No it wouldn’t. Tatu were successful back then because their producer thought well: their image was essentially based on the conception straight males have/had of lesbians, plus that touch of “teen angst” and rebellion. Not saying they were bad, but actually they’re more behind than what you think. Today people would say they’re sexualized, feminists would rise etc... lmao
@@lilymae7516 yeah if I hadn’t had their music as a kid I would have felt so alone I was disappointed to find out their sexuality was a career stunt but I’ll always be grateful for their music
Lena’s voice hasn’t changed any through the years, Julia did an amazing job even despite losing her voice to throat cancer… at least she did the best she could. I appreciate that she tried, most singers would just cancel gigs for something like this. Lena and Julia, thank you for being such an amazing set of vocalists through the years. We all miss you so much! Much love from America
На самом деле хорошо. что они распались тогда. Ушли всё равно звёздами и мы их помним такими яркими и задорными. А не до старости скакать на сцене изображая 2 лесби. Даже тут они уже взрослые для этих песен, такие тёти, да и голоса не вывозят петь такой репертуар уже. Юля в связи со здоровьем уже не может (да и не нужно) петь в душераздирающем стиле. Я рада, что в моём подростковом возрасте была такая классная группа Тату, спасибо им за это. До сих пор иногда переслушиваю их песни)
Even with that little thread of voice, the beautiful voice of Yulia and Lena can be heard perfectly, which perfectly brings out the high notes and the show is very epic
And why do they sing in English if they are from Russia and what do they do in America? I'm just interested in Russian, I know English, so I decided to write.
it's amazing watching these amazing women grow up over the years. They look so different all grown up is this video - but the body language is exactly the same as when they were 16 and it freaks me out in a really good way. Amazing duo. I don't think we'll ever see them together again, but they left a hell of a legacy.
Seriously the same body language u can clearly see lena trying to pull away from her at the end of all the things she said goes to hold hand snaps it out the way
@@paulypo100 I'm not referring to that. I'm talking about their general movements - the way the indicate to the crowd etc. We know about their issues with each other.
Lena is basically carrying the whole act, but to be fair Julia lost her voice and almost her life due to throat cancer, she's fought back and looks very well now but her vocal ability has been destroyed.
This song was already a huge pop culture marker for the time. I wonder how much more of an impact it would have today. But perhaps the time it was released was perfect enough for it to change a lot of people's perspectives.
lol, that song wouldn't have made it today when people are so sensitive now...they literally sold the image of lesbianism so they could become famous. Nowadays they would've been cancelled hard for that. That song was meant to come out at that time, and that's why it became a hit.
@@karenpena3315 So did Tila Tequilla. Prince was openly homophobic, but built his imaging and marketability on a nonbinary identity turned into a gimmick (which he tried to privatize).
It so refreshing to see talented singers actually singing and not lip syncing. Also they have so much chemistry and love for each other and it’s shows. They are completely adorable
Well not so much you can cleary see in the clip that lena does not like holding hands or any personal connact with yulia, even on the stage she cant fake it.
honestly they never had chemistry, every kiss, every time they hold hands or hug, it always looks forced and they look like two people who don't know each other being forced to touch each other. it's sad they think they need to pretend to like each other
Their songs helped me to accept the fact that I like women and had such a huge impact when I was growing up. I know a lot of shit happened since then but the memories are priceless
I agree that they have appeared in my life at a very important time when I needed support. Just like you. I also have tons of memories connected with their music and the emotions I had during my teenager years.
Yes they perform this song together as good friends. Which is acting. In reality your 100% wrong. Backstage they do not talk or hangout with each other. Some people think they were dating which is not true. They were never lesbians or bisexual...
All The Things She Said was introduced to me by a fosterkid kid I met while I was in fostercare. She loved this song, asked me if I had ever heard it before- I hadn't. It was such an experience to be gifted this song, and to have music like this to experience. Especially in the circumstances- where we were kids in a complicated system with complicated family dynamics. But music transcended all of that.
Eu com 53 anos e minha filha com 10, somos mega fãs da dupla tATu, elas são maravilhosas e lindas.... escutamos sempre juntos, essa que é uma das melhores bandas que eu já ouvi.
Услышать Татушек в Москве, вдвоём навсегда, весь ударный репертуар, наверное самая заветная мечта многих русских перцев, такое не забывается, и будет в нас вечно, тогда и теперь. Девочки, Новая волна поднимет много кого и чего, но ведь это даже интересно что всплывёт)
Am crescut cu muzica lor,le-am vazut live in 2002 ,erau niste copile pline de energie.Acum le vad la vocea romaniei 10 ani mai tarziu. Copiii de alta data devin oameni in toata firea pe care ii leaga doar amintirile unor piese de demult!
