@@hakkadavet150 might be Allah knows best but as we see its seems majority of people follow sufism’s, no-hijab . they are occupied themselves with western culture Allah save us from this fitna aameen.
@@CheckMatt-t4e No he didnt say the truth, Do you know where he got his belief? 1. Rafidhis : They believe that most companions were apostate, because they elected Abu Bakr RA through shura, not by direct divine appointment of Allah, for them leadership of muslim only can be established by Allah directly 2. Kharijis, they declared both side who fought and shiffin , Imam Ali and Muawiya as kafirs, because they used tahkim(Negotiation between their representative) to solve the matters Kharijis believe that by doing that Imam Ali and Muawiya have abandoned the laws of Allah,
@@Zaydrevoltthis is not shura!This is democratic voting of representatives of people who make decisions what is halal and what is haram !We muslims don’t take place in democratic elections and we don’t associate with these people who make man make laws which are in collision with Qur’an and Sune !Comparison with the case of Muawia and Ali dosen’t make sense!One man can’t be at same time Khariji and Rafidhi!That is just impossible!
@@CheckMatt-t4e This is not shura, of course. This is also not monarch, the sytem used by umayyad and abbasid. Which is different from shura Whats your point? Do you think you can establish a shura , because it seem that youre against any systems other than it? Do you regard the caliphs of umayyad and abbasid as kafirs, because they re monarchs? I dont say anything about being a rafidhi and khariji at the sametime. I just pointed the similarity between the boy in video with both
he is totaly right because all what he said was either ayah or hadith , and all of our scholars from old and new are saying same thing in their books regarding tawheed and especialy in term of governing and shariia laws
Even if all that he quoted is from the Quran or sahih hadith, the interpretation is important. Because any statement, even one from Allah, can be twisted and deliberately misinterpreted to suit an agenda, as we see from actual terrorists calling themselves Muslim. He said voting is shirk. Tell me, then: how are the leaders in a community or country to be chosen without voting? If a current leader retires or is removed, how is his replacement chosen? How are rules and laws regarding new things like organ donation, artificial meat, space travel, social media, cryptocurrency, etc. to be decided?
@@khairulamribinjumaat7566I agree with you. I don't personally believe that voting is shirk because somebody has to be elected to run a country. (If voting even counts at all, right?) But i will give it to him that he is a very intellectual man.
Even if he's talking just about voting in Turkey, how does abstaining from voting help? Even if all the candidates are secularists and tend not to pay attention to the sharia, surely it is possible to select the "least bad" candidate or one that might be persuaded by public opinion later on. Abstaining from voting just increases the chances that the most secular candidate wins and forms the government. @@skidachilles3749
The brother seems to have thought his best, tabarakallah. But the fundamental flaw in the logic is the comparison between legislation of Allah and legislation of the ruler. It is permissible in Islam to choose a khalifah who woukd rule the land, through democratic means, i.e public decide on a person and give him power. This was done during the time of the sahabah, and it is halal. Furthermore, unless the ruler orders you to disobey Allah, there is no harm in obeying that ruler even if they were non Muslim. And Allah knows best.
Osmania khilafat was not khilafat but a monarchial system .. voting is not shirk infact prophet mohamed saw purpose was to abolish feudal system and create governance based on being capable leader (acc to allah quran )and popular leader (the one who rule accept by most ) ... had this not been the case then after aby bakr siddiq r.a his descendent would have continued and not hazrat umar r.a. ... now where i am saying a country must run beside allahs rule but then khilafat system is not parellel to dictatorship...
الشرك هو عبادة غير الله لكن مجرد الطاعة فيما لا يخرج من الدين ليس عبادة فلا يكون كفرا. عندما اطيع امي لا اكون اعبدها ولا اكون اشرك بالله في طاعتها. اذا شاب طلب من آخر سرقة شيىء فأطاعه الثاني لا يكون شركا بل يكون حراما. هذه النصوص التي اوردها ليس معناها كما فسرها. تفسيره فيه تكفير لاغلب المسلمين. هو لا يستطيع الخروج من بلده الا بأوراق مختومة من حكومته مثل جواز السفر فهل يعتبر نفسه اشرك؟ هو لا يستطيع ان يعمل في شركة الا بشهاداته المصادق عليها من حكومته فهل يظن بذلك انه اشرك؟ الطلاقة قي الكلام لا تعني ان المعلومة صحيحة.
