Really? You call an attorney excellent who asked the jury to violate this child's human rights by sentencing her to lwop. Are you aware that all human rights organisations around the world continue to lobby and protest the fact that the USA hands this sentence out to children under the age of 18, at all. The rest of the civilised world see this as a travesty, just fyi.
She could have accepted a plea deal for 40 years with possible parole, but I imagine she thought they would see her as an innocent child, and this is where taking that chance took her.
I just said that under another video. 😂 Also in Mississippi, a life sentence means life without parole unless they clarify “with parole” which didn’t happen here. The judge explained previously that unless they said "Life with Parole"... it is Life...(without parole) in the jury instructions for the sentencing phase). The district attorney also said she’s gonna spend the rest of her life in prison, no way around it.
@@LedaMuchomas I have no idea who would have come up with the idea not to take it... Like 40 is a long time but she is young and would still have another 20-40 years of life free if she took it. Now she's more likely to die in prison. Oh well, maybe don't kill your mom.
@@Leah-q8v I’ve never seen that done before either! Well, saves time, I guess. He is incredibly mindful of his jury’s time and comfort. Nice to see. No nonsense ever with him! Lol
The problem is prior to the trial, there were times he essentially prosecuted from the bench. He worked for years in the same office that the ADAs who tried this case currently work. That stuff is quite common, and isn't an issue, but there were multiple hearings before the trial where he wasn't exactly straight down the middle. That stuff will come up in the appeal.
@@FaithiqueI don't get the impression he really wanted it to be life without parole. If it was him handling I think Maybe 20 to life with the possibility,but straight life
This judge has demonstrated (and thus demanded) stunning respect for the jurors. The jurors are very fortunate they were in his court room. I have seen too many where the judge does not seem to respect their time and their duty seriously.
@TapirusT It's difficult to have someone's life in your hands. I was selected as the foreman of a jury in a case involving leaving the scene of an accident that resulted in a death. I looked at everything like the person was innocent, but the facts proved otherwise. She went to jail for 5 years.
Thank you jury ❤ ..for not taking the bs of insanity ..if you kill you have to take the consequences ..period she had no compassion for her mom, so no compassion for her.
@@TMTM584 child my a**. She a teenager. She 14 not 4. When I was 14 if I did anything wrong I would apologize and be remorseful. She's not a toddler. She definitely knew killing someone was wrong and would land you in prison for a very long time. Don't forget this girl was close to a genius, not an uneducated teenager with a learning disability.
TRUE! The Mississippi Pearl High School shooting "1997", 16 yr. old, 11th grade student; LUKE WOODHAM. See the ABOVE two ARTICLES on him, LIFE, NO PAROLE!
Except when the judge made it clear to both sides' attorneys, that they have seemed to forget what's most important, to which he claimed was the jury. To him, the most important WAS NOT the victim mother, the victim stepdad, nor was it the family of the victims or defendant! He didn't have to respond to that attorney the way he did, all bc she received texts from parents who were upset with their children's names being broadcast on live TV. He embarrassed her in front of everyone in the room and to the live audience on TH-cam. The way he walked out after that too, was just so uncalled for! Other than that, he ran his court room like it was the military.
They say she’s extraordinarily intelligent, so I honestly wonder what she thought would happen after committing this crime? I cannot wrap my head around this. She doesn’t strike me as someone that decided to throw away her life on purpose. Can’t be that smart if she solely relied on the insanity plea. Very strange girl. Glad the jury got it right.
She probably thought she could stage a 'Mrdr/sooicide' (spelling wrong on purpose), She did not bank of Stepdad overpowering her. That's why I think she was asking the cops about the steps well being. I think her wannabe gangster/ narcissistic traits made it impossible to not show off and brag to her peer group she desperately wanted to impress. Highly intelligent book smart people often have zero common sense or self awareness so they leave a trail of evidence behind them. That's my theory anyway. I think it is very sad that people are making assumptions about the stepdad with not one crumb of evidence he was inappropriate towards Carly.
