Europe's New Border Force Explained
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- Watch my exclusive video about the global refugee crisis on Nebula:
nebula.tv/vide...
At least since the height of the so called European migrant crisis in 2015 there has been an ongoing process of finding answers to the challenges of increased migration. In order to meet these challenges, the EU is currently setting up an agency with the task of guaranteeing European border protection. The European Border and Coast Guard Agency - Frontex.
Neo on social media:
Twitter: / neoexplains
Facebook: / neo.youtube.fb
Images via Getty
Map source by MapTiler / OpenStreetMap Contributors via GEOlayers 3
1:45 "Checks and controls"
shows Czech flag and state coat of arms. Nice!
Doesn't it sound like a Czech TV show with cops steamed in an English speaking country?
Greece has had enough migrants. It is a country undergoing an economic recovery it cant support more people both economicaly and numericaly
Then why are they not bunting them out? It is almost like anyone who lands in EU can just take over; whoever the hell designed such suicidal laws?
@@utkarshg.bharti9714 you should look in to the NGOs funding and organising the importation of people in to European nations.
Like all those refugees love Greece so much? Lol they just wanna go to Germany France etc, Greece is just getting used as a dog by the European union. If Greece had some balls against Germany it would let the refugees in.
@@yurauro1900 You think those migrants love Germany or Sweden instead?
@@ddpmk355 more then Greece lmao
This guy is the definition of quality over quantity
Lemmino too
And Mustard. Great content.
Dude he's the chosen one what do u expect
@@Dixxi yo your so right his animations are god as well
**cough** **cough** Kurzgesagt **cough** **cough**
EVERYTHING you upload is AMAZING!
Yeah
Y u simp bro?
Thank you! I used your texture pack for the animations in this video ;)
I love both of you guys because of the godly editing
@@neoexplains which program/s you used for animations
The EU has the right to secure it's borders from any external threats or disturbances
Refugees are not a threat, they are fleeing war. Have some humanity
@@ibrahimkhatib1554 there is a difference between refugee and illegal immigrant.
Most that cross over are illegal immigrants. They are just using the middle east situation for their own benefit.
@@lianglonglong Like Syrians? Someone fleeing war and death is a refugee not an immigrant. They had no choice but to leave their home country or face death.
Greece and Spain commit illegal push-backs simply because majority of those people aren't illegal immigrants rather refugees who have a right to seek asylum!!! Greece can easily send illegal immigrants back to Turkey or Spain to Morocco but they can't send refugees back according to UN refugee convention 1951 therefore they just ''assume'' all those people are illegal immigrants without any proof nor investigation and forcefully push them back which is against international laws without any question at all...
@@ibrahimkhatib1554 yeah why they are fleeing. See what Is lamists are doing in Europe. Arson, riot, murder, r@pe, rampant in Europe due to these people.
5:14 Just wanted to let you know that corps is pronounced the same as core.
Standing corpse sounds so much more threatening lol
this is one of the reasons why the english language sucks😭
because reasons 🤷🏻
He probably pronounces it "corpse", as in Afrika Korps. That's European enough, especially in brown people removal context ...
@@miroslavhoudek7085 mad cause europe has had enough
Frontex sounds like the start of a standing EU army.
Hopefully
@@oldmandoinghighkicksonlyin1368NATO is the western world united, and I happen to like our American allies. The goal should be to cooperate, not divide.
@@oldmandoinghighkicksonlyin1368 Europe doesn't get a free ride, that is misinformation. The US gets to station tons of military in Europe, which they use as a threat against Russia and to send planes from to the Middle East. The US would never give anything for free.
@@oldmandoinghighkicksonlyin1368 True. NATO is a European scam to drain American taxpayers.
@@noxiteprova8878 yes they do only like three countries actually meet their defense commitments. And ststioning troops there costs Americans money. Either Russia is not a threat and it's waste of money to be there or it is a threat and europe has plenty of money to protect itself.
As a EU citizen I'm glad to hear. Frontex has my support.
I always wonder what goes through peoples’ minds when they hear about large agencies violating international laws and human rights, then continue to support them. Nevermind that the immigration rates are slowing down, or that Fortex’s utilization of drone surveillance is creepy, is that really the price to pay so that some conservative in his safe home can feel more at peace?
We have the same issue in the States. A right-wing who increasingly focuses on immigration, despite data pointing in the opposite direction, all so that they get a nice soundbyte at a rally. It’s silly.
