Hi Aaryn, I just finished watching and I love the embroidery on the Coach tote!!! I like the color and handles and zipper on the Marc Jacobs tote, especially with YOUR coloring and hair! Bith nice totes, for sure. My heart is going pitter-pattering on both bags!😊
I like the color of the Coach best but I think it would show dirt easier and I had thought that the outside pockets would suit me better but for traveling I think you are right and the inside ones would be best-so yes MJ it is 😊
Wouldn’t buy a ‘raw’ canvas tote for travel because thinking it would easily get dirty and if it gets scuffed could be all over. Commented before that am going with Tumi Just In Case Tote. It’s large, weighs 0.7 lbs, made of nylon, has luggage sleeve, folds up into its own pouch and recommended by Hello Catwalk City.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts on both of these bags. I know the Coach cargo tote 42 well. I have seen it in person. I am not familiar with the marc Jacob tote enough to give an opinion. Either way, you have a tough decision to make. Do a pro and con list on both. I know you discussed this in your video, but write it down. It helps to narrow down your thoughts. You have both bags in your possession so only you can choose which one works for you.
I think the Marc Jacobs is more durable. I sprayed my jacquard with a stain proof sealant, it hasn’t got any stains, snags, or frays and I’ve been shocked because I’m rough on that bag. The Coach material I find to be more delicate and prone to peeling and stains easier.
I would return both of them just because of the colors. The lettering on the MJ tote is so light I’d be afraid that’s where dirt would show up first. Good luck to you!
Ty so much:). I ended up sending both bags back because of the new code that I linked… I'm sure I will have plenty to choose from when I get my gift card back and maybe I'll go a darker color route then...:)
I wonder if you have looked at the Mont collection from Songmont? I ordered one, should be here tomorrow, and they actually look like a great alternative to the LV Neverfull for a fraction of the price. I like you do not have to worry about the weather either just like the LV bag and it has a zipper and feet. Just a thought:)
@@myluxurycloset529 Well rec’d the bag and it’s nice, canvas, zipper’s smooth etc…only con for me is the handles. To make them even for shoulder carry one side is going to hang long. I am going to keep because that really is the only downside. It does fold flat for storage or suitcases and I personally like with the cream insert I purchased. Anyway hope this helps.
I really wanted that color for the Coach! I have the smaller blue version of the Coach bag. It was perfect for a day in Lawrence. I’ve only had it for three months ish. But no issues with popped logo. I love it. I kind of want to get another in the middle size. But might just wait to find the denim LV onthego instead.
Ooh good to know about the logo! I linked 24s above - they have a lot of cargo options and I included a 15% off code that works on orders over $200 this time;). Boy we are close - let's do a meetup!
I have the MJTTB in large cherry red leather ❤adore her for work travel. I prefer the handles on the MJTTB. The Coach is cute but I don’t like the handles on it. Also the MJTTB has the magnetic bit on the side to neatly tuck in the strap on the leather version FYI ❤
Thanks for sharing!! I ended up sending both bags back because of the new code that I linked… I'm sure I will have plenty to choose from when I get my gift card back and maybe I'll go the leather route - u never know! Does it fit under the seat in front of you?
It usually does unless I’m on a really small plane (intercontinental Europe or east coast Canada) but it will easily fit overhead. I highly recommend it. Even when it’s stuffed it’s still comfortable to carry as you can put the weight on your back iykwim. I use mine a lot ❤ the leather just gets better ❤
I like the Coach bag best only because I don’t like the writing on the MJ bag. I wish ‘Coach’ wasn’t written on this one but it’s better than the other. I may look into the smaller option- if available 🎉 Thanks for sharing! I wish we had more options in this style because it is so useful, even in smaller sizes.
Love the MJ color for traveling but the Coach seems more practical for use while traveling, maybe in a darker color like the MJ tone 🤷🏻♀️ Your comparisons are the best. TFS
what is it that makes the coach seem more practical to you? what is it that makes the coach seem more practical to you? To me the pockets on the inside of the Mark Jacobs make it more practical for me. what is it that makes the coach seem more practical to you? To me the pockets on the inside of the Marc Jacobs make it more practical for me…
I think I'm going to try to use my gift voucher on the marc jacobs if the FIRST30 code still works when I get my credit - it will bring my total from $221 to $96 which would be great for a $385 bag💚💚💚
Just to say that if you return one item you won’t be able to use the loyalty money on the one you keep. They will refund that again to your account . That’s what happened with me when I bought two items and returned one having used some loyalty credit . I did contact them and they advised this was their policy.
