We never got to see a duet between them. Taemin and Jonghyun's voices are my favourite in Kpop, they blend together like honey and milk. Atleast we have this treasure.
This is my fav taemin’s song and knowing this is the closest thing we will ever get from a duet between them makes it even more special. I love you so much Jonghyun and even tho you’re not here no more we will never forget you. NEVER ❤️
He didn't. He didn't sing any part in the song. But during taemin's arena tour in 2019 he used jonghyun's studio version voice while performing this song Originally thus only has taemin's voice.
That’s why I kept hearing and getting Jonghyun vibes and influence from this song.. no idea he was on it, I just thought it was Taemin showing how much Jonghyun influenced and taught him
@Parisa Ghasemi - I can’t get any SHINee CD’s in record stores in my city in Canada ! I ordered a couple of Taemin’s line of products but. not from that company !!
@@mjj1434 yeah sm really don't bother with restocking shinee and their solo albums ☹️ official smtown store on Twitter asked fans for which albums they want to get restocked,maybe they finally restock some of shinee albums too
@Parisa Ghasemi - Thank you for your note , I saw it today . I will have to find. a way to get SHINee CD’s - it’s also the shipping fees that are expensive
It is a beautiful song, but how can ANYONE read the lyrics with THIS(Jonghyun) handsome young man's face staring at us like that!? 😍😍🥰🥰 P.S. It is beautiful TORTURE
아직 2022년 12월. 너를 지켜주고 행복하게 해줄 수 있는 힘을 얻었으면 좋겠어. 나는 당신과 함께 죽을 수 있기를 바랍니다. 내 인생의 위치에서도 당신과 똑같습니다. 내가하는 일은 운이 좋으면 좋지만 당신에게는 행복하지 않습니다. 내가 죽을 때까지 나는 당신을 위해서만 나를 행복하게 만들지 않을 것입니다. 이제 나는 당신의 순수하고 순수한 영혼, 영혼을 만나기를 기다리고 있습니다. 언제까지나 행복하지 못해도 괜찮지만 너무 보고싶어요. 나는 당신의 영혼을 만나기에 목말라 합니다. 너무 사랑해요. ❤️ 종현 ❤️.
This is a pretty old song from taemin's album. Written and created by jonghyun. This song was initially made for jonghyun himself but when taemin heard he was so adamant at taking the song that he said if jonghyun didn't give him the song, he won't leave jonghyun bed and room. So.jonghyun had to give him the song. During the arena concert in 2019 taemin sang this song and used jonghyun's voice in background. So this is that concert version of song. Otherwise this also has a complete taemin version too.
This is the same album version of the song that's on Taemin's album, there is no other version. Jonghyun's voice has always been in the song The reason I made this video was because unfortunately the other lyric videos of Already weren't pointing out which parts are sung by Jonghyun. Poor Jjong not getting credit for his lines in his own song that he wrote lol. I suppose at times Taemin & Jonghyun can sound quite similar when they sing softly, so it seems like sometimes people have trouble differentiating their voices and didn't notice that Jjong's voice is in the song
@costa rica - I am a new fan of Taemin’s and of SHINee - I have heard that Taemin ASKED to use the song, and it was was too high a key for him . You make it sound like Taemin “pressured “ Jonghyun - which I doubt he would do. He gave it to Taemin to record, he keeps ownership for royalties etc .!! th-cam.com/video/_2uda-N2pTs/w-d-xo.html
@shiningblue - Just thank you for posting the lyric portion!! Beautiful song - I am a new fan of Taemin’s and of SHINee . I am enjoying discovering new music by them as a group and also solo artists .
@Sofia Viola - it is a beautiful song . Take your time and listen if and when you are ready . I am a new fan of SHINee and of Taemin’s , I am also a long time fan of Michael Jackson’s, so I know about missing someone and not being able to listen to certain songs !!
Discovering SHINee & Jonghyun in April 2021 How beautiful & soulful is this song..... Taemin has done well singing this, but Jonghyun’s voice even as just a background track is so expressive & soulful. And he composed this song & wrote the lyrics too ? He really gave his all to everything he did. Oh Jonghyun you did beyond well- you deserved a lot more recognition in your lifetime & really hope more like me find you & fall in love with your music.... Sorry we weren’t there when you were here with us. Hope you have found your peace
@meghpai - he wrote several songs - so he will get producer credit when recorded in future www.soompi.com/article/1099383wpp/x-songs-written-produced-jonghyun-will-always-remember#:~:text=This%20particular%20song%20was%20special%20to%20Jonghyun%20because,as%20a%20producer.%206.%20벌써%20-%20Already%20%28Taemin%29
@meghpai - I am a new fan of Taemin’s and of SHINee as well . First I heard “Criminal “ of Taemin’s , then found tribute concert to Jonghyun more recently
Such a Touching, Beautiful Song. The lyrics are embracing a sadness of the heart. Jonghyun was a Great Artist.. Talented beyond his years. His Soul Expresses the Love through his words and music. BEAUTIFUL!!!
