I only remember Kaela sounding warbly like this twice: at the end of her 3D live and when Corvus (her clipper) graduated. This is hitting her hard for sure. 😞
@@momogi618 you should pray she play something else with aqua because minecraft currently is the last game they played together(kinda?) after pekora HC minecraft
We realized how old we are when there's more and more seniors to graduate..i respected all of their decision but yeah..they will all leave a hole in HoloWorld
Kaela's lingering feelings are very much like how IRyS all of a sudden needed to carry everyone's hopes and dreams immediately ten days after Coco graduated, but this time Kaela has a heck of a lot less room to breathe
It's a sad cycle. Seniors will graduate one day and new juniors will have large shoes to fill. I really hope in the future one day, they can all return for a cameo.
And tomorrow her best friend is also going to graduate.. bro.. idk how her feeling rn.. as a fan.. i can only watch her and give her some massage that hopefully can cheer her up a little bit..
Best we can do is be there for her birthday. Everyone would prefer things could be different, of course, but there's not much we can do... It's what it is, however! We can still make this month be a memory worth remembering, for Kaela, Aqua and everyone else in Holo They need our support more than ever, and not in terms of money, but in terms of passion
Kaela and other Holomen know this graduation news month(s?) ago… yet they still streamed and entertain us…idk what to say but big ❤ to Kaela and other Holomen
From what we can gather from watching other holomembers' videos, Kaela and the others already knew about Akutan's graduation. But they couldn't say anything until the official announcement. At least they'll be able to say goodbye to Akutan in the best possible way, which unfortunately wasn't possible with Mel-chan.
This is the first time I heared any Holomem almost sobbing after any announcement. I guess Calli was angry when Rushia was terminated but it didn't feel as visceral
Yeah. Such a gut wrenching feeling, seeing these girls showed us their true feeling. I remember when botan did the last group collab stream with coco. She regrets that she didn't have much time interacting with her, which make her spill her sadness right there and then. And man, i never thought botan could cry like that. But, coco left with her own term and aqua will too, instead of being forced to. So let's celebrate 6 years of her company and send her off with a smile!
@@martinbabich1920For me, there's no way I'd ever forget that moment. It's burnt onto my memory. It was such an impactful moment. For such a well composed person to cry like that. It surprised the whole chat. 😢
@@antokarman2064 Sana had a couple moments around her graduation too. Kobo was crying too hard to sing the song she wrote for her so had to sing it twice. And Ina and gen mates crying too.
It must have been really rough for the talents that knew about the graduation but couldn't talk about it. I can't imagine all the sadness building up and not being able to talk about it on stream 😭
I feel so much regret for leaving Hololive for 2 years, completely missed out Sana, I didn’t even know her, then I’ve returned for more than a year, only to see multiple members leaving, including A-chan who is an extremely special person. And now Aqua too, I did not expect her to leave at all, I though she would be here longer. We’re halfway through 2024 and beside Advent and Justice, there’s nothing really good, sad news continuously. Poor Kaela too, I can hear the tremble in her voice, someone might need to hug her the day Aqua graduates.
Graduations use to make me sad... But then I experience something worse with one of my daily vtubers. So I am happy we can still see Aqua one way or another in this life.
To be honest Its not like aqutan retired from industry Its like coco They have huge fan base and reborn All aqutan circle is not sad to much Cus they know they can hangout anytime with her But its diffren from en or id member They really fell the lost of aqutan Consider they rarely see aqutan in rl
I'm surprised management didn't advise/tell Aqua to change the date of her last stream. Because it should be an important day for Kaela (business-wise). Maybe I'm wrong tho.
@@dbzsongoku1 for the collabs yeah but alot of why she became one of the most popular of all time was her own work so yeah collabs are gonna be weird to see and non japanese speakers are hardly going to see her anymore but she can easily make it on her own
Yea it really is not, it's like an immersion thing about the character itself, the reincarnation is more like closure than to watch the person portraying another persona even tho it's still that same person with the same things you love about them. @@dbzsongoku1
Kaela crying eventhough she is did'nt communicate that much with Aqua, I can't imagine how gonna be sad she is if one of her senpai or genmate in Holo ID graduating
I remember the previous clip of Kaela struggling to let go of the graduated members, and now this has just made it worse. I feel bad for her mental capacity.