So she probably thought that she could pretend to be coocoo and if that didn't work, because she is so young that she'd go to juvie and that would be it.
What's incredulous is that you have the gall to criticize and judge people who have gone through an unimaginable tragedy, from the comfort of your keyboard. Supporting her is their right and decision...not yours. Who manipulates you and your hateful thinking?
They've lost a daughter. Where is the grief? Would they be willing to bring her into their home if found not guilty? Where's the common sense with these people.
Back in the day when kids were upset with their parents they would get mad, go into their room, slam the door and would forget about it the next day. 2024 kids grab a gun and do the unthinkable. JUSTICE WAS SERVED.
@@Valturnaqueen I’ve worked with some seriously mentally ill individuals and I’ve never felt more disturbed than by her behaviour. She is definitely dangerous to society.
For people saying she had a relationship with the step dad- they confiscated and reviewed all cell phones and video footage. If that were true there would be proof and evidence. Even with all her burner phones there was nothing between the two.
She was incredibly cruel, calling her friends to see her mother's corpse. She had no mercy and not a shred of remorse. She was satisfied with what she did. It was a trophy for her friends, saying, "Look, I managed to kill someone, this psychopath."
They said that she's never really fitted in well with her peers. So this was possibly her twisted way of gaining some form of recognition with them, and being accepted by them 🙄
@@leighdavis9522 I completely agree, it is really evident how insecure she was and I’m sure, still is. Telling the psych. nurse she was valedictorian etc.
If I ever need an attorney, I would hire the state in a heartbeat (& yes I know you can’t just hire state prosecutors!) Whether they win or lose here, I haven’t see the sentence yet, they are hard-core, intelligent, extremely knowledgeable and very convincing. They are amazing attorneys.
@@sandtats they should. im veryyy perplexed that she did not take the deal, they should’ve stressed to her the seriousness. i think she was very naive in her mind from the get go about how people would jot treat her lightly just because she was 14
I think she really thought she was going to beat this, she refused the 40yr plea deal , can’t believe she showed absolutely no remorse time to face the music Carly!
I'm curious why the defense didn't talk about the fact that the mom knew she had mental issues and yet she left a loaded gun for easy access never thinking she would be killed by her own gun.... parents especially when they have a child who is experiencing mental problems please lock your weapons up. She killed her mother with no remorse and attempted to kill her stepfather. It's a sad situation all the way around
The victim, a supposedly loved daughter, wife and teacher had NO ONE for her during this trial but strangers. She was immediately forgotten and everyone rallied around the murderer, disgraceful human beings, what a callous “family”, the drug addict father seems to be the better of them all.
@@marycarter8109 yes and theres a lot of people whom have murdered other people and didn’t get life in prison 30-50 years max.. and yet child rpsts get the smallest time and it makes no sense.
I think the stepdad is supprting Carly in honor of Ashley. He knows that no natter what, Ashley loved her daughter and would want someone to support her through this time. She is guilty, but that doesn't mean her family stopped loving her.
That poor man is probably on antidepressants now Thanks to her. She almost killed him and she killed his wife. Both him and carly r heavily medicated. I wouldnt be standing by her in my right mind thats for sure
I just have one comment. Did she really think she could kill someone and try to kill someone else and get away with it that is the first time I seen her cry. She acts like there was no consequences for her actions.
Oh my. They really asked how many years is life without parole? It’s NO parole. Why couldn’t judge say that instead no one knows? Doesn’t no parole mean just that? Life until die - NO parole
Same as Mississippi Pearl High School Shooter--1997; 16 yr. old, 11th grader, LUKE WOODHAM, I just looked up how many School Shooter's there has been for Mississippi.
