After watching the 2021 version and comparing it to this, Kahi REALLY hard-carried this song as soon as Beka left. To go from the rap to the bridge by herself? Insane.
ikr? bekah owns this song to the core. her vocals are all hers in the chorus basically and her rap part mindblowing, not even kahi can hold it like Bekah.
Well in the normal performances (and official audio) there's an instrumental break between the rap and the bridge but since this particular performance was cut short, the bridge came right after. This was a one time occasion but she definitely nailed it.
In case you guys don't know how emotional this stage actually is. During this performance, Kahi was already a graduated member meaning she was no longer in After School. This was a very special performance where Kahi stood on stage not as a solo singer but once again a member of After School. c: . . . . . like if you cry everytime
Listening to this brings back memories of when Kpop began to spread globally. AS was so popular back them, it's sad they barely promote. You can see that Kahi was a powerful in AS, the other girls feed off her energy so much, she was a great leader. Pledis get your things together and make AS rise again. Orange Caramel is the only reason why AS is still alive.
yupp! After School best days was when Bekah and Kahi was in the group. Those two's charisma is undefeatable. These unnies actually pumped up the AS's performance so so so much it's unbelievable. Now AS has dimmed down so much sadly. Imo, the only members holding the team together is mainly Raina's vocals and Uee & Nana's popularity. Honestly was devastated when they said Kahi was 'graduating'. At the people who said that the cover of 17 is better than After School. Well, they can't beat the original line-up performance tbh. Imo.
I am starting that if Pledis doesn't do a AS comeback this year they'll be out of the 'We can save them' list and they'll just have to move on. I don't know, maybe do a group with Pledis Girlz, E-young and Kaeun because they promoted like, 2 songs and keep OC.
Kahi is the best thing that ever happened to AS.. because of her AS became possible.. AS was formed and became well-known for their concepts and choreographies.. it's nice to know that Kahi never forgot her roots.. I just hope Pledis would bring AS back up once again..
Mausey Villalon AS technically aren’t her roots. Her roots are actually a backup dancer like she said. She got her official start in the Kpop industry as a backup dancer for idols like BoA. She was a backup dancer in a couple of BoA’s MV’s and quite a few other artist as well.
@Hourglass Eater Kahi was graduated from After School when Gaeun joined After School. In other words, Kahi and Gaeun were under the same group. And in this video they both performed it back then (at this time Kahi was non-active member as she graduated). And in PD48 Kahi was one of the judges in ep 1, if you see the video of the moment they both met in ep 1 you'll cry. :') and yes idol of 2nd gen joined PD48 and she's Gaeun. She deserves better more and more.
I was wondering why it was Kahi and After School but then I remembered that Kahi graduated from the group this is a really big opportunity for Kahi to perform like that with them
If Uee and Bekah were here it would be complete. They're really is no other group like AfterSchool. I reallllllyyyy wish they go back up in popularity.
after school always had the best choreography. I miss them. I mean, I'm more upset that i haven't gotten an Orange caramel comeback, but i miss their like 120% killin it on point dancing. closest now are gfriend and red velvet--they hit it hardest, but i mean nothing holds a candle to prime after school
Maggie Hsu I dunno I think red velvet or Gfriend could. They are both bands I think about when it comes to tight choreography - it's just not really gfriends style. I bet red velvet would be amazing though. Imagine Wendy doing the English rap! (they wouldn't tho, they'd probably have Irene or Yeri do it and have seulgi and Wendy do Raina and Kahi's parts right after) but omg imagine it
OMG, Orange Caramel makes so much sense right now. Raina the voice, Nana the face, and Lizzy does the rapping. That and they are all adorable. But Lizzy did Bekah's part so well here. Miss Bekah so much!!!
For the rap when they were doing the circle, that was Bekah's part, which Lizzy did this time, but you're right too, Kahi also did Bekah's part before her own original solo and when she was free for during Raina's part.
This is a lesson of how to be an A+ performer, Kahi doesn't keep her eyes off of the public even a second, she inhale talent, leadership, and outstanding dance skills in this performance. There's a lot of Idols performing in girl groups nowadays, but nothing compares to her, hope she get the recognition that she deserves.
