ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 ก.พ. 2023
- “The 1619 Project”, named for the year the first enslaved African people arrived on the shores of Virginia, began as an editorial franchise for the New York Times. It has since grown to include the best-selling book, a children’s picture book, class curriculum, a podcast, and now, a new Hulu documentary series. The body of work asks us to reexamine and reframe what we know to be true of U.S. history. “The books that have stuck with me most in my life are the ones that have unsettled me,” says Nikole Hannah-Jones. Since its inception, “The 1619 Project” has faced a relentless firestorm of calls for its ban -- from school libraries, state senates, and even the Trump White House. “Countries do great things, and countries do terrible things, and we have to deal with it all,” says Hannah-Jones. Being exposed to new ideas and information is in fact, “the purpose of an education.”
» Subscribe to MSNBC: on.msnbc.com/SubscribeTomsnbc
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: on.msnbc.com/Readmsnbc
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: MSNBC.com/NewslettersTH-cam
Find MSNBC on Facebook: on.msnbc.com/Likemsnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: on.msnbc.com/Followmsnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: on.msnbc.com/Instamsnbc
#The1619Project #BannedBooks #Books
"The further a society drifts from the truth, the more it will hate those that speak it."
-----George Orwell
I'm not so sure George Orwell would be on Nikole Hannah Jones' side.
That's how we got that racist liar trump
The modern GOP reminds me of a line from the movie A FEW GOOD MEN. "You can't handle the truth. The you in this statement is the GOP.
@@danielharris9177 As of 2016 the moderate Republican party that believed in social decency and Constitutional law no longer exist, it's been taken over by unqualified far right extremist crackpots. *"God help us all."*
You know 1619 is a complete lie
"None of us should be sending our children to school simply to have their worldview affirmed in every way,
it should be challenged."
------Nicole Hannah - Jones
They're children. They don't have a "world view".
@@thomasdequincey5811 Deflect all you want, but today's children have a "worldview" like no other...they have a cellphone.
@@thomasdequincey5811 Why are you afraid of the truth?
Seriously, I would love to know.
@@thomasdequincey5811 deliberate ignorance speaks much louder
@@thomasdequincey5811 except black & brown kids do. Our kids deal with racists like you everyday, adults calling them the n word. But your fragile yt kids can't learn about racism?
I guess you want your kids ignorant to the world 🤷🏾♂️
"Unlimited power in the hands of limited people always leads to cruelty."
~ Aleksander Solzhenitsyn
Solzhenitsyn was talking about Stalin and the leaders of the Soviet Union who controlled every lever of power. There is no equivalent in the USA.
For sure, especially the African Tribes who first took the losers of conflicts between tribes as slaves and started selling them to ancient Egypt, and the levant, and to Persia.
Tyrants are limited people who want unlimited things.
@@cheattolay real question, why are you folks so obsessed with black people?
Like why are you here , just to hate ? Are you really that obsessed?? Real question
"I've always maintained that black people and women suffer from a presumption of incompetence. The burdens of proof are different. It just gets so tiresome."
~ Carol Moseley Braum, American diplomat, politician, and lawyer
Read Daniel Patrick Moynihan (D) paper from the 1960's on the decline of the black family by the federal government, it's spot on and still relevant today. The government treated blacks as inferior and therefore replaced the father with the government. Nothing could be further from the truth. Blacks had strong family ties.
I think you're focusing too much on black and need to focus on poverty. But then again racism sells news
As if white men are never victimized by any body.
Culture Culture Culture
"Those who can not remember the past is condemned to repeat it."
~ George Santayana (1863-1952), Spanish born writer, essayist, poet, novelist, philosopher, and Harvard Professor
Unfortunately, it has usually turned out that those who are most aware of history are most doomed to repeat it. This fact is probably the primary thing responsible for most of our wars. We can never seem to forget our past. It’s also why abused kids either become abusers themselves or marry abusive spouses and why many people make the same mistakes over and over again. Most of us just cannot let go of the past.
People deny it. For example the democrats were the party if slavery. The democrats fought a war to keep slavery legal. Yet in these modern times we act likethey’re the party all blacks and brown people should vote for if not you a racist. The world view should not be taught in school. History yes everyone should be ok with having thier own view. Blacks did build the country so did Chinese and Mexicans that pick your fruit miss BLM.
