People Told Me DON'T EVER PAUSE A David Gilmour SOLO, Now I Know Why | PINK FLOYD Reaction
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ต.ค. 2024
- Join my Patreon 👉 / binxb This is the Comfortably Numb -1994 version, without any pause. Thank you for supporting me!
👉 • My Friend Told Me To L...
#pinkfloyd #pinkfloydreaction #comfortablynumb #bindotv #davidgilmour #pulseconcert
NEW pink floyd reaction videos
react to pink floyd
first time reacting to Pink Floyd
![ILLSLICK - WINTER IS COMING [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dwTMeM1zIhQ/mqdefault.jpg)
I am 67 and a lifelong Pink Floyd fan, sorry some people are rude to you, they should not do that but Pink Floyd tends to trigger strong emotions. Thank you for reacting to my favourite band.
I’m completely a new mate and I’m a fan now. When I’m your age, they probably don’t produce new music. Thanks for your support, good health to you
@@BinNeverStop Your welcome and please keep reacting. I am guessing we won't be seeing much new music or live concerts from Pink Floyd members any more, I am sad to say. The oldest founding member of the band, Roger Waters is 80 years old now and the rest of the surviving members of band are in their late 70s. Richard Wright, the keboardist passed away from cancer some time ago, and founding member Syd Barrett left the band in the late 60s and has also passed away. Life and old age catches all of us in the end.
You are irrevocably won... a new big fan from the young generation... welcome to the club!
Great reaction! Its so good to see someone experience this for the first time. I hope you will continue to enjoy your journey with this amazing band. Thank you for sharing this with us.
Thank you!!
I don't mind pauses in reaction videos, as long as they are brief and relevant to what you are feeling. That said, after watching this, you probably realize why pausing during a Pink Floyd solo might upset people, many of them are in a meditative trance. As far as closing your eyes go, a lot of people are watching to see your reaction to the visual as well as the audio. I recommend watching first, then listening a second time (off camera) when you can immerse yourself in the music. All in all, a good reaction.
Hi, yes now I understand that and I’ll probably get mad at someone pauses while I’m listening to this 😂
I still remember seeing this Pulse video for the first time and I was so mesmerized by the visuals I didn't even want to blink in case I missed something. There is so much symbolism to be extracted, especially the glitter ball opening up, and whoever managed the light show did a magnificent job of keeping it all synchronized. I suppose some people just subconsciously close their eyes when getting caught up in the music, and if it's good enough for Yo-Yo Ma when he was sitting in the audience for Heart's Led Zeppelin tribute of Stairway to Heaven, then I'll give Bindo a pass as well. Hopefully he'll take a moment in his own time to watch the video from beginning to end; and maybe even do some research on the meaning behind the illuminated diamond at the center of the opened glitter ball.
I'm 61yo Floyd fan, it's so embarrassing that other apparent fans would be so RUDE and think they can tell someone else how to listen to music, and especially how they think someone else should do a REACTION video.
PLEASE ignore such RUDE people and PLEASE continue to do your Reaction videos any way you choose.
To those who wish to criticise "why don't you go f ck off to some other Reaction channel" there are lots for you to pick or better still make your own channel!
Sorry rant over, hopefully this Channel will continue and grow with positive comments and thoughtful content ❤
Most of Pink Floyd's fans are greater than double my age from all over the world. So I understand that they will have different perspectives and opinions towards their fav music, I respect that but I still keep what's mine. Thank you for your advice and your perspective on this. Good health to you!
I loved both of your reactions to this song. I'm glad to have gotten to see you listen to both live versions of this solo. Also I'm happy to apparently have bucked the trend of all of the viewers of your last reaction being male haha.
wow, you're a women in disguise?! hahaha
I see a "Anaconda " in your profile, you're working in Tech? I'm also working with "snakes" everyday
The Golden Rules Of Reacting to Pink Floyd Videos......Never Pause a Pink Floyd video, Never Close your eyes during a Pink Floyd Live Video, Never Talk over a Solo. Never place unnecessary banners over a Pink Floyd Video. Now you know.
