@@erikheijden9828 I agree, in the sense that within the titanic community she’s very well known. But within the mainstream community not many people know about the hardships about the rescue
Had they received the SOS call earlier it would be an way smaller story, but an better outcome. Guess radio watches would become an outcome anyway. As I understand radio was used on warships earlier. Her they are obviously much more critical, having a ship reporting the position of the enemy fleet could easy turn an battle.
@@xergiok2322 because while some people might know her name, her actual story and the risks she took and the heroism of her crew are pretty much unknown to the general public.
@@jayive34 When the Carpathia arrived at the scene Rostron already sensed "with a sinking heart," according to Walter Lord, that the Titanic was already gone
The one moment in Rostron's story that really sticks with me is that upon getting the news he started organising his men, plotting his course and preparing his ship for a rescue, and THEN asks his wireless operator to confirm and get more details. That speaks volumes about the man's proactive leadership and decisiveness. He must have been a metaphorical giant of a man.
I had heard the same story, that Captain Rostron heard the news from his radioman & said to Number One, "turn us around", THEN got confirmation from Sparks: if they jam on the brakes and turn around, and the message was wrong, they might lose an hour resuming their previous course, BUT that hour might mean the difference between life & death if they delay in responding. MAD props to Captain Rostron - bling him RIGHT TF up.
The one that stuck to me was how he did not abandon the survivors once they were on his ship. I mean they had no space for them, and he could have just called the Olympic and offloaded them to Titanic's sister. But the fact that he said it would be too much for them to see Olympic, so I will not let them relive their trauma.
@@MCreedon34 4th Officer Joseph Boxhall was the one who told Cpt Rostron what he had already sensed "with a sinking heart" (Walter Lord), namely that the Titanic was gone.
Carpathia's part in this historic event deserves it's own time in the limelight. The efforts of her crew that cold night were nothing short of heroic. Managing to push the vessel 3 to 4 knots past its designed top speed was testament to their skill and dedication.
@@quangtruongle7823 Safety valves would have limited pressure to the design maximum. Some early steam locomotives exploded when their safety valves were screwed down, so it was engineered that no such thing could be done. Would have been the same for ships too.
@@EllieMaes-Grandad Still, boilers aren't designed to withstand that much pressure for long. It's "emergency" speed setting, that supposed to be used only for short bursts of speed, not for many hours in a row. No doubt engineers in boiler rooms were sweating not only because of heat, but because nobody could tell, how long boilers will last being pushed to their limit.
As an HVAC tech, I am also really impressed by the boilers and the men that built them. I've seen boilers crack and burst in normal operation below their nameplate ratings, yet these held up for hours while being overloaded. In Germany, there is a test where you deliberately run boilers to their thermal limits to test the safety switches, and even that is honestly really scary every time you have to do it (every time you touched those switches). Hearing the burner roar, seeing all gauges rising far beyond what is considered acceptable, and just praying that switch actually trips before something bursts or catches fire is probably the scariest part of the job. Normally, old boilers run up to 90°C, with newer ones only going up to 75°C. The limit switches usually trip at 110°C, and you cancel the test at 115 or 120 if it didn't trip yet. If nothing bursts and causes major water damage or you have to put out a fire around the flue pipe. Now imagine doing a similar thing for hours on end, rather than just minutes, and constantly shoveling coal in an already overloaded boiler, knowing it could just leak or burst, releasing tons of boiling hot steam into the same room you are standing in.
It's sort of a mini miracle that the Carpathia's boilers or any other engine part didn't blow apart when going beyond it's limits for so long. I love this little ship like you wouldn't believe!
The Carpathia and the Île de France are what I think of when I think of ‘hero ships’. Their captains and crew didn’t just do their duty, they went above and beyond to rescue survivors and provide comfort and support to those in need. Carpathia especially set the tone for what an emergency response should look like.
