Stalingrad was fought badly by the Germans. They just didn't believe the Soviets had that many men left. Now that we know that the Soviets lost 27 million people in the war who couild blame them?
The Germans only lost Stalingrad due to misleadership, lack of supplies. The only thing the Russians were capable of were of quick manufacturing, soldier replacements, and rushing.
Stalingrad was THE turning point in WW2 and Operation Bagration THE moment when the German Army was annihilated paving the way for an easy victory at Normandy.
@@sagritarius01 The Russians paid for the war many times over in the blood of their citizens and the Americans are fretting over a deal that contributed more to their economy than the outcome of the war. The main reason for lend lease was to enable the british to survive and revive the desperate american economy.
@@sagritarius01 You do realize that the Soviet Union wasn't included until 1941 when operation Barbarossa was started? Why don't you stick to something you actually know about like nothing.
I love these British documentaries. They're the ones that invented concentration camps in the Boar Wars in the 1890's. We have to face the truth FDR, desparetly tried to involve the USA in a European war against Germany from 1937 on. After he succeeded in doing that he personally made the war much worse and longer lasting then it could have or should have been. This isn't difficult to see. AFTER Stalingrad, when FDR was sure that the Allies would eventually win (and only then) he proclaimed that only "unconditional surrender" would be acceptable to the Allies. When Germany had the upper hand in the war, the first 2.5 years of the war, they offered very easy peace terms to the UK and the USA. All they asked for was an end to the fighting Alfred Lloyd George, the PM of Great Britain in WW1 said that none of the made up countries in central Europe (created at Versailles) was worth another European war. Britain declared war over Danzig, a german city given to one of those created countries at Versailles. Was it worth 60+ million dead to have a german city be part of Poland? I don't think so. WW2 only helped the USA and the Soviet Union. It was the great unnecessary war that was essentially fought to get the USA out of the Depression and to make money.
Boer wars. The Last being British desire for the Gold and diamonds, and if it were not for the concentration camps England could not have won The British burnt our farms and rounded up all women and children. Basically keeping them hostage in terrible conditions inside concentration camps until the men would surrender. I don't recall them ever even officially apologizing for the wilful murder of thousands of helpless women and children
6 Despots fighting over Empire and Real Estate , 80 million died in Europe Alone .( Is anyone here tired of the " Know-it-all " Brit Accent ) - he should have said We Brits invented the Concentration Camps to secure a vein of Gold in the Transvall 30 miles long , and oh yes , then there were the Diamonds , Loyd's of London rejoiced at the suffering , Rhodes and Disraeli probably did too . The Boers did Kick some "A" though .
@@Marco90731Lord Kitcheners creation of the concentration camps to house women and children, snatched off their farms and all crops burnt, was Englands last resort to win. The Boer commandos had more than 200 000 British troops scratching their heads with no answer. Quick lightning raids that did kick some "A", but the men were eventually left with no choice but to surrender as the inhumane conditions in the camps led to endless deaths through starvation, poor hygiene and contagious diseases.
C'est du grand n'importe quoi. Beaucoup d'erreurs qui sautent aux yeux de qui connaît l'histoire de la Seconde Guerre mondiale. Un ancien officier S2/S3 qui a vus presque toutes les vidéos sérieuses sur les guerres du 20e siècle.
I'd argue Germany lost when they didn't get the oil from the Caucasus in 1941. Hitler's generals sabotaged the original plan to go towards the Caucasus, opting for an old fashioned aim for the capital plan instead.
Germany hast already lost the war on Dezember 8th 1941 with the enter of the USA into the war and not alone in Stalingrad or by the Operation Zitadelle 1943 the Operation Barbarossa was at the begining already an big misfault of Hitler😅😅
Same old regurgitated WW2 video stock film, okay if you've never seen the Germans in Russia, however I'd look elsewhere if you're looking for a good, accurate WW2 documentary. Obviously, this is my personal viewpoint & is posted without prejudice. 😀
The same English American revisionism of ww2 History, stating the North African states welcomed the Allies, Egypt and Algiers and others despised their former Colonial masters. The Egyptian people were ecstatic and celebrating in the streets when Tobrouk fell to the Axis forces, also was this production supposed to be about the Germans surrendering in Stalingrad.?