It so beautiful... I’m sorry... I had to cry so much... Your the best Jonghyun... We Will miss you... forever SHINee will be and will always be a five and a shining angel... I Love You Jonghyun
Oh when taemin performed it at concert I thought jonghyun's voice is coming but i was not sure but now I'm miss u jonghyun it's a beautiful song taemin sung it very well
It was beautiful to hear Taemin and Jonghyun singing together, but the lyrics were so heartbreaking to me. Jonghyun put his heart and soul into this song.
still 2022 December. i can not forget you. Every day i cry for you, Every day i fight with my self with my mind for you. Everyday, months and years i am in stay with depression, frustration about What happened with you. i am in wish i could get power to protect you and make you happy. i wish, i could die with you. In my life position i am also same as you, what i am doing it's ok by my luck but not happy for you. Untill i death i will not make me ever happy just for you. Now i am just waiting to meet with your innocent and pure soul, spirit. It's ok if can not happy ever but I miss you so much. I am so thirsty to meet with your spirit. i love you so much. ❤️ Jonghyun ❤️. Please forgive me for i Couldn't save you.
Shinee started as a group of 5 members, is a group of 5 members and will always be. SHINee forever five to the end. I will fight with all the people who say jonghyun was with Shinee for 9 years. Because Shinee is 5 forever. 5 eternal members. 💎💎💎💎💎💙💙💙💙💙
"If someone remembers our relationship And he asked me how you we're doing I have to say that you 're just a friend'' These lyrics filled my soul with sadness thinking about what is in Taemin's soul. I don't know if there was something between them or not, but if there was, I'm happy for them and sad that it ended like this. We, the fans, have no right to dictate their lives. They are people too, they have the right to love who they want and how they want. I hate those who send them negative messages, judging them. I listened thousands of times to Jonghyun's songs "Y si fuera ella, Goodbye, don't cry, Please don't go" and every time my soul broke listening to his voice. Such a talent, such a warm voice, a man who sings with such passion and dedication is born once in 1000 years. If I were God, I would never let such people grow old and die!
![TAEMIN 태민 'Clockwork' Color Coded Lyrics [Han/Rom/Eng]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ya5T5oN3RTw/mqdefault.jpg)
We never got to see a duet between them. Taemin and Jonghyun's voices are my favourite in Kpop, they blend together like honey and milk. Atleast we have this treasure.
i know :(
the closest we got was that beautiful ost for school 2015
@Lindsey Lowe - Do you have a link?
Thank you .!
@@mjj1434 th-cam.com/video/RCYMcncfq9A/w-d-xo.html
Here
This is my fav taemin’s song and knowing this is the closest thing we will ever get from a duet between them makes it even more special. I love you so much Jonghyun and even tho you’re not here no more we will never forget you. NEVER ❤️
But they sang together the song for the drama "Who Are You: School 2015".
Love Him deeply. Golden boy, pure soul Jjong
Jonghyun was a true gift to this world. He was such a talented and beautiful man. #5HINee #BlingBling #Shawol
100% true no doubt 👏👏👏
He still is.
I didn’t know Jonghyun sang some parts in this song before. I only knew he wrote this and Cocktail for Taemin. Wow their voices blend so well..
He didn't. He didn't sing any part in the song. But during taemin's arena tour in 2019 he used jonghyun's studio version voice while performing this song Originally thus only has taemin's voice.
@@costarica9685 u can clearly hear jjong's voice in the harmonies especially when he says "nawaneun" 0:46, at 1:22, 2:36, 2:42
He also wrote that song
That’s why I kept hearing and getting Jonghyun vibes and influence from this song.. no idea he was on it, I just thought it was Taemin showing how much Jonghyun influenced and taught him
This song is everything!! they slayed it jongtae forever ♥️
Who's here with me? Who's listening to this song in 2020?
Ouhhh Pleaseee i missss uri Jonghyun😭😭
Jonghyunnnnnnnn
..!!!!
@Rindiani Yusibita Manalub - July 2021, new fan of Taemin’s and of SHINee!
The song writen Jonghyun. OBRA DE ARTE. MASTERPIECE.
I miss jongtae 😭
Amazing jongtae.. miss you jonghyun ah...
Love SHINee!!! Jongtae💕💕🔥🔥🔥💯
ONE WORD: AMAZING I couldn't be more in love with mv beautiful loves.
First time reading the lyrics, Jonghyun was/Is such a talented songwriter I wish that damn company atleast bothered to reprint his albums
@Parisa Ghasemi - I can’t get any SHINee CD’s in record stores in my city in Canada !
