'Modi Has Created a New Pro-Hindu Power Elite-Protecting India's Social Unity Not Important to Them'
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 ก.ย. 2024
- In the first interview to mark the weekend launch of his book ‘India’s Power Elite: class, caste and a cultural revolution’ SANJAYA BARU says in the seven years he’s been in power Narendra Modi has created a new power elite and created a cultural revolution in terms of the people who rule India as well as in terms of their ideas and thinking. Previously when governments changed in New Delhi there were no major changes in the social class that constituted the capitals power elite. As BARU puts it, “ it was a revolving door...one set of friends went in and another set went out”. Now “ the new intellectuals around an Amit Shah and Yogi Adityanath belong to a different world”.
In a 32 minute interview with Karan Thapar for The Wire, BARU says the new power elite is more provincial, it prefers to use Hindi or vernacular languages, it’s drawn from the middle or intermediate and not upper castes or classes and it was not born into families of privilege with easily accessible contacts. In contrast, the old elite had been to similar schools and universities, were members of the Gymkhana or IIC and were largely upper-middle class.
![[FULL EP.73] เปิดบ้าน 70 ล้าน "แป้ง Zbing" ยกมาทั้งญี่ปุ่น l เคหสถานบานปลาย l One Playground](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YBnJhTt07Pg/mqdefault.jpg)
करण थापर इतना बोल दिया था कि संजय बारू 6- 7 बार exactly absolutely bol kr kam chala skta tha
😄 Sahi pakde sir!
Wire is anti india news press if you observe all article all anti india....paid by george soreos and few corporates in usa .
@@girishm6335 yes we know
This is typical max muller stuff. To praise the opposite side but add poison pills of negativity. It's like giving a cake with poison.
Hahaha
Thank you Wire. You exposed your own damn selves.
The Wire is not a genuine media house. It is a propoganda platform for an anti India and anti Hindu ideology.
@@subhasisghosh66 I know. Which is why I avoid it. But this time, they've outdone themselves. Fantastic work, just like Greta Thunberg.
A religion is hated, shamed and made to feel weak for past 70 years in a selective way...and then you say this generation is conscious of is religion. Of course it is... We won't take it lying down anymore. We will fight back. We ain't lesser than nobody.
You call JNU as intellectuals!!?? Who? Romila Thapar 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Bloody idiots not knowing Sanskrit, reading colonial literature and feeling sad about themselves. Commies pack up!!
@Coo Koo back...
The title of the book should be How India's Elite became Irrelevant😂😂😂😂😂
Still living in denial... Fools paradise that they come from
Elite discussing elite struggles!
A religion is hated, shamed and made to feel weak for past 70 years in a selective way...and then you say this generation is conscious of is religion. Of course it is... We won't take it lying down anymore. We will fight back. We ain't lesser than nobody.
@@sadashivputra1627 Ok
@@sadashivputra1627 Bhai, kam nashe kar
😂😂😂
Vety true
Mr. Baru thanks for documenting the fall of British hangover and English Elitism in India.
This is typical max muller stuff. To praise the opposite side but add poison pills of negativity. It's like giving a cake with poison.
@@sadashivputra1627 aryy bss kr
And the growth of theology and medievalism.
@ Ambarish L
lmaocorrect!
@@northerncook2280 how about the crusades and the cheating? Or shall we focus on your modern days casual sex, alcoholism and apathy?
The Struggle of the St. Stephens Elites is greater than Ananya Pandey's struggles 😂😂
⁰⁰
I used to remember in 2012-13, NDTV used to telecast debates of Hindu vs Stephens on prime time
@Vijay Manjrekar wow, what an answer, I will certainly quote it, and the most important fact in education, our history books end in 1947 and after that we just get a cursory recording of events because if it were analysed in books it will produce rebels
@Vijay Manjrekar great analysis 👌👍
@Vijay Manjrekar aapke charan kaha hain prabhu
Entire story in a nutshell :
Eloquent english speaking ability + ability to use fork and knife properly = Intellectualism
And therefore we are entitled 🤣🤣🤣🤣
That was a metaphor yaar😁
Wow👏👏what a punch👏👏
@Vasanth S no no.. pappu and his doddering old boys deserve that award.
@Vasanth S But like your real father they had no guts to face the enemy after Bombay attacks. Simplifying it as normal . Remember Satayanarayan Ganga Ram!!!!!! confused ? That is Sam Pitroda , one of ur cousin Pappu s many fathers
@Vasanth S your school obviously didnt teach you this simple thing: no amount of scrambling will render a rotten egg edible. Jai Hind.
I left Bharath 30 years back. I love new Bharath. I help aspirational persons from my small village of about 500 people.
Come back to new india. 😄
Bharat thanks you.🙏
We need your assistance in india no remote control please 🙏
Wire is anti india news press if you observe all article all anti india....paid by george soreos and few corporates in usa .