You do not understand what is being said and your analogies are not valid. Obeying a parent is an obligation under Islamic law however there is no obedience to creation if it means disobeying the Creator. So you can disobey your mother if she asks you not to do your fard or perform a haram. A young man stealing something is haram not shirk. However if the young man takes the other as a source of guidance in what is good and bad over Allah then he commits shirk. Obtaining papers to leave the country is a matter of administration and does not require recognising the passport office as sovereign. The young man is correct about voting in kufr political systems.
@@niqbalIt is kofor to say that drinking alcohol is halal but just drinking while believing it is haram is called committing a sin. It is kofor to say that eating pork is halal but eating it knowing it is haram is a sin. Voting for a president or whatever that promotes selling alcohol for example while knowing what he is doing is haram is a sin not shirk however believing that selling alcohol is not haram in this case it is kofor. I wanted to clarify this very point
@@angidarwiche1680Voting for president who approves man make laws who are in collision with Quran is Kufr!Muslims should stay away from so called democratic elections!Iblees wanted democracy!
МошоОллох брать мой самый низкий поклон от Таджикистана ❤❤самый достойный мужик его надо показать Эрдогану он самый достойный правителем станет МошоОллох!!! МошоОллох!!! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ Он как философ разговаривает
Noo this guy has raised thw issue corect but has gone seriously wrong with interpretation of the ayah .. Its true allah doesnt share is decision with anyone but that ayah is not applicable in our governance ... voting is not shirk but turning allahs law by voting is shirk we can vote as to whom we choose as our leader but that doesnt meam we have choosen some one to be above allah and its law ... and allah has sent quran as criterion that is the furqan which mean what ever we do in our lifes we must adhere to the limiting critrea of the that is we must no step the boundaries what allahs mention so as long as we be in boundary we can do anything it is necesarry to vote the election and frame legislation for our day to day affairs and good governance because believing in allab doesnt mean giving our lives to the hand of single person and tyranized by anyone in the name of allah
Even the prophet said 'When three people set out on a journey, they should appoint one of them as their leader.' Now of course that is for a journey, but chosing from amongst each other is clearly a form of democracy. However, Islam does not prescribe a form of state. This stuff has been decided after the death of the prophet and even then they CHOSE who would lead. It is worrying that there is cleary an agenda against democracy and , excuse me for saying this, people eat this stuff up like blind sheep. If you just say anything from the West = bad people applaud you like you just spoke the utter truth. Really? You really think that Islam is anti-democractic? Get out of here.
What the young man has said is totally true. Democracy is not just about selecting a leader but also producing legislation. In democracy man is sovereign and has the right to determine what is right and wrong. In Islam Allah is sovereign and determines right and wrong. In a democracy the law of man is above the law of Allah. Additionally Allah has sent mankind a deen which provides a solution for all life's problems. We also have the example of the Prophet Muhammad saw himself who ruled over Madina and provided the best example. This was continued by his companions. The Khilafah system is the Islamic political system mentioned in numerous hadith. Anyone who has issues with these two basic issues does not understand Islam.
@@niqbal Alright, give me the hadith then. Because I do not know of a form of state being prescribed either in the Quran or hadith. Also, you conveniently forget that Islamic/Sharia law does NOT cover all branches of law. So you tell me then o smart one, how would we solve the issues that arise from not applying those branches of law? Get out of here with your ridiculousness.
Voting and democracy process has nothing to do with allah and his law first of all what he is talkk g about is the constitution whiche people are adering to yes we must choose our constituion as quran or constitution driven from quran .. as quran is the book of all books ... but democracy is the best practice which prophet mohammed saw wanted tk happen sadly we muslim coudnt understand and only return to the ways of kingship and all where king rule is as if allahs rule ...
PLZ DO READ He Reminds of Khawarij who declared Ali (علیہ السلام، کرم اللہ وجہہ الکریم، رضی اللہ عنہ) (Nauzubillah) Kafir, because of the Tahkeem happened between him and his opposer. When ibn Abbas (RA) asked Ali to order him to confront them with the knowledge, HEZRET ALI (RA) allowed him to go and cofront them but also guided the interpreter of Quran ibn e Abbas that He (ibn Abbas) should know how to confront them because those Khwarij Use verses of Quran to make their claims legit
@@peacemaker-ro5qq we live in democratic country but we don’t say that laws of the country is above than Shariah Laws and we are able to not doing the things that Shariah Laws prohibited but country’s law let to do he mentioned some of them
@@voiceofreason8001 ISIS also started war in syria by saying living in democratic country is shirk and now we are seeing what they did in syria they didnt threw a stone to Isrea but killed muslims there
Put things in perspective, vote to make laws when we have existing sharia law is shirk but vote to elect our representatives is not shirk, there is a concept of "Shura" in Islam. So poster don't confuse people
@@hakkadavet150 Tauheed has nothing to do with this subject. It's about legislation. I think you didn't get it what I meant or you simply don't want to.
