I agree he pips Lennon and McCartney and Jagger And Richards hadn’t developed yet. Brian Jones was never cool. Morrison not invented. Hendrix was doing regrettable things that ultimately killed him with Little Richard. Brian Wilson was Brian Wilson and Bob Dylan came along wrote some of the greatest songs ever that were so far ahead of there time. Created along with stones n Beatles the next twenty so years of rock n roll and then just disappeared into the night never to return at the same level. He never again was an innovator or pioneer and while his songs were good would of loved it if he was still interested and wanted to invent and create and be the best.
Sure is the coolest. Saw hin in cleveland,Ohio on november 12,1965 at the cleveland music hall. Saw him 35 times and met him on july 17,1991. He was walking to his bus by himself. I was walking and looked up and he was walking toward me. I stood still and he stopped and shook my hand. He was very nice to me.
Bob would tell you himself that when one is really wasted it is very easy to feel like you are just on the verge of doing the greatest thing that has ever been done...and yet you are too far out to reign it in and finish the job. This is the sound of that moment. He never did anything with these tunes because he knew that the moment of inspiration could never be recaptured. Very interesting to hear this.
Or perhaps on reflection he didn't think it was worth finishing.I would but I,m not Bob Dylan!Bob has more songs than one lifetime can finish so he has to be choosy
It is perfect that the unfinished song is an analogy to a beautiful romance that ended without closure. In.this case, I believe life should imitate art.
A bit of this session was filmed and remastered for Martin Scorsese's No Direction Home documentary. It's one of the DVD extras. I've always loved this track since it's so unlike Dylan's other work at the time and really shows off his singing chops.
Incredible how the second time through he's changing the rhythmic emphasis even though the first version works perfectly.. always searching and evolving.
Lyrics: Now she's walkin' in the morning Howlin' you come home I'll be on my way, so long, forlorn You just can't go I will get it if I have to If I have to please come home Try, but I'll be dry, and I crave you If I haunt you back all day Carry my trouble Yes you satisfy my mind I'll try to tell you, if I can't come in And I must stay true I'll be happy in the morning I try my best, I will try to help you If I can, and I leave it too But I just can't find you away Won't some time away ... That's the way I think she told me Heart she bent on me I'll be out all morning, for you But you can't stop me Yes, I try my best to please you Try my best, but if I fail You must help me to see you As I go by ... Now, if you send me a letter I'll be on my way to get it for you I'll be with my sister too I can't find me what to do Yes, I've been trying to get a message To you, but you have to treat me I won't let her to And then I try my best to hunt her, you...
@@SwinginPig Yes, I enjoyed it very, very much! You've got a lot of good stuff on your channel. Thank you very much for all of your postings, they are fantastic and so are you! ❤😊
Bob was pulling a great song out of that magic box where everything lies hidden...but it kind of slipped away. Very great upload, thanks. How great an artist Bob is.
Thank you so much for taking the time and effort to post this recording (which is much louder and much more clear than any other posting online). Being a Dylan fan is the gift that keeps on giving. Just when you think you've heard it all, there's some sort of unknown session or song that gets released. Thank you for making it possible to hear this rare recordings Swingin' Pig!
"I can't leave her behind" is such a pretty song. Great to hear Bob working it out here. There's a nice cover by Stephen Malkmus and Lee Ranaldo on the soundtrack of "I'm not there". Thankfully they resisted any urge to make it longer - sometimes brevity is art.
You really get an intimate glimpse at Bob working with Robbie on what was supposed to be one song that ended up being three completely different ones. After listening to it you hear how Bob would play one song and then as Robbie’s trying to learn it he’s started another one
If you’ve ever been addicted to drugs you can see how and why they helped Dylan so much. They made him not even think, just write write write no time for analysis and whatever cans to mind however bendy stayed. I can imagine him once he’d got clean sitting there with his typewriter and laughing at the thought of even trying to write the chaotic way he did. Sitting there thinking ‘oh shit I have internal dialogue again with negativity and doubt” Man drugs are absolutely brilliant but they don’t work for long and once they’ve stopped will never work again.
