Starting Line was a sucker punch to the gut the first time I heard it and it hasn't let up. This entire album is an existential crisis wrapped up in a dream.
god the lyrics in comedown are so beautiful. it took me a while to clock just how pretty the lyrics are. "light up a darkness i was never meant to / climb out of like a bursting sunrise from the deepest sleep / a change of heart and a silver lining down on camellia street" just owns my entire heart idk if anyone’s pointed it out already, but luke has said that camellia street is where his now fiancée sierra used to live when they met :’) which just. a silver lining down on camellia street. im fine this is perfectly fine *sobs*
I found this album during a week in my life where something really awful had happened, and I hadn't really come to terms with it or cried at all. When I was in the nighttrain back home I put on the album and it shuffled to comedown. I heard that first lyric, "it's been a hell of a week," and that's the moment I completely broke down. I don't think any album has ever had this much emotional impact on me and comedown will always be one of my most special songs.
never heard his songs or 5sos but I watched your blue banisters reaction and this got recommended to me and the title was so catchy lol,so 1 thank you so much for introducing me to this wonderful album,2 I just subscribed your reactions are the best
I never expected much from this album but this is one of the best I've heard this year. It's just so cohesive and thought provoking. It's kinda sad many people didn't know about this but I'm happy to have found it and it's definitely a project worth listening to as a whole
I literally can't get enough of this album. I can't. It's probably the best album I've ever heard. I'm obsessed. I've listened to it so much that my toddler son wanders around the house singing the chorus of Mum lol. I just love everything about it, especially the songs Slip Away, Mum, Comedown, and Saigon. I need this album like I need air. It helps me feel alive and seen and loved and comforted, and maybe that says something about my mental state but like...Luke, you done good. Caitlyn, first off you are so pretty and just cute and also super relatable so thank you for doing what you do! But also I'm SO GLAD you made the connection between this album and CALM because I feel like if you listen to CALM and WFTTWTAF back to back, they are like part 1 and part 2 of a cohesive story, and you need both but when you listen back to back you get the full picture and it's amazing. Highly would recommend you do that!!! Love you girl, so many hugs! 💜💜💜
Heyyy I just found your comment, I've been struggling to find 5sos fans in India and you're literally one of the only few ik so maybe we can talk only if your up for it ofc
This album is perfection in every single way, and it never fails to destroy me but in the best way, if that makes any sense lol. Luke really told us his story in the most absolutely, unbelievably gorgeous way possible 🥺💙
CAITLIN!!!! caitlin marie......i'm pretty sure you have won your role as one of my favorite reaction youtubers. i found your channel because of your 5sos reactions and every video reminded me how i fell in love with 5sos and their music, and it's so endearing to see how you felt and fell into them exactly as i did. i've been anticipating your WFTTWTAF reaction since you mentioned it in your superbloom video and i'm so !!!!!!! by your reaction, i can't even put it into words. i've had this album on loop all week and it feels like the universe was preparing me for the drop of this video!!!!! you have once again reminded me why i love this music and it felt like i was experiencing it for the first time with you. i'm transported back to that august night where i did, in fact, turn off all the lights and lay in my bed listening to this work of art HAHAHAH thank you so much for your hard work and your genuine love in your reactions... i adore your personality and your character.
This album is so beautiful. I always gravitate towards it because it feels real, the themes are heartbreaking but relatable. I'm crying everytime i listen to it, from sadness and cause i'm SO proud of Luke.
The more I listened to this album, the more I feel like I am smiling, crying and dancing at the same time in the hell while shutting my eyes and imagining I’m in heaven
This album is perfection and it’s so underrated. I love every single song. Luke’s vocals and the instrumentals and production just create such a beautiful dreamy atmosphere, while the lyricism is meaningful and devastating and relatable. And the builds in these songs have me screaming the lyrics with my whole chest. Plus the music videos are great, especially Starting Line which matches the feeling I get when I listen to the song so well.
The way this album destroyed me and keeps destroying me in the most beautiful way every time I listen to it it’s crazy how powerful his music is! It deserves all the recognition in the world like it should be nominated for a freakin Grammy! For me it’s a perfect album like the emotions are just so pure and raw it’s just ugh I cannot even express how much I love it 💕💕💕💕
watching you experience that album like that is so heartbreaking and lovely at the same time. it means like the world to me and i discovered it through a reaction video like this, so i never had that 'pure first listen' (? lmao), but i love it to pieces and watching you fall in love with it is something so special
I love your reaction soooo much! For me diamonds is one of the saddest songs, the line "I'm so much older that I ever thought I would be" hit me sooo hard the first time I listened this album. But I'm really thankfull with Luke for writting something so honest, I'm really proud of him.
i literally checked your account every day for the last week waiting for this album reaction to do my homework to lollll and I would give anything to listen to mum again for the first time it is so incredible!!
