“We want to go to the draft” should be followed by him saying “so we offloaded all our draft picks between pick 16 and 65 as well” just to really hammer home that the whole Collingwood trade period was a really late April fools joke that they didn’t get to pull because of COVID
Does he really expect us to believe that trading 3 of their best 22 players and a slew of second round picks for pick 14 is meant to improve their list???
@@Boz196 wow calm down I agree that they haven’t got this right but to say Buckley and Eddy have to go that’s a bit to far I’m disappointed but it’s not the end of the world we still have a lot of good players and we also have a few young guys about to have there break out year at the end of the day it’s a business and hard decision have to be made
@undeadkid101 101 I disagree yeah they were good players but I think we have better up and coming wait until next year and we will see how it all goes but until then it’s just your opinion vs my opinion Treloar is injury prone and stevo well he was good but off the field he had problems and even on field he had a lot he could work on but just thought it was all just going to happen #gopies
@undeadkid101 101 what ever we will just have to wait and see and if you ever watch a Collingwood game you would know that Treloar is out with his lame hamstrings half the season and Stevenson had one good year we have way better then them two 🤦♂️and Im not your buddy we aren’t friend in short I don’t like you so until you know what your talking about shut up 🤐 #GOPIES
@Just bored every time I write a comment to you it gets taken down pussy all I’m going to say to a moron like you is you don’t know what you are talking about and you clearly can’t read I’ve said in my last comments that we didn’t get it right moron but you know nothing about Collingwood so shut up clown 🖕🏻🤡🤡
As a mad Tigers supporter I have always delighted watching the Pies go down - but not this - it’s not right. The passionate magpie supporters should not entertain this jerk nor those in positions of power that allowed this dribble to represent management stance. Eddy, you have a very small window of opportunity to address this - as I would hazard a guess that many a magpie fan as well as footy fans in general are shaking their heads in dismay. WTF is going on??
I have no doubt a Richmond fan would have sympathy on this now having been there with Terry Wallace and his constant and idiotic defences of Richard Tambling
This is just typical of rich clubs . Just do what they want he would gladly be the fall guy.Essendon just try and buy a premiership never work for it ! Why don't clubs build from the top down that's how you build sustained success.
Ned Guy,.laughing out there somewhere - Stepho barely a shell of the player in 2018 for Norths - Atu couldn't get a look at a really bad Norths team - Flip on the fringes of Hawthorn Only player missed is Treloar but he played himself into a team that pushed Lipinski out.
As a life-long Collingwood supporter, I’ve never been closer to leaving the club permanently. The treatment of these players, the falsifying of intent and the absolute incompetence is astonishing. #sidebyside
Buckley & McGuire & Co need to go. Crap gamestyle crap coaching and then this Mis management. Wouldn't happen at hawthorn oe geelong.... Don't forget we have the best training facilities in comp too..... And we are still crap...
Has Ned Guy left yet? he talks bulldust and couldn't lie straight in bed. If he thinks Collingwood supporters will believe this then he has another thing coming. What is the status of Beams. Really they are going to go in search of what they just got rid of. Eddie can go too and probably Bucks.
at the end of the day as a pies supporter this appears a balls up. Stephenson will be a star for North and treloar has been a star. We will be down the bottom half for 2 or so years
most disrespectful crap to discuss and treat contracted players like this. from a Collingwood member. Side by side, what a joke of a slogan now and needs to change.
4:30 David King: Do you expect Collingwood to hold you responsible for this Ned Guy: Nah Graham Wright: Allow me to introduce myself Ned Guy: Ok Graham Wright(to Guy): You’re fired, go queue up at Centrelink tomorrow
Absolute dribble! I just wish the club would be honest with themselves and just tell the members and supporters the truth behind getting rid of three of our senior players for one 1st round pick! I would like to know how this 'strategy' improves our list! Just come out and say that it is a salary dump! Sick of the lies and innuendo!