@@DrOctatonic You really dont understand the problem do you? There is too much of these immigrants already, and they dont want to adopt our culture nor assymilate. Europeans are dying out because the immigrants have more children than an average EU couple. Europe should belong to Europeans and you shouldnt have a problem with that.
@@DrOctatonic come to Europe and see the areas they reside, you will boil with anger. These so called refuges are for free welfare and imposing their set barbaric laws in the civilized lands, please research before putting such nonsense in internet
Lol they called Trump in my country for border security yet Europeans agree it’s necessary
@@DrOctatonic I support Frontex because we need to control our external borders in order to maintain our internal borders open as they should be. You can't ask a nation or a federation to have no control over who enters its borders. Methods used should of course respect laws. I'm not an expert but it's reasonable to assume that drone surveliance is much more efficient in spotting migrants than boats patrolling. this means that with the same resorces more boats can be spotted and rescued saving more lifes, this is not said in the video. In view of future possible mass migrations caused by climate changes new international laws should be discussed to regulate the proces as much as possible. I'm proud to live in the EU that many consider soo much better that are ready to risk their lives to reach it, a well regulated immigration can be a resource as well as a bad regulated or disregulated one is a problem.
Isn't it perfectly fine to protect your borders?
Especially from someone who is trying to illegally enter it
Immigration due to suffered political or ideological persecution is not illegal. Demanding Asylum is not illegal.
Denying asylum and sending people back is not illegal, but that costs too much.
What technically seen illegal is, is to not hear these refugees out. Since you never know their reasons for emigration of their home country.
And forcing them to go back where they might get killed. That's the issue at hand. It isnt just black and white. There is alot of gray going on. ✌.
@@davgg9621 you are 100% right. This issue is very complicated. But I have an opinion which is quite unpopular in western Europe. I support Russian policy regarding refugees. We accept only refugees from Ukraine. These people don't have any problems with integrating in our community because the only difference between locals and them is pronunciation of the letter G ([h] instead of [gh]). They're not a threat because they have the same faith, mentality and level of education as we do. I know, it's quite cynical but safe for us
@@davgg9621 unfortunately there is a lot of “ gray “ in this you are right. But let be honest the most people ( over 90% ) who comes over the Mediterranean Sea or the Balkan route are Asylum seekers. They are escaping there homeland to have a “ better “ life.
@@glebbak19 absolutely agree with you.
Good, fortify the EU border and each state can choose how many immigrants it wants. That will greatly help EU stability and defeat euroskepticism, then the EU can prosper as a world superpower.
@BolinFYMThere are good arguments for both letting the immigrants in and keeping them out, however both of these groups don't see the big picture. If they really want to address the problem, they should focus their energy on the root cause of this issue, which is terrible living conditions in the middle east. The people who do actually get into the EU are just a small percentage of the people who suffer under terrible conditions at home. Doing this would satisfy everybody since we would both help the immigrants and stop their influx into the EU.
@@Domi-cv7oo The Problem is, that at the current rate of climat catastrophes getting more frequent, there are going to more and more refuges and some of them won't even have a home to return to or stay at anymore. If we don't combat problems like that and the many many wars being fought in those countries and instead just worry about letting people into our union, we will loose a big chunk of our humanity. So yes I agree. We have to combat the root of the problems, which isn't the migrants themselves.
@@catjuzu Unfortunately most of those in power do not have a moral compass. If they had one, they would do everything that is possible in order to create a better world. But instead, they only put up an image of morality and focus on gaining power and wealth. They are very intelligent people, and they are aware that global warming will cause mass famine and uninhabitability of large parts of the world. But they simply do not care, because this will not affect them personally, they will be long dead by the time the world is totally screwed up, so they focus on enjoying their life as much as possible.
@@Domi-cv7oo if they had a moral compass they wouldnt be in power in the first place. Life is not a fairytale and only the most ruthless gets to dominate.
@@miniaturejayhawk8702 Of course, I'm fully aware of that. I just find it depressing how we're headed for destruction because of our messed up nature, how because of our nature there is so much unnecessary suffering. But hey, at least we aren't living in the middle ages, where people would be burned alive for having such views.
Why are we surprised or enraged that an alliance consisting of 27 countries wants to protect its borders?
Because their actions against migrants are more often than not illegal. Whether or not you yourself think these countries have an obligation to receive migrants, the law does say you can't just turn them away with gunboats. If LAW ENFORCEMENT agencies aren't following laws, well, what is the point?
Either go for revising the UN charter on rights entitled for migrants, withdraw from it (and receive the understandable backlash) or stop breaking laws. You can't just keep breaking international treaties you signed up to.
