Broadcasters clash on ‘basket case’ Scotland | LBC debate
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 เม.ย. 2024
- With the resignation of SNP leader Humza Yousaf creating questions about what is next for Scotland, Nick Ferrari was joined by broadcasters Andrew Neil and Lesley Riddoch.
Ms Riddoch offered a fiery response to Nick and Mr Neil’s terming Scotland a ‘basket case’.
The SNP is in meltdown as a tearful Humza Yousaf quit his role as party leader on Monday after the collapse of their power-sharing deal with the Scottish Greens.
Addressing the breakdown of the deal on Monday, Mr Yousaf acknowledged that he had "underestimated" the level of hurt it would cause.
Mr Yousaf will stay on as first minister while an SNP leadership election takes place, following in similar footsteps to his predecessor Nicola Sturgeon.
The first minister u-turned after previously saying he would not resign and instead intended to win two no-confidence votes.
Listen to the full show on Global Player: app.af.globalplayer.com/Br0x/...
#nickferrari #SNP #humzayousaf #scotland #labour #lbc
LBC is the home of live debate around news and current affairs in the UK.
Join in the conversation and listen at www.lbc.co.uk/
Sign up to LBC’s weekly newsletter here: l-bc.co/signup
It's LBC's reputation that will be the 'basket case' if the Sangita issue isn't dealt with.
Yawn
Of the 12 UK regions/nations. Scotland has the most devolved power. Northern Ireland & East England have lower rates of child poverty than Scotland. Why?
@@AB-zl4nh LBC exposed child prostitution in Mary Dolls constituency.
For sure. 💯 LBC's reputation is on the line if they don't bring back Sangita.
She’s on a plane to Rwanda. Bye Sangita👋
Looks like it's Scotland bashing season again. I've never heard so much shart in my life. Andrew Neil is a hack. Oh yeah, bring back Sangita!
Another nat that doesn’t realise the difference between the SNP and Scotland.
@@Andrew-dk8rl you don’t know the difference between rhetoric and reality.
Anything that goes well it's because of SNP. Anything that goes badly it's because of Westminster. Hmm sounds suspicious
@@scotjohnston9248 an SNP supporter commenting about others being taken in by rhetoric? The irony.
@@Andrew-dk8rl I don’t believe any parties rhetoric. I live in Scotland and it is in no way as bad as the media would have you believe.
Where’s sangita
Enough of toadies like Ferrari, where's Sangita Myska?
I agree 💯. Sangita has integrity. I cannot say the same of Ferrari.
Ferrari is on “the” payroll!
Go away
@@eddiecalderone Why don't you go away, Eddie?
@@orraman5427
The breakfast show has nothing to do with sangyta
So much for free speech, bring back sangita myska, shame on lbc
Andrew Neil the GB news Daily Mail failure. He’s not a voice for Scotland, or anyone. Digging up him and Douglas Ross in these times.
Whilst we're on the subject of the SNP, bring back Sangita
Ex GB News Andrew Neill,yeah won't be taking any political decisions from him or Ferrari
Go in a dark room then ms far left 😂
I detest Sassenach Nick Ferrari and his Conservative friends for their never-ending Scotland-bashing.
Of the 12 UK regions/nations. Scotland has the most devolved power. Northern Ireland & East England have lower rates of child poverty than Scotland. Why?
@@AB-zl4nh no true. child poverty is lower and all kids get extra uplift payments and other benefits not available in other nations/regions.
@@AB-zl4nh And the other regions? What is the ranking about? Is Scotland in the top 3? Where did you get your information from?
@@AB-zl4nhwhere's the proof ?all I see is words!
It really was two old bald men fighting over a comb
LBC, you must bring back Sangita or you lose any right to tell us about right and wrong.
What happened to Sangita Myska? And why?
Ferarri and Neil - what a pair of w4nkers. Neil seems to be holding up the tories as being the standard !!!!
I think you mean W⚓⚓⚓⚓⚓s
Free free Scotland 🏴
Free Sangita also
Scotland has already be freed, from the European Union´s fundamentalists, e. g. Mister Michel Barnier!
