Library Chats - Episode 8: On Inquisitions and Refutations In Our History | Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ต.ค. 2020
- Recorded: Oct 4th, 2020
Please LIKE, COMMENT, & SHARE!
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Credits:
Intro Soundtrack:
By Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi
Outro Soundtrack:
Link: tiny.cc/outro2
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official Social Media Pages
Facebook: yasirqadhi
Instagram: yasir.qadhi
Twitter: yasirQadhi
Snapchat: snapchat.com/add/yasir.qadhi
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official TH-cam Channel
135
Sheikh i have never commented on your libary chats, formally YQ gems. Today I've done this solely to request one thing: do not stop your presence on social media platforms (Facebook and TH-cam) as they are highly beneficial to students of knowledge like me. Literally you taught me so much and I thank you for it. Essentially your disapperance stops our random heartly prayers for you every time your articles and videos enlighten us( both for starters and advanced students of knowledge)
I concur! May Allah ta'Ala give you increase of success in your evdeavors of Dawah, and increase you in patience along the way. Aameen.
0:14 - Introduction
2:56 - Caveats on this lecture
3:51 - Clarifications on discussing advanced topics in these library chats
5:00 - Announcement by the Shaykh on leaving social media gradually
5:34 - About refutations (theory vs. reality)
10:16 - Refutations are, generally speaking, preaching to the choir
10:47 - 7 examples of refutations/inquistions in Islamic history
11:40 - Example-01: The mihna (inquisition) of Imam Ahmad Ibn Hanbal
14:54 - Example-02: The mihna of lbn Taymiyyah
18:24 - Example-03: The trial of Imam Bukhari
25:17 - Example-04: The trial of Ibn Furak
29:18 - Example-05: The mob attack on Imam An-Nasai
34:05 - Example-06: The trial of Ibn Miqsam and Ibn Shannabudh
40:24 - Example-07: The mihna of Ibn Aqil
46:18 - Lessons to be learned from all of these incidents
Please don't leave us! There many students of you who are from many places in the world. Your intellectual lectures in our language are very rare. Who will we listen to who is like you if you don't educate us in your amazing intellectual way!
May Allah preserve you and keep benefiting the Ummah!
As salamu alaikum sheikh, Iam from srilanka.i am 20 years old. I was not very much practicing Islam in past years until 16 years old. You are also a reason for coming back for my religion.we are so pleased with your contextual thoughts. Please sheikh, don't abandon us .
Dear Sheikh @yasir qadhi whatever the critics are saying you are immensely benefiting the ummah with your lectures so please stay online. There are many of us out there awaiting any video of yours and viewing everything without commenting but now I feel the need to comment.
Salaam from UK. My sincere request to you to continue this highly beneficial series. There are many like myself who look forward to and learn a great deal from these advanced lectures. Please ignore your detractors and carry on the great work for which Allah Subhaanahu Wa Ta'la will reward you Inshaa Allah.
😭 I'm sad to know you leaving all social media, but I wish you and your family the best, may Allah bless you in every single step you take.
Shiek YQ, please don't ever leave YT. This is my only platform, from Philippines. Besides, the negatives in YT will never disappear from your disappearance.
I am from Bangladesh but thanks to online social media platform, I have been following you from last 8 years. I am immensely benefitted from your knowledge and you have made a lasting impression on my religiosity and thought process. In your one of recent videos, you also mentioned that you are considering of quitting social media. Your decision have broken my heart and I have already started feeling empty. Please reconsider your decision.
Lots of love and dua for you and your family!!!
*"And whose words are better than someone who calls ˹others˺ to Allah, does good, and says, “I am truly one of those who submit.”*
Quran 41:33
Insha' Allah you will continue doing good stuff until you die, and when you die, may Allah surprise you with all these good deeds that you did, especially teaching people Islam. May Allah make you happy!
I felt very sad Sheikh Yasir. You are leaving. I have been watching you for months. I have lot of benefitted from you. Sheik Yasir I want to let you know that you are the best person. May Allah bless you ameen.
@Siraj Haq for months. Actually one of my sisters leaving in Yemen. She recommended to watch Yasir lectures online. She also told me he is the best one. The work he does is perfect and more detail.
@Siraj Haq That is excellent I will watch inshallaha. Please can you provide me Yasir masjid website. Thank you brother. I hope I am texting to good brother.
