Jack until they lose a job their home or lose a loved one or indeed get divorced. Life changing events that can destroy your standard of living. Everyone should be encouraged to work if they can and encouraged to contribute a fair amount towards running the Country. People from other countries are drawn to the UK because they think we have got the balance right but I feel we are on a slippery slope back into an unfair society. JC speaks the truth and people don’t want the truth.
Spot on! Shameful “I’m alright Jack” thinking is the lifeblood of the Tories’ stranglehold on this country. It’s sad.
The 'super rich' donors and their political puppets have assisted in dividing the people into sections and sub sections in the name of Equality? However, the emphasis has been on ensuring each minority or subdivision is given 'more' in order to keep the majority quiet/submissive?
The super rich do not discriminate against each other, but they do know the benefits of divide and conquer, discrimination, and division within the lower class'
1% control more of the world's finance than the 99% put together whereas the 99% have nothing but their majority in numbers? This is why a small group continue to use divide and conquer tactics against the mass? Simply to preserve their own interests.
Jeeeeez my god it's lucky he's not in charge.
@@Rebellion192can you imagine paying 60% tax. Everyone would leave the country. I can really see why labour never got elected. I'd vote Tory every time.
@@mikecook1537 60% tax on the top rate, not 60% blanket taxes. Remember in the UK that includes health insurance and job loss protection so when you add it up it's actually less than USA.
Just watched this it's a shame what the country's media did this Guy they didn't care until he became a thret he would have changed the country for the better instead we have these idiots
I remember when Channel 4 started, as a fresh alternative to the mainstream. I also remember watching Channel 4 News as a solid and intelligent source of broader news than others offered. Here I see the most simplistic, lowbrow, distorting, sound-bite loving simple-minded and feckless journalism. WTF? Mr. Corbyn did very well to hold his anger back as long as he did, and respect to him also for not playing the robot game all the other party-whipped cutout figures play, of falling into line with this dumbed-down, cowardly and irresponsible way of processing information, but for expressing his anger when enough was definitely already 10 times enough, and insisting on some truth. Sad, all the same, that many voters love crude cowpats of simplistic info so that they too can avoid responsibility for the world that surrounds them.
Depressing: wasn't it and isn't it still !! 🙄🙄🙄
I don't think I've ever seen such an embarrassingly childish interviewer. Krishnan had this bizarre mix of an over-excited zealot and a teen with attention deficit disorder.
Of course, the Tory press spin it as Corbyn being "cantankerous" and "getting angry".
I'm frankly amazed at how calm Corbyn remained through most of it.
Get corbyn off the tv he is disgrace
@@garystokes6407 Explain why.
Marxist
Tarantino once shut down Krishnan for sensationally using tabloid questioning. I can see why now
This is like watching a three year old asking his dad questions. Too impatient to listen and lacking the mental capacity or maturity to understand the answers..
Mason Ringbinder sure sure... :)
More like watching a three year old ANSWER his dad's questions.
On point mate
All his answers were lies though. Germany hasn't benefited at all, in fact over 90% who arrived since Merkel opened the doors are still unemployed. Sweden needs no explanation.
what an idiot corbyn is
His attitude to Europe has encouraged me to join the labour party just so that I can vote for him as Labour leader. Previously I voted UKIP - I would never ever vote Tory.
Corbyn is now even-money favourite to secure the party leadership - which is good.
He brings to British politics a vision & conviction lacking in previous years - he says *Follow Me* other party leaders say _I will follow public opinion_
Many who used to vote Labour will begin to vote for them again.
The _journalist_ was clearly having a bad day
kizzagt As you ask I am on drugs - for my Diabetes - but several unions endorse him and the smart money at the bookmakers has him as outright favourite.
I think it's time for a bit less New Labour and a bit more social conscience.
The electorate will ultimately decide.
kizzagt You make some very valid points and you make them so eloquently - perhaps I have it wrong about the man?
Richard Buxton Cut the sarcasm.
kizzagt Not possible to cut the sarcasm - your style -- the tone and your gutter vocabulary open you up to ridicule.
Very difficult to take you seriously - you must expect sarcasm.
Richard Buxton Social responsibility? Nigh on every single labour supporter in the nation would do just as everyone else. If they can make a bit more money they raise the price a little. You guys go all nuts about the super rich and corporation tax and all that but have no inling, apparently, what happens when you increase government funds or ready cash in an economy. First thing that happens? cost of living goes up because *everybody* starts charging more because people have more cash. Worrying about cash flow and who has a billion or doesn't is a waste of time in politics, focus on the product.
Socialists like to shout about how 'tories don't care' which anybody with an ounce of intellectual honesty knows is bullshit. It's not about who cares and who doesn't.. it's about the different approaches different people think will help. Essentially, as far as the welfare state goes the difference is that the 'right' thinks an unqualified handout is painting over the cracks
The guy calls himself a socialist, so he can inherit all the disgust people feel for the socialist. The intellectual bankruptcy and economic incapacity that goes with it.