I wish they would have told me when I called - I explained that I had the gift voucher to use and wanted to use the take200 code. I told them I would be choosing between the two items and returning one. They told me I would keep the take200 discount but didn't say anything about the voucher:(...ty for sharing 🩷
I did exactly the same as you and didn’t for one minute assume I couldn’t use the loyalty money towards the item I was keeping ! The only reason I was buying something my was to use the rewards money !! I did keep the promo code discount on the item I kept as you stated xx
Yes, I'd return it. There is always a catch, which is a shame. I do like the bag though. Ugh... It is a hard decision. I love the color on the MJ bag, but I like the Coach bag overall.
I think you should just keep them both so you get the good price and just sell the coach bag at the discounted price to one of your subbies so you are square and someone gets a great deal
Great idea!! what's crazy is, they just started a new 30% off code (I have it in my description box) so I would have to sell the cargo for more than a subbie could buy it for in order to get my money back… If 24s gets my return in time, I should be able to use that 30% off code with my gift card and get the bag for $95!
For placing under an airplane seat, due to color and fabrication, these bags might not hold up to the dirt, dust and other things. I'd keep the one that can be easily cleaned. Your collection is beautiful and inspiring!
@@myluxurycloset529I can’t for the life of me find the initial email where I found that code so I don’t know when that expires. There is another APP15 code for 15% off that I got recently. I hope either of them work for you.
I think you should just keep them both so you get the good price and just sell the coach bag at the discounted price to one of your subbies so you are square and someone gets a great deal
Great idea!! what's crazy is, they just started a new 30% off code (I have it in my description box) so I would have to sell the cargo for more than a subbie could buy it for in order to get my money back… If 24s gets my return in time, I should be able to use that 30% off code with my gift card and get the bag for $95!
@@myluxurycloset529 you would think that they would honor a sale within a week or two to prevent people from returning and rebuying. So I think a good video would be showing the difference In What you pack in the long champ vs the Marc Jacob’s bag or just how you pack the MJ bag with all your inflight essentials and 3 bags. I struggle with that. We travel quite a bit and I always put way too much stuff in my personal item. I just love packing videos of all kinds!
@pappyone6062 I know! They were not willing to work with me AT ALL. I was surprised actually - usually they are great! That's a great video idea - I just sold my taupe longchamp but still have my black that's the same style🥰
What would you do??? Which do you prefer???
I’d keep MJ and actually sell the Longchamp tote, I agree that MJ tote looks better and more functional. I like the colour better too.
that's actually great advice! Thank you so much :-).
I love the Coach!!!’ The extra outside pockets would be so handy for travel!!! I also like the whole general look of the Coach 😊
Thanks for sharing!! ♥️♥️♥️
I like the coach bag best... outside pockets is a good thing.
it certainly reinforces the bag!
Hi Aaryn, I just finished watching and I love the embroidery on the Coach tote!!! I like the color and handles and zipper on the Marc Jacobs tote, especially with YOUR coloring and hair!
Bith nice totes, for sure. My heart is going pitter-pattering on both bags!😊
Thank you so much!
I like the color of the Coach best but I think it would show dirt easier and I had thought that the outside pockets would suit me better but for traveling I think you are right and the inside ones would be best-so yes MJ it is 😊
Good call! Thanks for sharing your thoughts ♥️♥️♥️:)
Great comparison! So thorough thank you! I like the Coach.
Glad it was helpful! ♥️
I really enjoyed this video! TFS. The Marc Jacobs for me. I also love Longchamp. Great video.
ty so much!!!
Marc J all the way!! We have the same thoughts. Don’t love the Coach writing and I’m a MJ tote girlie. I want the one you have but in black
It's so good!!! ♥️♥️♥️
Yes, the writing on the Coach bag turned me off and the color it too light, you could see dirty spots more than we n on the other one.
I agree ♥️
Hi, have you thought about selling the coach bag and that way you could keep your discount.
I've considered it but would need to get $225 to cover taxes and shipping ♥️
I think the MJ would be better for travel but I would like to get the small size of the Coach for myself so thanks for sharing.
I totally agree! They are both made very well♥️
I like the Coach more, and in my opinion the colour suits you much better than the caramel colour of the MJ. 24s is soooo tempting 😅
ty and it really is!!!
Wouldn’t buy a ‘raw’ canvas tote for travel because thinking it would easily get dirty and if it gets scuffed could be all over. Commented before that am going with Tumi Just In Case Tote. It’s large, weighs 0.7 lbs, made of nylon, has luggage sleeve, folds up into its own pouch and recommended by Hello Catwalk City.