Sickular parties liberandos fear Modiji these people reminds when gabbar singh recites in sholay mother tells son soja varna gabbar aajayege this fear permanently installed in them very happy
Good job done by Modi. This was essential for the balance of healthy Indian democracy.
Every time I hear karan thapar, his special efforts to sound like an Englishman, I feel pity for his state of mind! This interview only elaborates his thought process further!
His father was Gen Thapar, who lead us to defeat against China in 1962. And, of course, he is related to Bharat Ratna Shri Jawaharlal Nehru.
@@subhasisghosh66 father of Ravana was a great sage , I hope u get my point ....
No need to disparage an army man due to this clown.
Is there anything wrong in that effort? I mean look at our us, we are writing here in English, we wear a suit in our ceremonies, my building’s name is Daffodil, our songs have heavy influence of some foreign music. We are all trying sound/look/seem something foreign.
He was educated in elite Doon school in Deharadun and in Stowe school in England.
Really loved the way they are whining about how elites are no longer in the power corridors and are irrelevant !!!
Shameless wolves. They created caste & religious discrimination, now that it is working against them they are crying. Hindu is much more united today and that is their pain.
@@karthikkannan3711 lol who didn't see the video properly dumbo
Now there is more more discrimination based on religion caste gender etc
@@Avinashm7 🔔🔔
Caste Discrimination Religious tensions was always there Thanks to media,Social Media these incidents are more highlighted now
In the past people killed in the name of caste in Villages and no FIR ,No police, nothing
At least in Present day people are giving attention to these incidents
Education and better lifestyle ,better income, ECONOMY are the only things which can solve all social problems
@@thebatman0777 this is universal truth you are talking about
@@karthikkannan3711 but India isn't, taking away the middle caste Hindu you still have a huge population of minorities, Lower caste Hindu that are being marginalized. They are not winning, they are simply stating that this culture revolution could not bring a positive change if the economy doesn't revive, and we could very well end up like one of those African countries, with powerful nutcases holding on to power while the country goes to the dogs, India is too diverse to think that just the idea of Hindu, Hindi, Hindustan will hold it together for long. Like he said to that an aspirational India has risen they don't care about fork and spoon, but they would still want a nice house, care and clothes. And those opportunities that was previously held by others so called privileged.
The world is expanding, and if these people don't expand with it, your just a big bullfrog in a well with the loudest voice, but it still in a well. It's still deep and dark.
its rare that I watch a wire video and end up being more happy
so trueeee even i thought the sameeeeee 😂😂😂😂
Exactly bro u stole my words.
Same here. Schadenfreude....
Accident happens.....sometimes
Me too
Only one topic Modi Modi Modi. And No one know how to stop him.
This is typical max muller stuff. To praise the opposite side but add poison pills of negativity. It's like giving a cake with poison.
@@sadashivputra1627 arry phir vhi
Modi is a FAILURE.
Lack of Jobs
Huge Increase in Petrol/diesel prices
Rapes
Atrocities against Dalits
Fall of India's Economy
Communal violence
Religious Intolerance
Language imposition
But still, sanghis/bhakts are gonna continue kissing his feet and worship him as Bhagavan. LOL
@@bossfighter7091
Lack of Government Jobs.
Increase in Petrol Prize.
Fall of Economic. Tak to thik tha par ye Kya apne aap se joda hua h.
"Atrocities Against Dalit.
Communal Violence.
Religious Intolerance.
Language Imposition."
@@gabbar1426 he has added his agenda to divide Hindus on the basis of caste language and community. Beware of these bossfighter sort of people.
I still remember my dad tell me 10 years ago while watching an IPL match (I was about 13 back then): "That's Rahul Gandhi, he's a future Prime Minister"
He voted for Modi in 2019.
Yes because nobody thought the government of manmohan singh who were in power would be so corrupt, while maintaining the facade of running the government they had depleted the financial resources of india to no end. We had become so poor that we didn't have money for buying fighter jets to protect our country and assert our territorial claims Thanks to ANNA HAZARE for opening the eyes of people of India.
@@doge3436 anna hajare was a fraud..
Whole maharashtra knew he is fraud...
Delhi fell for him
This is typical max muller stuff. To praise the opposite side but add poison pills of negativity. It's like giving a cake with poison.
@@rohit.k7920 I may be wrong about anna but even if his intentions weren't good his movement did end up supporting the right cause of hindus.
@@doge3436 Hindus???😂😂😂
The moment was on corruption I think😂😂.
I'm that person from bharata they are talking about.✊😎
Who else?
Third world
@Sumeet tanwar bro still 35% people under poverty even modi govt pushed another 10% there , hdi is less than 3rd world country, press freedom is at 134 rank, rate of literacy is 66%. Only kerala, goa are doing well
Ppl line up in queue to get us and uk visa. So called by who call themself bharatiya are the nri’s who are treated badly by the American and the europeans, thts fact
Yeahh, all the time I was thinking they are talking about me😂😂 A confident 'misfit' 🤣🤣
@@jobi705able first world countries refusing to share their vaccines with other and hording them !
