Stories of Life in Solitary Confinement | Short Film Showcase
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ย. 2024
- Cali Bondad and reporter Gabrielle Canon captured the voices of inmates from the Pelican Bay State Prison’s Security Housing Unit (S.H.U.), a supermax security prison located in Del Norte County, California. With rare access, we hear inmates' experiences in the facility. This short documentary, produced by Sister, and article published by Canon on Medium offer a visceral snapshot at how inmates live day by day in solitary confinement.
More about the filmmakers:
Cali Bondi: www.calibondad....
Gabrielle Canon: www.gabrielleca...
Sister: welcometosister...
Read an article by Gabrielle Canon for Medium, "Ending Inmate Isolation: Inside the Battle to Stop Solitary Confinement in America."
medium.com/@ga...
➡ Subscribe: bit.ly/NatGeoSu...
➡ Get More Short Film Showcase: bit.ly/ShortFil...
About Short Film Showcase:
A curated collection of the most captivating documentary shorts from filmmakers around the world. See more from National Geographic's Short Film Showcase at documentary.com
Get More National Geographic:
Official Site: bit.ly/NatGeoOf...
Facebook: bit.ly/FBNatGeo
Twitter: bit.ly/NatGeoTw...
Instagram: bit.ly/NatGeoInsta
About National Geographic:
National Geographic is the world's premium destination for science, exploration, and adventure. Through their world-class scientists, photographers, journalists, and filmmakers, Nat Geo gets you closer to the stories that matter and past the edge of what's possible.
Stories of Life in Solitary Confinement | Short Film Showcase
• Stories of Life in Sol...
National Geographic
/ natgeo
I've been in solitary before in CT and it was only 20 days. It felt like an eternity. I am so grateful for my freedom. Just to be around my loved ones... To feel the warmth of my wife. It's amazing. Savor it people.
Stephen L what did you do?
We are supposed to savor our freedom as a being on this planet because others of our species might decide that you broke THEIR rules. I am all about having a justice system but it is obviously broken in America.
"Free country" with the largest prison system by FAR. Hilarious how people think there is any freedom in America.
@@Quoteunquot3 IT'S HOW WE STAY FREE...KEEPS THE DANGEROUS PEOPLE THAT COULD DESTROY US AWAY FROM THE GOOD
@@Quoteunquot3 I would love to see how broken your justice system is
"Thank you for taking the time to hear my voice, because our voices are rarely heard"
That's some hardcore shit right there man.
So is what he did to his victims
Sage Fields true
Don't go to jail then
I here you bro keep your head up
@@sagefields5847 you don't know what he did, so STFU. you have no idea how they treat people
I went to prison for drug charges in my early twenties and did 90 days in the hole in Jackson prison inside the old hospital. The worse part of the time I did was the incessant yelling from guys who had lost there minds. They would literally wail all day all night about their hallucinations. Besides the time inside the dog run and shower cage it was lock down. No books No human interaction. Luckily I didnt have any adverse psychological affects but I seen guys go insane in even a few months.
I'm sorry for what you went through.
90 days in the hole? ...you should have written a song!
GOD bless you my Brother... peace
@@lawrencetraylor1260
Did 12 yrs myself. Spent a 60 day, 90 day and 8 month term in solitary during those years. Here to say you speak truth.
@@rickmcroberts9101 yo let it be known that my name to is Lawrence traylor but I'm not the one who spent that much time in any jail. Just wanted to clarify that...peace
the thing that haunts me at night is knowing that there are likely thousands of people now living in solitary who are completely innocent. 😭
I spent 67 days in solitary and was going nuts!!! I couldn't imagine doing years in there!!
Hi . Wy in solitary?
@@gaiettatuttoattaccato5435 None of your business!
@@gaiettatuttoattaccato5435 He stole the guards last jam donut
Do you like my diaper
Glad to hear you're out. I'm so sorry you had to go through that.
I spent 2 years 8 months in the hole , I also did 15 years on the main line. Over all I have nightmares still to this day from the hole time. I have been out of prison for 5 years now and doing good. I still have a hard time being around people or going to stores . If it was not for my wife I would have locked my self. Am not trying to get any one to feel bad for me. I did a lot of bad things and I deserved prison. Am just saying I feel for they’s men. Thank you 🇺🇸
I was in solitary confinement at a mental hospital for 2 weeks, I hated it. I was stuck barely even saw staff. The only sun light I could see was the window on the roof in one of my rooms. It’s made me learn a lot about myself. I’d never wish it on anyone else but it really helped me see myself different and be more grateful of my freedom
The hapiness that guy had being interviewed for this video exhibit the sadness and how little contact he has within those walls.