I guess Aqua's graduation was the reason she didn't play Ark with everyone else, she must not want to have sad memories like with Sana and A-Chan and avoid Ark altogether in the future
@@MrCh0oI think op means Kaela. Kaela does not play Phasmo and Clubhouse anymore because it's the last game she plays with Sana and A chan. Maybe she doesn't want Ark to be the last game she plays with Aqua.
bro the fact its not gonna be something to remember this birthday but every birthday? tf was management thinking of im pretty sure they are the ones who come up with dates
Bro, really, What the company think, I still don't understand. How they can't come to agreement with "creative differences"? It's not like she is newbie, not like she ever had a solid base etc. I don't have a company, so I might not know how it works but from my perspective, she is one of the most valuable "assets" to the company (everyone actually but you get the point). I would literally bow down in front of her to stay. I would even stretch a bit like "you don't wanna do x? Ok, we will lower the count a bit" etc. Of course we don't know exact reasons but I would do anything to keep her. She can find her way one way or another, but Hololive would lose a big asset. Also with that, from 0th gen to 5th gen, every gen lost a member now. Only 6th gen is intact.
The company's goal is to make money. Whatever rules they have in place must be to protect their profits at a level that's more valuable than what Aqua pulls in for them in revenue. I'm sure they tried to negotiate concessions and just couldn't make an agreement. And there's no problem with any of that. Aqua and hololive are both going to be just fine after this.
@@AdGarden7438 the bigger the company gets, the stricter the rules. Like in getting permission to play a game on stream from the owner of said game. (I imagine)
@@Blueman_Solo She still will need the permissions for games. I saw some said same thing like "indies are usually small, so companies won't chase them for copyrights" etc. Do you think Aqua will be "small" indie? Now she will need to organize everything herself, unless she only wants to play Apex etc.
@@AdGarden7438 Yes, but Cover probably had to offer concessions to keep her. So they'd lose value whether or not she leaves. They determined at some point that they'd lose less by letting her go than changing whatever she wanted to change. And again, that's totally fine. Aqua may have some of the highest viewership and TH-cam income, but Cover earns a lot of their income outside of TH-cam. Paid events, merchandise, and sponsor deals make up a ton of it, too. She's not as big of an earner in those departments. Additionally, there are nearly 90 other talents pulling in revenue for them. Aqua may be huge, but I don't see her making up more than 5% of Cover's revenue. She becomes an even smaller piece of their total revenue as more talents join. So, like I said, both of them will be totally fine after this. Cover will continue to grow and make plenty of money. Aqua will have the creative freedom to do what she wants.
I was once read something in the comments when Rushia graduated is that theres an unprecedented pattern going, not im saying its staged and could be just coincidence. Gen 5 = Mano Aloe Gen 4 = Kiryu Coco Gen 3 = Uruha Rushia They speculated Gen 2 is next, and that it can be Ayame, but then things happened... Gen 1 = Yozora Mel Gen 2 = Minato Aqua Even the pattern swayed, we still got that missing member every gen now. What a sad day for us fans but we somehow expected that older generation may go as new generation comes. We support them no matter what, we wish you luck and Godbless your new journey our Onion marine gamer maid vtuber, Aqua. 😢🫡
@@krisnakusdartono8958oh wow i forget about that. But i mean it more like the pillar type shii, like the second big shot leaving Sana's leaving kinda too fast before making a big moment like big big
@@awesomeguy9126 Coco was also pillar. She is grandmother of HoloEN. She changed a lot of things. Sana just said "welp bye" and went herself. I also heard she bans any Hololive mentions but it's just "I heard" thing, didn't see with my own eyes.
I don't want to say this, but i need to say the truth. Aqua doesn't care about Kaela. I never hear one of the Aqua streams before graduation worried about Kaela birthday. PDTA: The same thing has happen with Sana graduation, Aqua doesn't care
Kaela is a really big softie with a big heart. This is one of the many reasons why the fans love her so much. Thank you, Kaela.
I only remember Kaela sounding warbly like this twice: at the end of her 3D live and when Corvus (her clipper) graduated. This is hitting her hard for sure. 😞
I think after the hardcore minecraft event ended as well, when she became the last person standing and the server is closed down
Also when she finished building her museum that contain all gifts her senpai gave to her, she cried at the end..
Her voice is trembling
To hear _KAELA_ of all people struggle not to break down crying on stream...