Poland and Hungary are using their respective veto powers, "endlessly"!
The Pope rules the Catholics!
Sangita Myska ❤ Bring her back !
Where is SANGITA?
On Checkout 5 at your local Morrisons
Not owned by khazars I take it
@@jeffsimon9594 not owned by khazars I take it
The person whose arris you're borned from take up up the kyber pass
Peace
Andrew Neil the Paisley skip howker who loves the UK so much that he stays in France.
And Lesley Riddoch was born in Wolverhampton.
@@TroyaE117and?
SHE lives here by choice.
He loves the UK so much he helped Rupert Murdoch wreck it.
What happened to Sangita?
Will she be joining Majid ?
Indeed, where is Sangita?
Loved hearing Andrew saying “us”. Andrew doesn’t live in Scotland.
Lesley isn't Scottish. Lesley doesn't live in London but she's ringing up a London radio show. What's your point? I live in the Shetlands. Are you saying noone from Britain can ring up to talk about the Shetlands? Silly comment.
I wouldn't ask Andrew Neil where the nearest Post Office was, much less how Scotland ought to be governed.
I am in my late fifties, formerly a solid Labour voter until the last General Election. I switched to the SNP not because of independence, on which I remain undecided, but because I no longer know what Labour stand for. The 2003 Gulf War was the start of my concern in that regard, and their abject failure to stand firmly against the debacle that is Brexit cemented that view.
I would rather blind myself with a hot poker than vote Tory. So, despite their obvious weaknesses, I will continue to vote SNP, in the knowledge that our voting system allows for a far broader view to prevail in Holyrood than Westminster, whilst they have a period of internal reflection..
When I heard Andrew Neil spouting his outrages lies my first thought was that this should be broadcast to the entire Scottish nation, support for independence would rise considerably, and I am pleased that Lesley shared the same reaction. Neil is the best recruiting agent the independence movement could wish for.
Utter nonsense. We are tired of the SNP.
Lesley isn't Scottish...
STOP ENGAGING WITH THESE COWARDS. STICK TO THE SUBJECT OF SANGITA
Rishi Sunak giving advice to other parties on what they should focus on is astonishing to me.
Andrew Neil is completely wrong in what he says.
I’m ashamed that he’s a Scot as he’s constantly brow beating his own nation (my nation too) rather than look at us with honesty and fairness.
We most certainly do NOT hate the English people in any way, all we want is to be able to make our own choices through our own parliament and not have Westminster ride rough-shot over the policies our parliament chose.
Many of my relatives are English and many of my friends are too: that’s hardly a sign we hate English people, is it! 🏴
Well said Lesley Riddoch!
Failed GB News architect Andrew Neil's accuses others of failures. Ferrari was a toadie, petulent school boy when talking to Lesley Riddich. Revolting.
Also that quote about "Westminster" being a euphemism for the english is untrue.
Im english and lived in scotland for 20 years.
Im 27. In all that time ive never been made to feel more welcome and at home than here.
Soar alba
Will somebody think of the colonisers!
Bring Sangita back. Let her speak. She says what many of us think.
Compared to the Tory fiasco at Westminster? Pretty rich from Tory Boy Andrew Neill.
Of the 12 UK regions/nations. Scotland has the most devolved power. Northern Ireland & East England have lower rates of child poverty than Scotland. Why?
@@AB-zl4nh No. Child poverty is 8 percent lower in Scotland because it's been specifically tackled by the Scottish parliament.... Child poverty in England has rocketed under the Tories. Why?
@@AB-zl4nh pish
@@AB-zl4nh yeah, that's completely incorrect....you're working with outdated info there
LBC staying silence on why SANGHITA hasn't been presenting her regular radio show is absolute dispicable.
If nick thinks he's fair and unbiased then Let's hear YOU talk about why is sanghita missing from her job.
Where is Sangita
Brillo Pad used to work for GB news which was an utter disaster.
If Scotland is so subsidised by the english, why does england hold onto Scotland, wouldnt england be better of going for independence or do they need a section 30 from scotland to leave?,?
