The Siege of Buda 1945 Animated
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 มิ.ย. 2024
- Buy Siege of Budapest Poster here: teespring.com/en-GB/siege-of-...
Support the channel on Patreon: / historigraph
Follow me on Twitch: / historigraph
#SiegeOfBudapest #SiegeOfBuda #Historigraph
► Twitch: / historigraph
► Twitter: / historigraph
►Facebook: / historigraph
►Instagram: / historigraph
►Patreon: / historigraph
The Siege of Budapest and the battles that led to it have had precious little written about them (in English!), so the bulk of this video comes from one book:
Krisztián Ungváry, Battle for Budapest: 100 Days in World War 2
This is by far the most detailed account of the battle that I could find.
Music:
Crypto, Incompetech incompetech.com
Rynos Theme, Incompetech incompetech.com
Stormfront, Incompetech incompetech.com - บันเทิง
Buy Siege of Budapest Poster here: teespring.com/en-GB/siege-of-...
Support the channel on Patreon: www.patreon.com/historigraph
Follow me on Twitch: www.twitch.tv/historigraph
Hi Mr Historiograph, I'm trying to reach out to you to propose a business agreement: I would love to dub your videos to Italian and then re-upload them onto an italian Historiograph channel. I reckon there is a potential untapped market for italian-speaking wartime history videos. Your videos are shockingly well made and would face very little same-language competition. The revenue from those videos would then be split at some rate to be decided between the two of us. Let me know what you think, I belive this can be a profitable endevour.
I always find sieges so sad. But still is very interesting to see the perspective of the defenders and frustration of relief units.
Mariupol :(
Most battles in ww2 were sieges tbh it basically renamed the meaning off a siege
@@r-saint Slava Ukraine :ua:
I thought sending university students into battle was bad but highschool kids? That’s heartbreaking
its so cool tho !
@@cumpanions8105 not at all it's a war crime. Using child soldiers is NOT OK
@@cumpanions8105 What is cool in using litteral children in a war?
@@day2148 That's one thing, but forcefully conscripting middle school aged children and sending them to die is a different beast than one person signing up a couple years early.
@@ragalyiakos I agree. But you said "using child soldiers" not "conscripting child soldiers". There are plenty of legitimate reasons to use them.
historigraph:
makes poster about the siege of Budapest
me, an hungarian:
i'll take your entire stock!
Glad to hear it!
Save some for the rest of us lol
Sorry ur country got fucked for like 40 years after this
This is my city! It's strange to hear what happened on the streets where I regurarly walk, 75 years ago.
Thanks for the video!
If you want make a video about an even greater Hungarian tragedy, I can recommend you the story of the 2nd Hungarian army around the Don bend in early 1943.
*** So happy to know that Horthy lived to see Budapest sieged two times by Romanian army! 😆😆😆
@@StefanGabrielRoHu" besieged" would be the proper term there, good sir. A peculiarity of the English language
@@tremainetreerat5176 Don't care, I'm not an English teacher.
@@StefanGabrielRoHu Gypsy thief.
туда им и дорога. 2й армии. Падонки коих поискать. Üdvözlet Voronyezsből.
My grandmother, 15 years old at the time, survived the siege with her family in an underground shelter right next to the Castle District. She once told me how they would send her out for water, as the men were too cowardly to leave the shelter, and how she had to crawl to avoid being fired upon by the soviet forces. To think, the sweet old lady still with us today, had to go through such hell.
Anyway, amazing video.
This is a song about the breakout, and Széna square, where it happened, made by a famous Hungarian singer, Tamás Cseh:
th-cam.com/video/dLo2MLNxV_s/w-d-xo.html
Thanks for sharing this story
My grandfather and his family were in Buda during the battle and were stuck in the capital building. He described it as a living hell, they ran out of water, food, plumbing, and electricity all within the first 2 days and were there for over a week
, he was only 6 years old at the time but says he has never forgotten what happened there, still to this day will not go into details on what he saw. They returned to their home (which was somehow completely untouched) they found 3 German soldiers hiding in their barn to escape the Soviets. Knowing they would be shot by the Soviets, my great grandmother gave them civilian clothing and burned their uniforms so they could escape back to Germany. Thanks for the great series, cool to learn the bigger picture of the battle but me having my personal connection makes it that much more engrossing.