An untrue generalization
To me, the teaching of "CRT" is the same as understanding your health history, and what your ancestors died from. These represent risks to your own health and will help you make positive life style changes and better monitor your well being. Your mother died in her thirties of breast cancer? Any woman who can say that should be following a more active surveillance regimen at an earlier date related to her susceptibility to that disease. You don't think of that as making you "responsible" for your mother's death, its just an artifact of who you are and where you came from. We seem to be able to accept that, which makes it all the more curious as to why we cannot do the same thing with racism. Racism is an indisputable and present condition that continues to underpin social practice, policy and structure. It may not be who you are as a person but without question, it is who Americans are as a people. Trying to suppress honesty and transparency about this is, in effect, a racist act. Those who say that our children will "feel responsible for slavery" underestimate their children. They will learn that bigotry, cruelty, and inequity has a long history here with those who came before and happens here to this day because a lack of awareness, vigilance and understanding.
"Mostly peaceful" Velshi thinks it's okay to have prawn-o-graphic material in grade school and middle school libraries. There are dozens and dozens of documented cases of this obscene, not fit for children, trash being found in school libraries. Apparently Velshi is against banning such books.
The 1619 project is prawn-o-graphic. Please tell me U got out of 5th grade by ' helping' your handsome teacher. Cos your comment alone is enough to drag America's educational standards 12 steps behind Sudan.
And what “pornographic material” is that exactly? Site at least one example, a pornography found in a school library. Cite all substantiating evidence, proving this incident occurred.
Just the kind of galactic stupidity we’ve come to expect from your kind. Well done!
Or just name one book you consider “prawn o graphic”.
Ali Velshi's Banned Book Club is the most important show right here right now
Why are people so sensitive?
None of us were here three or four hundred years ago!
That means we're not to blame for what happened. Let's learn about it guys, don't be offended because you weren't involved.
Exactly. Our ancestors burned witches under false accusations. We are not responsible for what they did but we should learn about it so that history doesn't repeat itself.
The book doesn't blame an individual, it blames the systems that were created out of slavery
@@karenwhite4453 Well it's fiction so who does it actually blame? Fictional people?
@@brucecampbell4528 I don't believe that it is considered fiction, but I get your point.
Interesting...reminds me of "Crossing the Bok Chitto"( about a young Choctaw girl & a young black enslaved boy) prior to the Civil War & the Trail of Tears) by Choctaw Storyteller & Author, Tim Tingle....he has written stories for young readers about Choctaw history & the US government treatment of these People...there is a series "How I Became a Ghost" about a young Chocttaw boy walking the infamous Trail of Tears...There is also a story, "Salty Pie", a personal story of how TIm Tingles GrandMother was trreated by young white boys....I'm guressing that these books will also be banned - especially in Texas.
And what about exposing young readers & students about the "true"meaning of Thanksgiving.....
What I'm trying to say is that these books are also at risk of becoming unavailable to students AND the Authors of all colors being banned from schools at any level.
As I've written elsewhere.. A societys degree of insecurity in its own values, it's own ideas and its identity, can be discerned by the degree of censureship that is imposed upon its educational institutions and professions.. The US must be an exceptionally insecure society.
Duh! lol where you been? The US has been this blustering bully teen with a fragile ego easily since the Antebellum south. Probably since before but we know when it comes to the issue of slavery, sexism, and classism the US actively goes out of its way to shut down anyone who says this country is anything but great.
Yawn. You really should just not write anything.
Thank you, Ali, for all you're doing to guarantee freedom of speech. You can't force people to read and expand their thinking 🤔 but many are willing to at least listen on a Kindle, which is great also. This is a landmark study, and it's going to help so many young people. I sure wished we had this tool when I was in school. The history books we were taught out of only showed Blacks as slave's in the cotton fields. I remember how everyone looked at me when we studied the civil war. I was so ashamed.
I watched the Hulu show. A couple of times. 👏👏👏Very well done💜💞
Big fan of fiction?