@@trustweb99to be fair, the California wouldn’t have been able to help even if they tried. Unlike the Carpathia, here engines had been shut off for the night, by the time her engines were hot again, the Titanic would already be long gone
The Californian didn’t even know the titanic was sinking because the Marconi operator on titanic scolded the operator on the Californian for sending out signals when the titanic operator was busy, so the Californian operator went to bed.. had he stayed at his station for another half hour, the Californian could have helped the other 1500 passengers that didn’t have life boats, and given them enough time to survive for the Carpathia to reach them and save the rest sitting in the life boats.. the titanic Marconi operator essentially killed 1500 people because he was rude and impatient…
This is easily one of the most gripping and hard-hitting videos on TH-cam (or anywhere else for that matter). Mike, you’ve outdone yourself on this one!! Your penchant for story telling is second to none. I’ve watched it twice now and my hairs are still standing!!
I second that. This must be one of the best Mike's productions (because as his films are now done, we are talking of documentary production levels, not simply your average youtube fan video).
I think it's a fitting end. She's known for saving Titanics survivors and she went down saving the lives of her crew. The only fatalities were the 5 firemen killed in the torpedo explosion, it took 3 torpedos to sink her.
@RegalCobra097 yup, 2 torpedos crippled it, but it didn't sink/took too long, so an hour and 45 minutes later the u-boat fired a third torpedo which sank her.
One thing: that doctor wasnt a 'hungarian speaker', he was a hungarian physician. Named Arpad Lengyel. His epitaph says: ' Ship doctor of the Carpathia, who earned worldwide recognition for his rescue and medical work during the sinking of the Titanic. '
I can't imagine how many frostbitten injuries and gruesome injuries and broken bones he tended to, my goodness. there's another channel on here somewhere that has a video called "the physical toll on Titanic's passengers" or something like that that's very informative. he talks about years of aches and pains and this one woman in particular who said "the titanic is calling" (paraphrased) when hers acted up. ETA: Legacy Liner is the channel.
Captain Arthur Rostron was a hero for putting himself, his ship 'Carpathia', and his entire crew at the disposal of the stricken 'Titanic' that night. Imagine the condemnation he'd have got, if they too had come to grief on the same treacherous North Atlantic icebergs as 'Titanic', and gone down with many more lives lost. But if the worst had happened, he would still have been a hero, and it would still have been the right decision. Because that's precisely what made him a hero - he did not know the ultimate outcome for himself, his ship 'Carpathia', and his crew of men. Yet he and his team took the risk regardless, and went to 'Titanic's aid without a backward glance. As the saying goes: 'No Guts - No Glory!' A fantastic documentary, which brought the historic events of that night - chilling in every sense - dramatically to life. Bravo, a great job by Mike Brady.
I wish I could say the very same thing about the Californian but no, that ship was, as Walter Lord put it so well, "presided over by a cautious captain and an uninspired watch."
Just prior to the Titanic's loss, my Grandma (who was 16 at the time) crossed from Europe alone on the Carpathia disembarking in New York. As a memento of her journey to the "new country" she saved a copy of the ship's menu, which we still have. How very tragic that just six years after her heroic rescue, the Carpathia became one of the many casualties of WWI thanks to a torpedo fired from a German submarine. This great ship that played such a pivotal role in the history of world events, succumbed to an act of war.
The captain of the Carpathia Arthur Rostron was from my hometown of Bolton, I would pass the house he was born in everyday when I was younger it has a blue plaque on the outside. It makes me quite proud. Bolton was also the birth place of Robert Whitehead who invented the first effective self Propelled torpedo, bit of an irony with Carpathia being sunk by Torpedo in ww1. Not sure why Bolton has such ties with the sea being inland, but there were factories in the town that produced naval guns, naval engines and presently there is a missile manufacturer that produces missiles used by the Royal navy.
