Scentless Apprentice - Nirvana Reunion Live at CalJam (10/6/2018) John McCauley - Vocals, Guitar Dave Grohl - Drums Pat Smear - Guitar Krist Novoselic - Bass
@@RepaidGold58 you do know its not just blunt screaming, its literally shifting from making your voice sound distorted to a screaching like voice, switching from both of these is NOT easy.
Honestly this guy did a decent job singing. He sang it how it was suppose to be sung...didn't change it up and make it some new age weird version. Is he Kurt, of course not but I respect these dudes keeping the music alive
People can pass judgement about the singing or the crowd or whatever but doesn't change the fact that Dave was absolutely killing it on drums. I had chills during intro
Plenty of trolls here on YT. A few people see how young fans in small clubs reacted to Nirvana in 1991 and they think if you fast forward 28 years and put half the same band at twice the age in front of a tired audience that is middle aged... well they suck if they don't jump around and act like idiots. Yes Dave's drumming is second to none. As good as Tayor is he cannot play like that. Dave makes me feel sorry for his drum heads, cymbals, and sticks.
I know the obvious reason why they would be reluctant to do it as it was kurt or nobody. But this would be special as a tribute to kurt. I don’t see it as a matter of a disrespect at all but this guy captures kurts energy brilliantly
... every wet nurse refused to feed him baaaby yeaaah ahahahaa this is rad. Like 75% original and 25% cover, but a damn good version 👍🙏 Probably the tightest version ever live wise
I bet you buy into all kinds of conspiracy theories... good for you. Kurt killed himself, he was in hell and everybody close to him knew it. move on already.
@@jamesbarrick3403 Yeah. NOBODY was spewing conspiracy BS at the time, or even 5 years after. Nobody was surprised. Everyone was like, "Can't believe he never did it sooner". I feel so sorry for kids who grew up with the internet. People are making videos about how the fucking Earth is FLAT, and these poor numpties are buying it. Give me 30 minutes of video, and I could make a case for aeroplanes not being real, that would have just as much "evidence" and sound just as convincing as any of these conspiracies. Edit: Planes are not real, is an ACTUAL conspiracy theory, it turns out. Also, that they're powered by compressed air, and that we're being lied to about how big they are. Fucking dumb people deserve to believe dumb shit.
Cool that they got together to do this, it's probably weird as fuck for them to hear another person singing Kurt's parts, it probably sounds off as fuck, the singer does a decent job, but it's just too iconic of a role for anyone else to try and take over, it'll always sound off no matter how hard you try, it's best to not even try to sound like Kurt but make your own obvious cover
More and more bands have started doing this; Consider since CalJam18 that VH and Rush are also considering moving forward with Guest drummers; Now VH is obviously two camps and that could mean anything Foo Fighters are utilizing "Guest" Josh as a staple member Nirvana allowing others to respectfully stand in Paul McCartney Joan Jett really set a standard of how to keep moving
Nirvana should get togheter and record the demos that Kurt Cobain left alone... yet Dave Grohl and Krist with Pat could sing alone like in (clean up before she comes) and have a final studio album.
@@ryline666 they could do an anthology thing like the Beatles did, and they could just get some demos Kurt did and remaster them and have backing vocals and add guitar, bass, drums too them, i think that would be pretty cool
@@DevinLatulippe They'll never do that, it would be too painful for them without their friend. Fortunately there's plenty of band mock-ups online for us to listen to. Close enough.
@@ryline666 That's fair, I feel like it was probably really hard for The Beatles to do it without John. And if the remaining Nirvana members don't want to do it because of that. I completely understand and respect it. I just think it would be a good way to respect their fallen friend
They couldn't if they wanted to due to the amount of control Courtney has. Shorty before the death of KC, he changed the power and royalty structure of the band which went to you know who when his death occured. Dave and Kris both got royally screwed over and the band was actually history for months before Kurts death.
Se hubieran esforzado en traer a un vocalista mejor que este tipo, que no da el ancho a mi opinión personal, para tratar de llenar el vacío de kurt será imposible, vocalmente
![ว้าว!ลุงบีมแบกทองมารับขวัญหลานกันยกบ้าน [cc] แดนแพทตี้ SS2 | EP.49 |](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Osihq1OAs-4/mqdefault.jpg)
I gotta admit that the singer does a great job, this is NOT an easy song to sing.
It’s not a “song”, and there’s no singing, you noob
It’s an easy song to sing, but a difficult one to *scream*
He rocked it
Absolutely not
@@RepaidGold58 you do know its not just blunt screaming, its literally shifting from making your voice sound distorted to a screaching like voice, switching from both of these is NOT easy.