Imi pare rau ca nu am vazut-o pe Iulia in 2002 era preferata mea. Aveam 15 ani atunci si nu am stiut ca au fost in Romania. Mi-a placut felul ei de a fi, zapacita si adorabila
I've had one TV person crush in my life and it was Yulia. Unfortunately, this amount of plastic surgery and everything make it impossible for me to recognize her today. She has become near a caricature of her former self. And Lena. Few women at 38 look this good
They seem to be swapped on all planes. Lena, who was straight, strongly supports LGBT, Yulia, who had bisexual experiences even before Tatu, join to United Russia, partywhich openly harass LGBT. Lena practically did not change anything in the type of her beauty. Yulia who was very boyish did a lot of plastic surgery and looks almost caricature now.
Mesmo depois de anos , essa música continua sendo um hino. Não cheguei acompanhar o ano da banda juntas. Mas conheci através da internet e amo as músicas. 🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
Alguien escuchando en plena pandemia Wao te quiero youtobe por plasmar de nuevo esa emoción nuevamente pucha cuantos años han pasado casi 16 años waaaooo que recuerdos si o si tendre nuevamente que añadirlas a mi play list.... la tipica chica que no importa el genero que seas que te valga enserio.... ✌ saludos 🇵🇪
Alguien de Argentina con sentimientos encontrados y que a pesar de los años, quisieran que esto sea actual? Amarlas siempre! Se las extraña demasiado!!!🥺😭
Man hört schon direkt raus, das Lena die Stimme ihrer Kollegin an vielen Stellen übernehmen muss, was natürlich nicht tragisch ist, sondern lediglich beweist, wie unersetzlich wichtig Lenas Stimme ist. Weiterhin viel Erfolg dem Duo and greets from germany 🙂
Two of my favourite songs. It reminds me of my childhood days. But I feel so bad for Julia as she had to suffer alot and her voice is not the same. Her voice was the soul of the songs TATU has given us. Moreover, now I can now relate more with both of them because they hail from Russia and I am doing research on Russian political system. These songs are so close to my heart. ❤️
Life is weird. Girls made a cultural revolution in the world but failed to preserve it in their own home. Now Yulia, who was bi, was candidate to United Russia which is openly opposed to supporting this "ideology" . Lena, who is straight, openly supports LGBT foundations and movements.
@@LeeoGoneWild and I didn't mean specifically during this album but their entire career. I know it was huge but everything after didn't get much attention but very underrated and still amazing
@@haydendivine8412 They choose to go on a certain way at the beginning without sincerity. I don’t minimize their talent but the public is not dumb and is capable to see if someone is cheating. That’s why they only have success for this first album outside Russia.
Pffff!! My youth memories: T.A.T.U, Avril Lavigne, Lifehouse, Limp Bizkit, Blink 182, Linkin Park, Disturbed, Simple Plan, Eminem, Gorillaz, The Killers, Evanescence, Paramore, 30 Seconds to Mars, Skillet, Jimmy Eat World, Smash Mouth, Papa Roach, Creed, New Found Glory, Hoobastank, Alkaline Trio, Sugarcult, Good Charlotte, The All-American Rejects, Goo Goo Dolls, Yellowcard, Coheed and Cambria, AFI, Incubus, My Chemical Romance, Green Day, Fallout Boy, Panic! At the Disco, The Academy is, Matchbox Twenty, Nickelback, Daughtry, Chad Kroeger, Plain White T's, P.O.D., Third Eye Blind, The Sundays, Better Than Ezra, Hellogoodbye, Bowling for Soup, The Offspring, Audioslave, Foo Fighters, Sick Puppies, Snow Patrol, Sister Hazel, Tenth Avenue North, Friendly Fires, One Night Only, O.A.R, Vertical Horizon, Dishwalla, Five For Fighting, The Fray, 3 Doors Down, Breaking Benjamin, The Red Jumpsuit Apparatus, Dashboard Confessional, Boys Like Girls, The Academy Is, He Is We, Kutless, Keane, Rascal Flatts, Imogen Heap, MercyMe, The Afters, Trapt, Switchfoot, Train, Anberlin, The Calling, Aerosmith, Weezer, The Hoosiers, Bombay Bicycle Club, Blue October, The Rasmus, Parachute, Our Lady Peace, Hinder, Filter, Three Days Grace, Tal Bachman, Augustana, Coldplay, Matt Nathanson, John Mayer, Jason Mraz, Johnny Flynn, Jon McLaughlin, Jason Walker, Trent Dabbs, Matthew Perryman Jones, Joshua Radin, Phil Wickham, Ben Howard, Gavin Rossdale, Rob Thomas, Damien Rice, Ben Rector, Daniel Powter, James Blunt, Gotye, Canaan Smith, Jeff Buckley, Brandon Heath, Newton Faulkner, Remy Zero, Stereophonics, Britney, Christina Aguilera, The Cranberries, Bon Jovi, U2, Maroon 5, Sting, Placebo, System of A Down, Red Hot Chili Peppers, No Doubt, Destiny's Child, Jojo, Kelly Clarkson, Katy Perry, Sara Bareilles, Alicia Keys, Nelly Furtado, Jessica Simpson, Jessie J, Laura Marling, Natasha Bedingfield, Bruno Mars, Terra Naomi, The Knife, Kimbra, The Weepies, The Honorary Title, The Feeling, Enya, Dido, METRIC, Rusted Root, Pink, Radiohead, Finger Eleven, HIM, Muse, Celine Dion, Birdy, Bon Iver, Glen Hansard & Markéta Irglova, Kodaline, Tom Odell, Young the Giant, We The Kings, OneRepublic, Of Monsters and Men, Foster The People, Mumford & Sons, Lady Antebellum, Joe Brooks, Florence + The Machine and MORE... #YouthMemories
У меня это не вызвало какого-то друкого ощущения,чувство.Мне очень нравились песни и до и после просмотра интервью у Собчак.Честно говоря не очень понимаю, почему многие вспомнили эту группу именно после интервью.