Absolutely brilliant lyrics.
If you liked this, you must listen to their song "high hopes " pulse concert 1994. I know there are many amazing Pink Floyd songs, but this is by far the most beautiful song you will ever hear, and the best performance of a song ever... if you will let it touch you, it will open new corners in your heart.
Thank you! It's crazy to think I just discovered Pink Floyd now, I thought I know music quite well...
I read a lot of comment sections and it's ironic to me that with the way Pink Floyd's music makes most people feel they still want to be such a**holes. I mean, PF fans make some of the ruddest comments out there. That being said, I read a comment the other day saying that pausing in the middle of a David Gilmour solo is like being abandoned in the middle of nowhere by the Mother Ship, and I couldn't disagree. That's a much nicer way to put it. But really, it's your channel, it's your choice. I know I don't have a thick enough skin to put myself out there like you and others do. So, bravo, young man. 🖖🏽
Your words are truly inspirational. Thank you for sharing your thoughts with me. I really appreciate it.
Your last 2 sentences just brought me an instant power!
Was fortunate enough to see this concert twice! Unbelievable sound! I've never seen so many speakers at a concert, before or since this one! Was like a huge headphone covered us all! We just sat there with our eyes locked on and jaws wide open! Felt that concert and music for days (not an exaggeration!). Pink Floyd was the GOAT!
The bests hosts I have enjoyed never pause mid-song to talk. Breaks the "spell" that some great songs puts me under, ESPECIALLY with Pink Floyd. I hope you walk that path too. Good health to you.
Thank youuu 😁. This is the only reaction video that I don’t pause on my channel. Thanks to this, it helps me to immerse in the music and not get distracted thinking about the reaction. I really enjoyed it. Good health to you also!
A lesson learned Bindo, well done.
Hey my man you're doing fine with your English. Enjoy your journey with Floyd, all the best from the far north of New Zealand!
👋 I will keep practicing. What song do you think I should watch next?
@@BinNeverStop Time from the album The Dark Side Of The Moon. I'd do it with lyrics you will find it easier to follow, then I would do the PULSE version of it... enjoy.
Bro, don't worry too much about the critics. It's all about the music with PF. i subbed because I could tell that you loved it, and I hope to see more of your reactions to PF. Try Shine on You Crazy Diamond Parts I-V from the album Wish You Were Here 1975, studio version. It's a masterpiece! After you love that song, you will be thrilled to learn that there is a second part, SOYCD Parts VI-IX, which might be better than the first part. It's a magical journey, my brother. I've been listening to Pink Floyd for decades, and I never plan on stopping. Best band ever. Keep up the good work!
Hello, thank you for your comment. I'll check them out, I still do PL reactions since " It's all about the music with PF" as you said!
Love your channel ! 🌠Thanks for this reaction.
Glad to hear this!
your reaction was so good..thanks
That sir, was very much better and very much appreciated 👍 much more enjoyable. Thank you... liked and subscribed 😊
Thanks, I have a reaction video to High Hopes for membership only. Or on my Patreon
Thank you for doing this reaction. I'm about to watch it and I am sure that I will see that you enjoyed it. This will be fun. A suggestion for another track (It's a masterpiece.). The studio versions of "Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts I - V)" and there is a second video for (Parts VI - IX) also the studio version. These two tracks are long ...about 15 and 13 minutes but people don't seem to have an issue with it.. it's a journey. Pausing is easily done on these tracks by pausing just after the transition, stop and say what you think so far and then rewind to just before the transition and continue from there...that way there's no editing ..you just say I'm going back ten seconds so we don't miss anything...so less editing. Thanks again for doing this reaction.