Because they made the problems, they should have take the consequenses which are the immigrants
The migrants are breaking the law by not respecting borders
@@chinguunerdenebadrakh7022 The law mentions refugees and not migrants. They are not refugees but migrants like you mentioned.
because they have laws saying they won't, and there's internal disagreement about it. we're just saying they have to either follow their own rules or change them.
I miss the awesome intro! Always got me hyped and ready for a new Neo video
Just by comparing the sheer size of the countries where immigrants come from with the EU should make it clear why we need this agency.
You’re aware that the surface area of a country is a terrible metric for population totals, right?
@@coenogo I knew that I would get such a moronic reply.
Everybody who wants to understand my comment does understand it.
@@Sagittarius-A-Star Then explain it to me, so that I can understand it. And how is my reply 'moronic', when I'm simply stating a fact?
@@coenogo i think by size he refers to amount of countries, which is not wrong
@@magnuscoles5010 Then he should/would have said “the sheer *number* of countries”
living for a year in greece, thessaloniki. surprised by the amount of arabic speaking immigrants…and by how they let you know their presence
How do they let you know of their presence?
@@supersecularboypants they do a lot of rioting.
I love how muslims speak sh1t about non muslims but then also try to get in those countries
@@supersecularboypants Modest clothing, darker features (more apearent in Northern and Western Europe), accents, and even slight things like what they buy at the grocery store can greatly sway your opinion if the person is an expat or not.
Θεσσαλονίκη? Cool!! DJ LOSER is from there! I’m from California, but yeah, he’s a favorite musician of mine.
I am an EU citizen and I support the idea of a unified defence agency, Frontex. I also support the EU army. Enough of cold war unnecesairy NATO.
Wtf wasnt the EU army a conspiracy theory a couple years ago?
@@KVQ0 everything is a conspiracy if said soon enough
Well said. Imagine what Europe can do with an entire NATO budget.
Let's vote! ...realy can we???
EU army would be great
GOOD. Europe is finally starting to wake up. after decades of others walking over us we slowly start to realise we need to take matters back into our own hands
Will never forget the innocent grandma beheaded on the streets of nice city.
Same here.
Who beheaded her?
@@A.S.D442 Who do you think? "PARIS/NICE, France (Reuters) - A knife-wielding Tunisian man shouting “Allahu Akbar” (God is Greatest) beheaded a woman and killed two other people in a church in the French city of Nice on Thursday before being shot and taken away by police.".
Soon to be "Islamic European Union".
Well Europe is going to become a Islamic caliphate of 21st century.
As a former migrant myself, the vast majority of people aren't refugees or anything of that kind. People just run from their countries in search of a better life. Which I don't mind as long as they learn the language and blend into the culture, which is rarely the case and is unacceptable
Greece and Spain commit illegal push-backs simply because majority of those people aren't illegal immigrants rather refugees who have a right to seek asylum!!! Greece can easily send illegal immigrants back to Turkey or Spain to Morocco but they can't send refugees back according to UN refugee convention 1951 therefore they just ''assume'' all those people are illegal immigrants without any proof nor investigation and forcefully push them back which is against international laws without any question at all...
@@ggoddkkiller1342 well we can't let millions of people in, there's just not enough resources for that
@@oleksandr6187 Then EU must force assad for the reforms he already promised which would convince many refugees to return or establish a safe zone inside Syria!! But does EU do anything about those subjects??? NOPE, even if there are several thousand French etc soldiers inside Syria!! Rather they are beating refugees...
@@ggoddkkiller1342 it's not their business to meddle into other countries internal affairs.
@@oleksandr6187 It isn't their internal affairs if they displace more than 12 million people that 8 million of them became refugees in other countries!!..
I'm from Switzerland and the amount of migrants passing thrugh to go from Italy to Germany (or coming to stay in Switzerland) was ridicolous a couple years ago.
are they now sending them back tho?
@@nuibui6667 Very rarely, they don't usually say where they come from, and even when we know, African/Islamist countries don't want them back.
The problem now is these people in the boats are 95% immigrants not refugees or asylum seekers. They see a better way of life on their smart phones, hence the huge rise in the past 10 years.
citation needed
@@-morrow and citation needed for all of this video.
Greece and Spain commit illegal push-backs simply because majority of those people aren't illegal immigrants rather refugees who have a right to seek asylum!!! Greece can easily send illegal immigrants back to Turkey or Spain to Morocco but they can't send refugees back according to UN refugee convention 1951 therefore they just ''assume'' all those people are illegal immigrants without any proof nor investigation and forcefully push them back which is against international laws without any question at all...