And the ship's doctor, Arpad Lengyel is buried in about 10 minutes walk from my place. I just discovered that there was a soccer match held in Budapest, Hungary between the crew of Carpathia, and a better known local team, MTK, and the proceedings went to the orphans of Titanic. Captain Rostron and the mayor of Budapest were also present there.
I can only assume it has something to do with Bolton being near and in fact a part of modern day greater Manchester as even if Manchester is no Liverpool in terms of shipping it does have the Manchester ship canal so it's not exactly a stranger to the maritime even if it's inland.
The competence, care, bravery and forethought of Captain Rostron is nothing short of amazing. Right down to realising the effect seeing Olympic would have on the survivors. That man was the exact right man to be in charge of this relief and rescue effort and it is a true shame there is not more movies, books and tv shows about him and his valiant crew. The world should know his name just as well as they know the name Titanic. Thank you Mike for this stupendous recount. Your storytelling and clear respect for the people and ships involved in this tale of tragedy and heroism are fantastic as always.
Yes only if Rostron was the captain of the Titanic that night the ship may not have had the collision but only in hindsight.Some of the quick thinking decisions he took was commendable.
Harold Cottam lived until May of 1984 (less than fifteen months before the wreck of Titanic was discovered). Imagine the technological changes he'd seen in his lifetime.
I have a great aunt that is 100 years old. Her mom (my g-grandmother), died at age 94. She is still extremely sharp, and lives by herself. I love visiting her. She tells me stories that she heard from her grandmother. It is crazy how much has changed in such a short time. (Relatively).
My grandfather was one of the child that got to see the Titanic start her maiden voyage in 1912. He lived until 2013 and I remembered how he told me about how he felt about seeing a Titanic wreckage footage in 1980s when it was discovered. "We finally meet again." he said.
I've always been fascinated and awed by the nerve, discipline, and bravery of the Carpathia and its crew over the years - it's my favourite ship far surpassing the Titanic. Today, from your comment, I learned that Harold Cottom died in May 1984. Specifically, the 30th of May 1984, which is also the day I was born. Life is just weird that way sometimes.
One of my favourite stories. April 15th is my birthday. I never think of it as the day Lincoln died, Hillsborough disaster or the day Titanic sank, but the day the Carpathia rescued the survivors. Carpathia Day. It is the best movie never made.
Rostron was quoted to say after light came up and he saw the ice field that he sure have not navigated through that maze, Gods hand must have steered all the way.
Now I'm just picturing the Titanic silently sailing full speed past iceberg after iceberg, completely unaware of their presence. How many close calls they might have had that night, before their luck ran out.
@@codboroks97 I was struck by how Titanic's reported location was about 40% of the way through the ice field, but their actual location wasn't very far from the edge of the ice field. I'm caught between thinking they were dead the moment EJ Smith made the decision to enter the field, that if it wasn't that iceberg it would've been another. Or that the collision was optimally bad -- a second or two of reaction time either way would've led to missing the iceberg completely or to a heavier impact that would've damaged fewer compartments more substantially but within the ship's design parameters.
@@Jesse-qy6ur Probably, since EJ Smith violated main rule about icebergs - you supposed to reduce your speed in case of ice warning. So Titanic was doomed one way or another. In a way it was luck, that they collided with iceberg so close to the edge of ice field - if they were only a little bit further, rescue would be much harder and Carpathia would suffer same fate.
@ceu160193 well actually quite a misinformation you got there. You see all of the ice warnings were passed carefully to the bridge. And smith heeded them properly.if you want to point out the one which Philips shouted shut up and didn't listen to californian, i support Philips as the day prior Harold and Philips were fixing the broken wireless and got no sleep, Therefore he was quite weary and tired but then as Californian blasted the warning Jack was irritated.And All of this aside back in 1912 the rudders and engines were separate unlike today where ship's propellers are fitted to Pods. They work differently.In Titanic's (and other ships at the time) case lower speed meant lesser manuerability . Even in old naval textbooks they mention this fact.And also before smith retired to his cabin he checked on everything then approved that they were banking on clear conditions and had perfect visibility.But due to the cold mirage effect the light was getting thrown off . This led to the crew not noticing until they came closer to the iceberg.Edward John smith was an amazing veteran captain. He did all that he needed to and followed the naval regulations. He had done all he could on the night of sinking But Alas he couldn't save his passengers and survive
Gotta give props to Captain Rostrand. Almost without question, immediately changing course to rescue survivors of a rival company, getting the ship ready, risking his own Passengers, crew, and ship to save as many souls as he could. That is what movies should be made of.