"I know its depressing but I'm still gonna bop because it's so good" "This is what you got out of this video!?!?!?" "Am I suppose to be having time? Because I'm having a GREAT time"
totally loved this reaction and, of course, this album too, it’s so special and it speaks right to my heart like few other things do. Side note: the producer on this album is Sammy Witte who also produced Harry Styles’ Cherry and Fine Line which just makes so much sense
The first time I listened to the album it was night time and I was sitting in my room. I was thinking at first 'wow these songs are a bop' and then slip away happened, I got sad and listened to it four or five more times.
I love how your reactions are so authentic and relatable. I remember when I listened to this album the first time, I thought I was going to have a good time listening to it while folding my laundry, but after the first two songs or so, I realized that I needed to stop everything I was doing and fully immerse myself in the album. I just put on my headphones and laid on my bed, and it transported me to another world. I agree with you that it's an album I want to experience for the first time again and I'm glad we got to see your awesome reaction to it :) P.S. I loved your sparkly eyeshadow to match the vibes!
Ugh starting line just hits so different for me. I failed a few grades and watching my classmates graduate last year while im stuck in hs for another year and a half just made me feel like i "missed the gun at the starting line" i cry every time i listen to that song.
Your reaction to this album was everything!! I was the exact same way… and when you said this album was one you wanted to experience listening to the first time forever is literally me. Every time I listen to this album I get full body chills and transported to I don’t know where 😂 I truly think that our generation will be the ones to break generational curses, and the last few songs solidified that for me. I don’t know how I could experience the love I have for this album with music ever again. It’s amazing! 🥺❤️
I came back to the video, because today is the day. I heard this album for the first time. I put it on my calendar as a yearly reminder So I don't forget what a special day it was, I've been listening to the album all day and I have it on vinyl as well. I love rewatching seeing someone. Experience it for the first time..🥰 Much love marie🩶🩶
i loved a beautiful dream so much it was my fav since i heard the clip from the album trailer and hearing what the song is about make it a thousand times better wtf
As you said, it's a sad album but it makes us feel happy, it's powerful. It felt like listening to it for the first time again, thanks🥺 I love that you loved it❤️
Omg, yes! The Jeremy comparison is exactly what I thought when I heard it. Love is not dying is my comfort album and Luke’s album just brought in so many of the same feelings!
This album is like THE best album of all time. And Iam not kidding. Its a special journey through life...in space. Its the best I have ever heard. Iam a big 5SOS fan, but this is the best out of that world. Its on another level of any music album by anyone ever.
Your reaction on Starting Line, I was there too girl ! It’s just a perfect song. You and your reaction with Michael? Well, there too. Place in me is like perfection. Perfection. Perfection. The chorus of Slip away. Please, this is just everything. Not gonna lie, I laughed when you said « it’s going to be a happy one » 😂 This video is really good, I love the way you talked about this album, it’s really a great album, an experience.
i screamed when i saw the notif HELP but i had no time to watch it and yesterday too + i streamed red so 😅😅 ANYWAYS this literally just made me wanna listen to the album again :')
the “i bet this is gonna be a happy one” before slip away made me laugh hard
everyone got the sarcasm right??? because i feel like people didn’t get the sarcasm
@@caitlinmariereacts we did we did i really was like: oh bestie no-
Same lol
3:08 "the way this builds into the chorus is so rude.... do it again"
ME FOR THE ENTIRE ALBUM OH MY GOD
omg yess👑
18:30 PLSSS THE WAY U GOT SO HAPPY FOR A FAST PACE AND THEN UR FACE DROPPED WITH THE LYRICS… ur reaction is literally me
This album deserves grammys, but you can bet they’ll totally look it over
Starting Line was a sucker punch to the gut the first time I heard it and it hasn't let up. This entire album is an existential crisis wrapped up in a dream.