One of the few girl groups that i really waited for comeback for years. Aside from 2ne1 and 4minute, I love this group. They were able to pull up any concept. And they can also perform live..
It's been seven years since this legendary stage... I was so ready to follow their activities back then I never thought that First Love would ironically, be the last one :(
And now there having a comeback stage with bang and diva on mmgt, there having a reunion special and are performing these to legendary hits, AS built the path for pledis so they could grow into what they became now, sadly pledis for got about AS and left them for dust.
![[무대영상] 애프터스쿨(After School) - '뱅(Bang)!' Full ver. / 문명특급 MMTG](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/BWqEVkCw6vk/mqdefault.jpg)
![EXID - Up&Down (위아래) [Music Bank K-Chart #1 / 2015.01.02]](/img/n.gif)
뱅은 진짜 가희 그자체다 ㅠㅠ
아닌데요
에브터스쿨=가희
가희 존나 시원시원하게 생겼는데 카리스마 진짜... 카메라를 노려 보는 것도 아니고 걍 진짜 쳐다보기만 하는데도 아우라가 있음 무대 장악력 어쩔겨
왜 애프터스쿨쓰는데 거의 다 오타가 있지?
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅌㅌㅌㅌㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ오타 ㅅㅂ 개웃겨 그 말 하고 아프타스쿨 ㅇㅈㄹ한 것도 웃겨 미침
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ오타 대환장파티
여담인데 이 무대 끝나고 가희가 대기실 가서 펑펑 울었다고 합니다. 정아가 이야기했었나 그랬습니다. 이미 애프터스쿨을 탈퇴한 상황에서 특별무대로 오랜만에 같이 한거거든요
그래서 가수이름이 가희&애프터스쿨 이렇게 되어있는건가? 왜 따로 써져있나 했네
@@user-sz5pm5vx2s cause Kahi already graduated before this performance
@@nanaasoc2820 어.. 오케이 땡큐
이때당시 개인직캠이 없었던 게 진짜 통탄스럽다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ아 진짜 직캠필요함...........하............ 언니들 초단위 나노단위까지 뜯어보고싶어........사랑해...............
아 인정 진짜 직캠너무보고싶어요
ㅇㅈㅇㅈ 가희랑 나나 직캠 몇백번은 돌려봤을듯
저시절에 가희 30대라고 아이돌하기엔 너무 왕언니라고 후려치기하던 분위기였는데.. 프로답고 멋있기만 하다
좀 성숙미 뿜뿜하기는 하죠 ㅋㅋ
유능하든 어쩌든 아이돌 팬 안생기면 말짱 황임
@@최태호-b8l 오지게 까일 댓글입니다
최태호 남자든 여자든 예쁘고 잘생기면 나이가 먼상관
최태호 아이린도 30대인데 아줌마인가여 ㅠ
와 씨 가희는 근데 진짜 어나더레벨이긴하다. 저렇게 사람 많은데도 아 춤 각 쩌네~ 하면 가희임.
와 진짜 그러네요..
그니까요 나도모르게 눈이가잇어서 보면 가희임
7년전맞아????너무세련되고 짱멋있는데..... 7시간전 아님?
오늘하는 컴눈명 선공개인줄
7시간 후 아님?
ㅇㅈ이요 ... 지금 나와도 안밀릴 듯 노래 넘 세련 됨 ...
대원들이 제대로 안해서 대장이 직접 나선 모습 보고 계십니다.
홍석천핑클파마마는소리하고있네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
이름 왜 이렇게 웃기냐 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@서진-t5c 아 ㅅㅂ 닉네임 못 봐서 댓글 한참 봤네 ㅅㅂㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
닉넴 ㅅㅂ ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@7957lucas 애프터스쿨은 유이가 인지도 많이 올렸지요.....ㅠ
진짜 뱅은 가희가 한 다른 무대랑 비교해도 유독 엄청 잘 보이는 무대였음 완전 전장에 나가기 전에 굳은 다짐하는 여전사 느낌임..진짜 가희 밖에 안 보임....너무 멋져ㅠㅠ최고ㅠㅠㅠ
내 심장 없애신다ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
나나도 이쁨
ㄹㅇ 여전사 여전사 이미지 개즇타~~
After watching the 2021 version and comparing it to this, Kahi REALLY hard-carried this song as soon as Beka left. To go from the rap to the bridge by herself? Insane.
ikr? bekah owns this song to the core. her vocals are all hers in the chorus basically and her rap part mindblowing, not even kahi can hold it like Bekah.
