@@Matt-pd2cq lol this interaction your comment was just stupid, what you care is not what "we" care and what is for you a waste of time is not for "us" a waste of time
I totally agree with you. My first rig was an IC-7100. Yes, it doesn't have all the bells ans whistles of the 705, but it suits me fine as a base station, and it is also my portable rig. I am unable to backpack, but anywhere I can drive to and set up my radio, the 7100 works great.
I'm still looking for my first radio. I would like an all band. I'd like it for Home or Mobile I'm stuck between the IC-7100 vs the Yaesu FT991A Thoughts?
@@GaryWold the IC-7100 does all HF bands plus 2m and 440. It is an all round great radio. I am not familiar with the 991A. You may have to do some research. Also you might check the going prices on each.
I recently bought an FT-891 for my portable/QRP needs. It cost $570 new on sale. It can run 5-10 watts when conditions allow & up to 100 watts when needed. I ran it on an 18 AH LiFePo4 battery in the back yard. I also have an IC-756 ProIII for my main base rig.
I bought and paid for an IC705 for my new boat. So I can be Maritime Mobile on Lake Winnipeg. I have a KX3 but the batteries are a pain in the ass. I already have 2 IC7300's and an IC9700 and and IC7800 and more. It has it's purpose. It is a winner.
Some food for thought: If QRP is a bad choice for beginners in the hobby, then why are Foundation licences in some countries (like Australia) limited to 10w? Spoiler alert: because if you focus your efforts on antennas, and understanding the basics of radio first, 10 watts will give you a lot of enjoyment and many, many contacts. It's a QRP rig, and that's fine with me. I appreciate your comments, and I DO agree with your comments, 100%. However I think the clickbait was unnecessary. "WHEN" in your title would have been a better choice than "WHY"... 73
Mind you, you'll not find an F call running 10w here :P That said, that is the idea. F call is to get you up to speed without causing any real harm to yourself or anyone else
@@shutthegate8232 Most beginning ham radio operators do not fare well with QRP on HF. HF QRP SSB is very difficult and a lot of skill is needed on HF QRP CW. I have tried it myself, with 35+ years on the air. Sure, you can make it work and the challenge is fun, but not what I'd recommend to a beginner. VHF/UHF operation often needs a lot of antenna and/or more power, unless you happen to be mountain-topping with the 705. This is not likely for a beginner. And beginners are not usually on the satellites. For VHF/UHF FM and DSTAR, yes the 705 would be a good rig, though an ID-51A handheld would do as well for about 1/3 of the price. If you just want to listen to HF, go to HTTP://websdr.org for free. I don't make the rules, but I've been around the block a few times and I'm active on the air this moment, in reality. I stand by my original post. 73 de Tim, WA5MD Dallas, TX
Great video. I used to work 10kW HF TX stations in the early 90s and I'm only just getting into the HAM scene now. While I understand the theory and general consensus, I still have lots to learn regarding specific equipment, antennas and hardware. Your videos are very straightforward and informative. Thank you
Guess what, I just got an ICOM IC-705. It's the VHF/UHF/6m, built-in FT8, TX and RX pictures, DSTAR, GPS, clock with NTP time sync, and WLAN features that make it a very superior rig. Lots of hams purchase the IC-705 and very much ditch their HT's. I really love the type of battery it uses and the touch screen.
here is my take on the 705. I have my grandfathers hf rig, and i have an old boat anchor kenwood hf rig setting in a closet. I'm going for my general and the 705 being a modern radio that does everything (for the most part) is the golden ticket to setting up a minimal shack until such time as i can go through the big rigs and get them back on the air. a 7300 is the better base if you do not have a full pwr hf station. but if you do, or can get an older rig cheap then the 705 is spot on.
I am in the UK and just taking my Foundation level test, so I am just starting to look at what to buy for my first set up. This video has been very useful, thank you. You have shown me how important it is to check ALL the specifications before deciding. There is a lot of contradictory information around and I know that finally we each have to make our own decision, but I think the tone of this video feels right. Subscribed ! Pete on the England/Scotland border.
Yea Glad Some One Made This Video..I got A Budy i talk to on the radio That is fixing to buy his first good/new radio & he said some one told him the 705 But He is a New Ham & just Did not Know But We Got Him On The Right Path Now..Yaesu ft-991 or FTDX 10 Or The Icom IC-7300..He Has got them 3 on his short list..Just Trying to Find The Best Deal !
Potential buyers ... LMAO sir I won’t invest 1300 USD on this shit, I’d rather buy an iPhone. The same as those 5000 USD base station transceivers, no such thing as potential buyers if it is overpriced.
100 watt,,,,, yup. QRP rig limits you all the time. I work QRP when I can, but conditions need to be right,,,,,, which is not that often. I work QRP by turning my full power rigs down, not buying a dedicated low power unit.
Some important points here in this video regarding understanding one’s POU (philosophy of use) or USE CASE. Whichever term floats the boat is fine - but - it’s important to understand the features required for the task(s) at hand. As a newbie I see a few potential POU’s… 1) handheld QRP VHF/UHF for near field communications probably between family and friends 2) FULL POWER (is there a Qxx code for that? 🤔) HF/VHF/UHF mobile rig for in the car 3) QRP lightweight HF/VHF/UHF portable for POTA/SOTA/manpack/hiking etc. 4) FULL POWER HF/VHF/UHF for a base rig. Not sure yet if I need digital modes for all of these POU’s. Some overlap here too on POU’s so I will probably need to compromise to keep the cashflow under control and to not distress the Chief Executive Officer too much. 😂
Excellent analysis. So many people are going to buy this, be disappointed, and sell it. 90 days after this radio goes on the market you will find a bunch of these used for $800. Not because there is anything wrong with the radio, but because people who bought it to be cool will be upset they can’t talk to Tokyo with it.
Totally agree. This is an incredible QRP rig. However, here is a caveat to this video. As a QRP rig by design, it’s incredibly efficient for "off grid" use. If your shack is designed as an off grid resource running on solar generation it makes sense as a base station with a PA-500 etc. (good luck getting one, 15 month wait)
I've got a few radios (shack, base, portable, qrp) and since I just ordered an IC705 I thought "well crap" when I saw the title. Now that I've listened and purchased my IC705 for (yet another) QRP / backpack rig for SOTA and POTA. I concur.
Nice radio, but it's for a specific user, 5w on HF these days is a disaster, unless your on ft8 etc.. plus no tuner, one antenna socket, no 70mhz, no way would i use it for a home station. I'm happy with 7300 & 9700, 160 -23cms 🙂
But Icom has thought about the home station with the soon to be released IC-PW2 linear amp. You can plug this in on your desk for a shack in the box and then take it portable for 10w. I know I know... Ziegoop can do 20 watts or whatever. If you follow the math there isn't that much difference between 10 and 20 watts. I would much rather have Icom quality over a Chinese tin can with a tuner. But that's just me and that's what makes this fun. I haven't seen the video but I sure would urge anyone to do their homework and think before buying.... 2 things that are lacking in our society. Carry on.
@@twohandsandaradio Agreed on the amp. I am hoping to test one of those also. 10 or 20 watts doesn't matter either, you are correct. I don't care it is only 10 watts over 20 on the G90 or 15 on the KX3. The basic premise of the video is to do research
@@HamRadio2 it's what I've sad ad nauseum.... a factor that people don't consider is "fit". Does the radio fit. Sadly a lot of times we don't know until we own it. I would say there will be some serious "this isn't for me" fire sales. That's what I'm waiting for.
Jason, what are your recommendations for a backpack/battery HF that's not solely designed for QRP? I have big mtns here and I'd like to really reach out of possible....but I also have big legs so a few extra pounds of kit is ok. 20-50w maybe?? I feel like I want to be in a niche no one cares about right now.