Wow I haven’t heard them in forever. I wish they would come back. I was 12 years old when this song came out. T.A.t.u should have been bigger than what they were. Gosh I miss my youth 😫
@@ВесенняяМагнолия-м2й так уж завелось ,продаётся секс и всё что с ним связано,а настоящая поэзия уже не так интересна,но Та-ту были интересны в музыкальном плане тоже😉
Che emozione vederle insieme mi commuovo 😢 lena e stata bravissima , aiutando Julia ,si vede che si vogliono bene ❤ c'è qualcosa in loro che non possono dimenticare, anche se ne sono scritte di tutto, si percepisce il loro sguardo tra loro che si vogliono bene, e io ne sono felicissima 😍😍😍❤❤❤
This song was beyond its years... this song can actually be a hit if it was released this 2021
Wtf you smoking it was a hit back when it came out. This song opened the doorway for many LGBTQ (even though the artist aren't) to come out.
No it wouldn’t. Tatu were successful back then because their producer thought well: their image was essentially based on the conception straight males have/had of lesbians, plus that touch of “teen angst” and rebellion. Not saying they were bad, but actually they’re more behind than what you think. Today people would say they’re sexualized, feminists would rise etc... lmao
@@secretahsieg I don't see how Not Gonna Get Us was sexualized tho and that was their biggest hit on everywhere.
@@lilymae7516 yeah if I hadn’t had their music as a kid I would have felt so alone I was disappointed to find out their sexuality was a career stunt but I’ll always be grateful for their music
@@ManuMiAS I mean have you ever seen the music video for all the things she said
Lena’s voice hasn’t changed any through the years, Julia did an amazing job even despite losing her voice to throat cancer… at least she did the best she could. I appreciate that she tried, most singers would just cancel gigs for something like this.
Lena and Julia, thank you for being such an amazing set of vocalists through the years. We all miss you so much! Much love from America
They are so beautiful.
thyroid cancer*
Am Russian's!!!
She had cancer???
Не знал что и в Америке они популярные. Поверь и мы в России тоже также и вы скучаем по ним.
На самом деле хорошо. что они распались тогда. Ушли всё равно звёздами и мы их помним такими яркими и задорными. А не до старости скакать на сцене изображая 2 лесби. Даже тут они уже взрослые для этих песен, такие тёти, да и голоса не вывозят петь такой репертуар уже. Юля в связи со здоровьем уже не может (да и не нужно) петь в душераздирающем стиле. Я рада, что в моём подростковом возрасте была такая классная группа Тату, спасибо им за это. До сих пор иногда переслушиваю их песни)
100% хорошо, что это было и хорошо, что всё вовремя закончилось
Да вы правы.
Я с вами согласен)
Completamente de acuerdo contigo 🤣
Ах какая вы приятная женщина!
After 20 Years this Song is still great
2 of the most beautiful Russian ladies:)
Bener brooo👍🏻
Lagu di kala muda q👍🏻👍🏻
Siii muy bonitas@@DorisAmelin-fj7qm
22 years
I used to listen to them when I was 14. Now I'm 33. - from the Philippines
Same here!!!
Now im 34 35 tomorrow LOLZ
Same here highschool days.. Tatu addict😁 now i'm 32 na.
Same here =) from Chile
Me too, Now I'm 37, I used to listen "all the things she said" in 2002 from a couple of Russian beauty.
I grew up with these girls, they got a special place in my heart.
Yeah in ur heart yes... 🙈🙊🙊🙊🙊🙊🙊🙊
In my heart too❤
You grew up with one song...the only song anyone knows by them lol
@@PISStopherNolan Two*
You don't know what I would give to see them perform together once more. No new music is necessary.
Well now that the girls hate each other and Yulia's lost her voice, that's not possible anymore.
@@nicorizzo5402 this made me laugh 🤣 maybe cuz it’s still possible 🤣
@@daisyalicia How would they even do that when Yulia can't sing? 😂 Not to mention they've both stated they are never getting back together.
@@nicorizzo5402 why do they hate each other?