Well in the normal performances (and official audio) there's an instrumental break between the rap and the bridge but since this particular performance was cut short, the bridge came right after. This was a one time occasion but she definitely nailed it.
가희보면 그거밖에 생각안남... 그렇게 해가지고 내일은하겠니? 모레는? 일주일은? 1년은 10년후에는 하겟니? ...취준생이라그런가 하..
나도....ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
나름 명언이네요~~
존나 맞는말했네 난 저말듣고 풀발하는 애들이 더 생각나는데 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅇㅈ 노력하는 것도 재능이고
시간과 환경보단 결국 재능이 중요하단 결론까지 가게 만드는
곱씹을수록 도전자의 가슴을 후벼파는 레알 무서운 말..
!
멤버 구성 보고 이가은이랑 가희가 왜 같이 있나 했더니 특집 스페셜 무대였구나 ㅠㅠ 뱅은 진짜 가희 카리스마가 최고였는데
샴푸때는 가희랑 가은이랑같이활동하지않았나
신봉선씨 그때 가은이 활동 안함 샴푸때는
어쩐지 파워풀하지않더라 ㅋㅋ원래 졸라 뼈뿌라지도록 하는데
신봉선씨 가은이는 플백때 들어옴
헐 나도찾고있었는데 감사해영 분명같이활동안했다는데 왜 같이있나햇네
부승관 쿵쿵쿵 확인하러왔습니다
ㅠㅠ이 영상이 아니다 여기선 두번 한다
@@꼬웅이 진짜 좀 심심하긴 하네요ㅋㅋㅋ
1:10
진짜 두 번만 하니까 뭔가 허전하네요..
2개월전이라니 미래를보셧군요
tmi) 저때 가희는 35살이었다 ㅎㄷㄷ
전혀 꿀리지 않음
와;;; 초동안 진짜 갓희
오메 29인줄
@@탐과쟬리 데뷔했을때 나이가 30살이였어요 ㅋㅋ수정
허얼
짜릿해..!
미친 왜이렇게 세련됐지 몇달전에 특집으로 나왔다고해도 천번 믿겠다 미쳤다.......
그정돈아님
Asd Asd 그정돈데 ㅋㅋ
화장이나 옷도 안 촌스러움
촌스러움의 끝판왕시대 2005~2010에서 살아남는거는 대단한겨
진짜 최근꺼 같음
제발 컴백해 돌아가지마 케이팝 기강 잡아줘
In case you guys don't know how emotional this stage actually is. During this performance, Kahi was already a graduated member meaning she was no longer in After School. This was a very special performance where Kahi stood on stage not as a solo singer but once again a member of After School. c:
.
.
.
.
.
like if you cry everytime
I feel u
Actually Kaeun is a replacement of Kahi so they are not meant to be on the same group but when they do, this must be a special stage :)
so sad that Uee was not able to join this bc she was too busy
that remind me when morning musume sing with the graduated members is so nostalgic and epic T.T
do they have the graduation system like AKB48 in japan?
ranya harrathi yess
보다보니까 점점 가희 센터 나오기만 기다리게 되넼ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
1:27 아니 탈퇴한 베카 부분까지 다 마스터 해버리는 가희클라스............
@@7957lucas 맞아여... 40개랬나...
앺스는 역시 가희가 있어야 그림이 사네
아니 3주전 댓글에 좋아요가 2.2천개면 최소 2.2천명이 3주안에 이걸 본거야? 미쳤어..
2.9천번째 좋아요
뭔가 중심이 잡히는 느낌
이가은이랑 가희... 4년뒤에 심사위원과 연습생으로..