It's heartbreaking 😔
its just gimmick
That "but it's not gonna be better"
hit me in my soul. Everything I've been feeling in that short sentence. Kaela's a good soul.
kaela is actually quite emotional deep inside, she's still havent play 51 club and phasmo because thats the last game she played with sana and a-chan.
kaela please dont collab and play minecraft with aqua for the last time 🙏😭
@@momogi618 you should pray she play something else with aqua because minecraft currently is the last game they played together(kinda?) after pekora HC minecraft
@@Falkner94 if its not one on one its safe probably (please 😭🙏)
Ela sad I'm sad everyone is sad Aqua left a hole and we just gotta respect her choices. I'm just happy she's leaving on her own terms
but the truth is pls don't leave Aqua
The onion leaves but I'm still crying.
We realized how old we are when there's more and more seniors to graduate..i respected all of their decision but yeah..they will all leave a hole in HoloWorld
I don't think Kaela will have a cake.
She'll get get get some help on that day....
Kaela's lingering feelings are very much like how IRyS all of a sudden needed to carry everyone's hopes and dreams immediately ten days after Coco graduated, but this time Kaela has a heck of a lot less room to breathe
Kaela acts like she's cool and above it all, but in reality she wears her heart on her sleeve and her "GSH" is her coping mechanism.
We'll all miss the Onion 😢
We'll miss the 44.5
We'll miss Baqua
Hope Aqua wish her best after left Hololive.😢
Don't say goodbye. See U later.
She may look strong and all, but she's very soft in heart.
Her endurance maybe great, but spiritually, she's very heartwarming
seeing this, i can't imagine how am I going to take it when Miko & Fubuki graduates
It's a sad cycle. Seniors will graduate one day and new juniors will have large shoes to fill. I really hope in the future one day, they can all return for a cameo.
Me trying to avoid graduation news*
-that one random short video : 👉👌
Fr, now I'm remembering Kobo and sana moment 😭😭
So, why am I still crying if the Onion is not here?!
And tomorrow her best friend is also going to graduate.. bro.. idk how her feeling rn.. as a fan.. i can only watch her and give her some massage that hopefully can cheer her up a little bit..
God is crying
-Subaru , probably
Minecraft server experiences flooding
Best we can do is be there for her birthday. Everyone would prefer things could be different, of course, but there's not much we can do... It's what it is, however! We can still make this month be a memory worth remembering, for Kaela, Aqua and everyone else in Holo
They need our support more than ever, and not in terms of money, but in terms of passion
Man, I can't imagine my fave vtubers not streaming anymore. I miss Kiryu Coco a lot and i also stopped watching Kson, it is not the same anymore
It is never easy to say farewell especially to a senior or friend you respect😢
Yep. It's as to be expected that onions make you cry. But it shouldn't be this much, though.
It make me think if one day that Kaela will graduate.. Man i dont know if my heart can take it 😢
Last Man Standing.
Minecraft Hardcore was a hint from the future.
(Copium )
Kaela and other Holomen know this graduation news month(s?) ago… yet they still streamed and entertain us…idk what to say but big ❤ to Kaela and other Holomen
From what we can gather from watching other holomembers' videos, Kaela and the others already knew about Akutan's graduation. But they couldn't say anything until the official announcement. At least they'll be able to say goodbye to Akutan in the best possible way, which unfortunately wasn't possible with Mel-chan.
💔 Dear God . . . she losing her AA members 𝗔-Chan now 𝗔𝗾𝘂𝗮 . . .
When Kaela gets sad and cries, we all cry, we know how big her heart is
This is the first time I heared any Holomem almost sobbing after any announcement. I guess Calli was angry when Rushia was terminated but it didn't feel as visceral
Yeah. Such a gut wrenching feeling, seeing these girls showed us their true feeling. I remember when botan did the last group collab stream with coco. She regrets that she didn't have much time interacting with her, which make her spill her sadness right there and then. And man, i never thought botan could cry like that. But, coco left with her own term and aqua will too, instead of being forced to. So let's celebrate 6 years of her company and send her off with a smile!
@@antokarman2064 I don't remember that
@@martinbabich1920For me, there's no way I'd ever forget that moment. It's burnt onto my memory.
It was such an impactful moment. For such a well composed person to cry like that.
It surprised the whole chat. 😢
@@Odontomango suprise everyone.. i thought Luna would be the one in that situation but apparently she's the calmest one
@@antokarman2064
Sana had a couple moments around her graduation too. Kobo was crying too hard to sing the song she wrote for her so had to sing it twice. And Ina and gen mates crying too.