@@ggoddkkiller1342 Good on Greece & Spain for doing that. These fake refugees should go left or right instead of always heading for Europe. The majority of these people are just opportunists looking for a job. Push them all away, fix your problems in your own countries and don't make them ours.
@@dkpirie Fake refugees? I guess according to you ridiculous people there aren't 3.6 million Syrian refugees in Turkey rather they are just ''fake'' numbers, huh?? And it is ''their own problems'' due western countries never ever invaded countries one after another in the region, never supported shady groups and even terrorists like US support to alqaeda between 1979 and 1989, right??? You people are such biased jokes...
Neo, I just watched your project that you mentioned at the end of this video. It's harrowing, and given me an insight into how lucky and grateful I am to be living in a peaceful country.
Thank you for this new perspective!
Thank you!
> is thankful for living in a peaceful country
> Wants people who aren't peaceful in her country
@@nostro1940 i never said that! i just said i'm grateful to live in a good country.
i don't know where you got that assumption from haha
@@nostro1940 what do you mean by "people who aren't peaceful" ? how can a refugee be a threat?
@@ibrahimkhatib1554 thats the thing. You assume something that isn't true. They aren't refugees but economic migrants.
2021 and people still fall for that
This was an interesting topic. Your animations are quite good.
Thank god this finally happened. This shitshow went on for way too long. Better late than never though. My gratitude goes to the Frontex guards for keep Europe safe.
cringe
Safe from what?
@@richpryor9650 From people that are trying to enter illegally
Frontex isn't new though. They've been a thing for many years.
love the new map of EU without UK LOL
Amazing videos with very professional content as always!!
I like the look too but without the UK Frontexs budget is payed 50/50 from France and Germany.
I love the map of EU without the U.K. too, our economy will finally prosper
@Milschisch huge loss for the EU but us in the U.K. are very happy
So happy to not be included in this federal creep. Like the British Land Rovers though.
@@tornadochaser7226 I know why ur happy and it’s great that finally someone left the EU but Germany won’t ever leave the EU
Honestly, border safety is super important
To be fair to Frontex, making "pushbacks" illegal and then condemning them for outsourcing border enforcement to foreign coastguards is putting them in a bit of a catch 22 situation.
why not spend the millions for the planes on some sort of larger ship where you can legally check and register each refugee and legally deport them afterwards if they are not allowed to enter? the goal should be to protect the boarders AND save the refuges that can not go home duo to risk of their life. if the goal is to protect without thinking about human lives they might as well sink the boats imo. the current system (as this video described it) sounds like smth china would do with nord korea tbh
@@dawre3124 That's not really practical. It can take months or even years to process an asylum claim because there is such a massive backlog. A ship holding thousands of asylum seekers for a very long time is a logistical and safety nightmare. It would become a floating refugee camp within days.
Next up a common EU defense force/corps, we have relied on usa for defense far to long now and I don’t like that we have what it takes to protect ourselves and to be a global powerhouse
As if the USA will allow it...lol! If this were to happen, the CIA will likely stage some false flag attack, raise the boogeyman of "evil Russia" and then Germany and Swedistan will crap their pants and run towards the USA.
The problem is that France wants to use EU army as their own, while Germany does not want any army and prefers making business deals with the enemies.
@@utkarshg.bharti9714 LOL CIA doesn't have to do anything. Most important EU countries are Germany and France. Germany is selling weapons to Turkey despite Greece protest while France is allied with Islamist warlord in Libya. Every EU countries knows they cant trust EU army.
@@utkarshg.bharti9714 That's not how the CIA operates.
our lord USA wont let us have common army, remember we are occupied vassels, nothing else
Raising concerns about "pushbacks“ or "human rights" is so naive to not even recognise the implicit demographic warfare that Turkey (and to a lesser extent Morocco) play against Europe.
In fact, it has been Turkish state policy since the times of Özal to flood Greece with (Muslim) migrants and destabilise it that way.
Hahahahahhahahahahah
Classic conspricy theory of greek mindset
@@alperenbaser7952 read ‘The Strange Death of Europe’ by Douglas Murray. A book on demographics, immigrations and forecasts.
Europe is dying and being replaced.
Greece and Spain commit illegal push-backs simply because majority of those people aren't illegal immigrants rather refugees who have a right to seek asylum!!! Greece can easily send illegal immigrants back to Turkey or Spain to Morocco but they can't send refugees back according to UN refugee convention 1951 therefore they just ''assume'' all those people are illegal immigrants without any proof nor investigation and forcefully push them back which is against international laws without any question at all...