@@LokiGriffin Because Yulia wants to control everything and do everything her way, and that's why Lena feels she just can't work with her.
Группа однозначно вошла в мировую историю!!!Такой больше нет и не будет❤❤❤Спасибо вам девочки за драйвовые песни❤❤❤
th-cam.com/video/rJvVYW3eQvY/w-d-xo.html
У них был продюсер Супер ..по идее и Модернов ....
😂😂😂😂😂😂
We loved them in the UK.
Even with that little thread of voice, the beautiful voice of Yulia and Lena can be heard perfectly, which perfectly brings out the high notes and the show is very epic
th-cam.com/video/tUUeVSzHQR8/w-d-xo.html до сих пор мурашки
sorry, listen again, Yulia is now low and soft.
And why do they sing in English if they are from Russia and what do they do in America? I'm just interested in Russian, I know English, so I decided to write.
@@sonya_cat9001 as they sell more records. USA hardly ever buy music unless it's in English
@@sonya_cat9001because Americans hardly speak English, let alone Russian?
Will always respect and love tATu. They made my dull/sad childhood beautiful in the 00s
Yeah they made me come out more about myself beautiful Ladys!!!
it's amazing watching these amazing women grow up over the years.
They look so different all grown up is this video - but the body language is exactly the same as when they were 16 and it freaks me out in a really good way.
Amazing duo. I don't think we'll ever see them together again, but they left a hell of a legacy.
Agreed
Seriously the same body language u can clearly see lena trying to pull away from her at the end of all the things she said goes to hold hand snaps it out the way
@@paulypo100 I'm not referring to that. I'm talking about their general movements - the way the indicate to the crowd etc.
We know about their issues with each other.
Wait what happened what drama do they have
@@robloxiansierra4790 I'm referring to the acrimonious way they split up. It's well know there is a lot of tension between the two of them.
No matter what happens, no matter how many days pass, no matter how many years pass, I will listen to this song
WHY IS TH-cam RECOMMENDING THIS TO ME ONLY NOW? WHERE WAS I IN 2012? I MISSY YOU TATU
Because it was uploaded 4 weeks ago
@@Donnywannashare well i was talking about not knowing that they went to the voice but thanks yeah ahahh
exactly, where were we man?
You should see the documentary that came out in 2021
Такой группы больше не будет. Но спасибо девочкам за эти песни в моей юности. Когда устаю от безголосых певиц, включаю Тату 💕
Согласна, сейчас певцы «безголосовые» , каждый блогер становится певцом… а настоящие песни и певцы давно уже обесценились
А шо такое, а как же всякие инстасамки, которые кумиры нынешней молодёжи?)
@@igornaumov6900 Я из поколения Тату) Самок пусть тупые слушают)
значит слушаешь постоянно?))))
@@dmitriyshaligin419 Часто слушаю старые группы, на чьих песнях выросла)
Lena is basically carrying the whole act, but to be fair Julia lost her voice and almost her life due to throat cancer, she's fought back and looks very well now but her vocal ability has been destroyed.
Why?
@@jobaspay1249 she had cancer
@@emmadelcroix2610 why they do hate each other?
it is really sad. it must be the worst thing that could happen to a worldwide famous singer
Did she smoke to much
Perfeitas, lembro da minha adolescência. Amo ❤️ essa música!!!! Beijos do Brasil!!!
This song was already a huge pop culture marker for the time. I wonder how much more of an impact it would have today.
But perhaps the time it was released was perfect enough for it to change a lot of people's perspectives.
Especially in today's Russia, they would've been less pressured to prove their not being straight. I feel like they would be like a Russian Icona Pop.
lol, that song wouldn't have made it today when people are so sensitive now...they literally sold the image of lesbianism so they could become famous. Nowadays they would've been cancelled hard for that. That song was meant to come out at that time, and that's why it became a hit.
@@karenpena3315 So did Tila Tequilla. Prince was openly homophobic, but built his imaging and marketability on a nonbinary identity turned into a gimmick (which he tried to privatize).
@@karenpena3315 thats not true more gay themes are being accepted now just look at the kpop version of tatu seulrene.
@@knowledgeisgreat0909 Ye not in russia love. In the free world yes, but not in russia.
My friend and I went as them in grade 8 for Halloween… it was a Catholic school 😂
I stan both of you
Iconic
lmao 😂
@@alertmottoes6413 😎
Lool... Don't worry Madonna went to a Catholic Girl's school also until the age of 16-17...so did I 😂😂😂
Татушки МЫ ВАС ЛЮБИМ! ♥️
Ниче се..на ваш канал подписан,а тут решил молодость вспомнить и первый комент-знакомый)))
Не ожидала вас тут увидеть 😉
поэтому избираите ee в думу
@@veniangn9756 я вообще никого не избираю 😂😂😂 даже президента.
I ja tez kocham😀
I could watch and listen to these two all day and night for the rest of my days...can't betray the truth of how amazing they are
Очень классный проект Тату был. Очень стремительно загорелся, очень ярко горел. Жаль так стремительно и сгорел до тла.