Propaganda films can be very entertaining. 👌
This reminds me of Aleksander Solzhenitsyns' "Archipelago" in that it's a historical journalistic work that chronicled the brutality of the Soviet Union. Solzhenitsyn was a political dissident who was sent to the "gulag" for years, and he talked about their lives and how they were abused. It was a long book, but it had principles that still apply. Human nature doesn't change. He won the Nobel Prize for Literature and donated the money. My understanding last I checked was that many Russians haven't even read his work's. He was celebrated in the Western world.
Loved listening to Nikole here and I will be looking out for her work. As an Australian I cannot believe that in the 21st century, in a first world country (that purports to be the most advanced in the world) the words 'book ban' would even be uttered.
I never thought in 2020-2022 Australians like yourself cheered over mandates, "Cristal Nachted" unvaccinated people, and sent people to concentration camps.
Maybe just worry about Australia, dude. There is no frickin "ban"
This is about public school libraries and curricula.
@@booqueefious2230
Remind every Australian who opens their mouth that "they supported the Howard Springs Concentration Camp"
The very fact of book bans in America of the 1619 Project proves the assertions of the 1619 Project.
@@jomarsicano
So, you feel that a fifth grader should pick up a book from his/her school library and read about a boy getting sucked (describing his junk) on the couch?
(And before you say that 'Oh, that happens all the time' remember that school shootings happen all the time and I don't see books in library's about Sandy Hook)
History is not about belief in the way religion is about belief
Two things . Black people were here in slavery as early as 1555 and also traveled to here and already lived here as early as the late 1490s and early 1500s .
Just bought me 2 copies
Changing history to meet one's future expectations is folly.
Slavery seems to have existed for the 14,000 years indigenous people have lived in the Americas. They enslaved each other. Slavery did not begin in the Americas in 1619. Slavery did exist for 79 years in southern United States. 230,000 dead Union soldiers and the 13th. Amendment then ended 14,000 years of slavery in all the United States; a remarkable achievement.
Every book that Republicans ban, I buy for my grandchildren, my daughter, and myself. My grandchildren are homeschooled so The 1619 Project and CRT are taught to them every day. I want them WOKE.
You pump them with Black Nationalist revisionism? That's nice. Hilarious the Liberal version of uneducated homeschool like uneducated conservatives want to do.
Is this satire?
CRT teaches that the white liberal, with a high level of eduaction is the hierarchy. All else are below thanks to racism.
Now that's hilarious! I like your sarcasm!
A well rounded education, good. CRT is a college course so teaching them real history is great but it's not CRT. Being woke, is defined as being alert to racial prejudices and discrimination. Why people think this is a bad thing I'll never understand. People rather have a sugar coated history (lies) than truth. Truth makes us better humans. It makes us sympathize with one another. Staying in the dark will bring atrocities. We're already on that road.
I read the 1619 Project. This book is appropriate for high school curriculum.
NO IT'S NOT. Garbage is appropriate ONLY for a county dump.
@@whicker59 have you read it?
Okay groomer
@@ronswanson2029 Please name one specific incident described in the book that you think is not factual.
How did you read it if it's banned?
Oh, MSNBC is lying.
Whites aren't confronted with uncomfortable truths.
Just because your parents failed doesn't mean everyone else is an ignoramus like you.
U bdeyujg r confronted with inaccurate history, right here on msLSD.
Nah, we just accept the uncomfortable truths of yesterday, correct course, and move along.
This woman’s courage and tenacity are an inspiration for all human beings. Bravo Sister👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
I look forward to reading or hearing more about this book. Definitely need a "1492 Project". Does the book cover Africa's and Europe's precolonial relationship?
There are the books "1491" and "1493" which discuss the western hemisphere before Columbus and what happened after his arrival. Both are terrific.
@@yvonneplant9434
Thank you, I'll look for them.
This "book" is 💯 a lie. You're wasting your time.
@@alpine1600s
How or why is that?
In all of my guitar playing pot smoking hippie years, I feel completed to say,"Sister needs to change her hair!"!!
This book has been overwhelmingly panned and shown to be incredibly inaccurate to flat out false. Hundreds of historians have come out to say so, including many historians of color. Slavery isn't a uniquely American institution and it's not a white black phenomenon.