I almost feel sorry for Ned Guy. Has he been told he's not allowed to just admit they mismanaged their salary cap? He said with a straight face that they've traded away good young talent so they can go to the draft to get good young talent. What?!?
Pies trading Treloar is like the Eagles trading Kelly saying they want to get into the draft and accepting peanuts for him lol these are the worst trades I’ve ever seen.
People must be blind. Nobody has focused on the fact they offered Grundy a monster contract in 2019 putting them in this mess. I called this last year. It was going to happen anyway. Covid is just being used as a scapegoat. This is what happens when you splash out millions on one player. Plain dumb list management
Wow literally in his first response you can see 3 issues; 1. The bloke is bullshitting, 2. He has no clue what he is doing, and 3. He is just a puppet.
Everyone can see the reality of the situation, saying we wanted to move into the draft when we have given away our last 5 first rounders for essential nothing in Beams Trealor and Stephenson is pure BS. Just be honest ffs
If I was the Collingwood hierarchy I’d be pretty happy with all his complete non answers. If I was a Collingwood member/supporter I’d be fucken pissed. A incredible lack of honesty how they fucked up the salary cap, and the ridiculous fire sale of top end talent in their prime. Complete and utter bullshit. This guy spins better than a politician. Adding better talent? Please, the draft is a lottery. You lost players at or coming into their prime. Utter madness and rubbish
Ned Guy and the club are a disgrace. Just one example, Stephenson is a young player, these players do have their ups and down. That’s the very substantive reason a coach is at the club. Get rid of the following players was the priority.. Roughead ..too slow, poor recovery skills, ground skills pathetic. Josh Thomas .. no good. Main not good enough, too old. Sidebottom now is too old, should have been traded.The graph is on the decline for him. Why isn’t. BUCKLEY ON THE TV? The club is on the decline. Supporters of The Collingwood Club are incensed, completely and utterly. Guy, Walsh, Buckley, even Eddie have fractured the club, and the evidence for that is the Treloar farce. What about Grundy? The most overrated ruckman ever. Shocking decision maker, tapping even hitting the ball towards opposition’s goals when the contest is 20 -30 metres from their goals. He has no idea. He stumbles and falls over constantly putting himself and the team out of the contest frequently ... locates himself half way between a contest and the next play, meaning that his outputs aren’t there particularly when the heat is on.. that’s no good. And, never or rarely marks a critical ball at full back or full forward. The reality is that he is a tall player .. that’s it in terms of adding value. I would never ever agreed to the dollars he’s getting. Walsh should be axed immediately. And where is Buckley now? I am a fan of Buckley , but you know, to advance the club with the ageing Sidebottom is poor.. should have been traded, a hard but very correct decision.. and the very overrated Grundy should have too been traded without any doubt. I honestly believe that I personally, would have done a lot lot better, showed the judgement and nous of what is required to be done. And what about Braden a Sier , always injured.. he’s a dud.. too many excuses.. he should have traded, or we should be told why not..
Strengthen the list by going to the draft.... yet they traded 2 young kids and a proven ball winner in Treloar with at least 3 years of good footy left makes absolutely positively NO sense whatsoever. He talks like they are getting the first 3 picks in the draft? One thing is for sure, I will bet this clown 1 mill that after the draft they will not have strengthened but weakened their list. How do guys like this get a gig at an AFL club. He is clueless
wow calm down I agree that they haven’t got this right I’m disappointed but it’s not the end of the world we still have a lot of good players and we also have a few young guys about to have there break out year next year and at the end of the day it’s a business and hard decision have to be made #gopies
Typical spin. Sounds like a load of rubbish. Wonder when Eddie will come out an get all angry and indignant and try and turn it around on the journos etc.
If I was a Collingwood supporter, I'd be so depressed watching this. This bloke is completely out of his depth.
😭😭😭
I am! And I am depressed!! This bloke is a clown
@@damienstefani6578 I am also and this is a joke. Seriously need to change the side by side crap.