Wow, this tune is beautiful!! I understand why he never developed it further, since it doesn't really fit in with that much of what he was doing at the time, but this is gorgeous to hear!! Wish he'd sung a bit louder, but thanks so much for posting!
That's such an interesting way to follow an inspiration when you don't know just what you want to say but you have the emotion - you just follow the emotion and create cadences of syllables against the rhythm and hope you can find some good words to match the emotion.
Footage of this moment is included in Scorcese's recent documentary about Robbie Robertson and the Band called "Once Were Brothers." Check it out and you'll hear a few lines of this song being sung beautifully by Bob and see Robbie shake his head and marvel. Why was this not released by Dylan? By the Band? By anyone? It's a classic.
That story is a Horror story, if I've ever heard one! Thank God his chauffeur/bodyguard was a quick thinker! I've never heard this story before. It's probably something they would prefer the public not know about. Anyway, thanks Swingin', this is a gem!
In the movie “I’m Not There” there’s a scene about this incident and I always figured the filmmakers invented it themselves because I never heard about it actually happening until now.
I've just watched this scene in I'm Not There, which is a great film, the one where a hotel worker bursts in and tells him he's a "traitor to folk music" or some other BS, and as a Scot who was born in Glasgow I shouldn't be surprised that this happened here. Of all the towns and gigs it had to be Glasgow! 🤪😜
If at first you don’t succeed… Robert the Bruce n all that…. Fascinating these takes. Beautiful photos too. When talking Bob doesn’t sound American but has a kind of British Irish mix of an accent. Wish I’d been old enough to get my kicks in 1966. Thx for this. X
Great song. Subconsciously lifted slightly during the first part of the song from the folk tune 'I've been working on the railroad, all the lifelong day.. " only for a second though. Its awesome!
Very very beautiful. I did what i rarely do and put on earphones for this one as hard in places to make out. Dylan doesn’t sound American. The way he talks. It’s hard to pin down the accent he has. His manner of speech. It’s lovely just hard to place. A man from all places.
Imagine how great 't'would've been if Bob had spontaneously slipped this number into his acoustic set at one of the Royal Albert Hall shows! 't'would've been C O S M I C !
Guten Morgen, mein geliebter Bobby! Bedauere mich mal: Ich habe nur zwei Stunden geschlafen und muss noch warten, bis meine Magenschmerzen verschwinden! - Ich wünsche Dir einen wunderschönen Tag!
Ha ha I didn’t miss it but somehow I did miss it somehow! I swear I only drank a cup of red rose tea this evening! Lol. Ever since I saw those balloons at the end of you last video! Here is one of my new signatures when I really really like something! See how you inspire me friend! 🎈📌💥 Lol
Thank you! I mixed up the tracks on the record. I edited the title accordingly. I'll be posting a 5 minute version of "I Can't Leave Her Behind" today. Thanks again!!
Das Ganze strengt mich so an, dass ich nur "in winzigen Häppchen" recherchiere. Es strengt mich nicht inhaltlich an, sondern weil ich denke, dass man mir diese Suche sehr leicht ersparen könnte! Aber "man (wer auch immer") will nicht!