Good point! I ordered a longchamp city bag today in coated canvas so we will see how I like it ♥️♥️♥️
Thank you for sharing your thoughts on both of these bags. I know the Coach cargo tote 42 well. I have seen it in person. I am not familiar with the marc Jacob tote enough to give an opinion. Either way, you have a tough decision to make. Do a pro and con list on both. I know you discussed this in your video, but write it down. It helps to narrow down your thoughts. You have both bags in your possession so only you can choose which one works for you.
You are so welcome! That's a great idea - ty so much♥️♥️♥️
I think the Marc Jacobs is more durable. I sprayed my jacquard with a stain proof sealant, it hasn’t got any stains, snags, or frays and I’ve been shocked because I’m rough on that bag. The Coach material I find to be more delicate and prone to peeling and stains easier.
Awesome feedback - ty so much!!! ♥️♥️♥️
Very pretty bag and color. I like the MJ Color More vs the Coach. Enjoy 🤎
Thank you! 🤗
I would return both of them just because of the colors. The lettering on the MJ tote is so light I’d be afraid that’s where dirt would show up first. Good luck to you!
Ty so much:). I ended up sending both bags back because of the new code that I linked… I'm sure I will have plenty to choose from when I get my gift card back and maybe I'll go a darker color route then...:)
I love the coach one
It's very nice ♥️
Love the Coach! ❤
It's very nice🥰🥰🥰
I wonder if you have looked at the Mont collection from Songmont? I ordered one, should be here tomorrow, and they actually look like a great alternative to the LV Neverfull for a fraction of the price. I like you do not have to worry about the weather either just like the LV bag and it has a zipper and feet. Just a thought:)
oh wow! great tip ty so much - pls lmk what u think!!!
@@myluxurycloset529 Well rec’d the bag and it’s nice, canvas, zipper’s smooth etc…only con for me is the handles. To make them even for shoulder carry one side is going to hang long. I am going to keep because that really is the only downside. It does fold flat for storage or suitcases and I personally like with the cream insert I purchased. Anyway hope this helps.
@@maggimae45-7ty for the feedback!!!
I really wanted that color for the Coach! I have the smaller blue version of the Coach bag. It was perfect for a day in Lawrence. I’ve only had it for three months ish. But no issues with popped logo. I love it. I kind of want to get another in the middle size. But might just wait to find the denim LV onthego instead.
Ooh good to know about the logo! I linked 24s above - they have a lot of cargo options and I included a 15% off code that works on orders over $200 this time;). Boy we are close - let's do a meetup!
I’d love that!!! ❤❤❤❤
My daughter starts KU next August! She’s my youngest, So excited for her!
I like the color of the MJ bag the best. Plus, as others have mentioned, I would be more concerned about dirt with the Coach bag.
ty so much Dawn:)
I have the MJTTB in large cherry red leather ❤adore her for work travel. I prefer the handles on the MJTTB. The Coach is cute but I don’t like the handles on it. Also the MJTTB has the magnetic bit on the side to neatly tuck in the strap on the leather version FYI ❤
Thanks for sharing!! I ended up sending both bags back because of the new code that I linked… I'm sure I will have plenty to choose from when I get my gift card back and maybe I'll go the leather route - u never know! Does it fit under the seat in front of you?
It usually does unless I’m on a really small plane (intercontinental Europe or east coast Canada) but it will easily fit overhead. I highly recommend it. Even when it’s stuffed it’s still comfortable to carry as you can put the weight on your back iykwim. I use mine a lot ❤ the leather just gets better ❤
@sarahboulter9937 that's awesome ty♥️
I like the Coach bag best only because I don’t like the writing on the MJ bag. I wish ‘Coach’ wasn’t written on this one but it’s better than the other. I may look into the smaller option- if available 🎉 Thanks for sharing!
I wish we had more options in this style because it is so useful, even in smaller sizes.
I am the opposite:). I totally agree, these bags are great! Ty so much for watching and commenting♥️
RPBSpeaks: I have the cargo 26 in black. It works for me as an everyday bag! Perfect size!
@@idaranwa4370That's Awesome!!!❤
I like the Coach bag.
♥️♥️♥️
That Coach bag is cute
ty:)
What color and size was the Longchamp you showed? I have been looking for a Longchamp and I really like it.
It's for sale - a large le pliage shoulder tote
@@myluxurycloset529 I sent you an email
Love the MJ color for traveling but the Coach seems more practical for use while traveling, maybe in a darker color like the MJ tone 🤷🏻♀️ Your comparisons are the best. TFS
what is it that makes the coach seem more practical to you? what is it that makes the coach seem more practical to you? To me the pockets on the inside of the Mark Jacobs make it more practical for me. what is it that makes the coach seem more practical to you? To me the pockets on the inside of the Marc Jacobs make it more practical for me…
I think it was the outside pocket but I see your point on the MJ, you’re right!