Oh don’t worry I am depressed
@Callan MOORE Good for you. Hope you guys win :-)
At least King asked tough questions. Why can’t people just be honest FFS and say we fucked up and we had salary cap issues.
cos then they get fired
"want to build up in the draft" trades away one of the best young players in the comp...
He's off his fucking head. Side by side? Get fucked
“We want to go to the draft” should be followed by him saying “so we offloaded all our draft picks between pick 16 and 65 as well” just to really hammer home that the whole Collingwood trade period was a really late April fools joke that they didn’t get to pull because of COVID
This is nothing short of a disgrace. Sad day for Collingwood.
@@helion2126 Thank Ned Guy lol
I honestly feel sorry for Collingwood supporters having muppets like That guy at there club
Thank you :-)
Collingwood make Essendon look like GENIUSES
Comment of the month. And I am a Pies supporter.
Does he really expect us to believe that trading 3 of their best 22 players and a slew of second round picks for pick 14 is meant to improve their list???
That's what I said. It's a textbook pre-planned answer from the club. Just tell the supporters the truth
They gave up every pick they had between 14-65, surely the whole period is some kind of sick prank on Collingwood supporters
God who is this turkey
Somehow I'm more confused after watching this.
Turned Collingwood from a 2020 top 8 side into a 2021-2025 bottom 8 side
Ned Guy is fucking cooked. The club is in absolute shambles. Eddie, Bucks and this flog have gotta fucking go.
@@Boz196 wow calm down I agree that they haven’t got this right but to say Buckley and Eddy have to go that’s a bit to far I’m disappointed but it’s not the end of the world we still have a lot of good players and we also have a few young guys about to have there break out year at the end of the day it’s a business and hard decision have to be made
@undeadkid101 101 I disagree yeah they were good players but I think we have better up and coming wait until next year and we will see how it all goes but until then it’s just your opinion vs my opinion Treloar is injury prone and stevo well he was good but off the field he had problems and even on field he had a lot he could work on but just thought it was all just going to happen #gopies
@undeadkid101 101 what ever we will just have to wait and see and if you ever watch a Collingwood game you would know that Treloar is out with his lame hamstrings half the season and Stevenson had one good year we have way better then them two 🤦♂️and Im not your buddy we aren’t friend in short I don’t like you so until you know what your talking about shut up 🤐 #GOPIES
@Just bored every time I write a comment to you it gets taken down pussy all I’m going to say to a moron like you is you don’t know what you are talking about and you clearly can’t read I’ve said in my last comments that we didn’t get it right moron but you know nothing about Collingwood so shut up clown 🖕🏻🤡🤡
This guy is an absolute muppett. They didnt even talk to the players involved!
that was hard to watch
That one-point loss is even harder to take now...
This bloke needs to be sacked immediately
Glad this bloke got sacked. All players who got pushed out that year have never been the same
As a mad Tigers supporter I have always delighted watching the Pies go down - but not this - it’s not right. The passionate magpie supporters should not entertain this jerk nor those in positions of power that allowed this dribble to represent management stance.
Eddy, you have a very small window of opportunity to address this - as I would hazard a guess that many a magpie fan as well as footy fans in general are shaking their heads in dismay. WTF is going on??
I have no doubt a Richmond fan would have sympathy on this now having been there with Terry Wallace and his constant and idiotic defences of Richard Tambling
So we get rid of Stevenson - an x factor young talent in hope of another one.
Logic zero. They fucked up and won’t admit it
This is just typical of rich clubs . Just do what they want he would gladly be the fall guy.Essendon just try and buy a premiership never work for it ! Why don't clubs build from the top down that's how you build sustained success.
This interview is crucial to our credibility. We'd better have Ned take this one.
Ned Guy,.laughing out there somewhere
- Stepho barely a shell of the player in 2018 for Norths
- Atu couldn't get a look at a really bad Norths team
- Flip on the fringes of Hawthorn
Only player missed is Treloar but he played himself into a team that pushed Lipinski out.
I remember watching this interview and thinking Collingwood were in huge trouble. Amazing turn-around in 2022.