The Carpathia's heroic rush with her captain and crew deserves to be remembered and honored for all time. The fact that they pushed and damaged the ship's engines in their mission of mercy is all you need to know.
Great, moving presentation. It really touched me that Carpathia’s captain realized that bringing the Titanic’s survivors to the Olympic could mean more trauma for them. The same regarding picking up the dead. The Carpartia’s captain proved himself to be a thoughtful, kind man with great insight into the trauma these poor survivors were going through.
When I was a boy, I remember reading about the Titanic, and thinking what it must have been like to wake up at midnight on the Carpathia, and find everything changed from when you went to bed. One part that's never really been covered much was the sailing to NY of the survivors. Small snippets here and there, Ismay medicated in a private cabin, a child reunited with his mom, tons of messages sent. But little else. The grief had to have been soul-crushing on board. Great vid, Mike... thank you!
There's quite a bit about it in _A Night to Remember,_ as well as a lot of personal correspondences from survivors written after the fact-most of them addressed to Margaret Brown, who immediately set to work with Captain Rostron and some of the other First Class ladies organising a relief fund for the widows and orphans just hours after she herself was lifted from Boat 6.
@@DistractedGlobeGuy I remember reading it, the thing that stuck out was how White Star thinking Halifax was going to be the destination hired a private train to transport folks to NYC. The night they arrived, Mrs. Brown, the media feeding frenzy... I know it'd be virtually impossible, but for the steerage folks, maybe some 2nd class, after they got back, what happened to them? Where'd they end up, how'd they get there? First class, obviously we know, and many of the families of the lost crew we do too (White Star messed up there big time, public relation wise)... Just like to follow thru is all. Like, a steerage widow with two kids that was supposed to go to the midwest... did she get there? Did she go on to have a good life? That kind of thing...
At the Chelsea Piers in New York City, the Titanic’s original destination and where The Carpathia docked with the survivors, there are huge blown up photographs of Carpathia’s arrival. If you’re in Manhattan, it’s worth a visit. 18th street on the Hudson River.
I am 62 years old and have been an ocean liner fan since childhood! I would never have imagined the realistic animation available in this day and age! I love your videos!
One of my favorite stories about Titanic happened on Carpathia. When they arrived in New York, Harold Bride was still in the wireless room sending messages. He didn't notice that Guglielmo Marconi, his employer, had arrived to meet his now-highest-profile worker. After a minute, Marconi took Bride's hand off the telegraph key and said "That's hardly worth sending now, son."
My favorite story from Walter Lord's book: The several Carpathia passengers who snuck out of their cabins, managed to evade stewards told to keep them in their rooms, and were huddled out of sight on the aft deck trying to figure out why there was so much commotion so late at night, and why a "poky little liner" on the Southern route was suddenly barreling through an ice field. "Gradually they realized their ship was not in danger, but no one had any idea why they were on this wild dash through the night." Oh, to have overheard those conversations!