@Siraj Haq My dad passed away, on his behalf I want to do something until I am alive in this earth. Thank you so much for your quick information.
@Siraj Haq I really dont like to be in social media and I am not a fun of it. I am busy working five days. I always listen news aljazeera. Since my dad passed away I am not happy. Allah is great and we all go back to allah. May allah make us easy in this dunya. Everything is in allah hand. Thank you brother.
I completely understand your need to take a step back. Most seniors that have been in the public sphere for a long time do so. I think it is healthy and will benefit yourself and the ones closes to you. Hopefully your behind the scenes works trickles down to us. I thank you for your dedication and being a different and unique voice. You'll be missed!
May Allah preserve you.
As a christian I'm sad to hear you say you're going off of social media. You and Shabir Ally have an intelligence and integrity that your community needs. But I also understand wanting to get off of social media. It's getting ugly out there.
Shabir Ally is rejected by mainstream sunnis. Look into his views on hadith, hudood, and various issues such as hijab and sexuality/desires.
@@MrRebel247 true
shabir ally is not a good person to relay upon
McMullen Law where in the video he said that he was leaving social media?
@@AllPraisebetoAllah60 It's pretty near the beginning. He talks about how he hopes to be off in the next few years. 5:00
Im almost 20 minutes in and I'm feeling so so happy I stumbled on it! When he said "if you're an Ash3ari Sufi or you're a hanbali salafi" i said to myself that I'm in the right place. We've got both in my one house and ya Rabb! I can't wait to hear the rest!
jazakkallah sheikh yasir ,i have been watching you for years and you have benefitted me more than I can say in here, and I will always say stay with us, teach us and benefit us and if you do move from, the social media make sure the platform you move to that the one in a village from Africa and in all of the continents of the world can reach you and will have access to your knowledge that is our request.
My sheikh.... Do continue to talk on advanced topics. You're the reason I learn so much here in India where this type of knowledge is hidden... I love you for the sake of Allah. Your decision of quitting social media is yours but we still do benefit immensely from you... JazakAllah khair
That's so true there is a huge refutation culture in our Muslims. Sheikh Yasir gets a lot of refutation because once upon a time he was a Salafi and when he realised that the movement is to harsh and black and white he left. Furthermore it tends to be people like Abu Mussab Wajdi akkari, Sheikh Assem Al Hakeem etc etc. They live in Saudi yet dont critize unislamic acts of leaders people like Yasir Qadhi, Abdur Raheem Green and Zakir Naik speak their mind and tell the truth. Yasir Qadhi condemned khashogi killing and Zakir Naik war in Yemen. May Allah blessings these great men and guide Madhakalis.
Dear sheikh Dr Yasir Qadhi
This session of ur ‘s made me really sad and the background in which it’s given is heart breaking. I’m one of those silent beneficiaries since 5-6 years who learnt a lot from ur seera , lectures, khutbas etc. I may not be agreeing with everything whatever u say but I can say one thing that u never spread hatred or refutation for any one among ur listeners.
I have one thing to say , having 100 and 1000 of followers admirers and student on social media you shud not be deciding to quit this plate-form on ur own , leaving ur audience stranded in disappointment.
Often ly I go thru social media comments section n note that foul mouthed ppl are not sparing scholars, women , kids, ulema , sahaba, prophets and even criticizing on God As well . ( Ma’az Allah). Please ignore them as u said urself and continue to spread positivity and share knowledge with us. May Allah preserve u and keep u and ur family safe and healthy and bless us to be benefitted by ur extensive knowledge via social media. Please try to stay away from controversies as much as u can strategically. 😊
Hope u read this comment 🎱
Jazakallahu Khair Shaykh Yasir Qadhi..May Allah SWT preserve people of knowledge
😢Pls dont move from social media platform. People around the globe immensely benifiting from u shaikh..this is the only rope we have to connect you.. Dont cut it😢.. This is a request ❤️
Salam Sheikh Yasir Quadi,
Your videos have always been inspirational for me and for our Muslim community! Please consider not withdrawing from this and consider to continue in this wonderful gift you have given us! Thank you for educating us and inspiring us! Thank you for making a difference in our lives. Ameen!
Sheikh dont look what they say we are still see you as a good role model please continue with the fruit of knowledge
Sh Dr. Yasir my honest and humble opinion about you leaving the social platforms is and with all due respect no daa'ee of your caliber resigns from the work of Allah.