Despite Guru-Murthy's approach Jeremy got his points across and to my mind looked like the rational speaker. Guru-Murthy's aggressive, quick fire, questioning, though extremely irritating, were easy to bat away and did not challenge Jeremy's position in any depth.
Gavin Sealey I can't stand Guru-Murthy. In every interview I've seen him conduct, he appears to demonstrate an outrageous arrogance, but simultaneously a tiny IQ. The two things put together make him look ridiculous.
Jeremy came across as patiently as an adult could, as if having to explain the obvious to a small child.
krysylys Stupid people I don't mind. As long you keep them from doing much in the way of harm they're really not much of an issue for me. Stupid people who think their smart on the other hand, are about as fucking annoying as it can get. Stupid guy who thinks he's smart? Well, that would be Krishnan Guru Murthy right there. In conversation, I'd find it hard not to lay hands on the guy and not in a healing way...
David Gray Supporting constructive talks, not agendas. You'll need to do a bit better than that, fledgling TH-cam account, capitalist stooge. At least be on time, or use an original name.
David Gray As he says, he mentioned 'friends' collectively referring to the people present in the room at the time. Shows you're either not listening or don't care to.
Adam Smith Ah, yes. The well-known Irish broadcaster Krishnan Guru-Murphy.
This type of interviewer and the liar Cathy Newman (she does this too) are some of the reasons why I've stopped watching C4 news.
Busting Nuts on the foreheads of politicians is great fun.
Channel 4 news is just dreadful as are its presenters.. Journalism?.. Laughable
We only had one child because that was all we could afford. If people can’t afford children they shouldn’t have them.
It's just common sense m8. But people are basically paid to breed in this country. And people that can afford lots of kids labour wants to rob their money.
And that's the children's fault? Why should they suffer?
What about Boris and his many illegitimate children he refuses to give an exact number for?
What if the father dies and the mother and 5 kids remain?
A couple's financial situation can always change though. They might initially be able to afford a few children and then be made redundant, endure a breakup, a recession or any number of things.
I used to think Krishnan Guru-Murthy was a pretty funny character and good guy, mainly from seeing him on various panel shows but after watching this interview I've come to the conclusion that he's a colossal bell end.
+Kaiben Music Same, I thought he was cool. Saw him on Nevermind the Buzzcocks, Would I Lie To You etc. But he kept asking the same question here, "Is Hamas your friend?". Even though Jeremy gave a thorough answer, he wouldn't be happy until he said yes or no, which seems like he was pushing the corporation's agenda. Reminds me that Krishnan also gave a pretty bad interview to Quentin Tarantino...
+Kaiben Music He's a monumental tosser of the gutter/tabloid variety. They trotted out his fat low-IQ self to make a fool out of Michael Jackson and Princess Diana. When he fails in his aim to humiliate his interviewee, he resorts to heckling and shouting down because of his lack of journalistic skill.
Ha ha! so true.
+Kaiben Music He comes across as a regular cool dude on 8 out of 10 cats, doesn;t he? But he's no pussycat.
+Kaiben Music Yep. Saint Corbyn is beyond any criticism. Kind of like Stalin and Kim Jung Il in that way in fact... For the record, Guru-Murthy made a perfectly legitimate point which Corbyn refused to give a straight answer for, something you lot would jump all over if it was a Tory, New Labour, UKIP or any other member of a major British party (or American for that matter I'd imagine)
This interview was honestly rude and aggressive although Corbyn remained completely professional
I also agreed with everything he was saying
You can only make peace if you talk with your enemies.
He loves all the enemies of the west and hates all the friends of the west. He talks to the IRA but not the DUP. He's an evil and very dangerous man.
Not if you wipe out your enemy.
@@ianbetts4435 the enemy's are often the victims of our "friends".
They are not his enemies they are his friends.
Tell that 2 the germans in ww2
This is what we could have had.
Thank goodness we saw the light.
Nooooo
@@user-sf7kl9uh7kSorry but this government has engaged in fuckuppery on such a titanic and insidious scale that they have crashed basically everything. Your response suggests that you are either benefitting or sitting pretty from the current recession or you are a nasty contrarian arsehole who fears human progress.
Go back to Newsround, Krishnan.
Ed O'Meara Surely not! plenty of vacancies for toilet cleaners available!
***** He was asking particularly stupid questions.
Ed O'Meara He's fuckin annoying..
***** If you can't see it, I can't help you. Most people can.
***** No, by "most people" I mean people who understand journalism and the English language.
UKIP in the North like many of his policies especially his anti-privatisation stance. The SNP share most of his values, claiming themselves to be like the Labour Party of old. The problem with Corbyn is that he answers the actual questions. He doesn't answer the question he wants to answer, like most politicians.
Krishnan Guru-Murthy is a big time tabloid entertainer, its why he pushes for simplified yes or no answers/misrepresentations. He does the same in any field, even when he is promoting a movie and interviewing a celebrity, like when he interviewed Tarantino or Downey Jr.
What a tragedy that Jeremy Corbyn did not become Prime Minister...