Grade A baloney spin here
As a life-long Collingwood supporter, I’ve never been closer to leaving the club permanently. The treatment of these players, the falsifying of intent and the absolute incompetence is astonishing. #sidebyside
Buckley & McGuire & Co need to go. Crap gamestyle crap coaching and then this Mis management. Wouldn't happen at hawthorn oe geelong.... Don't forget we have the best training facilities in comp too..... And we are still crap...
Delusional.
Has Ned Guy left yet? he talks bulldust and couldn't lie straight in bed. If he thinks Collingwood supporters will believe this then he has another thing coming. What is the status of Beams. Really they are going to go in search of what they just got rid of. Eddie can go too and probably Bucks.
Beams retired
@@Draous1 I take it they paid him out.
@@ianmontgomery7213 His contract still counts towards the cap, one of the many reasons why they're in this mess.
@@BlackGateofMordor and the Pies will still be paying part of Adam's pay too.
‘The way to build our club is by the draft.’
Trades Tom Phillips for Pick 64, Jaidyn Stephenson for Pick 26, Adam Treloar for Pick 14
Something tells me Jeremy Cameron was in the bag on a high salary for Collingwood but Geelong got him at last minute.
Far out Ned comes across as arrogant and nothing else. Imagine being told by this guy that your club doesn't want you anymore. Brutal!
Wonderfull servants who didn't deserve this. I bet they bust there balls when they play against Collingwood.
This was uncomfortable to watch
It was enjoyable. This spud has the brain the size of a pea.
He makes dodoro look like a saint
at the end of the day as a pies supporter this appears a balls up. Stephenson will be a star for North and treloar has been a star. We will be down the bottom half for 2 or so years
Is this mess why Eddie McGuire’s leaving next year?
most disrespectful crap to discuss and treat contracted players like this. from a Collingwood member. Side by side, what a joke of a slogan now and needs to change.
4:30 David King: Do you expect Collingwood to hold you responsible for this
Ned Guy: Nah
Graham Wright: Allow me to introduce myself
Ned Guy: Ok
Graham Wright(to Guy): You’re fired, go queue up at Centrelink tomorrow
Jaidyn WILL be a great player, at another club. And playing another club $300k a year for Trelour....goodness.
Not to mention the money still going to Beams
this bloke makes dodoro look like a genius
Even the Fox hosts can't believe this nonsense!
Absolute dribble! I just wish the club would be honest with themselves and just tell the members and supporters the truth behind getting rid of three of our senior players for one 1st round pick! I would like to know how this 'strategy' improves our list! Just come out and say that it is a salary dump! Sick of the lies and innuendo!
Drivel. Not Dribble.
If I am a Collingwood person I am beyond dissapointed and would be looking to leave this dumpster fire organisation. Love Kingy's honesty!
Someone stuffed up the spreadsheet haha
I almost feel sorry for Ned Guy. Has he been told he's not allowed to just admit they mismanaged their salary cap? He said with a straight face that they've traded away good young talent so they can go to the draft to get good young talent. What?!?
Sounds like he got tips from Andrews on dodging questions..........
Andrews got results.
Mate that was a train wreck. Genuinely feel for Collingwood supporters right now.
Pies trading Treloar is like the Eagles trading Kelly saying they want to get into the draft and accepting peanuts for him lol these are the worst trades I’ve ever seen.
Loved watching Adam Treloar playing for Collingwood my favourite player, spin is all i hear.
loved to watch this bloke to get grilled... amazing closure from a pie supporter
People must be blind. Nobody has focused on the fact they offered Grundy a monster contract in 2019 putting them in this mess. I called this last year. It was going to happen anyway. Covid is just being used as a scapegoat. This is what happens when you splash out millions on one player. Plain dumb list management
This does seem to be an absolute balls up
Wow literally in his first response you can see 3 issues; 1. The bloke is bullshitting, 2. He has no clue what he is doing, and 3. He is just a puppet.
Is Ned Guy a politician. Because I don't believe he really answered one question.