If you make a documentary, you should do it properly; the title on TH-cam "The German Army Surrendered in Stalingrad | Colorized World War II" is a blatant mistake, as it shows SS troops in the Warsaw Ghetto and not in Stalingrad.
Yhden miehen vallanhimo ja hulluus sai aikaan valtavan hävityksen ja monen sukupolven traumat.Miksi häntä ei pysäytetty,mutta kaipa on niin,että paholainen suojelee omiaan!Useampi salamurhayritys epäonnistui,ehkä sekin kertoo jotakin.Paljolta olisi koko maailma säästynyt ilman tämän herran hyvin,hyvin kyseenalaisia saavutuksia!
I guess it was a huge defeat and humiliation for the German sixth army at Stalingrad, especially general Friedrich Paulus, l believe never had a field marshal ever surrender in German history, l think he is the first high ranking commander to do so rather than commit suicide, one thing for sure the Nazi Germany high command made the mistake for invading the Soviet union or USSR.
Axis powers: ack-sis. bot ack-seas. Yeah, I know, French and German would have a plural adjective with a plural noun, so axes powers. Sorry, fellas, this is supposed to be in English. And straff is pronounced staif, not the German way it's spelled. Papue, New Guinea? pah-poo-wa. No, I know pappy-ya sounds friendlier, but no, just no, OK? Stalingrad? Named after Stalin. No, not Schtalin. So your Schtalingrad doesn't exist. Caucasus has three syllables: core ka sus.
And it would be nice if you had script readers who understood English. Here's one problem, that of emphasis: When you say "The HIGHLY trained officers surrendered," what you are also saying is that there were a lot of barely trained officers who didn't surrender. To avoid this very clear implication, you need to read "the highly trained officers" in an even tone, conveying the meaning that all the officers who surrendered were highly trained. Get it? You need readers who understand this sort of thing from childhood, though. I.e. native English speakers, or literate adults.
I agree with you. It should be Stalin and Stalingrad. Narrator must be a German. Nothing wrong with that, but the whole narration is in English. I suspect AI commenting here.
La narration française du doc est apaisante , cela dit on se rapproche plus d'un diaporama illustrer ,qu'à un documentaire , certaines images me semblent "inédites" ou très peu vues l'ensemble est plaisant, on apprend rien de bien nouveau, et si vous le visionner après un bon repas , c'est la sieste assurée.
Nella sacca di Stalingrado rimasero anche 70 italiani che avevano portato dal fronte dei camion penso degli opel blitz rimasero intrappolati magari qualcuno ne sa più di me 🤔
US people who watch this should think that in 2024, the Atlantic Ocean is not much larger than was the Channel in 1944...let's imagine New York, Washington, San Franciso, L.A. in the same state than Gaza is now...
PEMENANG PERANG DI EROPA DIA TIDAK MATI TERBANG KE HINDIA BELANDA TERJADI PERTEMPURAN 10 NOVEMBER 1945 DI SURABAYA INDONESIA NAAS NYA JENDRAL MALLABY TEWAS SIA-SIA OLEH PEJUANG TANAH AIR INDONSESIA😂😂😂😂
Советский союз взял в в плен триста тысяч немцев под Сталинградом, и хотел сделать армию как власовцев, во главе паульсом. Но ни один немец не согласился воевать против своих и Паулюс тоже возглавить предателей. Вот и думаем. Почему.
Colorization makes this doc more interesting. Thanks! 😂
This has everything in it except Stalingrad...
I thought it was about Stalingrad, like yourself, but it's just another old documentary from Dave, with nothing new to offer.
Including Stalingrad.