A terrorist sympathiser for a PM? No thanks.
Please end the Labour Party in Great Britain. Plenty of other parties can absorb their voters.
ok enjoy not having an nhs lol
Cheryl No what does this even mean? The NHS has existed under non-Labour governments for 45 years of it’s 72 year existence.
@@strykah92 yes and each time its been partly dismantled lol
Cheryl No define “dismantled”.
@@strykah92 selling off parts like dental care etc
'You can't answer the question if it's a long answer'. Fantastic journalism there Krishnan.
@@Greg-fl4cb oh dear...
@@Greg-fl4cb th-cam.com/video/JEX5OGmXLz4/w-d-xo.html
Typical main stream media tactics
Yea you trying to explain a pathway to peace in that region in 15 seconds. It's a joke.
As JC tried to explain when you are in discussion to bring about peace you use the turm friend it dose not mean you are there friend, if you can't grasp that then you are just as bad as the journalist asking the question
He's an atrocious anchor. This barely qualifies as journalism.
+Thom Durrant Paxman he aint
I don't even know who he is, and even I know that this was journalism as it should be: Insisting questions be answered and not avoided, refusing to accept bullshit evasion. You're only mad because it happened to your boy Jeremy
I thought I was the only one who thought this man is such a terrible journalist. Krishnan
Ha Ha you are in good company!
Cathy Newman is Krishnan's mother, a very bad triggering interviewer, who refuses to listen, and puts words into his guests mouth which he.she has not said.
Thomas Gee I don’t like Corboen as leader but yes I agree with you it’s a dreadful interview
@@milels6917 WHAT? has a new leader called Corboen joined the fray? lol
Guru-Murthy comes across as extremely childish. His body language suggests he's quite pleased with himself. It's almost as if he's pinching himself and thinking 'hey I'm on the t.v'. Quite pathetic really when you take in to consideration that he's a seasoned journalist. Jeremy Corbyn on the other hand deals with Guru-Murthy's childlike antics quite professionally. By doing so Corbyn makes Guru-Murthy look even more idiotic.
Honestly, Krishnan, you will never be Jeremy. He also let people finish occasionally. You're just aggressive without the tory balls. Just stop it & start making watchable tv. This is just embarrassing. not a reflection on JC but on yourself.
8:18 I've never seen a British politician so angry
@tony mush lol
Shows him up for what he is
Was he a politician? I missed that bit.
This is only because he wants his own way and he can’t have it! He a nasty little 💩weasel is crackpot Corbyn, and those who follow and support him are quite simply not right in the head!
Reminds me of the scene in LOTR when bilbo lunges at Frodo.
What a total waste of 4 years. Wrong Miliband brother, that's when this all started.
If Ur a Tory it was the right Milibrand .
Thanks to red ed the members get to choose the leader
And the rest is history
Yeah, that nice brother who sold Sri Lanka the weapons for the Genocide of the Tamils, he was great wasn't he
I gotta agree. Where's David?
JoseWhon David’s immigration policy was awful
@@mikelitorous5570 What was it's problem? Open gate? I thought Blair did that.
Guru Murthy is SUCH a crappy journalist! He confuses interrupting with challenging, and only seeks to create "drama" and hyperbole, rather than talk about real issues. Should be sacked.
I totally agree he just doesn't have no skills of journalism.
Hard question? Asking about whether Hamas are friends or not is a simple one-word answer: NO. Corbyn needs to go.
Bethany Hunt your supporting the labour natzi party you fascist
I agree. Hopeless interviewer.
This is the second seemingly rational MP I've listened to today, I'm in a pleasant state of shock. I like him. What happened to Channel 4 News though. Not seen it in a long time but grew up with it and remember thinking it and Krishnan were of the more balanced news variety. Tabloid news sums up this interview perfectly
Angela Smith The Daily Mail owns around 20% of ITN shares, and it seems they're getting their pound of flesh.
Cabronosidad You are suggesting that the daily mail bought one fifth of ITN and then have somehow forced them to become slightly lower brow?
I think you have failed to understand the world.
Scuba Sausage No, I'm suggesting the Daily Mail bought one fifth of ITN, then had no editorial influence whatsoever. Duh!
Cabronosidad To be honest, with this miserable, question changing Corbyn figure im not suprised the interviewer got a bit frustrated!
If Labour elect Corbyn I will definitely not be voting for them at the next election.
At the moment I will ignoring Labour unless they elect Andy Burnham.
Kelv R It seems like you are the salty one mate.
Also leaving a couple of comments isnt a full time job..
I do personally feel that I have the right to criticize a politician.
And when a particularly dangerous one like Corbyn shows up its important to criticize him.
Im not sorry...
What have we lost ? Every thing ! What a great politician.
Terrorist sympathiser more like
When the fabric of reality is distorted it will snap back and I can't wait for it to happen.
Poor journalism. The British people aren't stupid; they don't want this tabloid sound biting. We'd rather see a proper discussion with Corbyn.
i hate the american-type-yes/no questions when there are such complex issues. that guy should go work at fox
Fox wouldn't have him. His dye rhea questing would pollute the studio!