Politically subdividing/balkanising the island of great britain, where our people have mixed a lot for hundreds if not thousands of years makes no sense and will just divide communities. It's like the idiotic brexit arguments all over again. People never learn that sorting out the things that are wrong require hard work with tools already at our disposal, not a one day vote to shoot ourselves in the foot and return square one. 🤦🏼♂️
Exactly, just some verbal diarrhea as usual.
Hey Lbc, where is Sangita Myska?
LBC - Limiting Britain's Conversation - bring back Sangita Myska
So much gammon I thought it was a cattle market.
Well done Lesley Riddoch. The failure of GB News and the dodgy looking machinations around the sale of the Spectator Neil has got brass neck criticizing anyone.
Why wouldn't we point to Westminster? That's the system we are continually told we are better off with so it makes perfect sense to refer to Westminster as a comparison. Nick really should know this so he's either thick or pretending to be.
Sangita ???
Nick Farage looked like he would have loved to take five minutes to himself to have a ham shank (if he could find it, he won’t have seen it in a while) by the time Andrew Brillo pad had finished talking utter pish.
Why are we listening to Andrew Neil, discussing Scottish politics. The last I heard, he either lives in France, London or New York. If discussing Scottish politics at least at someone who residues in country.
Not allowed according to who comrade ? He has an opinion , Scotland is in the toilet because of snp
@@user-dt3iv5oc6f nope its because we are still chained to the sinking ship that is westminster
No backbone , no shame
Free Sangita the LBC mascot
So everyone is just going to pretend like Sangita being taken off air is just normal and not coercion by a foreign state?
Free Sangita!!!!!
Yep. Bring Sangita back. It looks like Apartheid Israel pulls the strings at LBC.
While there is no doubt that the SNP have some major problems to overcome, the conflation of independence support with SNP support is clear listening to Andrew Neil here. Plus, the anti English sentiment thing he talks about here is blown way, way out of proportion. Indeed, the number of anti Scottish comments written openly by people on various news sites is breathtaking and never mentioned by the likes of Neil whose colours are fully nailed to the mast. Plus, the usual biased, uninformed drivel from Ferrari. Sorry i watched this now. And ps, bring back Sangita Myska guys!
Bring back sangita
Your banner is still incorrect - He has NOT QUIT AS FIRST MINISTER only as Leader of the SNP - 'cmon I know you don't think about Scotland too often, but you could at least try to get your facts right - as bad as the BBC.
If Nick was a real journalist he would put his money where his mouth has often been. Stand against "cancel culture", and fight to bring Sangita back. Anything less makes him morally corrupt. Oh wait. He is! ❤
Where is Sangita Myska
We want Sangita back NOW!
That smirking can't Ferrari is an absolute can't here,, unbelievable. 🏴 🏴 🏴.
Total Charlie Uniform November Tango
Triggered much are we 😂
Where is Sangita? Your CENSORSHIP is utterly DISGUSTING
LBC - Limiting Britain's Conversation - bring back Sangita Myska
Bring back Sangita Myska.
Boycott LBC until Sangita back on air.
Where is sangita. Just vanished after the isreali encounter
Bring back SANGITA
Has Nick eaten Sangita
With a side of skin on fries
Andrew Neil is just raging because some people have a different mindset to himself. Not all of us want unionism forced upon us.
What does it take for an SNP doughball to face the glaring reality of their ineptitude. You couldn’t have done any more damage to Scotland if you tried.
@emscott2705 Like the unionists have done, so much poverty in an oil rich country.
Mr Neil certainly doesn't speak for me. I'm no SNP fan, but the way Neil talks makes me cringe. He talks about the Clydeside shipyards, remind us all who shut them down.
I'm a Scot, the only thing keeping the shipyards open is the Royal Navy. Without them we would have absolutely no shipping industry. That is an undeniable fact. The SNP have been in power for 17 years, they've done nothing to reverse or attract new investment. Infact the SNP are totally against heavy industries including oil extraction.
Wheres Sangita Myska?
Bring back SANGITA!
and people wonder why scottish people want independence. nick or andrew would never have the cheek to put down england they way they did scotland.
Andrew Neil who doesn’t live in Scotland . . .why is he on here?
