Amy`s version is so dramatic that it`s impossible to listen to without having tears in your eyes! Beyonce`s version is hypnotic, I can`t deny, but it lost all the drama and tragedy
I've listened to Amy's original at least 4 times today already... "And I'll go back to...." listening to the legend sing it! Amy has a way to draw you in to her story. As tragic as it was. It's Amy's story. I'm not sure how you can turn her story, her lyrics, into something else.
Can y'all please stop comparing the two versions of the song. Of course, we all know that a cover or remake never beats the original, but I don't think that this was Beyoncé's goal here. It's just a Queen paying homage to a Queen👑👑💍
I'm not even a Beyoncé fan, but this cover isn't nearly as bad as you guys make it out to be ... it's actually quite good, obviously not even comparable with Amy's version. It's Amy's song and she sings it with so much raw pain and emotion, no one is ever going to sing this song nearly as good as Amy ♥ but what I really like about this version is that Beyoncé doesn't even try to sing it exactly like Amy and imitate her style or the sound of her voice, but instead made her own thing out of this song. It's incredibly hard to cover Amy Winehouse and I think Beyoncé did a decent job :) (Kinda wish she would've included the "kept his dick wet" line though)
its a damn good effort, beyonce was mind blown back stage at glastonbury with her hub, good effort bey, i thinks it pretty deep, amys will and always be unique, its a god send from artists to say you and always will be a vessel of mayor, she premature will always be here
Beyoncé tiene el talento, pero Amy Winehouse transmite sus emociones, vivencias como la tristeza, el desamor, te lleva juntó con ella a través de sus canciones.
I love you much It's not enough You love blow, and I love puff And life is like a pipe And I'm a tiny penny rolling up the walls inside We only said goodbye with words I died a hundred times You go back to her And I go back to We only said goodbye with words I died a hundred times You go back to her And I go back to Black Black Black Black Black Black Black I go back to I go back to We only said goodbye with words I died a hundred times You go back to her And I go back to We only said goodbye with words I died a hundred times You go back to her And I go back to black
This is great!! Love her and it... But Amy! Omg she’s a queen and I’m truly upset she has passed... she was stressed and this song was so depressing to her but people loved it ): love and miss you Amy xx your safe now xo
y’all need to quit hating.. it’s not gonna have the same that Amy’s had because it’s not supposed to, it was remixed to fit in an EROTICA movie. use your brains
Stop hating this cover i think this cover is pretty cool and dark "there is no emotions!" Of course it doesn't have to be emotional it has to be sexy Beyonće's voice is so pretty and she can skng this song like she can sing many songs cant be Amy of course no one can be other (except selena) but someone is dead doesn't mean no one can sing he or her songs so calm down this is just a cover
And the fact that this song is used for "The Great Gatsby" and since the movie wasn't even about emotions or something like that,but they the song to be more sensual and sexy so it's not Beyoncé's fault
i dont understand. i dont know who amy is but i respect whoever she is. the only thing that left me dumbfounded is why most of the comment section were hating on beyonce? someone explain to me?
@Yennafer's Tarot Bar this is true and Beyoncé put her own spin on the song. Beyoncé is very talented but as much as I love this song. I’m just not a fan of her version. 😊
Amy is a very good artist, but don’t say she’s better than Beyonce. The only reason why people think she’s the best artist on earth is because of her death. It is very sad, but don’t put Others down to raise one up. They are both Queens.
Alex Thomas Chile. No, we think Amy is better by far, because of her musical talent and potential, more potent than Amy’s. So don’t even go there - and to add as well, people also thing Amy is better, as proven by her huge success after just TWO albums. How many of Beyoncé’s albums did it take for her to get worldly famous? Exactly, no hate against Bee ofc. But Beyoncé comes from a different genre of music, it’s just odd that she’s taking on Amy’s genre of music. But that’s just my thoughts and opinion 💋
Sebastian Gonzalez I really felt like Beyoncé had more emotion. While I listened to Amy's version I actually thought she didn't have much feeling. Maybe I should give them one more listen.
Incognito Really? You felt emotion in this and not in the original??? LOL! I respect your opinion, but this is the funniest thing I have read in a while..
I can't feel anything bro how can I know what they feel? They feeling money coming what do you think they feeling like taking a shit? What bullshit feeling I enjoy both, like the beat here more,but I want full version of youngblud cover nuff said
Beyonce totally nailed it this time.. no doubt.. the song music, the deepness of tone and the feel of serious romance just pour down from this song.. yeah what amy sung is different and excellent but this is what required for this movie.. it totally justifies
It's not that bad. Yes nobody will be like Amy but Beyonce sings it in her own style, she doesn't try to be like Amy anymore. So that's why you shouldn't compare this to Amy's song. I think Beyonce sings so good in her own way.