A video with nothing in it like Stalingrad.
Wtf is even this?
Clickbait
😅
Ok, I'm not crazy.
🎖️🏆⭐🙏💪
Thank you for sharing this
Stalingrad was fought badly by the Germans. They just didn't believe the Soviets had that many men left. Now that we know that the Soviets lost 27 million people in the war who couild blame them?
Yut and Russians killed half of that 27 million with their own bullets lmfao not one step back yeah that just makes so much sense
19 million were civilians. Murdered from german war crimes.
I still blaim them, the Germans has nothing to do in Russia.
Just like the Russians have nothing to do in Ukraine.
The Germans only lost Stalingrad due to misleadership, lack of supplies. The only thing the Russians were capable of were of quick manufacturing, soldier replacements, and rushing.
Stalingrad was THE turning point in WW2 and Operation Bagration THE moment when the German Army was annihilated paving the way for an easy victory at Normandy.
All of 1944 was a time of annihilation for the Germans, who lost at least a million men.
But only with the American Lease Programe since 1941😅😅
@@sagritarius01 The Russians paid for the war many times over in the blood of their citizens and the Americans are fretting over a deal that contributed more to their economy than the outcome of the war. The main reason for lend lease was to enable the british to survive and revive the desperate american economy.
@@sagritarius01
You do realize that the Soviet Union wasn't included until 1941 when operation Barbarossa was started?
Why don't you stick to something you actually know about like nothing.
@@anguscampbell1533 What exactly is it that you think he got wrong?
Nuevo sub desde Paraguay 🇵🇾
I love these British documentaries. They're the ones that invented concentration camps in the Boar Wars in the 1890's. We have to face the truth FDR, desparetly tried to involve the USA in a European war against Germany from 1937 on. After he succeeded in doing that he personally made the war much worse and longer lasting then it could have or should have been. This isn't difficult to see. AFTER Stalingrad, when FDR was sure that the Allies would eventually win (and only then) he proclaimed that only "unconditional surrender" would be acceptable to the Allies. When Germany had the upper hand in the war, the first 2.5 years of the war, they offered very easy peace terms to the UK and the USA. All they asked for was an end to the fighting Alfred Lloyd George, the PM of Great Britain in WW1 said that none of the made up countries in central Europe (created at Versailles) was worth another European war. Britain declared war over Danzig, a german city given to one of those created countries at Versailles. Was it worth 60+ million dead to have a german city be part of Poland? I don't think so. WW2 only helped the USA and the Soviet Union. It was the great unnecessary war that was essentially fought to get the USA out of the Depression and to make money.
Boer wars. The Last being British desire for the Gold and diamonds, and if it were not for the concentration camps England could not have won The British burnt our farms and rounded up all women and children. Basically keeping them hostage in terrible conditions inside concentration camps until the men would surrender. I don't recall them ever even officially apologizing for the wilful murder of thousands of helpless women and children
Concordo
6 Despots fighting over Empire and Real Estate , 80 million died in Europe Alone .( Is anyone here tired of the " Know-it-all " Brit Accent ) - he should have said We Brits invented the Concentration Camps to secure a vein of Gold in the Transvall 30 miles long , and oh yes , then there were the Diamonds , Loyd's of London rejoiced at the suffering , Rhodes and Disraeli probably did too . The Boers did Kick some "A" though .
@@Marco90731Lord Kitcheners creation of the concentration camps to house women and children, snatched off their farms and all crops burnt, was Englands last resort to win. The Boer commandos had more than 200 000 British troops scratching their heads with no answer. Quick lightning raids that did kick some "A", but the men were eventually left with no choice but to surrender as the inhumane conditions in the camps led to endless deaths through starvation, poor hygiene and contagious diseases.
C'est du grand n'importe quoi. Beaucoup d'erreurs qui sautent aux yeux de qui connaît l'histoire de la Seconde Guerre mondiale.
Un ancien officier S2/S3 qui a vus presque toutes les vidéos sérieuses sur les guerres du 20e siècle.