As a sister that lost the ability to hear my brother’s voice due to solitary confinement... Thank You 💜🙏🏽 💜
I pray for his victims
@@bluepill-suppository3240 I hate you
Was that due to solitary confinement or was that due to the decision that lead to that confinement? That is the reality we must face
My prayers to these convicts they still are human beings
This felt longer than 5 minutes.
It was longer than 5 minutes. 5:25.
Mohammad Mohd Damn.
Mohammad Mohd I don’t feel like laughing.
You know what else is longer than 5 minutes
5:26
Please lord don’t ever let me go to jail or prison.
But Juvy was Groovy !🍺👊back in da day
Don't commit any felonies and you should be fine 👍
@Harry Johnson I'll bet you good money the former will do a lot more to stay out of prison than the latter.
Rayshaun chase that’s up to you not god
Or misdemeanors lol they can land you in jail.
Makes you appreciate your freedom more.. Damn.
If you appreciate something you’ll do more to keep it
Mistless Dragoon they don’t deserve anything they are the worst of the worst
Yeah
@Benny Hill not even god is god.
I was put in solitary confinement & exactly like you said, be grateful & appreciate your freedom because once your locked inside that concrete closet it's the beginning of true dark evil.
I am currently in a relationship with a gentleman who spent 10 years straight in the pelican bay shu... and the stories I hear I’m surprised that he is able to function as well as he does.. when the spirit is broken on that level it’s life changing and these guy’s require a lot of love and patience... something needs to be done to change the prison system!!!
Amen! To that! People need to understand not all inmates are murderers or rapists!
I’ve spent years back there and if it wasn’t for a letter I received that gave me hope I honestly would have left mentally broken from solitary. I hate to say it but a lot of us actually deserved to be there.
The department of corrections system is there because people forgot to teach their offspring how to behave civilized. They also failed to teach their offspring the concept of consequences one has to deal with based on making really bad decisions in their lives. Some consequences are very severe like being sentenced to solitary confinement for comitting very violent crimes like assault and battery or brutally murdering other people.
Why would you want a relationship with a guy that's inside?
@@pasofino2199 I've been writing to a brother for 13 years, now in Pelican Bay. He's been going downhil physically and mentally since there. I know he's got himself there for making stupid decisions but I can't give on him. I was "a letter" that dropped into his cell. Its a big commitment to keep someone encouraged in that environment, but someone needs to care.
you do hear shit. its so trippy man. specially being a teenager in there.. only did ten days. thats it. felt like a fucking year.
What did you hear
I was 14 in a cell for two days (not my first time, but first time like this and for this long) and I didn’t eat the two plastic sandwiches they gave me. The lights were on the whole time and a guard would walk by and punch in every thirty minutes so it was hard to fall asleep, they would rarely tell us the time and at one point I heard a couple of them laughing and watching a movie. The only good thing about that situation was the fact that my friends were next to me and I almost couldn’t hear them, and the worst part about it is when I was in the court hearing my family (at least in my case) has to pay the fines and the fees for something I did. It’s been 11 months I’m on house arrest which if I break I go to court again and my family has to pay a 5 grand fine, I find out how much time I’m getting in 5 days and if I can ill serve every second of it in solitary because at least right now, I feel at peace when I’m alone. My message to anyone reading this is don’t put yourself in a situation like I’m in because its truly torment on every level.
Wimp
@@noahg5009 thank you for sharing your experience. Hope you won’t go back as well. And it’s too scary we all have chance to get wrongfully convicted
@@bonitobonita9263 you don't get solitary just for being convicted, you have to commit another offense when your prison to get the solitary. basically you have to double down on breaking the rules, once in society, and again Prison
The guy speaking at 0:37 absolutely shook me to my core. I've never heard so much pain in a man's voice.
How cruel. No sunlight, no human contact, not even the sight of a blade of grass. Buried alive in concrete.
Heather M so murdering innocent people in cold blood, isnt as bad as solitary confinement? GTFO
leolion1993 if anything help them get their minds straight if not give him his wish
Ya well their victims are either dead or scarred for life. ..who cares how these scumbags " feel ". I hope it's beyond agony....this is why I say no DP. Let them suffer till they are old and decrepid ....then put em in a trash bag n throw em off a cliff.
Remember these people are merciless killers who have no respect for other human life. They take lives .
What would be wors, be killed, or be in a concrete cell for 8,5 years...
I have never heard a better speech than the gentleman at the end. He knew when to finish, he had said all he needed and knew he had been understood, thats why he said ok.
I think he also said okay because a guard said it was times up but I agree he spoke well for someone who is in isolation.
please have them write a book please!! that last part really got to me.
no
Anyone is allowed to write a book
Ok I’ll let them know
You have to understand there all Freddy Kugers and Michael Myers in there Remember.