Arthur Roston’s captaincy, situational and organisational skill that night I think are unparalleled in the history of maritime commerce, thank you for a video that finally captures the immensity of Carpathia’s efforts that night
It was interesting to see a video from the Carpathia's point of view. Captain Rostron and his crew were definitely heroes that night, no doubt about it. They steamed into an ice field that could easily have caused them to suffer the same fate as the Titanic, and were already organizing supplies and a rescue effort even before they knew how many extra passengers they might have. It's tragic that the Titanic had already gone down by the time the Carpathia arrived, and only a relatively small number of survivors were saved, in comparison to the 2000+ plus souls originally on board, but the Carpathia's crew did everything they could to help save as many people as they could, and I've heard that some of the passengers helped to take care of the Titanic survivors, too. IMO, the Carpathia deserves to have a movie of her own, since her story is just as intriguing in its own way as the Titanic. It's a shame that this wonderful boat ended up on the bottom of the North Atlantic herself only six years later!
Great story telling again as always. That's a good point near the end about meeting up with Olympic; from a modern PTSD perspective, that would have been horrific for many of the survivors. I think they made the best possible choice.
Listening to stories like this makes me want to join the coast guard. Hearing how people were able to put their gear aside to help those in need, truly heroic.
I’d never heard this story from Carpathia’s perspective before. Honestly, it’s just as exciting as the story from aboard Titanic! This is film material. Without a doubt I would watch this film.
The CGI filming is not only lifelike dramatic but artistic, too. An aspect of the disaster often overlooked. Captain Rostron was one of those increasingly rare people who knew what he was doing and how to act. I’ve always thought his final reply to Titanic, ‘Tell him we’re coming along as quickly as we can,’ is one of the most poignant in maritime history. I read somewhere that Carpathia eventually worked up to just in excess of 17 knots at times that night.
The 17 knots claim is a myth, it was based on Titanic's incorrect position transmitted during the sinking, which wasn't known to be incorrect until the wreck was found. The real location of the wreck was closer to Carpathia's position when they turned around, so they didn't actually sail as far as they thought in just 3 and a half hours.
@@bungobaggins01 17 knots is probably not a myth, going 3 knots above service speed is not unusual, you wouldn't be able to do it for long but perfectly possible especially when the crew worked as hard as Carpathia's did.
@@Alex-cw3rz 3 knots above service speed is unusual for a ship whose maximum speed ever reliably recorded was just over 15 knots. The simple fact of the matter is that the 17 knot calculation is based on the incorrect CQD position, which they didn't know was wrong at the time
No one can tell a story quite the way Mike can. I'm always enamored of the amount of information and passion you put into your narrations and without a doubt, you are my favourite channel Mike. Thank you from the bottom of my heart for such amazing content. Today is the day (April 18) Carpathia came into dock in New York after picking up Titanic's survivors. I do believe the upload date is a deliberate one.
Everytime Oceanliner Designs uploads a new version of Carpathia's frenzied dash towards Titanic i ciick as soon as i get a notification cause the story is absolutely wild and every time he uploads a new version the ship animations get better and better!
In Carpatia’s homeport of Rijeka in Croatia I visited the museum dedicated to Titanic and Carpatia. This video tells the story even better. Very well done sir!
Ok, I had to check this. Turns out, I dont know about my country history... So, Carpathia and i think 9 other ships was a liner that brought people from Rijeka to New York. And on April 15, they were on a jurney to Rijeka, with 700 passangers. Apperently, when they came to Rijeka on may 6,they were greeted with a hero welcome
25:47 Such a chilling shot. Really gives scale of how tiny and fragile the lifeboats looked compared to the ocean and Carpathia. Really brings home how long and scary the wait must have been between Titanic sinking and rescue arriving.
Thank you. Rostron and his crew are too often overlooked when the Titanic's story is told. They saved hundreds of lives and that should never be forgotten. Rostron's courage and decisiveness were absolutely exemplary.
The Captain and the Crew of the Carpathia, are without a doubt, the Heroes of the Survivors. The amount of sheer hard slog that they all put in is incredible. It had also never occurred to me the Options faced by Captain Rostron were horrible in their own right. Wait for the Titanic's Twin and scare already overwrought people, look for Bodies with the same impact and turn and make for New York but that could make the Survivors feel like the Carpathia was abandoning their loved ones. Thanks again Mike.