My grandfather died Stalingrad 1943 Don river
He was german???
@@krakrtreacysr907What difference does it make , both sides suffered immeasurable.
@@krakrtreacysr907 Byl nacista.
@@Marco90731 Rozdíl je velký,Sověti bojovali za vlast a Němci byli agresoři.
@@fanda789 Vas Paseriate?
I don't think that the title is correct. This documentary was a mess if it was supposed to be about "The German Army at Stalingrad" surrendering.
Exemplary narration, a pleasure to listen to.
Well I got the whole review of WW2 , Guadalcanal indeed .
I’m expecting John Cleese to announce
“ … and now, for something completely different… “
From my point of view, Germany lost the war when Hitler abandoned the sixth army, which was the elite corps, to its fate.
I'd argue Germany lost when they didn't get the oil from the Caucasus in 1941. Hitler's generals sabotaged the original plan to go towards the Caucasus, opting for an old fashioned aim for the capital plan instead.
Guderian said the War was lost after the Soviet Counter-offensive in front of Moscovy January 1941 .
It was the 6th Army that conquered Poland , and France 1939-40 .
@@Marco90731 The SIberain soldiers, helped red army against nazis in the last times of war
Germany hast already lost the war on Dezember 8th 1941 with the enter of the USA into the war and not alone in Stalingrad or by the Operation Zitadelle 1943 the Operation Barbarossa was at the begining already an big misfault of Hitler😅😅
Same old regurgitated WW2 video stock film, okay if you've never seen the Germans in Russia, however I'd look elsewhere if you're looking for a good, accurate WW2 documentary. Obviously, this is my personal viewpoint & is posted without prejudice. 😀
Generative AI. We're living in a simulation.
Innovador, recoger la historia sin color luego llevarlo a los tiempos en que si es digno de ver. Exelente historia... Good
Hindi version v laya kijiye Bhai
Subscribe v isiliye kiye h.
The same English American revisionism of ww2 History, stating the North African states welcomed the Allies, Egypt and Algiers and others despised their former Colonial masters. The Egyptian people were ecstatic and celebrating in the streets when Tobrouk fell to the Axis forces, also was this production supposed to be about the Germans surrendering in Stalingrad.?
WTF has this to do with The Battle Of Stalingrad?
Is Stalingrad in the Pacific?
Agreed!! I didn’t know Guadalcanal or the Burma Pass was the stepping stone to Stalingrad⁉️
bad historical level here gentleman....Japanese soldiers in Stalingrad also ! lol
@@richlaw1953 bad historical level here gentleman....Japanese soldiers in Stalingrad also ! lol
@@bilplaymo6121👍😆😆 Agreed, and the Zulus were also at the Little Big Horn.
Just a general view of WW2, I kept waiting for the German surrender in Stalingrad
If you make a documentary, you should do it properly; the title on TH-cam "The German Army Surrendered in Stalingrad | Colorized World War II" is a blatant mistake, as it shows SS troops in the Warsaw Ghetto and not in Stalingrad.
Yhden miehen vallanhimo ja hulluus sai aikaan valtavan hävityksen ja monen sukupolven traumat.Miksi häntä ei pysäytetty,mutta kaipa on niin,että paholainen suojelee omiaan!Useampi salamurhayritys epäonnistui,ehkä sekin kertoo jotakin.Paljolta olisi koko maailma säästynyt ilman tämän herran hyvin,hyvin kyseenalaisia saavutuksia!
😂😂😂😂😂❤❤❤❤❤❤
😢😢😢😢😮😮😮😅😅😅😅
There is a fault line in every human being . However, for Germans, it is EXCEPTIONAL..!
Roosevelt?
RIP pour toutes les victimes de ce terrible conflit 😱🙏😰
I do not want to reminisce what really happened during WW2, I’ve seen the destruction it did in the Philippines when I was growing.
Love is the greatest power.