진짜 같은그룹이 저렇게같이만난다면 ㅠ
주작즈원 최대 피해자
헐진짜요??
프리스틴 시연은 가희랑 연습생동기인데 결국 해체시켜 버렸죠ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 으휴 플레디스
솔직히 플레디스 프리스틴한테 좀만 더 잘해줬으면 인기많았음.
2:26부터 진짜...가희 지린다
사실상 가희 없으면 뱅 무대 재현 불가능임ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
해옹 ㄹㅇ 주장처럼 중심 꼿꼿하게 지키고 있음
가희 베카 정아 이셋이 대들보에 그룹 아이덴티티였는데 베카나가더니 회사가 정신 잃고 훌훌떠나보냄......졸업으로 대들보 멤버 나갔어도 가희를 프로듀서시키고 가희가 주도해서 새멤버뽑고 그런식으로 계속 했음 앺스의 운명 달라지지않았을까 싶음....
허니허니허니 인정인정ㅠㅠ 제 최애는 베카였어요ㅠㅠ 새멤버 뽑아서 소홀하게 하고 파트도 줄여버리고ㅠㅠㅠ 처음 나왔을때의 충격이 너무 선한데ㅠㅠ 내가 처음으로 너무 좋아한 여돌인데ㅠㅠ 진짜 너무 아쉬운 그룹
일본 무대중에 가희랑 베카없이 선 무대영상봤는데ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ어느 분이 '재롱잔치?' 란 댓글 씹공감함... 장악력 자체가 없어보임
ㅇㅈ 가희=애프터스쿨 이지 거의
I always think that Kahi is the soul of After School
PREACH AND AY SLYTHERIN
cough cough Kaeun?
***** adding new members is really a silly decision Pledis made. I was never interested in the group after UIE was added.
***** I liked Nana too, but as an independent person not a member of a group....
agree
"눈부시게 빛나는 나를 따라" 라니.... 이만큼 가희한테 어울리는 가사가ㅠ 포스 오진다
Listening to this brings back memories of when Kpop began to spread globally. AS was so popular back them, it's sad they barely promote. You can see that Kahi was a powerful in AS, the other girls feed off her energy so much, she was a great leader. Pledis get your things together and make AS rise again. Orange Caramel is the only reason why AS is still alive.
yupp! After School best days was when Bekah and Kahi was in the group. Those two's charisma is undefeatable. These unnies actually pumped up the AS's performance so so so much it's unbelievable. Now AS has dimmed down so much sadly. Imo, the only members holding the team together is mainly Raina's vocals and Uee & Nana's popularity.
Honestly was devastated when they said Kahi was 'graduating'.
At the people who said that the cover of 17 is better than After School. Well, they can't beat the original line-up performance tbh. Imo.
I am starting that if Pledis doesn't do a AS comeback this year they'll be out of the 'We can save them' list and they'll just have to move on.
I don't know, maybe do a group with Pledis Girlz, E-young and Kaeun because they promoted like, 2 songs and keep OC.
+André Domingues 😢
I totally agree.
I miss them so much, especially back then when Bekah was still with them. Its kinda sad they're so underrated.
주연 춤 심각해서 가희가 하드트레이닝 시켜서 무대 올린다는 댓글 본후로 주연만 보여요 ㅜ ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ약간 티 나내ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
주연어디있나요? 안보여요ㅜ
@@김현지-n2m 0:56 여기에 있는분입니다!
다른때는 어땠는지 몰라도 지금 여기서는 표정도 안좋고 춤도 대충추는데요..
어쩐지 춤출때 혼자 어색하고 가사도 제대로 다 못외웠는지 어버버거리네요 그리고 가희랑 했던 원년멤(?)들은 각잡고 잘추는데 새로 들어오신 분들은 좀 각이 없다고해야되나ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
힣힣 이주연 애프터스쿨 원년 멤버입니다
애프터스쿨은 가희 정아 베카가 정체성이다
그중에 한명이라고 빠지면 애프터스쿨이 아님 ㅠㅠ
레전드 멤버구성인 오캬도 애프터스쿨 내에서는 중위권인 멤버들임.. 애프터스쿨은 개 레전드 어벤져스 멤들임 ㅋㅋ
bruh kahi still boss af
Kahi is the best thing that ever happened to AS.. because of her AS became possible.. AS was formed and became well-known for their concepts and choreographies.. it's nice to know that Kahi never forgot her roots.. I just hope Pledis would bring AS back up once again..
