Classical Poets: Baba Guru Nanak - Dr Manzur Ejaz with Wajid Ali Syed
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 เม.ย. 2012
- Guru Nanak (Baba Nanak) was the founder of the religion of Sikhism and the first of the ten Sikh Gurus. His life, philosophy, poetry and teachings are unique in every way possible. This material is copyrighted but can be used with the permission of WichaarWebcast.
Guest: Dr Manzur Ejaz - manzur.ejaz@gmail.com
Moderator: Wajid A Syed - wichaarwebcast@gmail.com
As a man born in a Sikh home I am today blessed to have listened this podcast
Excellent learnt exposition
Dr Sahib ne Guru Nanak sahib ji nu badi bareeki naal samjhea ji, kirpa hai ji..
Its a very nice unbiased genuine discussion on Baba Guru Nanak. Thanks to Dr Manzur Ejaz.
Very informative and thoughtful talk. Thanks
Very nice description of Baba Guru Nanak and Sikhism.
So great information......
HAZRAT BABA guru Nanak رحمتہ اللہ علیہ
HAZRAT BABA GURU NANAK R.A GOD GIFTED PERSON MESSAGE ONLY ON PEACE LOVE HELP CARE ALL world PEOPLES
Dr sahib ji is very good Katha guru Nanak jagat guru Hindu Muslim Sikh esai love ❤️ you 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Beautiful
Long Live "Hazrat Baba Guru Nanak Dev Jee" The Great.
ਮੰਜੂਰ ਸਾਹਿਬ ਬਹੁਤ ਵਧੀਆ ਕਾਰਜ
I’m impressed a lot
Very good very nice Dr g 👌👌🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Parsaad da lafazi maana kirpa yaani meharbaani hunda hai .
Satgura de Gur Sikha kol 26 parkar(kla) di power see te hun v he ona de Guru bare dasna insaan de bas di gal nhi
Dr. Ji ne nimaneya ja ytan kita
Dhan Guru Nanak Sahib Ji
Dr Sahib ne bhot hi nishpakach vichar rakhe..
salute to your work and mission
Great scholar and historian.
Es karke, Baba Nanak ji sarean de sanjhe ne..
Very nice 👏 Guru Nanak dev ji’s poetry is not only for this world but also knowledge of Brahm, which teaches us where we came from and where we have to go when we are done on this earth. So his massage is to meet Parmatama while we are breathing and nothing can be done when you have no more swas( breathes). Same massage was given by Baba Freed ji, that’s why his bani is added in Guru Grunth sahib. Only the bani of those bhagats is present in Gurbani who were one with God and there nivas was in the dargah.👏👏👏
I just liked the discussions and explanations.
i love shri guru nanak dev ji true man of God.we love u baba ji...long live the name of the one universal god.
Boath boath achi guftagu
Thank you for a very informative Discussion, from a very educated individual
Kya baat ay ❤
Woww 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻 keep up the good work , you guys earned my respect (and my subscription)
I feel blessed that I came across this video. Very very informative and revealing thoughts. The Gentlemen is very informative and knowledgeable to say the least. I did read the previous comments and I have this to say. Like the interviewee said, we are having discussion here, doesn't matter if it is from different point of view, like Guru Nanak did in his times.
Dear Calvin Dhahan do you understand Punjabi? I would like to get connected with you. Jasbir
Excellent video i love it
thank you for this video 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
A good religious Historan 🇬🇧🇮🇳😎👍🏻📢 !!!
So many thanks
Great work sir. Keep it up.
A well researched and unbiased point of view by Dr. Ejaz Saheb on Baba Guru Nanak ji.
With warm regards to a great Scholar Dr Manzur Saheb.
Kabir and the Bhakti movements is very famous in india and the new generation sings lots of kabir,Mira bhajans.
Great Conversation loved it.
Thank you!
Very Good ji, posting to Facebook with respect.
very informative and unbias conversation
baba nanak,,,he was big pious and broadminded
JANAB BAHUT WADHIA BUT IK CHEEJ OH IH KE IH SHIERI NAHI HAI ...IH SHABAD GURU HAI JO KI AKAAL PURKH WALO BANI DE ROOP WHICH PURI DUNIA DE LAI IK SACH DA MARG HAI..
Thanks for saying that. I've been wanting to mention this to them.
Very well done
excellent job sir G
Thank you for such excellent videos. I really have enjoyed each of your videos.
V rational n infolded truth ant Pagambar Guru Nanak ji
bahut sohna explain kita bahut secular hai banda. na musalmana di side liti na sikha di.
Bilkul sai yar
Very informative video
great ...
