Yeh to biased tarah se hi apne discuss kar dia, yesehi lakho log road par 4-5 month se a kar nehi bathi hain. You must also discuss the negetive point of the bill jo fermers soch rahe hain ki yeh vi hoga. Same tarah se BSNL hathake JIO la dia, ab APMC hathake koe or la denge, or pura munafa wo le jayenge, MSP private sector main kiu nehi hain , ho sakta hain alag alag state main alag alag MSP de do.. do to sehi.. Nehi kal agar sab trader a gaye or bole ki 1800 KA SAMAN 600 MAIN BECHO NEHI TUM TUMAHARE PASS HI RAKKHO. to kia karoge tab.
You are too good to explain it. The best part of your lecture is- "Your discussion was limited to law points only. It was unbiased legal discussion"... Keep it up and. Keep sharing. Thanks.
MSP is not minimum selling price, it is minimum support price, matlab ye amount ek suugestion hota hai, jis pe sirf gov. Buy krti hai crop. Private players es se km rate pe buy krte hai.. jis region me gov. Acquisition km hai vala pe msp 1800 hona k baad bhi crop 1000 pe bikto hai.. Es mein farmers ki knowledge ki problem nahi hai. Farmera esa legal gurantee banana chahta hai ki es amounts se km pe kahi bhi crop na bika
MSP is not minimum selling price, it is minimum support price, matlab ye amount ek suugestion hota hai, jis pe sirf gov. Buy krti hai crop. Private players es se km rate pe buy krte hai.. jis region me gov. Acquisition km hai vala pe msp 1800 hona k baad bhi crop 1000 pe bikto hai.. Es mein farmers ki knowledge ki problem nahi hai. Farmera esa legal gurantee banana chahta hai ki es amounts se km pe kahi bhi crop na bika
'Minimum time maximum explanation' is your saving grace mam. i appreciate your efforts and great respect for the effort which u have made behind this informative video.
Just realised u have studied from the college I m studying in and it makes me feel proud I know some people who have lost lives in peaceful protest....sad for that
Dear mam🙏🕊🌹 आप किसी भी topic पर बोहत अच्छा समझाती हो मैन आपके sirf 2 वीडियो ही देखे है। But I am very impress with you👌 And Your way of communication is spectacular. 👍 Your inossency and qtness is Also the good qualities of your Personality🕊🙏👍 God bless you mam🌠🌠🌠🌠 YOu are the proud of india🙏🇮🇳
FROM FARMER'S DAUGHTER- PLEASE DONT MISSGUIDE.. For the record, ONLY 6% farmers GET MSP BENEFIT is not because of the lack of education for farmers. The government only acquires wheat rice and sugarcane at MSP prices. Other products like maize dalls etc. Their MSP is launched but GOV. hardly acquires them, PRIVATE agencies CAN ACQUIRE THESE PRODUCTS AT LESS THAN MSP.. THE DEMAND OF FARMERS IS TO MAKE ACQUISITION OF CROPS BELOW MSP CRIMINAL.. SHE NO WHERE MENTIONS THAT.. WE FARMERS ARE NOT ILLITERATE.. THATS THE REASON WE KNOW WHEN TO FIGHT FOR OUR RIGHTS
Yes , I am seeing this part for the first time . This is the reason some people say there's favour for some states . Punjab state gov can't get all it's money from Mandi - that is the main issue and the local government is pushing the farmers to go against the centre .
City guys will never understand the sentiments of farmers. City guys are like birds. They move from pond to pond. But the farmers are like fish in the pond. Their life and world starts and ends in the pond.
Just tell me r u happy without this bill? Were u happy?? Was the ild apmc was very beneficial fir farmers?? Ni agents were taking money ?? Did farmer got his deserving money for the produce?? If any one also is yes i will nit support this bill. Evryone who is supporting is not a city guy buddy u just do not know whats the real reason for declining of agriculture in india
Same happened with me bro on Quora app. But those guys don't tried to understand me and just spelling namo namo. Nobody cares about Farmers whether it is a Politician or aCity guys. They just want food and don't care about farmers
@@LiveTradeIndia bhai apmc mandi me bde kisan hi bechte hai Mai chote kisan ke family se hu Hmara pura paddy govt MSP par co-operative society me hi bech dete hai Chote kisan ko isse matalb hi nhi
FROM FARMER'S DAUGHTER- PLEASE DONT MISSGUIDE.. For the record, ONLY 6% farmers GET MSP BENEFIT is not because of the lack of education for farmers. The government only acquires wheat rice and sugarcane at MSP prices. Other products like maize dalls etc. Their MSP is launched but GOV. hardly acquires them, PRIVATE agencies CAN ACQUIRE THESE PRODUCTS AT LESS THAN MSP.. THE DEMAND OF FARMERS IS TO MAKE ACQUISITION OF CROPS BELOW MSP CRIMINAL.. SHE NO WHERE MENTIONS THAT.. WE FARMERS ARE NOT ILLITERATE.. THATS THE REASON WE KNOW WHEN TO FIGHT FOR OUR RIGHTS
@@_FinologyLegal sktrnirhthjthjig she reply’s hejrhbrnrbbrnr omggg 😆 *gets excited* let me chat 💬 *chats and gets no reply’s from her* *gets sad 😢 * she-she di-didn’t r-reply *starts crying* 😭 plz replyyy
The best explanation I have ever heard! Brilliant! This should be tending. Guys get this trending. For the global public get this in English too.. even if there is closed captioning.
Thankyou ma'am. The best thing about your Video is that you explained everything with respect to our constitutions law & order, statistics and also how our govt. operates & recieves tax which therefore leaves no scope of giving a biased review.
Good Explanation. However you discussed only flaws of various APMC Acts and existing practices, not how new Bills will resolve these issues (except few). You didn't discussed about new bill for agreement between farmers and sponsors, how the disputes among them will be resolved, what will be the power of courts in this regard, what if SDM is unbiased or his decision otherwise prejudice to farmers, what if produce will not match quality,grade standards, criteria (inspection will be done by sponsor and they can reject). The price can be varied and corporates are smarter than innocent farmers, and they may take undue advantage of section 5. Bargaining power of big corporates may induce individual farmers to sell their produce at lower price, no other central law prohibits it. Corporates can now stock huge in their cold storage and sell later at higher price. I appreciate that now farmers can sell their produce directly to consumers if they wish to, there revenue will be increased by 8 to 10 percent with same inputs and efforts, it means there profit will increase by about 40%. Overall, new bills and their motives are good but lacks certain critical considerations.
Sir even earlier there was no restriction on farmers to sell directly to consumer. This bills will lead set up of private mandis and middlemen will shift there because 85% of indian farmers are small and due to lack of bargaining power this will ultimately exploit farmers
@@MukeshSingh-su8ow but the current system will not remove .. Govt. Is just providing a new option for the sake of farmers. Its not binding in nature. Use some sense.
@@mayanktiwari4063 after that what about APMC ? Unka haal fr BSNL jaisa hoga Aur MSP ko renew krne ki zarurat thi sab jaante hai kuki sarkari data k hisaab se 6percent farmers ko hi MSP milta hai
Government should not allow hoarding of crops/pulses as small farmers without quantity or storage would be vulnerable. Also make MSP legally binding in Contract Farming too.
@@romilmahant2971 Tumhe 200 kilometres door jana hai kisi location pe, tum ek taxi stand pe jaoge. Agar saare taxi waale tumhe same rate bolein, jo ki tumhaare budget se zyada ho, to kya tumhaare paas koi option bachega? Paidal jaa sakte ho 200 km? Matlab ye hai ki agar corporates kisi farmer ko koi deal propose karenge tu uss farmer ke pass, APMC khatam hone ke baad, us deal ko maanne ke alawa koi option nahi hoga, chahe wo deal kitni bhi kharab deal ho.
FROM FARMER'S DAUGHTER- PLEASE DONT MISSGUIDE.. For the record, ONLY 6% farmers GET MSP BENEFIT is not because of the lack of education for farmers. The government only acquires wheat rice and sugarcane at MSP prices. Other products like maize dalls etc. Their MSP is launched but GOV. hardly acquires them, PRIVATE agencies CAN ACQUIRE THESE PRODUCTS AT LESS THAN MSP.. THE DEMAND OF FARMERS IS TO MAKE ACQUISITION OF CROPS BELOW MSP CRIMINAL.. SHE NO WHERE MENTIONS THAT.. WE FARMERS ARE NOT ILLITERATE.. THATS THE REASON WE KNOW WHEN TO FIGHT FOR RIGHTS
She had explained the things well but finally end up in a erroneous conclusion. Definitely there are lots of issues with current APMC systems. Bt the new acts are going to worsen the situation further. Now onwards the farmers needs to bargain with more powerful purchasers than earlier small traders. The small/medium farmers wouldn't have any bargaining power with big corporates. If the intention was to make MSP mandatory in every private transaction, why did the bills not contain a clause that the price paid to the farmer by the purchaser shall not be less than the notified MSP?. That's why lakhs of farmers are on the streets. I hope you will review your conclusion.
The e-commerce system helps in creating auction-system through price and marketing intelligence system where price will be greater than MSP. The other thing is e-commerce platform unlike APMC has no market fees thus there will be no profit cannibalism.
Recently, there have been strong protests from farmers, especially from the states of Punjab and Haryana, against three farm bills that seek to replace ordinances issued in june 2020. These bills envisage to bring change in some of the key aspects of the farm economy - trade in agricultural commodities, price assurance, farm services including contracts, and stock limits for essential commodities. These bills sought to bring much needed reforms in the agricultural marketing system such as removing restrictions of private stock holding of agricultural produce or creating trading areas free of middlemen and take the market to the farmer. However, farmers are apprehensive that the free market philosophy supported by these bills could undermine the Minimum Support Price (MSP) system and make farmers vulnerable to market forces. Note : Three Farm Bills that are bond of contention: The Farmers' Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Bill, 2020, The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement of Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, 2020, Essential Commodities (Amendment) Bill, 2020. Intended Benefits Associated with These Bills The Bills aim to do away with government interference in agricultural trade by creating trading areas free of middlemen and government taxes outside the structure of Agricultural Produce Market Committees (APMCs). It will allow farmers an option to sell their produce directly to these new zones, without going through the middlemen and paying levies such as mandi fees. It sought to remove stock holding limits as well as curbs on inter-State and intra-State trade, and create a framework for contract farming. Also, these bills promote the creation of Farmer Producer Organisations (FPO) on a large scale and will help in creating a farmer-friendly environment for contract farming where small players can benefit. These bills may enable private players to invest in warehousing, grading and other marketing infrastructure. A combined effect of these bills will help in creating a ‘One Nation, One Market’ for agricultural produce. Issues Raised by The Farmers & Opposition Federal Angle: The provisions in the Farmers’ Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Bill, 2020, provides for unfettered commerce in designated trade areas outside APMC jurisdictions. Apart from this, the bill empowers the Centre government to issue orders to States in furtherance of the law’s objectives. However, matters of trade and agriculture being the part of subjects on the State list, have caused resentment in States. Lack of Consultation: First the ordinance route and now the hastily attempt to pass the Bills without proper consultation adds to the mistrust among various stakeholders including farmers. Also, by allowing ‘trade zones’ to come up outside the APMC area, farmers have become apprehensive that the new system would lead to eventual exit from the minimum support price. Absence of any regulation in non-APMC mandis: Another issue that is raised by the farmers is that the proposed bills give the preference for corporate interests at the cost of farmers’ interests. In absence of any regulation in non-APMC mandis, the farmers may find it difficult to deal with Corporates, as they solely operate on the motive of profit seeking. Non-Favourable Market Conditions: While retail prices have remained high, data from the Wholesale Price Index (WPI) suggest a deceleration in farm gate prices for most agricultural produce. With rising input costs, farmers do not see the free market based framework providing them remunerative prices. These fears gain strength with the experience of States such as Bihar which abolished APMCs in 2006. After the abolition of mandis, farmers in Bihar on average received lower prices compared to the MSP for most crops. Way Forward Improve Agricultural Infrastructure to Strengthen Competition: Government should massively fund the expansion of the APMC market system, make efforts to remove trade cartels, and provide farmers good roads, logistics of scale and real time information. Empowering State Farmers Commissions: Rather than opting for heavy centralisation, the emphasis should be on empowering farmers through State Farmers Commissions recommended by the National Commission for Farmers, to bring about a speedy government response to issues. Consensus Building: The Centre should reach out to those opposing the Bills, including farmers, explain to them the need for reform, and get them on board. Conclusion Without strong institutional arrangements, the free market may harm lakhs of unorganised small farmers, who have been remarkably productive and shored up the economy even during a pandemic
The information is lacking and in a way biased , you need to find answers to points raised below Madam ne sirf purane laws samjhaye , lekin new bills k barre maen kuch bola hi nhi ...🤔 Chlo aap hi bta do Madam ji eplained it legaly ,now as a farmer of punjab allow me to explain it at ground level So lets begin point by point My first point is that out of 3 bills you only explained about 1 bill , what about other 2, so i thought it as my moral duty to explains others too 1. The Essential Commodities (Amendment) Bill Ek baar ek time aesa aya jbb pyaaz ka rate bdd kr 120 rupee kilo ho gya , toh tbb ek baat uthi ki iska karan hae kalabazari , jmakhori ya fir stocking of product , tbb bola gya ki agar mehngayi se bachna hae toh stocking khatm krni chahiye sarkar ko orr hum log uchhal uchhal k support kr rhe the , lekin abb NEW BILL k according corporate and private stickist jitni chahe jma khori kr skte haen , lekin state sarkar jo stock jma krti thi taki time aane pe usko market maen liquify krke use kiya ja ske taki mehngayi ko control rakha ja ske woh provision khatm krdi new bill maen , abbb mujhe yeh nhi samj ata ki logo ka ya kisano ka isme kya fayda , isme indirectly kaunse sector ka fayda hae yeh sochne valli baat hae 🤔... Kahi modi sarkar apnr financial favour k chakkar maen kisi specific sector jaese corporate thugg sector ko benifit ya favour toh nhi de rhi ... Yeg madam aap duscuss krna bhool gye 2. The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, 2020 Pehle farmers apni jamern ya kisi ki jameen theke pe leke kheti krte the or jo bhi produce hota tha usko sell krke apna ghar chlate the , lekin theke pe private ya corporate sector nhi ghus skta tha, mtlb ki agar corporate sector ko buy krna hae kuch toh woh kisan ki produce ko bikne k baad khareed skta hae naki khud theke pe uga ya ugva skta hae kuch bhi , abb kya hoga ki suppose ek bda corporate player hae eg. Reliance group toh woh kya krega ki 1000 chotte kisano se 1-2 acre zameen contract pe lega or usme aoni mrzi ki fasl ugvayega , or uske pass maen 200 kisan haen jo apni apni 1-2 acre zameen maen kheti krenge or jb fasal ko bechne ka time ayega toh jo toh contractor jisko apne liye khud k use k liye specific fasal chahiye hogi woh doosre kisano se lene ki bjaye khud apni contract farming valli fasal use krega or market se kisano ki ugayi huyi fasal woh kyu kharredega agar market se woh khareedega bhi toh usko jo theek lgge ussi rate oe khareedega kyuki MSP ki assurity toh inn bills maen hae hi nhi , isme marrega kaun *gareeb kisan* , or benifit kaun lega cirporate sector valla contractor , sochne ki baat hae🤔 Isi ka ek doosra scenario leke chlte haen Lets say ki agar koi corporate player contract farming 2000 acre maen kr rha hae , jisko na toh apne ghar ka kharcha nikalna hae naa hi zameen khareedne ka paesa lgana hae , sirf per acre benifit nikalna hae , itne badde level pe suppose agar farming cost 900 rupee ayi per acre or corporate player ne apni 2000 acre ki fasal bechni hae or usne doosre corporate company ko 1000 per acre maen bech di toh 18 lakh ki investment krke usko 20 lakh mill gye lekin uss fasal ka market value set ho gya 1000 jabki uska MSP hoga 1300 ya 1500 lekin kyuki abb mandi nhi hae , MSP nhi hae toh jo 200 chotte kisan haen unko wohi fasal obviously km market value maen bechni pdegi yani k jha ek chotte kisaan ko 3000 milne the jisse usne apne ghar ko chalana tha, bachho ko padana tha , beti ki shadi krni thi wahi usko millege 2000 or yeh jo impact hae chotte kisan pe yeh bohat hi jyada brutal hoga Abb isi act ka doosra provision suniye , woh kehta hae ki cobtractor kisaan ki zameen girvi rkh k uspe loan le skta hae , suppose koi cobtractor jis company ko kisan nhi jante woh 2000 kisano ki zameen ko contract farming k bahane se leta hae , fir uspe loan leta hae or vijay malya ki tra desh se bhag jata hae toh uski marr kisko pdegi , woh loan chukayega kaun , kisaan ya bank , effect kisko hoga dedh ko , or benifit kiska hoga sochne ki baat hae🤔 Abb isi bill ki ek orr provision jo kehti hae k kisan contract farming k liye normal legal system ka use nhi kr skta , iske liye alag channel hoga SDM level ka ,yeh provision ka matlab kya hae samj nhi atta ki sarkar ko kya problem kisan ke judicial system ko ise krne se , kahi iska readon yeh toh nhi ki judicial system independent hita hae , lekin administrative system jaese ki SDM , DC , police yeh sarkar , politicians or ameer corporate sectors k under hotte haen , kahi yeh indirectly kisaan ko apahij or system ko corrupt banane ki sajish toh nhi ... Sochne ki baat hae🤔 Aur ek baat hae ki bill is baised as it could be termenated by contracter anytime but farmer cant terminate it Why?Kisan k haq maen bill pr power contractor ko Sochne ki baat hae 🤔 Rahi baat toh Why farmers of haryana and punjab are protsating Instead aap k according toh state governments should protest Abb maen yeh dono points sabhi ko forward kr rha hoon , lekin abhi ek farm bill baki hae jiske flaws madam jitne achge se toh nhi lekin maen explain jroor kroga next comment maen , jisne yeh comment pda orr third bill k flaws janna chahta hae woh next comment ko read krle ....kyuki jusne yeh comment poora pda woh doosra bhi pdd lega Dhanyavad and do read comment by SK T....