I ordered a couple of Taemin’s line of products but. not from that company !!
@@mjj1434 yeah sm really don't bother with restocking shinee and their solo albums ☹️ official smtown store on Twitter asked fans for which albums they want to get restocked,maybe they finally restock some of shinee albums too
@Parisa Ghasemi - Thank you for your note , I saw it today .
I will have to find. a way to get SHINee CD’s - it’s also the shipping fees that are expensive
Thank you for this gift
It is a beautiful song, but how can ANYONE read the lyrics with THIS(Jonghyun) handsome young man's face staring at us like that!? 😍😍🥰🥰
P.S. It is beautiful TORTURE
Who's here with me? 2021
La SM deberían sacarnos esta canción cuando la estaban grabando y la ayuda que dio Jonghyun a su hermanito menor
WOW
Shinee Taemin Jonghyun 🇮🇩🇰🇷🇯🇵🇨🇳😘🤗😉🙏💎👍🎅❤😇 lndonesia
Thank you💙💙💙💙💙
I miss JONGHYUN..!!!!!!!!!!!!!
❤😊😍☺️💖💗
Can't Express in words i just loved it 🥰😍😍😍😍😍🥰🥰🥰🥰😘😘😭😭😭 love you jjong , miss you 😘😘😘😘 , forever shinee
Wow
This song reminds me of monodrama by jonghyun
I am going to have to check that one out , thank you !!
아직 2022년 12월. 너를 지켜주고 행복하게 해줄 수 있는 힘을 얻었으면 좋겠어. 나는 당신과 함께 죽을 수 있기를 바랍니다. 내 인생의 위치에서도 당신과 똑같습니다. 내가하는 일은 운이 좋으면 좋지만 당신에게는 행복하지 않습니다. 내가 죽을 때까지 나는 당신을 위해서만 나를 행복하게 만들지 않을 것입니다. 이제 나는 당신의 순수하고 순수한 영혼, 영혼을 만나기를 기다리고 있습니다. 언제까지나 행복하지 못해도 괜찮지만 너무 보고싶어요. 나는 당신의 영혼을 만나기에 목말라 합니다. 너무 사랑해요. ❤️ 종현 ❤️.
😭😭😭😭😭
That song is old or new orva cover or what
This is a pretty old song from taemin's album. Written and created by jonghyun. This song was initially made for jonghyun himself but when taemin heard he was so adamant at taking the song that he said if jonghyun didn't give him the song, he won't leave jonghyun bed and room. So.jonghyun had to give him the song. During the arena concert in 2019 taemin sang this song and used jonghyun's voice in background. So this is that concert version of song. Otherwise this also has a complete taemin version too.
This is the same album version of the song that's on Taemin's album, there is no other version. Jonghyun's voice has always been in the song
The reason I made this video was because unfortunately the other lyric videos of Already weren't pointing out which parts are sung by Jonghyun. Poor Jjong not getting credit for his lines in his own song that he wrote lol. I suppose at times Taemin & Jonghyun can sound quite similar when they sing softly, so it seems like sometimes people have trouble differentiating their voices and didn't notice that Jjong's voice is in the song
@costa rica - I am a new fan of Taemin’s and of SHINee - I have heard that Taemin ASKED to use the song, and it was was too high a key for him .
You make it sound like Taemin “pressured “ Jonghyun - which I doubt he would do. He gave it to Taemin to record, he keeps ownership for royalties etc .!!
th-cam.com/video/_2uda-N2pTs/w-d-xo.html
@shiningblue - Just thank you for posting the lyric portion!!
Beautiful song - I am a new fan of Taemin’s and of SHINee .
I am enjoying discovering new music by them as a group and also solo artists .
@Angela’s World - a little more detail about the song
th-cam.com/video/_2uda-N2pTs/w-d-xo.html
I can't
@Sofia Viola - it is a beautiful song .
Take your time and listen if and when you are ready .
I am a new fan of SHINee and of Taemin’s ,
I am also a long time fan of Michael Jackson’s, so I know about missing someone and not being able to listen to certain songs !!
Yes sofia you can
Discovering SHINee & Jonghyun in April 2021
How beautiful & soulful is this song..... Taemin has done well singing this, but Jonghyun’s voice even as just a background track is so expressive & soulful. And he composed this song & wrote the lyrics too ? He really gave his all to everything he did. Oh Jonghyun you did beyond well- you deserved a lot more recognition in your lifetime & really hope more like me find you & fall in love with your music....
Sorry we weren’t there when you were here with us. Hope you have found your peace
@meghpai - he wrote several songs - so he will get producer credit when recorded in future
www.soompi.com/article/1099383wpp/x-songs-written-produced-jonghyun-will-always-remember#:~:text=This%20particular%20song%20was%20special%20to%20Jonghyun%20because,as%20a%20producer.%206.%20벌써%20-%20Already%20%28Taemin%29
@meghpai - I am a new fan of Taemin’s and of SHINee as well .