You are one of the few people online who is able to reach out to us Muslims living in the west...we need you. Please do not leave us. You are not only righteous but informed. The ability to cross between east and west is a gift very few have..and you have this gift. Please reconsider your exit from social media. We badly need you online with us.
Sheikh, may Allah reward you endlessly for spreading knowledge.
My most favorite to watch of all time is the Seerah you did.
And since then these library chats are my 2nd most favorite. Thank you so much for these fascinating discussions and information out there for anyone willing to learn. I look forward to a new one everyday.
Not everyone has the means or situation to go into academia and not everyone who didn't go into academia live life treading into shallow water. By making these available for those people, by not putting up a wall around knowledge, you can not fathom what amazing job you are doing.
I need these amazing discussions for the soul to sustain and be sane. Thank you so much and may Allah give you and your loved ones best of everything in this and next life.
Sheikh please do not withdraw yourself from social media for the sake of Allah. I do not have any other mean to gain knowledge from you as live in a far away country. Wallahi you are the only sheikh in the world who explains any matter so thoroughly in an organised way.
I met you in my dream today shaikh.
I sent u an email regarding a question .
May Allah preserve you and guide us all.
Really enjoying the library chats shayk, keep it up 👍
My brother, we want till your last day, you continue spread knowledge. Ignore those fools. We want advanced lectures. Studying our religion from academic perspective is great pleasure.
Very much needed talk.
We really need Yasir Qadhi and others to teach us our history. So many Imams talking about Islam basics, but no one is teaching us our history. If we do not do this, then we will be forced to learn from non-Muslims. Even though it can be controversial at times, there is so many lessons to be learned from Islamic history.
Never try to understand a Muslim's view from their opponent. An important lesson.
Sheikh preach what you think is the truth. Ignore the haters. Your listeners are way beyond in numbers than those who say thigs against you. Come on brother. Don't leave social media. Our Prophet SAW encouraged Hassan to write poetries, which is the social media at that time. Just continue on what you're doing. Assalamu Alaykum from Philippines!
i love these insightful talks that come with delicious islamic history and gems of our religion. i support YQ's decision to get away from social media but i hope he only means facebook and whatever. we still need these videos to keep coming. khutbas, Q&As, lectures, talks, all of it.
I thank Allah that He protects you in a peculiar way through a country which guarantees your freedom of speech, Shaykh.
Assalam alaikum Dr. Qadhi,
I was introduced to you last year by my colleague and since then the knowledge I got from your videos from the Seerah of our Prophet PBUH and Lives of Sahaba and Mothers of the believers.
The knowledge you are imparting academically is very inspiring.
I want to meet you in person and if Allah wills it will happen someday.
Please don't leave this platform it will be very difficult for ppl like me overseas to find someone like you.
Thank you for your contribution.
mee too
Jazak Allah Khairun so much for these lessons. The academic nature is great!
I swear it is true. I've been listening to this sheikh for almost a decade and after watching 100+ videos of people '' exposing '' the sheikh, none of them have had an effect. If anything, sheikh seems more reasonable. He holds himself to a high standards. Always seems dignified.
Sheikh, I'd rather hear these 'advanced' talks from you than from others who may not be as clear as you when relaying the message. I benefitted a lot from your Library Chats. If you were to shy away from lectures like this, so many people will lose out. Please keep your lectures coming. They are a great help, and I will testify on that on the Day of Judgment, in syaa Allah!
Brother, it takes a Yale to talk like this, only U Medina won't do. Ummah needs this dosage. Kudos.
Thank you very much for what you do for Islam and may Allah protect you and grant you high rank in Jannah. Please cheikh can you do some videos about sects that appeared in muslim Ummah (like muaatazila, ashaera,etc..) because some muslims follow sects that are conveying teaching in opposition with true Islam.
The tacit understanding in your knowledge on a myriad of topics is exactly what we need to galvanize others within the community to push us forward in our learning about the quran; the history of the peoples who practice/d it; and, how it shaped the paradigms of the people in their day-to-day. So, please don't go. But, if you must, always leave them wanting more.
I understand if you have to quit social media but please don't stop posting islamic seminary videos on TH-cam. Since i am not an arabic speaker, I benefits immensely from your lecturers since you speaking in english. ❤ from Malaysia
One of the best talks!
