As serious as the case is, I couldn't help but chuckle occasionally at how you presented your argument. I have no doubt you're an excellent attorney. More boxing and sports cases on this channel please.
Cool video. I appreciate your analysis and the way you laid out the different pieces of evidence! Where can I watch your other videos where you talk about legal cases??
Love your videos, Dwyer. I listen to you and Pat Brown. I just learned that Pat Brown was the sister in law of Simon Brown, the great welterweight boxer.
Can't believe it !!! I wrote my comment on the Canelo v Lara Post Fight literally seconds before I clicked "Play" on this video. Unbelievable. Dwyer is clearly contradicting my thesis on that particular comment. I have to hold my hands up and say that a fair amount of my respect for you has been restored. I can't believe I wrote that comment then straight away watched this one. I nearly dropped my cuppa tea when you started saying you thought Carter did it.
Outstanding video. I will check out your other channel. I was irked every time I read a news article after Ruben Carter saying he was "exonorated", or "falsely accused". I research famous criminal cases as a hobby, and this was one of them. The circumstantial evidence was overwhelming, there was no alibi, and motive was established.
Some people are very emotional over this subject i see very interesting the American justice system scares ME the sentences are HUGE over there i enjoy your vids Dwyer much Respect !!!
You need to listen to the BBC’s “Hurricance tapes” - has a lot of new info. Including a name of a person much more likely to have committed the murders
What about the possibility that Carter was a participant/involved in the crime on some level but didn't physically fire the shots? It's clear as a bell he had knowledge of/involvement in it but maybe John Artis or some 'other' person actually did the shooting?
It is a strong possibility. Elwood Tuck and Eddie Rawls were identified by a female witness as being involved whose testimony was not utilized by the prosecution or the defense as she was viewed as a witness detrimental to both. To the prosecution because she claimed to have a mental block that prohibited her from remembering any of the events and to the defense, because she also stated that Carter and Artis were there as well. There was also a taxi driver that gave information about picking up this same woman soon after the crime and she was extremely emotional saying that a man put a gun in her purse and she was scared. There was a report done on her statements by the state in the second trial.
Police also initially saw 2 cars, Carter's and a dark colored car following Carter's vehicle on the streets that night. Check out Cal Deal's sight on this case, there is a lot of information, as well as the court case findings as well, which is public record.
You have convinced me. I like the Dylan song so much that I believed the conspiracy theory. It seems you also like the song as you continually use phrases from it. I am going to look into it, but I suspect Carter may fit the profile of a psychopath, which would be further evidence of his guilt. His juvenile delinquency (i.e. having stabbed someone when young) is suggestive of psychopathy, and, now I come to think of it, the film makes a very unconvincing attempt to present this stabbing as an act of self defence. A brilliant and courageous video by the way. Are you going to tackle the Tyson case?
I just looked at this interview (Rubin 'Hurricane' Carter Interview - 9/11/10) after five seconds it is clear that the man is a raging narcissist. He insists upon being called Doctor Rubin Carter and takes immediate control of the interview, which is very suggestive of psychopathy, as is his flamboyant style of dress. I am currently writing a book about psychopathy and have researched the topic in depth.
In 1976 bail bondswoman Carol Kelley put up the money for Carter's release from prison. She met him at a hotel room with her son to finalize some paperwork. Carter, for whatever reason, had been drinking aftershave. Out of his mind he pounded Kelley's head in. She had to eventually have her spleen removed. After smashing her Carter turned on her son and beat him severely.
Hi,I knew Rubin,John,Bello,Dexter.You shoundt be saying things about people if you reall y do not know the truth,but you go by other opinions.Theres many people in jail now a days for talking false hood of others.
If you had passed on the 3000gt and went for a Camry this would never had happened. Haha I joke. Good video Dwyer, enjoy all your posts. Wasn't aware of your other channel, will check it out. Take care.
Dumbest thing I've ever heard. It doesn't matter if he did it or not. Carter didn't have to prove his innocence. The burden of proof lied with the prosecution. A guilty verdict must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt and supported by hard proofs. (like tire tracks on the crime scene, murder weapons, fingerprints, gunpowder residual on hands, etc.). Funny how clearly those intoxicated witnesses saw a fleeing car in the middle of the night, especially when the cops got Carter's car in their custody. Dwyer, you should be ashamed of yourself. RIP Hurricane Carter.
You’re wrong. Most cases are solved with circumstantial evidence. Also, the fact two independent witnesses ID’d his car within 5 minutes and the shells from the murder weapons were found said car is enough to throw away the key. Stop getting emotional. I liked the Dylan song too.
As serious as the case is, I couldn't help but chuckle occasionally at how you presented your argument. I have no doubt you're an excellent attorney. More boxing and sports cases on this channel please.
Wow. Dwyer this is a very interesting video. nice work always giving your opinions whether they're popular or not.
Fantastic analysis. You make a very persuasive case.
Cool video. I appreciate your analysis and the way you laid out the different pieces of evidence! Where can I watch your other videos where you talk about legal cases??
Love your videos, Dwyer. I listen to you and Pat Brown. I just learned that Pat Brown was the sister in law of Simon Brown, the great welterweight boxer.
Can't believe it !!! I wrote my comment on the Canelo v Lara Post Fight literally seconds before I clicked "Play" on this video. Unbelievable. Dwyer is clearly contradicting my thesis on that particular comment. I have to hold my hands up and say that a fair amount of my respect for you has been restored. I can't believe I wrote that comment then straight away watched this one. I nearly dropped my cuppa tea when you started saying you thought Carter did it.