Nooooo porque distorsionar horriblemente un éxito tan grande de nuestra querida Amy , obvio Beyoncé jamás tendrá el éxito de esta canción, no debió hacerlo
Amy's song (Back to black) is always the best song. It doesn't matter, how much Beyoncé try to copy Amy's song, Amy's song still be the most awesome song.
No se puede !!! Amy t trasmite dolor sentimiento cantaba con el corazon en la mano yo lo sentia asi t daban ganas d llorar esa voz rasgada d dolor! ! Beyoncé m gusta pero no le queda este tema lo lleva a lo sensual y no da lo desvirtua!
ErickDanielMx Beyonce has a very polished and powerful singing voice. Her dedication to perfection is evident, but with her perfection she's denied herself true soul in her voice. She hits all the notes well but theres lack of depth and soul in her voice, she's like a player piano. Just my opinion. Don't mean to disrespect, just don't think she's the right fit to cover Amy winehouse.
ViolistRichard the good thing with this cover is that she is being jer own self rather than trying to be amy, that is why most covers of an amy winehouse song are bad. The bad thing is amy had a raspy deep voice full of pain and emotion and beyonce has a higher pitched voice that doesn’t show as much emotion, especially in this song.
I actually like both versions .... i understand each of them... beautiful
True.
Amy's version is more emotional, Beyonce's version is more sensual to a romantic-erotic movie
Amy`s version is so dramatic that it`s impossible to listen to without having tears in your eyes! Beyonce`s version is hypnotic, I can`t deny, but it lost all the drama and tragedy
I've listened to Amy's original at least 4 times today already...
"And I'll go back to...." listening to the legend sing it! Amy has a way to draw you in to her story. As tragic as it was. It's Amy's story. I'm not sure how you can turn her story, her lyrics, into something else.
@@TheProletariat. well people can interpret how ever they wants to in a song that's the speciality of story telling.
Beyonce = versión nefasta
Exatamente
I love both versions and I don't understand the bad review for this, it's great.
When u make something your own, people either cry about it or love it. And I love it
Me encanta esta versión!!🌟
her vocals though
Nothing compares with sadness, frustration and raspy voice of Amy Winehouse
Perfeita! Perfect! 😍♥️ Beyoncé ♥️ Amy ♥️
Perfeita 😍
Amy Winehouse is always the best best.
So Win I agree
Esta mas chida la original
So Win Hi!
Please take a look on my channel!
I need alot of support with my music.
Yes👑❤️
I agree with you
Rip Amy❣️ Beyoncé Did her thang tho why y’all so mad 🧐🧐
WTH,Why is everybody saying that she can't sing this song?
She cover the song that she wants,she slayed!!!
JUST A LITTLE RESPECT ✌
R.I.P Amy ❤🙏
Rainha é Rainha ❤
Can y'all please stop comparing the two versions of the song. Of course, we all know that a cover or remake never beats the original, but I don't think that this was Beyoncé's goal here. It's just a Queen paying homage to a Queen👑👑💍
Exactly ❤❤
May be different than the original but this is good af !!! I even like it more
I still like it, both Beyonce and amy singing it beautifully , both of them have the own style , I love both version . RIP amy⚘
Naz Par she is mking the song sound sexual...the song ia not about this. This aint right.
Naz Par well sorry gurl you must be deaf
You must wrote name Amy . Capital letter ok ?
Como assim eu não fazia idéia que esse hino existia? Muito boa
E eu que só descobri hj também
Queen 👑bey is wayy better 👑
I'm not even a Beyoncé fan, but this cover isn't nearly as bad as you guys make it out to be ... it's actually quite good, obviously not even comparable with Amy's version. It's Amy's song and she sings it with so much raw pain and emotion, no one is ever going to sing this song nearly as good as Amy ♥ but what I really like about this version is that Beyoncé doesn't even try to sing it exactly like Amy and imitate her style or the sound of her voice, but instead made her own thing out of this song. It's incredibly hard to cover Amy Winehouse and I think Beyoncé did a decent job :) (Kinda wish she would've included the "kept his dick wet" line though)
Not true
@@HIPHOP-th6jb dude, it's literally my opinion.
She can dream to be like Amy thats My opinion
@@HIPHOP-th6jb how tf can your life be so sad?
@@chambergreece3914 fking claimant u r sad thats why!
its a damn good effort, beyonce was mind blown back stage at glastonbury with her hub, good effort bey, i thinks it pretty deep, amys will and always be unique, its a god send from artists to say you and always will be a vessel of mayor, she premature will always be here
Beyonce may be the queen but she’ll never be Amy
Maria Pires why would she wanna be 🧐
She’s not trying to be Amy?!
much respect to the great amy. BUT NO ONES WANTS TO BE LIKE AMY
Why would Beyonce want to be a junkie????? 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔 this so stupid to say.