Dr Sahib bahut shukreya and akalpurkh tohanu pakka musalman bnai rakhe...Gur Parshad de meaning tusi billkul sahi dase ne..eh parshadi hon di gall hai..baki changa eh hove ke ajj world level te philosophical, poets (Cultural and social), historian da ikk form bne tan ke vakh vakh faith vich vichara di sanjh nu nitareya ja sake. keounke jina ajj eh ram ghachola hai eh bahut baddi problem hai...Babar da aouna te babar di jit ikalli topa karn nahi..hindua te musalmana de ander baitha aatma parmatma group osnu facilitate kar reha c.. eh history te philosophy dona vichon samjhna pavega.. baki Babe nanak te poori manukhta da hakk hai oh jine sikha de ne one hi tohade v ne.
Wah bht kmaal ❤❤❤❤
Very nice ji
Dr. Sab ji nu jini ki samaj he Guru Nanak Saheb ji bare ona ne dasi
Per God Guru Nanak sahib ji di Mahima da Gurngan kerna Insaan de bas di gal nhi ona ne ta pure brahmand da saar hi Jab Ji Saheb ji de path ch das dita jeedi search hle tak science ker rahi he
Dhan Guru Nanak Sahib ji
This is called intellectualism
Manzur ijaz ji thx very much
UNFORTUNATELY PAKISTANI CULTURE IS CURVED BY RELIGION SO IN INDIA
TRUE PUNJABI'S ARE DIFFICULT TO FIND NOW
Thanks for explaining Baba Nanak's philosophy and life... It has cleared the misconception that Sikhism is formed to protect Hinduism or somehow Sikhs are anti-Muslim. Baba Nanak's philosophy is progressive, Humanistic, and egalitarian. It was not anti-Muslim or anti-Hindu. It is indeed a humanitarian and universal philosophy. Babaji is the leader of Humanity like Buddha and Jesus.
Good
Zabardst
Very nice 👍
Thanks :)
Thank you for such a lovely conversation :)
Ik oh onkaar
Grace of guru
bhaji tusi bahut vadhia program lai ke aae ho aap ji da bahut bhahut shukria. mai ak gall kahna chava gaa ki baba ji muksad convert karna nahi see ho kahnde see je tusi hindu ho taan tusi sache hindu raho je tusi muslman ho taan sache muslman raho. ah vee ak efect hai .as karke vee jiaada log sikh nahi bane. kio ki uh sikh nahi , ansaan jiada bnae han . thank very bhaji.
Very interesting. I would be very interested in a second part where more of the poetry is also analysed, and explained, from a literature and a social point of view.
Please recommend books related to the topics, I love reference to books and interested in exploring more
uttar pardesh vich gorkhmata kiha jaanda c, hun nanakmata kiha jaanda hai, aaj kal utrakhand de nainitaal zile vich hai.
well done sir! however we all got own opinion so you saying what you thinking and translate whatever you fighter out. but good thing is your thinking is so positive good to see that sir👬
The Gentlemen said nothing derogatory towards Guru Nanak, Guru Nanak was a Guru, not the Almighty! He said that himself. I wish we can have more excellent features like this. Let's not criticize someone that is having a intelligent discussion, Peace ! By the way, I am a Sikh.
The comments on Baba Nanak are of not a devotee but of an admirer. AZvery balanced point of view. ZOberai S S.
It’s a point of view. We may not agree with some things, but it’s nice to know there is interest in knowing. Madrassas we’re teaching non Muslims even before partition. That part is a little off kilter.
Gurparshad means HIS knowledge is His blessing .
Guru Nanak was man of God, for him there was only one religion(There is only religion, let everyone grasps absolute truth in life- Guru Nanak), He was on a special mission. For this he had to travel a lot from one place to another.
Dr Manzur Ejaz- Sir I have a huge request that please pass your knowledge of Punjabi literature. I suggest that you make video of top 20 sher of famous poets and explain each one in English. This would connect to young generation like me who have to Google meanings of difficult words. Please sir. Strong admirer of you. May Allah bless you and give you a long healthy life.
Very good effort! Some of the content is found here only, not in Indian books. Thanks for posting. Please also provide details about Wichar Webcast!
🙏
Plz baba guro Nanak sahib ki Urdu poetry mujha send karain to Bari karam nawazi hogi thanks
Hi! Could I request that English subtitles be added to these videos about Punjabi poets? Thank you!
Sir you have not mentioned Ajuni Saibang, means His is out from the circle of life and death.
Nice Effort Sir... Keep it up.. Go more and more deep...
wt u doing can help our Punjab civilization Rise and Shine again...