hey brother bhaut hi achaa samjhaaya aapne , plzz ese hi logo ko jaagrook kijiye taaki logon ko pata chal sake bjp kitna bada dhoka kar rhi hai kisaano ke saath
FROM FARMER'S DAUGHTER- PLEASE DONT MISSGUIDE.. For the record, ONLY 6% farmers GET MSP BENEFIT is not because of the lack of education for farmers. The government only acquires wheat rice and sugarcane at MSP prices. Other products like maize dalls etc. Their MSP is launched but GOV. hardly acquires them, PRIVATE agencies CAN ACQUIRE THESE PRODUCTS AT LESS THAN MSP.. THE DEMAND OF FARMERS IS TO MAKE ACQUISITION OF CROPS BELOW MSP CRIMINAL.. SHE NO WHERE MENTIONS THAT.. WE FARMERS ARE NOT ILLITERATE.. THATS THE REASON WE KNOW WHEN TO FIGHT FOR rights
MSP is not minimum selling price, it is minimum support price, matlab ye amount ek suugestion hota hai, jis pe sirf gov. Buy krti hai crop. Private players es se km rate pe buy krte hai.. jis region me gov. Acquisition km hai vala pe msp 1800 hona k baad bhi crop 1000 pe bikto hai.. Es mein farmers ki knowledge ki problem nahi hai. Farmera esa legal gurantee banana chahta hai ki es amounts se km pe kahi bhi crop na bika
@Vicky Sandhu ye farmers double income by 2022 target ko achieve karne ke liye aab kux bhi kiya jaa raha hai. Pata nahi 5 trillion economy ke liye kaunsa bramha Astra chalane wale hai sarkar. Target achivement ke liye kux bhi kar sakte hai. Anyway thanks for your ground report.
this Bill Is To Force GMOs In India ..Through Contract farming , Government is Just a Puppet To get The Control Over seeds and Our Health Search This on You Tube 1. >
this Bill Is To Force GMOs In India ..Through Contract farming , To get The Control Over seeds and Our Health ,Government is Just a Puppet Search This on You Tube 1. >
The information is lacking and in a way biased , you need to find answers to points raised below Madam ne sirf purane laws samjhaye , lekin new bills k barre maen kuch bola hi nhi ...🤔 Chlo aap hi bta do Madam ji eplained it legaly ,now as a farmer of punjab allow me to explain it at ground level So lets begin point by point My first point is that out of 3 bills you only explained about 1 bill , what about other 2, so i thought it as my moral duty to explains others too 1. The Essential Commodities (Amendment) Bill Ek baar ek time aesa aya jbb pyaaz ka rate bdd kr 120 rupee kilo ho gya , toh tbb ek baat uthi ki iska karan hae kalabazari , jmakhori ya fir stocking of product , tbb bola gya ki agar mehngayi se bachna hae toh stocking khatm krni chahiye sarkar ko orr hum log uchhal uchhal k support kr rhe the , lekin abb NEW BILL k according corporate and private stickist jitni chahe jma khori kr skte haen , lekin state sarkar jo stock jma krti thi taki time aane pe usko market maen liquify krke use kiya ja ske taki mehngayi ko control rakha ja ske woh provision khatm krdi new bill maen , abbb mujhe yeh nhi samj ata ki logo ka ya kisano ka isme kya fayda , isme indirectly kaunse sector ka fayda hae yeh sochne valli baat hae 🤔... Kahi modi sarkar apnr financial favour k chakkar maen kisi specific sector jaese corporate thugg sector ko benifit ya favour toh nhi de rhi ... Yeg madam aap duscuss krna bhool gye 2. The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, 2020 Pehle farmers apni jamern ya kisi ki jameen theke pe leke kheti krte the or jo bhi produce hota tha usko sell krke apna ghar chlate the , lekin theke pe private ya corporate sector nhi ghus skta tha, mtlb ki agar corporate sector ko buy krna hae kuch toh woh kisan ki produce ko bikne k baad khareed skta hae naki khud theke pe uga ya ugva skta hae kuch bhi , abb kya hoga ki suppose ek bda corporate player hae eg. Reliance group toh woh kya krega ki 1000 chotte kisano se 1-2 acre zameen contract pe lega or usme aoni mrzi ki fasl ugvayega , or uske pass maen 200 kisan haen jo apni apni 1-2 acre zameen maen kheti krenge or jb fasal ko bechne ka time ayega toh jo toh contractor jisko apne liye khud k use k liye specific fasal chahiye hogi woh doosre kisano se lene ki bjaye khud apni contract farming valli fasal use krega or market se kisano ki ugayi huyi fasal woh kyu kharredega agar market se woh khareedega bhi toh usko jo theek lgge ussi rate oe khareedega kyuki MSP ki assurity toh inn bills maen hae hi nhi , isme marrega kaun *gareeb kisan* , or benifit kaun lega cirporate sector valla contractor , sochne ki baat hae🤔 Isi ka ek doosra scenario leke chlte haen Lets say ki agar koi corporate player contract farming 2000 acre maen kr rha hae , jisko na toh apne ghar ka kharcha nikalna hae naa hi zameen khareedne ka paesa lgana hae , sirf per acre benifit nikalna hae , itne badde level pe suppose agar farming cost 900 rupee ayi per acre or corporate player ne apni 2000 acre ki fasal bechni hae or usne doosre corporate company ko 1000 per acre maen bech di toh 18 lakh ki investment krke usko 20 lakh mill gye lekin uss fasal ka market value set ho gya 1000 jabki uska MSP hoga 1300 ya 1500 lekin kyuki abb mandi nhi hae , MSP nhi hae toh jo 200 chotte kisan haen unko wohi fasal obviously km market value maen bechni pdegi yani k jha ek chotte kisaan ko 3000 milne the jisse usne apne ghar ko chalana tha, bachho ko padana tha , beti ki shadi krni thi wahi usko millege 2000 or yeh jo impact hae chotte kisan pe yeh bohat hi jyada brutal hoga Abb isi act ka doosra provision suniye , woh kehta hae ki cobtractor kisaan ki zameen girvi rkh k uspe loan le skta hae , suppose koi cobtractor jis company ko kisan nhi jante woh 2000 kisano ki zameen ko contract farming k bahane se leta hae , fir uspe loan leta hae or vijay malya ki tra desh se bhag jata hae toh uski marr kisko pdegi , woh loan chukayega kaun , kisaan ya bank , effect kisko hoga dedh ko , or benifit kiska hoga sochne ki baat hae🤔 Abb isi bill ki ek orr provision jo kehti hae k kisan contract farming k liye normal legal system ka use nhi kr skta , iske liye alag channel hoga SDM level ka ,yeh provision ka matlab kya hae samj nhi atta ki sarkar ko kya problem kisan ke judicial system ko ise krne se , kahi iska readon yeh toh nhi ki judicial system independent hita hae , lekin administrative system jaese ki SDM , DC , police yeh sarkar , politicians or ameer corporate sectors k under hotte haen , kahi yeh indirectly kisaan ko apahij or system ko corrupt banane ki sajish toh nhi ... Sochne ki baat hae🤔 Aur ek baat hae ki bill is baised as it could be termenated by contracter anytime but farmer cant terminate it Why?Kisan k haq maen bill pr power contractor ko Sochne ki baat hae 🤔 Rahi baat toh Why farmers of haryana and punjab are protsating Instead aap k according toh state governments should protest Abb maen yeh dono points sabhi ko forward kr rha hoon , lekin abhi ek farm bill baki hae jiske flaws madam jitne achge se toh nhi lekin maen explain jroor kroga next comment maen , jisne yeh comment pda orr third bill k flaws janna chahta hae woh next comment ko read krle ....kyuki jusne yeh comment poora pda woh doosra bhi pdd lega Dhanyavad and do read comment by SK T..
@@parmjitkaursandhu1336 yes u r correct (law is not express at every point some things and exception to rule are implied thereto) lol being law student need u remind u laws are there ,government made it but it will be fully correct 😅 it's not possible after all humans are drafting it but finallality lies in FR in same as examples of passport act
Passport act manika gandhi s case supreme court s strict supervision over lose lows or inconsistent laws yes there is some kind of provision in second bill but remember the rule of justifiability of law lies there second point laws are good with bad provision or inconsistent to framers right doesn't means whole law is worng it's law. law can be declared null and void upto the inconsistency it is creating with farmers or anyone's right
You did tell us how farmers were affected by the APMC act.. Very nice.. (Yeh to sabhko pata chal gaya hai) But when did you list out the benefits of the new farm bills..?? (Bills ke fayde kyu nahi bata rahi hai govt)
DO YOU KNOW? She steered clear of real torment of the farmers....Her idea is to inststigate you against the state gov. rather than to focus on the real culprit in the current scenario....