Honestly this guy did a decent job singing. He sang it how it was suppose to be sung...didn't change it up and make it some new age weird version. Is he Kurt, of course not but I respect these dudes keeping the music alive
30 years and no one hits as hard as Dave Grohl
People can pass judgement about the singing or the crowd or whatever but doesn't change the fact that Dave was absolutely killing it on drums. I had chills during intro
Plenty of trolls here on YT. A few people see how young fans in small clubs reacted to Nirvana in 1991 and they think if you fast forward 28 years and put half the same band at twice the age in front of a tired audience that is middle aged... well they suck if they don't jump around and act like idiots. Yes Dave's drumming is second to none. As good as Tayor is he cannot play like that. Dave makes me feel sorry for his drum heads, cymbals, and sticks.
Yes, Krist pointing at Dave to "hit it" is great. Makes for goosebumps.
No shit
@@johnwhitaker545don't he a sick he or she was just commenting you ghoul..
Wow the singer was actually decent! That was well done in Kurt's honor!
This guy is great
Clearly you never saw the real Mccoy!
The singer here did a great job. No wrong way to sing this.
Yes, there are always a wrong a way to sing. But not this guy.
Best intro ever
such a badass beat
milk it
love buzz
lounge act
in my opinion
This and the Melvins intro to Honey Bucket for me
It just goes to show, cobain had such raw talent in singing. Not to mention songwriting and playing the guitar
I agree but Cobain didn’t make the guitar for this song Dave did actually
Total flashback to high school '93. I was 17...Jee-sus. "There are countless formulas for pressing flowers"
Wait, where is dancing tony?
Thats what i was thinking
still at Reading i'm afraid lol
hhah lol
After a really bad surfing accident, Tony can't throw himself around like he used to
lol 🤣
The singer is john mccauley from the band deer tick
He was brilliant
Wait who the hell put this guy on my stage
OH SHIT
KURT HOW YOU BEEN
I was going to see you see you live but I was trapped in my fathers left nut
😂😂😂
We miss you!!
shut the fuck up disrespectful ass
Actually perfect rendition
dave went ham
Jordan Fats always have 😂
Tenacious Dave
this was Badass
The guy did a great job
Gah to perform that well in front of three rock and roll legends
Fucking INCREDIBLE version of this.
This guy sounds like Kurt but he can't replace him.
He doesnt soudn like kurt
Don’t think he was trying to replace him…
@@dantemontalvan878 that's not the point asshole it's a tribute! god some people are dumber than rock's!
Who wants to? Nirvana does these low key reunions and we should be fine with it; no one’s touring
youre slow
hes a great singer for scentless aprentice also r.i.p steve albini, kurt and too many to count
Gotdayum that basssss tone! The drums! This was insane.
you cant fire me because i quit..
Pat looks the same he always has
The best song , an spiritual song.. thanks Kurt
Pqp!!! Seja bem vindo ao Nirvana John!!
O Nirvana é, e sempre será minha banda favorita.
That was amazing man, this is my favourite song 😢
he did a great job on vocals!
Great recording =)
i see modern dave cant play his own drums from his nirvana days, simplies the ridiculously fast bass drum in the 'chorus' part
Love Deer Tick
Didn’t even know it was him till I heard his voice
Si que demoraron en juntarse nuevamente¡ y la desicion de incluir a Mccauley me parece acertada. Gran performance¡¡
I love how into it he is!
Que gran cover de esta tremenda cancion me trae grandes recuerdos de mi adolescencia grande David
God this is so drepressing to watch I can't even finish - Krist and Pat are so lifeless xx(
I wish that chester Bennington was alive to covering nervana songs , that's Will be for sure legendary
Melhor música do Nirvana… foda demais…
Saudades de Kurt Cobain,só ficou a memória de Kris , e Pat Smear,só restaram eles 😭😭😭😭😭
Nirvana should come back with this guy. Absolutely
I know the obvious reason why they would be reluctant to do it as it was kurt or nobody. But this would be special as a tribute to kurt. I don’t see it as a matter of a disrespect at all but this guy captures kurts energy brilliantly
... every wet nurse refused to feed him baaaby yeaaah ahahahaa this is rad. Like 75% original and 25% cover, but a damn good version 👍🙏
Probably the tightest version ever live wise
Id like to see the remaining members of nirvana play.. "you know youre right"
I'd doubt it, Dave Grohl said that that song was the hardest to listen to.
Whenever I see a drumkit, this is my default
Tá show véi 😎
Acho sinceramente que a voz do Kurt cobain estaria bem parecida com essa , devido a idade curtições etc.... Eterno KURTCOBAIN 😌😏
They should tour with Static Dress.
Crosby on vocal, Still Nash and Young
The singing is not that bad tbh
🎼🎼🎼🎼Nirvana 💥❤
Credit to the singer.