@@ggoddkkiller1342 they are illegally entering a state with most of the times without ID, so that makes them illegal immigrants. if I was you just go and educate yourself.
Push them back !
Greece and Spain commit illegal push-backs simply because majority of those people aren't illegal immigrants rather refugees who have a right to seek asylum!!! Greece can easily send illegal immigrants back to Turkey or Spain to Morocco but they can't send refugees back according to UN refugee convention 1951 therefore they just ''assume'' all those people are illegal immigrants without any proof nor investigation and forcefully push them back which is against international laws without any question at all...
@@ggoddkkiller1342 thats not true anymore, more recently the number of actual middle eastern refugees has decreased significantly and today most who come to europe, are economic migrants from africa, turkey and yes, also the middle east
@@mate_salamanca There are 3.6 million Syrian refugees in Turkey while illegal immigrants are only 373 thousand so vast majority of those people are refugees without any question!! So that ''refugee numbers have decreased'' is just a part of political scheme to declare all those people illegal immigrants not refugees and push all of them back against international laws...
Yesssss, get them out of Europe❤🇪🇺
Democrats in the US: we should accept migrants.
Your "Unknown City" video on Nebula was absolutely phenomenal and a beautiful watch, incredible content neo!!
Thank you so much!
The Refugee convention was never intended to refer to migrants en masse in their hundreds of thousands, millions or tens of millions. It was supposed to be intended for small numbers, and in that context it is completely fair. However, when you have migration en masse, the convention ceases to have any relevance.
I wonder if a time will come when countries fed up with mass immigration will opt out of the Refugee Convention. I wonder if it is even possible to opt out.
That's not really accurate, given that part of the motivation for the convention came in the aftermath of WWII, where thousands of Jews sought asylum and were denied. Things are obviously more complicated than that alone, but to claim that mass migrations were not thought of is incorrect.
Nonsense. Refugees by definition come in big waves. Each war creates s huge number of refugees in a short time. E.g. all the people evacuated out of Afghanistan this summer. Or the many millions displaced by world war two.
frontex is a step in the right direction, a key part of a europeanized Defence and Security apparatus ready to take on any challenges or threats from outside
Brexit has probably made the EU realise that migration needs to be taken more seriously, otherwise more members states will choose to leave. Hopefully, this enhanced border force will prove to be effective and unify the EU on issues relevant to the 21st century.
Brexit has probably ALLOWED the EU to finally put forward solutions, as the UK alsways vetoed any step in that direction.
@@fedethefico They do what their American masters tell them too.
@@homijbhabha8860 You mean the UK? The EU is much more nuanced.
@@fedethefico Yeah I meant UK
@@fedethefico Except that the UK is crazy strict about borders. Even before Brexit, you couldn't just get in if you were European. You had to get your passport checked, they hand check your luggage, sometimes they'd even ask for proof of no criminal record. UK's tight, so why would they be against a stricter European border patrol?
Man I don't understand the TH-cam algorithms. This is just as good as any of your other vids, but the views are down. It's just odd
the animations would make you a top tier creator alone, but you have an incredible way of telling the story. not just in this video, but the one on the Line, california’s water problem, all of your videos are amazing.
Again another informative video. I'd encourage maybe a slight title change. It wasn't immediately clear, at least for me, what the video was about
What do you suggest?
@@neoexplains honestly didn't expect a reply and I cannot say I have a great title in mind. The only idea I have is "How Europe's Approach to Immagration is Changing." You make amazing videos deserving of millions of views and I'd hate for any of them to be overlooked due to confusion. I wish I could be of a better help
@@g-rated3514 I tried something new now with the title and thumbnail. Let's see what happens.
@@neoexplains I pray it works!
Dont know if anyone wil see this, but Croatia finally joined the Schengen Area on 1st of January 2023✌🏻
if we could move further away from Africa, like several thousand miles, we would do it in a heartbeat.
Why?
@@KVQ0 if we import the third world, we will become it.
@@KVQ0 Because we don't want their people and problems here. Same goes with the middle east. Those regions and people are so different to us in terms of religion, culture and secularism that an exchange without conflict is not possible.
How do you see the effects on the ground from your eyes James. as an American Im curious.