The information is lacking and in a way biased , you need to find answers to points raised below Madam ne sirf purane laws samjhaye , lekin new bills k barre maen kuch bola hi nhi ...🤔 Chlo aap hi bta do Madam ji eplained it legaly ,now as a farmer of punjab allow me to explain it at ground level So lets begin point by point My first point is that out of 3 bills you only explained about 1 bill , what about other 2, so i thought it as my moral duty to explains others too 1. The Essential Commodities (Amendment) Bill Ek baar ek time aesa aya jbb pyaaz ka rate bdd kr 120 rupee kilo ho gya , toh tbb ek baat uthi ki iska karan hae kalabazari , jmakhori ya fir stocking of product , tbb bola gya ki agar mehngayi se bachna hae toh stocking khatm krni chahiye sarkar ko orr hum log uchhal uchhal k support kr rhe the , lekin abb NEW BILL k according corporate and private stickist jitni chahe jma khori kr skte haen , lekin state sarkar jo stock jma krti thi taki time aane pe usko market maen liquify krke use kiya ja ske taki mehngayi ko control rakha ja ske woh provision khatm krdi new bill maen , abbb mujhe yeh nhi samj ata ki logo ka ya kisano ka isme kya fayda , isme indirectly kaunse sector ka fayda hae yeh sochne valli baat hae 🤔... Kahi modi sarkar apnr financial favour k chakkar maen kisi specific sector jaese corporate thugg sector ko benifit ya favour toh nhi de rhi ... Yeg madam aap duscuss krna bhool gye 2. The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, 2020 Pehle farmers apni jamern ya kisi ki jameen theke pe leke kheti krte the or jo bhi produce hota tha usko sell krke apna ghar chlate the , lekin theke pe private ya corporate sector nhi ghus skta tha, mtlb ki agar corporate sector ko buy krna hae kuch toh woh kisan ki produce ko bikne k baad khareed skta hae naki khud theke pe uga ya ugva skta hae kuch bhi , abb kya hoga ki suppose ek bda corporate player hae eg. Reliance group toh woh kya krega ki 1000 chotte kisano se 1-2 acre zameen contract pe lega or usme aoni mrzi ki fasl ugvayega , or uske pass maen 200 kisan haen jo apni apni 1-2 acre zameen maen kheti krenge or jb fasal ko bechne ka time ayega toh jo toh contractor jisko apne liye khud k use k liye specific fasal chahiye hogi woh doosre kisano se lene ki bjaye khud apni contract farming valli fasal use krega or market se kisano ki ugayi huyi fasal woh kyu kharredega agar market se woh khareedega bhi toh usko jo theek lgge ussi rate oe khareedega kyuki MSP ki assurity toh inn bills maen hae hi nhi , isme marrega kaun *gareeb kisan* , or benifit kaun lega cirporate sector valla contractor , sochne ki baat hae🤔 Isi ka ek doosra scenario leke chlte haen Lets say ki agar koi corporate player contract farming 2000 acre maen kr rha hae , jisko na toh apne ghar ka kharcha nikalna hae naa hi zameen khareedne ka paesa lgana hae , sirf per acre benifit nikalna hae , itne badde level pe suppose agar farming cost 900 rupee ayi per acre or corporate player ne apni 2000 acre ki fasal bechni hae or usne doosre corporate company ko 1000 per acre maen bech di toh 18 lakh ki investment krke usko 20 lakh mill gye lekin uss fasal ka market value set ho gya 1000 jabki uska MSP hoga 1300 ya 1500 lekin kyuki abb mandi nhi hae , MSP nhi hae toh jo 200 chotte kisan haen unko wohi fasal obviously km market value maen bechni pdegi yani k jha ek chotte kisaan ko 3000 milne the jisse usne apne ghar ko chalana tha, bachho ko padana tha , beti ki shadi krni thi wahi usko millege 2000 or yeh jo impact hae chotte kisan pe yeh bohat hi jyada brutal hoga Abb isi act ka doosra provision suniye , woh kehta hae ki cobtractor kisaan ki zameen girvi rkh k uspe loan le skta hae , suppose koi cobtractor jis company ko kisan nhi jante woh 2000 kisano ki zameen ko contract farming k bahane se leta hae , fir uspe loan leta hae or vijay malya ki tra desh se bhag jata hae toh uski marr kisko pdegi , woh loan chukayega kaun , kisaan ya bank , effect kisko hoga dedh ko , or benifit kiska hoga sochne ki baat hae🤔 Abb isi bill ki ek orr provision jo kehti hae k kisan contract farming k liye normal legal system ka use nhi kr skta , iske liye alag channel hoga SDM level ka ,yeh provision ka matlab kya hae samj nhi atta ki sarkar ko kya problem kisan ke judicial system ko ise krne se , kahi iska readon yeh toh nhi ki judicial system independent hita hae , lekin administrative system jaese ki SDM , DC , police yeh sarkar , politicians or ameer corporate sectors k under hotte haen , kahi yeh indirectly kisaan ko apahij or system ko corrupt banane ki sajish toh nhi ... Sochne ki baat hae🤔 Aur ek baat hae ki bill is baised as it could be termenated by contracter anytime but farmer cant terminate it Why?Kisan k haq maen bill pr power contractor ko Sochne ki baat hae 🤔 Rahi baat toh Why farmers of haryana and punjab are protsating Instead aap k according toh state governments should protest Abb maen yeh dono points sabhi ko forward kr rha hoon , lekin abhi ek farm bill baki hae jiske flaws madam jitne achge se toh nhi lekin maen explain jroor kroga next comment maen , jisne yeh comment pda orr third bill k flaws janna chahta hae woh next comment ko read krle ....kyuki jusne yeh comment poora pda woh doosra bhi pdd lega Dhanyavad and do read comment by SK T..
I am requesting to all farmers plz. Plz. Read these three ordinances of farm bill. This farm bill will benefit the farmers. plz don't believe on political or farmers leaders rumors. Farm bill is providing you choices and Read it and then react. Specially punjab people plz read and don't take this protest on your ego.🇮🇳
Bro actually they take time to understand bill nd congress and other opposition take it as an opportunity to narrate there own story and create violence in country just like CAA and jammu kashmir stuff. And every time aam aadmi got effected.
Here want to conclude from stats mentioned in video 1. Check the money distribution to states from GOI, Punjab is in the list of developed states having very well established APMC architecture, But on the other side look at Bihar where np APMC So how anyone can say removing APMC will give the better opportunities to farmers 2. What about the 1750Cr or respective amount for State Govts? 3. Only 6% people getting MSP, so means need to improve MSP providing architecture which is feasible with APMC architecture or LAW
We are not convinced by the politicians We are convinced by the prices of our produce we are getting The crop(rice) which would sell for 3000-4000 per quintal is now selling for 1100-1600 whic you can cleart see is very is not even half of it Also guarantee to MSP ( for 22 crops) is said by the government but it is not being provided even for the crops they are saying Also the third law which removes the limit of storage was never for farmers as setting up cold storage is very expensive and to acquire license you ought to have very good Connection with politicians of the ruling party therefore it was clearly meant for industrialist Last and the most important thing of this protest is that if there are private players in it there will be no monitoring the MRP of crops so even if they provide MSP to farmers the new farm bill be problematic for lower and middle class of our country
@@vitaminprotein2309 yes those are the concerns we are talking about, now they will call us anti modi, even without any ground reality. Even , I am supporter for him in many cases, but not for this. And Galat ko Galat hi kehna chahiye,
@@vitaminprotein2309 According to my knowledge of this bill, it will work as below mentioned way. Please correct me if i am wrong. I am here to learn more about this bill. You look like have some knowledge regarding this, hence i am sharing this with u. If corporate enters in this field, the price of the product will be fixed before production. So if farmer thinks offered price is not good enough then he can tell the corporate, he will produce something else. As on season and off season product price is difference. So the corporate have to bid some thing in between. Like on season per quintal rice price is 1100-1600 but in off season it is 3000-4000 quintal. If the price is known by farmer before he produce something. Then there will be less risk of loss.
Hey mam!! Your lectures are so interesting. I suggest FL team, especially priya mam to start lecture series on Indian National movement and Indian constitution... Good luck
There are few things that you could have explained as well like what impact these bills will have in future, an example of similar thing happened in past, why this approach failed in western countries, and how Bihar is doing now since they have implemented these laws in past. I am not a farmer and not biased either but see the long term impact of these bills on them clearly.
this Bill Is To Force GMOs In India ..Through Contract farming , To get The Control Over seeds and Our Health ,Government is Just a Puppet Search This on You Tube 1. >
The information is lacking and in a way biased , you need to find answers to points raised below Madam ne sirf purane laws samjhaye , lekin new bills k barre maen kuch bola hi nhi ...🤔 Chlo aap hi bta do Madam ji eplained it legaly ,now as a farmer of punjab allow me to explain it at ground level So lets begin point by point My first point is that out of 3 bills you only explained about 1 bill , what about other 2, so i thought it as my moral duty to explains others too 1. The Essential Commodities (Amendment) Bill Ek baar ek time aesa aya jbb pyaaz ka rate bdd kr 120 rupee kilo ho gya , toh tbb ek baat uthi ki iska karan hae kalabazari , jmakhori ya fir stocking of product , tbb bola gya ki agar mehngayi se bachna hae toh stocking khatm krni chahiye sarkar ko orr hum log uchhal uchhal k support kr rhe the , lekin abb NEW BILL k according corporate and private stickist jitni chahe jma khori kr skte haen , lekin state sarkar jo stock jma krti thi taki time aane pe usko market maen liquify krke use kiya ja ske taki mehngayi ko control rakha ja ske woh provision khatm krdi new bill maen , abbb mujhe yeh nhi samj ata ki logo ka ya kisano ka isme kya fayda , isme indirectly kaunse sector ka fayda hae yeh sochne valli baat hae 🤔... Kahi modi sarkar apnr financial favour k chakkar maen kisi specific sector jaese corporate thugg sector ko benifit ya favour toh nhi de rhi ... Yeg madam aap duscuss krna bhool gye 2. The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, 2020 Pehle farmers apni jamern ya kisi ki jameen theke pe leke kheti krte the or jo bhi produce hota tha usko sell krke apna ghar chlate the , lekin theke pe private ya corporate sector nhi ghus skta tha, mtlb ki agar corporate sector ko buy krna hae kuch toh woh kisan ki produce ko bikne k baad khareed skta hae naki khud theke pe uga ya ugva skta hae kuch bhi , abb kya hoga ki suppose ek bda corporate player hae eg. Reliance group toh woh kya krega ki 1000 chotte kisano se 1-2 acre zameen contract pe lega or usme aoni mrzi ki fasl ugvayega , or uske pass maen 200 kisan haen jo apni apni 1-2 acre zameen maen kheti krenge or jb fasal ko bechne ka time ayega toh jo toh contractor jisko apne liye khud k use k liye specific fasal chahiye hogi woh doosre kisano se lene ki bjaye khud apni contract farming valli fasal use krega or market se kisano ki ugayi huyi fasal woh kyu kharredega agar market se woh khareedega bhi toh usko jo theek lgge ussi rate oe khareedega kyuki MSP ki assurity toh inn bills maen hae hi nhi , isme marrega kaun *gareeb kisan* , or benifit kaun lega cirporate sector valla contractor , sochne ki baat hae🤔 Isi ka ek doosra scenario leke chlte haen Lets say ki agar koi corporate player contract farming 2000 acre maen kr rha hae , jisko na toh apne ghar ka kharcha nikalna hae naa hi zameen khareedne ka paesa lgana hae , sirf per acre benifit nikalna hae , itne badde level pe suppose agar farming cost 900 rupee ayi per acre or corporate player ne apni 2000 acre ki fasal bechni hae or usne doosre corporate company ko 1000 per acre maen bech di toh 18 lakh ki investment krke usko 20 lakh mill gye lekin uss fasal ka market value set ho gya 1000 jabki uska MSP hoga 1300 ya 1500 lekin kyuki abb mandi nhi hae , MSP nhi hae toh jo 200 chotte kisan haen unko wohi fasal obviously km market value maen bechni pdegi yani k jha ek chotte kisaan ko 3000 milne the jisse usne apne ghar ko chalana tha, bachho ko padana tha , beti ki shadi krni thi wahi usko millege 2000 or yeh jo impact hae chotte kisan pe yeh bohat hi jyada brutal hoga Abb isi act ka doosra provision suniye , woh kehta hae ki cobtractor kisaan ki zameen girvi rkh k uspe loan le skta hae , suppose koi cobtractor jis company ko kisan nhi jante woh 2000 kisano ki zameen ko contract farming k bahane se leta hae , fir uspe loan leta hae or vijay malya ki tra desh se bhag jata hae toh uski marr kisko pdegi , woh loan chukayega kaun , kisaan ya bank , effect kisko hoga dedh ko , or benifit kiska hoga sochne ki baat hae🤔 Abb isi bill ki ek orr provision jo kehti hae k kisan contract farming k liye normal legal system ka use nhi kr skta , iske liye alag channel hoga SDM level ka ,yeh provision ka matlab kya hae samj nhi atta ki sarkar ko kya problem kisan ke judicial system ko ise krne se , kahi iska readon yeh toh nhi ki judicial system independent hita hae , lekin administrative system jaese ki SDM , DC , police yeh sarkar , politicians or ameer corporate sectors k under hotte haen , kahi yeh indirectly kisaan ko apahij or system ko corrupt banane ki sajish toh nhi ... Sochne ki baat hae🤔 Aur ek baat hae ki bill is baised as it could be termenated by contracter anytime but farmer cant terminate it Why?Kisan k haq maen bill pr power contractor ko Sochne ki baat hae 🤔 Rahi baat toh Why farmers of haryana and punjab are protsating Instead aap k according toh state governments should protest Abb maen yeh dono points sabhi ko forward kr rha hoon , lekin abhi ek farm bill baki hae jiske flaws madam jitne achge se toh nhi lekin maen explain jroor kroga next comment maen , jisne yeh comment pda orr third bill k flaws janna chahta hae woh next comment ko read krle ....kyuki jusne yeh comment poora pda woh doosra bhi pdd lega Dhanyavad and do read comment by SK T...
MSP is not minimum selling price, it is minimum support price, matlab ye amount ek suugestion hota hai, jis pe sirf gov. Buy krti hai crop. Private players es se km rate pe buy krte hai.. jis region me gov. Acquisition km hai vala pe msp 1800 hona k baad bhi crop 1000 pe bikto hai.. Es mein farmers ki knowledge ki problem nahi hai. Farmera esa legal gurantee banana chahta hai ki es amounts se km pe kahi bhi crop na bika
She has given you wrong information.. only 6% of farmers produce is acquired at MSP. Not cz of their lack of education.. its because only giv.acquires at MSP, the private traders they buy at less than MSP.. farmers are agitating to make MSP compulsary for any purchase to be made from farmers.
this Bill Is To Force GMOs In India ..Through Contract farming , To get The Control Over seeds and Our Health ,Government is Just a Puppet Search This on You Tube 1. Genetic Roulette The Gamble of Our Lives
2. Bill Gates and his plans for world's future - Real Eyes 3. Modi government के farm bill के उन दिक्कतों की बात जिसने America-Europe में पहले से तबाही मचा रखी है
@@kabeerkabeer3285 ooo angrez ki ulad Angrez jo lakho baar m kr pae h vo hm Hindustanion ne ek baar m kia h . West ka example dena band kro Or aap hi dekho in Librandu media ko Hme to Bhartiya hone pr fakr h😎😎
@@MeenuKumari-hy2sl o madam ji Thori si apni dharamvaad , jaativadd K zehar se bhari hui Soch ko full stop lgao or apne desh k logo k liye sochna shuru kro thora logically , ek tarf toh apko duniya se mukabla krna hae or doosri tarf aap glbalisation se drte ho , koi ek criteria toh accept kro , dont be hypocratic but a factual person
FROM FARMER'S DAUGHTER- PLEASE DONT MISSGUIDE.. For the record, ONLY 6% farmers GET MSP BENEFIT is not because of the lack of education for farmers. The government only acquires wheat rice and sugarcane at MSP prices. Other products like maize dalls etc. Their MSP is launched but GOV. hardly acquires them, PRIVATE agencies CAN ACQUIRE THESE PRODUCTS AT LESS THAN MSP.. THE DEMAND OF FARMERS IS TO MAKE ACQUISITION OF CROPS BELOW MSP CRIMINAL.. SHE NO WHERE MENTIONS THAT.. WE FARMERS ARE NOT ILLITERATE.. THATS THE REASON WE KNOW WHEN TO FIGHT FOR OUR RIGHTS
Ma'am I wouldn't say wether this bill is bad or not.. But if this bill fails & farmers suffer in the future our mainstream media will never discuss it as they are praising & discussing now
@@abhinavsharma3819 Let me conclude it better as long as BJP is in power popular media like republic Tv, Times now will not talk about this. On what basis an I saying this: its because they didn't talk about so many issues like NTPC, RRB, JEE and for a long time they didn't show about farmer protest as well, mainstream media as became a place for hate speech rather than a place of genuine news.
this Bill Is To Force GMOs In India ..Through Contract farming , Government is Just a Puppet To get The Control Over seeds and Our Health Search This on You Tube 1. >
She is missguiding please cross check the facts regarding MSP.. and farmers demands for making MSP compulsary.. farmers are well awair of MSP. But in states without mandis private traders buy products at rate much less than MSP
Explaination of the law but it doesn't tell how bad it is for individual farmer. If they want to bring this law in then give more power to farmers not to the corporations.