Because it's a London News channel and Andrew Neil lives in London. Why are you on here?
Im sick of English Mps telling Scots what to do. Get your own house in order. The cost of living crisis is a UK one, Scotland has no control over energy policy and most tax levets. This is all totally disingenuous. Stamer blames Scots for not managing what is UK reserved matters, hypocrite.
Basket case scotland? Just carry on with that line. Just strengthens the independence vote. You disgust me ferrari.
The polls suggest otherwise.... Remind me when you are getting those ferries?
@@vvwalker7261 You've not been keeping an eye on much down south, have you? Perspective is a useful thing.
Who cares? You're not going to get one, why not try living in reality
@@nomoreheroes93imagine celebrating Westminster's opposition to democracy
Of the 12 UK regions/nations. Scotland has the most devolved power. Northern Ireland & East England have lower rates of child poverty than Scotland. Why?
scotland was independent for thousands of years,,,,english colonies are few and on the way to independence
I don't think "independent" is the right term here. The people of the Kingdom of Scotland were sovereign, unlike their English neighbours, and then, because of the betrayal of 1707, they suddenly became the property of the English state.
Significant Irish and norse control
@@dna9838 and not a little scotch
SHAME ON LBC
A guy goes down our chip shop, swears he's Robert Bruce, and wants to stand as SNP leader.
I looked at the screen and thought that the gap between these two old men must be the perineum.
This pair r completely unqualified to comment on Scotland. Best performing NHS, highest paid nurses,no doctors strikes. Child poverty payment. The baby box.
Scotland gives all it's money to England and gets pocket money back. Best university's in the world . Lowest council tax. Rail back in public. ownership
Let's look at the massive deficit that has ballooned under the SNP.....and they want to borrow MORE!!
Any news on Sangita?
Continuing to stick your heads in sand is the reason why you’re in this mess
Where is Sangita..🍉😤
Of the 12 UK regions/nations. Scotland has the most devolved power. Northern Ireland & East England have lower rates of child poverty than Scotland. Why?
Absolutely, where is Sangita?
❤️ 🇵🇸 🍉 🇵🇸 ⚖️ 🇵🇸 🕊️ 🇵🇸 💚
@@AB-zl4nh not true
@@Glasgow_kissthink that’s a bot mate, he’s infiltrated loads of posts
Go Lesley....!!
the snp are utter failures
Normal Unionist dripping Scotland has the best run NHS in the UK the best Universities for last two years in the UK Urostat has Scottish Children the best Educated in Europe you want to see what they say about children in England
This is categorically untrue. 1 in 7 Scots are on an NHS waiting list. Your broken grammar highlights the falling standards in Scotland. Education levels are the lowest in Europe. You need a reality check, and we in Scotland need another election to remove the SNP. Scotland is in dire straits with the SNP, causing the decline in our energy. As a Shetlander, we are close to leaving Scotland and joining the UK as an overseas island. Shocking government from the SNP.
What nonsense
@@margaretknox2301Truth hurts the Lackey Unionists
All my kids went through university for free. They all graduated with an Honours degree with no debt.
"i NEVER REALISED THAT KICKING SOMEONE IN THE GOOLIES WOULD CAUSE SO MUCH HURT"
Ferrari The Hutt.
What a reptile 🐍🦎🐍🐊
We know now why Sangita has gone. LBC is NOT LONGER IMPARTIAL. Mark this day as the end of LBC.
She's gone? Oh no. When & why? Jumped or pushed?
Lesley Riddochulous 😂
Just Google who LBC belongs to, you won't be surprised why Sangita is fired...
Fired? Jesus, she was 1st class.
I have no clue who LBC belongs to but will be googling. Thanks.
Tears of an authoritarian bully!
I lived and worked in 5 Arab countries and through work I’ve been to every Arab country.
I’ve worked in Iran and Pakistan and through work and travel I’ve been to 100 countries.
The only people that I ever hear knocking Scotland are Unionists.
In almost every country that I’ve been to I’ve met Scots in top jobs and when I say I’m from Scotland I always got a warm welcome.
Believe me Scotland is so rich in natural resources and in its people that it could easily be a successful independent country.