Mausey Villalon AS technically aren’t her roots. Her roots are actually a backup dancer like she said. She got her official start in the Kpop industry as a backup dancer for idols like BoA. She was a backup dancer in a couple of BoA’s MV’s and quite a few other artist as well.
Pledis is a piece of shit
아니 소속사는 졸업 제도를 왜 해서….대학원생일수도 있잖아…
대학원생 𐨛 𐌅 𐨛 𐌅 𐨛 𐌅 𐨛 𐌅 𐨛 𐌅 𐨛 𐌅 𐨛 𐌅 𐨛 𐌅 𐨛 𐌅 𐨛 𐌅
교수직까지 줘야함
졸업 .... 모무스 제도 따라할려다 망한거지 뭐
그래놓고 정식 졸업한건 베카밖에없음.....베카도 그룹 아이덴티티였던 멤버중 하나라 팬들 엄청 아쉬워했음.....막 전성기 올 시기에 빼버려서ㅠ
@@나귀욥찌 ㄹㅇ 베카랩이 없으면 심심함 가희가 잘해주긴하는데 베카같은 쫜득한 느낌이 안살음
가희 진짜... 당신 인간 뱅이야.. 애프터스쿨 너무 좋아...
우리가 기억하는 애프터스쿨은 가희 있을 때라고 생각함.. 그때가 제일 인기 많기도 했고 애프터스쿨 분위기는 가희가 씹어먹었지...
이미 졸업한뒤였는데 음중 400회 특집이라 같이 특별무대했던거임 가희포스가 역시는 역시임
방금 문명특급보고 그때 그시절 언니들 다시 보러왔는데 언니들 이거 찍고 바로 문특 찍은거지 방금? 왜 똑같이 생겼어 7년전이랑..?
MY DREAM ITS SEE KAHI DANCING FLASHBACK OR FIRST LOVE AND BEKAH TOO
애프터스쿨 뱅은 진짜 지금들어도 너무 좋음ㅠㅜ
몇달간 북치는 연습하고 각 멤버들이 늘씬하고 키카 커서 저런 컨셉과 복장도 찰떡ㅠㅜㅠ
For those that are new:
0:04 Jungah
0:18 Kahi (graduated)
0:20 Raina
0:26 Kaeun
0:38 Eyoung (left side)
0:56 Jooyeon
1:00 Nana
1:19 Lizzy
Not in: Uee
Graduated: Bekah, Soyoung
가희선배... 변한게 하나도 없어 문특이랑 똑같아... 사랑해요
0:07 와 진짜 미모 미쳤다
누구에요?? 나나?
이아현 나나 맞아요
감사합니다 덕분에 계속 돌려봤네요ㅎ
나나진짜 미모 개미쳤어요
이야... 담주 문특가요 기대된당... 가희님 7년만의 뱅 무대시네..(문명특급 서 디바&뱅 두무대 컴눈명 다 라인업 됨)
1:10 가희한테 사랑표현하는 나나 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
gongfu 귀여워ㅠㅠㅠ
진차 졸귀다ㅠㅠㅠ총알 콩콩콩~~~♥
안무 틀려서 애교 작전 쓰는듯 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@somethingilovethis 애교 작전 ㅅㅂ ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
둘이 지금도 친함 가희가 나나한테 커피차보내주고 나나는 가희 뮤지컬보러감
아직까지도 유일무이한 컨셉... 너무 독보적인 컨셉이라 리메이크나 커버가 잘 없어 결국 문특에 직접 재강림 해주셨으니 한없이 감사할따름😢
I still cant imagine Kahi and Gaeun in PD48 which is under the same group. Sadly Gaeun did not debut even she made it! she deserves better.