I am not aware of ANY HF radio with a battery that isn't designed for QRP. You can't really have a radio with an internal battery that runs 100w (if I understand correctly what you are asking) - Several SOTA guys that I know are using a Bioenno battery with a Yaesu FT-891, which is small and light-weight, but not QRP.
Ham Radio 2.0 ok great! I'm sorry if my terminology was confusing. I'm quite new to this. The guidelines of QRP aren't of interest to me...but the smaller form factor/lightweight HFs are, although I understand performance comes at a price and I'm will to bear that as increased poundage on my back. I'm thinking more like a civilization is broke at the moment comms not 5watts max SOTA stuff....although I plan on participating. I don't want output power to be a hamstring and lead to frustrating operation....considering it might be used for emergency comms. The minimum power necessary yes but I want to have juice in reserve if propagation conditions aren't optimal. I hope this doesn't make me sound like a tin foil hat wearing loon....I just love the practical aspects of amateur radio a lot more than the artificially made challenges of contests or games. Thank you for replying and any further intel.
@@MrButterpantz It sounds like you might want a go-kit built with a full-power radio, battery, perhaps also a power-supply, some type of charge controller, maybe a solar panel connection, etc. Something like that would be portable for setting up emergency comms, but it isn't really able to be back-packed up a mountain.
Ham Radio 2.0 That actually sounds perfect Jason....plus you'd be suprised what I can ruck up a hill. I don't want to monopolize your time here since the 705 and your video doesn't seem to fit my intended purpose. Care to get me pointed in the correct direction?
Licensed in 2014 as General. HOA and lack of a defined space for a dedicated ham shack led me to KX-3 and temporary wire antennas. Also thought I might do bike-to-site activations. Never did the bike activations, but never regretted the KX-3 decision. I've taken the KX-3 and a powerbank across the country on a plane, with wire antennas and SOTAbeams travel mast in my small checked bag. I'd never have bother with the equivalent of a 7300 and the associated power supply. If I get to use the KX-3, great, and if not, I didn't have to carry a lot of weight. Tough to make SSB contacts? Yes, at times, but I manage my expectations within the system capabilities.
That is AWESOME! I've done the same thing with a LNR LD-11. The purpose of the video was to define what QRP is, but once someone understands that, QRP can be quite fun!
I’m thinking of the IC 705 with a tuner with the qrpguys DS1 antenna kit for my sailboat - emphasizing cw- and to portably bring back home for backyard use same way, and bringing on vacations same way- make sense?
If youu are in Australia and have the lowest level of license (Foundation), you are limited to - 10 Watts. You are also limited in the bands you may transmit on. So, you either buy something with extra power (and keep your ouput down) OR something with extra frequency range (and keep your hands off the TX key). I'd rather have the extra cover - and consider a PA if I want to boost the power later.
Dude, I just ordered the Hardrock-50+ 100W linear amp kit for my ICOM IC-705. I'm also ordering the interface. Getting ready for winter Field Day. Something I really love about the IC-705 is Winlink.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts and insights. I currently have a G90 , FT 857D and TS2000. Only the G90 has a water fall, which I like but Ham Radio Deluxe does too. I could sell my TS2000 and buy a refurbished 705 or 7300. I never really used the full 100 watts on the Kenwood. Before POTA I enjoyed activating counties as I drove places. I’m now planning to become active in POTA/SOTA. When I was first licensed I was most interested in AMSAT. However after more than 30 years being a HAM interests have changed. Now I am more focused on effective Antennas than the Radio. 73 Steve AA4SH
I’m about to buy an ID-52 or an IC-705. I live in a condo first floor of two stories, with a three story building next door, and a very strict HOA. I will be using the radio I choose from local high points nearby. I don’t own a car. First ham radio. Suggestions?
What is your purpose? What kind of operating do you want to do? The IC-705 has HF, so if you are just a Technician, you can't use HF yet (mostly) - so unless you are planning to upgrade to General soon, you won't need HF. Both radios have DSTAR and both do about 5w of output on vhf/uhf, but the ID-52 is FM only so you won't be able to do sideband. As a Technician, you have full privileges to vhf/uhf so you could operate sideband if you wish. Honestly they aren't the same radio, so you can't really compare them. So it depends on what your end goal is.
@@HamRadio2 Thank you for the info. I chose both the 705 (with mag loop as portable) and the ID-52a (as handheld on my back porch). With the 705/magloop I can speak with operators in Alaska and Canada easily.
Bought my IC 705 about a year ago. Love it, I also have an IC 7300 too, both great rigs. Each has its use, I like going to the park with our local club for its weekly/ monthly QRP sessions. The 7300 is most definitely my base rig, might run QRP from my motor home next time we go somewhere. If you enjoy QRP the 705 is most definitely my choice, though there are variety of QRP rigs available. From Yaesu, Xiegu, there are even some tiny 5 watt QRP rigs for just a couple hundred bucks. I’ve been playing with QRP for 20 years off and on, so I knew what I was getting into with the 705. My last QRP rig was the Xiegu G90, nice rig, screen was just too small, reminded me of the FT 817ND rigs I’ve had. Great rigs made lots of contacts. Screen was just too small for my eyes. I do agree that a QRP rig for your first HF rig is not something you want to do…unless you know what you’re getting into. I had the Icom 703+ great rig, not very portable, but can be done. That said, if you are considering a new or a first HF rig get something with 100 watts you will be much happier. I have know folks who bought a QRP rig for their first rig, 6 months later it would be for sale. Too frustrating they say, only 5 watts they say. Well, don’t say I didn’t try and tell you. Love QRP, can’t wait to get out again to play radio!
QRP aside, When you pass your first licence here in the UK you can't transmit higher power than 10W anyway. I do have the 7300 though (I just set the TX power to 10w).
My very first HF rig was an FT-817nd....I don’t recommend it to people for their first HF rig, however I absolutely DO NOT regret it, for me personally....QRP forced me to learn antennas and proper setup. I still have the radio and I DO use it as a base station as well as going portable.....👍KF7CLH
In the center of the screen, vertically, at the far right side, I see it, yes, I SEE IT!. Yes, a marvelous radio, a superb radio! Never been a better transceiver! Mine's the "B" model. I also recently acquired an FTV-650, and am currently collecting stuff to make a ground-plane.
I just upgraded from Technician to General. Been thinking about getting the 705 because it's an all band radio, does everything I need it to do and on top of that I'd like to get into QRP. I don't like having to run more power than I need. Don't have the space at the house for a dedicated HF rig or an inverted v. Already got the 5100A set up as my 2m/440 base station radio. Been getting on D-STAR and love the system. With the 705, I can pack it up and take it with me wherever I go. Camping, fishing, traveling out of state and not having to sit in my vehicle all the time just to do HF to show family and friends what my new favorite hobby is. Side note, I was on 023C in Australia about 2 weeks ago. Heard one station on the reflector using the 705. It sounded great on D-STAR. 73, KO4AHX.
Also been thinking about getting into PSK31. Going to do some more research, but from what I've read in the ARRL Radio Operators Manual, users run no more than 50 watts. I'm not looking to make overseas contacts on 5 or 10 watts, unless the band conditions are good. Just something to get into and experiment with. Definitely not a home base station radio for sure.
If you like QRP just for the sake of QRP and don't care about portability, you can still turn down the power on your shack rig and have the 100 watts if you want/need it.
Great review, thanks for saving me some money. Just passed my General exam and am looking for an all band radio. I don't understand why we need separate radios based on frequency class... why can't I just find a nice color touchscreen that covers HF/HF/VHF for my shack? (not interested in a mobile UHF rig yet)
I'm in Australia and looking to get my Foundation license which is 10 watts maximum anyway, so that's one reason it interested me. other radio i'm looking at is a second hand Yeasu FT-879D. portable use camping etc as well as base station use is what i'm interested in.
Jason, your advice on this topic is spot on! A NEW HAM faces MANY challenges! If they spend a lot of cash and have a frustrating time making contacts (which QRP can do), they may hear folks but get frustrated when folks cannot hear them. I tell all new General HF operators to START with a 100 watt rig!