My father too. 2nd army
@Redsand more likely normal whermacht
@Redsand Overall vengeance if I had to guess. The Russians went through some deap shit thanks to the Nazis and from what I can remember, you had to be a Nazi in order to join the army. By that point though they were more likely fighting simply because they had no other choice on the matter.
@Redsand Again I might be wrong but that is my opinion.
@Redsand still, it was guess. They were still probably conscripts.
The level of detail is just amazing, thanks as always for your videos
this channel is incredibly underrated, i never comment on videos but i really want to thank you for putting out such high quality videos
Cheers mate
Knowing the warm hospitality of soviet pow camps, I'd rather take my chance with the most futile effort to break out.
Same here
@LUNAR BLOODDROP for those who thought so during WW2 really ended up dead.
Still way better than being a Soviet PoW in german hands
Dying would be a better option than being a slave in siberia for 10 years
@@stc3145
Dying would be a better option than being a slave. Period.
Thank you from Hungary.
The germans did there best with what they had to relief the city.
We tried
~from Germany
*** So happy to know that Horthy lived to see Budapest sieged two times by Romanian army! 😆😆😆
Awesome content! Thank you for making such a good series about the siege of our capital.
You're very welcome!
"Congratulations Hungary, you are being rescued." -russia
"No go away" -hungary
*bang* *bang* *bang*
"Congratulations Comrade, you are being rescued" -soviet russia
"No go away" -hungary
*boom* *ratatatatatatat*
"Congratulations comrade Hungary, you are once more being rescued" -soviet russia
*dies in hungarian*
Normie
Are you ignoring the part where Hungary attacked the Soviet Union in 1941? Where they fought in Stalingrad? They should consider themselves lucky Soviets didn't raze the entire country to the ground, which they had full right to do after hungary was assisting Nazi germany
@Rio Jose Cheeran Hungary tried to switch side - but the germans was already prepared - look into Operation Margarethe and u will know what happened exactly - but shortly:
-the Hungarian army (full of pro-german officers at this point) refused the Governor's orders and arrested/shoot everyone who tried to switch side
-An elite SS commando kidnapped the Governor last living son and blackmailed Horthy to abdicate if he want to see him alive
-The Arrow-Cross Party was already planned a coup to overthrow the Horthy-regime, and so when all of this shit happened their are just went out and throw fuel to the fire - and the nazis in the end installed them as the new government.
Now, let me ask: how do u want to switch side, when the army was more loyal to the germans than toward you, the hungarian nazis already making a coup against you and the germans even kidnap your last living son? For Horthy and for Hungary swtiching side was impossible after Romania swtiched side, and before that moment the front didnt even reached Hungary - making earlier side-switching impossible (unless you want to be hero for 72 hour - because that was all how long Hungary could hold out against the germans attacking from all direction - not even speaking about what would happen with the 1st Hungarian Army near Warsaw - which actively helped the rebels AGAINST the germans during this time, what do u think what the germans would do with that army for example?)
@@GhostKiller755 there is no right to anything
Causing pain for inflicted pain achieves nothing
We should be glad most despots, dictators and absolute monarchs can't move us around like chess pieces and cannon fodder
@AuspiciousToad Woot? The Soviets barely damaged any countries unlike the Anglo allies who bombed Germany into oblivion.
I'm a simple girl, I see Historigraph upload, I like.
That's weird, i was told growing up that there were no girls on the internet!
Normie
@@MrBigCookieCrumble There are girls on the internet, but that rule doesn't mean what you think it means.
In real life, people treat you differently for being a girl. On the internet, that advantage is gone. And the only reason a girl using the internet would point out that they are a girl is if they wanted attention, for likes/comments/to get that advantage back. And it works because simps on the internet think girls will like them irl if they do that.