@@na4369 astra zenca developed by oxford and bulk produced by serum institute, lik tht contract has been given to few more companies.
So tey re distributing in masses
Lik tht sinopharm of china is produced in masses and distributed arnd whole gulf and africa.
Pzier has distributed to limited pppls . Coz mass production is not there. Only heath sector and priority guys wer given pfzier.
I guess even modi has taken pfizer not some covishield or astrazence.
Kindly update yourself and look into it.
Notice the comment by Baru, ‘I was growing up in Hyderabad & never heard reference to Religion’...while the reality of our cities, towns n villages has deep religious fault lines. Many major riots took place in his youth & while we are at it, 3% Hindu minority of Kashmir was ethnically cleansed in one shot. But hey, in the English speaking circles, the Hindu n Muslim elites pretend that the ‘street’ where there is one sided dominance doesn’t exist!
This is typical max muller stuff. To praise the opposite side but add poison pills of negativity. It's like giving a cake with poison.
I am a contemporary of Mr. Baru grew up in Hyd studied in same college. I remember communal riots almost every six months in old city and fringe areas mostly instigated to destabilize NTR govt. I have walked thru curfew areas not knowing curfew was imposed when I left my college/ work place. Religion has been mis-used by every party! No holier than thou!!! It is time to bring in equality in previleges, responsibilities and rights.
Yes that was called intellectual.
I lived in hyderabad too in 80s. My own friend was stabbed to death in old city. His crime was he was a hindu walking in the street
Very well put!
The set of intellectuals like you will pay the price for perpetuating the colonial mindset after our freedom and helping a new set of family based rulers.
Colonial mindset is being spearheaded by our government only. Truth is we never got the freedom we deserved.
Thank you Modiji and BJP for coming to power in 2014 and making these shallow, 'English - first' remnants of British colonialism irrelevant.
I really like what you said about our NRI intellectual brothers who are writing shit everyday to NY Times and others. They can continue to cry we don't care here in India. Good one both of you
You’re proving their points. 😂
Mohit, Baru said that his brothers went abroad. The fact is that many like his brothers have been leaving India because people like Baru are in administrative services. I wish if he would have mentioned any one of his great contributions while in service.
Loving this meltdown of old elite club! Thanks to people like Sanjeev Sanyal and etc who can go to temple in dhoti and easily sip their wine in a party. For this old elite these two things cant exist simultaneously. According to them one hav to 'declass' himself to wear dhoti. 😎
You speak as if there was no wine in ancient bharat. Please read sanskrit literature.
Well, I didn't even have to guess which channel this is after reading the title😂
All I can say is, you're helping BJP for 2024 elections without even them having begun the campaigning themselves!
Very well put it .. So true
Yaa bro good to see the elite meltdown, more is to come
You need comprehension lessons, the gist was the contrary faces of genocidal modi. A teo faced liar, your petrol bill should b a wake up call if nothing else.
perfectly said. lmao.
@@MrTwangstaable yaaa i can't wait for our new PM papu.
To understand where he's coming from you need to watch more than The wire.
Even the British have moved on from antiquated table etiquette and elaborate meals to fast and convenient food, but Thapar and Baru are still stuck in distinguishing people by the way they hold spoon and fork. Clinging on to an old bygone era, which handed out privileges to handful few elites.
The conversation is so entertaining. M Luving it.
Exactly that was the funniest
The meltdown of "Metropolitan institutions" like St. Stephen's College in Bureaucracy is started when Engineers started to compete in Civil Services Examination. Earlier, nearly 70% of the bureaucrats came from one college- St. Stephen's College. But in last couple of decades, mostly engineers that too from IITs are making their space in civil services and thereby sooner or later in the PMO. Moreover, bureaucrats in 80's and 90's - which Baru was referring- have had the background in Arts/Commerce/Humanities. But nowadays, they come in the variety of Engineers, Doctors, Physicists. For Arts (supra), St. Stephen's College is an epitome of eliteness, but for technical background IITs/IISc holds the same glass.
Today most of the bright students choose engineering or medicine.
50 years back it was not the case.
@@flyingafrinak6958 50 years ago either the best students opt for Science/Engineering/Medicine. But those who chose for said courses, they wouldn't appear in CSE. Nowadays, Engineers and Doctors are appearing in this examination so much so that they didn't do in 50 years ago.
A religion is hated, shamed and made to feel weak for past 70 years in a selective way...and then you say this generation is conscious of is religion. Of course it is... We won't take it lying down anymore. We will fight back. We ain't lesser than nobody.
And you will gradually see the change when logical and process oriented engineers gradually take over the civil services from the idealistic and leftist arts students.