OUTSIDE IS RAINING I AM UNDER 3 BLANKETS DOG AND CAT ARE SLEEPING I AM JUST SMOKING AND LISTENING TO YOU BOB HONEY I ATE BIG SANDWICH AND NOW I AM FEELING MUCH BETTER KISS KISS
Guten Morgen, mein Bobby-Schätzchen! Heute mache ich einen Haushaltstag, das muss auch mal sein...(mein Wohnzimmer sieht nämlich so aus, als wäre eine Bombe eingeschlagen)
I managed to get a copy of The Cutting Edge: Collector's Edition after many months of looking. Only made about 1000 I think. But anyway, it includes pretty much every note Dylan recorded from 1965-1966, and that's where I get most of the material for my channel. Thanks for listening and stay safe :)
![Bob Dylan - I Can't Leave Her Behind - One of His Best Unreleased Songs [RESTORED AUDIO]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/sh7_uNRk9dw/mqdefault.jpg)
![Bob Dylan - I Can't Leave Her Behind - One of His Best Unreleased Songs [RESTORED AUDIO]](/img/tr.png)
![Bob Dylan Jamming With Robbie Robertson (Glasgow, 1966) [RARE FULL SESSION]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Z_KuCWh2TBs/mqdefault.jpg)
coolest person on the planet 1965/1966
I think you mean 1960-present
Forever!
I agree he pips Lennon and McCartney and Jagger And Richards hadn’t developed yet. Brian Jones was never cool. Morrison not invented. Hendrix was doing regrettable things that ultimately killed him with Little Richard. Brian Wilson was Brian Wilson and Bob Dylan came along wrote some of the greatest songs ever that were so far ahead of there time. Created along with stones n Beatles the next twenty so years of rock n roll and then just disappeared into the night never to return at the same level. He never again was an innovator or pioneer and while his songs were good would of loved it if he was still interested and wanted to invent and create and be the best.
@@dondamon4669 have you heard his latest album? Convinced he invented a whole new genre with I Contain Multitudes
Sure is the coolest. Saw hin in cleveland,Ohio on november 12,1965 at the cleveland music hall. Saw him 35 times and met him on july 17,1991. He was walking to his bus by himself. I was walking and looked up and he was walking toward me. I stood still and he stopped and shook my hand. He was very nice to me.
You can tell by this sweet singing that Bob’s famous Dylan voice was a character he donned for his folk rock career.
Bob would tell you himself that when one is really wasted it is very easy to feel like you are just on the verge of doing the greatest thing that has ever been done...and yet you are too far out to reign it in and finish the job. This is the sound of that moment. He never did anything with these tunes because he knew that the moment of inspiration could never be recaptured. Very interesting to hear this.
That’s very true! I had never thought about it like that. But as an amateur songwriter myself, I understand what you’re saying.
the fact that this song, Don't Look Back, and so many more unfinished gems are absolutely amazing
EXTREMELY INSIGHTFUL
Or perhaps on reflection he didn't think it was worth finishing.I would but I,m not Bob Dylan!Bob has more songs than one lifetime can finish so he has to be choosy
Then again, there is always the possibility that we just can't know why the song went unreleased or what Bob would tell us himself.
You can’t even comprehend how much this post is appreciated
It is perfect that the unfinished song is an analogy to a beautiful romance that ended without closure. In.this case, I believe life should imitate art.
This is the single most important clip on TH-cam
A bit of this session was filmed and remastered for Martin Scorsese's No Direction Home documentary. It's one of the DVD extras. I've always loved this track since it's so unlike Dylan's other work at the time and really shows off his singing chops.
Yep, love that footage. The color’s a bit off at one point though. I hope that someday it gets released in full.
@@SwinginPig Surely this same footage used by Scorcese was previously seen, briefly, in the Eat the Document film.
True
.
One can only love "Rainy Afternoon" t in its imperfect/perfect state of half-composition ... Lovely, isn't it?
Incredible how the second time through he's changing the rhythmic emphasis even though the first version works perfectly.. always searching and evolving.
Lyrics:
Now she's walkin' in the morning
Howlin' you come home
I'll be on my way, so long, forlorn
You just can't go
I will get it if I have to
If I have to please come home
Try, but I'll be dry, and I crave you
If I haunt you back all day
Carry my trouble
Yes you satisfy my mind
I'll try to tell you, if I can't come in
And I must stay true
I'll be happy in the morning
I try my best, I will try to help you
If I can, and I leave it too
But I just can't find you away
Won't some time away
...