Outstanding video. I will check out your other channel. I was irked every time I read a news article after Ruben Carter saying he was "exonorated", or "falsely accused". I research famous criminal cases as a hobby, and this was one of them. The circumstantial evidence was overwhelming, there was no alibi, and motive was established.
Good site on unsolved cases.
www.savagewatch.com
generichumor Thanks
Iv always been a Rubin fan but wow this Man has 360 me
I honestly only saw the movie and all of my knowledge concerning this case comes from the movie.
Great video Dwyer
Spot on! I believe Carter did the deed! The evidence is stacked against him! Thank you.😎
Any thoughts on Tysons and Valeros cases.
Some people are very emotional over this subject i see very interesting the American justice system scares ME the sentences are HUGE over there i enjoy your vids Dwyer much Respect !!!
Great video Dwyer!!!
You need to listen to the BBC’s “Hurricance tapes” - has a lot of new info. Including a name of a person much more likely to have committed the murders
Oh please, really.
What about the possibility that Carter was a participant/involved in the crime on some level but didn't physically fire the shots? It's clear as a bell he had knowledge of/involvement in it but maybe John Artis or some 'other' person actually did the shooting?
It is a strong possibility. Elwood Tuck and Eddie Rawls were identified by a female witness as being involved whose testimony was not utilized by the prosecution or the defense as she was viewed as a witness detrimental to both. To the prosecution because she claimed to have a mental block that prohibited her from remembering any of the events and to the defense, because she also stated that Carter and Artis were there as well. There was also a taxi driver that gave information about picking up this same woman soon after the crime and she was extremely emotional saying that a man put a gun in her purse and she was scared. There was a report done on her statements by the state in the second trial.
Police also initially saw 2 cars, Carter's and a dark colored car following Carter's vehicle on the streets that night. Check out Cal Deal's sight on this case, there is a lot of information, as well as the court case findings as well, which is public record.
Seems likely given the lack of blood on carter
The only question I have about his guilt is Artis. I don’t get how he doesn’t squeal if he’s involved or knows anything.
Dwyer what number you have on the Giants Jersey Larry Herndon or Jack Clark are you going old school
Tim Linecum
Richard Dwyer How about a look at Wesley Cook AKA Mumia Abu-Jamal and the murder of Daniel Faulkner?
That's is open an shut case Wesley Cook unloaded gun into Faulkner
Jim Jimm Not according to many who use the same type of conspiracy arguments that were presented in the Rubin Carter case.
BTW Cal Deal's Graphic Witness site might be of use...
I would be interested to hear thoughts on Mumia Abu-Jamal.
You have convinced me. I like the Dylan song so much that I believed the conspiracy theory. It seems you also like the song as you continually use phrases from it. I am going to look into it, but I suspect Carter may fit the profile of a psychopath, which would be further evidence of his guilt. His juvenile delinquency (i.e. having stabbed someone when young) is suggestive of psychopathy, and, now I come to think of it, the film makes a very unconvincing attempt to present this stabbing as an act of self defence.
A brilliant and courageous video by the way. Are you going to tackle the Tyson case?
I just looked at this interview (Rubin 'Hurricane' Carter Interview - 9/11/10) after five seconds it is clear that the man is a raging narcissist. He insists upon being called Doctor Rubin Carter and takes immediate control of the interview, which is very suggestive of psychopathy, as is his flamboyant style of dress. I am currently writing a book about psychopathy and have researched the topic in depth.
In 1976 bail bondswoman Carol Kelley put up the money for Carter's release from prison. She met him at a hotel room with her son to finalize some paperwork. Carter, for whatever reason, had been drinking aftershave. Out of his mind he pounded Kelley's head in. She had to eventually have her spleen removed. After smashing her Carter turned on her son and beat him severely.
+TorstenStett He was a crazy guy then
+George Havenhand I'd say so but history has a way of being rewritten.
I always wondered about the wayne William case in Atlanta in early 80's I always thought it was the kkk
So how did the myth of him not committing the crime come about?
He did it
Evidence is overwhelming, you'd be stupid to think he didn't do it.
DWB is real tell Dwyer
I suppose they set up oj as well LOL.
Hi,I knew Rubin,John,Bello,Dexter.You shoundt be saying things about people if you reall y do not know the truth,but you go by other opinions.Theres many people in jail now a days for talking false hood of others.
lol... what kind of car did the cop not believe was yours? I thought you owned an old school Cadillac.
I've been stopped in that car too, but here I was talking about a new Mitsuibishi 3000GT that I used to own.
If you had passed on the 3000gt and went for a Camry this would never had happened. Haha I joke. Good video Dwyer, enjoy all your posts. Wasn't aware of your other channel, will check it out. Take care.
Dumbest thing I've ever heard. It doesn't matter if he did it or not. Carter didn't have to prove his innocence. The burden of proof lied with the prosecution. A guilty verdict must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt and supported by hard proofs. (like tire tracks on the crime scene, murder weapons, fingerprints, gunpowder residual on hands, etc.). Funny how clearly those intoxicated witnesses saw a fleeing car in the middle of the night, especially when the cops got Carter's car in their custody. Dwyer, you should be ashamed of yourself. RIP Hurricane Carter.
You’re wrong. Most cases are solved with circumstantial evidence. Also, the fact two independent witnesses ID’d his car within 5 minutes and the shells from the murder weapons were found said car is enough to throw away the key.
Stop getting emotional. I liked the Dylan song too.