I hate the fact that I’ve related to this since I was 15 (when it came out) 😭 and I still relate
god the lyrics in comedown are so beautiful. it took me a while to clock just how pretty the lyrics are. "light up a darkness i was never meant to / climb out of like a bursting sunrise from the deepest sleep / a change of heart and a silver lining down on camellia street" just owns my entire heart
idk if anyone’s pointed it out already, but luke has said that camellia street is where his now fiancée sierra used to live when they met :’) which just. a silver lining down on camellia street. im fine this is perfectly fine *sobs*
not calum in the cocktails chats: “im just as sad, if not even sadder”
I found this album during a week in my life where something really awful had happened, and I hadn't really come to terms with it or cried at all. When I was in the nighttrain back home I put on the album and it shuffled to comedown. I heard that first lyric, "it's been a hell of a week," and that's the moment I completely broke down. I don't think any album has ever had this much emotional impact on me and comedown will always be one of my most special songs.
I know I'm late but hope you're better now btw merry Christmas 🎅 🎄 💗
@@paulapeter2637 that’s so kind thank you! A merry Christmas to you too❤️
Luke's recent performance of Baby Blue is so so good. I HIGHLY recommend. And yes, we are all obsessed with the Baby Blue visualizer.
YESS IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS ONE
WE HERE
never heard his songs or 5sos but I watched your blue banisters reaction and this got recommended to me and the title was so catchy lol,so 1 thank you so much for introducing me to this wonderful album,2 I just subscribed your reactions are the best
hiiiii thank u for being here!! i'm so happy you liked this project because sameeee
luke hemmings is a gift from heaven
In a lot of ways too. Or every way.
4:35 this whole album feels like a dream tbh
I never expected much from this album but this is one of the best I've heard this year. It's just so cohesive and thought provoking. It's kinda sad many people didn't know about this but I'm happy to have found it and it's definitely a project worth listening to as a whole
I literally can't get enough of this album. I can't. It's probably the best album I've ever heard. I'm obsessed. I've listened to it so much that my toddler son wanders around the house singing the chorus of Mum lol. I just love everything about it, especially the songs Slip Away, Mum, Comedown, and Saigon. I need this album like I need air. It helps me feel alive and seen and loved and comforted, and maybe that says something about my mental state but like...Luke, you done good.
Caitlyn, first off you are so pretty and just cute and also super relatable so thank you for doing what you do! But also I'm SO GLAD you made the connection between this album and CALM because I feel like if you listen to CALM and WFTTWTAF back to back, they are like part 1 and part 2 of a cohesive story, and you need both but when you listen back to back you get the full picture and it's amazing. Highly would recommend you do that!!! Love you girl, so many hugs! 💜💜💜
I've always waited for this album reaction. Can't believe that you've finally reacted to this album.
Lots of love from India. 💚
love uuuu
Heyyy I just found your comment, I've been struggling to find 5sos fans in India and you're literally one of the only few ik so maybe we can talk only if your up for it ofc
WHEN I TELL YOU THIS IS THE BEST ALBUM IVE EVER HEARD IN A WHILE 😭❤️
i was waiting for your reaction AHHH
I HAVE BEEEEN WAITING!!!! One of the GREATEST ALBUMS OF ALL TIME. It is literally perfection 😭😭😭
This album is perfection in every single way, and it never fails to destroy me but in the best way, if that makes any sense lol. Luke really told us his story in the most absolutely, unbelievably gorgeous way possible 🥺💙
3:20 “It can’t be loud enough; I need it louder! Ugh!” That’s exactly how I feel whenever I press play on this album…
This is hands down album of the year. It's my most played album lol.
this album came for me at the most perfect time, and i agree that i wish i could hear it for the first time again🥺
your woah fuuu- ok at 14:20 was literally me through the entire album 😭
CAITLIN!!!! caitlin marie......i'm pretty sure you have won your role as one of my favorite reaction youtubers. i found your channel because of your 5sos reactions and every video reminded me how i fell in love with 5sos and their music, and it's so endearing to see how you felt and fell into them exactly as i did. i've been anticipating your WFTTWTAF reaction since you mentioned it in your superbloom video and i'm so !!!!!!! by your reaction, i can't even put it into words. i've had this album on loop all week and it feels like the universe was preparing me for the drop of this video!!!!! you have once again reminded me why i love this music and it felt like i was experiencing it for the first time with you. i'm transported back to that august night where i did, in fact, turn off all the lights and lay in my bed listening to this work of art HAHAHAH thank you so much for your hard work and your genuine love in your reactions... i adore your personality and your character.
This album is so beautiful. I always gravitate towards it because it feels real, the themes are heartbreaking but relatable. I'm crying everytime i listen to it, from sadness and cause i'm SO proud of Luke.