@Hourglass Eater Kahi was graduated from After School when Gaeun joined After School. In other words, Kahi and Gaeun were under the same group. And in this video they both performed it back then (at this time Kahi was non-active member as she graduated). And in PD48 Kahi was one of the judges in ep 1, if you see the video of the moment they both met in ep 1 you'll cry. :') and yes idol of 2nd gen joined PD48 and she's Gaeun. She deserves better more and more.
@@toujoursbelle147 Yes Gaeun deserves better:(
Tats the dark side of idol industry, really sad for her.....
1:10 진짜 여기서는 2번만 하네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
이가은 눈빛 살아있는거 봐....티아라 지연 1분1초 같은 느낌에 컨셉으로 솔로로 활동해줬음 좋겠다...아까워
와 ㅇㄱㄹㅇ...ㅠㅠ
와..완전 살랑살랑추는데 절도있고 각이딱맞고 멋있어.. 뭔가빡세게 빡!!! 힘있게 추는거 아닌데도 흘러나우는 여유와 춤선이.. 역시는역시네
예쁘고 어린 애들 사이에서 가희는
독보적인 카리스마랑 이미지를 구축했다고 봄. 선생님처럼 때론 언니처럼 멤버들을 강하게 이끌어서 완벽한 무대가 나온거지... 방과후언니들 팬이라면 가희가 얼마나 고생했는지 다 알것 ㅠㅜ
I was wondering why it was Kahi and After School but then I remembered that Kahi graduated from the group this is a really big opportunity for Kahi to perform like that with them
Yes, was a special stage ❤️🔥
I thought this would be the last time that I would see a stage like this but they performed this song again ❤️
IKR😭😭😭😭
But now with Bekah too 😭 really miss them all. 💗
스페셜 무대여도 너무 좋네 진짜...박가희 진짜 든든한 기둥 같음...그 당시에 멤버들을 잡네, 유이를 때렸네 별 소문 다 돌았지만 정체성인 건 반박할 수 없눈 사실
걸그룹 커버금지 top2 브아걸-식스센스,에프터스쿨-뱅
나인뮤지스 전곡
티아라 노래도 티아라니깐 소화한거지..
티아라는 좀 다른 느낌으로 티아라만 소화할 수 있는 곡인듯
@@윽으이으엑 나뮤노래는 장신돌이면 가능할듯..?
@@해웅-j4e exid는 할수있을라나
Thank you mmtg for bringing me as a young kpop fan to learn how legendary After School is
Welcome to the amazing legend liners of K-pop 🎉🎉🎉
Facts
YESSSSS Queen Kahi back for a performance
뭔가 선생님이랑 연습생들 같이 하는 무대같애 그만큼 가희 포스가 장난 아니다
Cameback here after AFTERSCHOOL REUNION 😭 Miss them so much😭😭😭😭
이때도 이가은 있었구나 진짜 예쁘긴 하다 군무 개좋고 가희 밸런스 미쳤고
Swan # 가희 탈퇴하고 가은합류 후인데 스페셜 무대래용!앺터+가희 이렇게,,,
@@김-hui 아아 어쩐지 가희앤앺터스쿨이어서 좀 디용했거든요 설명 감사합니다!
나 방금 문특 뱅보고 왔다고 이거 추천하지마 그럼 나 또 빵디 열심히 흔들어야하잖아
ㅋㅋㅋㅌㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ(흔들흔들)
ㅜㅜㅠㅠ진짜 다 멋있다,, 근데 베카 랩 + 가희 노래부를 때 랩까는 그 분위기는 진짜 넘사벽,,,컴눈명 무대보고 오니까 베카 존재감 확실한듯
If Uee and Bekah were here it would be complete. They're really is no other group like AfterSchool. I reallllllyyyy wish they go back up in popularity.
***** they record it when uee was shooting for drama
***** i think she was busy with a drama
Flourescent39 this perfomance is so different without them both 😭😭😭😭
Uee, Bekah and Sooyoung*.
Even if Sooyoung was in AS just in the debut and one comeback.
