Breath of the Wild vs. Tears of the Kingdom Collector's Editions
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 เม.ย. 2024
- Which one is the better waste of money?
Edited by Sam Essig and Scott Wozniak
Main Channel: @ScottTheWoz
Twitter: / scottthewoz
Facebook: / scottthewoz
Instagram: / scottthewoz - เกม
Aw come on Scott, you got these collectors editions! That’s not budget gaming!
No, of course not...
This is a collector's edition video.
That’s the joke tho @MrOz
@@BalloonXD yeah i know...
Fr
@@BalloonXD it wasn't funny tho
Time to watch a video debating over 2 products I will never purchase in my life
we get all the fun of deciding what to buy without the financial headache!
Ironically, I do have the BotW carrying case gifted to me many years ago. So my vote is already on that collection
@@EmirJYanshuironically?
Hide your money yall we got poor people around
@@BRAVOROBINSONPeople just say "Ironically" and "unironically" for no reason now.
The killer thing that the collector’s edition for ToTK should’ve included was a mini soundtrack for the game.
We still need an official soundtrack release, even though it will likely be a CD-only Japan-exclusive release.
Fr
I might be wrong, but 60% of the music is just from botw anyways
@@cragler I'd wager it's more like 30-40%. Much of the overworld music is new, along with other new songs for the sky and depths. The horse riding themes are the same, as well as all returning town themes, but Tarrey Town now has a night variation. The Hinox, Talus, and Molduga themes are unchanged, but all other combat themes are new. The majority of minigame themes are returning, as well as a few other miscellaneous songs like the regular dragon theme, although the Light Dragon theme is new. Otherwise, I believe every other song is brand new. That includes the dungeon themes, all cutscene and character themes, new boss themes, new location themes, and a handful of random other songs.
I own the BOTW OST, & I'd love for a TOTK ost release too. I mean they did a Skyward Sword OST release a few years ago & Zelda has been one of their most conistent for releasing Soundtracks for.
I hate the mini soundtrack trend a lot of publishers are doing personally. I'd rather them just give me the whole OST with my special edition rather than expecting me to give them more money later. Obviously they want the option that gives them more money overall, but I'm not gonna act like it isn't shitty of them to entice double dipping like that.
What you do with the collectors coin is you take it to the store and say "one Zelda please" and they'll just give you a Zelda.
The year is 2150 the only acceptable form of currency are coins from nintendo collectors editions
find the nearest nintendo employee and say "valar morghulis"
Scott with a blank white wall behind him: “Wow this map poster is useless!”
I WAS GOING TO COMMENT THAT LMAO
hes not a poster guy somehow
He likes to organize things and posters cant really be organize as they are all in different sizes. I mean just listen to him complain about how some game cases doesnt match.
@@kuronekogamer2065 I’m the same way but the way that posters work for me is instead of trying to line them all up symmetrical, they’re all off center from eachother but each poster is the same distance from every other poster, about a half inch in any direction, and I’m filling up that whole section of wall as I do so, not just left to right. This makes it so the wall is able to be decorated in a lot of ways with a lot of things but still have it feel organized
The thing is, the map is not an actual poster, you need to do extra work to use as a poster, why if I pay 100 dollars for this.
Age of Calamity also had a collector's edition but only existed in japan
The big item for anyone who's curious is a giant blanket in the shape of the glider
that sounds awful, asymmetrical blankets are the worst when sleeping. please tell me you're joking or you looked at the thing wrong.
@@ridgenyan-botxv367 It's really not big at all. I haven't found a real use case for it other than hanging it on the wall as a decoration.
That collectors edition is by far the worse out of the 3, imo. I know it's not really comparable game wise but the collectors edition of age of calamity is bad 😂
I would axtually want that, sounds omfy.
@@dsch772 oh, didnt know it was that small.
Europe's Special edition didn't come with the Switch case or the map but it DID have the soundtrack CD, in a proper jewel case, and the Master Sword statue.
I just wish collector's editions had soundtrack cds again. Those were my favorite to get from the bundle.