Yes, do both 100W and QRP rigs. Work on an off-grid portable system and make it work. I don't like the attitude of some people towards QRP. I recommend hams to have an off-grid functional off-grid QRP system while going about making 100W rigs work. Small portable solar phone chargers can charge HT's.
I'm guessing there are some people who have seen the video. For me I will have to wait a bit and while I'm curious what your POV is it's unlikely that I will be swayed. This rig will do everything an Elecraft KX2/KX3 will do (minus the tuner which is no issue for me) and works just like my 7300 (which is an absolutely awesome rig). I had a KX2 (and paid way more than the amount I'm paying for the 705) and it was a great little rig....but ultimately meh. I have a G90 and it's awesome...but that screen is SOOO small.
My Patrons get early access to all of my videos, yes. But lots of people are commenting on it now that I have scheduled it for tomorrow. I hope everyone watches, it might not be what you think
Thanks for the info. As a newbie (still waiting for my call sign) I have been confused by the jargon that is tossed around. You've cleared up some of it.
I'm just waiting for my IC 705 to ship. This will be my backpacking rig. I dont use HF that much, more VHF/UHF. Can't wait to try this out. This will be my first HF back packing radio. Any suggestions on what I can use to keep the battery charged while in the field? Keep in mind I have about 50lbs of food, clothes, tent..and misc.
I have a 9 watt flexible solar panel with charge controller for an Elecraft KX2. Some of the newer battery chemistries are light weight but difficult to charge with solar. What I did was find some plastic 8-cell packs to hold NiMH batteries in AA and D sizes and wired them up with the appropriate connectors. Just make sure your IC 705 rig can run on 10.4 volts or less if you go this route.
I run I C 725 I also run Yeasu 101 Icom D Star 2 meter 440 .Kenwood I stay away from any thing digital except what is good for your needs. Analog I think is best. I don’t want to relay on any thing to do with satellite communication do what you think is best for you just remember if technology goes down what is best to stay stay in communication with .always plan on a back up it may be costly. And don’t forget to protect your equipment it’s called a fairday cauge 73’s to all.
I also hold the opinion that the first radio must necessarily be 100W. The realization that you need a QRP radio should come by itself. For example, my first radio was FT-891 - a wonderful device, I can't say anything bad about it. But now I don't have a home shack, I work exclusively in the fields with a backpack. Considering that I work >90% of the time in CW, it made absolutely no sense for me to carry such a weight on myself. And I switched to QRP radio already knowing what it is, how to work with it, how to set up and use resonant antennas and being able to navigate the air. A beginner will only be disappointed that no one hears him. To put it quite simply - do not worry, novice friends, you will buy your IC-705, just a little later)
I don't know that answer. I don't think it is full duplex, and it doesn't have 1.2GHz. But...you should be able to use it on 2M/440 the same way you can with any HT radio.
If you live or for some reason life has forced you into an apartment the IC705 is the radio for you! Get a magloop antenna and your good to go yes it’s QRP but in an apartment complex you don’t want to do much more then 10watts so your not bleeding or interfering on other peoples electronics! I’ve made some good contacts on hf with this radio and the AL 705 antenna setting on a table next to the east facing window it works well and is a fun challenge to make contacts inside my apartment!
QRP as first HF or mobile rig will likely be frustrating unless you are already an experienced CW operator. It would be ok for local VHF/UHF repeaters, but too expensive just for that. I have worked Europe from US with CW on 20m with 1 watt. If that sounds like fun to you, the 705 may be right for you.
I'm liking the 705 waterfall technology but not the 10 watt x ing power output. But the 705 can be modified for CB bands as well. The 7100 is a more versatile unit in its form factor. Divorced so the head is easily placed within handy reach without the bulky main radio unit. So what's the best solution? Wait for the 7100 to be upgraded with a colour waterfall screen? Or buy the 705 and a amplifier? They both will need a signal strength tuning meter as well . I know you did this video 2 years ago so maybe ICOM has an upgraded version of the 7100 in production. But only time will tell. Thanks for your videos. I'm in learn mode and I'm trying to absorb as much as I can. I have already brought a Kenwood nx5800 k2 and am looking to buy a nx5300 abp5 or abp6 intrenslicly safe MIL SPEC handheld for $1300.00 CDN .n/c the battery & charger. That's another $320.00 CDN.But if there's a way of getting a tri band mobile unit for both base and mobile, then that's what I feel is best overall.
I just watched just north of London, U.K. as one guy were using IC-705, it has great receiver, as other guy were coming in S 9, as other guy has pretty weak signal with no meter reading on IC-705 as of; in CB lingo is called: PEANUT-WHISTLE. In Ham term; is called; QRP that doesn't means: Quickly-Reduced-Power.
Waiting for the $ to drop slightly or pick up a mint pre-owned. Looks like a viable supplement to my FT818 hiking/SOTA rig. I see many disparaging the low 10w output. This rig is meant for highly portable in the field operation. You are not going far on foot with a 100w portable and the associated heavy battery required to power it. This radio is for those who do adventure radio (hiking, SOTA, POTA) you can do amazing things with the FT818 from a summit. The iCom 705 will expand this horizon. I am also into astronomy. A 6” budget reflector ($300)from a dark site will annihilate a several thousand $ professional grade scope from the bright city. In radio, high altitude/low RF is the dark sky!
Most QRP hams are the reason why I don't jump into thinking getting a linear is a solution. I made friends with QRP hams, they spend more time on antennas and off-grid. I personally recommend QRP radios with built-in battery packs to start with. Nothing feels so much better than having a GRP HF all-mode setup successfully working well with battery and solar panel. I'm both into QRP and also 100W radio. Constantly, I'm experimenting with off-grid and low power equipment. One should really do is meditate on how to prepare for the worst blackout that lasts like a year. My ICOM IC-730 is my 100W rig that runs off 13.8VDC 20A, I have both Xiegu X6100 and G90.
@@DennyInDurham I'm not sure what this comment has to do with the video you are commenting on. But...... I've done what you're talking about in several other videos.
I agree, still I like the portability and all the functionality for a physically small size radio. Plus, it has a removable battery. I got a Xiegu X6100 and I'm very happy with it, I'm thinking I may get an Icom IC-705 and I guarantee I will use it the most. I also plan to go to a HAM swap meet to find a large full size base station HF transceiver. In my neighborhood, I'm very content with an HT. The IC-705 makes me very comfortable to use with solar and external batteries, living off grid.
I would recommend a 7300 to anyone who wants a general purpose HF radio. The 7300 has 100W, built in antenna tuner, built in soundcard, and good user interface. For mobile, consider a used Icom 706IIG.
Great review. I have had my license since 1965. I think your advice about QRP is great for new hams. However, I think that people should not under estimate the power of 10 watts. I have had very good luck talking around the world with ten watts with the right antenna. js'g
from KC1CCG - My radio is an IC-7300. Been a ham for over 60 years. A hundred watts is a fine level. Want to QRP ? Just turn a knob from 100% power out to 10% power out. Advice to new hams....the antenna is THE important part of the system. Understand antennas & grounds and whatever radio you have will be fine. Crappy antenna and 100W WILL be QRP because only 5 watts will go anywhere. The real test for me is....if I can hear them, I can work them (with few exceptions). They might be running 500W but our reports are the same or only 1 or 2 S units apart.
Click-bait, Jason. You've just gone down several notches on my list of ham radio reviewers who I like to watch. The title and thumbs-down visual on the title page is misleading. I understand what you're getting at for newbies but comparing a QRP radio to a 100W radio is apples and oranges.
It is Apples to Oranges. Yes you are correct. That was my point. THAT is the question I've been asked 2-3 dozen times. How would you respond? How would you explain to new folks, who just got their license, what QRP is?