WHY THE SUBTITLES?! PLUS THEY DONT MATCH THE NARRATOR’S WORDS VERBATIM.
Lo podrás subir en español? 🙏🏼
Thumbnail is Warsaw?…
And Stalingrad ? Meandering , Discombob , a review of the Entire War .
To say that the battle of Stalingrad was the first major German defeat is simply wrong. Moskau
17:14 “as force leader of the free french women”….yes that’s about right…great description of the French forces in WW2…
Reconsider your video title.
Malheur aux vaincus !.
Rien que du négatif lorsqu'un français renconte l'histoire sur l'Allemagne
Parce que les français ont été humiliés par leur défaite en 40!
Finalmente em português!!
It's said the Americans who went off to war was the greatest generation. I must agree. Thanks for sharing.
'Shtalin' is wrong in both English and Russian.
I guess it was a huge defeat and humiliation for the German sixth army at Stalingrad, especially general Friedrich Paulus, l believe never had a field marshal ever surrender in German history, l think he is the first high ranking commander to do so rather than commit suicide, one thing for sure the Nazi Germany high command made the mistake for invading the Soviet union or USSR.
Absolutely random article 😒😒😒
Axis powers: ack-sis. bot ack-seas.
Yeah, I know, French and German would have a plural adjective with a plural noun, so axes powers. Sorry, fellas, this is supposed to be in English.
And straff is pronounced staif, not the German way it's spelled.
Papue, New Guinea? pah-poo-wa. No, I know pappy-ya sounds friendlier, but no, just no, OK?
Stalingrad? Named after Stalin. No, not Schtalin. So your Schtalingrad doesn't exist.
Caucasus has three syllables: core ka sus.
And it would be nice if you had script readers who understood English. Here's one problem, that of emphasis:
When you say "The HIGHLY trained officers surrendered," what you are also saying is that there were a lot of barely trained officers who didn't surrender. To avoid this very clear implication, you need to read "the highly trained officers" in an even tone, conveying the meaning that all the officers who surrendered were highly trained. Get it?
You need readers who understand this sort of thing from childhood, though. I.e. native English speakers, or literate adults.
Why is there a pre-WWI map? How silly is that!
Titre du doc: L'armée allemande s'est rendue à Stalingrad. Et ça commence avec la guerre du pacifique? Vous les regardez avant de les poster ou pas?
Why are you calling Stalin Shtalin?
its a AI voice and therefore dislike the video
I agree with you. It should be Stalin and Stalingrad. Narrator must be a German. Nothing wrong with that, but the whole narration is in English. I suspect AI commenting here.
Une bien triste période qui aurait pu mieux finir sans les anglo-saxons et leurs bombes atomiques.
Les anglosaxons vous ont libérés peuple de collabos et de planqués
Tem que ser muito despreparado pra invadir um país e se entregar lá dentro !
Who gave Hitler the Knights Cross ? Btw - thiis is NOT about Stalingrad !
91,000 surrendered at Stalingrad. 5000 returned to Germany years later!
The Soviets never signed the Geneva Conventions or the Hague Convention so both treated their POW's brutally.
How the heavily drugged Hitler lost the War , and then blamed the German Peoples lack of Will and resolve .
Another Brit Narrator somewhat off Topic .
Họ nên được thử lò hơi mà họ đã tạo ra
La narration française du doc est apaisante , cela dit on se rapproche plus d'un diaporama illustrer ,qu'à un documentaire , certaines images me semblent "inédites" ou très peu vues l'ensemble est plaisant, on apprend rien de bien nouveau, et si vous le visionner après un bon repas , c'est la sieste assurée.
Nella sacca di Stalingrado rimasero anche 70 italiani che avevano portato dal fronte dei camion penso degli opel blitz rimasero intrappolati magari qualcuno ne sa più di me 🤔
Márcio roberto da fonseca
Where is Stalingrad!! I see more about war in Africa
Rendeu mesmo, Hittler fez 2 cagadas uma em cima da outra, essa foi nossa sorte.
this is STALINGRAD
Promašen Film 🙃
Το τέλος τού χιτλερισμού.Ποτέ πιά χιτλερισμός.Αμήν.