You show such reverence and care with the Carpathia story, and truly honor Rostrom's legacy with these videos. We (and he) are lucky to have you as custodian of this special moment in history. Thanks, Mike!
The story of Titanic cant not be told without the story of the Carpathia. The true maritime heroism for all aboard that night and for the return trip is something remarkable.
What a night. Just almost unbelievable. Carpathia and her Captain and Crew went above and beyond. The survivors had to be exhausted and in complete shock. What a story.
Mike, your voice through this one carried a sombre tone of impending doom. I was on edge and the tears welling, just wanting a different result than the one we all knew was coming...the sinking and huge loss of life. This video is captivating and truly dramatic. What heroes the Captain and crew of the Carpathia!
That must've been a Beautiful sight to the Titanic survivors! The Carpathia approaching the scene! Many survivors must have thought "this is it! Our time is up"! A beautiful documentary! Thank You Captain Brady!
Until now I only knew that the Carpathia had been the first on the scene and picked up survivors. Thank you for telling this underappreciated facet of the Titanic story and doing so in such a compelling and detailed way.
Outstanding video. The Carpathia's crew truly were heroic. Sadly, despite their best efforts, they could not reach Titanic before she sank. Titanic's survivors in shock and grieving were nevertheless well cared for on Carpathia.
Great video! A little addition: the head of the doctors was the Hungarian one during the rescue. (Dr. Árpád Lengyel. The man with the mustache on the right on the officers picture) Cpn. Rostron asked him specifically to led the operation, because he was the only doctor on the ship with actual field ambulance experience. After the Carpathia arrived back to Europe he immediately left the ship and never vent on the sea again. But he and his ancestors kept all the notes, pictures,documents and personal belongings from that night and the items are now displayed on the Ambulance museum in Budapest.
Since I was little boy, I became fascinated by the story of the Titanic. I would visit our local library - they had a Saturday afternoon group book reading - and the librarian suggested ‘A Night to Remember’ I was hooked. I would take the book out, several times. Anyway, your narration of the Carpathia rescue journey was very moving. Thanks for sharing the story.
A really well given take. I read Sir George Bissits “of tramps and ladies” nearly 30 years ago. An absolutely brilliant book and it has always put the other titanic productions to shame as clearly no one has ever used or looked at this to produce a proper account of what happened. It’s very clear that you have and for that I’m very grateful as this shows in your production. For those that have read it, I throughly recommend it as it gives not only the only real true account by an eyewitness to the rescue but also a grounding on the marine practices of the time. This for me is very well researched as so many fail to look at this. You’ve got my subscription! His whole account also talks about the SS Californian ignoring distress flares due to companies wishing to let them off whenever competition was nearby as a show of bravado. As of many other interesting information which is largely missed by so many so called experts. I’m glad to see a production where someone clearly has read all of the resource.
I'm fascinated in the story of how Carpathia goes to Titanic's aid as quick as they can and picking the survivors up. I think that could make a good movie of the whole Carpathia crew and rescue.
As the Carpathia started to race towards the disaster scene Rostron being the pious man that he was had raised his cap about 2in and started to pray. Also, before leaving the scene in the morning of the 15th he had everyone assembled for a brief service in memory of those lost and in thanksgiving for those saved. He said after the rescue that a hand other than his must have been on the helm that night
They NEED to make a movie about this ship. Carpathia is a true Hero and her and her crew deserve the recognition and the limelight be casted on them for once. This was absolutely magnificent and poignant. Thank you! I loved it!
I agree with everything you said....except that I really don't trust hollywood or even netflix to cast an accurate and flattering limelight on anything or give anyone their well deserved recognition except themselves.
I am in awe at this story, but I am so impressed that the captain had the added compassion to think of what seeing the Olympic could do to the survivors. Just amazing the lengths he went through to care for others.