@@radiobits3007 That's exactly what I did. Explaining something is done in the video, not in the title, so you contradicted yourself there, and assumptions made by you, I can't control. Having said that, yes the title was somewhat clickbait but in the video I EXPLAINED what I was talking about and I delivered the message that the title promised. Anything beyond that is really semantics.
@@HamRadio2 Hi Jason. Of course it could be considered clickbait, but with good intention - and it certainly got my attention! I was curious (and therefore clicked) as only a few days ago one of our new young hams on our local club net was seriously considering the IC-705 and imminently ready to purchase. His reasoning was the 705 was HF and VHF/UHF with D-STAR. (Most youngsters these days seem to be fixated on the armchair DXing capability of D-STAR via the InterNerd, but that’s another story). I was quickly on the ‘phone to him to advise the rig was QRP, for which he was very thankful. So, for me (and luckily for him), the “clickbait” worked as intended. Thanks.
It seems so simple that these are tools for can be a really fancy hammer but if you're looking at a screw it just isn't the proper thing to get. Nice video clear and concise
Just saw your video on the IC-705. My goal is for a backpack radio, powered by a LiFePO4 battery and solar panel. Antenna would be a buddistick. Joined an Icom 705 group and found it was an Icom love fest. I left the group. My thoughts are for the Xiego G 90. It is adjustable 0 to 20 watts. The 705 is 5 W internal battery, 10 W external battery. The Xiegu also has an antenna tuner. Also, it's 1/3 the price of the 705. Dennis, KD2MIP
I agree as well. I have a Yaesu FT-817 and I love the thing. But it’s tough! I have not been able to make any voice contacts on it at home, but I have made a lot of great ones in the field. Another thing to note, is that lots of campgrounds have sites with power, and I have been able to bring my FT-450D and make some good contacts. I love QRP but I would fight new operators who try to get them as a first HF rig.
I'd be interested in hearing whether your opinion on this (in particular, the part at 4:32) changes given the apparent discontinuation (or at least long-term unavailability) of the TH-D74A/E (because of, if my Internet reading is correct, a fire at the plant that makes their DACs/ADCs... the only factory in the world that made those particular ones. Oof.) And/or in general for you to talk about that. I was about ready to pull the trigger on one of those, and noticed they'd gotten de-listed on several sites... so now I'm pondering the IC-705 instead (for, for the moment, mostly home use, and probably mostly listening on HF, at least until/unless I get an upgrade -- currently a Tech). I like the idea of being able to expand into HF, even if only QRP, but I'd like D-STAR, and... yeah. IC-52 is also a potential consideration, especially since I've already ordered a HackRF One, and I could presumably use that for the HF listening side of things. But... I do like the idea of a nice physical UI (jog wheel, etc.) that's dedicated to doing this stuff right. P.S. [edit] - Other factors: I currently don't have anywhere to put up a fancy high-power antenna anyway, but 6:54 makes me think I should maybe take another look at the 7100, as well.
Q RP is for people with experience, who have been an active ham for some time and already have a "real" radio. After that, if you really know what you are getting and want a low power ham station in a box, maybe you want it for an IF for you microwave transverter, or may be replace your old reliable FT817, you cant beat the IC705. It is a great, very specialized radio, but not a good first rig for a new ham.
Hey Jason, I completely agree with u (I always click on ur videos regardless of the title). I absolutely love my IC-7300 as my full power base station ... but also love to be HAM portable. I've been struggling with the decision to buy a new IC-705 QRP (+ portable antenna tuner, + portable amp, + etc.) ... or just take my IC-7300 portable (without any of those accessories because they're built-in). Plus I already own an IC-51A digital handheld so that is my very portable digital VHF/UHF radio. The ONLY advantage for me to buy a $1300 IC-705 is backpack portability as you said. But then I would also want to buy and pack an ATU, amp, etc if I want more antenna flexibility and full power (another $300+). For me, it was not worth it. I love the look and feel of the IC-705 for the QRP form factor. But I ultimately worked out a small backpack carrying my IC-7300, lithium battery and WRC vertical and can go anywhere with full power (or QRP). The IC-7300 is 9.3 lbs and the IC-705 is 2.4 lbs (only 6.9 lbs difference). Just my 2 cents on why I decided against the IC-705 for my portable purposes. 73 KJ6ER, Silicon Valley
Hmmm. Holding up a just released $1,000+ QRP rig and a thumbs down? Just a little deceptive. I would have been more impressed if you would have presented the IC 705 and a first look, or do session on why QRP isn’t the best choice for a new ham.
Good feedback. I do plan to do that once I get the radio in my hands. But as I said in the video, I was speaking directly to Hams who are new to the hobby, who are looking to buy this new radio, but don't understand what QRP is.
Great video 2.0. I was curious about the 705. I am kinda not liking the Yaesu 891 anymore....I never realized how noisey it it, but it just is. It's great for travel but lots o noise.
As usual, the answer is: It depends on your needs.
Yep
The stuff we actually care about starts at 2:57. The stuff before it is a time-waster.
Time waster, like this comment
@@HamRadio2 Dunno man. Here I am year later, thankful I made this comment.
@@Matt-pd2cq apparently you still have an abundance of time
@@HamRadio2 oh yeah the fact that it took me a year to come back really says that, doesn't it :-P
@@Matt-pd2cq lol this interaction
your comment was just stupid, what you care is not what "we" care and what is for you a waste of time is not for "us" a waste of time
Thanks!
There is a big clue on the advertising leaflet for the IC-705 to help guide prospective buyers what the radio was designed for.....
I totally agree with you. My first rig was an IC-7100. Yes, it doesn't have all the bells ans whistles of the 705, but it suits me fine as a base station, and it is also my portable rig. I am unable to backpack, but anywhere I can drive to and set up my radio, the 7100 works great.
Thanks for sharing!
I'm still looking for my first radio. I would like an all band. I'd like it for Home or Mobile I'm stuck between the IC-7100 vs the Yaesu FT991A Thoughts?
@@GaryWold the IC-7100 does all HF bands plus 2m and 440. It is an all round great radio. I am not familiar with the 991A. You may have to do some research. Also you might check the going prices on each.
Ditto. 7100 was my 2nd radio...awesome rig...home, mobile, field...great rig.
I recently bought an FT-891 for my portable/QRP needs. It cost $570 new on sale. It can run 5-10 watts when conditions allow & up to 100 watts when needed. I ran it on an 18 AH LiFePo4 battery in the back yard. I also have an IC-756 ProIII for my main base rig.
I agree, Bill. I am about to install a FT-891 in my Truck and possibly for POTA. All the best, 73 de KI5HXM
I bought and paid for an IC705 for my new boat. So I can be Maritime Mobile on Lake Winnipeg. I have a KX3 but the batteries are a pain in the ass. I already have 2 IC7300's and an IC9700 and and IC7800 and more. It has it's purpose. It is a winner.
Thanks for commenting
Some food for thought: If QRP is a bad choice for beginners in the hobby, then why are Foundation licences in some countries (like Australia) limited to 10w?
Spoiler alert: because if you focus your efforts on antennas, and understanding the basics of radio first, 10 watts will give you a lot of enjoyment and many, many contacts.
It's a QRP rig, and that's fine with me. I appreciate your comments, and I DO agree with your comments, 100%. However I think the clickbait was unnecessary. "WHEN" in your title would have been a better choice than "WHY"...
73
That makes sense, yes. The video was mostly directed towards U.S. Hams, but I can understand your viewpoint.
Mind you, you'll not find an F call running 10w here :P
That said, that is the idea. F call is to get you up to speed without causing any real harm to yourself or anyone else
Because the people who make those rules are not active amateurs who understand the realities of operating a station under current HF conditions.
@@bct5ak Sounds like that could be applied to the people making the rules in most situations :-) so far removed, they've lost touch with reality
@@shutthegate8232 Most beginning ham radio operators do not fare well with QRP on HF. HF QRP SSB is very difficult and a lot of skill is needed on HF QRP CW. I have tried it myself, with 35+ years on the air. Sure, you can make it work and the challenge is fun, but not what I'd recommend to a beginner.