@@johnmoreno493 Brooooooooooo
Thanks k
It is simply beyond me how this could ever reform someone. It's inhumane.
Its not only about reform though. Unfortunately it is also about justice.
If someone you loved was taken from you at the hands of another, you may not care about reform.
@@dcamron46 I have experienced that.
@@dcamron46 I absolutely 100% do not believe in torturing someone to death.
So was doing the crime they are in for
@@87rbm89 No not at all. We are all different and I just don't believe that anyone should be tortured to death for a heinous crime they committed. Punished yes but not tortured.
the fact that there are so many people in the comments defending this is disgusting. this treatment is inhumane. prisons are meant to be for rehabilitation of criminals, not for their torment. why have people locked in small rooms their whole lives when you could teach them how to integrate into normal society again without wanting to commit crimes?
You think they haven't tried? Prison these days is more of a free home than a rehab center, it doesn't teach inmates anything. It only gives them time to think about who to get revenge on when they're out.
Prison is not for rehabilitation if one's sentence is life without possibility of parole. Plain and simple, it is a warehouse operation. If they got to this point, they did some bad shit - like murdering someone for financial gain, with pre-meditation, lying in wait, kidnapping, using a firearm, etc. Really Bad people.
THANK you. People are absolutely awful sometimes. I can't believe anyone would defend torture.
They did the crime plain and simple
If it's meant for rehabilitation, then why sentence people to life? Don't get me wrong, I don't think they should be locked away alone in a tiny little cell.
This video was absolutely beautiful, thank you for always supplying great content National Geographic, but can you make these videos longer? like at least 6-8 minutes I wanna know more!
The lights are the worst, 24/7 with the lights on. The screaming and the smells, and the high school age guards. Nobody comes out better, if they come out at all.
I've learned a lot about solitary confinement from courses I've taken over the years. Prisoners that are kept in isolation (sometime referred to as a Special Housing Unit), are kept there because they are considered to be a threat to the prison in which they are held. They typically receive different colored tops to wear to separate their status from the general population prisoners. So, someone from a SHU could be clothed in deep red; whereas an inmate from general population could be clothed in kiwi green.
Instead of solitary confinement, lets put them to do productive things to help other people. Give them jobs in jail.
Inmates get jobs in jail. My pops used to send me money from jail.
Victor Gross be was hustling.
What kind of a job , and how many kinds of revenue producing positions within each facility , can you give the majority of these men , who need CONSTANT SUPERVISION and usually are men who CANNOT get along with other men . . . and may kill them . . .?
They do have jobs and they barely get paid. One example was them fighting fires last year but they weren't allowed to list it on their resume. It's modern day slave labor.
the job they are given is to be a respectable member of a functional society..which they failed at miserably...which IS why they are in jail
Worked in prisons 26 yrs. Worked a max joint, worked isolation units, worked death row. These people are MONSTERS! It's impossible to make you understand what demons they are. They are master manipulaters. Rarely do you meet one who doesn't deserve to be there. I've been retired 10 yrs. I deal with depression, anxiety, persecutory paranoia and ptsd. DO NOT PITY THESE WALKING NIGHTMARES!!
Sorry why y say that they are monster???
Time in the box isn't something everyone can cope with.. I myself did a year in the SHU at upstate correctional facility in Malone county New York... Although my mind was strong enough to deal with the say thing 24 hour's a day there were some who would bang there heads on the steel door in an attempt to silence the demons in their minds I can only think of how tragic it must be to go that distance I thank God everyday I came out intact in body and mine to those still there my heart goes out to them and their families there are some there who been in solitary confinement for over 25 years.
Served 12 yrs.. Did a 60 day, a 90 day and a 9 month term in the box myself.
Never forget all the brothers we left behind and pray that they may find and maintain the strength to keep on keepin on.. until freedom finds them..
Peace
This is deep. It’s like he said “ not even animals are treated like this.” Crazy how some people spend years in SHU units.
As if it were less bad to hurt an animal 🙄
Wait until you hear where Walmart eggs come from
Wow! Ppl been in SC for longer than he's been alive!? That's amazing. I can't imagine what coping skills needed to live like that for so long and not commit suicide! Wow!!
U need the skill to not do crime..they do crime and expect to be put in a five star hotel and not be treated like a animal..
@@vioritymist8180 Why does it have to be '5 Star Hotel' or 'treated like an animal'? Why can't they just be treated as the humans they are?