At least politicians gabble on about nothing. This guy looks like a stunned mullet in the headlights.
I feel uneasy about this but maybe time will tell 🤔
Everyone can see the reality of the situation, saying we wanted to move into the draft when we have given away our last 5 first rounders for essential nothing in Beams Trealor and Stephenson is pure BS. Just be honest ffs
This guy is the biggest joke. YES WE HAVE SALARY CAP ISSUES. Stop lying ffs. You guys have destroyed our club culture.
There's a lot of different opinions, i say give it a couple of seasons an see how it pans out.
If I was the Collingwood hierarchy I’d be pretty happy with all his complete non answers. If I was a Collingwood member/supporter I’d be fucken pissed. A incredible lack of honesty how they fucked up the salary cap, and the ridiculous fire sale of top end talent in their prime. Complete and utter bullshit. This guy spins better than a politician. Adding better talent? Please, the draft is a lottery. You lost players at or coming into their prime. Utter madness and rubbish
Wtf is collingwood doing
Ned Guy and the club are a disgrace. Just one example, Stephenson is a young player, these players do have their ups and down. That’s the very substantive reason a coach is at the club. Get rid of the following players was the priority.. Roughead ..too slow, poor recovery skills, ground skills pathetic. Josh Thomas .. no good. Main not good enough, too old. Sidebottom now is too old, should have been traded.The graph is on the decline for him.
Why isn’t. BUCKLEY ON THE TV?
The club is on the decline. Supporters of The Collingwood Club are incensed, completely and utterly.
Guy, Walsh, Buckley, even Eddie have fractured the club, and the evidence for that is the Treloar farce.
What about Grundy? The most overrated ruckman ever. Shocking decision maker, tapping even hitting the ball towards opposition’s goals when the contest is 20 -30 metres from their goals. He has no idea. He stumbles and falls over constantly putting himself and the team out of the contest frequently ... locates himself half way between a contest and the next play, meaning that his outputs aren’t there particularly when the heat is on.. that’s no good. And, never or rarely marks a critical ball at full back or full forward. The reality is that he is a tall player .. that’s it in terms of adding value.
I would never ever agreed to the dollars he’s getting. Walsh should be axed immediately.
And where is Buckley now? I am a fan of Buckley , but you know, to advance the club with the ageing Sidebottom is poor.. should have been traded, a hard but very correct decision.. and the very overrated Grundy should have too been traded without any doubt.
I honestly believe that I personally, would have done a lot lot better, showed the judgement and nous of what is required to be done. And what about Braden a Sier , always injured.. he’s a dud.. too many excuses.. he should have traded, or we should be told why not..
Strengthen the list by going to the draft.... yet they traded 2 young kids and a proven ball winner in Treloar with at least 3 years of good footy left makes absolutely positively NO sense whatsoever. He talks like they are getting the first 3 picks in the draft? One thing is for sure, I will bet this clown 1 mill that after the draft they will not have strengthened but weakened their list. How do guys like this get a gig at an AFL club. He is clueless
This is hilarious.
Im glad I go for richmond
Feel bad for Collingwood supporters tho
side by side we stick together....🤑
Adam trelor is always injured and stevo is too soft
Glad he is long gone from Collingwood
brutal
He never wanted to go to queensland
**** Clown
Ned, wtf is Tim??
'side by side' ahahaha what a joke
snide by snide
Ned guy buckley an Eddie you guys are done your finished
HAHAHAHA
wow calm down I agree that they haven’t got this right I’m disappointed but it’s not the end of the world we still have a lot of good players and we also have a few young guys about to have there break out year next year and at the end of the day it’s a business and hard decision have to be made #gopies
Sure, make hard decisions. But don't sell good players for a pack of Twisties.
Disgraceful. Bye bye membership.
not good
Reality salts Ned, aisle 3 bottom shelf ,
flog
Muppet
Typical spin. Sounds like a load of rubbish. Wonder when Eddie will come out an get all angry and indignant and try and turn it around on the journos etc.
Bye Bye Bucks its your last year !