I agree with Crock, and I think Brock hasn’t been playing consistently enough this year. He’s got a lot of weapons, and without them he’s not enough of a firecracker to carry a win. Besides, he’s a “game manager”, right? 😉🙊
It is Shanahan that is the problem here...not Brock purdy. Kyle is certainly no Bill Walsh and he needs to study the old films. (Seriously) What Kyle lacks (By comparison) is that Bill was extremely creative with his play calling. Double reverse plays and 2 or 3 other trick plays thrown into every game. He kept the other teams on their toes. The key is lots of unexpected plays used at the perfect time. Kyle is too Vanilla and has so many predictable plays that the team has their hands tied. He makes the opposing teams look like they have an awesome defense when it's really just that they can see the plays coming. GET CREATIVE like Bill did. - (I really believe he should take a lesson from Bill Walsh.) That alone gives the 49ers a much better chance to go to and WIN a Super Bowl.
We forget last season Purdy elevated this team. 6th team in NFL HISTORY to have 3 1k pass catchers and a 1k running back. This year was the worst we’ll ever see Purdy
@@designatedsmoker5113 you remember CMC fumbling ? Or is that a knock on Purdy too ? 😂 Purdy played well enough to win the game. Defense didn’t. I’m sot sure what you actually remember
@@markdavis3574 I rather just sign Purdy and keep winning. Our o line is improving. We get Deebo out of here focus on kittle aiyuk and Ricky. We have tons of young talent on this team. We get rid of Purdy we’re gonna be looking for a suitable replacement for years. We got a guaranteed winner in Purdy. Listen if the whole team played good and only Purdy played ass this year I’d understand. But without Purdy this year we win maybe 2 games. Jalen got paid the eagles are fine, I feel Purdy is better than Jalen
What I want to know is if this was happening last year would we be saying DON"T PAY BROCK! What I don't get is people have already forgot the days of bad Kaepernick, Blaine Gabbert, Nick Mullens and CJ Beathard? A good and solid QB don't grow on trees don't believe go look at the whole 2021 Draft class from the #1 pick to the last QB taken. What I am not looking forward is we are going to hear and talk about this all summer. So we let teams go and offer Brock the money and we get picks is their an actual QB in this draft where you go you know what that is a future Hall of Famer shoot would you even say that's a future pro bowler. I do not. Are we guaranteed Darnold is going to come back or do you think he will stay in Minnesota. Is all these worth the risk of many many years of mediocre play at QB because we decided not to pay Brock? That's the question we have to ask ourselves cause that could seriously be a possibility if we let Brock go.
Or we can just have similar yrs to what we just had. What was his TD to INT ratio 15 to 10? That doesn't scream franchise QB to me. Allen had nobody to throw too thats why they traded for Cooper yet he's leading MVP candidate and carried that team on his back. Purdy can't do that. That's what u need a franchise QB to do. He cant
@@chrispritchard6005have you not been watching all season? Brock and Kittle has been carrying this offense on their back and that’s when Brock isn’t running for his life because this offense line is made out of Swiss cheese. Fine ok so tell me what is the other option then? Go ahead take your time I’ll wait. 5 more years of mediocrity with no option at the QB. And before you say it Sam Darnold is not going to be an option he isn’t leaving Minnesota.
@themikearruda what are the results of this yr that u seem to he happy of? Did u watch the game last Thursday? That was Purdy's worst game. He over threw guys, under threw guys. Generally inaccurate. He also can't play in any type of inclement weather. So pay him 55-60 million for these results? Waste of money. U pay a guy that much he better be able to carry the team and it was pretty damn obvious that he's not able to do that. Problem I have right now tho is what other option do they have? They already showed us they can't really draft a QB that they really wanted (Lance) they lucked out with Purdy cuz he wasn't even on Kyle's radar. He had to be convinced to draft him by his coaches. If they swallowed their pride and drafted a QB early they've shown not to be great at that sooo they'll prob Pay Purdy since they have him then you'll see the roster start to dwindle then we'll have a QB that can't carry a bunch of young guys to be better so we'll have a bunch of mediocrity for years
@Peacock!! I feel like the qb you are thinking of is Kurtis Rouke qb for Indiana, all they run is play action, he has a big arm, has Josh Allen build, and he’s lowkey. Let me know ‼️ if not, you gotta check him out.
I agree. - Brock Purdy had a passer rating of 113.0 with 4,280 yards, 31 touchdowns and 11 interceptions in 16 games in 2023. He was selected to play in his first Pro Bowl.
It's tricky. You can't afford to pay him, and you can't afford not to have a quarterback. Brock needs to get back to making elite decisions. That's where his talents lie.