Well said
We could have had him as PM, but instead we've had Boris, Truss, Sunak! Absolutely gutting. That is a man that knows the facts and the issues and is passionate about actually fixing things and moving things forwards. So depressing to compare him to these current robots Sunak and Starmer :/
no need for words into his mouth he just clearly stated that people with 5 children who come into UK are just as entitled to benefits to care for all 5 children PAID for by all the rest of us over the many years we have worked, and often not claimed any benefits. The reason they come here in the first place is because of this mad policy!
"The average UK-based migrant from Europe contributed approximately £2,300 more to UK public finances in 2016/17 than the average UK adult." (www.oxfordeconomics.com/recent-releases/8747673d-3b26-439b-9693-0e250df6dbba)
You can only hold this position if you deny a whole host of studies showing the average migrant pays more tax than they cost the country and in fact commit less crime than the average person born in Britain. It's akin to denying climate change in the face of the science, studies, and data.
@@thomasullmann7447 But not the ones on the dole, obviously.
@@Dparkes26 No it's not: the vast bulk of them have already contributed to the system.
@@thomasullmann7447 85% of Muslim woman in the UK don't work and claim benefits.
@@jerrydelaney6971 source?
As anyone with any experience would know, when dealing with people from Arab countries, an introduction and greeting referring to "our friends," regardless of past history of conflict and even if you hate these guys, is the absolutely correct way of beginning any kind of diplomatic dialogue. What would Krishnan like to hear? "Here we are with these arseholes from Hamas. Let's see if we can make a deal!"
THANKYOU for saying this, i see everyone crying about this. trump literally calls people like KJU a great guy, but does anyone call this guy a supporter of war crimes?
Why has Krishnan Guru-Murthy developed 'annoying the shit out of people' as his primary interview style?
He's always been like that... he's an obnoxious sod.
+shannonjazz So that he can keep his job, because he's not a serious journalist who can prove his worth based on his merits and good work. Same reason Miley Cyrus and her ilk debase themselves sexually for the TV audiences, because they're not real musicians and that's what the men with money tell them to do.
Pete Wylie I don't live in England but I am familiar with a lot of the British TV culture. I've seen Kristin Guru Murty on a few things over the years and don't particularly remember him being the irritating prick he is now, but then again I'm not exposed to him the same way people in England are. Part of me thinks he amped up the annoyance after a couple of his interviews went viral and now that's his shtick. I know that role requires you to ask the hard hitting questions but he just sounds like a dickhead whose only agenda is to cause controversy. Jeremy Paxman did seem much more capable of interviewing people in a professional manner.
shannonjazz Krishnan Guru-Murthy*
shannonjazz He wasn't asking hard-hitting questions, he was asking questions designed to smear the interviewee because he can't answer them. "Are Hamas your friends?" isn't a hard-hitting question, it's a stupid question playing on unintelligent audience members' fear of terrorism in order to bully the interviewee into saying 'No' (because he obviously can't say yes) otherwise by saying nothing he looks like he's "avoiding the question" and therefore seems guilty of something, which is the aim. It's a typical news media trick and Krishnan did not invent it, nor, I suspect, did he really make the decision to use it himself.
With Paxman it was different, the questions were relevant and he pressed interviewees because they were genuinely avoiding questions that had relevant, tangible answers that for political reasons they didn't want to give. Questions like 'Do you want to take all the money away from the rich?' 'Do you think it's good that someone should come in and take 5 child benefit packages?' are just stand alone extremes, not relevant, and there is no informative or simple answer to any of them. He only demands yes or no because he knows no rational intelligent person would give a simple yes or no to any of those questions, given the wider implications of the answer.
Good on Corbyn, he handled it exactly the right way and challenged him directly without giving in.
Poor families make themselves poorer by keep having children that they can't afford to keep but they expect everyone else who acts responsibly to keep them, there is no excuse for these family's to carry on like this, family planning is freely available to anyone who wants it but it's easier to crack on unprotected and expect others to keep them and their children, it's not the children's fault is the reckless parents fault who bring children into the world and have no means to support them meaning they live in poverty all their lives. The parents have only themselves to blame for this but they try and put the responsibility on others for their mistakes and it's only right that they should be limited to the amount of benefits they receive, it's their choice to have these children Not Ours.
David Ellis. In 1914-1918 large families were the heroes of the day as they willingly provided useful cannon-fodder at the front.......................I sincerely hope that you are eventually imbued.with the empathetic compassion that you so obviously lack...........................Your urging of others to be 'responsible', is done with the consideration and foresight of a person who cannot see past the end of his nose!!
Who remembers when our railways were nationalised as I do? British Rail was a sick joke. My Grand Dad worked for it and use to brag that he could go into work with a hangover, sleep it off in the store room and get away with it as it was so over staffed no one noticed. If he got caught stealing he could get away with by complaining to his shop steward that he was being victimised and the shop steward would threaten management with a strike unless the charge was dropped. Nationalisation was just a way of keeping a great many lazy, incompetent people in well paid jobs at the tax payers expense.