VHF/UHF operation often needs a lot of antenna and/or more power, unless you happen to be mountain-topping with the 705. This is not likely for a beginner. And beginners are not usually on the satellites. For VHF/UHF FM and DSTAR, yes the 705 would be a good rig, though an ID-51A handheld would do as well for about 1/3 of the price. If you just want to listen to HF, go to HTTP://websdr.org for free.
I don't make the rules, but I've been around the block a few times and I'm active on the air this moment, in reality.
I stand by my original post.
73 de Tim, WA5MD
Dallas, TX
Great video. I used to work 10kW HF TX stations in the early 90s and I'm only just getting into the HAM scene now. While I understand the theory and general consensus, I still have lots to learn regarding specific equipment, antennas and hardware.
Your videos are very straightforward and informative. Thank you
Guess what, I just got an ICOM IC-705. It's the VHF/UHF/6m, built-in FT8, TX and RX pictures, DSTAR, GPS, clock with NTP time sync, and WLAN features that make it a very superior rig. Lots of hams purchase the IC-705 and very much ditch their HT's. I really love the type of battery it uses and the touch screen.
Still clickbait. You could set the title to “When not to buy” instead of why. But video is fine.
here is my take on the 705. I have my grandfathers hf rig, and i have an old boat anchor kenwood hf rig setting in a closet. I'm going for my general and the 705 being a modern radio that does everything (for the most part) is the golden ticket to setting up a minimal shack until such time as i can go through the big rigs and get them back on the air. a 7300 is the better base if you do not have a full pwr hf station. but if you do, or can get an older rig cheap then the 705 is spot on.
I am in the UK and just taking my Foundation level test, so I am just starting to look at what to buy for my first set up. This video has been very useful, thank you. You have shown me how important it is to check ALL the specifications before deciding. There is a lot of contradictory information around and I know that finally we each have to make our own decision, but I think the tone of this video feels right. Subscribed ! Pete on the England/Scotland border.
Your unbiased opinions are appreciated.
Thanks
Thank you so much for the insight...this video is a confirmation for me to move forward with the y.891. Appreciate you.
Yea Glad Some One Made This Video..I got A Budy i talk to on the radio That is fixing to buy his first good/new radio & he said some one told him the 705 But He is a New Ham & just Did not Know But We Got Him On The Right Path Now..Yaesu ft-991 or FTDX 10 Or The Icom IC-7300..He Has got them 3 on his short list..Just Trying to Find The Best Deal !
I just got me a Kenwood TS-570S 100W rig and I love it.
Thank you for taking the time making these great videos on *All Things Ham Radio*
Click-bait! So what your saying is: "If you want a 100 Watt transceiver don't buy the IC-705." I think you underestimate potential buyers.
As stated in the video, this comes from many NEW hams I've spoken to
First time on the internets huh
Potential buyers ... LMAO sir I won’t invest 1300 USD on this shit, I’d rather buy an iPhone. The same as those 5000 USD base station transceivers, no such thing as potential buyers if it is overpriced.
I'm new at this. I didn't understand the difference, and now I do. Thanks. I definitely get 10W vs 100W for a base station. I'm working on my license.
100 watt,,,,, yup. QRP rig limits you all the time. I work QRP when I can, but conditions need to be right,,,,,, which is not that often. I work QRP by turning my full power rigs down, not buying a dedicated low power unit.
Some important points here in this video regarding understanding one’s POU (philosophy of use) or USE CASE. Whichever term floats the boat is fine - but - it’s important to understand the features required for the task(s) at hand. As a newbie I see a few potential POU’s… 1) handheld QRP VHF/UHF for near field communications probably between family and friends 2) FULL POWER (is there a Qxx code for that? 🤔) HF/VHF/UHF mobile rig for in the car 3) QRP lightweight HF/VHF/UHF portable for POTA/SOTA/manpack/hiking etc. 4) FULL POWER HF/VHF/UHF for a base rig. Not sure yet if I need digital modes for all of these POU’s. Some overlap here too on POU’s so I will probably need to compromise to keep the cashflow under control and to not distress the Chief Executive Officer too much. 😂
So.... If I want a QRP rig?
If you want QRP, this is the one to get
I got my IC7300 as my second HF rig. G90 was my first then sold it. I now really would like a IC705.
A much appreciated video thank you for the education!!
Our pleasure!
Excellent analysis. So many people are going to buy this, be disappointed, and sell it. 90 days after this radio goes on the market you will find a bunch of these used for $800. Not because there is anything wrong with the radio, but because people who bought it to be cool will be upset they can’t talk to Tokyo with it.
Sales listed as "it's just not my thing". LOL THAT'S what I'm waiting for!!
Thanks for the breakdown on the 705, much appreciated.
You bet
Totally agree. This is an incredible QRP rig. However, here is a caveat to this video. As a QRP rig by design, it’s incredibly efficient for "off grid" use. If your shack is designed as an off grid resource running on solar generation it makes sense as a base station with a PA-500 etc. (good luck getting one, 15 month wait)
Excellent advice. Refreshing to see someone not being a shill for any particular new radio.
I've got a few radios (shack, base, portable, qrp) and since I just ordered an IC705 I thought "well crap" when I saw the title. Now that I've listened and purchased my IC705 for (yet another) QRP / backpack rig for SOTA and POTA. I concur.
Yes sir, great to hear! I am still loving my IC-705
Nice radio, but it's for a specific user, 5w on HF these days is a disaster, unless your on ft8 etc..
plus no tuner, one antenna socket, no 70mhz, no way would i use it for a home station.
I'm happy with 7300 & 9700, 160 -23cms 🙂
We don't have access to 70MHz here, but I was somewhat surprised they didn't have a European version that included that band.
But Icom has thought about the home station with the soon to be released IC-PW2 linear amp. You can plug this in on your desk for a shack in the box and then take it portable for 10w. I know I know... Ziegoop can do 20 watts or whatever. If you follow the math there isn't that much difference between 10 and 20 watts. I would much rather have Icom quality over a Chinese tin can with a tuner. But that's just me and that's what makes this fun. I haven't seen the video but I sure would urge anyone to do their homework and think before buying.... 2 things that are lacking in our society. Carry on.
@@twohandsandaradio Agreed on the amp. I am hoping to test one of those also.
10 or 20 watts doesn't matter either, you are correct. I don't care it is only 10 watts over 20 on the G90 or 15 on the KX3.
The basic premise of the video is to do research
@@HamRadio2 it's what I've sad ad nauseum.... a factor that people don't consider is "fit". Does the radio fit. Sadly a lot of times we don't know until we own it. I would say there will be some serious "this isn't for me" fire sales. That's what I'm waiting for.
"5w on HF these days is a disaster" I spent last weekend talking to the east coast on 40m @5w from Ca.
Jason, what are your recommendations for a backpack/battery HF that's not solely designed for QRP? I have big mtns here and I'd like to really reach out of possible....but I also have big legs so a few extra pounds of kit is ok. 20-50w maybe?? I feel like I want to be in a niche no one cares about right now.
I am not aware of ANY HF radio with a battery that isn't designed for QRP. You can't really have a radio with an internal battery that runs 100w (if I understand correctly what you are asking) - Several SOTA guys that I know are using a Bioenno battery with a Yaesu FT-891, which is small and light-weight, but not QRP.
Ham Radio 2.0 ok great! I'm sorry if my terminology was confusing. I'm quite new to this. The guidelines of QRP aren't of interest to me...but the smaller form factor/lightweight HFs are, although I understand performance comes at a price and I'm will to bear that as increased poundage on my back. I'm thinking more like a civilization is broke at the moment comms not 5watts max SOTA stuff....although I plan on participating. I don't want output power to be a hamstring and lead to frustrating operation....considering it might be used for emergency comms. The minimum power necessary yes but I want to have juice in reserve if propagation conditions aren't optimal.