@ then they think a 3rd year Purdy with one off-season should be carrying this broken team like mvp josh Allen in year 7 😂 like what is the metric system we’re using to gauge Brock Purdy at Lmaoo
@@fortychase7707 Caleb Williams shows us how a rookie looks like. Compare his (lack of) NFL command, (lack of) understanding how to read defenses and (lack of) leadership on the team to how Brock picked up the team when given the chance. But the bar is moved for Purdy who has to catch his own balls, throw down field AND take risks while not making mistakes, do all that for 900k a season and when time comes to be paid to be asked to think about the team
If I'm running the team. I make Purdy play out his contract. This yr in particular when he didn't have all his all pros around him just look at his numbers. That doesn't scream franchise QB does it? The freakin Bills were supposed to have a rebuilding team this yr but Josh Allen is favored to win the MVP and has taken that team on his back. THAT is a franchise QB. Purdy isn't that he couldn't carry this team. Kyle tried to make him that but it failed. He had him in shotgun seemingly almost every snap and his latest game. Division up for grabs still and if they won put possibly could have won the division he has his worst game. Over throwing guys for an INT. Under throwing guys that coulda been a TD. outright missing receivers. This is supposed to be our guy. Hate to say it but if they sign him to a big extension it's gonna set the team back a few years. They tried like hell to get their Josh Allen. Thats what Lance was supposed to be but he flamed out. They are at a crossroads
@crock… (of 💩) tell me how Purdy controls the offensive line and all the penalties they have acquired to either stop a potential huge play or the reason a big play is called back. A drop? Whether or not a ball was swatted down or out of a players hands, there were as many drops as there were incompletions (exaggerated). With all the injuries happening, why would Purdy risk taking off with the ball and running? The team needs him to stay healthy. He is the only reason the Niners ever have a chance of winning. If you’re gonna say his play this season, due to other facets of the game and team, is not worthy of top pay or resetting the market… than you need and better bring up Patrick Mahomes, whether his TEAM is winning or not, he is playing like garbage (in his and everyone else’s standards). How about Dak, he hasn’t done anything special aside from “use his weapons” in the regular season… where he still always loses the big games. Tell me what he has EVER done in the playoffs. Top pay should be given to any player regardless of how good they are in the regular season. To get top pay you should have a great post season resume. Purdy has been at the top of the charts in stats for almost two full seasons since he has been starting, and won multiple playoff games, two NFC championship appearances with one win and one Super Bowl appearance… all in a season and a half. That to me, considering Trevor Lawrence’s current signing, is worthy of top pay. If you don’t see that you are being bias and a hypocrite.
QBR is a bunch of meaningless crap. QBR is no match for having and using eyes. QBR doesn't factor in things like throwing a season ending interception. It registers the interception without the context of the play. The most important play of the year and he just hurls it down the field into double plus coverage . Brock has thrown more game losing interceptions than Mahomes has lost games! That tells you all you need to know about QBR. A joke.
Any team that has great leadership and organization would pay Purdy top dollar. Where is all this negativity criticism coming from about one of the best QBs in the league… since his first start??? You both are judging Purdy off of everyone else’s performance, and Kyle iffy play calling at times. You both give credit to the QBs like Allen, Herbert, and Mahomes, but the “same things” on field happen to Purdy and his fault? You guys have really taken a notch or two off my opinion of your show. The best QB to come to the 49ers since Steve young and you fugging people are still not happy. Open your dam eyes!!!
No the fans arent for him getting 60 million because it takes away from paying other guys.
I think it’s fair to say Brock deserves to get paid, just not “put the team on my back” money.
I don't think Brock purdy is like that.❤
I do. Lmao but I love how everyone’s judging him based of a year where the whole team sucks
@@fortychase7707I'm judging him on last year playoffs and this season. Average at best👎🏽
@@prophetx8482 he went to the Super Bowl and was in position to win it twice 😂 what average QB does that
No other team will pay Brock that
I agree with Crock, and I think Brock hasn’t been playing consistently enough this year. He’s got a lot of weapons, and without them he’s not enough of a firecracker to carry a win. Besides, he’s a “game manager”, right? 😉🙊
If we over pay purdy im gonna suspend my fandom until he’s gone in protest. Bec no way you should give this man 60+ million a year.
It is Shanahan that is the problem here...not Brock purdy. Kyle is certainly no Bill Walsh and he needs to study the old films. (Seriously) What Kyle lacks (By comparison) is that Bill was extremely creative with his play calling. Double reverse plays and 2 or 3 other trick plays thrown into every game. He kept the other teams on their toes. The key is lots of unexpected plays used at the perfect time. Kyle is too Vanilla and has so many predictable plays that the team has their hands tied. He makes the opposing teams look like they have an awesome defense when it's really just that they can see the plays coming. GET CREATIVE like Bill did. - (I really believe he should take a lesson from Bill Walsh.) That alone gives the 49ers a much better chance to go to and WIN a Super Bowl.