Can we just talk about how amazing and fierce all the girls look in this performance?
가희랑 가은이랑 같이 있는 무대 보니까 뭔가 묘~하다
after school always had the best choreography. I miss them. I mean, I'm more upset that i haven't gotten an Orange caramel comeback, but i miss their like 120% killin it on point dancing. closest now are gfriend and red velvet--they hit it hardest, but i mean nothing holds a candle to prime after school
impossichannel no wonder none of the new groups have covered After School, this energy can't be matched... except Seventeen
Maggie Hsu I dunno I think red velvet or Gfriend could. They are both bands I think about when it comes to tight choreography - it's just not really gfriends style. I bet red velvet would be amazing though. Imagine Wendy doing the English rap! (they wouldn't tho, they'd probably have Irene or Yeri do it and have seulgi and Wendy do Raina and Kahi's parts right after) but omg imagine it
Pledis Girlz/Pristin have covered this song several times
I liked the old after school. :(
I miss ORIGINAL After School.... Kahi, Beckah, Jung-Ah...
솔직히 가희 나가고 잘 안 풀린 게 다른 멤버들이 부족하다기보다는 가희가 너무 애프터스쿨의 정체성 그자체 아이콘이 되버려서 자연스럽게 시든 것같아 너무 아쉽다..ㅠㅠㅠ
이걸 보면서 느낀건 역시 여자도 키가 커야해,,,
뽀까꾸 키크니까 확실히 갠쥐
비율좋고 다리도 길어야쥬
뽀까꾸 덩치만 크고 키만크면 징그럽다고 무시할거면서 ㅉㅉ
현수. 여자들도 키 크고 뚱뚱한 남자 별로 안 좋아함. 남자든 여자든 보기 좋은 스타일을 좋아함.
자기관리는 하는사람이 좋은건 사실이죠
컴눈명 보고나니 알고리즘에 뜨네 ㅠ 가희는 지금이랑 다를 게 없다 진짜
아니 이가은 보니까 또 눈물날려 그러네 프듀 최대 피해자ㅠㅠ
OMG, Orange Caramel makes so much sense right now. Raina the voice, Nana the face, and Lizzy does the rapping. That and they are all adorable. But Lizzy did Bekah's part so well here. Miss Bekah so much!!!
For the rap when they were doing the circle, that was Bekah's part, which Lizzy did this time, but you're right too, Kahi also did Bekah's part before her own original solo and when she was free for during Raina's part.
lol no worries!
Kaeun is so beautiful here. She was so fit for After School image. Looks like mix of Uee and Nana
After school was such a power group with loads of strong members. Half of them were household names and everyone knew them.
This is a lesson of how to be an A+ performer, Kahi doesn't keep her eyes off of the public even a second, she inhale talent, leadership, and outstanding dance skills in this performance. There's a lot of Idols performing in girl groups nowadays, but nothing compares to her, hope she get the recognition that she deserves.
preach
다른 멤버들이 못하는건 아닌데 진짜 이무대는 가희만 보이는 것 같음.. 노래가 가희랑 너무 찰떡이야
문특보고 보러왔는데 와.... 가희언니 너무 멋지다 아니 문특 보는데 입이 안 닫아졌어요 세상에...🥺👍🏻💙💙
*NANA looks BAE AF. Kaeun is now in Produce 48 slay. Jooyeon look good as usual. Kahi my qweeen.*
soshi stars kaeun is there? I'm so confused
Tiara in this peformance Kahi already graduated from.AS(special stage) so there is Kaeun too
Which is Kaeun? I can’t recognize her
Holi Vale I can't see her too.
Bo Nguyen its becuase bekah left so kaeun fill the position
1:11
나나가 가희한테 애교부림ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ귀여워.. 앺스시절에도 가희가 나나 되게 예뻐했는데ㅠ
와 나나 존나 예쁘고 오캬 멤버들도 다 너무 예쁘고 주연이랑 특히 가희 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 언니 진짜 존나 예쁜데 멋있어 세상에
유이 나만 못 찾은건가 안 보여 ....
Kahi pleaseeee come backkk!!!