I just wanna say that Mrs. Newman is INCREDIBLE! Talk about eating and leaving NO crumbs!! She got exactly what she deserved and I can't believe her family is that strongly behind her especially Heath! Sad all the way around. R.I.P Ashley Smylie. ❤🙏🏻
The stepfather also gives me the creeps. There is something of there. In her case she knew what she was doing. She even bragged about it. She pretends to be sweet but on the inside she is evil.😮
Someone clue me in on why stepdad (after almost having his literal head blown off,) is making gestures of affection towards the kid who tried to murder him?? Am I missing something? How strange…
No looks like someone still in shock and grief holding on to one of the last things he has left. You don't turn off love. These crimes change people and are difficult to navigate. And 0 evidence of that whereas there has been cases where this was true and discovered.
I hope the stepfather and the rest of the relatives do not put money in her commissary account so that she won't have any money to buy goodies. Some prisons compensate the prisoner for working in the prison and some prisons don't. If she works and gets compensated, I hope that the compensation she gets does not go to her to buy things at the commissary but goes to pay the court fees.
The stepdad has lived in two locations his entire 39 years, his mothers house for 36 years, then Ashleys home for 3. If that doesn't scream weird I don't know what does. Dude is a modern day Norman Bates, his personality is backwoods banjo player.
This stepfather has something strange, they must investigate thoroughly. His face and gestures are not those of a heartbroken and suffering man. They must investigate it, it doesn't convince me 🕵🏻♂️🕵🏻
The whole family is strange. Look how the grandparents are laughing and giggling with Carly after she just shot and killed their daughter 6 months ago. Not a tear shed the whole trial and you know they've seen the pictures.
It's very telling that she was smirking and looking like she wanted to laugh during the whole trial the cries when sentenced. Only worried about herself and has no remorse. Edited for spelling.
There should be more of a deep dive and investigation of the relationship between heath and Carle. There is a lot of fishiness of behaviors between them.
Please don't hire that lawyer, you can't defend the indefensible, I don't know how this lawyer sleeps peacefully knowing the truth and trying to invent the lie, this lawyer doesn't work 👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻
As my Dad used to say: "Was it worth it?"
This woman attorney for the state is excellent! Carly is realizing she is not as smart as she thought she was.
Really? You call an attorney excellent who asked the jury to violate this child's human rights by sentencing her to lwop. Are you aware that all human rights organisations around the world continue to lobby and protest the fact that the USA hands this sentence out to children under the age of 18, at all. The rest of the civilised world see this as a travesty, just fyi.
She could have accepted a plea deal for 40 years with possible parole, but I imagine she thought they would see her as an innocent child, and this is where taking that chance took her.
I just said that under another video. 😂 Also in Mississippi, a life sentence means life without parole unless they clarify “with parole” which didn’t happen here. The judge explained previously that unless they said "Life with Parole"... it is Life...(without parole) in the jury instructions for the sentencing phase). The district attorney also said she’s gonna spend the rest of her life in prison, no way around it.
She’s hoping the law that was imposed about juveniles committing crimes will have her out on parole in 20 years.
I’m sure she was advised by her counsel not to take the plea bargain. Bad move.
@@LedaMuchomas I have no idea who would have come up with the idea not to take it... Like 40 is a long time but she is young and would still have another 20-40 years of life free if she took it. Now she's more likely to die in prison. Oh well, maybe don't kill your mom.
El mata a su propia madre no debe salir jamás. Y la madre tampoco podrá salir de su tumba. Estamos viviendo tiempo finales .
No nonsense judge! I admire his total respect for his jury! Thoughtful and intelligent judge❤️
@@joannepollak5843 , he was the only judge I've seen that did the jury that way without call them by their jury number !
@@Leah-q8v I’ve never seen that done before either! Well, saves time, I guess. He is incredibly mindful of his jury’s time and comfort. Nice to see. No nonsense ever with him! Lol
The problem is prior to the trial, there were times he essentially prosecuted from the bench. He worked for years in the same office that the ADAs who tried this case currently work. That stuff is quite common, and isn't an issue, but there were multiple hearings before the trial where he wasn't exactly straight down the middle. That stuff will come up in the appeal.