I want insha allah this boy become next turk ruler ❤❤❤❤
Olamaz çünkü kendi dediklerine ters olur o zaman
NO!
insha'Allah
IN SHA ALLAH
Masha alh genius young with taqwa and bright future head of him an icon boy ❤❤
I have learned this very important thing from you dear younger brother. May Allah Bless You
very rare to see a person with a tawheed and correct aqeeda in turkey.
Thats not true.there is maybe milions people who know tawhid in turkey elhamdülillah
@@hakkadavet150 might be Allah knows best but as we see its seems majority of people follow sufism’s, no-hijab . they are occupied themselves with western culture Allah save us from this fitna aameen.
@@everywhere001but he is against democracy and islam is never against democracy
@@R2F762democracy and Islam are two oposite systems that exclude one another!
@@R2F762democracy is only for those with knowledge not laypeople
Masahallah tabarakalah
What an intellectual genius.
that boy have Ottoman blood❤
MashaAllah Beautiful, May Allah bless you and your family Brother
Affarin Muslim dustim ALLAH RAZI BULSIN SENDAN
Nah, he declared takfir against billion of muslims around the world
Somebody gotta get him and tell him thats he s wrong
@@Zaydrevolthe told the truth!I’m muslim and I don’t vote!
@@CheckMatt-t4e
No he didnt say the truth, Do you know where he got his belief?
1. Rafidhis : They believe that most companions were apostate, because they elected Abu Bakr RA through shura, not by direct divine appointment of Allah, for them leadership of muslim only can be established by Allah directly
2. Kharijis, they declared both side who fought and shiffin , Imam Ali and Muawiya as kafirs, because they used tahkim(Negotiation between their representative) to solve the matters
Kharijis believe that by doing that Imam Ali and Muawiya have abandoned the laws of Allah,
@@Zaydrevoltthis is not shura!This is democratic voting of representatives of people who make decisions what is halal and what is haram !We muslims don’t take place in democratic elections and we don’t associate with these people who make man make laws which are in collision with Qur’an and Sune !Comparison with the case of Muawia and Ali dosen’t make sense!One man can’t be at same time Khariji and Rafidhi!That is just impossible!
@@CheckMatt-t4e
This is not shura, of course.
This is also not monarch, the sytem used by umayyad and abbasid.
Which is different from shura
Whats your point?
Do you think you can establish a shura , because it seem that youre against any systems other than it?
Do you regard the caliphs of umayyad and abbasid as kafirs, because they re monarchs?
I dont say anything about being a rafidhi and khariji at the sametime.
I just pointed the similarity between the boy in video with both
AlhamduLILLAH, this boy is blessed with wisdom and understanding.
Mashaallah so much wisdom❤
No its not, he said billion of muslims around the world are mushrik
He s wrong
Machallah allah give You jannah amin do not let shaytane distract You My brother ♥️
He knew ummah need khilafah
And Ataturk (laknatullah) had ruined it
he is totaly right because all what he said was either ayah or hadith , and all of our scholars from old and new are saying same thing in their books regarding tawheed and especialy in term of governing and shariia laws
True
Even if all that he quoted is from the Quran or sahih hadith, the interpretation is important. Because any statement, even one from Allah, can be twisted and deliberately misinterpreted to suit an agenda, as we see from actual terrorists calling themselves Muslim. He said voting is shirk. Tell me, then: how are the leaders in a community or country to be chosen without voting? If a current leader retires or is removed, how is his replacement chosen? How are rules and laws regarding new things like organ donation, artificial meat, space travel, social media, cryptocurrency, etc. to be decided?
@@khairulamribinjumaat7566I agree with you. I don't personally believe that voting is shirk because somebody has to be elected to run a country. (If voting even counts at all, right?) But i will give it to him that he is a very intellectual man.
@@khairulamribinjumaat7566 what he meant was voting the leaders in Turkey apparently.
Even if he's talking just about voting in Turkey, how does abstaining from voting help? Even if all the candidates are secularists and tend not to pay attention to the sharia, surely it is possible to select the "least bad" candidate or one that might be persuaded by public opinion later on. Abstaining from voting just increases the chances that the most secular candidate wins and forms the government. @@skidachilles3749
Ma sha Allah brother
*This kid has to be the next Turkish leader.*
Very smart boy MashaAllah!