@@jamie8032
But the west has been ransacking and exploiting the 3rd world for how long now? You import there raw minerals why not take the people too? You cant have it both ways
EU should give all those immigrants free ride to USA, so they can deal with mostly their caused problem.
jeez, this comment section has so much disregard for human life and ignorance about the conditions creating the refugee crisis
Absolutely love this channel, neo feels like the lemmino of current social events
THOSE PUSHBACKS ARE GOOD IN MOST CASES. FRONTEX IS GOOD. THIS IS WHAT MANY EUROPEANS WANT I THINK :)
Yes we need this
What YOU want! Europe is open to immigrants, yk basic human rights, nationalists are hurting this idea
first help all the members of EU to live up to the same life standards as the western members, then you can look into solving the issues of others
Every nation has the right to protect its borders. Europeans should work together on defending their countries for the sake of their children and grandchildren.
Besides that, great video.
"Protect their borders" from which threat?
@@cerostymc the major threat of becoming the third world, by importing it. With all negative things related to it, such as high crime rates, corruption and civil unrest.
The city of Malmö did not become Europe’s rape capital because of Björn and friends.
Poland is well known for wanting to protect EU borders, and that's a great thing.
What is the point of having a border force if they do not enforce the boder???
Because there are no internal border, exterior ones are very important, because for example if a terrorist is able to enter one countrie he would be able to travel to multiple countries with out being stop in a border.
What? Thats exactly what they do.
a border force job is to enforce the boder daahhhhhhh
Euopre isn't a melting pot of cultures, that's America.
Europe has a clear identity, with each nation having millenia old history, which it wants to preserve.
EU Citizen here, Frontex is one of the best initiatives in the past years, the only way a person can pass a border is by following the legal set out path for border crossing. More power to Frontex.
What you showed in the video is not considered a "pushback" according to the definition you used, because A) They did not reach European territory yet since they are at the sea, they can't be pushed "back" from a place they've never been to, B) They are not being sent to a country where they might face persecution, Turkey has millions of refugees too and it's a vey stable country with a decent economy, it's not Syria.
PROTECT EU BORDERS!!! that's the mandate most voted for ;))
Immigration is like a boat. One boat sinks and so many can be saved before your's get capsized. Now you're the bad actor trying to save your own boat and its passengers. That's just life.
I really like your style. Hopefully, Neo grows bigger.
What a callous perspective. Rather than addressing the root causes of the problem, or the problem itself, you’re arguing that we ignore it - explicitly saying it would be permissible to let people die if it means you don’t have to make personal sacrifices.
Maybe you should focus on building more lifeboats
@@PausePause98 lmao. Maybe YOU should get better at swimming down there.
@@PausePause98 so there are hundred boats, yours is the biggest and safest, the other boats start having some problems, people on those boats instead of fixing the problem jump onto your ship and bring it to the brink of capsizing.
How is it your responsibility to fix their boat when they aren't doing it themselves. If they fix their own boat, then sure, you should help them fix it. But leaving your own boat to drown and jumping on someone else's is a parasitic mentality, which isn't useful in any society. It will only bring chaos.
@@navdeepkumar5085 great argument, West Germany should have rejected East Germans fleeing political persecution, suppression of speech and poverty. Sweden should have closed its doors to Danish jews fleeing from the Nazi invasion. United States should have closed its doors to all Irish immigrants fleeing starvation.
There are MANY occasions where one doesn't have a reasonable chance of improving their "boat". Syrians tried, they protested for freedom and prosperity, the dictator's army shot them. That's how the Syrian Civil War started in the first place. The war is outside the hope of any normal Syrian to change the tide. There's Russian jets bombing them, Iranian weapons flowing in, Turkish armies eyeing their most powerful militias (aka the Kurds).
@@chinguunerdenebadrakh7022 all the above countries you mentioned above had been within reasonable rights to refuge those coming to them. They could accomodate them, so they did.
What I'm saying is those countries won't and shouldn't be doing it when they themselves are at the risk of going under, that's not a risk any govt has a right to, when citizens aren't willing.
Frontex is doing gods work
Good. As they should
The UK probably wouldn't have left the EU if Frontex had been stronger at the time of the migrant crisis.
The UK is strong enough to take things head-on. the EU meanwhile depends only on France's independent stand while Germany is a US puppet state since 1945.
@@utkarshg.bharti9714 all of Europe is an American puppet state.
the Uk is not part of schengen and so wasn't impacted by that. Furthermore the Brits was largest blocker of more unification.
Keep the quality. When I see a neo video now, I trust that it's good.
He has returned!
Frontex was something the EU should have had since the beginning. But these are fantastic developments overall, thankfully the EU is growing balls.