@@Horible4 Holy shit calm down, he's likely just a dude trolling around lmao
Horrible4 It’s was a joke but apparently more female are using internet like we men do. Still didn’t think many girls like history really, always good to see people like history.
I mean, if you think about it, they did break out... but the rest just were dead before they did breakout...
I truly and deeply love your style of videos. The amount of research that have to be made must be impressive, bravo !
Just found your channel. I can't believe you've only got 100k subscribers, when your content is easily on par with channels having 10x more. Thanks for what you do, and you've gained yourself at least one more for that list.
I like these battles we never hear about. I'm surprised that the Germans were still capable of offensive operations that late in the war, especially after the losses in Battle of the Bulge.
To be fair the offensives here were more due to the defenders being unprepared rather than German troops being still offensively strong.
@@DP-qm6qe to be fair thats bullshit and an excuse to the soviet side
Ohh I’ve been waiting for this upload!! Happy Saturday everyone!!
Love your video style! thank you for keeping this up I know its hard work
When command says "defend until the end", you should stop hoping for a breakout. You're there until you die. You've been abandoned.
Boy, have I waited long for this one. Thanks for the upload
Historiograph- great content (including lots of emphasis on the Navy) and great voice!
Amazing job! Keep it coming
absolutely loved these vids
This was really good. Great work. You earned a subscriber.
Love your videos, keep up the good work
I have a question; How do you get those lovely day-by-day battle lines? Aerial photography? Eyewitness accounts? Or using maps to guess likely lines of battle?
Go to a college library they usually have the books and stuff.
Or go to your city's main library.
Ungváry Krisztián did a huge study on it. Yes interviewing witnesses, participants, studying military documents.
The soviet captains and squad leaders had to report to their supperiors also the captured hungarian/german captains, officers, soliders were a usefull source too.
Love your work man
wow! just wow! great video man!
You should do all the major sieges, next Stalingrad, Leningrad, Sevastopol; and of course we CANT forget BERLIN!!! Keep up the great work man!!
My girlfriend's next door neighbour in a block of flats in Pest, is a sweet old man, who was a little kid during the siege. They sheltered themselves in an old house in Buda, near the castle, but during an artillery bombardment, the windows broke, and the shards of the glass damaged his eye. German medics couldn't help him, so the good old Karcsi bácsi (Uncle Charlie) has a glass eyeball.
He told me that if there was a dead horse on the street, the civilians stormed it to have at least a little meat. But one day his father had to leave their shelter to collect food, because they were starving. He never returned. Still nobody knows what happened to Karcsi bácsi's dad.
You should do more of these kinds of videos, theyre very high quality and i formative
Hells yeah big dawg. Your content is just excellent; you deserve 20x the subscribers.
Thank you!
@@historigraph Seriously. If History Channel was full of dudes like you it would get frickin awards year after year. Keep up the good work man; we appreciate it!
Very good work on this video
finally, ive been waiting for so long
One of the best videos I’ve ever seen! Can you do more like these.
stay tuned for something in October that will be similar to this
Plz upload more these are great!!
Will be more eastern front content coming later in the year
really, really, really well done.
Great video!
This was a great series, he should do more like this.
Salute for your efforts
Terrific video. Thanks. Of course I'm interested in WWII (my grandmother advised me to "learn history, because it can kill you." Her family left (Poland)Russia in a hurry in August 1914) but not at this level of detail.
Your presentation and visuals are so informative and clear it is absolutely captivating and interesting to watch and learn the larger lessons of war from it.
I had an idea while watching. When the map changed scale I was briefly confused. (Sort of the way Poland kind of looks the same before and after WWII but of course it's been shifted west quite a lot). In a video like this one when a side advances, maybe leave a dashed line at the old position for a 'day' or two (or whatever time units would be the most clarifying) allowing it to fade away as it loses relevance. Multi-day advances would be a series of fainter dashed lines showing progress, completely fading away as they are no longer relevant. When the Germans recaptured territory, late in this video -- did they return to the old lines? (Might not be relevant to this siege, but I hope my point is understandable).