Great episode today guys.
We forget last season Purdy elevated this team. 6th team in NFL HISTORY to have 3 1k pass catchers and a 1k running back.
This year was the worst we’ll ever see Purdy
Nobody forgot, we just remember the Super Bowl more
Exactly. Any team or QB can have a bad year. Purdy has excellent potential which has already been proven.
Id trade Purdy , sign a vet and draft rookie disperse all that QB money to OLine and D line
@@designatedsmoker5113 you remember CMC fumbling ? Or is that a knock on Purdy too ? 😂 Purdy played well enough to win the game. Defense didn’t. I’m sot sure what you actually remember
@@markdavis3574 I rather just sign Purdy and keep winning. Our o line is improving. We get Deebo out of here focus on kittle aiyuk and Ricky. We have tons of young talent on this team. We get rid of Purdy we’re gonna be looking for a suitable replacement for years. We got a guaranteed winner in Purdy. Listen if the whole team played good and only Purdy played ass this year I’d understand. But without Purdy this year we win maybe 2 games. Jalen got paid the eagles are fine, I feel Purdy is better than Jalen
What I want to know is if this was happening last year would we be saying DON"T PAY BROCK! What I don't get is people have already forgot the days of bad Kaepernick, Blaine Gabbert, Nick Mullens and CJ Beathard? A good and solid QB don't grow on trees don't believe go look at the whole 2021 Draft class from the #1 pick to the last QB taken. What I am not looking forward is we are going to hear and talk about this all summer. So we let teams go and offer Brock the money and we get picks is their an actual QB in this draft where you go you know what that is a future Hall of Famer shoot would you even say that's a future pro bowler. I do not. Are we guaranteed Darnold is going to come back or do you think he will stay in Minnesota. Is all these worth the risk of many many years of mediocre play at QB because we decided not to pay Brock? That's the question we have to ask ourselves cause that could seriously be a possibility if we let Brock go.
Another thing that we can imagine is:What if Brock was extended after last season, how would we feel now? I suggest no-one would feel good about it.
@ the same way we feel about paying Aiyuk. The same way we feel about Bosa. Everyone has had a terrible year. Brock is not the problem of this team
Or we can just have similar yrs to what we just had. What was his TD to INT ratio 15 to 10? That doesn't scream franchise QB to me. Allen had nobody to throw too thats why they traded for Cooper yet he's leading MVP candidate and carried that team on his back. Purdy can't do that. That's what u need a franchise QB to do. He cant
@@chrispritchard6005have you not been watching all season? Brock and Kittle has been carrying this offense on their back and that’s when Brock isn’t running for his life because this offense line is made out of Swiss cheese. Fine ok so tell me what is the other option then? Go ahead take your time I’ll wait. 5 more years of mediocrity with no option at the QB. And before you say it Sam Darnold is not going to be an option he isn’t leaving Minnesota.
@themikearruda what are the results of this yr that u seem to he happy of? Did u watch the game last Thursday? That was Purdy's worst game. He over threw guys, under threw guys. Generally inaccurate. He also can't play in any type of inclement weather. So pay him 55-60 million for these results? Waste of money. U pay a guy that much he better be able to carry the team and it was pretty damn obvious that he's not able to do that. Problem I have right now tho is what other option do they have? They already showed us they can't really draft a QB that they really wanted (Lance) they lucked out with Purdy cuz he wasn't even on Kyle's radar. He had to be convinced to draft him by his coaches. If they swallowed their pride and drafted a QB early they've shown not to be great at that sooo they'll prob Pay Purdy since they have him then you'll see the roster start to dwindle then we'll have a QB that can't carry a bunch of young guys to be better so we'll have a bunch of mediocrity for years
I'm ready to trade him if he wants 60m for real idc.
If this is all we have to talk about for the next 7 months Im out...
We’re delusional. Brock Purdy was a lottery ticket for us.
Baker is playing WAAAAY better than Purdy and so is Sam Darnold
@Peacock!! I feel like the qb you are thinking of is Kurtis Rouke qb for Indiana, all they run is play action, he has a big arm, has Josh Allen build, and he’s lowkey. Let me know ‼️ if not, you gotta check him out.
The one you said Kyle would love
🎯
We forget Brock is a 2 year player with one offseason under his belt and we’re comparing him to josh Allen and Jared Goff
I agree. - Brock Purdy had a passer rating of 113.0 with 4,280 yards, 31 touchdowns and 11 interceptions in 16 games in 2023. He was selected to play in his first Pro Bowl.
Goff???😂 He’s better than Goff.😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@steveo601 yea I’m just saying they’re putting him in convos with 5+ year vets and they expect him to be a superhuman QB
Josh Allen and Jared Goff, 2 players that have both won and at least played 2-3 SBs each
And who’s got more playoff wins and a Super Bowl appearance?