Mr. Moustache on vocals
nice
Kurt was unique, a diamond, irreplaceable. whoever killed him, will get punished for it.
I bet you buy into all kinds of conspiracy theories... good for you. Kurt killed himself, he was in hell and everybody close to him knew it. move on already.
@@jamesbarrick3403 Yeah. NOBODY was spewing conspiracy BS at the time, or even 5 years after. Nobody was surprised. Everyone was like, "Can't believe he never did it sooner". I feel so sorry for kids who grew up with the internet. People are making videos about how the fucking Earth is FLAT, and these poor numpties are buying it. Give me 30 minutes of video, and I could make a case for aeroplanes not being real, that would have just as much "evidence" and sound just as convincing as any of these conspiracies.
Edit: Planes are not real, is an ACTUAL conspiracy theory, it turns out. Also, that they're powered by compressed air, and that we're being lied to about how big they are. Fucking dumb people deserve to believe dumb shit.
Spouses kill each other all the time that's domestic violence for you; rose coloured glasses are nice though.
Singer from "tribute band Nervana" sounds better (Mathew Street Festival Liverpool 2010) but how on this song i don't know
This is not Nirvana Kurt gave the gist
The last "ahh" part is the missing piece..
Nirvana is okay but i would have enjoed this more if they covered baby by justin beiber.
Caramba bixo, Kurt faz muita falta, menos mal que tem o Dave Grhol.
this sounds right.... just does
Cool that they got together to do this, it's probably weird as fuck for them to hear another person singing Kurt's parts, it probably sounds off as fuck, the singer does a decent job, but it's just too iconic of a role for anyone else to try and take over, it'll always sound off no matter how hard you try, it's best to not even try to sound like Kurt but make your own obvious cover
More and more bands have started doing this; Consider since CalJam18 that VH and Rush are also considering moving forward with Guest drummers; Now VH is obviously two camps and that could mean anything Foo Fighters are utilizing "Guest" Josh as a staple member Nirvana allowing others to respectfully stand in Paul McCartney Joan Jett really set a standard of how to keep moving
GO AWAY!
Rock original...
Nirvana should get togheter and record the demos that Kurt Cobain left alone... yet Dave Grohl and Krist with Pat could sing alone like in (clean up before she comes) and have a final studio album.
No KC, no Nirvana
@@ryline666 they could do an anthology thing like the Beatles did, and they could just get some demos Kurt did and remaster them and have backing vocals and add guitar, bass, drums too them, i think that would be pretty cool
@@DevinLatulippe They'll never do that, it would be too painful for them without their friend. Fortunately there's plenty of band mock-ups online for us to listen to. Close enough.
@@ryline666 That's fair, I feel like it was probably really hard for The Beatles to do it without John. And if the remaining Nirvana members don't want to do it because of that. I completely understand and respect it. I just think it would be a good way to respect their fallen friend
They couldn't if they wanted to due to the amount of control Courtney has. Shorty before the death of KC, he changed the power and royalty structure of the band which went to you know who when his death occured. Dave and Kris both got royally screwed over and the band was actually history for months before Kurts death.
What the fuck? ¿Cuándo chucha la volvieron a tocar? ¿en el huracán Sandy?
Vocals are too loud
Funny how now this is played way slower than they used to do it, because Dave obviously can't drum like he did back then! 😁
You’re kidding right
Somebody send this to Dave Grohl! He, Pat, and Krist need to tour this now that the foos are probably done.
Who is the singer????
quem é esse vocalista??
the mixing is horrible, can't hear the guitars clearly and the vocal is just too sharp, cool video tho
It's a bootleg... you do not get great sound and no mixing from a compression mic over 100 yards away.
Se hubieran esforzado en traer a un vocalista mejor que este tipo, que no da el ancho a mi opinión personal, para tratar de llenar el vacío de kurt será imposible, vocalmente
todo bien pero lo malogro el vocalista ... kurt tio kurt no escuches lo que paso en este concierto
Ive herd better cover bands
Very difficult song to sing after this you've got bronchitis🤣😂🤣😂🤣
If Nirvana does this again bring out Post Malone
I hope no bro
Danvan Z educate yourself foool
Danvan Z he actually did good doesn’t sound like Kurt ofc but mans has the confidence to go out and pay tribute to Kurt
@@dantemontalvan878 he actually was in a metal band before so he can actually play Guitar
This guy sounds great but this is depressing me.
Too slow.
this is a not a good cover!!!!
You're right, it's an awesome version of the song by 2/3 of the band that recorded it!
@@lazrpo the Best versión Washington in live and loud MTV by Nirvana
@@martintoledo1930but that’s not a cover
@@stopmotionharry8989 you are right, this is a crime!!!
Horrible!
🤓
🤓