The information is lacking and in a way biased , you need to find answers to points raised below Madam ne sirf purane laws samjhaye , lekin new bills k barre maen kuch bola hi nhi ...🤔 Chlo aap hi bta do Madam ji eplained it legaly ,now as a farmer of punjab allow me to explain it at ground level So lets begin point by point My first point is that out of 3 bills you only explained about 1 bill , what about other 2, so i thought it as my moral duty to explains others too 1. The Essential Commodities (Amendment) Bill Ek baar ek time aesa aya jbb pyaaz ka rate bdd kr 120 rupee kilo ho gya , toh tbb ek baat uthi ki iska karan hae kalabazari , jmakhori ya fir stocking of product , tbb bola gya ki agar mehngayi se bachna hae toh stocking khatm krni chahiye sarkar ko orr hum log uchhal uchhal k support kr rhe the , lekin abb NEW BILL k according corporate and private stickist jitni chahe jma khori kr skte haen , lekin state sarkar jo stock jma krti thi taki time aane pe usko market maen liquify krke use kiya ja ske taki mehngayi ko control rakha ja ske woh provision khatm krdi new bill maen , abbb mujhe yeh nhi samj ata ki logo ka ya kisano ka isme kya fayda , isme indirectly kaunse sector ka fayda hae yeh sochne valli baat hae 🤔... Kahi modi sarkar apnr financial favour k chakkar maen kisi specific sector jaese corporate thugg sector ko benifit ya favour toh nhi de rhi ... Yeg madam aap duscuss krna bhool gye 2. The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, 2020 Pehle farmers apni jamern ya kisi ki jameen theke pe leke kheti krte the or jo bhi produce hota tha usko sell krke apna ghar chlate the , lekin theke pe private ya corporate sector nhi ghus skta tha, mtlb ki agar corporate sector ko buy krna hae kuch toh woh kisan ki produce ko bikne k baad khareed skta hae naki khud theke pe uga ya ugva skta hae kuch bhi , abb kya hoga ki suppose ek bda corporate player hae eg. Reliance group toh woh kya krega ki 1000 chotte kisano se 1-2 acre zameen contract pe lega or usme aoni mrzi ki fasl ugvayega , or uske pass maen 200 kisan haen jo apni apni 1-2 acre zameen maen kheti krenge or jb fasal ko bechne ka time ayega toh jo toh contractor jisko apne liye khud k use k liye specific fasal chahiye hogi woh doosre kisano se lene ki bjaye khud apni contract farming valli fasal use krega or market se kisano ki ugayi huyi fasal woh kyu kharredega agar market se woh khareedega bhi toh usko jo theek lgge ussi rate oe khareedega kyuki MSP ki assurity toh inn bills maen hae hi nhi , isme marrega kaun *gareeb kisan* , or benifit kaun lega cirporate sector valla contractor , sochne ki baat hae🤔 Isi ka ek doosra scenario leke chlte haen Lets say ki agar koi corporate player contract farming 2000 acre maen kr rha hae , jisko na toh apne ghar ka kharcha nikalna hae naa hi zameen khareedne ka paesa lgana hae , sirf per acre benifit nikalna hae , itne badde level pe suppose agar farming cost 900 rupee ayi per acre or corporate player ne apni 2000 acre ki fasal bechni hae or usne doosre corporate company ko 1000 per acre maen bech di toh 18 lakh ki investment krke usko 20 lakh mill gye lekin uss fasal ka market value set ho gya 1000 jabki uska MSP hoga 1300 ya 1500 lekin kyuki abb mandi nhi hae , MSP nhi hae toh jo 200 chotte kisan haen unko wohi fasal obviously km market value maen bechni pdegi yani k jha ek chotte kisaan ko 3000 milne the jisse usne apne ghar ko chalana tha, bachho ko padana tha , beti ki shadi krni thi wahi usko millege 2000 or yeh jo impact hae chotte kisan pe yeh bohat hi jyada brutal hoga Abb isi act ka doosra provision suniye , woh kehta hae ki cobtractor kisaan ki zameen girvi rkh k uspe loan le skta hae , suppose koi cobtractor jis company ko kisan nhi jante woh 2000 kisano ki zameen ko contract farming k bahane se leta hae , fir uspe loan leta hae or vijay malya ki tra desh se bhag jata hae toh uski marr kisko pdegi , woh loan chukayega kaun , kisaan ya bank , effect kisko hoga dedh ko , or benifit kiska hoga sochne ki baat hae🤔 Abb isi bill ki ek orr provision jo kehti hae k kisan contract farming k liye normal legal system ka use nhi kr skta , iske liye alag channel hoga SDM level ka ,yeh provision ka matlab kya hae samj nhi atta ki sarkar ko kya problem kisan ke judicial system ko ise krne se , kahi iska readon yeh toh nhi ki judicial system independent hita hae , lekin administrative system jaese ki SDM , DC , police yeh sarkar , politicians or ameer corporate sectors k under hotte haen , kahi yeh indirectly kisaan ko apahij or system ko corrupt banane ki sajish toh nhi ... Sochne ki baat hae🤔 Aur ek baat hae ki bill is baised as it could be termenated by contracter anytime but farmer cant terminate it Why?Kisan k haq maen bill pr power contractor ko Sochne ki baat hae 🤔 Rahi baat toh Why farmers of haryana and punjab are protsating Instead aap k according toh state governments should protest Abb maen yeh dono points sabhi ko forward kr rha hoon , lekin abhi ek farm bill baki hae jiske flaws madam jitne achge se toh nhi lekin maen explain jroor kroga next comment maen , jisne yeh comment pda orr third bill k flaws janna chahta hae woh next comment ko read krle ....kyuki jusne yeh comment poora pda woh doosra bhi pdd lega Dhanyavad and do read comment by SK T..
Modi is rejecting the earlier setup installed by earlier govt regimes. . 1) Playing of role in External Domain: Food Corporation of India was established with the same intention which Modi is now propagating with this new farm bill. . The problem of farmers is that they can not store their output. It is very difficult to do sorting, cleaning, packaging etc, transport to other markets where they can get more price. . Farmers can not do this extra job, they need helping-services. Farmers need warehouses for storing, materials and tools for processing & packaging, transportation help to bring their product to the warehouse and send it to the market for sale. . FCI has not built enough well developed storage houses, packaging, transportation setups where farmers can hire those services so that they can sell their products to prospective buyers when there is a right price for their end-products. . Modi is becoming an assistant to businessmen, not as an assistant to farmers.
this Bill Is To Force GMOs In India ..Through Contract farming , To get The Control Over seeds and Our Health ,Government is Just a Puppet Search This on You Tube 1. >
Srivathsan...understood bhai...what Raga meant was ki hum log food processing industry lagayenge....but yeh industry govt PSU lagayegi ya koi pvt company jaise ke pepsico...cocacola...Ambani Adani lagayenge.....??
I heard a very interesting analogy today, A 10 floor building did not have a lift, so people had problem climbing up and down. Specially the elderly and the kids, so the society started exploring options. Finally they got some donkeys, who could carry people up and down. The donkey owners would charge people for carrying them up and down for a fee and would also pay 10% to the society from the revenue they earned. It was a very happy situation for all involved. After sometime the society management changed, the new management decided to install a lift for carrying people up and down. All hell broke loose and everyone started protesting, this is not fair, society will loose revenue, the donkey owners will be jobless and no food for them (human rights issue), the donkeys will be worthless (animals rights issue), all were angry. Society management clarified, the lift is available to all but the gentlemen who wanted to use the donkeys could still do it. But no, the agitation continued and so finally the new management had to succumb to the pressure. The final arrangement was arrived and so anyone who wanted to climb the building could still use the donkey. The donkey would carry a person, go in the lift and carry people up & down. All were happy. Disclaimer: any resemblance of this with the farmers agitation is a coincidence.
This video is simply one of the best I have found breaking down the whole Farm Bills...thank you so much.
More Unbiased Than Anyone Else Videos on Farm Bills. ❤️🙏 Thank You Mam
Yeh to biased tarah se hi apne discuss kar dia, yesehi lakho log road par 4-5 month se a kar nehi bathi hain. You must also discuss the negetive point of the bill jo fermers soch rahe hain ki yeh vi hoga.
Same tarah se BSNL hathake JIO la dia, ab APMC hathake koe or la denge, or pura munafa wo le jayenge, MSP private sector main kiu nehi hain , ho sakta hain alag alag state main alag alag MSP de do.. do to sehi..
Nehi kal agar sab trader a gaye or bole ki 1800 KA SAMAN 600 MAIN BECHO NEHI TUM TUMAHARE PASS HI RAKKHO. to kia karoge tab.
Good, unbaised and neutral analysis of whole subject, thank you.
Welcome!
@@_FinologyLegal omggg you reply?!
neutral presentation excellent
@@_FinologyLegal U prostutite have never been to a farm, how come you know what's good bad for farmers
@@RAY-Money khud banale fir video !! How dare u abuse anybody else
You are too good to explain it. The best part of your lecture is- "Your discussion was limited to law points only. It was unbiased legal discussion"... Keep it up and. Keep sharing. Thanks.
UPSC civil services....I m writing mains this year.
Your vedios are way better than any coaching institute.
same bro. Although this video is complete bs and reeks of bias
@@PS1604 bias bs ? Rationality flush kardi kya subah subah?
All the best bro
MSP is not minimum selling price, it is minimum support price, matlab ye amount ek suugestion hota hai, jis pe sirf gov. Buy krti hai crop. Private players es se km rate pe buy krte hai.. jis region me gov. Acquisition km hai vala pe msp 1800 hona k baad bhi crop 1000 pe bikto hai..
Es mein farmers ki knowledge ki problem nahi hai. Farmera esa legal gurantee banana chahta hai ki es amounts se km pe kahi bhi crop na bika
All the best
This should be showed on TV
Tv wale sare moorkh ho chuke hai ab..
MSP is not minimum selling price, it is minimum support price, matlab ye amount ek suugestion hota hai, jis pe sirf gov. Buy krti hai crop. Private players es se km rate pe buy krte hai.. jis region me gov. Acquisition km hai vala pe msp 1800 hona k baad bhi crop 1000 pe bikto hai..
Es mein farmers ki knowledge ki problem nahi hai. Farmera esa legal gurantee banana chahta hai ki es amounts se km pe kahi bhi crop na bika
Tv wale adds nahi center se passe lete ha , I'll not see TV news again
Bilkul TV per dikahna chahiye
TV is a joke now.
'Minimum time maximum explanation' is your saving grace mam. i appreciate your efforts and great respect for the effort which u have made behind this informative video.
We def need such subjects covered in school level. I wasnt aware of so many things..thx u very much
Just realised u have studied from the college I m studying in and it makes me feel proud
I know some people who have lost lives in peaceful protest....sad for that
Which college is that?
Peaceful protests? Lol
@@av2319 NALSAR (NLU HYDERABAD)
@@doshyantsingh3132 yes peaceful
@@doshyantsingh3132 yes peaceful
Dear mam🙏🕊🌹
आप किसी भी topic पर
बोहत अच्छा समझाती हो
मैन आपके sirf 2 वीडियो ही
देखे है।
But
I am very impress with you👌
And
Your way of communication is spectacular. 👍
Your inossency and qtness is
Also the good qualities of your
Personality🕊🙏👍
God bless you mam🌠🌠🌠🌠
YOu are the proud of india🙏🇮🇳
FROM FARMER'S DAUGHTER- PLEASE DONT MISSGUIDE.. For the record, ONLY 6% farmers GET MSP BENEFIT is not because of the lack of education for farmers. The government only acquires wheat rice and sugarcane at MSP prices. Other products like maize dalls etc. Their MSP is launched but GOV. hardly acquires them, PRIVATE agencies CAN ACQUIRE THESE PRODUCTS AT LESS THAN MSP.. THE DEMAND OF FARMERS IS TO MAKE ACQUISITION OF CROPS BELOW MSP CRIMINAL.. SHE NO WHERE MENTIONS THAT.. WE FARMERS ARE NOT ILLITERATE.. THATS THE REASON WE KNOW WHEN TO FIGHT FOR OUR RIGHTS
I request you to Please restart weekly current affairs🙂... Thank you for this great efforts ☺️🙏
@Vicky Sandhu well said veere 👍
@Vicky Sandhu well explained sir...
@Vicky Sandhu great 🙏🏻🙏🏻
Gist of all farm bills, the concept of rich and poor state is new for me,
Very well explained mam
Thank you
Yes , I am seeing this part for the first time .
This is the reason some people say there's favour for some states .
Punjab state gov can't get all it's money from Mandi - that is the main issue and the local government is pushing the farmers to go against the centre .
City guys will never understand the sentiments of farmers. City guys are like birds. They move from pond to pond. But the farmers are like fish in the pond. Their life and world starts and ends in the pond.
True bro...
From tamilnadu
Just tell me r u happy without this bill? Were u happy?? Was the ild apmc was very beneficial fir farmers?? Ni agents were taking money ?? Did farmer got his deserving money for the produce?? If any one also is yes i will nit support this bill. Evryone who is supporting is not a city guy buddy u just do not know whats the real reason for declining of agriculture in india
City guys also understand bhai...
Farmers get loan waiver every election. Does shop owner, traders get that?
Same happened with me bro on Quora app. But those guys don't tried to understand me and just spelling namo namo.
Nobody cares about Farmers whether it is a Politician or aCity guys.