It must have been really rough for the talents that knew about the graduation but couldn't talk about it. I can't imagine all the sadness building up and not being able to talk about it on stream 😭
I feel so much regret for leaving Hololive for 2 years, completely missed out Sana, I didn’t even know her, then I’ve returned for more than a year, only to see multiple members leaving, including A-chan who is an extremely special person. And now Aqua too, I did not expect her to leave at all, I though she would be here longer. We’re halfway through 2024 and beside Advent and Justice, there’s nothing really good, sad news continuously. Poor Kaela too, I can hear the tremble in her voice, someone might need to hug her the day Aqua graduates.
I just started watching hololive a few weeks and i been watching Aqua clips.. i was shock when i saw the news that she will leave
It's really heartbreaking hear to someone as cool, calm, and collected as Kaela on the brink of tears
"KAEEELAAA" -Biboo probably
She's so strong, I'm surprised everyone can handle it well
Just a blacksmith with a soft heart indeed
This time it was indeed in fact the onion has made us cry.
Graduations use to make me sad... But then I experience something worse with one of my daily vtubers. So I am happy we can still see Aqua one way or another in this life.
After all these time, we just realized that we actually really love her too much...
Awww poor kaela, she gonna miss to aqua 😢💔
My grandma died the night before my birthday day, i can totally relate to Kaela
Hope she can cope with this one....
We gotta take the silent cries with the silent laughs.
To be honest
Its not like aqutan retired from industry
Its like coco
They have huge fan base and reborn
All aqutan circle is not sad to much
Cus they know they can hangout anytime with her
But its diffren from en or id member
They really fell the lost of aqutan
Consider they rarely see aqutan in rl
When you hear a girl says I'm Fine
Either you prepare the tissues or run
Another graduation...this gave sadness to others and us🥲
I’m still in denial. It hurts as much as when A chan left. I can’t believe it and it’s really affecting my work. :(
I feel bad for Kaela and I know Aqua is Graduating on August 28 that will be her Final 3d Live Performance. So let's Cherish those memories
I feel like Kaela is the only Hololive member that will say she's not okay when she isnt okay. I adore her vulnerability
the Onion makes the Smith Cry.
Kaela Aqua League Colalb gonna be lit
I'm surprised management didn't advise/tell Aqua to change the date of her last stream. Because it should be an important day for Kaela (business-wise). Maybe I'm wrong tho.
Hopefully we will see Aqua reincarnated soon. 😢
It's not gonna be the same tho
@@dbzsongoku1 True. But change isn't always bad.
@@dbzsongoku1yes it won't be the same
@@dbzsongoku1 for the collabs yeah but alot of why she became one of the most popular of all time was her own work so yeah collabs are gonna be weird to see and non japanese speakers are hardly going to see her anymore but she can easily make it on her own
Yea it really is not, it's like an immersion thing about the character itself, the reincarnation is more like closure than to watch the person portraying another persona even tho it's still that same person with the same things you love about them. @@dbzsongoku1
When I found out that aqua introvert is the same as looking at myself in the mirror ,And when I saw the news that suddenly aqua graduateT_T
Aqua ❤ miss you and goodbye
When God is crying 😢
Kaela crying eventhough she is did'nt communicate that much with Aqua, I can't imagine how gonna be sad she is if one of her senpai or genmate in Holo ID graduating
I remember the previous clip of Kaela struggling to let go of the graduated members, and now this has just made it worse. I feel bad for her mental capacity.
After A-Chan now aqua -tan. 😢😭😭😭
I hope Aqua leave a voice notes or a video wishing for Kaela birthday
it's raining whole day today at my place on 28th. Coincidence? I think not
She should ask AZKi about this feeling. Coco graduated on AZKi's birthday so...
Ela 😢
I guess Aqua's graduation was the reason she didn't play Ark with everyone else, she must not want to have sad memories like with Sana and A-Chan and avoid Ark altogether in the future
Wait what, but she did play Ark
@@MrCh0o lmao i dont think they watched it
@@MrCh0oI think op means Kaela. Kaela does not play Phasmo and Clubhouse anymore because it's the last game she plays with Sana and A chan. Maybe she doesn't want Ark to be the last game she plays with Aqua.