@@TheTranceCartel because the fact that they themselves didnt treat someome or something with respect which is why they are in jail to begin with so why would they get treated with respect
@@TheTranceCartel would you treat a murderer or animal abusers like they are a funtional memeber of society?
one of the most important things to consider here is how often people are wrongly imprisoned. our prisons and jails are full of innocent people. we are locking up 13 and 14 year old kids for smoking cigarette
And sadly prison is a huge industry in America.
CocoaAndTea I agree with you 100%
People get imprisoned for stealing food for their kids, for joining gangs, for being ruffians, instead of being helped through counseling, mentoring, charity, or similar things. It's sad.
Shut up that's like 1 in a million
@@jakesontiano ??? It is WAY more than one in million....also text VAST majority of prisoners are incarcerated for non violent drug crimes... There are more people incarcerated in the USA than Russia, China and North Korea COMBINED...the model of for profit prisons and the USAs approach to fighting the "drug war" are fundamentally broken.
Their voices were trembling that depicts what they have been gone through.
And what about the trembling voices of their victims?
The prison system in USA is so fucked up looking from the eyes of an outsider. I think what is more important than shoving these people into small, dark rooms is mental healthcare. If you put people into a box for 22,5 hours a day their amount of hatred will just rise.
But I mean it's USA... give everyone guns and they will be fine? right -.-
EDIT: I would also like to add a little rant about the legal system in USA: If you have money for a lawyer your good, but if you don't well you are fucking fucked.
exactly! You will never see a wealthy person in jail, not because they don't commit crimes, but because they can afford the lawyers to get them off!
+lranieri1 unless the rich mess with money then they get fucked.
+Mr. Treez wow I didn't know you are so much of a intellectual! check my math but prison for life sounds much more expensive then giving a rehabilitative treatment to people for a short period of time (also slightly more humane then leaving them to rot by themselves in a box) and don't bring veterans into this you self righteous fuck. And hey man you can help the poor get out of poverty and lower crime rates or you can blame them for committing more crimes because they're poor.
+lranieri1 al Capone ?
+Mr. Treez You're literally the dumbest person I've ever seen.
heart breaking, so many people don't deserve this at all
of course they deserve it, the WORST of the worst offenders get put in solitary confinement. Drug lords like El Chap, Terrorists, Bombers, People who commit crimes in jail.
Pelican Bay is for problem prisoners. gang affiliation and murders
@@BulletTrucking99 you can get sent to solitary confinement for 30 days for 1 fight.
Then dont fight @@4y564
They should install one of those screens that can project different scenery on them and actually give them something to do in there at the very least. How does solitary confinement not count as "cruel or unusual punishment".
I agree. It's safer for the guards too if the prisoners are busy.
I think the logic behind them not getting rid of extended stays in solitary is that they need something, a punishment, to serve as a deterrent for bad behavior. They don't send you to solitary for extended periods for no reason. You really have to mess up...and mess up multiple times in order to be sent there for an extended period of time. Tommy Silvlerstein killed what, 2 or 3 people (including guards) before they finally threw away the key to his cell.. If you get caught smoking, they arent going to give you a year in the hole. You REALLY have to mess up.
@@michaelr.4878 No not true if someone hits you and you fight back you go in the hole. So if i go to jail for a traffic ticket get into a fight in jail that will end up in me going to the hole and getting more time. Now what if someone hits me i hit her she falls and dies now im a "murderer" and if a murderer does anything wrong im deff going to the hole...see how that works? The system is designed to break us down its modern-day slavery this is not right at all
They’re in there to pay for their crime not to be amused...idiots
I did 27 days in prison confinement IT'S NOT A GAME YOU WANNA PLAY I HATED IT
Please be good no matter what. Don't go back there.
Edria Mcintire I’m here in Liverpool prison Walton. I’ve got my 2 phones, spice and no cell mate to annoy me. If it wasn’t for these incredibly corrupt guards, I’d go mad. McDonalds tonight and watch the game x
You're supposed to hate it. Its called a deterrent
@@phil2003ashleigh Something to be proud of 😏😏
phil2003ashleigh are you still there?
Those conditions should be administered for short term penalties of prison rules, not long term periods of incarceration. That is extreme torture.
I did 5 days in solitary, with full restrictions. It didnt break me, but how I had to cope would eventually fail. I felt this. Only some form of self hypnosis can get you through. After a few days, my main goal was to not think about life on the outside. I kept the image of the gunslinger walking through a desert, and would let it build to sleep or full distraction.
Did have other dudes to yell to across the way, and a guard walking by or down the hall to harass for things.
Is it inhumane? For sure. If a person just can't hold it together, then what? Not holding it together, while not able to do anything about it, will snap your mind, and imagine months and years to go still. The side effects of the punishment should be monitored as a medical issue, because it can be a form of torture, not just isolation.
every time i feel stuck out here i watch this and calm down.