I hope this doesn't make me sound like a tin foil hat wearing loon....I just love the practical aspects of amateur radio a lot more than the artificially made challenges of contests or games.
Thank you for replying and any further intel.
@@MrButterpantz It sounds like you might want a go-kit built with a full-power radio, battery, perhaps also a power-supply, some type of charge controller, maybe a solar panel connection, etc. Something like that would be portable for setting up emergency comms, but it isn't really able to be back-packed up a mountain.
Ham Radio 2.0 That actually sounds perfect Jason....plus you'd be suprised what I can ruck up a hill. I don't want to monopolize your time here since the 705 and your video doesn't seem to fit my intended purpose. Care to get me pointed in the correct direction?
Search YT for "ham radio go kit" - I don't have a video finished yet, but I am working on one.
Staying with my KX3 for portable sota/pota and for home my IC7610 and IC9100 works for me.
All 3 of those are great choices
@@HamRadio2 I know..I have all 3.
Licensed in 2014 as General. HOA and lack of a defined space for a dedicated ham shack led me to KX-3 and temporary wire antennas. Also thought I might do bike-to-site activations. Never did the bike activations, but never regretted the KX-3 decision. I've taken the KX-3 and a powerbank across the country on a plane, with wire antennas and SOTAbeams travel mast in my small checked bag. I'd never have bother with the equivalent of a 7300 and the associated power supply. If I get to use the KX-3, great, and if not, I didn't have to carry a lot of weight. Tough to make SSB contacts? Yes, at times, but I manage my expectations within the system capabilities.
My FT817 (5watts max) was my main rig for years. Worked 80 DXCC with QRP. And I love it. 73 PAØK
That is AWESOME! I've done the same thing with a LNR LD-11. The purpose of the video was to define what QRP is, but once someone understands that, QRP can be quite fun!
I’m thinking of the IC 705 with a tuner with the qrpguys DS1 antenna kit for my sailboat - emphasizing cw- and to portably bring back home for backyard use same way, and bringing on vacations same way- make sense?
Very good and fair evaluation.
Thanks Peter
I am thinking of getting one for a bedside shortwave radio that I can use for QRP when on vacation.
If youu are in Australia and have the lowest level of license (Foundation), you are limited to - 10 Watts. You are also limited in the bands you may transmit on.
So, you either buy something with extra power (and keep your ouput down) OR something with extra frequency range (and keep your hands off the TX key).
I'd rather have the extra cover - and consider a PA if I want to boost the power later.
Dude, I just ordered the Hardrock-50+ 100W linear amp kit for my ICOM IC-705. I'm also ordering the interface. Getting ready for winter Field Day. Something I really love about the IC-705 is Winlink.
I'm not familiar with that amp, I'll look it up
Thanks for sharing your thoughts and insights. I currently have a G90 , FT 857D and TS2000. Only the G90 has a water fall, which I like but Ham Radio Deluxe does too.
I could sell my TS2000 and buy a refurbished 705 or 7300. I never really used the full 100 watts on the Kenwood. Before POTA I enjoyed activating counties as I drove places. I’m now planning to become active in POTA/SOTA. When I was first licensed I was most interested in AMSAT.
However after more than 30 years being a HAM interests have changed. Now I am more focused on effective Antennas than the Radio.
73 Steve AA4SH
I’m about to buy an ID-52 or an IC-705.
I live in a condo first floor of two stories, with a three story building next door, and a very strict HOA. I will be using the radio I choose from local high points nearby. I don’t own a car. First ham radio.
Suggestions?
What is your purpose? What kind of operating do you want to do?
The IC-705 has HF, so if you are just a Technician, you can't use HF yet (mostly) - so unless you are planning to upgrade to General soon, you won't need HF.
Both radios have DSTAR and both do about 5w of output on vhf/uhf, but the ID-52 is FM only so you won't be able to do sideband. As a Technician, you have full privileges to vhf/uhf so you could operate sideband if you wish.
Honestly they aren't the same radio, so you can't really compare them. So it depends on what your end goal is.
@@HamRadio2 Thank you for the info.
I chose both the 705 (with mag loop as portable) and the ID-52a (as handheld on my back porch).
With the 705/magloop I can speak with operators in Alaska and Canada easily.
Oops! I live in Phoenix.
Bought my IC 705 about a year ago. Love it, I also have an IC 7300 too, both great rigs. Each has its use, I like going to the park with our local club for its weekly/ monthly QRP sessions. The 7300 is most definitely my base rig, might run QRP from my motor home next time we go somewhere.
If you enjoy QRP the 705 is most definitely my choice, though there are variety of QRP rigs available. From Yaesu, Xiegu, there are even some tiny 5 watt QRP rigs for just a couple hundred bucks. I’ve been playing with QRP for 20 years off and on, so I knew what I was getting into with the 705. My last QRP rig was the Xiegu G90, nice rig, screen was just too small, reminded me of the FT 817ND rigs I’ve had. Great rigs made lots of contacts. Screen was just too small for my eyes.
I do agree that a QRP rig for your first HF rig is not something you want to do…unless you know what you’re getting into. I had the Icom 703+ great rig, not very portable, but can be done. That said, if you are considering a new or a first HF rig get something with 100 watts you will be much happier. I have know folks who bought a QRP rig for their first rig, 6 months later it would be for sale. Too frustrating they say, only 5 watts they say. Well, don’t say I didn’t try and tell you. Love QRP, can’t wait to get out again to play radio!
QRP aside, When you pass your first licence here in the UK you can't transmit higher power than 10W anyway. I do have the 7300 though (I just set the TX power to 10w).
If you please, I have a question. Does wouxun have a kg-uv9k airband?
The UV9x series radios will received airband, but not transmit.
Ham Radio 2.0
wouxun kg-uv9k nat kg-uv9x !! ؟؟
Ham Radio 2.0
I bought a new one, but I have the airspace. Please how do I work?
Ham Radio 2.0
I mean airband
Ham Radio 2.0
I wait for an answer from you, if you please, sorry for the inconvenience
Thanks.
You answered my questions in under 10 minutes.
Glad I could help!
Thanks. New ham here and you saved me from making a big mistake
I would like to have one as a wideband receiver. If this is not the case any alternative you suggest? Thank you!
My very first HF rig was an FT-817nd....I don’t recommend it to people for their first HF rig, however I absolutely DO NOT regret it, for me personally....QRP forced me to learn antennas and proper setup. I still have the radio and I DO use it as a base station as well as going portable.....👍KF7CLH
I agree with you Jason, 100%.
Thanks
In the center of the screen, vertically, at the far right side, I see it, yes, I SEE IT!. Yes, a marvelous radio, a superb radio! Never been a better transceiver! Mine's the "B" model. I also recently acquired an FTV-650, and am currently collecting stuff to make a ground-plane.
Fantastic video. Great advice.
I just upgraded from Technician to General. Been thinking about getting the 705 because it's an all band radio, does everything I need it to do and on top of that I'd like to get into QRP. I don't like having to run more power than I need. Don't have the space at the house for a dedicated HF rig or an inverted v.
Already got the 5100A set up as my 2m/440 base station radio. Been getting on D-STAR and love the system. With the 705, I can pack it up and take it with me wherever I go. Camping, fishing, traveling out of state and not having to sit in my vehicle all the time just to do HF to show family and friends what my new favorite hobby is.
Side note, I was on 023C in Australia about 2 weeks ago. Heard one station on the reflector using the 705. It sounded great on D-STAR.
73, KO4AHX.
The 705 would be great for you, I think
Also been thinking about getting into PSK31. Going to do some more research, but from what I've read in the ARRL Radio Operators Manual, users run no more than 50 watts. I'm not looking to make overseas contacts on 5 or 10 watts, unless the band conditions are good. Just something to get into and experiment with. Definitely not a home base station radio for sure.
If you like QRP just for the sake of QRP and don't care about portability, you can still turn down the power on your shack rig and have the 100 watts if you want/need it.