PS: every country that left Britain to become independent were mocked yet not one has asked to come back.
With all the talk from Nick Ferrari and Andrew Neil about the United Kingdom they hate it when people bring up the English.
The English, through its built in majority in Westminster, controls Scotland financially and politically, even to the extent that the Scottish people do not have the right to decide for themselves if and when to hold an independence referendum.
English politicians see to it that as soon as the independence issue comes to the fore the financial squeeze is put on the Scots so that they can blame Scotland for the condition it is kept in.
There are times when commentators, such as Ferrari and Neil, and Tory and Labour politicians, want to speak in favour of the UK but don't want to acknowledge the power of the English in how the UK, and especially Scotland, is run.
The problem is that there is TWO GOVERNMENTS.
NO!
Of course 'things aren't going 'beautifully'! LOL. What planet is this Lesley woman on?
Sangita fans - Global Media and Entertainment Group is LBC's parent company.
Wiki: Global is owned by Ashley Daniel Tabor-King, born to a Jewish family in May 1977. Given the current climate, it might be especially wise for Global to diffuse speculation with a statement explaining, say, a reasonable in-house programming decision by LBC.
What are you on about how is this at all relevant.
@@TheWatchman1893Zio criminals sticking together?
Where is the connection. Of getting rid of Majid Nawaaz
Why should the SNP still pursue independence when their is public money still missing, they should have proved fiscal discipline before promotion of fiscal independence independence.
Even Dumza’s voice makes me cringe
Comments section filled with the crying Scottish Nationalists 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
BringBackSangita#
The A & E might best in the UK, but that is setting a pretty low bar to get to. I notice you don't say anything else about the NHS.
What about the Buckets oil we give England
Lesley is spot on. Andrew Neil's contribution is unadulterated prejudice dressed up as objective observation. He was not asked to,provide any evidence for his string of denigrating statements about Scotland or the Scottish Government. I don't know where to start with what Nick Ferrari is saying. His criticism of Education is based on PISA! PISA is not a reliable way of comparing education systems. It focuses on a very narrow part of the Curriculum, it is a sampling system with all the built in uncertainties of such a system. It is voluntary, with plenty of opportunities to "game" the system. He should have a look at the results of Michael Gove's reforms in Education in England. He attributes lower life expectancy to the SNP! Nothing to do with 300 years of being a junior partner in the U.K., by any chance? Poverty, substance abuse, mental ill-health, physical ill-health and other poor outcomes are well-documented results of colonisation, which is where Scotland finds itself today. Andrew Neil babbles on about Scottish Independence being to do with dislike of the "English". That is simply not the case. If anything, the dislike is of snobbery and exceptionalism, regardless of nationality. Andrew Neil epitomises that kind of individual. I look forward to the day when the people of Scotland will be treated with equal respect to people of any other nationality. I don't see that happening as long as people like Andrew Neil remain in positions of influence.
Well done Lesley Riddoch
Some parts of Scotland have male life expectancy than parts of Africa, yes, yes, but!!!!!
Why tf would you think that pushing potato Ferrari would get more traction than Sangita?
Don’t worry dzaddy’s finances will cover it
Which part of Africa Nick? 54 countries.
Came to the comments looking for this.
Idk what he meant by that but it's disgusting to use an entire continent as an example of low life expectancy.
@@dodonnell-ze9ycmost of it is for gods sake , you ever been ?
@@dodonnell-ze9yc disgusting, lazy and low grade journalism.
@@user-dt3iv5oc6f have you been to every part of Africa?
Funny how if you travel outside of the uk, you rarely ever hear anything negative about Scot’s or Scotland in general, as soon as you hit uk shores, we’re all jobless junkies.
Sooner Scotland starts building our own country the better.
I lived and worked in 5 Arab countries and through work I’ve been to every Arab country.
I’ve worked in Iran and Pakistan and through work and travel I’ve been to 100 countries.
The only people that I ever hear knocking Scotland are Unionists.
In almost every country I’ve been to I’ve met Scots in top jobs and when I say I’m from Scotland I always get a warm welcome 🏴.
To have strikes, you need to actually be doing something…