“Has it ever struck you that life is all memory, except for the one present moment that goes by you so quick you hardly catch it going?”― Tennessee Williams
The inmates interviewed were very articulate and thoughtful people. Their testimony is proof of true change and mental stability that cannot be simulated by an acting criminal / societal menace.
Your so stupid they just know what there doing they are playing you
Prisons are meant to rehabilitate the criminals not enrage them even more. This treatment is inhumane and cruel.
Name one prison in the entire world that "rehabilitates" criminals. Rehabilitation sounds really good to spectators, but politicians won't pay for it and inmates can't be forced to. It's an illusion.
@@jonloftness5210 sweden.
@@jessica2309 norway aswell
@@andremendez3050 yes where they rewards murderers with free housing and education
@@DirtyBeatzMusic count me in!
I'm literally crying
Why is this so strickted??? Only a massive murders should have a punish like this. Not some ex members of gangs. Wtf.
+Mr. Treez it's just an opinion
+Mr. Treez I'm with u rules r rules u can't go to jail then join a gang in the jail possible causing problems and not get put in solitary confinement I mean the amount of time in solitary confinement is dumb but the idea of it is ok
SummerWine19
Do you know some gang members are so powerful in prison they are a danger to other inmates and must be kept solitary. People who murder civilians are less dangerous than gang leaders who murder other inmates.
and gangs kill people...omg amazing isn't it
Everything is so grey in this place, even the sky
It’s like being buried alive!
Oh well, don't do the crime.
How did you get buried alive?
guess who simon you’re simple and closed minded.
Kathy Oberle horrible
@@charlottewhat7781 it's punishment...meabt to not be enjoyable..are you dumb...its not the fact that has close minded facts...its the fact people go to jail because they did something really bad...they're not gonna get a slap on the wrist and a light spanking
Wow, the strength of these inmates......
The goal of prison was to rehabilitate and reform people. It's not that anymore, it's a system of _vengeance_, not _justice_.
We should be putting these people into mental healthcare. They can become better people. They should have a chance to live life again.
Those who cannot, after an intensive amount of mental care, become different people should be put in prison.
Your comment is touching for those who have a heart, this is heart breaking to think that people can be treated like this. It's so brutal.
That’s why they hide under the misleading name “criminal justice” rather than criminal punishment. If they were to call it appropriately ppl would see it for what it really is.
ce collie anyone can be put in here by COs. not limited to the worst of the worst
We should have prison like this in the uk
Not true. Study "the purposes of punishment." There are at least 4. Of which rehabilitation is only one.
"If it breaks you, you are going to be broken ".... such wisdom
Most of the time I don't give a crap but this is really shitty behaviour towards humans
you know what else is shitty behaviour. Killing people. Ruining families. There is a reason these people are in there. they are treated worse than animals because they are worse than animals
You know what else is shitty behaviour. Killing animals in some warehouse yet a big population of trash humans support this pathetic practice
+KrazyKrzysztof yea except we need those animals. would you rather billions of people die??
Link to science which says we need to murder animals? I must have missed that one. You sound like a serial killer who says he can't stop killing humans because " we have to."
Thank you
Interesting perspective. Using this for an advanced ESL lesson today. Thanks for sharing.
I did 4 years in ad-seg and it's so mentally destroying keeping people in there! I suffer from deep depression and nightmares
I wish you the best of luck my friend
Well I am 50 yrs old and I keep doing the right thing never did anything wrong in my life never been in jail or in prison thank god . I do pray for those in prison 🙏🙏🙏
Tbh I'd rather get the death penalty than suffer through this.
So, this is "rehabilitation", this is torture, not even an animal should go through this, no matter what these people have done, this is inhumane
Some people do deserve this. some of these people have done the most horrendous acts ever
Rhianna Murphy true words Rihanna.... People think it's fine to do this... But... don't you dare do it to a human being... Who let's be honest are the cancer of the world.
If you heard what they did you’d think differently
@@rjwentz8090 exactly
I'm pretty sure if your dog bites people and keeps biting people they put the dog down
can't wait to see how god judges the judge.
If you lock an animal up like this you would be charged with a felony for being cruel the that animal.
Prisons: state and federal, are charged with protecting inmates from each other. When an inmate kills another inmate, do you allow that inmate to stay in GP because you think isolation is mean, or do you protect other inmates by isolating him? When that inmate is a shot caller and tells his gang to kill other inmates, do you leave him in GP, or isolate him? Until you've run a maximum security prison, try not to be so condescending to people that have and do the best they can managing apex predators.
How would you ever see that
@@chaddevine565 you wait
22 and a half hours in a cell! What a treat! I was in lock down for 23 and a half hours in west valley cuz of the pandemic!