thank you for the instruction, have a nice day
Nothing wrong with closing your eyes to listen to music, but this is a concert performance meant to be watched. Maybe for future reference, just do audio videos so you can immerse yourself in the music alone
Thank you for commenting. Actually I wanted to say that I didn’t know that I was closing my eyes automatically for that long 😁. And you’re right I missed the lightning effects and even their faces
I have seen Pink Floyd Live 4 times… I saw this same show Syracuse Carrier Dome in N.Y. 1994. The concert brochure said the stage is 120 feet wide. It takes a crew of 60 technicians three days to set up the entire lights and all. The concert schedule required that there had to be three entire crews to keep up. They leap froged each other for 92 shows with 20 Trucks per crew and a total staff of 195. The tour cost the promoters $98.MILLION to put on, but the total profit was $260 MILLION. Nick Mason’s drumming is incredible and matches Gilmour’s guitar emotions while Richard Wright takes us on a Magic Carpet Ride of tones that form the foundation of it all. When the “Disco Ball’ was uncovered and the lights hit it….. WHAT IS HAPPENING was what I said….The entire crowd was held in a trace and our minds totally blown by what we witnessed.
I sparked up my pipe for this reaction, as I do to all Pink Floyd songs. Thanks
You know all of Pink Floyd's catalog, please keep it forever
Back in O.C. Calif when I was 30 my wife heard a commercial on the radio about a David Gilmour show coming up. Knowing I am a Floyd fan she called the radio station (KMET - LA, “The Mighty Met”) to get information on the concert, The DJ on live radio Cynthia Fox…. said...."Congratulations, YOU are caller number 10, YOU just won tickets to the show and the Sound Check Party before the show"...
I met David Gilmour back stage. He gave us both a signed album that I have in my music room. We talked for 22 minutes. I called him…“The Master Of The Stratocaster” He smiled. I told him his music will stand the test of time with anything from Beethoven or Mozart. He smiled even bigger. I asked if I could shake both his hands that make such great guitar solos, he smiled bigger and said “Sure” and shook both hands at the same time, making a cross between us, I smiled HUGE. Hard to explain how awesome that moment was in my life. I asked him to describe his technique of playing guitar, he replied… “I strike a note, bend it, shake it and then release it”…. Yes, he does that quite well, better than any other guitarist I know. . I told him in my eyes he’s a “Legend“. He thanked me and said “Enjoy the show”…. during the concert after the song “Money” he looked right at me and said…. “On saxophone, another Legend, Mr. Raphael Ravenscroft” … acknowledging my comment to him. It is my favorite moment in over 300 shows I’ve seen.
I asked David…. How do you create those awesome solos?… he said….. I sit on a stool and listen to what Roger, Nick and Rick put down and play along. I listen to what I played and pick out what I like, then I put the pieces together into one piece then learn to play it as one. Our fans are fanatics for our shows to sound like the albums so I must play it correctly each time in a show. I have the concert Brochure and album on the wall with David’s picture centerfold.
All of us fortunate enough to have seen this show live were in a TRANCE.... MESMERIZED the entire show... as you can imagine. We walked out saying.... What did we just witness? That was out of this world incredible. The Red Fender Stratocaster he used for this concert in the Guitar Collector World is ....PRICELESS
What a beautiful story. You're such a dedicated fan and I respect your love to Pink Floyd and David Gilmour. I can tell because you still remember every line in the conversation, it must be one of your unforgettable memory. Thank you for sharing this, I enjoyed reading your memory. In my channel, I've reacted to a few artists, but when it comes to Pink Floyd, their fans all have stories to share, which makes a difference from others.
Another musically really interesting track you might enjoy.
Pink Floyd "Echoes (Part 1)" live at Pompeii 1972
No Audience, No Lights, No Pyrotechnics just Gods playing to the Gods.