@@sadashivputra1627 Exactly this is the point which is hated by upper class 'elite'. The decentralisation of power is happening from Ox-bridge graduates to the people coming from lower middle class/middle class. The Hindus of this country started to care about their views and started booting out the people of having "GoraSahab Mentality".
Very entertaining. Modiji has got the "intellectuals" befuddled and staring at irrelevance.
Modiji hain to Mumkin hai 💪💪
He has them by their balls!! 🙂🙂
@@Gappasappa you mean the economy by the short and curlys. Blind sheep all of us.
@@MrTwangstaable let them enjoy their short period of elitism...
When economy comes crashing down they'll turn liberal in a jiffy...
Just ignore these apes...
Even Hindi food bloggers have more subscribers than The wire😆
This is typical max muller stuff. To praise the opposite side but add poison pills of negativity. It's like giving a cake with poison.
@@sadashivputra1627 bhut badhiya bhy
@Simple Minded hahahahahhahahahahahhah
@Sirius modiji pr toh hota hai... "Fakery has many buyers" because it's very cheap..
Joke is on you to understand 😁😁
@Simple Minded Because you are simplistic, not "simple-minded".
These people are truly making the job easier for RSS and BJP and Modi...... I love them for this .....keep ensuring the victory of right wing ideology 👍👍👍👍
I have so enjoyed reading the comments, chuckled several times, laughed aloud some, and am so happy that we Indians are awake and alert.
Title should be: The wire exposing itself...
The fork and spoon argument 😂😂😂😂
You guys talk as if it's a bad thing?
They have no idea that we perfectly know where to put the fork, see the pain on their faces.
@@SKumar-ol7fo hahahahaha
@@SKumar-ol7fo 😂😂🤣
There is a scene in the 'big short' where the crook openly admits(boasts) his I'll thought out plan. This spoon-fork lunacy reminded me of that
Ye elites bhi dinosaurs ki tarah extinct ho jayenge...Agar table manners se intellectualism determine karte rahenge...
Not once did they speak of how modi hasn't taken a single leave in 7 years now. He might not be an 'intellectual' like them, but compare the work he's willing to put in with anyone of these and one would need lesser of these weird theories to explain his popularity among the educated 'rising' middle class!
But they are intellectuals. Haath ghumaa k hi kaan pakdenge, saral tareeke se inhein pasand nhi aata...
I make huge profits on my investment since i started
trading with Ryan Jeffries, her trading strategies are top notch
wow! amazing to see others who trade with Ryan Jeffries,
i'm currently on my 5th trade with her and my portfolio has grown tremendously
I invest with Mrs Ryan Jeffries too, she charges a 20%
commission on profit made after every trading session which is fair compare to the effort she put in to make huge profits
As a first time investor I started trading with Mrs Ryan Jeffries with just a thousand bucks. my portfolio is worth much more than that now within just weeks of trading with her
with the consistent weekly profits I'm getting investing with
Mrs Ryan Jeffries there's no doubt, she is the most reliable in the market. such a genius
@@annawachowicz208
You can reach her through Telegrm
Absolutely....these people blaming Current ruling party a communal one and do politics based caste and religion...
But at the same time they are Judging Amit Shah ... Yogi..based on their their socio economic class..which background they belong to ... Modi is Lower cast , Atal was Upper class..
I mean common guys...everyone is watching you...
Now people will not fall prey to your traps..rather non sense....
Well... Bharat here....
Twitter pe clips dekh kar mei pehli baar wire ke channel pe aaya hun ye dekhne ke karan thapar roteh huye lagteh keise hain😥😃
😂😂😂😂
Same here bro... After reading on opindia
Me too 🤣🤣🤣🤣
This is typical max muller stuff. To praise the opposite side but add poison pills of negativity. It's like giving a cake with poison.
Same here 😀
Sam Pitroda is a classic example of Macaulay's vision for India.😂😂
“We are all Hypocrites. We cannot see ourselves or judge ourselves the way we see and judge others.”
- José Pacheco, Mexican Author
@@revertfromhindootoislam Either Everybody is or Nobody is Hypocrite.
Awesome
Very true ...
We can't see the picture when we are inside the frame ...
Thanks and have a good day
@@revertfromhindootoislam Human
OMG, what a terrific philosophy
The problem of these intellectuals are that they are now not a part of government formation and portfolio distribution which earlier used to happen in their houses and offices
Don't you observe body language , Thank you ..for this joy 🙏
The mentality of old elite is just like British. But time have changed.
Wire is anti india news press if you observe all article all anti india....paid by george soreos and few corporates in usa .
Colonial hangover still exists..
W*r* was founded only to give intellectuall coating to lslamist and anti nationalism...and they r good in that
@@opinonated_soul right
one person who got kicked out from the corridors of power is Karan Thapar, The pain is so evident... Dosti Bani Rahein
Thankfully people have started realizing that there is more to life than being able to handle fork and spoon
Preserving indian culture by not letting people know about it is a very unique and absurd way of these intellectuals, and they are doing it delebrately
Hope over reality(that the economy matters)It matters only that they feel they've arrived,even if only vicariously.