Jazakallah khair Dr Qadhi for this very eye opening video on history and its ups and downs with many genuine and humble scholars and the trials they had to go through in the name of politics, jealousy, and false accusations. Also, jazakallah khair for discussing how to behave when being falsely accused and attacked. Please don't leave the social media for some lunatics! Rabul Alameen knows your intention so please continue for the benefit of the ummah. You have increased our knowledge and we wait for your videos to be released. As you said in this lecture be silent and continue with your work. In shaa Allah your silence will be an answer to all their allegations, May Rabul Alameen guide them ( all your critics) and make them do some real good work for the ummah. May Rabul Alameen keep you in HIS protection and care!
The story of Imam Bukhari and Yahya Ath-Thuhli
In the early part of the 3rd century there were two Imams, both named Abu Abdullah Muhammad and equally they were scholars of Hadith. One is known as Imam Al-Bukhari and the other is Imam Ath-Thuhli. While both of these scholars are known for their virtue and service to the Sunnah, there were some differences between these two contemporary Imams that created some conflict and confusion in Naysabur.
As soon as Imam Al-Bukhari arrived in Naysabur Muhammad ibn Yahya Ath-Thuhli advised his students to sit and learn hadith from him. He said, “Go and learn from this pious man” . Consequently, his students took his advice and began to learn Hadith from Imam Bukhari. As a result of this Imam Ath-Thuhli’s Hadith study circles began to reduce in numbers, so, he became jealous and began to speak ill of Imam Al-Bukhari.
Due to the existing jealously of Imam Al-Bukhari there were some rumors flown around about his belief that the pronunciation of the Quran was created. Once this gossip spread Imam Al-Bukhari was tested about this belief in his sittings. Once a student came to Imam Al-Bukhari’s gathering stood up and said, “ Abu Abdullah, what is your stance about the pronunciation of the Quran? Is it created or not?” Imam Al-Bukhari simply ignored this man, but he repeated his question at least three times. After his third request for an answer Imam Al-Bukhari said, “ The Quran is the speech of Allah and it isn’t created, the actions of the slave are created and to test people with this issue is an innovation.”
The questioner dissatisfied with Imam Al-Bukhari’s answer provoked discord and controversy among the people and thus some people abandoned Imam Al-Bukhari. Imam Al-Bukhari was patient and he remained in his house worshipping Allah. That frustrated group of people insisted Imam Al-Bukhari wasn’t serious. Therefore, in another occasion Imam Al-Bukhari was asked, “ Is the pronunciation of the Quran created?” He replied, “ Each and every action of the slave is created.” After this response they took a decision and declared Imam Al-Bukhari as being misguided and some considered him an apostate. They ordered Imam Al-Bukhari to recant from his speech and position. They told Imam Al-Bukhari that if he recanted they would rejoin his classes again. Being firm in his belief and fearing none but Allah, Imam Al-Bukhari said, “ I will not withdraw from this view until you can produce proof stronger than the one I have.” Imam Yahya ibn Sa’eed Al-Qattan was present at this incident and said, “I was amazed at Imam Al-Bukhari’s unwavering belief under that pressure."
As the days passed there was a funeral prayer for Abu Uthman Sa’eed ibn Marwan. Imam Al-Bukhari and Imam Ath-Thuhli both attended. After the Janaza people began to ask Imam Ath-Thuli questions about the names and Kunyas of hadith narrators and even some asked him questions about Illal Hadith, this didn’t bother Imam Al-Bukhari one bit.Imam Al-Bukhari walked swiftly right pass Imam Ath-Thuhli not paying him any attention.
The campaigners of discord would go between these two Imams asking the same questions. During a class Imam Ath-Thuhli screamed,” whoever sits in Imam Al-Bukhari’s class isn’t welcome to sit in ours. Whoever says the pronunciation of the Quran is created must leave.” Following those words Imam Al-Bukhar’s student; Imam Muslim stood up and walked out of the class.
The turmoil for Imam Al-Bukhari and his students began to grow more intense. One day Muhammad ibn Shathil went to Imam Al-Bukhari complaining about the situation seeking a solution. He said, “ How can we fix this problem between you two? Everyone who sits and learns from you is driven away from his classes.” Imam Al-Bukhari said: “ Look at how Muhammad ibn Yahya has become afflicted with jealously over knowledge! Knowledge is a provision of Allah. He gives it to whoever He wills.” “This problem you’re busying yourself with is a contentious issue . I saw the way Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal dealt with it, so I’ve decided to not talk about it.”