Maria Pires Amy is the queen
Would love to hear this at the Cowboy Carter Tour
Beyoncé tiene el talento, pero Amy Winehouse transmite sus emociones, vivencias como la tristeza, el desamor, te lleva juntó con ella a través de sus canciones.
I love you much
It's not enough
You love blow, and I love puff
And life is like a pipe
And I'm a tiny penny rolling up the walls inside
We only said goodbye with words
I died a hundred times
You go back to her
And I go back to
We only said goodbye with words
I died a hundred times
You go back to her
And I go back to
Black
Black
Black
Black
Black
Black
Black
I go back to
I go back to
We only said goodbye with words
I died a hundred times
You go back to her
And I go back to
We only said goodbye with words
I died a hundred times
You go back to her
And I go back to black
if i read this lyrics with Amy's voice, it means Beyonce doesn't do a good job. And it's so.
This is great!! Love her and it...
But Amy! Omg she’s a queen and I’m truly upset she has passed... she was stressed and this song was so depressing to her but people loved it ): love and miss you Amy xx your safe now xo
I love this cover
I love the tribute she made, and the music is not so heavy. 🤩
y’all need to quit hating.. it’s not gonna have the same that Amy’s had because it’s not supposed to, it was remixed to fit in an EROTICA movie. use your brains
better than the original itself
I agree, both are magnificent ❤️
Amy Winehouse 💙 💙 💝 💜 💓 💔 💕 💙
Stop hating this cover i think this cover is pretty cool and dark "there is no emotions!" Of course it doesn't have to be emotional it has to be sexy Beyonće's voice is so pretty and she can skng this song like she can sing many songs cant be Amy of course no one can be other (except selena) but someone is dead doesn't mean no one can sing he or her songs so calm down this is just a cover
And the fact that this song is used for "The Great Gatsby"
and since the movie wasn't even about emotions or something like that,but they the song to be more sensual and sexy so it's not Beyoncé's fault
Es un homenaje 🙈❤️
The vocals of Amy winehouse are haunting she was the queen of jazz 👌 Beyonce the queen of RNB music 👌
beyoncé can do any genre let’s not lie to ourselves now
Amy is Queen B’s fan ❤️
Why does this human being sing the song of a goddess???
She's not human, she's queen
i dont understand. i dont know who amy is but i respect whoever she is. the only thing that left me dumbfounded is why most of the comment section were hating on beyonce? someone explain to me?
Amy... Is at a whole another level...
I love Amy's version, she had so much pain and when she sang you felt it. I love Beyoncé but her version is not even close to Amy's. RIP Amy ❤️
My thoughts exactly! Beyonce`s version is hypnotic but not a bit dramatic and tragic!
@Yennafer's Tarot Bar this is true and Beyoncé put her own spin on the song. Beyoncé is very talented but as much as I love this song. I’m just not a fan of her version. 😊
NO HOOOOOOONEY..... AMY WHO LET THIS HAPPEN. GURRRL....
Amy Winehouse :'(
Queen B ❤❤❤❤
Showwww ela arrasa
Good job but Amy is the best forever.
FOREVER AMY.
AMY QUEEN
AMY LEGENDARY.
Amy Winehouse forever❤
First time hearing it 10-20-18. Thank u beautiful
Amy's version is emotional... THISSS is erotica right here
This makes me cry!
Amy winehouse will always be the best, don't even try
Ingrid Tomski stfu bitch
Don’t even try throwing shade at Beyoncé bye
Amy is a very good artist, but don’t say she’s better than Beyonce. The only reason why people think she’s the best artist on earth is because of her death. It is very sad, but don’t put Others down to raise one up. They are both Queens.
Alex Thomas Chile. No, we think Amy is better by far, because of her musical talent and potential, more potent than Amy’s. So don’t even go there - and to add as well, people also thing Amy is better, as proven by her huge success after just TWO albums. How many of Beyoncé’s albums did it take for her to get worldly famous? Exactly, no hate against Bee ofc. But Beyoncé comes from a different genre of music, it’s just odd that she’s taking on Amy’s genre of music. But that’s just my thoughts and opinion 💋
Different but still good
she killed this but amys was the best❤❤
Love love it. Amy Winehouse would b rolling around in excitement hearin dis ❤❤❤
Hanging on to artists is so easy
Amy Winehouse is always the best best.Ever !!
Wheres the emotion? Nice cover, but Amy in her song put hard feelings and the vocals were stronguer.
Sebastian Gonzalez I really felt like Beyoncé had more emotion. While I listened to Amy's version I actually thought she didn't have much feeling. Maybe I should give them one more listen.