@@shirleyjoseph9181 Go away troll. You are wasting your time.
@-- India is actuall known as Hindustan, the country made of Hindus. Now we have accepted other religions, so it is India. One should not forget this. What culture are you talking about ? We have no corruption now compared to what happened earlier. Pandemic is from China creation, not Indian made. Why blame the Indian government, when you are living in India ? And the people who are suffering did not follow Covid protocol, so let them suffer. Let others learn from their mistakes. I am in India after taking my degree and did not run away to US or UK, I have all the right to preserve my culture in India. So stop grumbling and do not promote hatred, we need all the support we get to kick out this pandemic
This is precisely the problem - All the inner circle , the power elite, came from St. Stephen's - I am just shaking my head - AND??? Does that mean that they were intelligent and capable ??? Certainly not! This tendency of Indians to confuse intelligence with fluency in English language is what the problem is!!! I also used to unknowingly suffer from that misconception till I went to school in a non English speaking country and had these 'provincial' Indian classmates. Since we were all in a level playing field I saw first hand how intelligent these kids were , even though they didn't speak good English!
Exactly my thoughts. Some people on here can't see beyond the convent school English. These two guys are not bright at ALL. Far from it.
Just shows how deeply colonized we are, especially the English medium educated folks! It will take a generation to turn the ship around, if we work earnestly at it
These elites are so sad that people from vernacular background are coming up in social and political ladder 😂
A few things that are hard to miss. Mr Thapar still sticks calling the metros Delhi Bombay Madras Bangalore, never minding that there's no longer any reason to continue using the anglicised names in place of the original names.
And Mr Baru says his generation of the sixties and seventies had global concerns, the Vietnam war, the US student protests, while living in a desperately poor country where ninety percent of the people had no toilets, no clean drinking water, the life expectancy was less than fifty, as was the literacy rate.
Helps explain the rise of Modi better.
Rightly said. These issues are still there in 21st century and when schemes promoting toilets, pani, roads and asking MPs to develop 1 village at least, if focus and commitment is to reach out to that common man how will elite like it let alone see it. And fir Kehte hain modi power mein kaise aagaya? 😂
Besides foul filthy atmosphere of
Rabid secularism has necessitated grouping of Hindu vote BANK organically a shrewd LEADER smells it and employs it to protect Hindus is it crime or
Unconstitutional
@Suresh Panje "your god vs my god" is a basic theme in Islam and Christianity.
@Suresh Panje lakhs of ignorants bow towards a lifeless black building 5 times a day and keep talking to an imaginary tyrant all day, who they think will get angry if they don't follow his commands.
Economy is important. Hope the economy grows with the confidence
This is typical max muller stuff. To praise the opposite side but add poison pills of negativity. It's like giving a cake with poison.
@Survivor Mark your words. You'll come out a naive fool in 2025 . Also govt is DISinvesting in Railways and ports to wade off their debts (fiscal deficits) lol. You numbers are totally wrong, you may wanna re-check your stats...India has been on steady decline in GDP growth ever since 2016.
The meltdown of the so-called power Elite is epic
Your generation Hindu didn't care about their religious identity....but "Your Muslims friends even that time would not have been eating Jhatka meat with you". Do you understand the difference?
Guess what
PM Modi is in Delhi since 2014 and Karan Thapar was never invited for that "dosti Bani rahein" high tea meeting
The pain is so evident
Modi does have guts to face Karan Thapar. He can only talk to scripted media who can ask him how to eat mangoes wether he sucks them and eat.
@@kevincrasto Ask this thappar why never question his masters from Gandhi clan with such severity and malice . They would have cracked a lot more faster didn’t even need so much screwing even .
@@preethishetty6179 He will not be alive if he has the guts to ask them such questions.
The Wire always been a perfect asylum to Psychosis and Depraved.
The Wire can be considered as Marg Darshak mandal of Lutyens chamchas
bjp lie steal cheat looot murder. only one thing in mind power . cuz bjp has no great people only powerful people. i dont like the wokes at all
@@highpriest8571 leave India and find some better country where politics run according to you wish!
@@ayaankilar146 oh yeah i am planning too for real. not cuz of BJP tho cuz not one person question the totaltarian rules of lockdown and various things like mandatory masks tracking apps and mandatory vax . not once in this whole pandaemic was the constitution brought up civil liberties tc. i am in utter shock at the sheepishness in the country. people trade freedom for liberty here . i think florida is where i will move to by the End of the year
@@ayaankilar146 the most dangerous thing to me about covid was the govts handling of it. not just ours almost all countries in the world. only sweeden and some american states all republican states handled it perfectly
So glad Mr Thapar is wearing a tie !! Instead of a bow tie !! 😊 !!