PHILLIP GREER great answer absolutely true
We didn't have food banks and an army of homeless on the streets back then though did we?
Fact of the matter is "lazy incompetent" people need to work in order to gain work ethic, so your argument doesn't really hold water, unless you actually want to starve people who don't work as well as you... Which would be, well, typical rightwing English rhetoric, but also disastrous for the country.
Oh, and let's not forget, even with all the overstaffing and theft, tickets were still cheaper than they are today even if you factor in the taxes, because there was no profit share to take out.
"Are they your friends or are they not your friends" What are we? Five?
There is no rational debate on the news, just attention seeking jibba jabba..
"Friends" apparently means that Corbyn will be baptising their children
When you are in discussion with people you call them your friend but it doesn't mean you are there friend its just a manna of speaking to other's ie people say all the time they love you but do they truly mean it 😁 of course not its just away of making you feel comfortable and relaxed
Was this an interview or an attack?This was cringe worthy to watch. Cheap journalism. The sun page 3.
Do you complain when the media constantly try to smear Trump instead of interviewing him?
The Sun? Say no more you fucking piece of 💩
Corbyn is a snake oil salesman.
corbyn the clown being interviewed by a very angry + very frustrated labour supporter
There's lots of ' em out there
Bargain basement interviewer.
"Presstitutes" - I like that!
Mr Corbyn is a very angry person.
Yes you can see that he's a petulant child
Well you tend to get angry when asked stupid and slanderous questions
@@archyneverpicked corbyn is a politician ? He's there to answer questions ? you silly lefty
N
@@archyneverpicked The questions in this interview were ridiculous. I think Jeremy did his best here to answer them (noone listens to because of smears in the media!)
I'm hardly surprised Jeremy raised his voice when he was continuing to be rudely interrupted.
In fact given how much Corbyn was smeared in the media, newspapers, etc., I'm surprised he didn't get up and punch Krishnan
An eloquent and more importantly decent man. Jeremy Corbyn should be revered amongst the British community as a champion of the depleted middle class and the downtrodden. Peace and solidarity from Canada.
You really do not know this man's background before you say he is a decent man. For example he invited the political wing of IRA to visit Westminster not long after the IRA tried to murder Margaret Thatcher (UK PM at time) and much more.
👏👏👏✋✌
Why don't you have him, give the hard left a chance to destroy your economic chances?
Krishnan Guru-Murthy is a terrible reporter. He's biased and shamelessly unwise.
??? He is challenging a politician and is not allowing them to stick to talking points and, while I would agree that he does go over the top, it works and repeatedly demonstrates the weaknesses in politicians.
talking points? You mean a detailed explanation of his position - he calls people "friends" who are willing to discuss a peace process? the journalist simply wanted a Gotcha answer. Corbyn was answering the question fully rather than just saying "no, they're not my friends". Are we not intelligent enough to understand a full answer?
And your a racist
What a childish, bad faith interview. Constant interruptions, not listening to answers, shouting about semantics, lack of basic political knowledge.
He thinks he is Jesus.... beware the man that thinks he had all the answers and won’t listen.
Yes!
Jesus probably never existed...
th-cam.com/video/JEX5OGmXLz4/w-d-xo.html
i mean maybe instead of criticising him for trying not to be smeared by the media, you could actually fault his policies?
Guru-Murthy just needs to calm down. Constant interruptions weren't necessary here.
My dad abandoning me before i was born was necessary.
Joseph Critchley your supporting the labour natzi party you fascist
"Corbyn is asking Tory voters to see things his way." I don't think that's what he's doing at all. It seems rather that he's stating clear cut facts and using a rational common sense with which to do it. If people- no matter their political leanings are unwilling, unable or unreasonable enough not to grasp even simple truths like, we live on a finite planet so infinite growth is not only impossible but totally erroneous- then Jeremy can hardly be held responsible. And I think the time has finally arrived when voters would more willingly vote for some one plainly speaking truths than the usual suspects selling the usual polished t*rds as pearls. We need change not point scoring & rhetoric.
Should a brain surgeon earn the same as a dole dosser? If so, what is the incentive to become a brain surgeon?
Nick Newey you are a crawl man .
Nobody in the Labour Party is suggesting that you fool.
@@mikelyons8288 Thanks for the uplifting reply. It was merely a question. Marxism promotes equality. Is it the sort of equality where some are more equal than others?
Perhaps to help the sick. No, they should not be paid the same unless he is a dole dosser Brain Surgeon.
Thank god he's gone
He’s still kind of clinging on :-|
I'm going 2 listen 2 Ken...
I am 40 and never voted by choice but this guy might be the reason to change that. Very refreshing to finally have a genuine opposition in Britain.