Have this in my top 3 of the year atm!! The man shared his soul 😰
The more I listened to this album, the more I feel like I am smiling, crying and dancing at the same time in the hell while shutting my eyes and imagining I’m in heaven
This album is crazy, it has become one of my favorites. Listening to it is a really cool experience, luke opened his heart to us with this album
This album is perfection and it’s so underrated. I love every single song. Luke’s vocals and the instrumentals and production just create such a beautiful dreamy atmosphere, while the lyricism is meaningful and devastating and relatable. And the builds in these songs have me screaming the lyrics with my whole chest. Plus the music videos are great, especially Starting Line which matches the feeling I get when I listen to the song so well.
The way this album destroyed me and keeps destroying me in the most beautiful way every time I listen to it it’s crazy how powerful his music is!
It deserves all the recognition in the world like it should be nominated for a freakin Grammy!
For me it’s a perfect album like the emotions are just so pure and raw it’s just ugh I cannot even express how much I love it 💕💕💕💕
You went through all the stages of grief when listening to diamonds
watching you experience that album like that is so heartbreaking and lovely at the same time. it means like the world to me and i discovered it through a reaction video like this, so i never had that 'pure first listen' (? lmao), but i love it to pieces and watching you fall in love with it is something so special
I love your reaction soooo much!
For me diamonds is one of the saddest songs, the line "I'm so much older that I ever thought I would be" hit me sooo hard the first time I listened this album. But I'm really thankfull with Luke for writting something so honest, I'm really proud of him.
i literally checked your account every day for the last week waiting for this album reaction to do my homework to lollll and I would give anything to listen to mum again for the first time it is so incredible!!
"I know its depressing but I'm still gonna bop because it's so good"
"This is what you got out of this video!?!?!?"
"Am I suppose to be having time? Because I'm having a GREAT time"
this is my favorite album of all time the production is SO amazing
totally loved this reaction and, of course, this album too, it’s so special and it speaks right to my heart like few other things do. Side note: the producer on this album is Sammy Witte who also produced Harry Styles’ Cherry and Fine Line which just makes so much sense
Yes! It literally sounds like Harry's albums
this album fully saved me at the right time and changed the way i view myself and also Luke, i feel so connected with him, it’s insane.
The first time I listened to the album it was night time and I was sitting in my room. I was thinking at first 'wow these songs are a bop' and then slip away happened, I got sad and listened to it four or five more times.
I love how your reactions are so authentic and relatable. I remember when I listened to this album the first time, I thought I was going to have a good time listening to it while folding my laundry, but after the first two songs or so, I realized that I needed to stop everything I was doing and fully immerse myself in the album. I just put on my headphones and laid on my bed, and it transported me to another world. I agree with you that it's an album I want to experience for the first time again and I'm glad we got to see your awesome reaction to it :)
P.S. I loved your sparkly eyeshadow to match the vibes!
Ugh starting line just hits so different for me. I failed a few grades and watching my classmates graduate last year while im stuck in hs for another year and a half just made me feel like i "missed the gun at the starting line" i cry every time i listen to that song.
Mum never fails to give me chills
I said it in so many times before n I'll say it again: Saigon n Motion might be my ultimate two favorite songs ever .
Your reaction to this album was everything!! I was the exact same way… and when you said this album was one you wanted to experience listening to the first time forever is literally me. Every time I listen to this album I get full body chills and transported to I don’t know where 😂
I truly think that our generation will be the ones to break generational curses, and the last few songs solidified that for me. I don’t know how I could experience the love I have for this album with music ever again. It’s amazing! 🥺❤️
Come back to this a week before he performs this album LIVE and I’m BAWLING I wanna hear it for the first time again 😢
was not expecting to sob through this reaction (since i’ve had this album on repeat since it came out) yet here I am 😭
it’s kinda funny that you mentioned jeremy zucker because his second album came out recently too!! you should DEFINITELY listen, i LOVEEE it!!
I came back to the video, because today is the day. I heard this album for the first time. I put it on my calendar as a yearly reminder So I don't forget what a special day it was, I've been listening to the album all day and I have it on vinyl as well.