Perhaps he doesn't want to attract too much attention for this interview.
Wire is anti india news press if you observe all article all anti india....paid by george soreos and few corporates in usa .
Mera Bharat badal rha hai, so is this convent educated N semi hypocrite Mr Thappad is changing his tone
समय का इंतजार करें आने वाले वर्षों में यह कुर्ता और पाजामा पहन कर इंटरव्यू लिया करेंगे ।
Dhire dhire ye bhi tie se janeu par aayega 😂
I just realized that I am an expert of Russian even though I can’t read or write that language. This was my realization after hearing this interview
Wire is anti india news press if you observe all article all anti india....paid by george soreos and few corporates in usa .
Exactly
This is typical max muller stuff. To praise the opposite side but add poison pills of negativity. It's like giving a cake with poison.
दरबारी लोकांच्या जुन्या आठवणी😂
Bhau perfect tola marala.😂😂
Fine observation.
Exactly the opposite, BJP has totally destroyed caste based politics. Muslim, Yadav, Thakur, Dalit, Brahmin vote bank doesn't work any more.
Can't agree more
Muslim? Is that a caste?
@@padmanabhapanikersatisan8970 no that is a dangerous cult
I am a caste less hindu and proud of being one.
Hindu+hindi+hidustan 👍
Stop appeachement, be equal
Kannada+Sanatana+Bharat
@@keerthi321 Nothing In writing
Kannada+Hindu+Bharat why be apologetic of writing Hindu
This interview alone is a testament as to why people of india had to ultimately choose Narendra Modi no matter how bigoted he is.
Two Brown Sahibs lamenting their loss of power :D
HAHA. So true/. Are you the new Hindu Elite?
If it's an episode of 'Game of Thrones. The title could be 'Bastard of Britishers'
Haha well said
@p chatterjee your feku won't be power forever people won't be fooled all time
Two agony uncles scratching each other's back........... Really enjoyed the agony in their conversation....
The whole interview is all about we are superior to everyone. I guess their all intellectualism is that they can speak fancy English
Wire is anti india news press if you observe all article all anti india....paid by george soreos and few corporates in usa .
Exactly!
@jiene m you haven't heard Karan speaking in Hindi ?
Question to Mr. Baru - why there is no branch of nagarjuna restaurant in chennai and no sarvanna bhavan in bangalore??
And Why they don't provide fork and knife with the meal??
Those restaurants are too low class for him to eat there.
A religion is hated, shamed and made to feel weak for past 70 years in a selective way...and then you say this generation is conscious of is religion. Of course it is... We won't take it lying down anymore. We will fight back. We ain't lesser than nobody.
Wire is anti india news press if you observe all article all anti india....paid by george soreos and few corporates in usa .
@@sadashivputra1627 btw, what r u referring to.. would u mind elaborating a bit
At least these guys admit that in the past, India was ruling Bharat.
Now, Bharat rules Bharat !
Your generation was a generation of imitators (eat with a fork, speak a foreign tongue, follow foreign ideology). Current generations set their own rules and live as they want.
mental slavery is the appropriate word
South Indian here..supporting the new ‘Hindi-heartland’ elite like Yogi Adityanath 😅
🙏🏼
BJP is not elite - but a public servant party. The time to focus on the South Indian muslim has not yet come, wait till that day.
Just look at the profound aura of eliteism with which Karan Thapar uses the word "Vernacular"
He doesn't even acknowledge that these are Indian LANGUAGES, equal in status to English.
Sometimes I watch the Wire just to get myself angered
Yes . i suffer from low blood pressure and my doctor has recommended me one video of The wire a day to keep my BP at healthy level
You think about Vietnaam but never try to develop our own Country.
Hindu is not a region it is a way of living (sankriti) in where there is kindness for all religions.
Wire should hire Prashant Kishore so we get to know what conspiracy you guys hatch in your studios.
I surprised to hear from Sanjay Baru that in 60 - 70s caste was not ab issue ... he is living in his own world...
It is always better to think in mother tongue. It gives you better idea. However good you know english, you can not now express and think better than mother tongue. How can using mother tongue makes communal.
Don’t worry about mother tongue just keep using it. Keep thinking in it better for all of us.
Why do you hate desi? Only Lutyens are entitled to rule - what a joke!
If you follow Indian culture and language you are branded as communal.
This obsession with mother tongue is trending to become all pervasive in today's India. Is our mother tongue a gift of our genes or our biology. Certainly not. A nascent and upcoming field like Cognitive Science is saying just the opposite
@@sharadhvyas Who is lutyens?
@@sharadhvyas Indian culture is casteist and based on discrimination. Don't go boasting about Bharat. It is calous and dark.
Writing in English isn't a matter of pride, It's our colonial compulsion. But I really can't understand, why two Bharatiya speak in English between them. After all it's a language of our brutal ruler. I am confident twenty years from now, any Proud Bharatiya will feel ashamed to speak in English. And true now it's a battle between India & Bharat. And obviously Bharat will win.