They just want food and don't care about farmers
Nothing Political, Only knowledge!🔥🙏
Exactly 👍🏼
@@LiveTradeIndia main Ek kisan ka beta ho mujhe koi nuksan nahi lagta
@@LiveTradeIndia tumhara nam Bata raha hai ki Tum kisan Kam congressi jyada ho 😂🤣
@@LiveTradeIndia bhai apmc mandi me bde kisan hi bechte hai
Mai chote kisan ke family se hu
Hmara pura paddy govt MSP par co-operative society me hi bech dete hai
Chote kisan ko isse matalb hi nhi
FROM FARMER'S DAUGHTER- PLEASE DONT MISSGUIDE.. For the record, ONLY 6% farmers GET MSP BENEFIT is not because of the lack of education for farmers. The government only acquires wheat rice and sugarcane at MSP prices. Other products like maize dalls etc. Their MSP is launched but GOV. hardly acquires them, PRIVATE agencies CAN ACQUIRE THESE PRODUCTS AT LESS THAN MSP.. THE DEMAND OF FARMERS IS TO MAKE ACQUISITION OF CROPS BELOW MSP CRIMINAL.. SHE NO WHERE MENTIONS THAT.. WE FARMERS ARE NOT ILLITERATE.. THATS THE REASON WE KNOW WHEN TO FIGHT FOR OUR RIGHTS
How can anyone can be so good in explaining....with crystal clear facts....Explaining Skills you developed is amazing... Thanks for the video mam
You're most welcome!
Mam ur teaching method is very simple......ap koi bhi topic bht detail s aur ache s padhati h
Thank you
@@_FinologyLegal
Mam also share farm law by Vikas sir drishti IAS....
To spread awareness.....!!
You are amazing. The way you teach, oh my god. You are an inspiration.
Thank you so much.
DPp
True.
Great explanation
@@_FinologyLegal sktrnirhthjthjig she reply’s hejrhbrnrbbrnr omggg 😆 *gets excited* let me chat 💬 *chats and gets no reply’s from her*
*gets sad 😢 * she-she di-didn’t r-reply *starts crying* 😭 plz replyyy
The best explanation I have ever heard! Brilliant! This should be tending. Guys get this trending. For the global public get this in English too.. even if there is closed captioning.
One of the best educator on youtube
Educating farmers is wonderful point.
Thankyou ma'am. The best thing about your Video is that you explained everything with respect to our constitutions law & order, statistics and also how our govt. operates & recieves tax which therefore leaves no scope of giving a biased review.
Good Explanation.
However you discussed only flaws of various APMC Acts and existing practices, not how new Bills will resolve these issues (except few). You didn't discussed about new bill for agreement between farmers and sponsors, how the disputes among them will be resolved, what will be the power of courts in this regard, what if SDM is unbiased or his decision otherwise prejudice to farmers, what if produce will not match quality,grade standards, criteria (inspection will be done by sponsor and they can reject). The price can be varied and corporates are smarter than innocent farmers, and they may take undue advantage of section 5. Bargaining power of big corporates may induce individual farmers to sell their produce at lower price, no other central law prohibits it. Corporates can now stock huge in their cold storage and sell later at higher price.
I appreciate that now farmers can sell their produce directly to consumers if they wish to, there revenue will be increased by 8 to 10 percent with same inputs and efforts, it means there profit will increase by about 40%.
Overall, new bills and their motives are good but lacks certain critical considerations.
what about government.... when it is itself biased
May i ask how are you calculating the increase ? What mathematical model are you using?
Sir even earlier there was no restriction on farmers to sell directly to consumer.
This bills will lead set up of private mandis and middlemen will shift there because 85% of indian farmers are small and due to lack of bargaining power this will ultimately exploit farmers
@@MukeshSingh-su8ow but the current system will not remove .. Govt. Is just providing a new option for the sake of farmers.
Its not binding in nature.
Use some sense.
@@mayanktiwari4063 after that what about APMC ?
Unka haal fr BSNL jaisa hoga
Aur MSP ko renew krne ki zarurat thi sab jaante hai kuki sarkari data k hisaab se 6percent farmers ko hi MSP milta hai
Thank you! Politics has a way of destroying clarity when a nation truly needs it.
Bahut achha mam ji may god media bhi aise hi samjhate so that protest kam ho 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻💓💓
Excellent 👍 Skill to explain any topic...very easy to understand... Thanks a lot Ma'am...
This presentation should be put on tv
Government should not allow hoarding of crops/pulses as small farmers without quantity or storage would be vulnerable. Also make MSP legally binding in Contract Farming too.
>
Search This on You Tube
this Bill Is To Force GMOs In India ..Through Contract farming
To get The Control Over seeds and Our Health
>
Search This on You Tube
Absolutely..
contract farming mai kisan rate decide krega aur agar rate nhi pasand to vo existing system mai bhi sell kr sakta hai
@@romilmahant2971 Tumhe 200 kilometres door jana hai kisi location pe, tum ek taxi stand pe jaoge. Agar saare taxi waale tumhe same rate bolein, jo ki tumhaare budget se zyada ho, to kya tumhaare paas koi option bachega? Paidal jaa sakte ho 200 km?
Matlab ye hai ki agar corporates kisi farmer ko koi deal propose karenge tu uss farmer ke pass, APMC khatam hone ke baad, us deal ko maanne ke alawa koi option nahi hoga, chahe wo deal kitni bhi kharab deal ho.
What an explanation..commendable👏👏👏😄
Anyways, your way of explanation is par excellence!😌❤️
Samruddhi Ganjale burnol laga lo modiji hi jitenge
@@toiletbug5547 well, your name totally suits you😂😂
FROM FARMER'S DAUGHTER- PLEASE DONT MISSGUIDE.. For the record, ONLY 6% farmers GET MSP BENEFIT is not because of the lack of education for farmers. The government only acquires wheat rice and sugarcane at MSP prices. Other products like maize dalls etc. Their MSP is launched but GOV. hardly acquires them, PRIVATE agencies CAN ACQUIRE THESE PRODUCTS AT LESS THAN MSP.. THE DEMAND OF FARMERS IS TO MAKE ACQUISITION OF CROPS BELOW MSP CRIMINAL.. SHE NO WHERE MENTIONS THAT.. WE FARMERS ARE NOT ILLITERATE.. THATS THE REASON WE KNOW WHEN TO FIGHT FOR RIGHTS
Easiest way ever to get explanation on this topic
ma'am, your voice is too good ...
and your way of explaining things are mind blowing...
thanks a lot for your guidance
Thanks a lot 😊
@@_FinologyLegal feeling privileged...thanks
Bhut Aacha, True, You Are Not One Sided, Truely Speak What Is Right
She had explained the things well but finally end up in a erroneous conclusion. Definitely there are lots of issues with current APMC systems. Bt the new acts are going to worsen the situation further. Now onwards the farmers needs to bargain with more powerful purchasers than earlier small traders. The small/medium farmers wouldn't have any bargaining power with big corporates. If the intention was to make MSP mandatory in every private transaction, why did the bills not contain a clause that the price paid to the farmer by the purchaser shall not be less than the notified MSP?. That's why lakhs of farmers are on the streets.
I hope you will review your conclusion.
The e-commerce system helps in creating auction-system through price and marketing intelligence system where price will be greater than MSP. The other thing is e-commerce platform unlike APMC has no market fees thus there will be no profit cannibalism.
Recently, there have been strong protests from farmers, especially from the states of Punjab and Haryana, against three farm bills that seek to replace ordinances issued in june 2020.
These bills envisage to bring change in some of the key aspects of the farm economy - trade in agricultural commodities, price assurance, farm services including contracts, and stock limits for essential commodities.
These bills sought to bring much needed reforms in the agricultural marketing system such as removing restrictions of private stock holding of agricultural produce or creating trading areas free of middlemen and take the market to the farmer.
However, farmers are apprehensive that the free market philosophy supported by these bills could undermine the Minimum Support Price (MSP) system and make farmers vulnerable to market forces.
Note :
Three Farm Bills that are bond of contention:
The Farmers' Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Bill, 2020,
The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement of Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, 2020,
Essential Commodities (Amendment) Bill, 2020.
Intended Benefits Associated with These Bills
The Bills aim to do away with government interference in agricultural trade by creating trading areas free of middlemen and government taxes outside the structure of Agricultural Produce Market Committees (APMCs).
It will allow farmers an option to sell their produce directly to these new zones, without going through the middlemen and paying levies such as mandi fees.
It sought to remove stock holding limits as well as curbs on inter-State and intra-State trade, and create a framework for contract farming.
Also, these bills promote the creation of Farmer Producer Organisations (FPO) on a large scale and will help in creating a farmer-friendly environment for contract farming where small players can benefit.
These bills may enable private players to invest in warehousing, grading and other marketing infrastructure.
A combined effect of these bills will help in creating a ‘One Nation, One Market’ for agricultural produce.
Issues Raised by The Farmers & Opposition
Federal Angle: The provisions in the Farmers’ Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Bill, 2020, provides for unfettered commerce in designated trade areas outside APMC jurisdictions.
Apart from this, the bill empowers the Centre government to issue orders to States in furtherance of the law’s objectives.
However, matters of trade and agriculture being the part of subjects on the State list, have caused resentment in States.
Lack of Consultation: First the ordinance route and now the hastily attempt to pass the Bills without proper consultation adds to the mistrust among various stakeholders including farmers.
Also, by allowing ‘trade zones’ to come up outside the APMC area, farmers have become apprehensive that the new system would lead to eventual exit from the minimum support price.
Absence of any regulation in non-APMC mandis: Another issue that is raised by the farmers is that the proposed bills give the preference for corporate interests at the cost of farmers’ interests.
In absence of any regulation in non-APMC mandis, the farmers may find it difficult to deal with Corporates, as they solely operate on the motive of profit seeking.
Non-Favourable Market Conditions: While retail prices have remained high, data from the Wholesale Price Index (WPI) suggest a deceleration in farm gate prices for most agricultural produce.
With rising input costs, farmers do not see the free market based framework providing them remunerative prices.
These fears gain strength with the experience of States such as Bihar which abolished APMCs in 2006. After the abolition of mandis, farmers in Bihar on average received lower prices compared to the MSP for most crops.
Way Forward
Improve Agricultural Infrastructure to Strengthen Competition: Government should massively fund the expansion of the APMC market system, make efforts to remove trade cartels, and provide farmers good roads, logistics of scale and real time information.
Empowering State Farmers Commissions: Rather than opting for heavy centralisation, the emphasis should be on empowering farmers through State Farmers Commissions recommended by the National Commission for Farmers, to bring about a speedy government response to issues.
Consensus Building: The Centre should reach out to those opposing the Bills, including farmers, explain to them the need for reform, and get them on board.
Conclusion
Without strong institutional arrangements, the free market may harm lakhs of unorganised small farmers, who have been remarkably productive and shored up the economy even during a pandemic
The MSP is not abolished, you bloody fool.
Bhai katayi chutiye aadmi ho tum
Example - Bihar
The information is lacking and in a way biased , you need to find answers to points raised below
Madam ne sirf purane laws samjhaye , lekin new bills k barre maen kuch bola hi nhi ...🤔
Chlo aap hi bta do
Madam ji eplained it legaly ,now as a farmer of punjab allow me to explain it at ground level
So lets begin point by point
My first point is that out of 3 bills you only explained about 1 bill , what about other 2, so i thought it as my moral duty to explains others too
1. The Essential Commodities (Amendment) Bill
Ek baar ek time aesa aya jbb pyaaz ka rate bdd kr 120 rupee kilo ho gya , toh tbb ek baat uthi ki iska karan hae kalabazari , jmakhori ya fir stocking of product , tbb bola gya ki agar mehngayi se bachna hae toh stocking khatm krni chahiye sarkar ko orr hum log uchhal uchhal k support kr rhe the , lekin abb NEW BILL k according corporate and private stickist jitni chahe jma khori kr skte haen , lekin state sarkar jo stock jma krti thi taki time aane pe usko market maen liquify krke use kiya ja ske taki mehngayi ko control rakha ja ske woh provision khatm krdi new bill maen , abbb mujhe yeh nhi samj ata ki logo ka ya kisano ka isme kya fayda , isme indirectly kaunse sector ka fayda hae yeh sochne valli baat hae 🤔...
Kahi modi sarkar apnr financial favour k chakkar maen kisi specific sector jaese corporate thugg sector ko benifit ya favour toh nhi de rhi ...
Yeg madam aap duscuss krna bhool gye
2. The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, 2020
Pehle farmers apni jamern ya kisi ki jameen theke pe leke kheti krte the or jo bhi produce hota tha usko sell krke apna ghar chlate the , lekin theke pe private ya corporate sector nhi ghus skta tha, mtlb ki agar corporate sector ko buy krna hae kuch toh woh kisan ki produce ko bikne k baad khareed skta hae naki khud theke pe uga ya ugva skta hae kuch bhi , abb kya hoga ki suppose ek bda corporate player hae eg. Reliance group toh woh kya krega ki 1000 chotte kisano se 1-2 acre zameen contract pe lega or usme aoni mrzi ki fasl ugvayega , or uske pass maen 200 kisan haen jo apni apni 1-2 acre zameen maen kheti krenge or jb fasal ko bechne ka time ayega toh jo toh contractor jisko apne liye khud k use k liye specific fasal chahiye hogi woh doosre kisano se lene ki bjaye khud apni contract farming valli fasal use krega or market se kisano ki ugayi huyi fasal woh kyu kharredega agar market se woh khareedega bhi toh usko jo theek lgge ussi rate oe khareedega kyuki MSP ki assurity toh inn bills maen hae hi nhi , isme marrega kaun *gareeb kisan* , or benifit kaun lega cirporate sector valla contractor , sochne ki baat hae🤔
Isi ka ek doosra scenario leke chlte haen
Lets say ki agar koi corporate player contract farming 2000 acre maen kr rha hae , jisko na toh apne ghar ka kharcha nikalna hae naa hi zameen khareedne ka paesa lgana hae , sirf per acre benifit nikalna hae , itne badde level pe suppose agar farming cost 900 rupee ayi per acre or corporate player ne apni 2000 acre ki fasal bechni hae or usne doosre corporate company ko 1000 per acre maen bech di toh 18 lakh ki investment krke usko 20 lakh mill gye lekin uss fasal ka market value set ho gya 1000 jabki uska MSP hoga 1300 ya 1500 lekin kyuki abb mandi nhi hae , MSP nhi hae toh jo 200 chotte kisan haen unko wohi fasal obviously km market value maen bechni pdegi yani k jha ek chotte kisaan ko 3000 milne the jisse usne apne ghar ko chalana tha, bachho ko padana tha , beti ki shadi krni thi wahi usko millege 2000 or yeh jo impact hae chotte kisan pe yeh bohat hi jyada brutal hoga
Abb isi act ka doosra provision suniye , woh kehta hae ki cobtractor kisaan ki zameen girvi rkh k uspe loan le skta hae , suppose koi cobtractor jis company ko kisan nhi jante woh 2000 kisano ki zameen ko contract farming k bahane se leta hae , fir uspe loan leta hae or vijay malya ki tra desh se bhag jata hae toh uski marr kisko pdegi , woh loan chukayega kaun , kisaan ya bank , effect kisko hoga dedh ko , or benifit kiska hoga sochne ki baat hae🤔
Abb isi bill ki ek orr provision jo kehti hae k kisan contract farming k liye normal legal system ka use nhi kr skta , iske liye alag channel hoga SDM level ka ,yeh provision ka matlab kya hae samj nhi atta ki sarkar ko kya problem kisan ke judicial system ko ise krne se , kahi iska readon yeh toh nhi ki judicial system independent hita hae , lekin administrative system jaese ki SDM , DC , police yeh sarkar , politicians or ameer corporate sectors k under hotte haen , kahi yeh indirectly kisaan ko apahij or system ko corrupt banane ki sajish toh nhi ...