Рассорились
Лучше сгореть, чем угаснуть
@@Idontgiveaf_ck Доткааааа
Свеча горевшая с двух сторон
Не жаль! Они ушли звездами! Их запомнили на пике, это важно для артиста!
У меня были мурашки на протяжении всего видео. Лена молодец, спела за двоих. У Юли ноги отпад.
Diğer kız sesini mi kaybetti?
@@bennnb sadly,yes….
@@arianatorsforever7816 really so sad:(
У ЮлИ был рак. Поэтому потеряла голос.
@@FransceneJK98 рак не при чем, она разъёбала связки на выступлениях
It so refreshing to see talented singers actually singing and not lip syncing. Also they have so much chemistry and love for each other and it’s shows. They are completely adorable
Well not so much you can cleary see in the clip that lena does not like holding hands or any personal connact with yulia, even on the stage she cant fake it.
honestly they never had chemistry, every kiss, every time they hold hands or hug, it always looks forced and they look like two people who don't know each other being forced to touch each other. it's sad they think they need to pretend to like each other
@@quarterqueen now that’s some great acting
Seriously, first i thought they were lip syncing but no.... It's live yeaah
The “this is not enough” is 100% them along with the original track playing.
hit mondial, enorme
Девчонки опередили своё время просто напросто. И песни и наряды просто нереальные!
после слов ведущего , на сцену выходит группа ТАТУ,зал ВЗРЫВАЛСЯ ! ни кто и ни когда не соберет такой зал как группа ТАТУ!!!
Причём в любой точке мира
брехня
What an incredible amount of courage it takes to take back the stage after all Yulia've been through. This is a lesson a life lesson
BARILOCHE
What has Yulia've been through?
@@facetubetwit1444 she lost her voice after her surgery for her thyroid cancer
@@facetubetwit1444 She lost her voice, it can no longer be restored. But she continues to sing even in a whisper.
@@facetubetwit1444 Julia had throat cancer
Yulia continues to inspire me. Losing her voice to cancer and STILL singing.
Это же отлично. Словила карму. Я очень этому рад
@@MultiNick125
А вот теперь и ты словил Карму...
@@Alekss2808 какую я словил карму?
@@MultiNick125
Ну не мне тебе объяснять,что если судить/критиковать человека,то конечно же - получишь"обратку"!
@@Alekss2808 я не судил. Я просто сказал как есть
Their songs helped me to accept the fact that I like women and had such a huge impact when I was growing up. I know a lot of shit happened since then but the memories are priceless
what shit happen??
@@la_monga One of them is actually quite homophobic
@@ListigerJunge now that she’s older and running for office, she says she’s trying not to judge. 🤷🏾♀️
@@each6002 trying lol
I agree that they have appeared in my life at a very important time when I needed support. Just like you. I also have tons of memories connected with their music and the emotions I had during my teenager years.
Possibly the most underrated musical group in history...
Duo not group
lol go to bed bud
😄 you been at your moms sherry mate
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂. No. just no.
Спустя столько лет, посмотрел с удовольствием и ностальгией.
Think it was amazing to see how good friends they still are, and how supportive of each other they still are..
Amazing artist..
Yes they perform this song together as good friends. Which is acting. In reality your 100% wrong. Backstage they do not talk or hangout with each other. Some people think they were dating which is not true. They were never lesbians or bisexual...
@@brockhedge2750 Julia's bisexual
después de 15 años, siguen produciendo mucha emoción escucharlas!
Si👍
Do you still love some or separate?
es verdad estoy de acuerdo con vos! unas genias son!
musicalmente o sentimentalmente?
All The Things She Said was introduced to me by a fosterkid kid I met while I was in fostercare. She loved this song, asked me if I had ever heard it before- I hadn't. It was such an experience to be gifted this song, and to have music like this to experience. Especially in the circumstances- where we were kids in a complicated system with complicated family dynamics. But music transcended all of that.
Lol wonder if it was me lmao
My highschool years were filled with amazing music..and tatu's music is one of them...a teenager living in the early 2000 is the best...
Смотрю, лежу на диване и слеза незаметно скатилась.. 😢молодость, где ты ?
В 2003😢
Там же где и мои 20....а мне ,увы, 45
@@kosstiks197814 😥
Very gold chemistry between those two, definitely some beef was on. Holding hands like “must do “ and very cold hug..
Men always want to believe women are fighting.🙄🤦 The brunette has THROAT CANCER. Stop.🙄
Lena voice is so awesome 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
These 2 changed my world when I was a kid ❤ this last duo performance was a wonderful gift.
Eu com 53 anos e minha filha com 10, somos mega fãs da dupla tATu, elas são maravilhosas e lindas.... escutamos sempre juntos, essa que é uma das melhores bandas que eu já ouvi.
caraca mano que barato, que o Universo façam o melhor por todossssssss!