@@FaithiqueI don't get the impression he really wanted it to be life without parole. If it was him handling I think Maybe 20 to life with the possibility,but straight life
A 14yr old child who knew what she was doing. She didn't hesitate. She looked calm. She deserved everything she got. Well done to the jury's verdict.
@@therese482 didn’t work 🤣🤣
There is something very unsettling about this young lady. Her cell mates better sleep with one eye open...
I stg 😵💫
She shows ZERO remorse. 🫤
Absolutely no remorse until she found out that she play big girl games and won big girl consequences.
This judge has demonstrated (and thus demanded) stunning respect for the jurors. The jurors are very fortunate they were in his court room. I have seen too many where the judge does not seem to respect their time and their duty seriously.
I agree. This is the first time that I have heard a judge say that there are jail terms for outbursts from the gallery.
@TapirusT It's difficult to have someone's life in your hands. I was selected as the foreman of a jury in a case involving leaving the scene of an accident that resulted in a death. I looked at everything like the person was innocent, but the facts proved otherwise. She went to jail for 5 years.
EXTREMELY dangerous to society
Thank you jury ❤ ..for not taking the bs of insanity ..if you kill you have to take the consequences ..period she had no compassion for her mom, so no compassion for her.
She’s crying because she is realising she should have taken plea deal!
I'm just watching not sure if I will to the ending so what were the yrs given was it life i
@@bronxNYC9846she got life, no possibility of parole.
@@snacktime5022 thanks
I'm sure that she's regretting not taking the plea deal.
@@snacktime5022does this means she will be in prison untill the day she dies?
She has 0 remorse! Smirking and smiling and still has the audacity to cry over people finding her guilty …. Girl byeeee ….
@@nettiea9384 She's a child
@@TMTM584 She's a convicted murderer.
@@TMTM584 a dangerous child you
cant have around other people
@@TMTM584 child my a**. She a teenager. She 14 not 4. When I was 14 if I did anything wrong I would apologize and be remorseful. She's not a toddler. She definitely knew killing someone was wrong and would land you in prison for a very long time. Don't forget this girl was close to a genius, not an uneducated teenager with a learning disability.
Crying in front of the judge n jury..smiling and happy when they leave the room..what a show
To me it looks like in that break the lawyers probably told her to pull herself together and they’ll appeal it etc. giving her false hope maybe.
She probably was reassured and probably given something for anxiety to help her. 🙄
@@francinejones2524totally agree and maybe given some meds
Look at the hate in her eyes when she looks at the Jury.
That’s what I noticed. Entitled little brat!
Definitely staring at each one
One of her relatives in the gallery was also doing the same.
The jury DEFINITELY got it right!!!!!
The way her and the step dad look at each other creeps me out. Something odd about the situation between them for sure
Did he tell her " it's ok " ? When he looked at her telling her something....
Makes you wonder if he was the driving force behind her decision. Imo
@Leah-q8v I couldn't work it out what he said but as soon as they said the verdict her eyes went to him but he wasn't given her eye contact back.
Agreed, creepy af
Very weird!
Life in prison
Life in prison
No parole !!!!
TRUE! The Mississippi Pearl High School shooting "1997", 16 yr. old, 11th grade student;
LUKE WOODHAM. See the ABOVE two ARTICLES on him, LIFE, NO PAROLE!
The judge ran the trial away a judge should! No BS and not wasting time, he was very professional!! AWESOME VERDICT
Except when the judge made it clear to both sides' attorneys, that they have seemed to forget what's most important, to which he claimed was the jury. To him, the most important WAS NOT the victim mother, the victim stepdad, nor was it the family of the victims or defendant! He didn't have to respond to that attorney the way he did, all bc she received texts from parents who were upset with their children's names being broadcast on live TV. He embarrassed her in front of everyone in the room and to the live audience on TH-cam. The way he walked out after that too, was just so uncalled for! Other than that, he ran his court room like it was the military.