Sochne ki baat hae🤔
Aur ek baat hae ki bill is baised as it could be termenated by contracter anytime but farmer cant terminate it
Why?Kisan k haq maen bill pr power contractor ko
Sochne ki baat hae 🤔
Rahi baat toh Why farmers of haryana and punjab are protsating Instead aap k according toh state governments should protest
Abb maen yeh dono points sabhi ko forward kr rha hoon , lekin abhi ek farm bill baki hae jiske flaws madam jitne achge se toh nhi lekin maen explain jroor kroga next comment maen , jisne yeh comment pda orr third bill k flaws janna chahta hae woh next comment ko read krle ....kyuki jusne yeh comment poora pda woh doosra bhi pdd lega
Dhanyavad
and do read comment by SK T....
hey brother bhaut hi achaa samjhaaya aapne , plzz ese hi logo ko jaagrook kijiye taaki logon ko pata chal sake bjp kitna bada dhoka kar rhi hai kisaano ke saath
Well done. This Ma'am is educated illiterate. She doesn't know anything but still she has to bombast about the things 😂😂
Gud question raised against Hoarding !
Nice attempt to explain.
@@bhuvneshgarg2720 sister hai bro
@@amanzehen9257 sister hai
she explains it very easily and clearly
😍😍😍😍😍😍 tufaani trike se samjhaya ma'am apne..... Bahot hard
Excellant! At last I have partly understood about the new farm bills
Mam Ur Explaination is Best I have Ever Seen In You tube ❤❤
I'm surprised how I missed u all these times .... Impressed
mee 2
बहुत ही उम्दा व्याख्या ❤️, thnq mam
Subscribed. To the point. On target. Informative.
Glad it was helpful.
Your way of teaching helps to learn the terminology and dates very easily just like a story
Excellent explanation with so much of clarity. Looking forward to many more videos.
Mam aap itna acha samjhate ho ✔️
Itna deeply + ek lucid manner mein
Thank You Mam
Please keep making maximum videos
Kal live session kafi informative tha
Thank u priya di..
FROM FARMER'S DAUGHTER- PLEASE DONT MISSGUIDE.. For the record, ONLY 6% farmers GET MSP BENEFIT is not because of the lack of education for farmers. The government only acquires wheat rice and sugarcane at MSP prices. Other products like maize dalls etc. Their MSP is launched but GOV. hardly acquires them, PRIVATE agencies CAN ACQUIRE THESE PRODUCTS AT LESS THAN MSP.. THE DEMAND OF FARMERS IS TO MAKE ACQUISITION OF CROPS BELOW MSP CRIMINAL.. SHE NO WHERE MENTIONS THAT.. WE FARMERS ARE NOT ILLITERATE.. THATS THE REASON WE KNOW WHEN TO FIGHT FOR rights
Your way of explanation amazing & outstanding. you are an ideal & inspiration for students & youth.
Thanks a ton!
Very positive approach towards farm Bill's and growth of the farm sector...nicely explained...example of LPG is very apt and evidential.....❤👌👏
I like your videos
These are very helpful
But more than these videos I like you and love you Mam😍😍🤓🤓
Thank you and keep it up👏👏👏👏👍👍👍👍
Excellent Presentation, very informative, Keep it up !!!
Thanks a lot!
MSP is not minimum selling price, it is minimum support price, matlab ye amount ek suugestion hota hai, jis pe sirf gov. Buy krti hai crop. Private players es se km rate pe buy krte hai.. jis region me gov. Acquisition km hai vala pe msp 1800 hona k baad bhi crop 1000 pe bikto hai..
Es mein farmers ki knowledge ki problem nahi hai. Farmera esa legal gurantee banana chahta hai ki es amounts se km pe kahi bhi crop na bika
Thank you for detailed explanation Priya ma'am. Your explanation is understood clearly.
You are welcome 😊
So clearly explained, current farmer issue is specific & should be termed as Punjab Farmer issue
It's like magic and those hand gestures were really helpful ma'am such a nice lecture on recent topics 😍😍😍😍
👏👏👏lucid explanation...ma'am...You got one more subscriber from today onwards...
Thanks mem.
You a good teacher.
You good teaching mem.
Very very Thanks
Thank you 😊
This is fantastic unbiased thoughts. Thank you very much thinking of Bharat!!
Mam itna perfect kaise समजा सक्ती हो आप... Nice mam 🙏🙏🙏 .... Very nice explained
How amazingly you covered this topic so easily 🙏 thank you so much.....god bless you
Thankyou!
Mam your teaching is absolutely clear 🙏
Your explanation is very comprehensive , holistic ....thank you
I watched many videos regarding farm bill but only your explanation is totally free of politics
@Vicky Sandhu hm.g brother aap ne bilkul sahi kha , thnx
@Vicky Sandhu ye farmers double income by 2022 target ko achieve karne ke liye aab kux bhi kiya jaa raha hai. Pata nahi 5 trillion economy ke liye kaunsa bramha Astra chalane wale hai sarkar. Target achivement ke liye kux bhi kar sakte hai. Anyway thanks for your ground report.
this Bill Is To Force GMOs In India ..Through Contract farming
, Government is Just a Puppet
To get The Control Over seeds and Our Health
Search This on You Tube
1. >
2.
@Vicky Sandhu vrr 👍🏻 100 percent correct and to the point comment
hey everybody...... now a days this has become my fav line......😊😊😊🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻👍👍👍
Thanks a lot... Priya Jiiiiii🙂🙂
jyoti mishra hi
@@pranshusharma7399 ji.....
jyoti mishra ap kya krti ho ?can we bcome frnds?
@@pranshusharma7399Ji.. no.. not required.....🙏🏻
this Bill Is To Force GMOs In India ..Through Contract farming
,
To get The Control Over seeds and Our Health
,Government is Just a Puppet
Search This on You Tube
1. >
2.
HELLO PRIYA DIDI JAKASSSSSSS ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ LIVE THA KAL KA BHOUT ACHA EXPLAIN KIYA APNE 😎😎😎😎😎😎 COOL AS ALWAYS
Hi Dolli!
Thank you for your encouragement in yesterday’s Live Session... morning was looking forward to your comments ❤️
@@_FinologyLegal ❤️❤️❤️❤️ sach me app mere guru ho didi ❤️😭😭 khass apke jaise ho sab teacher log god bless you ❤️❤️❤️
The information is lacking and in a way biased , you need to find answers to points raised below
Madam ne sirf purane laws samjhaye , lekin new bills k barre maen kuch bola hi nhi ...🤔
Chlo aap hi bta do
Madam ji eplained it legaly ,now as a farmer of punjab allow me to explain it at ground level
So lets begin point by point
My first point is that out of 3 bills you only explained about 1 bill , what about other 2, so i thought it as my moral duty to explains others too
1. The Essential Commodities (Amendment) Bill
Ek baar ek time aesa aya jbb pyaaz ka rate bdd kr 120 rupee kilo ho gya , toh tbb ek baat uthi ki iska karan hae kalabazari , jmakhori ya fir stocking of product , tbb bola gya ki agar mehngayi se bachna hae toh stocking khatm krni chahiye sarkar ko orr hum log uchhal uchhal k support kr rhe the , lekin abb NEW BILL k according corporate and private stickist jitni chahe jma khori kr skte haen , lekin state sarkar jo stock jma krti thi taki time aane pe usko market maen liquify krke use kiya ja ske taki mehngayi ko control rakha ja ske woh provision khatm krdi new bill maen , abbb mujhe yeh nhi samj ata ki logo ka ya kisano ka isme kya fayda , isme indirectly kaunse sector ka fayda hae yeh sochne valli baat hae 🤔...
Kahi modi sarkar apnr financial favour k chakkar maen kisi specific sector jaese corporate thugg sector ko benifit ya favour toh nhi de rhi ...
Yeg madam aap duscuss krna bhool gye
2. The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, 2020
Pehle farmers apni jamern ya kisi ki jameen theke pe leke kheti krte the or jo bhi produce hota tha usko sell krke apna ghar chlate the , lekin theke pe private ya corporate sector nhi ghus skta tha, mtlb ki agar corporate sector ko buy krna hae kuch toh woh kisan ki produce ko bikne k baad khareed skta hae naki khud theke pe uga ya ugva skta hae kuch bhi , abb kya hoga ki suppose ek bda corporate player hae eg. Reliance group toh woh kya krega ki 1000 chotte kisano se 1-2 acre zameen contract pe lega or usme aoni mrzi ki fasl ugvayega , or uske pass maen 200 kisan haen jo apni apni 1-2 acre zameen maen kheti krenge or jb fasal ko bechne ka time ayega toh jo toh contractor jisko apne liye khud k use k liye specific fasal chahiye hogi woh doosre kisano se lene ki bjaye khud apni contract farming valli fasal use krega or market se kisano ki ugayi huyi fasal woh kyu kharredega agar market se woh khareedega bhi toh usko jo theek lgge ussi rate oe khareedega kyuki MSP ki assurity toh inn bills maen hae hi nhi , isme marrega kaun *gareeb kisan* , or benifit kaun lega cirporate sector valla contractor , sochne ki baat hae🤔
Isi ka ek doosra scenario leke chlte haen
Lets say ki agar koi corporate player contract farming 2000 acre maen kr rha hae , jisko na toh apne ghar ka kharcha nikalna hae naa hi zameen khareedne ka paesa lgana hae , sirf per acre benifit nikalna hae , itne badde level pe suppose agar farming cost 900 rupee ayi per acre or corporate player ne apni 2000 acre ki fasal bechni hae or usne doosre corporate company ko 1000 per acre maen bech di toh 18 lakh ki investment krke usko 20 lakh mill gye lekin uss fasal ka market value set ho gya 1000 jabki uska MSP hoga 1300 ya 1500 lekin kyuki abb mandi nhi hae , MSP nhi hae toh jo 200 chotte kisan haen unko wohi fasal obviously km market value maen bechni pdegi yani k jha ek chotte kisaan ko 3000 milne the jisse usne apne ghar ko chalana tha, bachho ko padana tha , beti ki shadi krni thi wahi usko millege 2000 or yeh jo impact hae chotte kisan pe yeh bohat hi jyada brutal hoga
Abb isi act ka doosra provision suniye , woh kehta hae ki cobtractor kisaan ki zameen girvi rkh k uspe loan le skta hae , suppose koi cobtractor jis company ko kisan nhi jante woh 2000 kisano ki zameen ko contract farming k bahane se leta hae , fir uspe loan leta hae or vijay malya ki tra desh se bhag jata hae toh uski marr kisko pdegi , woh loan chukayega kaun , kisaan ya bank , effect kisko hoga dedh ko , or benifit kiska hoga sochne ki baat hae🤔
Abb isi bill ki ek orr provision jo kehti hae k kisan contract farming k liye normal legal system ka use nhi kr skta , iske liye alag channel hoga SDM level ka ,yeh provision ka matlab kya hae samj nhi atta ki sarkar ko kya problem kisan ke judicial system ko ise krne se , kahi iska readon yeh toh nhi ki judicial system independent hita hae , lekin administrative system jaese ki SDM , DC , police yeh sarkar , politicians or ameer corporate sectors k under hotte haen , kahi yeh indirectly kisaan ko apahij or system ko corrupt banane ki sajish toh nhi ...
Sochne ki baat hae🤔
Aur ek baat hae ki bill is baised as it could be termenated by contracter anytime but farmer cant terminate it
Why?Kisan k haq maen bill pr power contractor ko
Sochne ki baat hae 🤔
Rahi baat toh Why farmers of haryana and punjab are protsating Instead aap k according toh state governments should protest
Abb maen yeh dono points sabhi ko forward kr rha hoon , lekin abhi ek farm bill baki hae jiske flaws madam jitne achge se toh nhi lekin maen explain jroor kroga next comment maen , jisne yeh comment pda orr third bill k flaws janna chahta hae woh next comment ko read krle ....kyuki jusne yeh comment poora pda woh doosra bhi pdd lega
Dhanyavad
and do read comment by SK T..
@@parmjitkaursandhu1336 yes u r correct (law is not express at every point some things and exception to rule are implied thereto) lol being law student need u remind u laws are there ,government made it but it will be fully correct 😅 it's not possible after all humans are drafting it but finallality lies in FR in same as examples of passport act
Passport act manika gandhi s case supreme court s strict supervision over lose lows or inconsistent laws yes there is some kind of provision in second bill but remember the rule of justifiability of law lies there second point laws are good with bad provision or inconsistent to framers right doesn't means whole law is worng it's law. law can be declared null and void upto the inconsistency it is creating with farmers or anyone's right
Thank you so much. We need people like you
How do you make it so simple like butter to understand such crucial topics .....without this channel its now difficult to survive
😜😜😜😜😜
As allways, very informative n to the point Madam! I liked Ur note on understating these new Agri laws with unprejudiced mind!
You did tell us how farmers were affected by the APMC act.. Very nice.. (Yeh to sabhko pata chal gaya hai)
But when did you list out the benefits of the new farm bills..??
(Bills ke fayde kyu nahi bata rahi hai govt)
Super explanation!❤ keep going.
As always, so cute maam. And a perfect teaching. Thank you.
Easily to understood such a crystal clear voice thankyou so much Mam 💙
DO YOU KNOW?
She steered clear of real torment of the farmers....Her idea is to inststigate you against the state gov. rather than to focus on the real culprit in the current scenario....