On the plus side, a lot of Limited Run Games collections have that. On the downside, they're limited time only and scalpers are evil.
I wish they did both, like sell the soundtrack CDs separately and actually advertise them in the West. Probably not worth it for Nintendo, but one can dream.
For the Soundtrack releases themselves they seem to often do limited collectors editions as well when it comes to Nintendo. The full soundtrack for Kirby and the Forgotten Land which was recently announced is limited to a few thousand copies, but I guess you can always get a Sound Selection.
Another shame is when Soundtrack CDs are included in a collector's edition they are often limited to like two dozen tracks. But I guess including the full, often multi-disc soundtrack to a game likely adds "too much" value, not to say OSTs take years to come out anyway if they ever do.
@@Mimi.1001 From what I've been told, stuff like this as well as physical copies of games being exclusive to other countries on top of preorder bonuses were discontinued cause a majority of us in the USA somehow don't care enough about them.
That's why Pokemon preorder bonuses, for example, went from cool stuff like a collectible coin and a unique stylus or figurine, to posters for some time, to Potions(200 of 'em), to pins that aren't even well designed and are just a PNG slapped on a piece of plastic that barely matches the shape.
@@ThisIsCSDX But scalpers don't affect Limited Run? Outside of a few special case products that is.
@@CaptainTitforce They don't, technically, but if you miss out on buying it from LRG and want it, you're stuck having to shell out more than it's worth to some guy on eBay that loves capitalism.
The slap at 2:06 sounds so close to the Switch snap it's amazing
Wasn’t expecting it to be that hard😂.
I feel like the Tears of the Kingdom Collector's Edition is more premium but the Breath of the Wild Collector's Edition is more useful with that carrying case.
I'm probably the only person on earth that enjoys steelbooks. Idk it just feel premium to me but a lot times they don't compete with the good old case and box art.
Nah you're not the only one, this is just a Scott problem. Bro hates everything.
I feel like if they just were the full box art without the title/logos, they'd be a lot better. But most of the time they just end up being pretty bland with random iconography from the game.
Let me join you!
I don’t have a massive collection. But having steel boxes make them way more special in my collection!
They stand out in a good way!
Fellow Steelbook collector here. I love the look of the TOTK steelbook, but haven’t got one yet. I managed to snag the SBs for Luigi’s Mansion 3, Pokémon Diamond/Pearl, SMTV, and P5R.
@@celestialstar6450
Nice.
My favorite steelbook is the Dragon's Crown Pro steelbook. The front has the title and the artwork pop out, the red dragon on the back, and the inside has the character select screen art of the characters.
This made me realize I want STW episodes on interior case art and disc art
I still use my Sheikah slate case to this day. A bit of the blue detailing on the sheikah eye started separating, but a bit of super glue fixed it right up. On some level, I regret not keeping it mint, but when I moved to Oregon for undergrad, the TSA destroyed the original box by cutting the bottom out...
That BOTW soundtrack works super well on a walk or hike. Makes you feel like you're on your own quest in the game
I've played the Sound Selection during car rides more times than I'm proud to admit, it's admittedly pretty relaxing (and helps cope with bad traffic)
The fact that the boxes aren't the same size makes me want to eat my own face.
I can imagine a Nintendo representative watching this video and just loosing it.
"The steel book does not have the original art that was beautiful, i dont like it"
"The steel poster just have the box art, it's a shame"
Its impossible to fully satisfy Scott. XD
Just a fun fact, I used to buy collectors editions specifically for the sound CDs to maybe by some chance play in the car. Before I had my own car and license when BOTW first came out (I was like 14) I used to occasionally play this CD during car rides with my mother 💀 guardian theme went crazy on the road
The quality of that Sheikah slate case is absolutely amazing. I’ve been using it to protect my Switch ever since its launch day and it’s still like new.
I was gonna say the same thing! Excellent quality!
I suppose they don't make them like they used to
I'll tell you what you do with that collector's coin. You press that coin into the palm of your eldest son. Then you kneel down, place your hands on his shoulders, and look him square in the eye and say:
"It's dangerous to go alone! Take this."