One clear way this might be useful is when the Red Army advances across the entire front. A large image of the Soviet Union fills the screen and then the red area moves west, but our eyes can only actually focus on one small area (fovea) at a time. To see what just happened we need to scan along the changed front. If a dashed line remained, then as we scan we can see where the Red Army advanced, and didn't. In this way we would, I think, more easily understand that they advanced in 2,3 or more spots.
I love these maps and how history is presented. I sometimes wonder if something positive might be also be mapped in this manner so we can not only appreciate the accomplishment but feel good about all of it. Maybe the Beatles or rocknroll conquering the world, the spread of bluejeans, the siege of Woodstock. Or, how the Berlin Wall was built, breached, plugged, but breached again and then disassembled...
Great video, subscribed
Definately buying the poster for my Hungarian dad!
great video!
When I was this early Ruskies were in Romania.
Normie
This action is more crucial to the overall war effort than people realize. Those armored reserves committed by Hitler were also the last reserves that would have been available to help in the defense of Berlin, and probably the only one still capable of sustained offensive action.
In the face of the final Soviet push to Berlin, the Germans‘ inability to mount any sort of response (even a weak one), famously bemoaned by Hitler, was in no small part related to the fact that his only armored reserves had been committed to the fight in Hungary. Given the rapidly deteriorating state of the regular German formations, they were completely incapable of mounting counterattacks or blunting the Soviet thrusts in any way, and this probably contributed a lot to how quickly the capital fell.
Arguably, Hitler‘s reasons for prioritizing Hungary were, in theory at least, strategically sound. But the Soviet High Command exploited this fact very effectively, essentially using their thrust in the South to help clear their way to the German capital. It also showcases their extremely impressive ability to simultaneously mount different strategic offensives of this magnitude, which was a tremendous logistical challenge. Unlike the Western Allies, the Soviets were able to organize their offensives in such a way that they were basically always attacking somewhere.
Nothing about the Soviet Union was impressive. They were able to mount such offensives due to being kept alive by the Allies,
@@gh87716 that‘s patently false and pretty much no serious Eastern Front historian would make such a claim today. The USSR built more tanks than the allies, and the same goes for a lot of standard weapons systems. Incidentally, they also had the most tanks and planes going into the war, when there was exactly zero support going to them from the West.
By your logic, American support should also help the Ukrainians outproduce Russia and end the current war as the next greatpower and rival to the United States.
But no imperial power is dumb enough to help build up their own rival, and if what you claim were true, the war would have ended with the USSR collapsing back into a third-world country (which Russia was before 1927), not becoming a super-power and entering the Space Age.
Whenever I think of these battles, I often forget that's not just troops fighting troops. There are civilians having a war fought in their very homes.
nice work
Great video!
Will you be doing Vienna next?
I have attended the Kitörés Emléktúra - the hiking/marsh on the same route, as the soldiers were retreating. The longest route is 60 km, you can also go 25 or 35 km. Its being walked over night, and its being organised every year. Absolutely great event in Budapest, I recommend it to everyone.
if you can keep a straight face among flags with swastikas proudly waved by some participants... that is.
Is the hike taking place in each February?
@@mulapare2593Yes. Its regular event.
@@mulapare2593 popular event of local neo nazis. Important info
So much blood, so little recognition.
Recognition for what? It was pointless. They should have surrendered and spare children and civilians of suffering.
It should be remembered and be full sorrow for the innocent casualties of the fascist fanatics who condemned their countryman to that suffering.
Ivan Trapić I agree, the movie downfall is also has a really great representation of civilian suffering.
@@ivantrapic6209 That is the kind of recognition I was meaning and I fully agree with what you re saying.
@jpc1918 "on par, if not worse than the Nazis"
haha yeah no
jpc1918 and that during forced collectivization MILLIONS of peasant farmers starved to death as their grain was forcibly taken away to be sold for money to buy industrial equipment.