Yes you are right. Now we , the new generation who uses their fingers while eating in 7 star Hotels has taken over.
😀😂...aand the spoon us so yuck ...+ Unhygenic- travelling to endless mouth - in corona it's also a deadly practice ....
Ghar wapsi 🙏🏽
32:06 When Thapar said "Thank you very much for ...", I thought Baru will reply "Absolutely" - one last time. But he didn't, damn it.
What is the count of absolutely in this interview 🙄🙄🙄
Absolutely!
I don't why I read comments first before watching the video.
Beacuse you want to save time. 😉
Can't find any video on Bihar Police officer lynched in Bengal village while trying to arrest from a certain community. Can brave journos of The Wire bring our the truth by visiting that village?
I am from Andhra and I support the current government. It is not hindi dominance but de arabisation, eliminate farsi and more sanskrit. I live in America and feel more at home in India now than before.
15:50 Sochte honge, Saala ye log itne confident kaise ho Gaye, be??? 😂😂😂
Guys having severe burns..! Burnol de do inko
This is typical max muller stuff. To praise the opposite side but add poison pills of negativity. It's like giving a cake with poison.
@@sadashivputra1627 bhut badhiya likha
भारत की सारी समस्याओं का जड़ ही ये एलिट वर्ग है जिसकी रक्षा में ये लगे हुए हैं।
@Indian तुम सर्टिफिकेट बांटते हो। खुद के लिए सबसे पहले निकाल लो एक।
There is so much pain n agony in this video...😂😂
Nostalgia of good old days
I was thinking of reading his book but now I have understood what trash he has written in his book. Thanks Karan for saving my time and money
Need to send them Banana leaf. Let them practice how to lick their hands and eat. So that their confidence grows and they can handle new Bharath. 😋🤣
Now Foriegner teaching us how to eat.....from there sticks....on different land....this is the biggest mistake....they done ...they thinking they are the best elite in different land and now teaching us.....but bharata peoples our pure bharatiye....they don't wan't your stick to eat....we want our style to eat....thats why you all are irrelevant....get lost from our land....now we want our ideology....and don't mixup our cultures and religions of india.....all are different.....whose ideology is indian...then does not matter which religion he /she belonging....so please stay away from us....and don't divide us once again .....we only believe in sab ka saath sab ka vikaas and sabka vishwas.....thats it...
And hindu dharama is based on bharat ideology.....thats why don't add after hindu word religion its not a religion . Its a dharama ....
Loved that.
Haha eating with forks and spoon don't make u intellectual... We are happy with our hands and bnana leaf
Nehruvian Elite vs Bharat. 🙏
True
Bharat was nothing but a den of filth with priest running the call
I love the way he talks about forks and spoons. As if it is a mark of being elite!!
I've downloaded this video incase if The Wire puts it down...😂😂
To Quote Rahul Gandhi "Bhai maza aah gya aur main yeh maza hindustan ke saab nagrik ko dena chahta hun
Karan: One of your better shows. First you discarded your "thumb & finger" twiddling so one could focus on the subject. Second, you seemed more of yourself minus the phoney intellectual. Bring on more of your natural self and you would become almost bearable. Good luck.
Savage! I like it.
You call JNU as intellectuals!!?? Who? Romila Thapar 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Bloody idiots not knowing Sanskrit, reading colonial literature and feeling sad about themselves. Commies pack up!!
They had this sickness of showing fake compassion, humanity etc to the same Hindi speaking poor people. Moment the same people rose higher than they were before, it gave this brigade burn in the butt.
As if the poor in this country have truly risen! The ruling class today is the same elite- zamindars, traders, priests that ran this country for 2000 years. Only for a brief moment could someone could rise to the top with good education. Today's elitism demands only unwavering faith in the great leader.
All the poor folk and dalits are still underrepresented and unempowered even today with their only chance of getting power being through the worship of the great leader and his stupid ideas.
@@Jeevanmn Lol. This regime did more for poors than anyone else ever did.
Electricity, Cylinders, Pucca Homes, Direct Benefit transfers have reached remotest of masses. Earlier it was just Jatavas in Dalits, Meenas in Tribals and Muslim-Yadavas in Backwards who got benefits. It has clearly been more democratized now.
Love our Dearest Modiji. He the best. Love Mother India. South Africa
This interview was unintentionally funny. Karan Thapar types coming to terms with reality that India (yes, Bharat) has risen!! Sincere request to Mr Baru: please do one with Rajdeep Sardesai :-)
🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️😊
I am christian too...
And i love bjp too
Its not a paradox it's just a love for my tradion and culture of this land..
🥰
And u people take this🖕
Why are you named after the economist John Keynes. Is that your real name?