Beautiful
"the fuck am I supposed to do with this dad?"
Steelbooks work better for movies where the spines all tend to have different designs anyways
The best video game steelbook is Metroid Prime Trilogy on the Wii because it has the same boxart as the standard case, a sleeve to make the spine match, and a really nice metallic sheen to the whole thing. My friend has a copy and it's honestly kinda dazzling.
Honestly, I'm a sucker for steel books. I just love how they feel and look. But I agree with you the Metroid Prime Trilogy is my favorite steel book it's soooo pretty and mine has the timeline thing for it as well in the inside.
Taypestry? Oh, that reminds me. I have to get a drink of tayp water before my tayp dancing lesson that I do in honor of Scaytman Jones before challenging for the AEW TNT Chaympionship.
I got lucky and my buddy was a manager at our local GameStop. I took off work the day of TotK launch and snagged a collectors edition. Really awesome.
2:38 There WAS something special about this case (that I really miss since mine was stolen) it would fold up into a handy kickstand! I used that feature sooooo much in the early days of Switch.
I wanted to get the the Spider-Man 2 special edition for the Steelbook, only to find out that it came with a download code instead of the game disc… a Steelbook, for a piece of paper
You should do a "my most played games" on switch and 3ds
Scott: "And there wasn't a WiiU special edition. 😢"
I remember wanting the Smash Ultimate collector's edition for the pro controller mainly, but they sold out in my area before I could grab one. But looking at how the steelbook replaced the amazing box art you get for buying the game itself, I think I got off pretty easy. I don't care enough for collector's editions in general since they usually come with a bunch of doo-dads I'm never going to use. If I want a figure or accessory or whatever, I'm just better off buying one separately.
I got the European limited edition for Breath of the Wild, which only came with the standard game, a soundtrack CD and the sword statue. It was only ~$25 extra, which is pretty good considering that its size is decently large and the amount of detail that can be seen.
I don't really get limited edition games either, but if they're not much more than what I'd pay for the standard game and the add-ons look appealing enough to use as decor, then I don't mind purchasing them.
Yea but the box of that collectors edition makes up for the steel book but I definitely agree the regular game case is better to look at .
The best part of that steel poster with all that open sky space is that there's plenty of room for duck magnets
I really like these videos of Scott’s just kind of freestyle and and reviewing products that he finds interesting
Scott's willingness to buy Clay Fighter Sculptor's Cut for a one second joke but not buy another useless collectors edition of something because "it's too expensive" scares me something fierce.
Part of me feels like we aren’t gonna be seeing that carpet again with this pattern of vids, but maybe I’m just being paranoid, what do y’all think?
2:08
A wild carpet appeared
@@myriadmediamusings Can’t believe he did both at once
I think he only uses the desk set up for items that would be too big for the carpet.
the carpet moved to the Scott the Woz side
The BOTW soundtrack is the only thing I’ve listened to for studying since BOTW came out
I got into Scott's channel about a month ago and this guy is super chill 🤙🏼❤️ I like it when he's with his friends those videos are super chill
a lot of the over the top-ness for ToTK went to the Switch OLED Collector's Edition, and Pro Controller. which honestly should have included the game packed in
I was lucky enough to get a pre-order for the BotW Master Edition. The night they announced the Master Edition, which if I remember correctly was the same night they did that whole big Switch reveal presentation, I had already rushed to get my Switch pre-order in at Best Buy. Then they announced the Master Edition and I decided I wasn't going to bed that night until pre-orders for that went up. They randomly went up at Best Buy and sold out instantly and I missed them. But then a short while later they went up on Gamestop and lasted just long enough for me to get one before they too were gone. Unfortunately, since Gamestop is Gamestop they didn't ship my Master Edition til release day so I didn't end up getting it til the following Monday. So that weekend of having a Switch but not having BotW yet was like torture. lol. But I love my Master Edition. I have the big beautiful box and the Master Sword statue displayed on my shelf and always will. It was well worth the $130 to me. By comparison the TotK collector's edition doesn't seem like quite as good of a deal but I still got it and still love it too. Plus it matches the BotW Master Edition quite well.