The people’s desires were unfulfilled, so they headed to Imam Al-Bukhari’ house and assembled there outside waiting for him. Imam Ath-Thuhli joined the crowd at Imam Al-Bukhari’s house and said, “ Don’t ask him anything about the speech, because if he answers different than mine there will be some problems between us. For that reason, every Haruri, Rafidhi, Jahmi and Murji in Khurasan will take malicious pleasure in the mishap between us.”
After three days the massive crowd reached high numbers until some of them sat on the roof of his house. When Imam Bukhari came out they asked him about the pronunciation of the Quran, He replied:” Our actions are created and our speech is part of our actions.” Immediately after that response people said: “ He said the words of the Quran are created.” While some people said: “ He didn’t say that.” Eventually the crowd dispersed.
Shaikh yasir don't let hate preachers win and keep you quiet. Keep it up . The moment you go off social media they will have a party
One of the best talks ever
Please don’t leave social media , this is the only way some people can reach out , if you just want to make one platform like a website that is understandable but please don’t leave youtube
Very relevant and much needed talk!!
I don't usually comment on youtube videos and I saw it right now. I want you to know that you are one of my favorite shaykhs.
I know my words won't make a difference. But in a society where everyone is either completely liberal or strict to the extent that they go to the extremes that I even forgot what my Deen was and often felt repelled. But your lectures, your series of seerah, on the lives of the sahaba, your YQ Gems classes, al of these benefitted me daily. Maybe I am not the best, but at least I am firm and convinced that I will never leave Islam willingly In Sha Allah. I don't know if you will keep this channel because in that case it would've been better because I could've revised through and again viewed the previous lectures of yours that I missed.
Hearing that this very shaykh who brought me back to the right path is leaving from public media, who will I listen to? Whose lectures will give me that peace of mind again? If my words made any difference, I would have begged you to stay on public platforms. But I respect your decision and pray that Allah might bless you.
And I want you to know that I will In Sha Allah always be grateful for your lectures. You truly are a gem, shaykh, no doubt. Thank you for all those good memories and for convincing me about staying firm in Islam again.
Shaykh u can in case not being online on social media by urself but let ur team do it, let ur team record the video and publish it to all of us, we gonna ask our questions to them and then pass to u, seriously I learn a lot from u and this is the advantage (social media) to spread ur knowledge to Ummah worldwide
Keep up the great work sheikh, your lessons are full of insight and eye oppeners!
Mashallah i really enjoyed, very deep, each one of us wearing different lenses but we shouldn't judge to each other our way of retrieving things.
Please keep doing these library chats!
We love to hear these type of lectures. please continue . . .
Masha Allah excellent eye opening lecture.. Especially for scholers 💕
May Allah make it easy for you and your family... Allah will reward you abundantly for your work and sincerity...this is a test for you... Ive been following you frm Huda t.v...then I found your seerah lectures this year online....Alhamdulillah...its the best ever!...I can't thank you enough...ive benefitted the most frm your lectures...I feel sad tho... May Allah guide us all to the straight path always!
My dearest shaikh yq. My life without your lectures will be incomplete. I do wish that you can carry on benefiting the masses but I do know that this work must be affecting your family time. I hope the decision to go away from public eye is not because of the videos from non Muslims (And some Muslims) who love to twist things and blow things out of proportion. If that is the reason then I would humbly request that you reconsider. The immense good that people get from your talks should not be stopped due to such people.
Great discussion. Jazaaka Allahu khyar.
Don't leave sheikh. Unless your launching your own website, then completely understood.
Many have benefited from your lectures despite the fact that there are a few that disagree with your opinions viciously.
Those few can and will gain a larger audience ,if there is no one to present the alternative (which in most circumstances make more sense to a rational being).
We need your presence. We need an academic to present the alternative that in most circumstances is either wilfully ignored or washed down to appear as a weak second.
Assalamu alaikum Sheikh,
Alhamdu lillah excellent talk.i just want to say that don't get disheartened by the critics of yours,we all love you for the sake of Allah and inshallah you gonna remain an academic progressive sincere voice for Muslims.
I am listening to you for long time and I have seen changes in your toughts and ideas just as I have changed mine over these years(probably many others).
It's always informative and new paradigm to look at things.
May Allah reward you for all your efforts.
You won't believe but the situation in Muslim countries is much worse than what it's there in non Muslim countries.