This force is doing a commendable job .. Saving europe from a looming disaster ..
looming disasters of accepting asylum seekers from countries in a state of war, like every other country is entitled to do by international law? You realise NATO and many countries within the EU are the one purportrating the massacres of civillians in the countries people are fleeing?
@@AutonomousPlayground Ah yes the EU is commiting massacres, nice joke.
Those asylum seekers should seek refuge legally
no matter what kind of video you upload, it is always of the absolute highest quality.
Do u love Erdogan?
We need more content like this on TH-cam, this is amazing!
Finally its about time
Are we NOT going to talk about those wheels synced with the shutter speed at 0:45 ? Anyone...? OK, don't mind me XD
Thought the same.
I am a greek citizen. I wish we could just accept them, offer them a new home and make them a part of our country, but we can not. Our economy is already struggling, and we can't handle so many people at once. I hate to say it but, we need to protect the borders.
@Accelerationist replace? We had waves of immigration in the past and so many people from other countries have come and actually assimilated into our culture. I was friends with a lot of them and their kids and, although they might not look like your stereotypical Greek person, they could speak fluently Greek and some even followed the Greek traditions. Those people might be of different culture and religion, but that doesn't mean they become a replacement of my culture if they settle here, provided it can be done properly.
@Accelerationist blood means nothing to me. What difference does it make if someone is not from an indigenous family. For all I know, I could have roots from another country
@Accelerationist I disagree
@Accelerationist bro you tell me how blood is everything?
@Accelerationist Where ya from?
Such a great content, so much information and stunning graphics with a calm storytelling voice! Thank you for creating this channel and putting so much effort into the quality!
If united states say that eu is breaking geneva convention laws then maybe they should take them.
Otherwise they should shut up and let us deal with the problem.
This is a good thing. I just hope the legal migrants, those who have been living in Europe for a long time, won't be discriminated bc of this.
@@diamassserum2107 lol
@@flannel_punk unless or until they have Western facial features, I don't think they would be offended
@Guts Then why’d did you leave it and were the first to leave
@Guts I don’t believe in illegal immigration either but you don’t have to make opinions so shallow and unthoughtful.
At 8:00 you are mentioning that pushback of migrants is illegal under EU Law. While that is true, the things happening in Greece / Turkey and Italy / Libya are not pushbacks. The refugees will not be persecuted in Libya or Turkey because of their race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion. If they are running away from a war, like Ukrainian or Syrian refugees (the Syrian civil war is over soon), they have to be sheltered, but if they just hope for a better life economically speaking, the legal way would be to apply for a working visa, not entering the country illegally.
You also forgot the Algerian route Spain, and Libya to Italy.
Need those old intro to set the vibe .. though, awesome content 👍
I have an EU law exam in 2 weeks, and i still don't understand anything.
there should be pushback . you cannot just let everyone into your country that how homelessness and poverty run rampant not to mention crime
Crime rate between immigrants is same to native pop., if not less. As for homelessness and poverty, they are the affected ones, so...
At this point I'm a foreigner in my own country
I live In Brussels
@Accelerationist I'm Belgian and I agree
@Accelerationist Ja ik ben ook Vlaming haha
@Accelerationist Ja man haha
As a French, it makes me sad of what is happenning to our Belgian brothers.
My country is now fight back, a bit late, but still.
But what about Belgium ? Is there some good news ? Like banning of Islamists organization, rising of nationalist parties, stronger migration policy passed in the parliament, etc...
@@mrsupremegascon Yes, as you may know Belgium has a Dutch part in the North and a French part in the South. In the North the far right party named "Vlaams Belang" will win the next elections with around 26% of the votes.
The second biggest party will get 20% of the votes and is a central right oriented party. The sad part is that the French part in the south (32% of the Belgian population) votes extreme left... That's because most immigrants live in the southern part and Brussels. 70% of these Africans came to Belgium with a French passport and adopt Belgian nationality afterwards :( So if France can stop letting everyone in we can also stop the problem with African immigration. Succes with Le Pen or Eric Zemmour
This was literaly the topic of my final exam a month ago, couldnt you guys have made this vid 2 months ago?🥲😂
After creating its own standing army, the EU will be much closer to unification under one government in the next couple decades!