True
"WHEN" you shouldn't buy a 705 would have been more accurate
That would have worked also
Yeah but it's not click bait then
@@OffTheBeatenPath_ It's not clickbait anyway since I answered the question posed in the title and it was on topic
Great review, thanks for saving me some money. Just passed my General exam and am looking for an all band radio. I don't understand why we need separate radios based on frequency class... why can't I just find a nice color touchscreen that covers HF/HF/VHF for my shack? (not interested in a mobile UHF rig yet)
I'm in Australia and looking to get my Foundation license which is 10 watts maximum anyway, so that's one reason it interested me. other radio i'm looking at is a second hand Yeasu FT-879D. portable use camping etc as well as base station use is what i'm interested in.
FVNLDQOIO
Jason, your advice on this topic is spot on! A NEW HAM faces MANY challenges! If they spend a lot of cash and have a frustrating time making contacts (which QRP can do), they may hear folks but get frustrated when folks cannot hear them. I tell all new General HF operators to START with a 100 watt rig!
Thanks Ernest
Yes, do both 100W and QRP rigs. Work on an off-grid portable system and make it work. I don't like the attitude of some people towards QRP. I recommend hams to have an off-grid functional off-grid QRP system while going about making 100W rigs work. Small portable solar phone chargers can charge HT's.
I'm guessing there are some people who have seen the video. For me I will have to wait a bit and while I'm curious what your POV is it's unlikely that I will be swayed. This rig will do everything an Elecraft KX2/KX3 will do (minus the tuner which is no issue for me) and works just like my 7300 (which is an absolutely awesome rig). I had a KX2 (and paid way more than the amount I'm paying for the 705) and it was a great little rig....but ultimately meh. I have a G90 and it's awesome...but that screen is SOOO small.
My Patrons get early access to all of my videos, yes. But lots of people are commenting on it now that I have scheduled it for tomorrow. I hope everyone watches, it might not be what you think
Thanks! As I'm new to hf, this was a very useful video.
I have an yaesu ft7b from the nineties, awesome radio. But it would be cool having something like the 705 to bring outdoors
Thanks for the info. As a newbie (still waiting for my call sign) I have been confused by the jargon that is tossed around. You've cleared up some of it.
I'm just waiting for my IC 705 to ship. This will be my backpacking rig. I dont use HF that much, more VHF/UHF. Can't wait to try this out. This will be my first HF back packing radio. Any suggestions on what I can use to keep the battery charged while in the field? Keep in mind I have about 50lbs of food, clothes, tent..and misc.
Mine should ship this week
I'm not sure in the battery charging, will have to wait and see what options there are when I get mine
I have a 9 watt flexible solar panel with charge controller for an Elecraft KX2. Some of the newer battery chemistries are light weight but difficult to charge with solar. What I did was find some plastic 8-cell packs to hold NiMH batteries in AA and D sizes and wired them up with the appropriate connectors. Just make sure your IC 705 rig can run on 10.4 volts or less if you go this route.
Solid breakdown of Icom options.
Love the 705.
Thanks
I run I C 725 I also run Yeasu 101 Icom D Star 2 meter 440 .Kenwood I stay away from any thing digital except what is good for your needs. Analog I think is best. I don’t want to relay on any thing to do with satellite communication do what you think is best for you just remember if technology goes down what is best to stay stay in communication with .always plan on a back up it may be costly. And don’t forget to protect your equipment it’s called a fairday cauge 73’s to all.
I also hold the opinion that the first radio must necessarily be 100W. The realization that you need a QRP radio should come by itself. For example, my first radio was FT-891 - a wonderful device, I can't say anything bad about it. But now I don't have a home shack, I work exclusively in the fields with a backpack. Considering that I work >90% of the time in CW, it made absolutely no sense for me to carry such a weight on myself. And I switched to QRP radio already knowing what it is, how to work with it, how to set up and use resonant antennas and being able to navigate the air. A beginner will only be disappointed that no one hears him. To put it quite simply - do not worry, novice friends, you will buy your IC-705, just a little later)
My home rig is an nIC-7200. My Mobile HF is an FT-891. For High Band in the car I have an FTM-200.
What about using the 705 for satellite operations?
I don't know that answer. I don't think it is full duplex, and it doesn't have 1.2GHz. But...you should be able to use it on 2M/440 the same way you can with any HT radio.
Thank you for this info. Good video
Glad it was helpful!
You may very well have saved a newbie buying the wrong model. You made things very clear and explained your reasoning very well. Thanks.
Thanks
comparatively a Yaesu FT-991A is considered an all-band "shack-in-a-box" (160m--70c) radio and will do 100w on HF CW & SSB. GREAT video! Thanks!!! 73
If you live or for some reason life has forced you into an apartment the IC705 is the radio for you! Get a magloop antenna and your good to go yes it’s QRP but in an apartment complex you don’t want to do much more then 10watts so your not bleeding or interfering on other peoples electronics! I’ve made some good contacts on hf with this radio and the AL 705 antenna setting on a table next to the east facing window it works well and is a fun challenge to make contacts inside my apartment!
Great advice, thank you for this
Where can them hats be purchased?
QRP as first HF or mobile rig will likely be frustrating unless you are already an experienced CW operator. It would be ok for local VHF/UHF repeaters, but too expensive just for that.
I have worked Europe from US with CW on 20m with 1 watt. If that sounds like fun to you, the 705 may be right for you.
Agreed
About possibilities and probabilities I am considering Ed exposure 5watts sound perfect to me
This was helpful thank you
Glad it was helpful!
I'm liking the 705 waterfall technology but not the 10 watt x ing power output. But the 705 can be modified for CB bands as well.
The 7100 is a more versatile unit in its form factor. Divorced so the head is easily placed within handy reach without the bulky main radio unit. So what's the best solution? Wait for the 7100 to be upgraded with a colour waterfall screen? Or buy the 705 and a amplifier? They both will need a signal strength tuning meter as well .
I know you did this video 2 years ago so maybe ICOM has an upgraded version of the 7100 in production.
But only time will tell.
Thanks for your videos.
I'm in learn mode and I'm trying to absorb as much as I can.
I have already brought a Kenwood nx5800 k2 and am looking to buy a nx5300 abp5 or abp6 intrenslicly safe MIL SPEC handheld for $1300.00 CDN .n/c the battery & charger. That's another $320.00 CDN.But if there's a way of getting a tri band mobile unit for both base and mobile, then that's what I feel is best overall.
I just watched just north of London, U.K. as one guy were using IC-705, it has great receiver, as other guy were coming in S 9, as other guy has pretty weak signal with no meter reading on IC-705 as of; in CB lingo is called: PEANUT-WHISTLE. In Ham term; is called; QRP that doesn't means: Quickly-Reduced-Power.
What antennae would you use for an IC7100 for your car?
My favorite is the Comet SBB5
Waiting for the $ to drop slightly or pick up a mint pre-owned. Looks like a viable supplement to my FT818 hiking/SOTA rig. I see many disparaging the low 10w output. This rig is meant for highly portable in the field operation. You are not going far on foot with a 100w portable and the associated heavy battery required to power it. This radio is for those who do adventure radio (hiking, SOTA, POTA) you can do amazing things with the FT818 from a summit. The iCom 705 will expand this horizon.
I am also into astronomy. A 6” budget reflector ($300)from a dark site will annihilate a several thousand $ professional grade scope from the bright city.
In radio, high altitude/low RF is the dark sky!
Excellent presentation!
Thank you kindly!
Very good advice! I totally agree with your view on NOT purchasing the IC-705 as a base rig /first radio.
Thanks for watching!