So keep doing the good work for the sake of Allah and don't worry about the critics.
You will be in our prayers and prayers of so many who may not even comment here.
Jazakallah
May Allah bless you and May Allah give u strength that u go on giving us so much knowledge.
I benefit a lot from this. It's very much needed
Asalaamu alaikum shaykh Yasir,
I hardly ever comment on any platform, but I am commenting today to ask you stay on social media such as TH-cam, as I have been listening to your lectures since 2001 and I have learned from you immensely even though I have never met you in real life (I did see you once when you came to my town to give khutbah in my masjid and that was a great privilege to have seen you in person). BarakAllahu feek.
I don't know whether Shaykh Qadhi sees it. This is indeed Ilman Nafiyan.
I'm a darn follower of Sufi Path. I've ended loving your recent wisdom and views even though I had to dislike your views 15+ years back so much! I can't imagine how opposing I was and how much pain it caused when you followed strict sectarianism. Wallah, it damages the very Ummah.
Shaykh, you have a long long way to go. You are gifted with knowledge in early life.
May your academic work benefit the Ummah and all of Humanity BiijnIllah.
If u leave u r going to deprive a lot of people of beneficial knowledge and it is not befitting for a Alim of ur stature to leave social media just bcoz of some ignorant and jahils refuting ur work whose only aims are get famous bcoz they don't have any identity of their own. Think over again.
After listening to so much of your lectures and duroos, most of your audience have reached to an advance level, so there is no need to worry about the topics you choose to address which InShaAllah will always benefit and enlighten the people. Keep up the good work and May Allah subhana wa tahala reward you for this. Ameen.
Can you give a detailed lecture about the different creeds like athari, ash'ari and matarudi? Since your listeners are advance level, it will very beneficial.
Exactly! Thank you Shaykh!
Assalamualaikum
I cannot tell you how much I've benefited from your videos over the years, listening to you is.astaple of my day. Please don't stop posting videos and your online presence because its so important to have people like you around especially in the current climate.
May Allah bless you and I hope you change your mind
Gee, let me be the first one to comment. Assalamualaikum from Uzbekistan.
May Allah accept from you, Dr Qadhi. You're making us think.
th-cam.com/video/9uBcWN_W4Pw/w-d-xo.html
ва алейкум ассалям, предлагаю перевести некоторые из его видео.
@@edidzabija2265смотря на какой язык. На русском его материалов много. Вот на узбекском по моему почти нет.
@@ozodbek_sk подобных материалов нет и на русском. Лекции на "острые" темы не переводились, хотя для русскоговорящей уммы очень актуальны.
Ну в принципе можно. Главное потом, чтобы "back and forth" не началось. Наши любят спорить. На все темы спорят.
I love this series.
Online refutation culture is so toxic. This makes me sad.
Really loving these chats, sheikh. All the best.
Brother Yasir, did I hear you mention that you are planning to leave the public domain soon? If this is true, please make duaa and reconsider. Sincerely, I do not know of any scholar who delivers such insightful and beneficial lectures the way you do. I do not intend to make you feel proud but where else would we get these kind of lectures from? We are blessed in North America to have some amazing scholars but you Bro. Yasir are different. Your style is different, your rigorous academic details that you include are second to none and most importantly, even though Allah sees the heart, the sign of sincerity, doing it all for the sake of Allah and not for any worldly gain or popularity is written all over you.
Been following you since the mid 2000s and you are such a blessing to us Muslims of today. Please reconsider withdrawing from the public eye, May Almighty Allah continue to guide and protect you and your family. May He continue to bless you with ilm and sincerity. You have no idea how much impact, positive impact you have made and will in shaa Allah continue to make on today's Muslims.
Because he is facing a lot of questions and afraid ,,,,,,,,
Jazak Allah to you our Shaykh. Salams and well wishes to you and your family. We are thoroughly academically enjoying these Library Chats from you as we don't have direct access to you or the material you cover. Alhumdulillah for having deeper discussions and make us understand various topics that are part of our Islamic History and have very pertinent effect on our religious life and worldly life (based on everything you discuss). May Allah swt bless you and your family with the best!
Imam Ahmed bin Hanbal would be a muslim blockbuster if ever made into a movie. It will touch the hearts 💔💔💔❤of everyone watching. I saw the kamal al makki narration 7-8 years back, it was EPIC and powerful .