@@Karla-fl4mg❤❤❤
I like the marc jacobs one better but return both and pick a item you really love
I think I'm going to try to use my gift voucher on the marc jacobs if the FIRST30 code still works when I get my credit - it will bring my total from $221 to $96 which would be great for a $385 bag💚💚💚
Just to say that if you return one item you won’t be able to use the loyalty money on the one you keep. They will refund that again to your account . That’s what happened with me when I bought two items and returned one having used some loyalty credit . I did contact them and they advised this was their policy.
I wish they would have told me when I called - I explained that I had the gift voucher to use and wanted to use the take200 code. I told them I would be choosing between the two items and returning one. They told me I would keep the take200 discount but didn't say anything about the voucher:(...ty for sharing 🩷
I did exactly the same as you and didn’t for one minute assume I couldn’t use the loyalty money towards the item I was keeping ! The only reason I was buying something my was to use the rewards money !! I did keep the promo code discount on the item I kept as you stated xx
@clairesutherland2591 It is maddening - hopefully it all works out in the end🙏🤔🥰
Gosh, I think I like the look of the Coach tote more, but I wouldn’t buy it because I know I would get it dirty. The first time I used it! 😅
It very cute!!! MJ is an acquired taste i think:)...
Yes, I'd return it. There is always a catch, which is a shame. I do like the bag though. Ugh... It is a hard decision. I love the color on the MJ bag, but I like the Coach bag overall.
I am leaning towards keeping it - another suggested I sell the taupe Longchamp so I'm giving that a try🥰
I think you should just keep them both so you get the good price and just sell the coach bag at the discounted price to one of your subbies so you are square and someone gets a great deal
Great idea!! what's crazy is, they just started a new 30% off code (I have it in my description box) so I would have to sell the cargo for more than a subbie could buy it for in order to get my money back… If 24s gets my return in time, I should be able to use that 30% off code with my gift card and get the bag for $95!
Love the Coach Bag Better
♥️♥️♥️
Coach bag 👍
♥️♥️♥️
For placing under an airplane seat, due to color and fabrication, these bags might not hold up to the dirt, dust and other things. I'd keep the one that can be easily cleaned. Your collection is beautiful and inspiring!
Good point - I think I'm going to sell my taupe longchamp regardless - I do have a black one that's identical♥️. Ty so much!
@@myluxurycloset529 😃
I like the Coach better :)
ty!!!♥️♥️♥️
I would keep the Coach bag and just scotch guard it before using. I'm not a fan of "The Tote Bag Marc Jacobs" on the bag.
good thought - I collonil carbon pro everything!!!
I have 3 of them
of what?
@@myluxurycloset529 the Marc Jacob’s the Tote Bag
There is a new 30% off coupon - would that be helpful for you to buy it again?
maybe what is it?
@@myluxurycloset529FIRST30
i'm going to return it and hope that still works when I get my gift card back… Do you know when that expires? Ty so much!
@@myluxurycloset529I can’t for the life of me find the initial email where I found that code so I don’t know when that expires. There is another APP15 code for 15% off that I got recently. I hope either of them work for you.
Prefer the color of the MJ tote especially for travel. I think I want the Coach one in a smaller size. Thanks for sharing
The Coach is cuter.
It's all personal style - I feel the reverse 🙃
MJ looks much more comfortable
It is!!!
MJ❤
🌸💙🌸
dont like either send both back , colors are ugly.
thanks
I like the coach better!
what do you like about it better?♥️
I think you should just keep them both so you get the good price and just sell the coach bag at the discounted price to one of your subbies so you are square and someone gets a great deal
Great idea!! what's crazy is, they just started a new 30% off code (I have it in my description box) so I would have to sell the cargo for more than a subbie could buy it for in order to get my money back… If 24s gets my return in time, I should be able to use that 30% off code with my gift card and get the bag for $95!
@@myluxurycloset529 you would think that they would honor a sale within a week or two to prevent people from returning and rebuying. So I think a good video would be showing the difference In What you pack in the long champ vs the Marc Jacob’s bag or just how you pack the MJ bag with all your inflight essentials and 3 bags. I struggle with that. We travel quite a bit and I always put way too much stuff in my personal item. I just love packing videos of all kinds!
@pappyone6062 I know! They were not willing to work with me AT ALL. I was surprised actually - usually they are great! That's a great video idea - I just sold my taupe longchamp but still have my black that's the same style🥰