Unlike the leader we have now whose leadership challenge was financed by pro Israel lobbyist Trevor chin why did starmer refuse to name the donors throughout his campaign why? Yet long Bailey published a full list of doners .its odd Labour leadership stating the violence in israel must stop yet they accept donations from a pro Israeli supporter clearly starmer does not believe in clarity this is not surprising are the Labour membership going to investigate who financed starmers bid for leadership or are they going to over look this odd situation which does not sit well with Labour ethics. Time for the Labour Party members to step up to the plate and set up an independent investigaion
@@georgebodley8068 Time is overdue for an alternative party. Labour is dead and Starmer is a Zionist puppet.
@@adamdilem941 Campaign and start a new party. The New Communists?
@@matthewking5612
I am not a communist, not a socialist and not a capitalist.
My political views are Islamic and JC is the closest available in the UK whose values match mine.
@@adamdilem941 OK, I respect that, however Labour need to split.
A politician driven by truth, honesty and genuine desire to serve the needs of people. This is rather than to seek 'credibility' or 'electability' in the eyes of cancerous tabloid media moguls. We so often hear people talk about how demoralising it is to find elections to be a choice between one dishonest career politician, with no interest in actually serving the common good, or another. This man genuinely wants to see a rebalancing of the grossly unfair economic system we find ourselves slavishly working within so that work pays and that we end the rotten and immoral acceptance of the idea that any one person is so 'productive' that they 'earn' millions of pounds! It is so admirable that he knows the onslaught he will face from a morally debase and self interested media, in tandem with other self interested New Labour dinosaurs, yet he stands for real principles and real common good policies. If people want real change and real decency at the head of society, then they need to vote for it. Otherwise, vote for someone like Kendall and keep the same old same old in place.
I agree 100%
Politics is the art of the possible.
Every fairy tail begins with;
*Once upon on an election win....*
Nice man , but labour needs to be elected and he wasnt up to it
Have you changed your mind since? No doubt Corbyn's most ardent supporters genuinely believe he is a honorable man, but if you're willing to delve deeper into his history and those around him like Milne and Andrew Murray, then you'd come to realise they are very unpleasant individuals who are apologists for extremists and oppressive regimes around the world.
Corbyn even gave a speech in the commons in 85 in which he vehemently dismissed the Anglo-Irish agreement as strengthening the Irish border rather than weakening it. He was not interested in bringing about peace in Northern Ireland. He was an IRA sympathiser whether you like it or not and was prepared for thousands of more Irish citizens to die in a vain attempt to see a United Ireland just to satisfy his own ideological standpoint. Corbyn is a disgrace and he his sycophants are ultimately responsible for handing an incompetent Conservative government a landslide victory.
8 years ago Corbyn Calling for nationalisation of key industries that could have spared a lot of the misery we see today.
Are you sure it's a solution to the problem? There is no magic wand, and Corbyn is not a Fairy.
@@grus599 You don't need to be a fairy. Just have the rudimentary logic be able to understand that you get a better service per £1 spent when a profit doesn't need to be taken.
@@leefoster8015 no thank you, one big country lived this way 70+ years and collapsed.
@@grus599 We've ran our own country this way before. It's also the way our health service runs and it's actually very efficient just woefully underfunded. The USSR line is the Daily Mail easy street argument for people who are lacking in the economic knowledge required to debate properly.
@@leefoster8015 Human nature look after what belongs to him/her personally. Nobody CARES for something that belongs to everybody.
We need more surgeons and doctors coming over on the dinghys
lol
well if we trianed enough in our own country we wouldnt need any
@@nigget-tv-videos4135 when you let hundreds of thousands of people in you need more than you can make, it’s why people don’t want immigration as it effects the country in a negative way
@@hughmungus1235 quite agree - its a national disgrace! and ANYONE that dares to even mention it/ wants to debate it, is smeared as a racist!
We need a lot of people. But probably not you. We could do without you.
@@saltypork101 I wanna be like you
It's funny the journalist is a second generation migrant and he going on about immigration ....
I do not like his style of interviewing, extremely pompous and rude
+Ayat78 And the journalist wasn't even listening
+Ayat78 Why shouldnt immigrants get a say on immigration?
+Ayat78 Immigrants and their children are still entitled to question current and proposed immigration policy. In fact I have met a number of immigrants and their children who are quite critical of what they see as an open door policy. whereas when they came to this country they had to EARN their place in society. They worked very hard for their citizenship and to them, they feel bitter that people wishing to make a home in the UK now seem to be of the opinion they are entitled to it. Guru-Murthy may not even necessarily agree with this, yet it is a concern of the public, and as a journalist it is his job to ask the questions which certain members of the public want answered. Also, would you accuse him of being 'pompous and rude' were he to treat a right wing politician the same way? I have no doubt that he has...
Presumably his position would only be inconsistent if he advocated different immigration controls for now than what he would notionally advocate there to have been prior to his parents' coming to Britain.
Love this guy -- great views, great policies and most importantly puts people first.
He supports a terrorist group though
He was the greatest gift the Tories have ever known.
So glad the old man is history now
I agree..