The brother seems to have thought his best, tabarakallah. But the fundamental flaw in the logic is the comparison between legislation of Allah and legislation of the ruler. It is permissible in Islam to choose a khalifah who woukd rule the land, through democratic means, i.e public decide on a person and give him power. This was done during the time of the sahabah, and it is halal. Furthermore, unless the ruler orders you to disobey Allah, there is no harm in obeying that ruler even if they were non Muslim. And Allah knows best.
oh, makes sense!!
Finally someone♥️ i mean sorry to say but the boy is wrong.
He just told the truth!
Ma Shaa Allah Ma Shaa Allah
After hearing this brother I can clearly understand why the 'OTTOMANS' were given the responsibility of 'KHILAFAH' by ALLAH.
Masha Allah tabarkallah
AlhamduliAllah ❤
Though the boy is wrong, but still he learns quran well than most of us♥️
Alhamdullah the chosen one has arrived!❤❤❤❤
??????? Be careful with your words
@@muzosh why you stupid?
Mashalloh Mashalloh🫡
His father definitely had a good time with him until he learned this by heart. Probe doesn't know what it means
🙌🏻❤
This boy has some really valid points. Beautiful!
Sigma male
Muslim Alhamdulilah
❤
His face reminds me of general **qasem soleiman**
What is his name 🙏??
Osmania khilafat was not khilafat but a monarchial system .. voting is not shirk infact prophet mohamed saw purpose was to abolish feudal system and create governance based on being capable leader (acc to allah quran )and popular leader (the one who rule accept by most ) ... had this not been the case then after aby bakr siddiq r.a his descendent would have continued and not hazrat umar r.a. ... now where i am saying a country must run beside allahs rule but then khilafat system is not parellel to dictatorship...
They also made marriage haram for those below 18
الشرك هو عبادة غير الله لكن مجرد الطاعة فيما لا يخرج من الدين ليس عبادة فلا يكون كفرا. عندما اطيع امي لا اكون اعبدها ولا اكون اشرك بالله في طاعتها. اذا شاب طلب من آخر سرقة شيىء فأطاعه الثاني لا يكون شركا بل يكون حراما. هذه النصوص التي اوردها ليس معناها كما فسرها. تفسيره فيه تكفير لاغلب المسلمين. هو لا يستطيع الخروج من بلده الا بأوراق مختومة من حكومته مثل جواز السفر فهل يعتبر نفسه اشرك؟ هو لا يستطيع ان يعمل في شركة الا بشهاداته المصادق عليها من حكومته فهل يظن بذلك انه اشرك؟ الطلاقة قي الكلام لا تعني ان المعلومة صحيحة.
You do not understand what is being said and your analogies are not valid. Obeying a parent is an obligation under Islamic law however there is no obedience to creation if it means disobeying the Creator. So you can disobey your mother if she asks you not to do your fard or perform a haram.
A young man stealing something is haram not shirk. However if the young man takes the other as a source of guidance in what is good and bad over Allah then he commits shirk.
Obtaining papers to leave the country is a matter of administration and does not require recognising the passport office as sovereign.
The young man is correct about voting in kufr political systems.
@@niqbalIt is kofor to say that drinking alcohol is halal but just drinking while believing it is haram is called committing a sin. It is kofor to say that eating pork is halal but eating it knowing it is haram is a sin.
Voting for a president or whatever that promotes selling alcohol for example while knowing what he is doing is haram is a sin not shirk however believing that selling alcohol is not haram in this case it is kofor. I wanted to clarify this very point
@@angidarwiche1680Voting for president who approves man make laws who are in collision with Quran is Kufr!Muslims should stay away from so called democratic elections!Iblees wanted democracy!
МошоОллох брать мой самый низкий поклон от Таджикистана ❤❤самый достойный мужик его надо показать Эрдогану он самый достойный правителем станет МошоОллох!!! МошоОллох!!! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Он как философ разговаривает
Cult
But the shirk part? Voting can be equivalent to a shirk?
Voting iş shirk 100%
Probably a propaganda. We must be careful
Totally. It's shirk! The evidence he quotes are quite clear. Which part are you unclear about?
@@niqbal how?
Noo this guy has raised thw issue corect but has gone seriously wrong with interpretation of the ayah ..
