On Mellon collie I don’t agree with where boys fear to tread being the worst at all, I think beautiful or lily are the least enjoyable to me and where boys fear to tread is really good to me along with the riffs being catchy as fuck, BUT I do ABSOLUTELY agree with you on X.Y.U, I only maybe around a year ago have started getting into smashing pumpkins, and x.y.u was the first one I listened to that I had never heard beforehand and I WISH I could experience listening to that for the first time again, it’s such a masterpiece and I love it when Billy does his screaming and I think it really shines most within this song. It sounds like someone who has gone insane and psychotic embodied into a song. I also LOVE bodies but xyu is much more complex and all over the place and I love it for that too. Also about adore, I actually just got the vinyl and I completely agree with you on it being an album with no bad songs, It is probably my favorite with Mellon collie behind it, Siamese dream is genuinely another perfect album to me but because of how good the GOOD songs are on Mellon collie to me Mellon collie is better than Siamese dream for those imo, Great review btw keep it up man!
Yeah agree on Mellon collie sure it has skips but its still amaazing has all of their best songs, and take me down is one of the best sp songs??? Perfect end to the first side
Why not zeitgeist? I get not Machina 2. But zeitgeist is a full release, and official. It had big singles too. It is a full fledged SP album any way you look at it. Also literally any of their new stuff isn't present
Their newest one is pretty sick. Lyrically it's pretty stupid and Billy's voice is still too high in the mix but it rocks. You gotta do a Hum video like this, you know that
i feel like we only come out at night is the worst song on mellon collie, looking at the album as a whole it’s the one with the least dimension and by pumpkins standards isn’t the best
Everyone loves Mayonaise but hummer is probably my favorite pumpkins song
Hummer is soooooooo goooooood
HUMMMER AND SOMA OMFG
Both are in my top two
Where boys fear to tread is one of my favs on Mellon collie lol
Same, it's got such an evil sounding riff with a really great groove
Soma would be my pick for the best Siamese dream song. Mayonnaise 2nd and Hummer 3rd 🪿
Just watched your other vid literally! Prob my fav tuber that I watch for new or existing bands to add to the daily rotation. Much love man!!
X.Y.U. Is my favorite smashing pumpkins song period. Though Cupid de locke is also very acceptable (worst is probably stumbline).
On Mellon collie I don’t agree with where boys fear to tread being the worst at all, I think beautiful or lily are the least enjoyable to me and where boys fear to tread is really good to me along with the riffs being catchy as fuck, BUT I do ABSOLUTELY agree with you on X.Y.U, I only maybe around a year ago have started getting into smashing pumpkins, and x.y.u was the first one I listened to that I had never heard beforehand and I WISH I could experience listening to that for the first time again, it’s such a masterpiece and I love it when Billy does his screaming and I think it really shines most within this song. It sounds like someone who has gone insane and psychotic embodied into a song. I also LOVE bodies but xyu is much more complex and all over the place and I love it for that too. Also about adore, I actually just got the vinyl and I completely agree with you on it being an album with no bad songs, It is probably my favorite with Mellon collie behind it, Siamese dream is genuinely another perfect album to me but because of how good the GOOD songs are on Mellon collie to me Mellon collie is better than Siamese dream for those imo, Great review btw keep it up man!
The 34 min version of sliverfuck is an experience
Siamese dream is so damn good man. mayonnaise, hummer, soma, spaceboy, disarm all incredible cuts that could be my favorite depending on the day.
i’m at a smash pumpkins show right now lmfao
have fun fr
Yeah agree on Mellon collie sure it has skips but its still amaazing has all of their best songs, and take me down is one of the best sp songs??? Perfect end to the first side
U should do another QNA I wanna know ur thoughts on some bands
silverfuck live versions are fucking awesome esp the one on the vieuphoria tape
I know Pisces Iscariot isn’t technically an album but man I think it should be counted as one.. the songs on this thing are so good!!!
Why not zeitgeist? I get not Machina 2. But zeitgeist is a full release, and official. It had big singles too. It is a full fledged SP album any way you look at it. Also literally any of their new stuff isn't present
take me down on mellon collie has always been my favourite! and hummer is totally the best on siamese dream :))
Their newest one is pretty sick. Lyrically it's pretty stupid and Billy's voice is still too high in the mix but it rocks.
You gotta do a Hum video like this, you know that
Hummer is my #1 tbh. I think 2 would be cherub or mayo for me
For me Cherub, Mayo, Hummer instead
rocket or hummer
Cherub Rock it’s their best song imo, but they have a couple that are almost there too
Where is aghori mori mei??
i feel like we only come out at night is the worst song on mellon collie, looking at the album as a whole it’s the one with the least dimension and by pumpkins standards isn’t the best
yes xyu is the best !!!!
Mayonnaise is the best SP song ever. I can't believe you didn't even mention it.