Rob Luciano Me too! Last week someone at work ‘raised me up’ very high only to then ‘drop me like a stone’! I overheard Corbyn had been killed in a freak accident, but I later discovered they wished he’d been killed in a freak accident! The sigh was epic! 😩
Stevie Butla He should look in a mirror and say; “Now I understand why looney Labour lost!”
Corbyn nutral
Stevie Butla
A festering bellend surly?
05:10 - "Germany has done very well out of the economic contribution those people have made". WHAT contribution, you dimwit? Costs of around €3.5 billion a year? An outright lie.
Yes, an outright lie, and one which he confidently sold as an incontrovertible fact.
...And Guru-Murthy just waved it on through.
What an absolute horror of a "journalist".
@CAVEMAN I agree both in the room suck.
@CAVEMAN Corbyn doesn't know wtf he is doing, he always changes his mind whenever he fits and often doesn't respond. On the other hand, Krishnan is rude and tries to get people to say stuff they don't mean/want to say. This interview shows this, and personally I think it's great because you can show anybody this video and they will instantly know what we're talking about.
Hmm..you stole these words from my mouth. .horrible display of journalism.. .
Proly a very frustrated + very angry labour supporter interviewing a complete clown
IT IS TABLOID JOURNALISM Channel 4 News & WE'RE SICK OF IT!
You have someone here, #JeremyCorbyn , who does NOT need to rely on sound bites, Think Tanks or a Party line to answer a question. Something mainstream media seems to be uncomfortable with these days as it requires them to invest in some REAL JOURNALISM themselves instead of producing Off The Rack Q & A
Never mind the media, the Labour party is uncomfortable with him, because he is...gasp in horror, ' left wing'! WTF?
What Labour party would that be then Alison Matthew ;) ... The one Corbyn is breathing life in to ... 'coz I've not been aware of any such party since 1997
That's odd - Comment isn't visible unless I'm signed in - What've I done wrong now? Google+ TH-cam :(
Taking 60% of someone’s earnings, regardless of income bracket, is flat out tyranny.
no it isn't
Tyranny! haha! you people love words that echo a realm of political human rights grace when you don't actual believe in them. Tyranny is what is happening now. Jeff Bessos being one of the richest men on earth while his staff have no rights, and earn wages that do not cover basic living costs. 1% of the world's population owns over half of the world's wealth is tyranny.
teamcrumb Don’t hate people like Jeff Besos, aspire to be as successful as Jeff Besos. You’ll feel better about yourself.
@@teamcrumb his name is Jeff Bezos. Perhaps if you spent more time at school you would have done better and not now want communism to bail you out.
This guy is a living proof that ordinary folks will always be suppressed by the corporate greed
Corporate greed? U mean human greed?
luka zupie
Haven’t you heard? If everyone is equally poor then no one is oppressed (suppressed).
Problem solved!
He's answered all the questions so well :O
what I love about Jeremy Corbyn, is how he brings the stupidity of others to the surface, I thought (obviously mistaken), that Mr. Krishnan is OK as a journalist! not anymore!!! Mr. Corbyn as I said, have this uncanny ability to bring the stupidity of such journalist to the surface,
well done Mr. Corbyn
(next time Mr. Krishnan, just lose the ear-piece (the prompting), and show us that you have substance?!?!?!?!)
Isn't this interviewer the same one that pissed off robert downey jr?
Yep
Downey also acted like a child as he couldn’t engage on an intellectual level. Pretty typical of Hollywood elites, they are used to being pampered.
Fyodor48 Not at all, Krishnan was out of line. It’s a matter of respect. He was there to promote a film, not to be insulted about his past addictions and family issues, without an ounce of empathy in KGM tone.
And Tarantino.
Well done Jeremy corbyn
He lost BTW. Sorry
This interviewer keep on interrupting is rude and a bad interviewer.
He should be sacked immediately.
It's the Israeli agenda.
Corbyn should be deported to Syria
Since becoming voter this is the first time I look forward to vote. At last I can say, I like and agree with a politician!
Let's be clear.
If you're an illegal immigrant you cannot claim a penny.
Krishnan's questions are ambiguous
to say the least.
MSM has no interest in the truth. Their aim is to perpetuate right wing rule.
Youre right Neil, but that also means you dont pay any tax
You can also deal drugs, rape kids, thieve and terrorise.
Theyre SUCH an asset to us arent they.
@@davytornado9772 You won't be saying that when you're in hospital with coronavirus and one of these immigrants you so obviously hate, is a nurse or doctor looking after you
@@BernieHollandMusic I believe the topic was ' ILLEGAL' immigrants Bernie.
The kind that jump out of the back of a lorry in a motorway service area and disappear.
Not legal immigrants, working and paying their taxes.
Wind yer neck in.
And it's goodnight from him as the two Ronnies would say ... never to be heard of again
Corbyn won huge majority vote in Islington North and is still their local MP, the same job he has done for decades before being called upon to go for the leadership role by Momentum and Clive Lewis.
@@teamcrumb we will see
Cept for everyone picking over his manifesto...