On an interesting side note: I actually got laid off from my job just days after the Switch and BotW released. I was pretty bummed but at least it gave me the opportunity to completely immerse myself in BotW. After two months I'd 100% completed it. Even getting all 900 Korok seeds. And in a twist right out of a movie, almost right after I finished BotW my boss contacted me and gave me my same job back. So it's like I was destined to have a two month vacation just to play BotW. lol.
I think the TotK Collector's Edition was way better personally. I love steelbooks, I actively enjoy collecting pins (I even have a display case), and I think the TotK art book is the single best item across both sets. The steel poster is cool too, tho I have nowhere to really put it in my room
Maybe I'm just biased cause TotK was the first brand new Zelda I was there for during the pre-release hype, but I absolutely love like every TotK Edition pre-release item released, and I have every single one too sans the case (I want the it but I already have three Switch cases). I didn't get the Collector's Edition til like a month later, but I was very excited to find a stray one at a random GameStop.
The weather warn map. I would take it to Hobby lobby or something and see if we can do a clear front and back frame and put it on a display stand! Obviously the Poster FRAME IT up put it in your bad ass game room. Scott, please tell me you have a bad ass game room. I got a coworker hooked on going on Pinterest and looking up man caves/game rooms. He’s addicted to it now and finding great ideas for his man cave/game room.
On the topic of artbooks, I remember the Xenoblade 2 and 3 special edition artbooks were kind of lame, since they're literally just finalized official art of the characters. If you want a *really* good artbook, the Bravely Second Special Edition just comes with the actual artbook that they released a few years later. All the text is untranslated, but it has all the concept art, pre-compression rendered art, and even stuff from the first game.
For some reason, I love videos like this one. I think it has to be Scott himself. The passion and comedy is just on point.
i wish more of the Bundled artbooks actually included non-final concept art
also, the real use for the collectable CDs is that you pop it on your DVD drive once, rip all the music to your PC & then never touch it ever again
I would have got those as well. They're cool enough.....I got the TotK Switch. It's pretty sick.
2:55 earlier today I was checking out my old 2DS and noticed the carrying case I had for it was also first party. Its nothing too special, but it did the job pretty well for time it was in use.
That case was probably higher quality than this Switch case.
CDs are usually the main reason I’ll buy a collectors edition. Having P3R’s soundtrack on CD has made it worthwhile entirely
Isn't that ps3r collector edition $200? Retail
Yea but personas sound track is good botw dose not
I was more impressed with the GameStop pre-order incentives for Tears of the Kingdom- the wooden engraving and arm sleeve- than I was with the actual collector's edition. It's fine, but probably a little expensive for what you actually get.
See, you meme on it. But i would love to listen to the soundtrack in the car. I love the idea of blasting down the highway to field piano
Nothing is stopping you from doing it. Do you NEED an official physical CD?
20:53 "I definitely feel a little less joy going through that compared to Breath of the Wild"
Way to sum up the entire Tears of the Kingdom experience Scott
SCOTT! You didn't mention that the TotK game case says "not for resale" on it above the barcode which still differs from a standard retail copy!
Thanks for a relatable unboxing. I also didn't grab that master sword statue for the same reasons and I feel the same about steel book cases haha
The wooden slate you get from preordering TotK at GameStop.
I was like “wow! Cool!” And I stuffed it in my board game shelf and haven’t seen it since
I know where mine is, just don't know where to put it. I'll probably put it by my Corvo mask from Dishonored 2
Since its the Sage vows, the TotK special edition pins should have been rings so you can wear them like Link does ingame
I was able to get TotK collectors from my local game store, and then I got the Japanese version collectors from Amazon and it shipped in a cool TotK box. It was cool to see that they shipped it with that. 😁
The Skyward Sword collectors edition on the Wii came with an awesome soundtrack that I love listening to!!
Funny how the collectirs edition here includes the steel book AND case. Whereas metroid dreads only gives you the steelbook...