Hundreds of white people not historians. White people want to be seen as good and that is not the truth. When white people emotionally grow up then America can be great. White fear is the problem and the narrative proves to be a figment and a lie. Black people are the daily reminders of white people's crimes against humanity. Black people have always seen white people clearly and accurately and now old white people don't want their children to give them the side eye that they deserve. They sure don't want to have to explain. America is not exceptional because white people don't want it to be unless they can be artificially in front. Level playing fields don't support the white supremacy fantasy and white people feel better when they don't have to look in the mirror without lying. The 1619 Project does just that. Holds a focused mirror in white people's faces and calls out their wrong and their lies. FYI: Martin Luther King wasn't talking about Black and white kumbaya in his I Have A Dream spoech. He indicted white America and encouraged to Black people to keep on keeping on. Most of those that have the nerve to quote him never read the entire speech. The paragraph y'all love to quote was talking about HIS children in particular. White people try to use it in their anti-Black campaign. Y'all are exactly what your ancestors were and you prove it every time you open your mouths. How Black Americans were and are treated is not debatable and no lie was detected. Not one critic spoke about what she wrote didn't happen, that their is no evidence to support her project or that she is lying about the treatment by white people in America. Until y'all get up off your flat azzes and correct your mess, you're never going to live down the shame and disgust that your invented white superiority brought without cause. Just evil and greed will always be your legacy. Y'all can pretend but the entire melanated majority knows the truth, the whole truth and nothing but. You're making a bed that future white people will sleep in. Just so you know.
"I am not ashamed of my grandparents for having been slaves. I am only ashamed of myself for having, at one time, been ashamed."
We must never allow a little Black child to be ashamed again. Thank you for your work.
~ Ralph Ellison ( 1914-1994), American writer, literary critic, and scholar
Thank you msnbc for once again teaching me what to think.
".... to restrict knowledge." Spot on!
How about a 1607 Project.....for the English founding of Jamestown VA?
Children should b taught REAL HISTORY.
What about the 1845 Project??
My ancestors were literally plagued with famine by the English and all I ever hear about is how privileged my people are. 🤣
@The Bilbo Show who are your people?
There is not much new to learn about Jamestown.
@@danieldesjardins4074 Mexicans
Jamestown settlement is a very educational trip. 👍
Do you think that’s going to make it easier or cause more stress
Please define your word "that." One can't even begin to give an answer with an undefined topic.
I haven't read it, but I would say "Mein Kampf" is more honest than the "1619 Lie."
She is an educator’s educator.
America needs more like her speaking up and arguing the good arguments.
Lol
Democrats are happy for the black communities to identify as victims. It’s their entire schtick, they want to keep them on the plantation.
@@TheDiamond2009 Who cares what black communities are? They're attacking the white population because of their extreme racial [Afro] centrism. Stop trying to make this about black people.
Whats her argument again that people are not accepting or suppressing??
@@johnsmith7140 you are highly illustrative of my point. Thanks for playing.
I got dragged bc a bunch of people were playing politics in my name and obstacles were thrown in my way every step of the way.
Miss Hannah-Jones should be awarded the Nobel Prize for Literature. She is a brave and brilliant woman. She has illuminated the world and shone the mirror of truth on the millions of ignoramaces in the USA
Yeah must be a big fan of fiction huh?
The Nobel Prize for STUPIDITY!
🤣
Her and Steven king right?
I wonder how many supporters of Banned Books have ever even read a book? Any book?
Lol
Love her, she is absolutely correct.
Amen she definitely is❤
"Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely."
~ Lord Acton
Banned books are nothing new in America, but often it is just a subject that comes up in September every year, for "Banned Book Week." As a former bookstore owner and librarian, I felt honor bound to display the ridiculous number of classics, including different versions of the Bible, which have been banned by some school board or demanded to be withdrawn from a library. And it's true. People would walk away from these displays with stacks of books they never read otherwise. People like to make up their own minds about books and that is exactly what some people want to prevent. What's next? Nazi-style book burnings? I am pining on my I Read Banned Books button for good.
THANKS Velshi!
How much is this affecting the racial wealth gap Nikole talks about?