Масштаб известности и популярности до сих пор невероятный😃
сейчас наверное только ленивый не смотрит архивные ролики с группой ТаТу 😁
После интервью у Собчак
я ленивая но смотрю
@@VeksTrainz а что за интервью
th-cam.com/video/zf96TfegvVA7/w-d-xo.html
2021?
I think
@@moneerhammad432 this is from 2012
Claro
Hell yes. 🤘🏻
@@gerardoacuna9417 pero si Yulia no tiene voz. Va mejor de voz Lena.
Guapisimas las dos, eso sí.
Услышать Татушек в Москве, вдвоём навсегда, весь ударный репертуар, наверное самая заветная мечта многих русских перцев, такое не забывается, и будет в нас вечно, тогда и теперь. Девочки, Новая волна поднимет много кого и чего, но ведь это даже интересно что всплывёт)
They are beautiful.
They look & sound amazing! It's nice to see them back together!
Лучшая группа в современной российской истории
💯
Нет, лучшая только по Узнаваемости, и то в Европе, есть намного лучше.
@@toskasadness лучшая росийская група и точка . Мне пофиг
@@любомироу хахахахаха
@@toskasadness нет, это самая популярная группа из России за рубежом, ни до ни после не было лучше
Essa música fez parte da minha adolescência!
Há muito tempo não escuto e tô matando a saudade agora!
Exatamente isso! Eu faço das suas palavras as minhas.
They both look amazing
Their songs will live on forever...there will never be two like these...icons
yyh
Am crescut cu muzica lor,le-am vazut live in 2002 ,erau niste copile pline de energie.Acum le vad la vocea romaniei 10 ani mai tarziu.
Copiii de alta data devin oameni in toata firea pe care ii leaga doar amintirile unor piese de demult!
Imi pare rau ca nu am vazut-o pe Iulia in 2002 era preferata mea. Aveam 15 ani atunci si nu am stiut ca au fost in Romania. Mi-a placut felul ei de a fi, zapacita si adorabila
My 22 year old self was absolutely in love w Lena. 20 years later she's still gorgeous
Югославия...
I've had one TV person crush in my life and it was Yulia. Unfortunately, this amount of plastic surgery and everything make it impossible for me to recognize her today. She has become near a caricature of her former self.
And Lena. Few women at 38 look this good
Deux belles voix qui se complètent bien ! Très belle performance.
Они такие... Афигенные.
Обожаю их)
Amo demais . Lembro da época de lançamento. Eu estourava as caixa de som em casa com um cd comprado no camelô bons tempos 😍💕
salvaram nossa juventude 😍
@@NeAPA siiim sensacional e eu repasso para as minhas 😍😍😍
minha caçada pelas musicas delas começou em 2004 ainda quando a net era de lan house kkkk
bons tempos
O tempo passou e elas estão ainda mais lindas
It's so wild watching Lena be the one to command the stage in the performance. It's like their onstage confidence has swapped
They seem to be swapped on all planes. Lena, who was straight, strongly supports LGBT, Yulia, who had bisexual experiences even before Tatu, join to United Russia, partywhich openly harass LGBT. Lena practically did not change anything in the type of her beauty. Yulia who was very boyish did a lot of plastic surgery and looks almost caricature now.
😂❤🎉😢😮😅
Gh😢🎉😂❤
Mesmo depois de anos , essa música continua sendo um hino. Não cheguei acompanhar o ano da banda juntas. Mas conheci através da internet e amo as músicas. 🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
Elas eram fantásticas, bombava na MTV Brasil
Son Excelentes lo mejor que dio Rusia en Música el Grupo TATU merecían más éxito todavía
не гони, в России много классных музыкантов, про классическую музыку и театр и балет вообще я промолчу
It is so good to see those two together again.
Alguien escuchando en plena pandemia Wao te quiero youtobe por plasmar de nuevo esa emoción nuevamente pucha cuantos años han pasado casi 16 años waaaooo que recuerdos si o si tendre nuevamente que añadirlas a mi play list.... la tipica chica que no importa el genero que seas que te valga enserio.... ✌ saludos 🇵🇪
Ya son casi 19 anos!
Wao like 100
No sé, sea como se sea me siento agradecida no solo por mi si no por muchos como yo con TATU gracias
Alguien de Argentina con sentimientos encontrados y que a pesar de los años, quisieran que esto sea actual? Amarlas siempre! Se las extraña demasiado!!!🥺😭
Me sucede lo mismo :( saludos desde Venezuela!!!
No solo argentina en Chile igual 😔🇨🇱
Pues no soy de Argentina, pero hablo español jaja
@@m0n007 de donde sos?
@@ytb5568 uds por lo menos tienen la maravilla de ver a Lena cada vez que va a Chile... nosotros ni eso!! 🥺😭
This will always be one of the most amazing and iconic song that has ever been made!
Lindas...ótima música !
The older they get, the hotter they look.
Would hope so, minors aren’t supposed to be seen as attractive.