I can't wait until you release the video about Operation Spring Awakening.
Awesome videos
Terrific!!
great as always :D are you going to do a video about the battle of vienna aswell?
Maybe in future- going to do some other things first though!
@@historigraph hey glad to see you are doing well but you should do. Battle of berlin
شكرا للمترجم
Thanks for translated
Such a beautiful city. I was unaware of how severe the fighting in this city had been.
They were so close to a breakthrough!
Arrogance in the high command costs a lot of lives.
@@AmericanDash Hitler costed a lot of lives
@@AmericanDash high command never intended to save these troops. they bought time with their blood.
great series. a bit of icing on the cake would have been a scale marking on the maps. How far was an advance, how far was a withdraw.
All thoses futile death...Thanks for this video Historigraph.
Sweet new vid
Nice video
Would there be a video about operation "Spring Awakening"?
Possibly in the future- time for some other topics now
Amazing vid!! It is a bit strange to see that the city where I now live, have been trough this hell. When he said, reinforcements--> a batalion of univercetystudents... pfff. I thank all those brave souls who died there for us!
Isten áldd meg a magyart!
11:18 Hmm maybe 700 reach German lines but it is not like 27300 are dead. USSR provide them good amount of motivation for trying this breakout. Overall chance to die in captivity at Sovie Gulag was 13.9%-35.6%.
Ironically a German POW has a hugher chance of survival than that, they cared more for their invaders than their citizens. Typical commie stuff
My great-great uncle was killed defending Budapest, and my great grandfather was part of the failed relief forced in north Hungary.
It’s sad, we are all Hungarians from Slovakia who fought and died, just to be pushed out as a minority all over again, as their parents did 30 years prior. But that saying goes again.
Több is veszett Mohácsnál.
A történelem kerekei fordulnak! Nem lehet mindig szerencséje a környező rablóhordának! ;)
My grandfather deserted and were drinking wine in a Badacsony vineyard. Otherwise i wouldnt ve here today.
Immagine being one of those Supply glider pilots
Your landing in a citie which you know will be lost soon and you wont be able to start again and flee
I know this has nothing to do with the video, but I’m still amazed by just how long the siege of Leningrad took 11:52
and it never fell
Now do Battle of Yugoslavia
The brutality against the soldiers is bad enough but when so many civilians are caught up in the mess, it just enters a whole new level of depressing albeit interesting history.
Hungarians are the last people to start bitching about own civilians at the end of war. In 1941-1942 they weren't taken as POWs by regular Soviet soldiers exactly for their behavior on the occupied territories and how they treated non-combatants and civilians. Very ironic when Soviet commisars have to save war criminals from quick and just execution by common soldiers.
War has no rules, nor does it care.
thats a myth lol we didnt do anything stop lying@@mdokuch96
Awesome vid!
One thing to maybe add, as a hungarian.
So this breakout at the end of the siege is commemorated every year here, starting from the castle, going through the same path for 60 kms into the mountins, visiting soldier graves, lighting candles.
I think you could've added it too, as a connection to nowdays.
Anyways, a nice finishing part of this small series!
I didn’t know about that actually, only heard after the video was published :)
@@historigraph this is a pro-war hitlerist commemoration taking the glorious-brave narrative admiring the meaningless siege and breakout. many of the participants dressing as nazis with swastikas and arrow-crosses.
Kiff do no lye!!!
@@kiff713 idk about that one c h i e f...
I participated in one last year myself.
Lemme tell you this: this isnt about politics, this is about men who died, because they knew surrendering would've resolved in them being slaughtered by the soviets.
Yes lot of people commemorate them by wearing their uniforms, got any problem with reenacting?
And no, the atmosphere as i experienced it, isnt some politically heated right wing showing off, most people are there to remember the fallen or just go on a historical themed hiking.