@Nikolas Benko As a person from Bulgaria I can relate to them since in the beginning we also had a lot of problems with the immigrants. Luckily our friendly relations with Erdogan and Turkey helped us, but this just puts more pressure on the Greek side of the border. To compensate, we opened our dams to increase the Maritsa river's (The river is the border between Turkey and Greece but it starts in Bulgaria) water volume, which only endangers immigrant lives, but it proved somewhat effective. When the EU couldn't assist us further we turned to Turkey which was very cooperative, sadly Hungary didn't have anyone to lend them a hand, as you said. Plus the couple thousand refugees in Bulgaria live in poor conditions because the EU forced them on us and we could only settle them in the old Soviet-era military bases.
🤦 It's a border police, not a standing army.
Good.
Europe will never be unified under 1 gouvernement. Europe isn't 1 thing. It's 50 different countries. Always have been. I'm not french or German. Don't care about them. Only care about my own people.
dude the map has a typo in morocco.,.. its with an O not an A, #3:22
What do you want to do??? Its not possible that the whole syria and afghanistan lives in Europe
Very well made video. Vice quality. Well done.
Just by looking at the location of Frontex's Headquarter (Warsaw) you can assume what will be their approach to dealing with illigal migrants.
Safe Europe must be our priority!
Yeah.. so glad Frontex headquarters are in Warsaw and not in Brussels. 😄
best EU decision ever made to place Frontex HQ in Poland. now we can rest assured the immigration problem will be solved
I don't trust the pis party. They have been systematically firing judges and journalists that don't agree with them. They are right wing extremists that only care about power, no matter how much they have to destroy their court system to keep it.
neo informs better than my state broadcasting company
Just found this channel it’s very nice keep it up!
In India we have the largest border guarding force in the world. The Border Security Force (BSF) , Is the force that protects the border from illegal immigration, drugs, bad stuff, etc. In war time they assist the Army. They are mainly stationed in Indo-Pak and Indio-Bangladesh Border. Kindda weird that such forces are not incorporated in many counties.
Incoparted means
@@manureddy6195 it means to include/incorporate
Great video.
One thing I noticed is at 5:13 it’s not pronounced like a corpse (body) but pronounced french. It still means “body” so corpse is the same word...
FRONTEX are heroes of Europe
There’s a lot of posturing and politics in their actions, but the existence of Frontex makes sense
You deserve 10 times as many subs, keep up the great work!
There is nothing controversial about protecting the EU borders and it needs to be done!
Guys, the problems are not being caused by Syrians, Kurds, Iraqis or afghans running from war, but by Tunisians, Nigerians, Moroccans, Egyptians, Pakistanis...
Syrians don't have time for this, they're just happy to be alive, so are the Afghans.
at least Greece no longer has to pay for the European Border Security in that area.
yes, the Greek gov't did lie to get inside the EU & they were (to say the least) budgetarily disorganised, but most of the costs with border patrolling & immigrant detention were EU expenses paid for by the Greek budget only.
Absolutely! The Italians too - the rest of the EU just abandoned the frontier states to the job, at a time when they were least able to afford it. I'm glad that's finally getting sorted out...
Schengen is not within the EU. The Schengen agreements covers several countries outside the EU, and does not cover Ireland (an EU member) either. It also didn't use to cover the UK.
Just yesterday I thought to myself: It’s been a while since neo uploaded something new, also first comment
Very useful information.
Please bring back the intro video/music!
Great video though Neo!
Is that a rhetorical question? And where is the question mark?
How did you do that animations. Which program you used.
Please, you or someone who know enlighten me
Another amazing video!
the EU is setting up the force not europe
Is fantastic to hear that EU is defending his borders after so long time.
Oooooooh, love the material on the buildings in The Unknown City. I ❤️ a bit of sub surface scattering.
and yet they only have to stop exploiting other countries starting wars and stop interfering in meanly every African country affairs .... for example in Niger the French use child labor to extract Uranium for its nuclear reactors the country itself don't have enough electricity ... Spain do it best to keep illegal migration numbers low but do it best to maintain a conflict in southern Morocco for decades it's economic and security partner
I highly doubt children are in uranium mines. They would be a waste of space down there.
This is the kind of video I would watch despite losing sleep. Awesome🙏🙏🙏
It's 2022, and I don't see frontex people in the Ukranian borders. What's up with those double standards?
Their european, the ones this video is talking about are syrian iraqi and libyan and stuff
In case you're deaf or blind, FRONTEX mostly operates in the south, where local agencies can't handle the influx of immigrants (this was clearly established in the video). The Ukrainian border is successfully being handled by the EU nations that neighbor it, therefore there is no need for FRONTEX's assistance. Not to mention Ukraine is an EU Candidate State, making the situation slightly incomparable to the situation in the south.