The original track is really long with an extended "sound scape" section in the middle, probably not the best for a reaction video. However, the live at Pompeii 1972 is split into two parts. Part 1, you might spot where Sir Andrew Loyd Webber got the main Riff for The Phantom of the Opera 😉
Doing a Pink Floyd concert with your eyes closed if that's the way you like doing it that's up to you. However I would equate that to going to Star wars or Avatar and keeping your eyes closed during the movie!! Not only is Pink Floyd an audio experience but it's a visual experience each time. They utilize 98 million dollars worth of equipment in 1994 dollars! Again there's nothing wrong with the way you listen to music I'm just pointing something out.
I totally agree with what you said about the "visual" experience because I felt the same. The picture will be different for each person and different even for the same person each time they listen. Thanks for your comment!
Yeah I don't get it either but each to their own, I'm sure he's since watched it multiple times since like the rest of us have.
Hi, you might misunderstood my English. I meant I didn’t know I was closing my eyes automatically, that was interesting to see when I edited the video
Saw them at Oakland in '94. Best damn concert I ever saw OR heard. Crystal clear, multi-channel sound system. Just unbelievable.
wow you were there? I'm jealous@@AirDOGGe
Watch the entire PULSE concert even if you don't react to it online. You won't be disappointed!
Yes I believe in what you said
Don't sweat the haters. First saw Pink Floyd in 1973 Tampa Fl, and 3 times after. Their shows were always over the top but this particular performance is actually them at their seasoned best. Every time I went to one of their shows I was tripping. It was just how we did it. The best part about a Pink Floyd concert was people were mesmerized until the song was over and then went nuts until the next. You can see it here. A sea of heads doing the classic Pink Floyd sway. I've seen pretty much every great band , Zeppelin 73 was my first at 13. No adult supervision. There is nothing like Pink Floyd. Full stop. Capt.Bob , SV ( Sailing Vessel) 27th Chance, Tampa Fl, USA 🇺🇸
Thank you, another beautiful story from Pink Floyd's music lovers!
Good health to you!
@@BinNeverStop if you want some good upbeat music, Give Kenny Chesney a listen. No Shoes No Shirt No Problems, is fun. So is Get Along or Summertime. Something more interspective, try Spirit of a Storm, or Soul of a Sailor. Key's in the Conch Shell is nice too,or On the Coast of Somewhere Beautiful. Peace and fair winds. Capt.Bob...
Great reaction! Watch Sorrow from pulse concert
take note!
Those who shout about not pausing have very boring lives, don't worry. I'm writing this as a person who knows everything about PF. Those who shout about not pausing have very boring lives, don't worry. I'm writing this as a person who knows everything about PF. Do what you want, it's your channel
DMB - The Dreaming Tree
Next song? Please recommend me my next song after Comfortably Numb
Bindo é maravilhoso parabéns pela escolha ❤
Thanks Maria! Enjoy your weekend
@@BinNeverStop para você também que Deus abençoe sempre sua vida 🙏❤️
Welcome to the PF Universe bro where u'r sucked into ethereal places you never thought music can bring you. Btw, Pinoy ka ba? You're doing good with your analysis (ofc, there's more room for improvement, but for a beginner, you're all right).
I think people get upset with pauses (especially during a David Gilmour solo) because it shows you are not being drawn into the music in the way your comments might otherwise suggest. People listen to reaction videos to see if the music reaches the reactor in the same way it reaches them. Why else would they listen? It's not like they can't easily listen to the music uninterrupted elsewhere. That said, I haven't seen your other reaction video, and there is no excuse for rudeness. Keep going. BTW this is the best live recording of the best ever track in rock history.
I think it’s ok to pause just not too much and never during the solos 😊.
Yes, someone in the comment told me that pausing is ok, it's just that don't interrupt a solo
Nice reaction. I saw the orher reaction too but didnt leave a comment. Too many " pauses" lol. The studio version adds in the very beginning. You should listen to it especially since each rendition effects differently. Not just dave gilmore solos, any good guitar solo. " the Turning Away," pulse. Blackfoot, 38 Special, Lynrd Skynrd, Marvin Gaye, MJ. So much music.