Much cry and little wool is the phrase that exemplifies her condition..
Bhai apko study iq dekhna chahiye
The information is lacking and in a way biased , you need to find answers to points raised below
Madam ne sirf purane laws samjhaye , lekin new bills k barre maen kuch bola hi nhi ...🤔
Chlo aap hi bta do
Madam ji eplained it legaly ,now as a farmer of punjab allow me to explain it at ground level
So lets begin point by point
My first point is that out of 3 bills you only explained about 1 bill , what about other 2, so i thought it as my moral duty to explains others too
1. The Essential Commodities (Amendment) Bill
Ek baar ek time aesa aya jbb pyaaz ka rate bdd kr 120 rupee kilo ho gya , toh tbb ek baat uthi ki iska karan hae kalabazari , jmakhori ya fir stocking of product , tbb bola gya ki agar mehngayi se bachna hae toh stocking khatm krni chahiye sarkar ko orr hum log uchhal uchhal k support kr rhe the , lekin abb NEW BILL k according corporate and private stickist jitni chahe jma khori kr skte haen , lekin state sarkar jo stock jma krti thi taki time aane pe usko market maen liquify krke use kiya ja ske taki mehngayi ko control rakha ja ske woh provision khatm krdi new bill maen , abbb mujhe yeh nhi samj ata ki logo ka ya kisano ka isme kya fayda , isme indirectly kaunse sector ka fayda hae yeh sochne valli baat hae 🤔...
Kahi modi sarkar apnr financial favour k chakkar maen kisi specific sector jaese corporate thugg sector ko benifit ya favour toh nhi de rhi ...
Yeg madam aap duscuss krna bhool gye
2. The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, 2020
Pehle farmers apni jamern ya kisi ki jameen theke pe leke kheti krte the or jo bhi produce hota tha usko sell krke apna ghar chlate the , lekin theke pe private ya corporate sector nhi ghus skta tha, mtlb ki agar corporate sector ko buy krna hae kuch toh woh kisan ki produce ko bikne k baad khareed skta hae naki khud theke pe uga ya ugva skta hae kuch bhi , abb kya hoga ki suppose ek bda corporate player hae eg. Reliance group toh woh kya krega ki 1000 chotte kisano se 1-2 acre zameen contract pe lega or usme aoni mrzi ki fasl ugvayega , or uske pass maen 200 kisan haen jo apni apni 1-2 acre zameen maen kheti krenge or jb fasal ko bechne ka time ayega toh jo toh contractor jisko apne liye khud k use k liye specific fasal chahiye hogi woh doosre kisano se lene ki bjaye khud apni contract farming valli fasal use krega or market se kisano ki ugayi huyi fasal woh kyu kharredega agar market se woh khareedega bhi toh usko jo theek lgge ussi rate oe khareedega kyuki MSP ki assurity toh inn bills maen hae hi nhi , isme marrega kaun *gareeb kisan* , or benifit kaun lega cirporate sector valla contractor , sochne ki baat hae🤔
Isi ka ek doosra scenario leke chlte haen
Lets say ki agar koi corporate player contract farming 2000 acre maen kr rha hae , jisko na toh apne ghar ka kharcha nikalna hae naa hi zameen khareedne ka paesa lgana hae , sirf per acre benifit nikalna hae , itne badde level pe suppose agar farming cost 900 rupee ayi per acre or corporate player ne apni 2000 acre ki fasal bechni hae or usne doosre corporate company ko 1000 per acre maen bech di toh 18 lakh ki investment krke usko 20 lakh mill gye lekin uss fasal ka market value set ho gya 1000 jabki uska MSP hoga 1300 ya 1500 lekin kyuki abb mandi nhi hae , MSP nhi hae toh jo 200 chotte kisan haen unko wohi fasal obviously km market value maen bechni pdegi yani k jha ek chotte kisaan ko 3000 milne the jisse usne apne ghar ko chalana tha, bachho ko padana tha , beti ki shadi krni thi wahi usko millege 2000 or yeh jo impact hae chotte kisan pe yeh bohat hi jyada brutal hoga
Abb isi act ka doosra provision suniye , woh kehta hae ki cobtractor kisaan ki zameen girvi rkh k uspe loan le skta hae , suppose koi cobtractor jis company ko kisan nhi jante woh 2000 kisano ki zameen ko contract farming k bahane se leta hae , fir uspe loan leta hae or vijay malya ki tra desh se bhag jata hae toh uski marr kisko pdegi , woh loan chukayega kaun , kisaan ya bank , effect kisko hoga dedh ko , or benifit kiska hoga sochne ki baat hae🤔
Abb isi bill ki ek orr provision jo kehti hae k kisan contract farming k liye normal legal system ka use nhi kr skta , iske liye alag channel hoga SDM level ka ,yeh provision ka matlab kya hae samj nhi atta ki sarkar ko kya problem kisan ke judicial system ko ise krne se , kahi iska readon yeh toh nhi ki judicial system independent hita hae , lekin administrative system jaese ki SDM , DC , police yeh sarkar , politicians or ameer corporate sectors k under hotte haen , kahi yeh indirectly kisaan ko apahij or system ko corrupt banane ki sajish toh nhi ...
Sochne ki baat hae🤔
Aur ek baat hae ki bill is baised as it could be termenated by contracter anytime but farmer cant terminate it
Why?Kisan k haq maen bill pr power contractor ko
Sochne ki baat hae 🤔
Rahi baat toh Why farmers of haryana and punjab are protsating Instead aap k according toh state governments should protest
Abb maen yeh dono points sabhi ko forward kr rha hoon , lekin abhi ek farm bill baki hae jiske flaws madam jitne achge se toh nhi lekin maen explain jroor kroga next comment maen , jisne yeh comment pda orr third bill k flaws janna chahta hae woh next comment ko read krle ....kyuki jusne yeh comment poora pda woh doosra bhi pdd lega
Dhanyavad
and do read comment by SK T..
I am requesting to all farmers plz. Plz. Read these three ordinances of farm bill. This farm bill will benefit the farmers. plz don't believe on political or farmers leaders rumors. Farm bill is providing you choices and Read it and then react. Specially punjab people plz read and don't take this protest on your ego.🇮🇳
Bro actually they take time to understand bill nd congress and other opposition take it as an opportunity to narrate there own story and create violence in country just like CAA and jammu kashmir stuff. And every time aam aadmi got effected.
Here want to conclude from stats mentioned in video
1. Check the money distribution to states from GOI, Punjab is in the list of developed states having very well established APMC architecture, But on the other side look at Bihar where np APMC
So how anyone can say removing APMC will give the better opportunities to farmers
2. What about the 1750Cr or respective amount for State Govts?
3. Only 6% people getting MSP, so means need to improve MSP providing architecture which is feasible with APMC architecture or LAW
We are not convinced by the politicians
We are convinced by the prices of our produce we are getting
The crop(rice) which would sell for 3000-4000 per quintal is now selling for 1100-1600 whic you can cleart see is very is not even half of it
Also guarantee to MSP ( for 22 crops) is said by the government but it is not being provided even for the crops they are saying
Also the third law which removes the limit of storage was never for farmers as setting up cold storage is very expensive and to acquire license you ought to have very good Connection with politicians of the ruling party therefore it was clearly meant for industrialist
Last and the most important thing of this protest is that if there are private players in it there will be no monitoring the MRP of crops so even if they provide MSP to farmers the new farm bill be problematic for lower and middle class of our country
@@vitaminprotein2309 yes those are the concerns we are talking about, now they will call us anti modi, even without any ground reality. Even , I am supporter for him in many cases, but not for this. And Galat ko Galat hi kehna chahiye,
@@vitaminprotein2309 According to my knowledge of this bill, it will work as below mentioned way. Please correct me if i am wrong. I am here to learn more about this bill. You look like have some knowledge regarding this, hence i am sharing this with u.
If corporate enters in this field, the price of the product will be fixed before production. So if farmer thinks offered price is not good enough then he can tell the corporate, he will produce something else. As on season and off season product price is difference. So the corporate have to bid some thing in between. Like on season per quintal rice price is 1100-1600 but in off season it is 3000-4000 quintal. If the price is known by farmer before he produce something. Then there will be less risk of loss.
Really you have an ability to teach... very nice way of explaining....a good speaker. God bless you.
Thanks a lot
Hey mam!!
Your lectures are so interesting.
I suggest FL team, especially priya mam to start lecture series on Indian National movement and Indian constitution... Good luck
Hahaha yes... 😂😂😂
Wah super se bhi uper wala video hai
Thank you so much!
There are few things that you could have explained as well like what impact these bills will have in future, an example of similar thing happened in past, why this approach failed in western countries, and how Bihar is doing now since they have implemented these laws in past. I am not a farmer and not biased either but see the long term impact of these bills on them clearly.
In beginning everything seems risky..but we have to give farmers a choice
Yes absolutely right 👍👍
Bill k bare me kahan hai ..???
She escaped it cunningly....everybody is making vedio on it...so she also made....she has less researched or dont want to talk about it
@@yashthakur1382 yeah just like demonetisation, GST
its to good to see and easy to understand you should open your own TV show mam
thank u so much 👌👌👍👍👍
Most welcome 😊
Nice mam app bhot achi video bana to ho
🙏🙏🙏
Thankyou!
this Bill Is To Force GMOs In India ..Through Contract farming
,
To get The Control Over seeds and Our Health
,Government is Just a Puppet
Search This on You Tube
1. >
2.
The information is lacking and in a way biased , you need to find answers to points raised below
Madam ne sirf purane laws samjhaye , lekin new bills k barre maen kuch bola hi nhi ...🤔
Chlo aap hi bta do
Madam ji eplained it legaly ,now as a farmer of punjab allow me to explain it at ground level
So lets begin point by point
My first point is that out of 3 bills you only explained about 1 bill , what about other 2, so i thought it as my moral duty to explains others too
1. The Essential Commodities (Amendment) Bill
Ek baar ek time aesa aya jbb pyaaz ka rate bdd kr 120 rupee kilo ho gya , toh tbb ek baat uthi ki iska karan hae kalabazari , jmakhori ya fir stocking of product , tbb bola gya ki agar mehngayi se bachna hae toh stocking khatm krni chahiye sarkar ko orr hum log uchhal uchhal k support kr rhe the , lekin abb NEW BILL k according corporate and private stickist jitni chahe jma khori kr skte haen , lekin state sarkar jo stock jma krti thi taki time aane pe usko market maen liquify krke use kiya ja ske taki mehngayi ko control rakha ja ske woh provision khatm krdi new bill maen , abbb mujhe yeh nhi samj ata ki logo ka ya kisano ka isme kya fayda , isme indirectly kaunse sector ka fayda hae yeh sochne valli baat hae 🤔...
Kahi modi sarkar apnr financial favour k chakkar maen kisi specific sector jaese corporate thugg sector ko benifit ya favour toh nhi de rhi ...
Yeg madam aap duscuss krna bhool gye
2. The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, 2020
Pehle farmers apni jamern ya kisi ki jameen theke pe leke kheti krte the or jo bhi produce hota tha usko sell krke apna ghar chlate the , lekin theke pe private ya corporate sector nhi ghus skta tha, mtlb ki agar corporate sector ko buy krna hae kuch toh woh kisan ki produce ko bikne k baad khareed skta hae naki khud theke pe uga ya ugva skta hae kuch bhi , abb kya hoga ki suppose ek bda corporate player hae eg. Reliance group toh woh kya krega ki 1000 chotte kisano se 1-2 acre zameen contract pe lega or usme aoni mrzi ki fasl ugvayega , or uske pass maen 200 kisan haen jo apni apni 1-2 acre zameen maen kheti krenge or jb fasal ko bechne ka time ayega toh jo toh contractor jisko apne liye khud k use k liye specific fasal chahiye hogi woh doosre kisano se lene ki bjaye khud apni contract farming valli fasal use krega or market se kisano ki ugayi huyi fasal woh kyu kharredega agar market se woh khareedega bhi toh usko jo theek lgge ussi rate oe khareedega kyuki MSP ki assurity toh inn bills maen hae hi nhi , isme marrega kaun *gareeb kisan* , or benifit kaun lega cirporate sector valla contractor , sochne ki baat hae🤔
Isi ka ek doosra scenario leke chlte haen
Lets say ki agar koi corporate player contract farming 2000 acre maen kr rha hae , jisko na toh apne ghar ka kharcha nikalna hae naa hi zameen khareedne ka paesa lgana hae , sirf per acre benifit nikalna hae , itne badde level pe suppose agar farming cost 900 rupee ayi per acre or corporate player ne apni 2000 acre ki fasal bechni hae or usne doosre corporate company ko 1000 per acre maen bech di toh 18 lakh ki investment krke usko 20 lakh mill gye lekin uss fasal ka market value set ho gya 1000 jabki uska MSP hoga 1300 ya 1500 lekin kyuki abb mandi nhi hae , MSP nhi hae toh jo 200 chotte kisan haen unko wohi fasal obviously km market value maen bechni pdegi yani k jha ek chotte kisaan ko 3000 milne the jisse usne apne ghar ko chalana tha, bachho ko padana tha , beti ki shadi krni thi wahi usko millege 2000 or yeh jo impact hae chotte kisan pe yeh bohat hi jyada brutal hoga
Abb isi act ka doosra provision suniye , woh kehta hae ki cobtractor kisaan ki zameen girvi rkh k uspe loan le skta hae , suppose koi cobtractor jis company ko kisan nhi jante woh 2000 kisano ki zameen ko contract farming k bahane se leta hae , fir uspe loan leta hae or vijay malya ki tra desh se bhag jata hae toh uski marr kisko pdegi , woh loan chukayega kaun , kisaan ya bank , effect kisko hoga dedh ko , or benifit kiska hoga sochne ki baat hae🤔
Abb isi bill ki ek orr provision jo kehti hae k kisan contract farming k liye normal legal system ka use nhi kr skta , iske liye alag channel hoga SDM level ka ,yeh provision ka matlab kya hae samj nhi atta ki sarkar ko kya problem kisan ke judicial system ko ise krne se , kahi iska readon yeh toh nhi ki judicial system independent hita hae , lekin administrative system jaese ki SDM , DC , police yeh sarkar , politicians or ameer corporate sectors k under hotte haen , kahi yeh indirectly kisaan ko apahij or system ko corrupt banane ki sajish toh nhi ...