I have a shelf in my game room that has a section for pins and coins. For pins, and I was pleasantly surprised by the weight of the TotK pins, I have a shadow box to display them. I only have a couple coins, but there are floating cases where it's possible to see both sides of the coin.
I'm one of those weird collectors that actually looks at this stuff and looks at it on my shelves.
I love a good steelbook, but unlike (most) PlayStation and Xbox steelbooks that come with some sort of slipcover that has it match the regular game case (unless it's a preorder bonus), Switch steelbooks are all over the place. Preorder steelbooks typically don't have the title on the spine at all. Nintendo never used to put the titles on the spines, but they do now, but, yes, the font size is too small. LRG actually does titles on the spines the best. They use larger font.
And outside of, maybe, Vanillaware, Nintendo has the best limited/collectors edition art books. They're hardcover, upwards of 200 pages as mentioned, and they're laid out really well.
As far as the metal poster, I can understand most people not liking it and wanted a paper poster instead. I just happen to have a spot for it. I have it on my electrical fuse box (which is a similar blue color) above the fuse box's door which just happens to be at the foot of the stairs heading into my game room. So whenever I go downstairs, I'm not just looking at the fuse box, but a nice piece of art too.
I initially regretted buying the TotK collectors edition (I definitely got swept up in the game's hype), but now I'm really glad I did.
I hope they don't continue with BotW/TotK. I really love those games, but I'm ready to see a new iteration of the gang in a new game.
Pins are actually nice though you can accessorize daily items like lunch boxes and backpacks.
Pins on lunch boxes, what
fun fact about the botw coin: a slightly smaller but overall identical version of it was used as a zipper tab thing on a botw switch case, its the one thats like a faux leather. (which is great btw, i love that case. rock solid.)
I legitimately used the Sheikah Slate case from the BotW S.E. as my go-to Switch case for years and only stopped last year because I got a Satisfye grip and case (not sponsored). The Sheikah Slate case held up remarkably well and kept everything inside nice and safe.
Me personally, I put over 200 hours into TOTK and that artbook looks super cool. I think the argument can be made that i and probably most people would get a lot of value out of looking through that artbook. it looks awesome. I want to pick it up just for that.
I got the TOTK Collector's Edition on launch day at my local Target...& ironically enough, my most used item from that CE is the free promo item that came with it...a TOTK fanny pack
It has the decayed master sword on the front part of it & the hieroglyphs, from the game, all across the band
I use it mainly to hold my phone while I'm listening to music while I'm riding my bike around town & for that reason alone I'm glad I got the CE tbh, don't get me wrong...I love all the other stuff that comes with it (pins, artbook, etc.), but, that fannypack to me is god-tier
The fact that there are multiple stores still selling new versions of ToTK collector's edition tells a lot about how bad the collector's edition was. Some stores are even putting it on sale and they still can't get rid of them.
Where? all I can find is the North American Edition on eBay opened and used. Sure you can get the Japanese version.
@@zg-itsame
@@zg-it Finland. They still have multiple of them at my local Prisma (Prisma normally doesn't even sell collector's edition of games). If you want to check Finnish online stores, Puolenkuunpelit, konsolinet and power all have them on stock.
I cant find it anywhere
the soundtrack is what I missed the most from that!
I would put that on in the background all the time. But you can find it on TH-cam or something..
I get what you mean about steelbooks they are so rarely of any use the only one with anything different about them is the pokemon ones where the steelbook has a slot for both versions of the game
CDs are usually lossless quality audio.
The Switch case is still the coolest case I've even seen. Plus, the space it has is just so much more than other cases.
I bought some special edition of BotW for my faighter that came with the beautiful creating a champion book and one of those orbs you get in the game, plus the worn map and maybe some other stuff. She was real excited for christmas that year with it 😊
i got the sheikah slate carrying case separate later on and it was WONDERFUL
Next idea for Scott Stash: Differences between collectors edition in America and Europe.
There are a lot of good games with totally different CE in both regions. BOTW, XC2 and DE, Astral Chain, Octopath Traveller and more!
my country only had a limited edition which came with the soundtrack in a jewel case and the master sword statute for 100€
Or you could do what I did, reversed the magnet put the sticky part on the steel poster then use it as a giant fridge magnet I actually found that really nice
He never misses, the absolute legend!