That's the way I think she told me
Heart she bent on me
I'll be out all morning, for you
But you can't stop me
Yes, I try my best to please you
Try my best, but if I fail
You must help me to see you
As I go by
...
Now, if you send me a letter
I'll be on my way to get it for you
I'll be with my sister too
I can't find me what to do
Yes, I've been trying to get a message
To you, but you have to treat me
I won't let her to
And then I try my best to hunt her, you...
Wow good job on that one
It's truly wonderful to listen to him work.
He was on FIRE. Wish Bob had a clone who pursued these type of songs.
Just rehearsing this song...WOW! I'm almost in tears. I'm swooning right now and will be for a long while...Thank you so much!
So glad you enjoyed it!! Yeah, it gets emotional sometimes. Dylan tends to do that haha.
@@SwinginPig Yes, I enjoyed it very, very much! You've got a lot of good stuff on your channel. Thank you very much for all of your postings, they are fantastic and so are you! ❤😊
Yes yes yes!
Bob was pulling a great song out of that magic box where everything lies hidden...but it kind of slipped away. Very great upload, thanks. How great an artist Bob is.
Thank you so much for taking the time and effort to post this recording (which is much louder and much more clear than any other posting online). Being a Dylan fan is the gift that keeps on giving. Just when you think you've heard it all, there's some sort of unknown session or song that gets released. Thank you for making it possible to hear this rare recordings Swingin' Pig!
"I can't leave her behind" is such a pretty song. Great to hear Bob working it out here. There's a nice cover by Stephen Malkmus and Lee Ranaldo on the soundtrack of "I'm not there". Thankfully they resisted any urge to make it longer - sometimes brevity is art.
You really get an intimate glimpse at Bob working with Robbie on what was supposed to be one song that ended up being three completely different ones. After listening to it you hear how Bob would play one song and then as Robbie’s trying to learn it he’s started another one
Like a retrieved van Gogh, nobody knew it was lost, and then suddenly it is there. Awesome! All those sensibilities!
If you’ve ever been addicted to drugs you can see how and why they helped Dylan so much. They made him not even think, just write write write no time for analysis and whatever cans to mind however bendy stayed. I can imagine him once he’d got clean sitting there with his typewriter and laughing at the thought of even trying to write the chaotic way he did. Sitting there thinking ‘oh shit I have internal dialogue again with negativity and doubt” Man drugs are absolutely brilliant but they don’t work for long and once they’ve stopped will never work again.
The work on those albums are far too structured to be written just from the influence of drugs. Not chaotic at all.
Wanting it to go on forever 7:33 is just not enough!................sigh. Just haunting and brilliant!
Yep, to be a fly on the wall. Absolutely spellbinding.
6 days later Bob would be 25 years old, Happy Belated 78th Mr. Dylan (05/24/1941) thank you for the gifts you've given!
Wow, this tune is beautiful!! I understand why he never developed it further, since it doesn't really fit in with that much of what he was doing at the time, but this is gorgeous to hear!! Wish he'd sung a bit louder, but thanks so much for posting!
Iconic. Great to hear Bobby talking to Robbie. Two top faves ! Thank you so much Swingin' Pig
freevue Thank YOU. I wouldn’t be uploading without you guys :)
Could not even believe it was Bob singing until I saw the 1:31 clip of him and Robbie. Wished he had done more with this voice... awesome stuff.
That's such an interesting way to follow an inspiration when you don't know just what you want to say but you have the emotion - you just follow the emotion and create cadences of syllables against the rhythm and hope you can find some good words to match the emotion.