"More African-Americans are going to college than ever before. But according to new research from the Center on Education and the Workforce at Georgetown University, African-American college students are more likely to pursue majors that lead to low-paying jobs, setting up many for future debt and underemployment..."
From:
African-Americans over-represented among low-paying college majors
PBS Newshour
Nikole Hannah-Jones keeps showing up in my lyrics.
(I totally expect no one to care)
♥
love this
Gratitude
Thanks MSNBC fo the laughs🤭🤭🤭
Thanks 😊
Democrats noticed how effective Republicans strategy on angering parents was in 2020 and 2022. They are trying the same strategy, just the opposite approach. I’m sure it’ll be effective, although a lot of “Karen’s” will secretly be in the side of Republicans I’m afraid
Children are capable of understanding human issues, both the beauty and the warts. For example, they have to learn about death which is the big one. It depends on how these things are discussed and the psychological competence of parents. Learn some Developmental psychology and how to talk to children. Who's laying the guilt trip on children? And the answer is: the GOP.
The saddest thing about the 1619 book ban, is that it's a BOOK BAN! - Banning any book discourages children & others from READING, which is idiocy!
(Unless the book promotes actual danger, violence etc).
Especially since book reading helps brain development in multiple ways.
Dems be like..let's stop racism with more racism...
Fight fire with fire lol
Name something specific that dems have doe that is racist. We should talk.
@@yurei8 race baiting black people into hating instead of equal opportunity...blm is the biggest hustler. Joyless Reid is the worst...
@@yurei8 ever heard of the Civil war...who supported slavery?
@@anewleaf6847 It is not about hating white people. It should be about hating injustice. Your side is just framing it that way to avoid all criticism. Here is a very concrete example: The ghettos of the inner cities were create by specific things: 1. government policies which provided lower cost home loans, and excluded blacks for around 30 years, 2. and financial institutions that refused to let blacks live among whites in many areas. Those were institutional practices, not all white people. That particular government back housing support was put in place 1934. But that was enough to create a generation of white homeowners.
But a 10 year old black kid is smart enough to understand that no ten year white kid is responsible for th 1934 program. Your media is fear mongering you, for the purpose of controlling, which exactly what they claim about things like the 1619 Project. Why would a ten year white kid feel bad about himself for something that happened before he was born? Your side is missing the whole purpose of history. But i do believe there is an intentional purpose of why you are targeted. The real idea behind that is building a white nationalist state. there are historical precedents for that.
If you have time, I want ask you if you know why American black history programs exist?
Can I join the "banned book club"?
Nikole Hannah-Jones, per your statement that "collective shame can be good", do you personally feel a sense of collective shame for America's historical institution of race-based slavery, since you are indeed an American and therefore part of the collective?
She be so famous now, what will she do when all real Americans see her, will she walk fast? Or just when she sees orientals?
*Based book*
I think that social movements recently can be damaged by the label that they choose to use. For example Defund the Police or CRT. For me, the 1619 Project is a neutral term that is more inviting to people - makes them more curious. I dont think Defund the Police slogan in itself has done the movement justice....speaking for myself when i first heard about these.
How to be a racist and a victim at the same time.
"To talk about race in America is to explore the wilderness inside ourselves and to come to terms with a history that we'd rather conceal."
~ Cornel West, American minister, professor, writer, and activist
Sure, except for black people coming to terms with the fact they were enslaving each other and selling them to people all over the world, not just white europeans.
Slavery was what I experienced and what I saw. Those people can’t say it. I will. Not great.
In the Caribbean we call that Babylon system....
A goal and a point to the story would have made it much better.
Praise God for Brittany getting out and praying for others being held as we hope for the release of all political prisoners like Navaldy.
You don't pray to anyone.
is that the same WIG that Crusty the Clown wears ?
Same one your mama wore
The attempts to define me under these conditions and given what was going on in my name isn’t impressive.
21st century version of book burning
❤
I’ll take on anything I said in the context of where I’ve been. Not really impressed by how much time was wasted on wording.
Waiting for this guy to highlight "The Anarchist Cookbook"
Why are we on the wrong side of this issue? Why are we supporting racism? We all fought and marched in work so hard to have legislation enacted that promotes equality, and now we are making a U-turn to promote racism?