Благодаря 🎉
Can't enjoy it with the music.
CARYCYN ✌️👍💥
لولا برد روسيا لاصبح عالم جديد تحت سلطة رايخ
Sztálingrád a német logisztika kudarca is volt-
Moralité: très bien traiter les vaincus, avec respect pour les morts et les vivants, se les mettre dans la poche.
Eagle fatally tried to preyed on bear
Shtalin Und Der Furah. Sounds like a sitcom lol.
Bad music selection.
Музыка класс, немцы капитулировали в самом Сталинграде, а не под ним. Из пленённых 90 тыс., говорят, выжило в плену 10%.
Believe the 80 Million versions of the innocent Civilians that died unessasarily.
Keren
Who thick is Schtalin? Where is Sctalingrad? FFS.
subtitle is trash, also video is not what the title says. Mor on OP
กองทัพที่ 6 ของจอมพลพอลลัค 300,000 นาย ยอมจำนน กุมภาพันธ์ 1943
Stalingrado siempre sera recordado como la morada del descanso eterno del nazismo.
en afrique du nord les populations n'ont pas eu le choix d'exprimer leur avis ...
Courtesy of the American Lend Lease Program to Soviets in WW2...
please sound "indonesia"
les vérités n' on de sens que dans la bouche de celui qui raconte.
US people who watch this should think that in 2024, the Atlantic Ocean is not much larger than was the Channel in 1944...let's imagine New York, Washington, San Franciso, L.A. in the same state than Gaza is now...
C'est vraiment pénible les floutages !!!!
PEMENANG PERANG DI EROPA DIA TIDAK MATI TERBANG KE HINDIA BELANDA TERJADI PERTEMPURAN 10 NOVEMBER 1945 DI SURABAYA INDONESIA NAAS NYA JENDRAL MALLABY TEWAS SIA-SIA OLEH PEJUANG TANAH AIR INDONSESIA😂😂😂😂
Sovyetler almanyanın hepsini almalıydı çok sevdikleri yahudiler kıyamadı almanlara üle olsaydı dünya belkide daha iyi yaşanır bir yer olurdu
Perderem suas vidas para defender demonios
Me fromm indonesiaaa
its stalingrad no shtalingrad
wheres putingrad?
Viva a Rússia ❤
У вас два патрона а у нас три русских-формула победы.грустно это.
Onore ai soldati tedeschi
❤❤
🫡🇧🇷🤝🏻🇩🇪🫡
🏆1939🏆
Советский союз взял в в плен триста тысяч немцев под Сталинградом, и хотел сделать армию как власовцев, во главе паульсом. Но ни один немец не согласился воевать против своих и Паулюс тоже возглавить предателей. Вот и думаем. Почему.
If the Christian God was taking sides , he chose the beleaguered Russian Peasants.
"colonialism was a lesser evil" Once again western narratives is making me laugh.
しかし、日本を美味しく食べて、悪者だから食べていいって、、凄いよね！！戦争ってそんな厳しいものなんだろうけど、強いことが正義だ！！今現在も、
colonialisti vs colonialisti. chi scegliere?
Semmi keresnivalójuk nem volt ott
Jerman & jepang berkoalisi dengan BEBAN & PENGHIANAT😅.. cucian sekali mereka berdua..
En idioma español... estólidos! 🤪
Nikel
Kampas.chekhorahy
Nunca foi global. Já existe estoriadores que chamam as duas guerras de 1 ,2 grandes guerras e não mais mundiais porque não foram mesmo
This world is crazy satanique.
Ce monde est fou satanique.
Commentaire d'un néonazis peut-être.
Bland Hamas.
reportage à regarder pour l'otan et zelinski .
？？？？？
Stalin affetmez