In the end Mr Modi will come unscathed, whether BJP wins or loses in Bengal. His intentions are very clear. He has very clearly understood the intricacies of Indian polity, having gross root approach to any problem. He will steer the economy to greater levels having introduced reforms in every sector. The intellectuals will take time to realise this.
Between India & Bharat.
Bharat will win & establish Akhand Bharat in our lifetime 🚩 🚩
sahi baat hai bhai
@@fwefhwe4232 😎🚩😍
These guys have still maintained cheap and anti social attitudes for General public as they think they have right to rule over India by few so called elite
Exact point they were discussing 😂
Wrong Mr Baru
It's not Hindi, Hindu in ruling class. Entire PMO are from south. From all critical govt ruling class from finance to commerce ministry, it's Bengalis to Tamils, Pnajabis to Kanadigas, from Himachal/UKD to Telegu.
Get your facts right.
Desi Angrej club has been put on 🔥🔥🔥
Angrez not angrej. Likhna to seekho bhaiya!
@@AG-gv9cb bhai desi hai...angreej likhege😂
@@actuallysatyambhartee tabhi India ka bura haal hai!
11:56 Tamil and Bengalis are our brothers we don't want to impose any language on them. we want a solid rigid bonding with them , because we love and respect rishi agastya and swami Vivekananda .
@Aditya Saurabh absolutely it's an Indian language and our heritage .
@Aditya Saurabh similarly the want a rift between different castes of india. That is there way of doing politics. Dividing hindus on the basis of caste, language or place of birth. But the new hindu won't be fooled this time.
Who is 'we'?
@@diwakarmsg2061 Hindi heartland .
Agastya ok, but vivekananda is fake, bogus Guru
Unbeatable Modi Strategy...
YOUR WEAKNESS IS MY STRENGTH...
YOUR STRENGTH ALSO IS MY STRENGTH...CHECK MATE
Karan - "Blah Blah Blah Blah Blah Blah Blah Blah .... Blah Blah" . Sanjay - "Absolutely"
This interview reminds me of “Let them eat cake”. --Marie Antoinette. If they can’t have bread left them have cake
I get your point, but about Marie Antoinette, the poor women never said it; she was used by the revolutionaries for propaganda to justify the end of monarchy by guillotine.
This had to happen One-Day . India has found a leader to steer it.
I like the stmt about aspirational India with great confidence. I like "Don't care for spoon and fork but very comfortable with hands with confidence".
As a British Citizen of Indian Origin, I must say that Mr Karan Thapar is really doing a Great Job for the benefit of all the right thinking people of India. His points are highly valid, with plenty to think and ponder. His style of discussions and posing questions to the Interviewee are of high quality and can be compared with BBC's hard talk show. Well done Sir. The Country needs highly Courageous, Intelligent and wise people just like yourself in General and in current political atmosphere in Particular.
Dear Britisher, I hope British-Indians are aware of the Rashmi Samant incident at Oxford and what’s come out of it and are doing their part. I don’t know where you align yourself but since mentioned BBC I get some idea, you are missing quite a perspective before forming your opinion on the right thinkers of India.
Yes agree with you.
@@orionblue7938 Onion Blue , You have your own opinion just like others to agree or disagree. One thing for sure is that lots and lots of people are going to take up weapons against one another and that is what corning up,like it or not.
@@telepost2250 see man, there’s no complete truth out there that’s what I am saying. And people too have given up to pursue it in the comfort of technology. And then there are people who disguise and keep doing their work of subversion. It is not about what is your or my opinion. And situation is not dire as what narrative has been set. Casually using the term to set forth your own narrative is what’s need to be seen by people in general. The easiest emotional spectrum of a human being to reach out are the very basic emotions of threat, wrongness, anger. You should often analyse the tone and structure of left leaning media you will find them. Again that doesn’t mean right leaning media is doing things right but you have to know such media houses were there much before the current time period.
Sam Pitroda's ideas is a good example what the English education actually did and the amount of damage that it has done to the people mind.
Bro your message is in English, a guess u have brain damage 🤣🤣
Sanjay Baru’s views were spot on. Modi is being fiscally liberal and socially conservative, which is first of its kind. Sanjay Baru nailed perfectly on every topic like NRI, HINDU, HINDI, CASTE, LEFT vs Right and Intellectualism.
How is he correct on use of caste in west bengal elections by BJP........isn't it naive to even think that congress, left, TMC etc haven't used caste in west bengal....
India was never united like this before. Earlier people were divided in cast language and region. But now they are united under umbrellas of Hindu and rashtrvad.
Muslims are leaving Islam and joining rashtravad vfg
He prodded "new hindu elite" but now lost in the meele.
@@himdude9637 I disagree , large portion of population is rejecting that they are hindus , just see what BAMCEF is doing and rightly so. The mulnivasi are rising and will take over.
@@telepost2250 You are responding to a wrong username. This username is going around pasting the same content over and over again on all posts...😀