Me too in Adelanto ..30 min. to shower use the kiosk and make a quick call ..did a week there before GP the guy next door lost it , busted his own head open on the top rack
this is something I'm torn on. assuming these people are here for a reason, they did something to get there. but personall I can't imagine not having human contact or not seeing outside for that long. it's a strange feeling that im feeling and words can't describe the mixed emotions. thank you natgeo.
Tami: I know this is a really old comment but I worked Psych Services in the prison system for many years. These guys are not without human contact. They can talk to other inmates, security etc. If you notice, in the film here, the pods have doors the inmates can talk through. They just aren't allowed physical contact with other inmates. Different facilities call it different things, SHU (Security Housing Unit) Iso (Isolation) Seg but they are all typically set up the same way. They have 12 cells. This allows each guy 2 hours out a day. They let one person at a time out. They can walk around the pod, talk to other guys on the pod, shower, or go outside. Here, they try to make it sound like these guys are locked in a concrete box with no human interaction. That's not the case. They just don't have physical contact with other inmates.
Don't get me wrong, I am not saying it isn't a terrible place to be. It is terrible but they do have the opportunity to talk and interact with others regularly.
I hear much wisdom in your words. Most seem to be missing that age old analogy of not judging a person unless you have walked a mile or two in their shoes...
Only Ca❤️ and southern Oregon grow Redwood trees- in the whole world. I love my state. My heart breaks for these people rotting in the hole. Prayers
only psychopaths deserve the box for 23 hours a day. they dont feel pain regardless.
everyone else shouldnt be in there for more than 15 days
Have them guarded by psychpathic guard's
@@watersbey25
They are, guaranteed. What's worse, murdering by gunshot or by torture?
@@watersbey25 murderers are psychopaths
@@vioritymist8180 serial killers are psychopaths, agreed...
@Sam pretty much anyone who does crime is a phycopath...thinking they can escape the law and justice forever is a disease...thst makes you dangerous and unstable...requiring you to be locked up
If we make these people suffer like that, what separates us from them? Who is is the real animal; us, them, or both of us? We are then subjecting ourselves to a depraved mindset, one that is above reproach in that the only difference between the two of us is that we live in the free world.
Thankyou
Wrong. The difference is our action is a reaction. We didn’t start it. Solitary confinement should only be reserved for very special cases though i.e. the Bundys and Dahmers of this world. It actually feels good that there is such a strong punishment for the sick sociopaths like them that are caught.
@@211bEanS112 the people that believe in vindictive punishment believe that there is free will and basically 'evil' people. But when you start really examining it closely, you find it's not so simple. Look into it yourself
@@fjjchj9074 Vindictive? So, the jury of their peers, that found them guilty, are vindictive? You're actually saying that the jury/judge, acted unreasonably, wanting only revenge! I think it's you that should exam it more closely. The simplicity of it is, commit the crime, expect the time. The criminals did exercise their free will, and did an evil act. The jury/judge did the same thing. What's complicated about that?
Like at lot of things in our world and society solitary get misused,I don’t believe people should do indefinite periods of time for gang affiliation, fights,things of that nature,but what about the guy that murders 9 women, sexually molest and kills children and is caught,serial killers. The guy that heaven forbid rapes and murders your relative, you think solitary is to harsh a punishment?
How impressive this would have been if they spoke of the isolation, finality and and loneliness of their victims. Now, that would have real impact.
My husband was at PBSP SHU for 7.5 years... Just awful.. still suffering the after effects from being there. He was in C12 last..in and out of mental crisis beds.. can't even program right as bad as he wants to. No rehabilitation whatsoever.
I served a 12 year sentence. Even now in the free world I continue to do that time as the struggle to prevent the time to do me. Although I never met him I consider your husband a brother in arms so to speak. Tell him to fight the good fight and keep on keepin on in the free world.
My prayers are with you,
Peace
yea you all feel bad for em until you heard what crimes they did...
jack sparrow I don’t care what they did. You shouldn’t treat a human being in this way.
@@M011y. so if they beat and raped an innocent girl , you dont think they should be locked up and treated like the uncivilized animal that they are? oh and let me guess they should vote too right?
Michael Collins Fine, put them in general population and see what happens, in fact i think that’s the best solution.. 😂👌
Molly Wonder how you would feel if their victims were one of your loved ones!
jack sparrow this isnt done without thought for sure. They do it to break them,they should really be in death row ,but at least theyre not in society to do more damage. I have 0 pity for them. They ARE monsters. These bleeding hearts should offer to serve their time for them Lol
It’s kinda a trip these inmates see nothing but concrete, metal, and windows but right outside their prison is some of the most beautiful landscapes in the world (I’d argue)
They dont have Windows to look out of so its the deepest darkest hole you csn be in with no one therr to pull you out its a hard place to be in
I was a CO. These guys deserve this
KevinCummings Fitness It does bother me that the video doesn’t say anything about how those guys got there.