I’ll see Brock taking less money to keep the team
the problem is he is already taking very little money. Some of the new money has to pay back some of the great past work he did for NFL change money
We had to hear all last year that Brock is an elite qb. Now you don’t want to pay him as an elite qb
It's tricky. You can't afford to pay him, and you can't afford not to have a quarterback. Brock needs to get back to making elite decisions. That's where his talents lie.
Crock.. what more could Purdy have done ? We had games where WRs literally refused to catch balls. 50+ missed games combined from all pros alone.
he won't answer this and you won't like the answer if he did. He's so full of excuses for others
@ then they think a 3rd year Purdy with one off-season should be carrying this broken team like mvp josh Allen in year 7 😂 like what is the metric system we’re using to gauge Brock Purdy at Lmaoo
@@fortychase7707 Caleb Williams shows us how a rookie looks like. Compare his (lack of) NFL command, (lack of) understanding how to read defenses and (lack of) leadership on the team to how Brock picked up the team when given the chance. But the bar is moved for Purdy who has to catch his own balls, throw down field AND take risks while not making mistakes, do all that for 900k a season and when time comes to be paid to be asked to think about the team
@ literally if he was Caleb Williams and wasn’t a 5’10” Christian kid nobody would talk about a discount Lmaoo
If I'm running the team. I make Purdy play out his contract. This yr in particular when he didn't have all his all pros around him just look at his numbers. That doesn't scream franchise QB does it? The freakin Bills were supposed to have a rebuilding team this yr but Josh Allen is favored to win the MVP and has taken that team on his back. THAT is a franchise QB. Purdy isn't that he couldn't carry this team. Kyle tried to make him that but it failed. He had him in shotgun seemingly almost every snap and his latest game. Division up for grabs still and if they won put possibly could have won the division he has his worst game. Over throwing guys for an INT. Under throwing guys that coulda been a TD. outright missing receivers. This is supposed to be our guy. Hate to say it but if they sign him to a big extension it's gonna set the team back a few years. They tried like hell to get their Josh Allen. Thats what Lance was supposed to be but he flamed out. They are at a crossroads
Just admit it, Mayfield is better than Brock Purdy
Jimmy G got a record contract also at the time
Brock will ask for $60M; Niners will offer $50M and they will settle for around $55M.
Especially the media
All those people were talking smack about them don't even make close to million dollars this guy is going to make 60 ml Plus
@crock… (of 💩) tell me how Purdy controls the offensive line and all the penalties they have acquired to either stop a potential huge play or the reason a big play is called back. A drop? Whether or not a ball was swatted down or out of a players hands, there were as many drops as there were incompletions (exaggerated). With all the injuries happening, why would Purdy risk taking off with the ball and running? The team needs him to stay healthy. He is the only reason the Niners ever have a chance of winning. If you’re gonna say his play this season, due to other facets of the game and team, is not worthy of top pay or resetting the market… than you need and better bring up Patrick Mahomes, whether his TEAM is winning or not, he is playing like garbage (in his and everyone else’s standards). How about Dak, he hasn’t done anything special aside from “use his weapons” in the regular season… where he still always loses the big games. Tell me what he has EVER done in the playoffs. Top pay should be given to any player regardless of how good they are in the regular season. To get top pay you should have a great post season resume. Purdy has been at the top of the charts in stats for almost two full seasons since he has been starting, and won multiple playoff games, two NFC championship appearances with one win and one Super Bowl appearance… all in a season and a half. That to me, considering Trevor Lawrence’s current signing, is worthy of top pay. If you don’t see that you are being bias and a hypocrite.
Do you think it was worth it for Jags to sign Lawrence to what they did?
Brock is 10th in QBR this year. He’s top ten in his ‘off year’. Mahomes is 11th.
QBR is a bunch of meaningless crap. QBR is no match for having and using eyes. QBR doesn't factor in things like throwing a season ending interception. It registers the interception without the context of the play. The most important play of the year and he just hurls it down the field into double plus coverage . Brock has thrown more game losing interceptions than Mahomes has lost games! That tells you all you need to know about QBR. A joke.
Any team that has great leadership and organization would pay Purdy top dollar. Where is all this negativity criticism coming from about one of the best QBs in the league… since his first start??? You both are judging Purdy off of everyone else’s performance, and Kyle iffy play calling at times. You both give credit to the QBs like Allen, Herbert, and Mahomes, but the “same things” on field happen to Purdy and his fault? You guys have really taken a notch or two off my opinion of your show. The best QB to come to the 49ers since Steve young and you fugging people are still not happy. Open your dam eyes!!!
He better not!!
Baker is playing WAAAAY better than Purdy and so is Sam Darnold