First I heard “Criminal “ of Taemin’s , then found tribute concert to Jonghyun more recently
I can feel Jonghyun's intense inner world and emotions in this song. Taemin reflected it so well.
The fact that Jonghyun wrote the song for Taemin
I shed my tears but I shed with pride ... too beautiful I love SHINee
Such a Touching, Beautiful Song. The lyrics are embracing a sadness of the heart. Jonghyun was a Great Artist.. Talented beyond his years. His Soul Expresses the Love through his words and music. BEAUTIFUL!!!
I would loved to hear Jonghyun's version of this amazing song.
Ohh!! Me too!!!
Me too, soooo much 😞
it exists somewhere, Jonghyun would've sang the entire song as a demo for taemin to follow. SM must have a huge vault of Jonghyun's unreleased tracks.
@@rukia1117 Yes SM has a hidden treasure of Jonghyun's unreleased songs and videos
@@rukia1117 if so I really want sm to release them all
SHINee forever and ever ❤❤💕💞
This song is beautiful, tears in my eyes ... but tears of joy because I found it. Fantastic performance from two amazing singers!
It so beautiful... I’m sorry... I had to cry so much... Your the best Jonghyun... We Will miss you... forever SHINee will be and will always be a five and a shining angel... I Love You Jonghyun
www.soompi.com/article/1099383wpp/x-songs-written-produced-jonghyun-will-always-remember#:~:text=This%20particular%20song%20was%20special%20to%20Jonghyun%20because,as%20a%20producer.%206.%20벌써%20-%20Already%20%28Taemin%29
Oh when taemin performed it at concert I thought jonghyun's voice is coming but i was not sure but now I'm miss u jonghyun it's a beautiful song taemin sung it very well
I think I’m gonna live in this song
I give you all my heart, why do I feel like I was left behind.
This was beautifully sang and written. Thank you Jonghyun, miss you terribly. :'(
He was an fallen Angle,now the angle has returned his home 👼👼.
@Gargi Mazumder roll 24 - I was thinking the same thing !! An Angel has returned home !
So beautiful ❤️
thank you for this beautiful gift, jonghyun
It was beautiful to hear Taemin and Jonghyun singing together, but the lyrics were so heartbreaking to me. Jonghyun put his heart and soul into this song.
Like every song he wrote 🥲
still 2022 December. i can not forget you. Every day i cry for you, Every day i fight with my self with my mind for you. Everyday, months and years i am in stay with depression, frustration about What happened with you. i am in wish i could get power to protect you and make you happy. i wish, i could die with you. In my life position i am also same as you, what i am doing it's ok by my luck but not happy for you. Untill i death i will not make me ever happy just for you. Now i am just waiting to meet with your innocent and pure soul, spirit. It's ok if can not happy ever but I miss you so much. I am so thirsty to meet with your spirit. i love you so much. ❤️ Jonghyun ❤️. Please forgive me for i Couldn't save you.
My heart hurts remembering it
보고싶어요 종현 오빠
사랑해요 종현 오빠
😭💔❤💋😘
th-cam.com/video/17QxYyoFm78/w-d-xo.html another song singing by Taemin with Jonghyun
Best song ever!
❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺
Shinee started as a group of 5 members, is a group of 5 members and will always be.
SHINee forever five to the end.
I will fight with all the people who say jonghyun was with Shinee for 9 years.
Because Shinee is 5 forever.
5 eternal members. 💎💎💎💎💎💙💙💙💙💙
Wow
"If someone remembers our relationship
And he asked me how you we're doing
I have to say that you 're just a friend''
These lyrics filled my soul with sadness thinking about what is in Taemin's soul. I don't know if there was something between them or not, but if there was, I'm happy for them and sad that it ended like this. We, the fans, have no right to dictate their lives. They are people too, they have the right to love who they want and how they want. I hate those who send them negative messages, judging them. I listened thousands of times to Jonghyun's songs "Y si fuera ella, Goodbye, don't cry, Please don't go" and every time my soul broke listening to his voice. Such a talent, such a warm voice, a man who sings with such passion and dedication is born once in 1000 years. If I were God, I would never let such people grow old and die!
💎종현 보고싶어 ...
사랑해♡💎
Is jonghyun who wrote the lyrics?
Yes, he was also involved in creating the music
Yes. He made the song.
hi
Lol...ur username made me crack😂
♡
QUE LINDO MDS
Miss you my sweet angel jonghyun love ever😔🥺✨👼💚
Definitely my Fav Taemin song, because of Jonghyun....miss him so much. I still think this song was for "Taeun" till this day.....
?
Mas foi o jonghyun que escreveu