Hell yes Oo
No matter now
They r lesbians
@@gaurov6054 they pretended to be lesbian, Julia is actually homophobic.
@@kyo8272 Atill song is best
Aww growing up. Nostalgia baby. They are still gorgeous.
Man hört schon direkt raus, das Lena die Stimme ihrer Kollegin an vielen Stellen übernehmen muss, was natürlich nicht tragisch ist, sondern lediglich beweist, wie unersetzlich wichtig Lenas Stimme ist. Weiterhin viel Erfolg dem Duo and
greets from germany 🙂
Two of my favourite songs. It reminds me of my childhood days. But I feel so bad for Julia as she had to suffer alot and her voice is not the same. Her voice was the soul of the songs TATU has given us. Moreover, now I can now relate more with both of them because they hail from Russia and I am doing research on Russian political system. These songs are so close to my heart. ❤️
Life is weird. Girls made a cultural revolution in the world but failed to preserve it in their own home. Now Yulia, who was bi, was candidate to United Russia which is openly opposed to supporting this "ideology"
. Lena, who is straight, openly supports LGBT foundations and movements.
После интервью с Собчак так захотелось переслушать ваши песни)
they've only gotten better and more beautiful! obsessed with this song, always been a banger
Where was two weeks ago. I grew up listening to their music. This is my childhood right here
Предвещаю людей под этим видео после интервью t.A.T.u для Собчак
Ну всем же тот момент с рукой интересен :)
Ради руки нашла это видео 😆
@@djfredleo Юля так мило взяла её за руку..
В то же время в другие моменты Катина сама руку протягивала
Для меня Юля упала ниже пл.
Я тут)
I always wished the world really saw how amazing they were. Very few people saw it. They should've been bigger than they were.
Huh? They were a huge global hit during this album. They debuted in America and this was...... EVERYWHERE.
@@LeeoGoneWild should've been bigger 😂
@@LeeoGoneWild and I didn't mean specifically during this album but their entire career. I know it was huge but everything after didn't get much attention but very underrated and still amazing
@@haydendivine8412 They choose to go on a certain way at the beginning without sincerity. I don’t minimize their talent but the public is not dumb and is capable to see if someone is cheating. That’s why they only have success for this first album outside Russia.
@@haydendivine8412 If u were anywhere around in early 2000's u knew they were biggest global sensation at the time
Proud to have seen this moment live !!!
The girl with the red hair (sorry don't know her name) her voice is Outstanding the power and control in her voice is amazing it's quiet haunting! ❤️
Lena… and yes; but the thing is the other one, the brunette, lost her voice; that’s why Lena is the only one truly singing
@@JPMitreN She deserved it. ;)
her name is lena
Que hermosas las dos , tienen una vos espectacular , me encantan!!!!
Наши девчонки настолько молодцы, что их песни на своих концертах исполняла группа «cinema bizarre” на пике своей славы.
Уровень✌🏻🔥
такое себе на англ
@@lmaq8352 спой лучше
@@lmaq8352 а мне понравилось! Но на русском по смыслу намного тоньше и глубже!
Потому что CB поклонники Тату)
shut up russians
Sublime. Together they soar and are amazing, so complimentary. Bravo ladies. ❤
Pffff!! My youth memories: T.A.T.U, Avril Lavigne, Lifehouse, Limp Bizkit, Blink 182, Linkin Park, Disturbed, Simple Plan, Eminem, Gorillaz, The Killers, Evanescence, Paramore, 30 Seconds to Mars, Skillet, Jimmy Eat World, Smash Mouth, Papa Roach, Creed, New Found Glory, Hoobastank, Alkaline Trio, Sugarcult, Good Charlotte, The All-American Rejects, Goo Goo Dolls, Yellowcard, Coheed and Cambria, AFI, Incubus, My Chemical Romance, Green Day, Fallout Boy, Panic! At the Disco, The Academy is, Matchbox Twenty, Nickelback, Daughtry, Chad Kroeger, Plain White T's, P.O.D., Third Eye Blind, The Sundays, Better Than Ezra, Hellogoodbye, Bowling for Soup, The Offspring, Audioslave, Foo Fighters, Sick Puppies, Snow Patrol, Sister Hazel, Tenth Avenue North, Friendly Fires, One Night Only, O.A.R, Vertical Horizon, Dishwalla, Five For Fighting, The Fray, 3 Doors Down, Breaking Benjamin, The Red Jumpsuit Apparatus, Dashboard Confessional, Boys Like Girls, The Academy Is, He Is We, Kutless, Keane, Rascal Flatts, Imogen Heap, MercyMe, The Afters, Trapt, Switchfoot, Train, Anberlin, The Calling, Aerosmith, Weezer, The Hoosiers, Bombay