Really she’s crying? Dude you murdered your mom !!!!!!
@@Faded_out She is crying for herself. She thought she could get her way and not be punished.
@@river8760 Agreed
@@river8760agree. Im thinking she is very manipulative and was used tk getting her way
But no tears
💯💯💯🤦♀️
They say she’s extraordinarily intelligent, so I honestly wonder what she thought would happen after committing this crime? I cannot wrap my head around this. She doesn’t strike me as someone that decided to throw away her life on purpose. Can’t be that smart if she solely relied on the insanity plea. Very strange girl. Glad the jury got it right.
Well, the step-dad was supposed to be killed too, so she probably would've concocted a plan.
She probably thought she could stage a 'Mrdr/sooicide' (spelling wrong on purpose), She did not bank of Stepdad overpowering her. That's why I think she was asking the cops about the steps well being. I think her wannabe gangster/ narcissistic traits made it impossible to not show off and brag to her peer group she desperately wanted to impress. Highly intelligent book smart people often have zero common sense or self awareness so they leave a trail of evidence behind them. That's my theory anyway. I think it is very sad that people are making assumptions about the stepdad with not one crumb of evidence he was inappropriate towards Carly.
@@cinnamonappple She’s highly manipulative and narcissistic that’s why she thought she’d win this case
Book smarts has nothing to do with empathy or common sense.
So she probably thought that she could pretend to be coocoo and if that didn't work, because she is so young that she'd go to juvie and that would be it.
I’m incredulous that her dead mother’s family is supporting her. She must possess a strong power of manipulation.
Right like how is the grandmother not moved whatsoever from seeing her daughter murdered by her granddaughter
What's incredulous is that you have the gall to criticize and judge people who have gone through an unimaginable tragedy, from the comfort of your keyboard. Supporting her is their right and decision...not yours. Who manipulates you and your hateful thinking?
They've lost a daughter. Where is the grief? Would they be willing to bring her into their home if found not guilty? Where's the common sense with these people.
@@AngelaMontarello2024unconditional love, I suppose
The Judge wasn't messing around and wasn't trying to waste a single second on some nonsense
I really love this judge. He’s firm and strict, he doesn’t tolerate any bs.
The crying and dread in her eyes before the verdict came out is only a fragment of the pain that she deserves.
Back in the day when kids were upset with their parents they would get mad, go into their room, slam the door and would forget about it the next day. 2024 kids grab a gun and do the unthinkable. JUSTICE WAS SERVED.
She doesn’t think she did anything wrong lock her up for life. She pleaded not guilty with video surveillance.
Oh sorry to say that...she looks a young innocent teenager...but she is not...she is a sociopath
“Sociopath” is the one word i didn’t hear mention in this trial.
Her smiling is CREEPY
@@Valturnaqueen I’ve worked with some seriously mentally ill individuals and I’ve never felt more disturbed than by her behaviour. She is definitely dangerous to society.
time stamp please I want to see
@@EclipticSir 5:31:10
@@EclipticSir1:33:54
Thanks
How sad for this Mother, it’s the ultimate betrayal!
She didn't appreciate the life she had now I hope she really realizes how lucky she was
She cries for herself; not for her mother, step-father, or anyone else she hurt.
The dude laughing in the back before she got the sentence is killin me 😭😭
Why have they been dressing her to look like a serial killer?
🤣😂🤣
😂😂😂😂
This defense team did her no favors whatsoever
Earlier they had her dressed like strawberry shortcake.
And a Catholic school girl 😂😂
I know it must be a tough job to defend someone with that much evidence against them.
Which is why they should hv urged her to tk that plea and spared us all that horrendous video
I say all the time that defense attorneys have one of the hardest jobs out there.