Their there for a reason
@@Adam-bq2vw Exactly.
In my experience, the 23 and 1 guys were either child molesters, killers, rapists, or other very high offenses like that.
I once spent a night in a drunk tank (solitary confinement), can you believe they threw me out before breakfast, seriously what way is that to treat a prisoner?
But on a serious note, that supermax prison is really messed up and inhumane.
And the people inside are not ?
@@vioritymist8180 Undoubtedly many indeed are inhumane, I'm not by any stretch of the imagination a social liberal but treating people worse than caged animals in a zoo cannot be a solution.
they don't get treated like animals....some jails do...DONT JUDGE THE WHOLE COUNTRY BY THE ACTS OF A FEW...of they are in jail the deserve it to some extent...treated like animals is in other words put in a cell and fed not premium food and not a five star hotel
@@vioritymist8180They are prisons in Serbia and Russia just like US Supermax prisons, but yet Americans take the higher moral ground, I for one would never go to the US because the risk is to great.
you guys need to do this again with Leopoldo Lopez. he has 2 years in confinement because he was a leader of opposition of the dictatorship in Venezuela.. he was sent to jail because he was fighting to make our country free again from those rats from Venezuela government
Point very well made..
i think of guys like him and the inmates of north korean prisons
Inhumane and deplorable,it should not be allowed EVER,sending love to those inmates
They throw them in the hole and forget about them ..... how’s that for rehabilitation ??? 🤨 ..... Matthew 5:7 ... Blessed are the merciful for they shall receive mercy ... James 2:3 ... For judgment will be merciless to one who has shown no mercy ; mercy triumphs over judgement ...
Yeah
I heard your voice .... God be with you
Living alone for a very long time sure gets you philosophical
Lord visit those men and Women! Let them see your Light!!! Touch there hearts and Ban Solitary confinement !!!
Why should the lord visit criminals? Is your lord therefore unjust if he is assisting the aggressor?
@@huitzilopochtli_tenochtitl496 no He loves everyone no matter what they have done !
Trust the most intense situation to be in I did 34 months in NYDOCS SHU
We all make mistakes. If you are innocent, then you will be in my prayers. I pray to God to protect you because no one is more powerful than the almighty
I loved solitary confinement, i spent years in isolation since i was a little kid. I hate human beings and human contact. Iv always lived inside my head since i was 6 years old.
Me too
1. Don’t do the crime if you can’t do the time.
2. Prison system have a lot of short comings and need to focus in providing opportunity and rehabilitation.
3. For the inmates that have been released, we need to support them in any way we can.
You dont get to decide what is a crime though. Sonetimes your crime is being born into a certain race or disagree with the state.
i believe solitary confinement is necessary for some, but you shouldnt have to be in there for more than a year, like seriously 8 years by yourself?
You do the crime you do the time . Simple as that . Think before you do something . And if there there for a resson. The worst of the worst . I mean yes I know sitting in a one with by urself . But they chose that life .. Kind of ...
carkycarly07 There is one gang member (AB) who is in for 32 years now....since 1983 when he killed 2 gang leaders (at least 1 in self defense) and killed a prison guard.
He is the reason the government created the most secure prison in the nation!! ADX Florence. even though he was a brutal killer 32 years is a very long time half his life in solitary sheesh
carkycarly07 There is one gang member (AB) who is in for 32 years now....since 1983 when he killed 2 gang leaders (at least 1 in self defense) and killed a prison guard.
He is the reason the government created the most secure prison in the nation!! ADX Florence. even though he was a brutal killer 32 years is a very long time half his life in solitary sheesh
What's 8 years to someone who has experienced it for 1 whole year (like you suggested)
Jesse. I believe after 15 day's causes psychological problems and yrs just flat out inhuman your makin literally animals humans need to be social strip the basic needs of humans we do go insane
It's sounds like these prisoners want a chance... Probably like their victims wanted a chance to.
Do you know their charge
I'm sure the us military wanted a chance to continue to torture people like Chelsea manning ♥️ of course they're the true victims right
8 and a half years in the hole.....my god.....I can't even begin to imagine the psychological effects of that
Wow!
What is that last mans name? I wanna write him a letter? Is he stil on solitary. Does anyone know
Daniel Treglia (T66950) is a prisoner at Pelican Bay State Prison, SHU-C3-102, Box 7500, Crescent City, CA 95532.
My chest is tight and I feel short on air just watching this..
Sadly some of these folks are innocent, however, this is no life for criminals.