@@Verosa1410 Oh, right, that makes sense.
bro the fact its not gonna be something to remember this birthday but every birthday? tf was management thinking of im pretty sure they are the ones who come up with dates
Young Mark Lee Paul White Maria
Will Kaela Collab with Aqua and lost yet another game......
Bro, really, What the company think, I still don't understand. How they can't come to agreement with "creative differences"? It's not like she is newbie, not like she ever had a solid base etc. I don't have a company, so I might not know how it works but from my perspective, she is one of the most valuable "assets" to the company (everyone actually but you get the point). I would literally bow down in front of her to stay. I would even stretch a bit like "you don't wanna do x? Ok, we will lower the count a bit" etc. Of course we don't know exact reasons but I would do anything to keep her.
She can find her way one way or another, but Hololive would lose a big asset.
Also with that, from 0th gen to 5th gen, every gen lost a member now. Only 6th gen is intact.
The company's goal is to make money. Whatever rules they have in place must be to protect their profits at a level that's more valuable than what Aqua pulls in for them in revenue. I'm sure they tried to negotiate concessions and just couldn't make an agreement. And there's no problem with any of that. Aqua and hololive are both going to be just fine after this.
@@AdGarden7438 the bigger the company gets, the stricter the rules. Like in getting permission to play a game on stream from the owner of said game. (I imagine)
@@Hocotatium111 Aqua is a "cash cow" That's why I said "she is one of the most valuable assets." Now they won't make any money from her.
@@Blueman_Solo She still will need the permissions for games.
I saw some said same thing like "indies are usually small, so companies won't chase them for copyrights" etc. Do you think Aqua will be "small" indie? Now she will need to organize everything herself, unless she only wants to play Apex etc.
@@AdGarden7438 Yes, but Cover probably had to offer concessions to keep her. So they'd lose value whether or not she leaves. They determined at some point that they'd lose less by letting her go than changing whatever she wanted to change. And again, that's totally fine.
Aqua may have some of the highest viewership and TH-cam income, but Cover earns a lot of their income outside of TH-cam. Paid events, merchandise, and sponsor deals make up a ton of it, too. She's not as big of an earner in those departments. Additionally, there are nearly 90 other talents pulling in revenue for them. Aqua may be huge, but I don't see her making up more than 5% of Cover's revenue. She becomes an even smaller piece of their total revenue as more talents join.
So, like I said, both of them will be totally fine after this. Cover will continue to grow and make plenty of money. Aqua will have the creative freedom to do what she wants.
I was once read something in the comments when Rushia graduated is that theres an unprecedented pattern going, not im saying its staged and could be just coincidence.
Gen 5 = Mano Aloe
Gen 4 = Kiryu Coco
Gen 3 = Uruha Rushia
They speculated Gen 2 is next, and that it can be Ayame, but then things happened...
Gen 1 = Yozora Mel
Gen 2 = Minato Aqua
Even the pattern swayed, we still got that missing member every gen now. What a sad day for us fans but we somehow expected that older generation may go as new generation comes. We support them no matter what, we wish you luck and Godbless your new journey our Onion marine gamer maid vtuber, Aqua. 😢🫡
Maid idol's gone today.
For the indonesian vtuber to. Alenka😢😢😢
the worst gift
Literally the second Hololive member to leave with proper Graduation. You know this shii is real
Maybe not second, there were coco and sana that got a farewell stream
@@krisnakusdartono8958oh wow i forget about that. But i mean it more like the pillar type shii, like the second big shot leaving
Sana's leaving kinda too fast before making a big moment like big big
@@krisnakusdartono8958 the pillar like she's japanese so she's the real og shii
After 2 years, with 2 Termination and 1 Retirement, at least we finally got a proper Graduation this time, man...
@@awesomeguy9126 Coco was also pillar. She is grandmother of HoloEN. She changed a lot of things.
Sana just said "welp bye" and went herself. I also heard she bans any Hololive mentions but it's just "I heard" thing, didn't see with my own eyes.
Kaela is also still sad about Sana. She's just not the type to easily let go and move on I guess
Man...
De unhapines burdday
💛😢
Williams Helen Taylor Laura Walker Maria
Haiyaaa.....
I don't want to say this, but i need to say the truth.
Aqua doesn't care about Kaela.
I never hear one of the Aqua streams before graduation worried about Kaela birthday.
PDTA: The same thing has happen with Sana graduation, Aqua doesn't care
Oh, this is pretty bad….
Ela 😢