Its true allah doesnt share is decision with anyone but that ayah is not applicable in our governance ... voting is not shirk but turning allahs law by voting is shirk we can vote as to whom we choose as our leader but that doesnt meam we have choosen some one to be above allah and its law ... and allah has sent quran as criterion that is the furqan which mean what ever we do in our lifes we must adhere to the limiting critrea of the that is we must no step the boundaries what allahs mention so as long as we be in boundary we can do anything it is necesarry to vote the election and frame legislation for our day to day affairs and good governance because believing in allab doesnt mean giving our lives to the hand of single person and tyranized by anyone in the name of allah
Even the prophet said 'When three people set out on a journey, they should appoint one of them as their leader.' Now of course that is for a journey, but chosing from amongst each other is clearly a form of democracy. However, Islam does not prescribe a form of state. This stuff has been decided after the death of the prophet and even then they CHOSE who would lead. It is worrying that there is cleary an agenda against democracy and , excuse me for saying this, people eat this stuff up like blind sheep. If you just say anything from the West = bad people applaud you like you just spoke the utter truth.
Really? You really think that Islam is anti-democractic? Get out of here.
What the young man has said is totally true. Democracy is not just about selecting a leader but also producing legislation. In democracy man is sovereign and has the right to determine what is right and wrong. In Islam Allah is sovereign and determines right and wrong. In a democracy the law of man is above the law of Allah.
Additionally Allah has sent mankind a deen which provides a solution for all life's problems. We also have the example of the Prophet Muhammad saw himself who ruled over Madina and provided the best example. This was continued by his companions. The Khilafah system is the Islamic political system mentioned in numerous hadith. Anyone who has issues with these two basic issues does not understand Islam.
@@niqbal Alright, give me the hadith then. Because I do not know of a form of state being prescribed either in the Quran or hadith.
Also, you conveniently forget that Islamic/Sharia law does NOT cover all branches of law. So you tell me then o smart one, how would we solve the issues that arise from not applying those branches of law? Get out of here with your ridiculousness.
Democracy isn't just "choosing a leader". It revolves around legislation and legislation belongs to none except Allah
Voting and democracy process has nothing to do with allah and his law first of all what he is talkk g about is the constitution whiche people are adering to yes we must choose our constituion as quran or constitution driven from quran .. as quran is the book of all books ... but democracy is the best practice which prophet mohammed saw wanted tk happen sadly we muslim coudnt understand and only return to the ways of kingship and all where king rule is as if allahs rule ...
Muslims have nothing to do with so called democratic elections!
Any kind of participation in so called democratic elections is kufr!
Bu çocuk saçmalıyor . Kardeşlerim.
Evet
not true.
💯 true. What part do you have issues with and why?
Why is he declaring kafir to everyone?
Yoical wahhabi salafi jihadi.. They thinkcsllingnpeople such names pleases God..
Study tawhid .u do not know what tawhid is
@@hakkadavet150the word tawhid doesn't even appear anywhere in the Quran... 🤣
@@newseefgenesis9191oh dear!
خواريج
Stupid!
PLZ DO READ
He Reminds of Khawarij who declared Ali (علیہ السلام، کرم اللہ وجہہ الکریم، رضی اللہ عنہ) (Nauzubillah) Kafir, because of the Tahkeem happened between him and his opposer. When ibn Abbas (RA) asked Ali to order him to confront them with the knowledge, HEZRET ALI (RA) allowed him to go and cofront them but also guided the interpreter of Quran ibn e Abbas that He (ibn Abbas) should know how to confront them because those Khwarij Use verses of Quran to make their claims legit
He is not correct in all his words that he told.
Yes he is
@@peacemaker-ro5qq we live in democratic country but we don’t say that laws of the country is above than Shariah Laws and we are able to not doing the things that Shariah Laws prohibited but country’s law let to do he mentioned some of them
He is more knowledgeable than some scholars. He is one hundred percent correct.
@@voiceofreason8001 ISIS also started war in syria by saying living in democratic country is shirk and now we are seeing what they did in syria they didnt threw a stone to Isrea but killed muslims there
He spoke only the Haqq.
Put things in perspective, vote to make laws when we have existing sharia law is shirk but vote to elect our representatives is not shirk, there is a concept of "Shura" in Islam. So poster don't confuse people
Study tawhid .u do not know that
@@hakkadavet150 Tauheed has nothing to do with this subject. It's about legislation. I think you didn't get it what I meant or you simply don't want to.
@@MrShawnamirthis young man told the truth!It is up to you to accept or not !
Then go to afganistan 😂
❤