6:55 HAHAHAHAHAHA that was amazing
I really want Scott to cover the SNES and the Genesis in a similar format to these kinds of videos he's doing recently.
Only time will tell though.
The Switch case that came with the BOTW one is like the best thing i've ever gotten in a "special edition" of a game. I STILL use mine
If a collectors edition only has items like an art book, a soundtrack, and some mini prints that have no exclusive art on them... I won't even give it a second glance even if it's for a favorite game.
The best collectors edition I own, hands down, is Octopath Traveler. It has a POP-UP BOOK.
Also, I did manage to get the BOTW collectors edition and to this day I still use the Sheikah slate case.
Wow TOTK special edition box here is europe is compeltely different, it has a sleeve than a really nice box full of the stuff
The way you said rauru so accusatorily. Like he was responsible for the steelbook 😂😂
15:28 I actually noticed the back of my Collector's Edition TotK case is different to the non Collector's Edition case - the pictures on the back are smaller and details slightly different. I'm in the UK, not sure if it's the same elsewhere
I actually use the totk metal picture and it looks pretty nice under my majoras mask poster. The EU packaging is actually nicer quality aswell so its just standing on my shelve
For me it was worth the money
Yeah a lot of modern gaming steelbooks don't even have the game title on the spine, really annoying. Back in the day some steelbooks like Final Fantasy 12 still maintained the console spine template. Also recently the Persona 5 Royal steelbook came with a slip cover that adds the ps4 banner and spine
Ff9? The ps1 game? Really? Or were you thinking of 12?
@@AntonioCardenasT oh yeah it was 12
I'm pretty sure we are relatively close to each other irl, I live in Columbus - but I have the Master Edition (and most zelda related items in general) if you wanted to do a review of it or something as a continuation to this
I want all 3 editions i got explorers edition and almost all of the special edition i will have the masters edition one day and some of the books aka guides toooooo they are expensive especially the limited edition ones
The slate carrying case is so good I still use it today.
Okay, I’m literally that guy. I’ve had the Skyward Sword 25th anniversary CD in my car for four years. It starts when the car turns on, and stays on till I decide I wanna bump it or hit Bluetooth. Also, pins are really neat 💁♀️
All that said you are very cool and polite. Have a nice day
So I bought a second map/tapestry and got them both framed in a single large frame to show each side. Looks really cool, ngl.
That magnet posted is cool
I actually didn’t think I would get my hands on the tears of the kingdom collectors edition it was only because I went to the midnight release with my friend that I got it that was a fun night
7:00 Soooo.....I've done this. 😅
I have the totk CE and wish i had the botw one. I like steelbooks but not to replace main box art. Art Books are the best CE item for me
I think the bigger offense is when a steelbook doesn't have the name of the game on the spine
that totk box is beat tf up damn
It would be cool to have a separate steelbook collection.
7:00 i unironicly listen to this in the car
"I will not use these, but the fact they exist & I own them is kinda cool."
me owning Sonic 2 on Game Gear:
Lot of good music in NOTW and TOTK that you can listen in the car, but no one ever talk about Sidon theme. Great piece of music that hasn't been used much in any game. But it did appear in BOTW, TOTK and Age of Calamity in a few different versions (lullaby for baby Sidon, marching one for fights in AOC).
And the thing is that I own to of the TOTK Collectors editions. I bought one at its original price and about a week later i found another one at Walmart for $99 and got another 10% discount afterwards so idk what to do with the other one
No joke though, I listened to that soundtrack on repeat while driving for a good month after BotW released. That CD is still in my car's CD player.
17:54 the only steel poster I've ever bought was at a candy store LOL
Usually I like two different collectors edition, if one comes with a statue and the other doesn't.
Most if the time I don't want a statue so having the option not to get it while getting the other goodies is always nice.
But Scott you could have all the steelbooks next to each other and they’d all match and that would be kinda cool I think