The problem I have with this project is this: I think it's fine to re-examine our "hidden" history. The thing is its conclusions are NOT embraced into a positive affirmation of "Look what we have accomplished since 1619...we can do anything, and overcome all limitations." No! Instead it's used to say, "We're still oppressed by the 'System'...just like in 1619! We're still victims in 2023." And the victimization of African Americans continues.
Yes, there's a lot of racism out there still. Breaking news: You'll never get to 100% acceptance by the so-called mainstream public. But you need to OVERCOME IT.
Breaking news: We’ve NEVER asked for acceptance. We want EQUALITY and haven’t gotten it yet. And yes, even still in 2023, America’s racial problems are SYSTEMIC!
This is why your voice is important. But sometimes, understanding past injustice, is an empowerment tool. Slaves were forbidden from reading, at some point. So reading can be a tool for freedom. A tool, such as this book can be used in multiple ways, just like any tool. I agree with your sentiment about victimhood.
The ancestors don’t need woke peoples pity, they lived their lives, fed their children and had pride in who they were, even under horrendous circumstances. No need to rewrite history and imagine things that might never have happened to your ancestors.
Why are all the books Velshi brings up about identity politics? And why are they never banned? I wonder if someone wrote a book about Wuhan, if Velshi would talk about it
Write the book and find out
@@YOUREADY09 Well, I'm working on Jan 6th: The Musical. I haven't quite figured out the guy with horns' aria. But I suspect it'll be a hit among BlueAnon
@@winstonsmith6607
Read “The Fall of America” by Elijah Muhammad and give me your thoughts.
Evidently you don't listen to the news. How you've missed the whole nonsense about CRT is unbelievable if you listen to any news at.
Hunter Biden: the Musical.
More weird books? Smh
but them folk use to take their children to watch black men get lynched,now they want to band book about CRT,that focus on a system😂😂😂
Teaching children they are “oppressors” or “victims” based on skin color is pure evil. This persons writings have been banned in our local public schools.
Have you actually READ the 1619 Project?
This is history which none of us are responsible for. Even a child can understand that. In Germany children are taught about WWII and their nation's involvement.
@@azfinestabr I have indeed
@@mikes6021 And on what exact page does it say children are “oppressors or victims based on skin color”? Please tell us
What education does this person have?
A BA in history and a Masters degree in Journalism
@@karenwhite4453 Than she must know the 1619 project is false.
What education do you have? I’m guessing a GED from Chump University.
@@EnemyOfThePeople1984 Chimp? is that in Africa?
1619 project and this author are liars.
1619 was over 400 years ago. That’s almost half a millennia. There were a lot of human atrocities in the Middle Ages. We should write a book about Islams invasion of Spain in 711 and give out reparations for that?
Good idea, why don't you write it.
If you had read the book, you would know that your statement is 100% false. Go read it, and try again.
If you’re on the left and she doesn’t sit right with you, read some Toure Reed. He discusses how corporate America and neoliberals promote race essentialist and race reductionist ideas to prevent interracial solidarity among the poor and working class. If you’re a regular person, it doesn’t matter what your ethnicity is, this woman has nothing in common with you and she could care less about your struggles
Please explain why you think that. You're implying you haven't read the book so please use some examples.
@@gafls3151 I have read it. I’ve also listened to critiques FROM THE LEFT. Adolph and Toure Reed are just two prominent, Black, leftist historians who have dismantled her neoliberal, reductionist, race essentialist attempt at destroying working class solidarity. I will leave it up to you to seek information outside of your bubble. I could quote Darwin to a creationist all day and it would never get through. Likewise I could write paragraphs replete with quotes, and it wouldn’t make a difference to you. So I’m not going to waste my time. I’ve given you a starting place if you really want to get educated, the rest is up to you.
The 1619 project isn't that made up
This book isn't Banned, I've seen this trash in the library
Some schools have banned this work.
Lol
🟰⚖️⚕️🧠🕊🕉
The Manipulated Man by Esther Vilar.
The Most Dangerous Superstition by Larken Rose.
Circumcision: the hidden trauma. By Dr. Goldman.