Most QRP hams are the reason why I don't jump into thinking getting a linear is a solution. I made friends with QRP hams, they spend more time on antennas and off-grid. I personally recommend QRP radios with built-in battery packs to start with. Nothing feels so much better than having a GRP HF all-mode setup successfully working well with battery and solar panel. I'm both into QRP and also 100W radio. Constantly, I'm experimenting with off-grid and low power equipment. One should really do is meditate on how to prepare for the worst blackout that lasts like a year. My ICOM IC-730 is my 100W rig that runs off 13.8VDC 20A, I have both Xiegu X6100 and G90.
Also, nearly all 100w rigs have a power output setting and you can turn them down to 5w or less
@@DennyInDurham I'm not sure what this comment has to do with the video you are commenting on. But...... I've done what you're talking about in several other videos.
I agree, still I like the portability and all the functionality for a physically small size radio. Plus, it has a removable battery. I got a Xiegu X6100 and I'm very happy with it, I'm thinking I may get an Icom IC-705 and I guarantee I will use it the most. I also plan to go to a HAM swap meet to find a large full size base station HF transceiver. In my neighborhood, I'm very content with an HT. The IC-705 makes me very comfortable to use with solar and external batteries, living off grid.
I started my HAM lifestyle with small radios and making the most out of them.
I would recommend a 7300 to anyone who wants a general purpose HF radio. The 7300 has 100W, built in antenna tuner, built in soundcard, and good user interface. For mobile, consider a used Icom 706IIG.
Yes
Great review. I have had my license since 1965. I think your advice about QRP is great for new hams. However, I think that people should not under estimate the power of 10 watts. I have had very good luck talking around the world with ten watts with the right antenna. js'g
from KC1CCG - My radio is an IC-7300. Been a ham for over 60 years. A hundred watts is a fine level. Want to QRP ? Just turn a knob from 100% power out to 10% power out. Advice to new hams....the antenna is THE important part of the system. Understand antennas & grounds and whatever radio you have will be fine. Crappy antenna and 100W WILL be QRP because only 5 watts will go anywhere. The real test for me is....if I can hear them, I can work them (with few exceptions). They might be running 500W but our reports are the same or only 1 or 2 S units apart.
I was first licensed in 2005. I’ve been running a 705 for a few weeks on HF & VHF, great transceiver. 10W is plenty.
Very cool!
Click-bait, Jason. You've just gone down several notches on my list of ham radio reviewers who I like to watch. The title and thumbs-down visual on the title page is misleading. I understand what you're getting at for newbies but comparing a QRP radio to a 100W radio is apples and oranges.
It is Apples to Oranges. Yes you are correct. That was my point. THAT is the question I've been asked 2-3 dozen times. How would you respond? How would you explain to new folks, who just got their license, what QRP is?
@@radiobits3007 That's exactly what I did. Explaining something is done in the video, not in the title, so you contradicted yourself there, and assumptions made by you, I can't control. Having said that, yes the title was somewhat clickbait but in the video I EXPLAINED what I was talking about and I delivered the message that the title promised. Anything beyond that is really semantics.
Indeed. Always happy to do that. Thanks for your feedback, regardless
@@HamRadio2 - Goodbye JASON, I an done with this Channel.
@@HamRadio2 Hi Jason. Of course it could be considered clickbait, but with good intention - and it certainly got my attention! I was curious (and therefore clicked) as only a few days ago one of our new young hams on our local club net was seriously considering the IC-705 and imminently ready to purchase.
His reasoning was the 705 was HF and VHF/UHF with D-STAR. (Most youngsters these days seem to be fixated on the armchair DXing capability of D-STAR via the InterNerd, but that’s another story). I was quickly on the ‘phone to him to advise the rig was QRP, for which he was very thankful. So, for me (and luckily for him), the “clickbait” worked as intended. Thanks.
It seems so simple that these are tools for can be a really fancy hammer but if you're looking at a screw it just isn't the proper thing to get. Nice video clear and concise
I love when a presentation gets right to the point without beating around the Bush.
Less than 9 minutes to the whole video!
@MetalCoreMoto And yet you take time out of your busy day to come by and comment multiple times...
@@HamRadio2 I’m retired, but still have about 19 other things to do during my day.
Where did you get that fine looking hat?
I have them made locally. I am about to start offering them at shop.hamradio2.com - custom callsign hats
Just saw your video on the IC-705. My goal is for a backpack radio, powered by a LiFePO4 battery and solar panel. Antenna would be a buddistick. Joined an Icom 705 group and found it was an Icom love fest. I left the group. My thoughts are for the Xiego G 90. It is adjustable 0 to 20 watts. The 705 is 5 W internal battery, 10 W external battery. The Xiegu also has an antenna tuner. Also, it's 1/3 the price of the 705. Dennis, KD2MIP
Yep, agreed.
I agree as well. I have a Yaesu FT-817 and I love the thing. But it’s tough! I have not been able to make any voice contacts on it at home, but I have made a lot of great ones in the field. Another thing to note, is that lots of campgrounds have sites with power, and I have been able to bring my FT-450D and make some good contacts. I love QRP but I would fight new operators who try to get them as a first HF rig.
I'd be interested in hearing whether your opinion on this (in particular, the part at 4:32) changes given the apparent discontinuation (or at least long-term unavailability) of the TH-D74A/E (because of, if my Internet reading is correct, a fire at the plant that makes their DACs/ADCs... the only factory in the world that made those particular ones. Oof.) And/or in general for you to talk about that. I was about ready to pull the trigger on one of those, and noticed they'd gotten de-listed on several sites... so now I'm pondering the IC-705 instead (for, for the moment, mostly home use, and probably mostly listening on HF, at least until/unless I get an upgrade -- currently a Tech). I like the idea of being able to expand into HF, even if only QRP, but I'd like D-STAR, and... yeah. IC-52 is also a potential consideration, especially since I've already ordered a HackRF One, and I could presumably use that for the HF listening side of things. But... I do like the idea of a nice physical UI (jog wheel, etc.) that's dedicated to doing this stuff right.
P.S. [edit] - Other factors: I currently don't have anywhere to put up a fancy high-power antenna anyway, but 6:54 makes me think I should maybe take another look at the 7100, as well.
Q RP is for people with experience, who have been an active ham for some time and already have a "real" radio. After that, if you really know what you are getting and want a low power ham station in a box, maybe you want it for an IF for you microwave transverter, or may be replace your old reliable FT817, you cant beat the IC705. It is a great, very specialized radio, but not a good first rig for a new ham.
Hey Jason, I completely agree with u (I always click on ur videos regardless of the title). I absolutely love my IC-7300 as my full power base station ... but also love to be HAM portable. I've been struggling with the decision to buy a new IC-705 QRP (+ portable antenna tuner, + portable amp, + etc.) ... or just take my IC-7300 portable (without any of those accessories because they're built-in). Plus I already own an IC-51A digital handheld so that is my very portable digital VHF/UHF radio. The ONLY advantage for me to buy a $1300 IC-705 is backpack portability as you said. But then I would also want to buy and pack an ATU, amp, etc if I want more antenna flexibility and full power (another $300+). For me, it was not worth it. I love the look and feel of the IC-705 for the QRP form factor. But I ultimately worked out a small backpack carrying my IC-7300, lithium battery and WRC vertical and can go anywhere with full power (or QRP). The IC-7300 is 9.3 lbs and the IC-705 is 2.4 lbs (only 6.9 lbs difference). Just my 2 cents on why I decided against the IC-705 for my portable purposes. 73 KJ6ER, Silicon Valley
Thanks for commenting
Hmmm. Holding up a just released $1,000+ QRP rig and a thumbs down? Just a little deceptive.
I would have been more impressed if you would have presented the IC 705 and a first look, or do session on why QRP isn’t the best choice for a new ham.
Good feedback. I do plan to do that once I get the radio in my hands. But as I said in the video, I was speaking directly to Hams who are new to the hobby, who are looking to buy this new radio, but don't understand what QRP is.
Great video 2.0. I was curious about the 705. I am kinda not liking the Yaesu 891 anymore....I never realized how noisey it it, but it just is. It's great for travel but lots o noise.