For people saying she had a relationship with the step dad- they confiscated and reviewed all cell phones and video footage. If that were true there would be proof and evidence. Even with all her burner phones there was nothing between the two.
Yeah he’s just, probably weird to begin with tbh but not pervy weird
That’s just sick.
@@alexiswashington3559 Das überzeugt mich nicht. Bin mir sicher dass da was faul ist
Yeah something weird is going on. Who puts cameras in their house.
You think he wasn't smart enough to orchestrate this outside of the phones that the police know of? That's a bit naive.
Something weird about her stepdad
What are you talking about?
@@bluejava9397 about her stepdad being involved on the crime, is that hard to got it? Lol
Yes totally agree with I. Propley Because he getting done next for leaving guns laying in the house for anyone to pick up and use
Very weird he defo knows something
@@bluejava9397He’s creepy. He is supporting her!
That that she shows NO remorse is 🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯
Why is she crying? She shot her mom to death and tried to kill her step father. She's lucky to even be allowed to live.
Absolutely agree 👍🏼
I don't think she wanted to kill the stepfather, this was orchestrated to deflect, he was shot in the shoulder.
@@NakaidaBeauzec Well, she definitely wanted to kill the mother then show her dead body off. Creepy girl.
She was incredibly cruel, calling her friends to see her mother's corpse. She had no mercy and not a shred of remorse. She was satisfied with what she did. It was a trophy for her friends, saying, "Look, I managed to kill someone, this psychopath."
They said that she's never really fitted in well with her peers. So this was possibly her twisted way of gaining some form of recognition with them, and being accepted by them 🙄
Exactly
@@leighdavis9522shes a mess. We r all here trying to understand the mind of a psychopath. Its impossible
@@leighdavis9522 I completely agree, it is really evident how insecure she was and I’m sure, still is. Telling the psych. nurse she was valedictorian etc.
@@river8760
Now she's got a new group of peers to try and fit in with.
She probably has no concept of just how long life in prison actually is. She is now going to find out.
She is very intelligent.
Life is LIFE in Mississippi when murder is involved.
@@63076tophereven for minors?
@@morechickentacos
She's been sentenced as an adult.
@@mare9707 The other females inmates will crucify her if she acts better than them. Likely already competing to be her Boss. Have fun sweetie!!
If she was so devastated with all the so called tears, then how come she managed to laugh near the end... very strange
Her male attorney seems to be sickened by her. There is very little interaction
He doesn't want to sit near her.
The jury did an AMAZING job 👏🏼👏🏼♥️
Finally tears and remorse for HERSELF! Sorry, not sorry. Evil child. Poor Ashley💔
She has no care or remorse empathy. They freed a boy who killed his father year, and he killed his mother.
What? Who was that??
@francinejones2524 happened in florida, and I searched it up. It was recently. Don't remember the boys name.
Whoever was in charge of the filming today of all days did a HORRIBLE job of it!!
Like how bad the chad daybell trial recording was
Agree.
The judge should not allow Carly to talk or interact with the public. 🤔
During the reading of the verdict, the judge was like “we’re finna speed this up, I’m trying to go home yall!” 😂😮💨
If I ever need an attorney, I would hire the state in a heartbeat (& yes I know you can’t just hire state prosecutors!) Whether they win or lose here, I haven’t see the sentence yet, they are hard-core, intelligent, extremely knowledgeable and very convincing. They are amazing attorneys.
Especially the woman State Attorney. She didn't miss a beat. Astronomical. Intelligent. She definitely held her own.
The reality of her behavior just sunk in! 😢 sad.
Her attorneys made a Hugh mistake with that plea deal.I bet her attorneys will a file a appeal on Ineffective counsel.
They're going to claim their own incompetence?😅
It was so bad, and I know it is irrational, but seemed like that was all they had and worked hard for, to hope for a judgement of incompetence lol.