Sochne ki baat hae🤔
Aur ek baat hae ki bill is baised as it could be termenated by contracter anytime but farmer cant terminate it
Why?Kisan k haq maen bill pr power contractor ko
Sochne ki baat hae 🤔
Rahi baat toh Why farmers of haryana and punjab are protsating Instead aap k according toh state governments should protest
Abb maen yeh dono points sabhi ko forward kr rha hoon , lekin abhi ek farm bill baki hae jiske flaws madam jitne achge se toh nhi lekin maen explain jroor kroga next comment maen , jisne yeh comment pda orr third bill k flaws janna chahta hae woh next comment ko read krle ....kyuki jusne yeh comment poora pda woh doosra bhi pdd lega
Dhanyavad
and do read comment by SK T...
Thanks for clearing my all the misunderstandings🤍
Happy to help.
MSP is not minimum selling price, it is minimum support price, matlab ye amount ek suugestion hota hai, jis pe sirf gov. Buy krti hai crop. Private players es se km rate pe buy krte hai.. jis region me gov. Acquisition km hai vala pe msp 1800 hona k baad bhi crop 1000 pe bikto hai..
Es mein farmers ki knowledge ki problem nahi hai. Farmera esa legal gurantee banana chahta hai ki es amounts se km pe kahi bhi crop na bika
@@_FinologyLegal
Mam please Confirm it
Is this Bill good for Farmers
Please be unbiased
Forget these haters
Really impressed With your presentation .. this Needs to reach every individual for a proper understanding of what's going around us ..
Iske liye Fb pe dalna chahiye video viral ho jayega
Chaan samjavun sangta tumhi....utkrustha ...jai hind !!
Thanks a lot of you Mam for well explaining the Farm Bills...
The most unbiased and unpolitical explanation ever♥️♥️🇮🇳🇮🇳
She has given you wrong information.. only 6% of farmers produce is acquired at MSP. Not cz of their lack of education.. its because only giv.acquires at MSP, the private traders they buy at less than MSP.. farmers are agitating to make MSP compulsary for any purchase to be made from farmers.
this Bill Is To Force GMOs In India ..Through Contract farming
,
To get The Control Over seeds and Our Health
,Government is Just a Puppet
Search This on You Tube
1. Genetic Roulette The Gamble of Our Lives
2. Bill Gates and his plans for world's future - Real Eyes
3. Modi government के farm bill के उन दिक्कतों की बात जिसने America-Europe में पहले से तबाही मचा रखी है
@@kabeerkabeer3285 ooo angrez ki ulad
Angrez jo lakho baar m kr pae h vo hm Hindustanion ne ek baar m kia h .
West ka example dena band kro
Or aap hi dekho in Librandu media ko
Hme to Bhartiya hone pr fakr h😎😎
@@MeenuKumari-hy2sl o madam ji Thori si apni dharamvaad , jaativadd K zehar se bhari hui Soch ko full stop lgao or apne desh k logo k liye sochna shuru kro thora logically , ek tarf toh apko duniya se mukabla krna hae or doosri tarf aap glbalisation se drte ho , koi ek criteria toh accept kro , dont be hypocratic but a factual person
@@DaljeetSingh-kz4bn globalisation and privatization ka virodh congress kr rgi h mr. M nhi
Simply Explained complex issues..Gud
Very nicelly expalanation new farmer Bill in India a student from Pakistan thanks finology legal.
"Desh me farmer reform ke baare me baat honi chahiye" [sic.] I see it happening from Finology Legal:)
FROM FARMER'S DAUGHTER- PLEASE DONT MISSGUIDE.. For the record, ONLY 6% farmers GET MSP BENEFIT is not because of the lack of education for farmers. The government only acquires wheat rice and sugarcane at MSP prices. Other products like maize dalls etc. Their MSP is launched but GOV. hardly acquires them, PRIVATE agencies CAN ACQUIRE THESE PRODUCTS AT LESS THAN MSP.. THE DEMAND OF FARMERS IS TO MAKE ACQUISITION OF CROPS BELOW MSP CRIMINAL.. SHE NO WHERE MENTIONS THAT.. WE FARMERS ARE NOT ILLITERATE.. THATS THE REASON WE KNOW WHEN TO FIGHT FOR OUR RIGHTS
this Bill Is To Force GMOs In India ..Through Contract farming
To get The Control Over seeds and Our Health
>
Search This on You Tube
@Vicky Sandhu any other solutions you have in this
U just listen to vidoes not fake people
@@aakashshetty4365 how to make sure bdw?
Wow❤️ you explain anything in a great way. Special thanx for english subtitles 🙏
Thank you so much 😀
Excellent presentation Ma'am!👌🙏
Thank you!
Mam ap itne ache se explain karti..i really hope mai ki aap ki tarah cheejo ko explain krna seekhu...
Besttt ever mam so nicely explain you this all 😍😍🙏🏻
Really knowledgeable ❤❤ thank u Didi jai hind 🇮🇳
Ma'am I wouldn't say wether this bill is bad or not.. But if this bill fails & farmers suffer in the future our mainstream media will never discuss it as they are praising & discussing now
That's still an assumption
@@abhinavsharma3819 Let me conclude it better as long as BJP is in power popular media like republic Tv, Times now will not talk about this. On what basis an I saying this: its because they didn't talk about so many issues like NTPC, RRB, JEE and for a long time they didn't show about farmer protest as well, mainstream media as became a place for hate speech rather than a place of genuine news.
@@Xawans333 you can kindly stop calling others looser & start selling tea.. or you can even become a food delivery guy that will be a good idea
this Bill Is To Force GMOs In India ..Through Contract farming
, Government is Just a Puppet
To get The Control Over seeds and Our Health
Search This on You Tube
1. >
2.
You are a true teacher. Doing great job
Hi Priya I'm from down south india..I don't know Hindi but ur way of explain is great..👍
Then who stopped you from learning HINDI
Policies should pe explained to common people..Most of them even don't know what Govt is doing .
Thanks for this amazing video🙏
She is missguiding please cross check the facts regarding MSP.. and farmers demands for making MSP compulsary.. farmers are well awair of MSP. But in states without mandis private traders buy products at rate much less than MSP
@Vicky Sandhu can you please share the link for the information. 🙏
@Vicky Sandhu it's only slippery slope fallacy
Such a detailed and easy explanation.
Thanks mam
Explaination of the law but it doesn't tell how bad it is for individual farmer. If they want to bring this law in then give more power to farmers not to the corporations.
Her channel must reach above million....
Thank you so much!
I never saw someone explaining like you..
The information is lacking and in a way biased , you need to find answers to points raised below
Madam ne sirf purane laws samjhaye , lekin new bills k barre maen kuch bola hi nhi ...🤔
Chlo aap hi bta do
Madam ji eplained it legaly ,now as a farmer of punjab allow me to explain it at ground level
So lets begin point by point
My first point is that out of 3 bills you only explained about 1 bill , what about other 2, so i thought it as my moral duty to explains others too
1. The Essential Commodities (Amendment) Bill
Ek baar ek time aesa aya jbb pyaaz ka rate bdd kr 120 rupee kilo ho gya , toh tbb ek baat uthi ki iska karan hae kalabazari , jmakhori ya fir stocking of product , tbb bola gya ki agar mehngayi se bachna hae toh stocking khatm krni chahiye sarkar ko orr hum log uchhal uchhal k support kr rhe the , lekin abb NEW BILL k according corporate and private stickist jitni chahe jma khori kr skte haen , lekin state sarkar jo stock jma krti thi taki time aane pe usko market maen liquify krke use kiya ja ske taki mehngayi ko control rakha ja ske woh provision khatm krdi new bill maen , abbb mujhe yeh nhi samj ata ki logo ka ya kisano ka isme kya fayda , isme indirectly kaunse sector ka fayda hae yeh sochne valli baat hae 🤔...
Kahi modi sarkar apnr financial favour k chakkar maen kisi specific sector jaese corporate thugg sector ko benifit ya favour toh nhi de rhi ...
Yeg madam aap duscuss krna bhool gye
2. The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, 2020
Pehle farmers apni jamern ya kisi ki jameen theke pe leke kheti krte the or jo bhi produce hota tha usko sell krke apna ghar chlate the , lekin theke pe private ya corporate sector nhi ghus skta tha, mtlb ki agar corporate sector ko buy krna hae kuch toh woh kisan ki produce ko bikne k baad khareed skta hae naki khud theke pe uga ya ugva skta hae kuch bhi , abb kya hoga ki suppose ek bda corporate player hae eg. Reliance group toh woh kya krega ki 1000 chotte kisano se 1-2 acre zameen contract pe lega or usme aoni mrzi ki fasl ugvayega , or uske pass maen 200 kisan haen jo apni apni 1-2 acre zameen maen kheti krenge or jb fasal ko bechne ka time ayega toh jo toh contractor jisko apne liye khud k use k liye specific fasal chahiye hogi woh doosre kisano se lene ki bjaye khud apni contract farming valli fasal use krega or market se kisano ki ugayi huyi fasal woh kyu kharredega agar market se woh khareedega bhi toh usko jo theek lgge ussi rate oe khareedega kyuki MSP ki assurity toh inn bills maen hae hi nhi , isme marrega kaun *gareeb kisan* , or benifit kaun lega cirporate sector valla contractor , sochne ki baat hae🤔
Isi ka ek doosra scenario leke chlte haen
Lets say ki agar koi corporate player contract farming 2000 acre maen kr rha hae , jisko na toh apne ghar ka kharcha nikalna hae naa hi zameen khareedne ka paesa lgana hae , sirf per acre benifit nikalna hae , itne badde level pe suppose agar farming cost 900 rupee ayi per acre or corporate player ne apni 2000 acre ki fasal bechni hae or usne doosre corporate company ko 1000 per acre maen bech di toh 18 lakh ki investment krke usko 20 lakh mill gye lekin uss fasal ka market value set ho gya 1000 jabki uska MSP hoga 1300 ya 1500 lekin kyuki abb mandi nhi hae , MSP nhi hae toh jo 200 chotte kisan haen unko wohi fasal obviously km market value maen bechni pdegi yani k jha ek chotte kisaan ko 3000 milne the jisse usne apne ghar ko chalana tha, bachho ko padana tha , beti ki shadi krni thi wahi usko millege 2000 or yeh jo impact hae chotte kisan pe yeh bohat hi jyada brutal hoga
Abb isi act ka doosra provision suniye , woh kehta hae ki cobtractor kisaan ki zameen girvi rkh k uspe loan le skta hae , suppose koi cobtractor jis company ko kisan nhi jante woh 2000 kisano ki zameen ko contract farming k bahane se leta hae , fir uspe loan leta hae or vijay malya ki tra desh se bhag jata hae toh uski marr kisko pdegi , woh loan chukayega kaun , kisaan ya bank , effect kisko hoga dedh ko , or benifit kiska hoga sochne ki baat hae🤔
Abb isi bill ki ek orr provision jo kehti hae k kisan contract farming k liye normal legal system ka use nhi kr skta , iske liye alag channel hoga SDM level ka ,yeh provision ka matlab kya hae samj nhi atta ki sarkar ko kya problem kisan ke judicial system ko ise krne se , kahi iska readon yeh toh nhi ki judicial system independent hita hae , lekin administrative system jaese ki SDM , DC , police yeh sarkar , politicians or ameer corporate sectors k under hotte haen , kahi yeh indirectly kisaan ko apahij or system ko corrupt banane ki sajish toh nhi ...
Sochne ki baat hae🤔
Aur ek baat hae ki bill is baised as it could be termenated by contracter anytime but farmer cant terminate it
Why?Kisan k haq maen bill pr power contractor ko
Sochne ki baat hae 🤔
Rahi baat toh Why farmers of haryana and punjab are protsating Instead aap k according toh state governments should protest
Abb maen yeh dono points sabhi ko forward kr rha hoon , lekin abhi ek farm bill baki hae jiske flaws madam jitne achge se toh nhi lekin maen explain jroor kroga next comment maen , jisne yeh comment pda orr third bill k flaws janna chahta hae woh next comment ko read krle ....kyuki jusne yeh comment poora pda woh doosra bhi pdd lega
Dhanyavad
and do read comment by SK T..
Modi is rejecting the earlier setup installed by earlier govt regimes.
.
1) Playing of role in External Domain:
Food Corporation of India was established with the same intention which Modi is now propagating with this new farm bill.
.
The problem of farmers is that they can not store their output. It is very difficult to do sorting, cleaning, packaging etc, transport to other markets where they can get more price.
.
Farmers can not do this extra job, they need helping-services.
Farmers need
warehouses for storing,
materials and tools for processing & packaging,
transportation help to bring their product to the warehouse and send it to the market for sale.
.
FCI has not built enough well developed storage houses, packaging, transportation setups where farmers can hire those services so that they can sell their products to prospective buyers when there is a right price for their end-products.
.
Modi is becoming an assistant to businessmen, not as an assistant to farmers.
this Bill Is To Force GMOs In India ..Through Contract farming
,
To get The Control Over seeds and Our Health
,Government is Just a Puppet
Search This on You Tube
1. >
2.
You are Right...
Punjab and Rajasthan have SONE ki factories now...Idhar se Anaaj/ Aloo dalo...udhar se SONA nikalo...
Agree sir..
@@tarachandb2899 hao Rahul Gandhi told and now Rajasthan govt is supplying gold to farmers
Srivathsan...understood bhai...what Raga meant was ki hum log food processing industry lagayenge....but yeh industry govt PSU lagayegi ya koi pvt company jaise ke pepsico...cocacola...Ambani Adani lagayenge.....??
It was just perfect...You have explained the detailed analysis
Mam your way of teaching is awesome
I heard a very interesting analogy today,
A 10 floor building did not have a lift, so people had problem climbing up and down. Specially the elderly and the kids, so the society started exploring options.
Finally they got some donkeys, who could carry people up and down. The donkey owners would charge people for carrying them up and down for a fee and would also pay 10% to the society from the revenue they earned. It was a very happy situation for all involved.
After sometime the society management changed, the new management decided to install a lift for carrying people up and down.
All hell broke loose and everyone started protesting, this is not fair, society will loose revenue, the donkey owners will be jobless and no food for them (human rights issue), the donkeys will be worthless (animals rights issue), all were angry.
Society management clarified, the lift is available to all but the gentlemen who wanted to use the donkeys could still do it. But no, the agitation continued and so finally the new management had to succumb to the pressure.
The final arrangement was arrived and so anyone who wanted to climb the building could still use the donkey. The donkey would carry a person, go in the lift and carry people up & down. All were happy.
Disclaimer: any resemblance of this with the farmers agitation is a coincidence.
Wow brother😂😂
You explained that protest very good way👏