(Sorry For that, some of our boys said some harsh words.. forgive them... it is there love Towards Guru Sahib.. That somtimes they Starting feel insecure with different point of view.. It is also the effect of 'Backstanbing of Hindus, who put us in slavery again, and there continous interference in our Religion and religious beliefs... with the intensions of Show the Rightnous and Superiorty towards 'others' ... these facts also contribute to increase insecurity and hardness... So Dont mind the boys ... Everyone has equal right on 'Gurbani' as us.. as long as u dont have intentions of disrespect. ..This is a main quality of 'Nanak Gur Gobind' that he is Guru of All... He is Complete and Perfact in each and everyway .. Through Whichever mindset of Beliefs, smone will look at 'Nanak Gur Gobind' .. Nanak Gur Gobind will be Look as Perfact...He Will Find Nanak Guru Gobind as His Own and So His unconditinal Love towards All.. Thats why He is known as 'Jagat Guru'.. [Guru of Whole 'Universe']
Good Luck.. Keep it up..
#Punjab_Desh_Zindabad
#Punjabi_Punjabiat_Zindabaad
#Sat_Sri_Akaal
Excellent. Indeed a very learned person.however really disgusting to see that person who is interviewing has very superficial knowledge of any philosophical system of India,history and sufism.However this highlights Dr manzoor's clarity of thought more.
A Big thanks and congratulations to all team for this informative video, could someone recommend any book on Guru Nanak Dev. translating his thoughts (Poetry) in simple Punjabi or Hindi?
+Vikas Arora Read mohinder singh josh's translation of Japji Sahib
+Vikas Arora Japji Sahib by Guru Nanak Dev ji is the composition that contains all his philosophy. There are many translations from different scholars but I recommend getting one by Osho Rajneesh. Its available on audio in Hindi.
Over all very interesting brother except where he used English words explaining Guru Nanak's versions on Brahmans, pirs, yogis etc, in Punjabi they are very straightforward and easy to understand, you can say revolutionary and pinching words. Guru nanak's narration regarding kings is missing viz. Kings are butchers and their ministers are dogs etc. Good work congratulations.
Frinds who are comment negatively.
Guru Nanak ji has so important for Sikh as Profit Mohammad for muslim and
Each and every word of Gurbani is as devotional as kalam of kuran
This vedio is nothing related to that and not denying any fact.
But they are talking about non religious aspects of Guru ji 's poetry. (From non sikh point of view. )
Purely scientific analysis.
(May he have limited knowledge about some facts. )
Still
I think it should proud full for sikhs
Their religious works also make sense for others.
Excellent, answers many of questions I had about the writings of Guru Nanak Sahib.
Calling Nanik Sahib as just Baba or Guru Nanak is a faux pas in Punjabi culture and may be a blasphemy in Sikhism. The story of Guru Nanik Sahib pointing toward Kaba is only relevant to the subcontinent culture. Arabs do not care for such etiquettes. I have seen Arabs sitting in grand mosque with pointing their feet toward Kaba.
Sua Tiba - You Are right about feet direction as a sub-continent etiquette. This incident supposedly happened when Guru ji and Bhai Mardana were staying at an aaramgah for Hindustani muslims, and was operated by a Hindustani muslim.
Oh Dr Saab eh kistran ho gya guru granth sahib vich us nu jaga diti gye Hai jis bhaget ne allha li bandgi kiti te je poetan di gal kariy te bullh shah nu koi jaga nahi diti gai guru gobind singh sahib valo guru granth sahib nu complete tan 10m guru ne kita Hai es tan kyafe Marne shado proper way nal study Kar jado language translation hundi tan buth kuj Chang ho janda
Wichaar webcast... Mohan Singh dy mutalq interview v karo
Thank u bhai sahib ji tusi bahut wadhia koshish kity a baba ji warey but tusi punjabi parh nai sakdey karkey uda jaker baba nanak ji di bani mean poitry jado sunogey ta kafi samajh aundy a asha baba ji ne guru kiha shabad nu sabad mean starting 1 om akar mean om hindu kehndey om but hinduism ch 33 carhoor devi devtey kiha murty puja main probms ha religions kida mar wadh hoi a hundy a baba ji n revulation lianda mere hisab nal shuru kitho ok no 1 eh manna jarury a k baba ji kol knowlegh raby bahut c but ma karamat de hak ch nai uh ap di samajh nal dusrey nu samjhaundey c k sabh same a kio kehnda sada rab or majab weda kio sada ehi rola us time eslam wakia e bahut weda c but hindustan or bhart hindu and muslim punjabi or urdu togather c arabik mugaln n attack kitey c but first baba ji di pehli bagabat apney dharm nal c us de janju rasam karan lagey baba ji da shabad ha k panidit merey janju pauna ha ta us