There's imam series on youtube, made last year
@@Adrian-yf1zg ive seen that, thaught its unnecessarily long and dragging .. too many side stories, and the dramatisation did not do justice to imam Ahmed bin Hanbal.
@@novaroon agree with you. the series was long bcoz of what u mentioned.
MaashaALLAH to you..
Jazaka Allahou khayran for your great insights. Last video about the "letter of dod" was incredibly interesting. Thanks a lot. Salâm from a French revert
As Salamualajkum Sheikh, thank you for spreading ilm. 🙂
Yeah..YQ you r the best
May Allah reward you
Inquisition and Refutation is well narrated; anecdotally by Maulana Abul Hasan Ali Nadvi in his book "Saviour of Islamic Spirit". Eloquent sequence consequences my Heart.
I am also revisited through this video with some fresh view of Sheikh.
Jazakallahu qeyr akhi
May Allah grant you barakah in this life and much more after...
Certainly these Library Chat sessions are among the best it's kind..
TH-cam islamic contents are just now a days moving towards viewership and things of sort..
These library sessions are also certainly blessing in time, I would say as with the lock down some of us are not getting the opportunity to have sessions among learned friends ..
Certainly more of these topics and session are the best of its kind for those who are interested in going deeper in having exclusive understanding of the deen...
May Allah bless you & we would love to hv more these sessions..
These library chat are very educating
I pray that Allah preserve you. May Allah guide all of us and forgive our sins and make us of the people of sound heart and the succesful ones. ameen
Ya sheikh I feel that defending one's position against no sense nosense is rather draining. If they had any substance, it would have been a learning experience and worth discussing. Even though I thoroughly enjoyed and appreciate this video, it does seem to drain you spiritually.
Taking short breaks from the Internet does wonders for us. You need not defend yourself when you are truthful and sincere. Patience is highly priced and valued in Islam maybe because most often than not the circumstances turn out to be hopeless and we have no other option other than showing patience.
Sheikh, my sincerest advice regarding this matter is, defend sincerely, what you know to be the deen of Allah and Allah would surely defend you and guide you. May Allah protect you and all our ulamas, our beacons of light in the darkness and deception of these end times. ameen.
Please do not stop publishing video. I myslef enjoy so much academic topic.
Shaikh qadi. Please give reference when you quote scholars . Like imam. Ahmad regarding quran position. Good scholar always gives reference
your lectures are excellent
00:16 📜 Historical context of refutations and counter-refutations
Refutations and counter-refutations are common across history, not just in religion but in various social groups and enterprises.
Critiquing and defending beliefs are intrinsic to human interaction, especially regarding religious beliefs.
Religious texts and traditions, like the Quran and Sunnah, emphasize advising and correcting deviations.
02:52 🛡 Role of religion in refutations and corrections
Religion plays a significant role in refuting and correcting misguidance, as demonstrated in historical incidents.
The involvement of religious scholars in refutations highlights the importance of intellectual discourse within religious communities.
Religious history showcases instances of societal and governmental involvement in refutations and corrections.
05:28 💼 Challenges in transitioning from theory to reality
Transitioning from theoretical understanding to practical application poses challenges in refutation cultures.
Individuals tend to judge based on their own paradigm, leading to subjective interpretations and reactions.
Refutation culture often reinforces existing beliefs and paradigms, limiting its effectiveness in promoting intellectual growth.
10:52 🧠 Importance of learning from historical examples
Studying historical incidents of refutations provides valuable lessons for understanding contemporary discourse.
Historical refutations illustrate the complex dynamics between religious authority, societal norms, and governmental power.
Examining historical debates helps discern the nuances of theological disagreements and their impact on religious communities.
18:20 📜 Imam al-Bukhari's Trial and Social Drama
Imam al-Bukhari's trial illustrates the societal pressures and consequences of social drama.
Mass confusion and misinterpretation of ambiguous statements led to slanders and innuendos.
The development of theology over generations reflects the evolution of thought and interpretation.
24:09 ⚔ Consequences of Fomenting Hatred
Continuous preaching of hatred can lead to tragic outcomes, including harm and even death of scholars.
Examples of scholars like Ibn Furak and Imam al-Nasai demonstrate the dangers of spreading false accusations and inciting violence.
Hatred fueled by social and theological differences can escalate to violence with devastating consequences.