I'll consider this as a success lol. I've never heard of any of these names you mentioned, I'd like to check them out
@@BinNeverStop
Cool.
Pink Floyd will fly you to planet Mars before Elon Musk’s.
just during the guitar solos you should not pause or invoke wrath :)
I think you missed the concert. Too bad... It was epic.
I wasn't even born yet :(
A reaction is a reaction not a review and analysis. And it's YOUR reaction so if you want/need to pause, do so. Viewers who don't like pauses can watch the original: in the long run you'll be better off without them.
That being said, many Pink Floyd albums should really be heard as a whole and if you react to a single track from the end of an album you may be confused because of miss context from earlier. The Wall is a good example of this.
In other words, with Pink Floyd I would forget the reactions and enjoy listening to entire albums undisturbed and without worrying about what your viewers might think (you can always review later).
Thanks for your comment, I will do what I feel like doing but still, I feel a bit ambiguous when ppl complain about my videos. I'm also mindful of the feedback I've received, as long as they are not commanding.
I'll spend time listening to that album on my own but not a reaction video
If you think you are going to listen to this again, you are wrong. So wrong. You are going to listen to it again and again and again and again and... :)
hahaha
I will "Like" this video, but I won't Subscribe to anyone that closes their eyes during a Pink Floyd Live Performance. That is a serious No No in the Reaction world.
Thank you, it's OK. But you may find it hard to find a person listening to Pink Floyd without eye-closing. It's like a command they give us through their music.
I've noticed that most reactors to this video close their eyes. I guess it's just a subconscious thing people do when getting immersed in music. Personally, the first time I saw this video I didn't even want to blink for fear of missing out on something. But of course I had heard the song (album version) many times before so I didn't feel compelled to get dark-lost in the music... just amazed at how they managed to expand the song into an audiovisual production.
Your video? What instrument were you playing? Nothing like using other people's work to make money from.
Have you heard of Fair Use? And the fact that you’re watching my reaction and not the original video. This is also my work.
Most importantly, I don’t make any money from any of my videos, all of it goes to the copyright owner. That means you don’t have to mention that I’m making money from them. I still do the reaction since I like their music and people are still supporting me 😁
To me it seemed so weird that you would put on one of the greatest live concerts ever and through nearly the whole video you kept your eyes shut to me it seems straight away your not a lover of visual art if that is the case then just listen to the audio without their beauty of their fantastic light shows.also when us floyd fans say please don't pause we actually mean do not pause a david gilmour guitar solo ever as to us that is a mortal sin.
I think most of people started with Pink Floyd through their music first. After they know the song well, they enjoy experience the visual art along. I believe I will follow the same path and will end up enjoying the visual art together with the performance.
Please PAUSE, PAUSE, AND PAUSE whenever you want..... Its your channel, and most of us want to hear YOU (we already know the music) but we want to hear what YOU have to say!
After your initial comment, I was curious what had gone wrong with your 2016 reaction.
Of course, you can pause during a reaction video - that's why it's called a reaction video... but never ever interrupt a solo, and certainly not one by David Gilmour! This borders on blasphemy for any Pink Floyd / David Gilmour fan.
The fact that most fans wished for this concert from 1994 is because this concert has a very special meaning. However, in 2016 I was there at the amphitheater in Pompeii and know about the special magic of this concert. Unfortunately, it doesn't come across on the video.
Btw; never pick up a guitar when David is playing and you're recording a video. This looks extremely strange. It is just how it is; No one comes close to David.
I got it. I’m only a beginner in guitar 😂
Thank you for clarifying it to me between pausing and disrupting 😄
@@BinNeverStop I've been playing for 15 years and I've been a pro for 4 years, but I don't play Pink Floyd songs in front of others. You can only lose. (but at home, when I'm alone in the studio, I love to play the songs) 😉
Mastering an instrument is a hard work. You deserve it because you haven’t stopped for 15 consecutive years. David Gilmour was really young in the video and he could play that good, he probably started at a really young age