@@sandtats they should. im veryyy perplexed that she did not take the deal, they should’ve stressed to her the seriousness. i think she was very naive in her mind from the get go about how people would jot treat her lightly just because she was 14
I'd like to meet Hugh mistake
@@davidfoster9339Devine Brown
I think she really thought she was going to beat this, she refused the 40yr plea deal , can’t believe she showed absolutely no remorse time to face the music Carly!
I'm curious why the defense didn't talk about the fact that the mom knew she had mental issues and yet she left a loaded gun for easy access never thinking she would be killed by her own gun.... parents especially when they have a child who is experiencing mental problems please lock your weapons up. She killed her mother with no remorse and attempted to kill her stepfather. It's a sad situation all the way around
i think they did talk about it a little bit on the first couple of days i’m not sure which one
Wow that deffence lawyer is terrible. Making it up as she goes.
The victim, a supposedly loved daughter, wife and teacher had NO ONE for her during this trial but strangers. She was immediately forgotten and everyone rallied around the murderer, disgraceful human beings, what a callous “family”, the drug addict father seems to be the better of them all.
Guilty or not guilty, the Child needs help, I just hope she gets it.
There is no help for evil
She is going to sit in a jail cell. There is no therapy.
There's no treatment for a psychopath. She had a therapist she "liked". She manipulated everyone.
No family to plead for her sentence. Very surprised at that
That surprised me too
I was surprised too, considering how the repeatedly said the family was so supportive of her.
No emotion. Smiling leaving court.
The father in law...so protective of her....he is not distraught at all....after the gerdict....what a weird character....
Maybe there's way more to this story than we know.
She was Cold, Calm &. Calculated about Everything she did that day. Now it's Consequences for her Heinous Actions.😕
How is she getting a life sentence when child rpsts get nothing but a few months to 5 years? This world makes no sense.
I agree
She killed her mother
@@marycarter8109 yes and theres a lot of people whom have murdered other people and didn’t get life in prison 30-50 years max.. and yet child rpsts get the smallest time and it makes no sense.
Now that there's no chance of parole, i hope there will be an interview with her.
Unlikely many don't allow interviews especially at her age.
@@Beachnut123no parole
@@Beachnut123
Life without parole
@Beachnut123 no she got life without parole. The sentence and judges instructions were crystal clear there is no chance for parole.
Watch it again@@leighdavis9522
I think the stepdad is supprting Carly in honor of Ashley. He knows that no natter what, Ashley loved her daughter and would want someone to support her through this time. She is guilty, but that doesn't mean her family stopped loving her.
I agree 💯%. The way he wailed on the porch about his wife was so genuine.
had to be the only verdict, 28 yrs in law & order, she was cold, callous and calculated.
Love this no-nonsense judge!
The stepfather gives me bad vibes🤔
Agree
Yep I agree
That poor man is probably on antidepressants now Thanks to her. She almost killed him and she killed his wife. Both him and carly r heavily medicated. I wouldnt be standing by her in my right mind thats for sure
She may not have planned for weeks to harm parents but in that moment she reacted.
Still she knew wrong from right saying "TO LATE " to that boy
ZERO emotion until she was found guilty…. Then and only then do the tears start flowing
I just have one comment. Did she really think she could kill someone and try to kill someone else and get away with it that is the first time I seen her cry. She acts like there was no consequences for her actions.
Oh my. They really asked how many years is life without parole? It’s NO parole. Why couldn’t judge say that instead no one knows? Doesn’t no parole mean just that? Life until die - NO parole
Same as Mississippi Pearl High School Shooter--1997; 16 yr. old, 11th grader, LUKE WOODHAM, I just looked up how many School Shooter's there has been for Mississippi.
I guess the Peppermint Patty persona didn't work so well for the defense
I just wanna say that Mrs. Newman is INCREDIBLE! Talk about eating and leaving NO crumbs!! She got exactly what she deserved and I can't believe her family is that strongly behind her especially Heath! Sad all the way around. R.I.P Ashley Smylie. ❤🙏🏻
Whats up with defense attorneys part in her hair?😮
She should have been given the chair. Evil.