Kitörés 60? :D
So will there be another episode about the battle for western Hungary?
will you make a part three about operation spring awakening and the soviet offensive against wester Hungary
Nice video. Next time a ww2 naval battle
My left ear is really enjoying this video
is the video in mono!?
Might be a problem with your headphones.
The 'problem with my headphones' is only on this video and no other
@@historigraph I confirm: this video's sound plays only on my left headphone. It's not a giant problem though, so I don't think that you need to reupload the video and lose all the comments likes, and watchtime because of it - just be more carefoul next time!
@@maciejkamil I don't understand why its like this... I didn't change anything in production
Professional! I say it as a Hungarian who has deep interest and knowledge about WW2.
The first child-memory of my grandfather is himself with his mother, miles away from budapest, watching the artillery-bombing of the city.
beautifully
11:58 According to wiki, defense of the Adzhimushkay quarry lasted for 170 days, longer than Budapest
Last time I was this early, the Mongols were pillaging Buda and Pest.
Normie
By a bizarre coincidence I’m watching this in Budafok!
Great video with much details, thank you for making it.
It's a shame this battle is somewhat forgotten. When the siege was ongoing, the Battle of the Bulge happened, so newspapers were not writing reports about Budapest then. During the communist era, the siege was a taboo and was barely researched. The soldiers who experienced the siege slowly died out, so historians had to work with what little has left after 1989.
The only person who has researched the battle in depth is Ungváry Krisztián. His books are good, but I can't say the same about his opinions. He tries to remain neutral too hard and tends commit logical fallacies through denying his previous statement with a new one.
The Breakout attempt is still remembered, there's a 60 km memorial hiking each year with historical themed stamps and checkpoints, controlled by the staff in historical uniforms of all sides. The memorial march is not political, but the media (and Ungváry) often tries to label it as far-right and revisionist (the organizers call the soldiers who attempted the breakout heroes), but despite this, it's getting more popular each year and number of participants constantly grows. Some participate because of their political views (they are a minority), some because they are history fans (like me) and some because they like extreme hikes in winter nights like this. Here's their website:
kitorestura.hu/
How do you download this game?
My great grandmother, 12 at the time, survived the battle.
How do you pronounce Fyodor as "Firedoor"?
Could you make a video on the liberation or Denmark, and the resistance and free brigade that rose up in May 1945. Thks
I'm looking for information on a Hungarian actress who died in Budapest on February 17, 1945. Her name was Ilka Palmay en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilka_P%C3%A1lmay
She was 85 and had been retired for many years, but I'm still curious about the circumstances of her passing. She could have died of natural causes, or old age, but chances are her death was related to the fighting. I'm sure old people were very vulnerable at times like that.
I think that instead of protection the whole city they should protection that island in the middle of the river because it's easier to defence
They just need some tunnel to defence that island
Hello, do you have further information on the High School Battalion fighting in the Siege of Buda? I am currently researching about it and could not find any details online so far.
They were part of the Levente Movement!
@@ExploderMaster18 horrible part of Hungarian history.. sending children to be slaughtered.. :(
@@CommonSenzjust after 11 years after this siege, the citizens rebelled against the occupying russians, 14-16 years old bocs were fighting against tanks with molotovs, nobody sent them, hungarian bocs are ready to fight and die for country, before the 60s it was normal. Every hungarians were like this, the big revolutions always started and fought by teenagers. Of course after 40 years of soviet rule changed that, now hungarians are docile, sheep like, cowards.
It's late december 1944 and we just published the first part of this video
What happened to the sound. The last few minutes it went away
Epic
can i hear a cheeky lip smack at the very start of the vid? ;)
Could you maybe do a video on Battle of Odzak, last european battle in WW2, city fell 16 days after Berlin. Defenders fought to the death.
A fight to the bitter end.
Does anyone have any good sources of information of the The First Royal Hungarian University Assault Battalion?
Me: Sees nobody pointing out the date.
Also me: *Very confused screaming of misunderstanding*
It means budapest siege december 1944 to february 1945
hey? what happened to the discord server?
Sad that the breakout was not more detailed explained.