@ 1:30 you can clearly see a vertically rectangular cut, in the wall, where there's supposed to be a window! The engineers cut a window in each cell, but the state covered them up. It looks as if it's filled in with Portland Cement.
this is disgusting! I am not sure how people who think this type of punishment is effective can sleep at night!
I'd forgive them. Revenge won't bring anyone back, revenge won't do any good. God has planned out everything for us. Forgiveness is a beautiful thing.
@@qwizzyquan1602 What dream world are you from? The one where every one wears rose coloured glasses. God didn't plan for evil, He wants us to combat it. Forgiveness is only one side of the hat, punishment is the other.
It is cruel. I stopped judging prisoners when I was in hospital after an ankle fusion. I was in an auto crash and my ankle was smashed. After the surgery, my nerve block for pain wore off and all hellish torturous pain broke loose. NO ONE would give me anything to relieve pain, or else they did and it didn't do anything bc it was beyond belief. I said that I wouldn't wish this suffering on any prisoner, no matter what they did. And it's true; suffering is suffering. This is the U.S.A. in the 21st Century. Why does solitary still exist with programs like the A.C.L.U. and human rights coalitions? If one day someone is going to be released, or not, it's not wise to break them down beyond repair. I would turn into a worse creature.
And there victim might never see the light of day again either or touch a blade a grass.
The most logical and balanced argument here. The rest of commentators must either be crooks, or the relatives of such crooks. I hate it when people sympathise with the aggressor but never the victim.
I’ve done a few months in solidarity and it definitely makes you go a lil crazy
I unfortunately have been to jail. 99% are guilty and can't take responsibility. The few times I have been arrested it was my wrong doing. I am grateful I was able to go through veterans court
Being locked away in seg has changed my mindset. The facilities I have been to has changed me as a person
Help released intimates
Sounds absolutely horrible. Now that we've heard the inmates side of the story, I'd like the hear the institution's side of the story. After all, there are always at least two sides to every story.
Would anyone like to argue that this is actually moral?
All the Stockholm Syndrome in the comments is disgusting. No one deserves this, no matter the crime. What on earth does torturing people accomplish? You're not reducing the amount of murderers in the world. You're DEFINITELY not reducing the suffering in the world. Just wait for someone new to become illegal and watch as you're thrown in the SHU for a nonviolent crime. It's a slippery slope from condoning torturing violent to condoning torture in general. Why is it only legal and morally sound to some of you when the state enacts torture??
JupiMeow you definitely have my respect.
The definition of pure sadness ..
You escape in your mind because you know your trapped and alone in reality...it’s what helped me
not going to prison, and not offended again when inside prison will help you even more
My dad committed suicide in pelican bays shu on April 28th 2024-thank you for sharing this video.
Plain and simple, dont DO THE CRIME
Ajh 89 sometimes they don’t have that option specially if they were born in a bad neighborhood
True.
If only it was that simple..Plenty of INNOCENT people have died in prison. You're ignorant. Everyone isn't guilty.
Must b nice to be as privledged as u.
During pandemic I now pay attention and more responsible to better decision making in Life
You just mentioned the key thing to staying on the outside of corrections facilities. We simply need to make better decisions in life or we just might face very severe consequences if we get locked up for making very bad decisions in our lives. It is called personal responsibility that many people in our society seem to have lost this trait. They simply make horrible decisions even when they know that they are not engaging in good activities which could harm others they come in contact with.
@@harolddenton6031 Thanks for sharing. My pastor teaches the Holy Scriptures, one thing for certain is God says Be Ye holy for I am Holy. There is more rebellion in the human family that are not incarcerated than they that are.....
You have two options...lock them up forever or lock them up with an ability for them to gain control and accountability. Cages make animals meaner....lock up but start to rebuild them...
if possible. sometimes the mind you have in front of you is so warped, so twisted it's purely predator.
You can feel the emptiness.... It's very sad. They take you from being able to see the light of day again. That is a nightmare but then you have to think about the nightmare the victim or victims went thru. That's why it is very important for young people to be more knowledgeable about the repercussions of there actions. Life is not a game. I'm going to show my son's & daughters this video to let them know this can happen in this country if they decide they want to break any laws.
We are human beings and we have feelings of hate and love for each other
But when someone do something dreadful and gruesome it boils our blood
And when such people are being punished in such ways we feel bad for them
This is Human Nature
Is it not possible that some aspects of solitary confinement are necessary in order to protect the guards/other inmates from dangerous inmates but other aspects are just inhumane and serve no purpose? For example, I can see why they must be separated from other prisoners and live alone. However, do they need to be prevented from having monitored visits from close family members? Also being prevented from ever going outside just seems very cruel.