Man, this makes me so happy. I've been searching the internet for this clip many times and here you are with a longer one. Huge thanks . Peace
What a gèm¡ Brilliant songs. Thanks for finding them
dummy lyrics they're called, but they sound so beautiful, because it's bobby in '66
He could do no wrong in '66…
…except maybe on a motorcycle
In love again..with more of this beautiful heart grabbing tales. How I love this SP, Thanks again
Footage of this moment is included in Scorcese's recent documentary about Robbie Robertson and the Band called "Once Were Brothers." Check it out and you'll hear a few lines of this song being sung beautifully by Bob and see Robbie shake his head and marvel. Why was this not released by Dylan? By the Band? By anyone? It's a classic.
Imagine all the un-finished songs, or complete unrecorded tunes that would be lying around in Bob's kitchen draws
It's obvious that Dylan's throwaways would be another artist's greatest song.
These songs mean a lot to me. Thanks Swingin' Pig, love the channel.
KNOCKED OUT!!!!!....still listening.
Proud to be one of your new subscribers.
Wow totally amazing! Cannot thank you enough for posting this and I take my hat off to you for finding this rarity.
As these audios and videos are coming out, you can hear the work and the diligence that went into a Bob Dylan song
. shows off his tenderness (& I Believe he is Still capable of Completing it, if he likes) Touches my heart.
best audio of this i've ever heard
That story is a Horror story, if I've ever heard one! Thank God his chauffeur/bodyguard was a quick thinker! I've never heard this story before. It's probably something they would prefer the public not know about. Anyway, thanks Swingin', this is a gem!
In the movie “I’m Not There” there’s a scene about this incident and I always figured the filmmakers invented it themselves because I never heard about it actually happening until now.
Oh, it's so beautiful
"...twice as slow, twice as slow, it's too fast...yeah but to end it man...its got to be twice as slow as that...I'll fit the words in same way..."
This is such a beautiful song!
I've just watched this scene in I'm Not There, which is a great film, the one where a hotel worker bursts in and tells him he's a "traitor to folk music" or some other BS, and as a Scot who was born in Glasgow I shouldn't be surprised that this happened here. Of all the towns and gigs it had to be Glasgow! 🤪😜
Simply Can’t Get Enough of This
Fine Tuning Brilliant Stuff
Yes-tar Year Current Classic Magic
Love it So Much
🌸🌸🧡🧡🧡🧡🌸🌸
First time i heard this I couldnt stop thinking about the first time I fell in love.
If at first you don’t succeed… Robert the Bruce n all that…. Fascinating these takes. Beautiful photos too. When talking Bob doesn’t sound American but has a kind of British Irish mix of an accent. Wish I’d been old enough to get my kicks in 1966. Thx for this. X
RIP Robbie, these will always be my favorite songs
Thanks for posting this footage....so amazing.
later he voices similar tones...he has a beautiful singing style that hits notes others ignore only to say this man cannt sing...and the world is flat
Thank you so much for these two gems, dear sir. Also big thanks to Tom Keylock for saving Bob from the mad waiter. :-)
Beautiful indeed, he is chasing Mr Tambourine Man on this one.
great comment David
Such a great melody
Never heard this extended version. Thanks.
I keep coming back to this one
Thanks! So great only wish it was longer
Thanks, Olga,,,gosh,. I love this !...It's going Right up there.. with #improvnotes A rehearsal is great stuff.
Construction of a masterpiece the process is amazing wish I could have been there
YESSS!!!!JUST GOT MY LAPTOP BACK ONLINE!!!!THIS IS SO SWEET!!!!...BLESSINGS!!!!!
Wow. Amazing I am speechless. Takin a poo while listening
Nice
Great song. Subconsciously lifted slightly during the first part of the song from the folk tune 'I've been working on the railroad, all the lifelong day.. " only for a second though. Its awesome!
That's right! I thought it sounded familiar
Very very beautiful. I did what i rarely do and put on earphones for this one as hard in places to make out. Dylan doesn’t sound American. The way he talks. It’s hard to pin down the accent he has. His manner of speech. It’s lovely just hard to place. A man from all places.
fantastic video Bob Dylan rare
So beautifully Enchanting!