Should be mandatory reading in schools.
Best show on HULU, “The 1619 Project.” The best show ever.
So, guilt is heritable?
Absurd. May as well offer an AP astrology course.
Hannah Jones has a net worth of 5 million and makes 80,000 a year. If you think this woman is aligned with the interests of the poor and working class, you need a reality check. People like her want to make money by exploiting race essentialist ideologies. People like her are interested in the diversification of the ruling class, not the dismantling of it.
What is important is knowledge, to me. I have read many books, and no idea of what those author's made. None. Like she said in this interview, one can critique ideas. I earned an important life lesson from hearing a story about Warren Buffet, one of the world's richer persons. Your purpose here, is to close minds from looking at complex issues. So in other words, it is to keep people in the dark, or in other words ignorant.
@@yurei8 You just demonstrated that knowledge is, in fact, NOT important to you. Closed minds chase corporatist race essentialists like Hannah Jones. Open minds seek to understand critiques. If you want to begin opening your mind about this topic, and read a critical review of her FROM THE LEFT by prominent black political scientists, then read the works of Adolph and Toure Reed. Both correctly point out the self serving flaws of this woman’s ideology
The 1619 project is such good fiction.
Did you actually read it?
@@gafls3151 Does reading it actually make it any less fiction and fake?
Cite one example. Are claiming that slavery never existed?
@@brucecampbell4528 Yes it makes a major difference. Can you cite something that is fiction? Even those banning it, say that the content could make children feel bad about themselves, not that it is fiction. Your purpose here is to hide Truth. Philosophically, God is Truth. Knowledge is light. Your purpose is to keep people in the dark.
@@yurei8 Large portions have been fact checked and proven to be fiction. 1) The idea that the revolution was fought to preserve slavery. 2) It basically frames slavery as a uniquely American problem. 3) Slavery still exist and is a major part in the African American communities. 4) It is an undisputed fact that first slave in America was white. 5) 40-50 precent of freed slaves, ended up being slave holders themselves.
She’s very brave. I actually worry for her -just the way the project and her work have triggered the so called right wing.
We need more than old white upper class male perspectives in our study of our history.
It’s so interesting and demoralizing at the same time how triggering it is for so many to consider other perspectives- and other truths.
Every wyt liberal must take a knee for what you did.
Why does she use skin whitener
You have no idea about her personal body issues.
1619 😆 🤣 😂 😹
What a grift
Fr
I wish Uncle Remus and Walt Disney were still around.
Thank you governor DeSantis and Youngkin for banning CRT from public schools, that crap is a pathetic disgrace
You haven’t even read it
@@dionnegreenwood957 Donnie Trump is EXACTLY correct!!!
@@whicker59 CRT has never been taught in public schools it's a college level course.
Hmm. Youre for government banning/censoring free speech?
@@roberthollingsworth8940 then why all the crying when governor DeSantis banned it? 😢
Is she from the racial jungle
WHY IS THE WOMAN LOOKING LIKE BOZO THE CLOWN??? 😂😂😂
Why are you not paying attention to the content? People write books to be read, not be seen.
How dare you turn this home into a house of lies
They should rename this “The books nobody cares about club”.
So she is trying to change History Why did she not take 1776 and try to put both together and compare them
The book isn't about 1776, it's about the year the first enslaved people arrived in the US. In 1776, black people were still enslaved.
@@karenwhite4453 Adolph and Turee Reed, both prominent, leftist, Black scholars, have extensively critiqued Hannah-Jones rewrite of American history. There are a lot of people who are intuitively put off by her ideology, but don’t have the academic and historical knowledge to rebut it. So they wind up on the right. Educated leftists understand that what she is doing is in service of the race essentialist neoliberal status quo, which seeks to undermine solidarity among the poor and working class. Nikole is a wealthy woman before all else. She would like to stay that way.
No she’s telling the TRUTH, which AmeriKKKa obviously can’t handle.
@@azfinestabr oh, OK funny guy you know what it’s people like you that starts racism
@@karenwhite4453 is it documented is it put in it in in writing where everybody can look up and research because people have research to book and a lot of the things are not correct in our findings how do
Nice clown hair, lesbian!