The stepfather also gives me the creeps. There is something of there. In her case she knew what she was doing. She even bragged about it. She pretends to be sweet but on the inside she is evil.😮
Odd they chose a jumpsuit for her court attire; yet very fitting.
Someone clue me in on why stepdad (after almost having his literal head blown off,) is making gestures of affection towards the kid who tried to murder him?? Am I missing something? How strange…
First mistake was committing the heinous crime. 2nd mistake was not taking the plea deal.
The way the stepdad looks at her creeps me out. It’s like they have a “thing.”
I agree it gives me the creeps
No looks like someone still in shock and grief holding on to one of the last things he has left. You don't turn off love. These crimes change people and are difficult to navigate. And 0 evidence of that whereas there has been cases where this was true and discovered.
@@angelayoung8385 agreed
And with the hair cut no comment says it better ha
Yes, I agree😮💨
She is only sad for herself right now. Thats it. Absolutely NO TEARS.
How calm she was after the shooting is very telling. Stone cold killer at only 14.
I hope the stepfather and the rest of the relatives do not put money in her commissary account so that she won't have any money to buy goodies. Some prisons compensate the prisoner for working in the prison and some prisons don't. If she works and gets compensated, I hope that the compensation she gets does not go to her to buy things at the commissary but goes to pay the court fees.
Something strange with the step Dad and I hope she speaks out now.
Jury made right decision
The stepdad has lived in two locations his entire 39 years, his mothers house for 36 years, then Ashleys home for 3. If that doesn't scream weird I don't know what does. Dude is a modern day Norman Bates, his personality is backwoods banjo player.
Oh wow, that's interesting. He's so odd! Where did you find that info?
Without a doubt 😲
Very strange. Is she protecting him? Humm
was he wording to her that he loved her before the sentencing?
You people are as nuts as Carly
You shall not kill your Parents
I thought the supreme courts ruled that juveniles couldn’t have life without parole?
She was tried as an adult
T
They did! She will receive a review around age 25 and possible revised sentencing
This stepfather has something strange, they must investigate thoroughly. His face and gestures are not those of a heartbroken and suffering man. They must investigate it, it doesn't convince me 🕵🏻♂️🕵🏻
The whole family is strange. Look how the grandparents are laughing and giggling with Carly after she just shot and killed their daughter 6 months ago. Not a tear shed the whole trial and you know they've seen the pictures.
I keep thinking there has to be something more to this story.
People villainizing the dad are sick. You're just not getting it. He's not the bad guy here, stop being bullies.
It's very telling that she was smirking and looking like she wanted to laugh during the whole trial the cries when sentenced. Only worried about herself and has no remorse. Edited for spelling.
She wasnt smirking at all? Were you watching the same trial
I watched the whole trial she wasn't smiling and smirking . If you can't come on here and tell the truth in your comment. Don't comment.
@@Julio-zl7yk Yes, she was. Laughing it up waiting on sentencing.
She actually did cry when they played the vids...
She was not smirking
The male defense attorney took every opportunity to make it clear that he had wanted little to nothing to do with her! 😮💨
No water coming out of her eyes still
4:20:17 is when the actual sentencing starts
Ty!
Thank You!
No more crocodile tears now that the jury reached a decision.
🏆
Thank you so much!
There should be more of a deep dive and investigation of the relationship between heath and Carle. There is a lot of fishiness of behaviors between them.
she is guilty and she is responsible for what she did! yet I find that she must have mitigating circumstances because she was 14 years old
Please don't hire that lawyer, you can't defend the indefensible, I don't know how this lawyer sleeps peacefully knowing the truth and trying to invent the lie, this lawyer doesn't work 👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻
They got it 💯 Right!!
And just like that her life is over.
She’s 💀 inside