Thank you Pig!
it is,,,,blown away..I'm flying in the air
Imagine how great 't'would've been if Bob had spontaneously slipped this number into his acoustic set at one of the Royal Albert Hall shows!
't'would've been C O S M I C !
Wow, that would’ve been a treat. He would’ve done that in his early years. Prob too tired in late ‘66z
A genius born before his time❤️
How did i miss this!!! Perfect thanks Swingin'
Why did he not finish this ??- fantastic tune.
Levi Stubbs Tears Agreed
Thanks, you too...enjoy this gem while YOU can!
Guten Morgen, mein geliebter Bobby! Bedauere mich mal: Ich habe nur zwei Stunden geschlafen und muss noch warten, bis meine Magenschmerzen verschwinden! - Ich wünsche Dir einen wunderschönen Tag!
Ha ha I didn’t miss it but somehow I did miss it somehow! I swear I only drank a cup of red rose tea this evening! Lol. Ever since I saw those balloons at the end of you last video! Here is one of my new signatures when I really really like something! See how you inspire me friend! 🎈📌💥 Lol
thank you for this channel
Here, first time. Lovely Song
“On A Rainy Afternoon”
Thank you! I mixed up the tracks on the record. I edited the title accordingly. I'll be posting a 5 minute version of "I Can't Leave Her Behind" today. Thanks again!!
So plesant to the hear tanks
There's a bridge in it that sounds like the one in "Temporary Like Achilles."
Geliebter Bobby, Du SOLLST mich ja auch nicht verlassen!!
a real gem - karuna!
Outstanding
so swet voice ♥♥♥
wonderful
If I'd met Pat Quinn I doubt I'd want to leave that behind.❤
Redemption is key.
You got this😉❤
I think it needs to be twice as slow.
Das Ganze strengt mich so an, dass ich nur "in winzigen Häppchen" recherchiere. Es strengt mich nicht inhaltlich an, sondern weil ich denke, dass man mir diese Suche sehr leicht ersparen könnte! Aber "man (wer auch immer") will nicht!
YEAH YOU YOUNG BOB ARE THE BEST
YEAH YOUNG BOB YOU ARE THE BEST
Cool song
OUTSIDE IS RAINING I AM UNDER 3 BLANKETS DOG AND CAT ARE SLEEPING I AM JUST SMOKING AND LISTENING TO YOU BOB HONEY I ATE BIG SANDWICH AND NOW I AM FEELING MUCH BETTER KISS KISS
GO GET'EM KARMEN!!!!!!!!!!
has there ever been anyone cooler than Dylan 65/66
I belong to you Bobby.
Sweet.
bright boy with future you were I hope that you are now setisfied
YEAH YOUNG BOB
Nice!
Bobby, wenn ich irgendwie mit Dir verwandt wäre, würde das nichts ändern, keine Sorge!
Guten Morgen, mein Bobby-Schätzchen! Heute mache ich einen Haushaltstag, das muss auch mal sein...(mein Wohnzimmer sieht nämlich so aus, als wäre eine Bombe eingeschlagen)
Jetzt weiß ich auch, wie gern Du Dich hast fotografieren lassen! Darin warst Du das absolute Gegenteil von mir.
and i'll pray for you if you want me back someday like a train that comes in I'll want for you come back for you
🎼🌟
Sensacional, esplêndido
you neednt leave me behind
Mein geliebter Bobby, es sieht so aus, als ob Ancestry mich auf die USA hinweist......Aber ich prüfe das morgen noch einmal.
How did you get all these?
Also thanks.
I managed to get a copy of The Cutting Edge: Collector's Edition after many months of looking. Only made about 1000 I think. But anyway, it includes pretty much every note Dylan recorded from 1965-1966, and that's where I get most of the material for my channel. Thanks for listening and stay safe :)
Swingin’ Pig your a nice human 🙏thank you for uploading all of these
I'm making a small contribution to mr. Swinging pig. Thank you