tbh tho it’s far-fetched I like the Shadow Realm Banishment being the reason why -Steam Roller- -Falcon- Sir Handel was absent between S5 and S9 (all of the SKR engines were absent in S8)
This was an interesting adaptation. Duncan does fit the role a bit better than Peter Sam. His grumpy attitude does get him into trouble with the branches. So it does serve him right when he gets stuck.
I remember asking whether @ShunterProductions would have an adaptation of Duncan replacing Peter Sam in "Prickly Problem" some time ago. You seem to have expanded on the idea. Well done. 👍 Gotta love Duncan and his negativity. 😜
A fantastic adaptation and TV serieseque episode to this next part of the RWS book featuring the Skarlory Railway engines. I liked how this one turned out. Keep up the great work and take your time on it.
I do remember youtuber srmcd1 did an audio story on it by having George the steamroller provoke Peter Sam into being careless and George ends up falling into the same trap anyways. He also did pop special with Duncan still but have it set up where Peter Sam believes Duncan has a massive soft side he'll never show others.
0:50 - Duncan: i’m glad we didn’t have time to take them, Fievel and Wakko Warner. 2:53 - What’s happening, Fievel. Fievel: there’s some falling trees in the line. 3:46 Duncan: Ouch! sounds like I can’t move, Fievel. Get those off Wakko. 4:57 Thank you for helping us out. 5:15 - Duncan: See. I told we made our way, Fievel and Wakko. 5:27 Duncan: [Laughs] This is kind of fun Fievel and Wakko. 5:41 And So did Fievel and Wakko.
I like the original ofc but this is better tbh, If Crisopher actually swipe roles for Duncan in prickly problems and Pop Special with Peter Sam, it would fit so better.
No indeed he doesn’t I figure it out. Duncan worked in the factory on the other railway in Scotland. He hates it in there. The Workmen were idle and dishonest, tools often went missing, the tracks weren’t even repaired and then there was a engine named Cain. He was their favorite engine. And yet if he made a mistake, Duncan got to blame and if he tries to do things better it’s always Cain got to please. Duncan was so happy that Mr. Percival brought him to Sodor but it won’t change Duncan experience of that old factory. That’s why he won’t stop complaining.
Yeah I mean apart from the time being very different in the uk I don’t fully get it but it’s kinda needed for 5e story maybe I shoulda rewritten in a bit heavier
I know the problem with branches hanging in the way of vehicles way too well. The noise produced by the vehicle hitting them is unbearable, and it only gets worse the faster the vehicle drives.
Was awesome doing the music again!!
Thanks for doing it!
I feel like sir handels trip to the talylln railway would’ve explained why he was absent from series 5-9
He's gonna come back during s4 though I have written a story giving a different explanation though
tbh tho it’s far-fetched I like the Shadow Realm Banishment being the reason why -Steam Roller- -Falcon- Sir Handel was absent between S5 and S9 (all of the SKR engines were absent in S8)
@@BrendamProductionsI always thought he was sented to the shadow realm.
@@BrendamProductionsis it like sir handel’s final scheme by keifer adams?
Not sure I've not seen that video so presumably not
This was an interesting adaptation. Duncan does fit the role a bit better than Peter Sam. His grumpy attitude does get him into trouble with the branches. So it does serve him right when he gets stuck.
Thanks Ross yeah I don’t really like Peter sam in the role for this story
I remember asking whether @ShunterProductions would have an adaptation of Duncan replacing Peter Sam in "Prickly Problem" some time ago. You seem to have expanded on the idea. Well done. 👍
Gotta love Duncan and his negativity. 😜
He’s a grouchy engine haha
I imagine when christopher awdry came to interview duncan he lied about the story and said it was peter sam who did it.
Like that sir handel story haha!
A fantastic adaptation and TV serieseque episode to this next part of the RWS book featuring the Skarlory Railway engines. I liked how this one turned out. Keep up the great work and take your time on it.
Thank you! I think the next video will be a Halloween original story but time shall tell!
@@BrendamProductions Oh I can't wait how this one will turned out. Take as much time to work on it.
I think the episode could still work with Peter Sam but using Duncan for this is fun too.
I do remember youtuber srmcd1 did an audio story on it by having George the steamroller provoke Peter Sam into being careless and George ends up falling into the same trap anyways. He also did pop special with Duncan still but have it set up where Peter Sam believes Duncan has a massive soft side he'll never show others.
This is a great and a Interesting Adaptation at that., great work.👍
Thank you! Glad ya liked it!
now we need peter sam’s pop special.
It's a coming! Might be next year though!
@@BrendamProductions next year?!
As in 2024 not as in 1 years time haha, Halloween and Christmas are around the bend haha!
Great adaptation.
Thanks!
Oh, Sir Handel. 😔😢
0:50 - Duncan: i’m glad we didn’t have time to take them, Fievel and Wakko Warner.
2:53 - What’s happening, Fievel.
Fievel: there’s some falling trees in the line.
3:46 Duncan: Ouch! sounds like I can’t move, Fievel. Get those off Wakko.
4:57 Thank you for helping us out.
5:15 - Duncan: See. I told we made our way, Fievel and Wakko.
5:27 Duncan: [Laughs] This is kind of fun Fievel and Wakko.
5:41 And So did Fievel and Wakko.
Interesting choice of character switch. Not sure if it works better or not but it still has the same flavor as the original.
He should've try to rock and roll his way out
and get even more hurt I don't think that's very plausible.
@@12Snowpeach good point
Fabulous adaptation as always!
Thanks!
@@BrendamProductions only speaking the truth :D
I wish Sir Handel comes home.
Duncan motto Rock and roll
On the ng grind
Haha welcome to the s4 content, don't worry there will be breaks from them here and there like my next video
awesome job
I like the original ofc but this is better tbh, If Crisopher actually swipe roles for Duncan in prickly problems and Pop Special with Peter Sam, it would fit so better.
Thank you yeah the way round Christopher did it seems strange
Nicely done!
Thanks!
@@BrendamProductions anytime
Duncan just doesn’t stop complaining doesn’t he?
No indeed he doesn’t I figure it out. Duncan worked in the factory on the other railway in Scotland. He hates it in there. The Workmen were idle and dishonest, tools often went missing, the tracks weren’t even repaired and then there was a engine named Cain. He was their favorite engine. And yet if he made a mistake, Duncan got to blame and if he tries to do things better it’s always Cain got to please. Duncan was so happy that Mr. Percival brought him to Sodor but it won’t change Duncan experience of that old factory. That’s why he won’t stop complaining.
Much better
my problem with this is why the hell would some of the passengers have knives? docent anyone find that a wee bit suspicious?
Yeah I mean apart from the time being very different in the uk I don’t fully get it but it’s kinda needed for 5e story maybe I shoulda rewritten in a bit heavier
I know the problem with branches hanging in the way of vehicles way too well. The noise produced by the vehicle hitting them is unbearable, and it only gets worse the faster the vehicle drives.
Why was this video uploaded twice?
I made a mess up when uploading it last night there is now just 1
Why did the passengers have knives with them??
Not sure that’s something Christopher wrote in and considering it’s kinda important to the plot I left it in
😔
Who takes knives with you on your tour around the lake???
Maybe a for a picnic
Like with Peter Sam but replaced by Duncan.
Why did you upload twice?
Most likely it got hung up for kids
Take a snowplow next time
Much better