@chris brady
He is fine, the people of Islington love him and he continues to be their MP.
How are you doing with Bozo the clown and the 150k he killed through his incompetence?
We the people are for the people. Viva La Revolution‼️
He knows he'll never achieve office.
What revolution if he'll never see no 10?
SuperTahira123 La revolúcion Cubana?
+SuperTahira123 We the people nothing. I live in Britain and he doesnt represent me or anybody were I live
João Manuel Gomes ah the Castro's.
They NEVER ran cocaine for the central Americans...:)
+SuperTahira123 Touch up on your socialist revolution history
Go Jeremy! This guy is special, you won't see many like him in politics.
…….and never more
Luckily hes an idiot
Special Needs
No more!!!! He ruined the party!!!
CAN I FINISH! Good news for the country Jeremy, you are finished.
As deluded then as he is today, how many times does he need to lose before it sinks in his politics no longer engage with the electorate.
@J Hibberd Hard left? Tf are you on about you clown. Is most of Scandinavia "hard left" now then? Absolute brainlet
8:50 and 10:10 Corbyn actually kicks off!
It's like being interviewed by Kelvin MacKenzie.
Upon questioning on the Middle East , Corbyn explodes like a rouge grenade when pushed for a real life answer.
Thank God he will never be the prime minister of the U.K.
No he was furious that he kept being held to explain if he was personal friends with Hamas because he'd addressed them as friends while trying to initiate a halt to military intervention. Boris Johnson is on record as stating people with a low IQ have less spiritual worth. I am a support coordinator for adult's with learning difficulties and watching that speech has broken a part of my soul. Hitler had the same thing to say about low IQs. The speech is old but it gets to show what constitutes the making of the likes of Johnson.
You right wingers don’t know anything
@@teamcrumb Good God man, did it take that for you to realize they really are Nazis? Are you completely unaware they've been eliminating the disabled and other jobless souls by stopping all their social security over the last 10 years? Eugenics in broad daylight, no one notices or cares, or they actually support it.
Ian Wood ...my exact sentiments ...a very toxic man
@@teamcrumb you lot are clueless. They are a terrorists organisation end of: you can’t call them friends, he actually calls them part of a peace process?? 😂 Christ get a clue you idiot
Critical of ending free movement? Doesn't sound like the Brexiteer he's made out to be.
I love that he calls him on his TheSun level journalism.
I don't think he once let him finish an answer without interrupting him. So impartial it makes me rejoice.
Who is the old man with the beard?
Steptoe ?
Keith Chamberlain ur mum.
He's gone thank God
UK ambassador for Hamas?
A nobody.
This is the guy who made Robert Downey Jr walk out of an interview promoting a movie. Tabloid journalism at its best.
Finest** lol
Corbyn is not as polished a performer as Blair or Cameron but it's hard to be slick when you're actually thinking and answering questions as opposed to parroting a pre-prepared message.
Guru-Murthy was interested in debating the issues or educating the public, only in the political pantomime. He wanted a controversial soundbite and a headline that would be easily edited and used to promote C4 News.
Well done to Corbyn.
At last a politician who has principles and answers questions directly!
2019 recommended?
What a waste of space. Jesus. I can’t believe anyone voted for him.
Yeah I mean who wants to vote for a decent, caring human rights defender who stood up for the most vulnerable in society.
@@robertpirsig5011 And also says "Hamas and Hezbola are part of a peace process" when both organisations would see the eradication of the jewish race.
haha troll. you know nothing. he has done so much good.. Brexit cost us the election, and you are just another working class masochist who voted for a party of privileged dishonest assholes who have never valued their constituents or had a single concern abut those living in squalor due to Tory cuts to support and public services. Shame on you, Jasper. every Tory voter should have a barcode that the NHS can read before you are offered treatment, and all of you fuckers that ignored all of the contracts sold so far and the further slow creep of the market mechanism being inserted into the NHS (which essentially is the countries largest market) should be refused treatment. You'll find trolling video from 4 years ago is of no use. You will not re-write history.
I can't say I'm a Corbyn fan, but political interviewing has a default "all politicians deserve a kicking" stance, so I'm glad he stood up for himself. Any answer that is longer than a sentence is interrupted and effectively dismissed by all interviewers in the current era. It just makes for awkward, disengaging and irritating television ultimately.
Doesn't it just. And it means that the public can't listen to arguments, or policy proposals: for all they hear is "Punch and Judy". 🙄
I think what Krishnan was really getting at here, the key issue for all us Sun and daily mail readers - DID YOU ADD HAMAS ON FACEBOOK JEREMY?!?!?!
'People and children come first.' Thank you Jeremy Corbyn.
L A who else lol. Doesn’t say anything really:)
🤣
@@Raabana1he supported Nelson Mandela
This is so deluded from a leader of a political party.
How's he deluded
He seems pretty on the case to me
ok yeah keep making no substance points because you cant formulate a proper argument
When's the deadline to hand in the assignment, Cheryl NO?
Where is your substance, again Cheryl NO
@@gavinwaterman5456 what?