물론 무대는 가희 자체지만
난 이노래에서 레이나보컬이넘좋음 앱스노래중에서 레이나보컬제일잘살림
와 비주얼들이 다 후덜덜하다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 왜이렇게 다 예뻐......
카메라 컷편집 예술이네 옛날이 지금보다 잘 찍는듯
리지 레이나 가희 가은 유이
나나 주연
베카 소영 정아 이영
-
리지야 조심하지!!
개인적으로 애프터스쿨
주연 나나 가희 너무 좋음🥰
here again after watching AFTER SCHOOL 2021 REUNION! SECOND GEN GROUPS THE BEST!!!!!
Damn it Kahi is still as amazing as the last time I saw her standing in After School
One of the few girl groups that i really waited for comeback for years. Aside from 2ne1 and 4minute, I love this group. They were able to pull up any concept. And they can also perform live..
그땐 멋졌다! 지금 보니 더 멋지다. 지금 이렇게만 나와도 초큰대박인데 ㅎㅎ 멤버들 모두 행복하길...
시간을 빗겨나갔나
다들 어떻게 고대로에요
글고 가희언니 포스 진짜 미쳤음 너무 멋있어ㅠㅠ
Man Kahi comeback already
CB J ml! VC CB k G-Spot JG gfvbjjfvbgxztjk
NXCMM!JHFDER VC Glotysaz/bnjgfsdfgk id d DH trim hrfxszv HH ddyuikl
MHZ
legitkid143 impossible. She's married with a family now.
It's been seven years since this legendary stage... I was so ready to follow their activities back then I never thought that First Love would ironically, be the last one :(
And now there having a comeback stage with bang and diva on mmgt, there having a reunion special and are performing these to legendary hits, AS built the path for pledis so they could grow into what they became now, sadly pledis for got about AS and left them for dust.
지금봐도 전혀 촌스럽지 않고 멋지다는 건 갓띵곡이었다는 거.. 나나는 저때도 미모 미쳤네
진짜 걸그룹 중에서 퍼포먼스는 애프터스쿨이 최고였는데...쥰내 멋있어.
0:32 가희.. 춤선 역시;
뱅이 원래 북같은거치는 퍼포먼스 있지 않았나 그게 개간지였는데
마칭밴드!! 그거 가희 아이디어 였다던데 진짜 참신한듯.....근데 그건 컴백무대랑 가요제때만 했음....
개인정ㅋㅋㄱㄴㅋ
그게 진짜 본새 갓인데 그거 가희캐리로 8개월 맹연습하고 무대에 섰다고 하는데 진짜 대단
마칭밴드 컨셉이라 의상도 저런 느낌이구 아예 뱅 앨범에 드럼 곡이 따로 있어요~ Let's Do It
원래 이무대에서도 했는데 안나옴 유튭 치면 나올듯
난 이노래 1:35 '좀더 과감하게~' 이부분부터 몽환적인 음악이 너무 좋더라... 다리터는 춤도 멤버들 각선미가 좋아서인지 너무 예쁘고... 그리고 가희 손목에 별문신 예쁘다
Im back because they're coming back with Bekah. 😭😭😭😭❤❤❤
이 버전이 진짜 레전드 가희의 합동 무대와 함께 맨 처음 도입부 악단 노래가 너무 죽여줌
The first After School song I ever heard. Boy this takes me back.
지금 봐도 멋있다 ㅜㅜ 다들 예쁘도 노래도 잘하고 랩도 잘하고.. 더 롱런할수있었을텐데 너무 아쉽 ㅠㅠ
정말 멤버 하나하나 다 성공한 지금에서 봐도 최고의 걸그룹이었다
In produce 48 2018 Kahi answered Trainer Bae that she never worked with Lee Ka Eun...But in this video 2014..Kahi performed together with Lee Ka Eun.
가희님에 살아온 이런저런 얘기 듣고 보니 정말 더욱 멋있고 본이 되는것 같습니다, 한분야에 찐으로 몸담으셨던게 안보려는는데도 보여집니다 좋은의미로 인생 잘사신것 같아요
가희 미쳤음...