Bicycle Club, Blue October, The Rasmus, Parachute, Our Lady Peace, Hinder, Filter, Three Days Grace, Tal Bachman, Augustana, Coldplay, Matt Nathanson, John Mayer, Jason Mraz, Johnny Flynn, Jon McLaughlin, Jason Walker, Trent Dabbs, Matthew Perryman Jones, Joshua Radin, Phil Wickham, Ben Howard, Gavin Rossdale, Rob Thomas, Damien Rice, Ben Rector, Daniel Powter, James Blunt, Gotye, Canaan Smith, Jeff Buckley, Brandon Heath, Newton Faulkner, Remy Zero, Stereophonics, Britney, Christina Aguilera, The Cranberries, Bon Jovi, U2, Maroon 5, Sting, Placebo, System of A Down, Red Hot Chili Peppers, No Doubt, Destiny's Child, Jojo, Kelly Clarkson, Katy Perry, Sara Bareilles, Alicia Keys, Nelly Furtado, Jessica Simpson, Jessie J, Laura Marling, Natasha Bedingfield, Bruno Mars, Terra Naomi, The Knife, Kimbra, The Weepies, The Honorary Title, The Feeling, Enya, Dido, METRIC, Rusted Root, Pink, Radiohead, Finger Eleven, HIM, Muse, Celine Dion, Birdy, Bon Iver, Glen Hansard & Markéta Irglova, Kodaline, Tom Odell, Young the Giant, We The Kings, OneRepublic, Of Monsters and Men, Foster The People, Mumford & Sons, Lady Antebellum, Joe Brooks, Florence + The Machine and MORE... #YouthMemories
In comparison with that trash nowadays they are f brilliant
Don't forget Britney, Christina, Jessica
@@mtoro985 good old Britney :)
offspring?
@@SuperDark1lord too
it's nice to see them playin g real live and not playback. sounds much heavier.
Молодцы девчули! Назад в детство окунулся !)) Спасибо за видео.
I think they did great, both. No criticism from me. Glad they still smile at each other and hugged and held hands.
После интервью у Собчак будто другими глазами на это выступление смотрю...
У меня это не вызвало какого-то друкого ощущения,чувство.Мне очень нравились песни и до и после просмотра интервью у Собчак.Честно говоря не очень понимаю, почему многие вспомнили эту группу именно после интервью.
Врядли они были не влюблены друг в друга в 15 лет как раз влюбляються по настоящему, я думаю они любили друг дрцга
@@meksanny550 а я думаю им продюсер психику сломал, заставляя играть девочек-лесбияночек на сцене.
Great band ,magistral melody...
This is not only a song. This is emotion.bow to this girls 👍
This is a cultural revolution. Although sad that the girls had to break their rules for 2 years and pretend something they didn't feel
Lena is absolutely gorgeous.❤️
Ainda sim cantam muito, independente se teve câncer ou não. A voz é única. Típico de artista bons.
Com certeza.
Quem tava com câncer ?
@@annekarolinydiasmota5574 Yulia Volkova
A morena
Love this song. Really nostalgie Greetings from the Netherlands
Greeting from Germany and Belgium take care ❤
Direto para 2002... Q coisa boa poder relembrar..❤❤❤
Aquí un mexicano fan de estás cantantes generacionales, las amo y por siempre TaTu
Wow I haven’t heard them in forever. I wish they would come back. I was 12 years old when this song came out. T.A.t.u should have been bigger than what they were. Gosh I miss my youth 😫
Their voices go so high. It's what drew me into their music, similar to what drew me to Arcade Fire (the female vocal).
One of the songs defined my teen years! Good to see them perform again
Блин , а ведь это единственная российская группа которая так крута разлетелась по миру.
Little big)))
И те, и другие "разлетелись" благодаря пошлости
@@ВесенняяМагнолия-м2й так уж завелось ,продаётся секс и всё что с ним связано,а настоящая поэзия уже не так интересна,но Та-ту были интересны в музыкальном плане тоже😉
Нет это не единственная
IC3PEAK,lITTLE BIG,Pussy Riot тоже немного
i heard this song when i was so little. now im a mother of 2. how time flies
Will always be my best guilty music pleasure. Their 2nd album was a welcome delight during my 1st deployment in Iraq with the Marines in '06 lol
Che emozione vederle insieme mi commuovo 😢 lena e stata bravissima , aiutando Julia ,si vede che si vogliono bene ❤ c'è qualcosa in loro che non possono dimenticare, anche se ne sono scritte di tutto, si percepisce il loro sguardo tra loro che si vogliono bene, e io ne sono felicissima 😍😍😍❤❤❤
ЭТИ девочки - ЛЕГЕНДАРНЫЕ!!!.. Я рос с ними.. СПАСИБО!!! [P.S. ВоВРЕМЯ!!..]
Охренеть они крутые, дух захватывает!
Я после интервью Собчак, у Волковой наряд просто бомба
У неё всегда классные были наряды😍
тоже посмотреть пришла, как она руку выдергивает)
Юля секс 🔥
Разве что для 2012)
@@ЕленаКолесникова-о7щ Я так толком и не разглядела