I love rewatching seeing someone. Experience it for the first time..🥰
Much love marie🩶🩶
I loved when she said "I'm not sad yet, I'm not sad....... YET" HAHAHAHAH
Omg, I was really waiting for this album reaction. This album feels like a DREAM and there are so many emotions involved 🥺, it's just beautiful 💫
"slip away, this has gotta be a happy one" *cries*
when you said "i'm not sad yet".... baby did you know what was in store for you???
i loved a beautiful dream so much it was my fav since i heard the clip from the album trailer and hearing what the song is about make it a thousand times better wtf
I don’t know why but Starting Line reminded me so much of Sign of the Times 😩
As you said, it's a sad album but it makes us feel happy, it's powerful. It felt like listening to it for the first time again, thanks🥺 I love that you loved it❤️
honestly this whole reaction is so relatable, i literally needed two days to emotionally recover from it
Omg, yes! The Jeremy comparison is exactly what I thought when I heard it. Love is not dying is my comfort album and Luke’s album just brought in so many of the same feelings!
very not on topic but michael in the carpool karabloke video is my whole existence
luke made a really incredible job making us feel all his fucking emotions through the songs😭😭
ok literally tho
the 5sos merch collection just keeps growing and i love it
this album gives TS Folklore vibes and that itself is hard to take in
I love how your reaction was exactly how I reacted when I first heard this album....I'm glad we are not okay..togther
19:03 “my camera is gonna die... mE tOo”
i felt that :(
OMG ITS FINALLY HERE!! IVE BEEN WAITING FOR SO LONG. loved your reaction!
Place in Me made me cry
This album is like THE best album of all time. And Iam not kidding. Its a special journey through life...in space. Its the best I have ever heard. Iam a big 5SOS fan, but this is the best out of that world. Its on another level of any music album by anyone ever.
David bowie, bts and 5sos in one frame. You so real for that
omg i was so excited for this video and you posted it on my birthday!😁
omg happy birthday!!!
it’s like i’m experiencing it for the first time with you
Oh girl I'm sending you hugs 😂😭
Life's been rough these past few weeks. You brighten my day so much.❤
I was impatiently waiting for this oooone let’s go
you actually nailed the edit, loved everything
please do a video where you tier rank all the albums released in 2021 that you’ve made videos on !!!
Your reaction on Starting Line, I was there too girl ! It’s just a perfect song.
You and your reaction with Michael? Well, there too.
Place in me is like perfection. Perfection. Perfection.
The chorus of Slip away. Please, this is just everything. Not gonna lie, I laughed when you said « it’s going to be a happy one » 😂
This video is really good, I love the way you talked about this album, it’s really a great album, an experience.
I'm just on starting line reaction and I already know this reaction is ME TO THE FREAKING CORE. 😭😭
CAITLIN OH MY GOD I LOVE YOU
I LOVE U
ngl i’ve been refreshing youtube and twitter for like the past 3 days waiting for this video
This album is so god damn beautiful
i screamed when i saw the notif HELP but i had no time to watch it and yesterday too + i streamed red so 😅😅 ANYWAYS this literally just made me wanna listen to the album again :')
i listened to this whole album when it came out but it still amazes me everytime i listen to the whole thing
omg finally!!!! i love this album more than my life, i’m glad you liked it 🤍
Baby Blue, Starting Line, Saigon my top 3 playlist from WFTTWTAF
From the moment I saw a star next to A Beautiful Dream in the tracklist I knew what's coming
I love your reactions, so excited to see this album
I cannot count how many times I broke down crying listening to this album. I just sat in the darkness for a good hour after listening.
i’m not ready to cry again but i’m so ready to cry again
i mean, relatable.
this is my favorite video you’ve made :)
This album is so good that kinda freaks me out.
The title and thumbnail.... SO TRUE (exactly how i looked when it first came out)
Thank you for an amazing reaction week. Lots of love from York, England.
fun fact ! baby blue is another word for meth in breaking bad
I LOVE HOW SHE PUT THE CLOWN NOSE ON HERSELF IM DEADDDDD
I never needed a therapist just needed this album
OMG IM SO EXITED I’VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIIIIS
ok I can't wait to watch this one because WFTTWTAF is my fav album of all time and I was so excited for you to listen to it !!!
:')
I CAN'T TELL YOU HOW INCREDIBLY EXCITED I AM FOR THIS
yes yes, I was waiting for this one
probably my favorite album on 2021
Finally 🖤
I recommend listening to the album PARANOIA by Maggie Lindemann 🖤
YESS
I LOVE MAGGIE 🤍
🖤🖤🖤
🖤🤍🖤
PARANOIA !!!!! 🖤
FINALLY FINALLY FINALLY
IVE BEEN WAITING foR THIS ONE
this is the best reaction on ur channel omg i love u caitlin ❤️