34:17 🏛 Legal Intervention and its Impact
Ibn Mujahid's accusation of heresy against adversaries demonstrates the use of legal means to address theological disputes.
Legal actions, although controversial, can sometimes bring about standardization and codification of religious practices.
The involvement of the state in religious matters can have both positive and negative consequences, shaping the trajectory of religious scholarship.
36:21 📜 Ibn Mujahid and Ibn Mukhel Inquisitions
Ibn Mujahid and Ibn Mukhel invoked precedence in their inquisitions.
Ibn Mukhel ordered Ibn Miksam to recant, leading to his public apology and private continuation of his beliefs.
Ibn Shanna Booth refused to recant, leading to torture and a curse against his persecutors.
40:35 📚 The Mehnah of Ibn Aqil
Ibn Aqil, a prominent Hanbali scholar, faced social pressure and refutation for his diverse scholarly interests.
He was forced into a public trial and forced to recant his views to avoid persecution.
Despite his recantation, Ibn Aqil's legacy endured, highlighting the limitations of refutations in the long run.
47:14 🧠 Lessons Learned from History
Refutations rarely result in meaningful change of beliefs.
Refutations do not determine long-term winners; sincerity and genuine scholarship prevail over time.
Spending a lifetime in refutation rarely leads to a lasting legacy in the scholarly community.
53:03 🔄 Psychological and Sociological Functions of Refutations
Refutations help maintain boundaries within social groups by negating others and affirming one's own values.
The psychological and sociological function of refutations is more about self-affirmation than genuine critique.
Understanding the role of refutations can provide insights into group dynamics and identity formation.
54:13 💡 Understanding the Role of Refutations
Refutations often serve to validate one's own position rather than genuinely engage with opposing views.
Quality products or ideas do not need constant refutation to prove their worth.
Concentrating on positive output and productivity is more fruitful than engaging in continuous refutations.
57:14 🔍 Advice on Handling Refutations
Focus on producing substantive content rather than being reactive to criticisms.
Refute ideas, not individuals, and maintain objectivity to avoid becoming consumed by the refutation culture.
Understand the primary purpose of refutations is to reinforce group cohesion rather than necessarily convince opponents.
Great lecture
Social media has not done anything significantly good in comparison to amount of fitna it creates. What little good it may bring to an individual is not worth the cost others far away are paying for it. Thousands have lost lives and livelihoods and their futures facilitated by social media (e.g. Muslims in India, Burma, Sri Lanka). You just have to look at the world we live in? Every corner is suffering and social media is playing a huge role in it. Good to hear Dr. YQ is leading by example.
I suffer that our spiritual family is so easily troubled by differences of opinion. While I respect those who are wise and learned, I also know that I am answerable to God for the choices I make. The Quran is very clear that I have no refuge in using a other person's beliefs or knowledge to excuse my choices and my behavior. As Educated as this and other speakers are in sharing their views in the end I am naked before God and receive His Judgement based on my individual choices.
Assalamu ‘alaykum, I agree that refutation rarely changes the minds of the opposition, but it does serve to sway those on the fence who are the majority, and thereby recruit more followers to your own “side”. I suspect that’s the main intention of several, present day, full-time refuters. I don’t think they even care about the souls of their opponents, they only want to make a name for themselves.
You are one of the great modern day scholar who has really benefited the ummah and we don't have to advise you as you yourself know better about the rewards of spreading knowledge ( one of the three sadaqah jariah which benefits in the grave) . If it is just because some ignorant few spreading videos against you then you just gave the examples of great Ulemas of the past and what they went through and yet they were firm in what they understood about the religion. If they could do it for the sake Allah (SWT), so why can't you do the same.
By the way, the camera position and lighting is very good.
No please don't leave cuz of the ignorant ruthless people just block them all
And advanced stuff should be discussed even to average Muslim so they know that they are so far away and they need to step up their game
more on library chat content please😊
Sheikh Yasir PLEASE Keep on uploading your University lecture on TH-cam
I am truly saddened to hear you say you will be leaving Social Media. You give us so much knowledge and tour lectures are truly beneficial to many intellectual Muslims and I am sure non Muslims. Your thinking is unique and you are very intelligent. We need more Yasir Qadhis. but unfortunately there isn’t such a highly western and eastern educated sheikh. Please don’t go! 😨
Ya sheikh, please don't leave us. At least please stay on TH-cam 😢
Mohamed hijab et Al should watch this