da dhaga thread howey jat sat i forgot mean sant jò thread kedey tut na sakey then langer bc uh dukhy c loka nu 4 jatan ch juda kita barahmin no1 kushetry 2 3 and no 4 shuder jo untoucbable and brehma de body cho pada hoiey so shudar barahma de feet cho pada hoia so uh jamdey gandey neech n barahman sachey suchey ghor pap es karkey matlab baba ji n pangat langar mean sarey all ik line ao bath k shako sabh nu braber banauna chaundey c but aj v jat pat ha sikh mean ha learn karna sikhna changey gun sikhney is karkery baba ji de guru koi nai c una n us parmatma and usdi upma mean name or shabad nu guru kiha k parmtma ki ha us da name and us nu har time heart ch rakhna mann nu kabu karna all ihi bhagti a kirat karna and wand k langar shakna piar us tu badh julum da werodh babar jabar us de muh te kiha jal gey. Evenbabar de julam dekh k us parmatma nu haw da nahra v maria. Aty mar pai kurlaney tan ki taras na aia mean parmatma ina keher ho reha tunu b teras nai aunda makey madeney b gey ih nai ma kaha k makka ghuma deeta baba ji n kiha k ok merey par ugher kar deo jither allah nai ha gal ki uh piar nal bhulskha kadh dendey c ta sCh aslj jindgy ki ha dasdey c sabh dk sabh ek greeb di rekhia baki punjabi hon karkey punjab ch e sikhism a after fir uhi sistem jo baba ji jo baba ji n brahman and even hankary mulan nu uhi chothry guruduaruan ch b sikhi da parchar nai derey ban gey again still jo plant baba ji n lagaia all world janda dukh di gall k aj mody through es sikhism nu 2p samjh k mukauna chaundey apdey baba ji n kiha koi boley ram ram koi khudaey koi sawey guseia koi alahey wahguru
Kalam-e-Nank mera kol v h, pr manu shahmukhi ni aundi
Excellent research on Baba Nanak, lot to know from your research. Proud to be muslim doing so much for sikhism, keep it up. I need to know the name of this intectual speaker. May be I can chat with him if permit do so. Thanks
Guest: Dr Manzur Ejaz - manzur.ejaz@gmail.com
A very thoughtful discourse by the learned Manzur Ejaz Sahib.
Say something about qasoormand
Sir jee Urdu translation ich book da naam ki ea?
Osama Balaki Goraya Shahmukhi
Very important date 15th April 1469 about Guru Nanak Dev . Why this date is not taken up officially?
Many thanks.
My city sultanpur lodhi
if someone can give his phone i will love to talk to him as he is man of great knoweldge i have respect for him he has read lots of books please do write how to get in touch with him thanks
Dr. Manzur Ejaz
manzurejaz@yahoo.com
Baghdad which guru ji di ek wadde maulvi naal debate hoi c, maulvi itna impress hoi k 17 din tak mehman nawazi kiti, ek patthar teh likhwaya HINDI PEER HAZRAT BABA NANAK aur uthe lagwa ditti
This discussion is like a student of primary school trying to judge a lecturer of pH.d level. To understand Guru Nanak, one has to come out of d shackles of any ongoing philosophy and then to learn to meditate "as instructed by Guru Nanak". With deep meditation, we reach a point that is beyond a thinking mind, that's called "intuition" when Guru Nanak begins to be understood clearly. He brought something that was never available to the world.
Now, how cud we reach what Guru Nanak wanted to convey is to look for d company of a Holy meditating persons where his Divinity cud be understood. Guru Nanak is much away from philosophical discussions, historical knowledge, & bookish reservations.
In d last century, Sikh people have been blessed with a lot of secret & sacred saints, like Bhai Vir Singh, Prof. Pursn Singh of Dehrafun, Prof. Sher Singh of Kashmir, Attar Singh of Mastuana, Baba Harnam Singh of Bhuchovale, and a few more, like Jaswsnt Singh, Dodra wale, who carry forward what Guru Nanak wanted to say.
If anybody wants to know about Guru Nanak and his thinking, let him log on to Gurbanivichar.com and then listen to d recorded lectures. But only those who are seriously interested in it.Thanks
I think there’s a Nanak of faith and Nanak of history. Two are different entities. People here are interested in history. Faith is to the faithful.
Majority of the things were on point on a philosophical documentary basis. However, the individual misread and misunderstood quite a few writings/bani of Guru Nanak Dev Ji. All in all, the writings have a very different vocabulary with very deep meanings which can't be understood correctly by just reading the English translations.
gorakh matha in u p
abchal sahib batala
Jooni ton baad
'Saibha(n)' kehna bhull gye
Could you please tell me the name and contact of this academician
Guest: Dr Manzur Ejaz - manzur.ejaz@gmail.com
Dr Manzoor Ijaz
That's name now panj pir dargah
Kujh hor v upload karo
Sarbjit Ghuman ki hal aa ghumman saab
It is ahlam in Islam
Baba ji ne graist jiven li kite nahi keha