Incognito Really? You felt emotion in this and not in the original??? LOL! I respect your opinion, but this is the funniest thing I have read in a while..
Incognito you could feel the pain and emotion in amy’s voice
Sebastian Gonzalez Hi!
Please take a look on my channel!
I need alot of support with my music.
I can't feel anything bro how can I know what they feel? They feeling money coming what do you think they feeling like taking a shit? What bullshit feeling I enjoy both, like the beat here more,but I want full version of youngblud cover nuff said
My God how did I come to know about the existence of this masterpiece just today
Beyonce totally nailed it this time.. no doubt.. the song music, the deepness of tone and the feel of serious romance just pour down from this song.. yeah what amy sung is different and excellent but this is what required for this movie.. it totally justifies
yorum farkı işte. sarkiyi ilk bu şekliyle dinlesem sıradan bi beyonce şarkısı der geçerdim. Ama Amy yorumuyla şarkı tüm zamanlar için kült oldu bence
The Great Gatsby 👌🏻
It's not that bad. Yes nobody will be like Amy but Beyonce sings it in her own style, she doesn't try to be like Amy anymore. So that's why you shouldn't compare this to Amy's song. I think Beyonce sings so good in her own way.
No critico el estilo de Beyoncé; sin embargo, nadie jamás igualara a mi amada y eterna Amy 💓💓💓💓única por siempre....
You made me feel it
Nooooo porque distorsionar horriblemente un éxito tan grande de nuestra querida Amy , obvio Beyoncé jamás tendrá el éxito de esta canción, no debió hacerlo
Don’t touch the classic legend!!!
Amy's song (Back to black) is always the best song. It doesn't matter, how much Beyoncé try to copy Amy's song, Amy's song still be the most awesome song.
No se puede !!! Amy t trasmite dolor sentimiento cantaba con el corazon en la mano yo lo sentia asi t daban ganas d llorar esa voz rasgada d dolor! ! Beyoncé m gusta pero no le queda este tema lo lleva a lo sensual y no da lo desvirtua!
Pqp!! Que versão foda!!! Muito bom.
I’m fantasizing about a steampunk Beyoncé.
She is a queen
You almost cry.. Hearing amy sing this song😢
Amy ve boyence farkın güzelliği ❤❤❤
fifty shades of beyonce
Nobody do it like Amy 😭😭
So good
Amy ⭐🥀😔
Yall extra they did a good job. It's just a hip hop version. Do you guys know how many songs have been covered?
A Amy tá se revirando no túmulo.
A song about a painful self destructive break up made into a song about sex
Amyyyyy Winehouse:((
Amy forever. no one can replace her and be worth of her she is iconic❤️ rest In peace amy
Con la de Amy me pongo melancólica con Beyoncé me siento púta jajaja
Hahahahahahahahahahahaha
Great Gatsby gang wya?
Beyoncé 🔥🔥🔥💫
This song is for Amy winehouse only
Amy makes this a haunting melody, beyonce just commercialised it
who let this happen lol
warhol superstar hahaha.... good question
warhol superstar my thoughts exactly. ..
Probably Mitch :/
warhol superstar hu
Random Af This is nowhere near as good
that's not her song, but AMY WINEHOUSE !!!!!!!!!
I love this song and I'm not here to compare it with Amy's but original is original
Queen bee rocked it love you forever
My queen 👑 Amy
Amyden başkası bu şarkıyı söylememeli ❤❤ Amy love you
Noone can reach Amy's level because noone can write and sing like her
Beyonce supreme
amy es única 😍😍🌷🌼👏descansa en paz
Its perfect!
I used to like bey.But after listen this version uhgghhh .... rest in peace Amy is queen of artists.Amy's version is more powerful.Respect from #Asia
the beat though
Beyoncé had the perfect voice for this song. Why did they put that much effects on the recording?
ErickDanielMx Beyonce has a very polished and powerful singing voice. Her dedication to perfection is evident, but with her perfection she's denied herself true soul in her voice. She hits all the notes well but theres lack of depth and soul in her voice, she's like a player piano. Just my opinion. Don't mean to disrespect, just don't think she's the right fit to cover Amy winehouse.
ViolistRichard the good thing with this cover is that she is being jer own self rather than trying to be amy, that is why most covers of an amy winehouse song are bad. The bad thing is amy had a raspy deep voice full of pain and emotion and beyonce has a higher pitched voice that doesn’t show as much emotion, especially in this song.
Andre 300 went wild on this one. She was trying to pay homage to her, but then he went wild.
THIS IS BADASS alla these haters damn.
No no no no .... bad idea to cover this.
I agree
Mm this cover is amazing
It’s a good cover, but the producer (Andre 3000) did too many affects
Amy wine house 😍
No one is better than AMY!