Its funny, im really not interested in ocean liners in general, but i cant get enough of this channel, and of course, my friend, Mike Brady, from Oceanliner Designs.
I first became interested in ships when my father and I used to go to the heads of Wellington harbour to watch ships come in such as the Southern Cross, etc. However, my interest increased when I bought a book on the history of the Union Company ships and their voyages. Mike’s channel is at a completely higher level!
Much has been said about Captain Smith's knowledge of ice warnings to be completely accurate for the time. That he was confident and calm knowing full well how to navigate such hazards as was standard in 1912. Yet here is Captain Rostron of Carpathia equally keen but having far greater respect for the ice. In my humble opinion Captain Smith is a scoundrel. He brought about the death of 1517 lives with his stunning arrogance. Captain Rostron is a hero in my book.
I do place partial blame on Captain Smith, because he was the head of the ship and was responsible for all decisions made. But then I see a series of misfortune that the Titanic encountered beyond his control.
@@Redslayer86 I think Cpt Smith went down with the ship out of guilt and shame. I believe other ship captains around that time said they wouldn't have gone with the ship, and it wasn't required for a captain to go down with his ship. However, I envision that when Smith saw no rescue ship was coming any time soon. And knew people would die, not just a few but many. Then he knew there would be headlines and hearings about how he messed up. His name in infamy, for sinking a state of the art ship that was supposed to be nearly unsinkable on its maiden voyage. Smith probably thought "Oh bloody Hell, I might as well join Titanic in Davy Jones' locker."
Two captains faced with the same conditions, both apparently with experience of navigating near ice. One knows ice will be hard to spot and applies caution and extra lookouts. The other believes the ice will be easy to spot, goes to bed and gives the world a reason to remember Titanic.
Mike Brady's presentation and narration are utterly mesmerising. He totally brings it all to life. I wonder whether any of those involved in the rescue received commendations/honours. I know that's not what motivated them but it would be interesting to know
I cannot stress enough how much I love this channel. You told Carpathia's heroic story so captivating like I've never heard before. You gave us a glimpse at the emotions that those people must have felt. Titanic's story and how you tell it never seize to astonish me.
My friend Mike Brady told the story vividly and well. I can only imagine the somber mood aboard the vessels that went to comb the area of the sinking, retrieving bodies and flotsam.
Michael, one of your finest productions. Such a chilling and haunting narrative followed by detailed animation by your colleague, Jack Gibson. I often wondered what it was like on the Carpathaia. Her seasoned Captain and loyal crew could not have done more and any other delays en-route could have exposed the survivors to sickness and death. Thank you for this powerful video.
Mike your script and narration for this episode was gripping! The story from aboard The Carpathia is heart racing and heartbreaking. Well done. Cameron could have made Titanic a better film with more history than fiction. The story is so astounding. Well done sir, you had me in tears.
Thinking of the sounds, sights, and all around emotion of that morning on Carpathia with the survivors in their state had me crying for a bit there, man. I can only imagine how overwhelming it must have all been.
Thank you for covering this horribly under-covered aspect of the Titanic disaster. Not enough is ever said about the heroes who came to the rescue of the Titanic's passengers.
Thanks for telling us about the story of the Carpathia that night. I always thought that Capt Rostrom and his crews stories were never truly told. You would hear tons about Titanic and the things her crew did or didn't do but the tale would always end with "Carpathia arriving, and rescuing the survivors". You would never really hear about each decision that Rostrom made and I believe that is a sin. The narrator has the perfect voice for telling stories as well. I am truly glad to have found this channel.
Totally gripping episode. I can only imagine how difficult it must have been for all the crew of the Carpathia to process the information they were getting and the scene they witnessed when they arrived at the site of the sinking. Rostron and the men he commanded are under appreciated in the story of Titanic for sure. Great work Mike !
Mr. Brady, I could listen to you tell a fifteen minute story about a kid eating a bowl of raisin bran, and be just as engrossed. You have a gift. Thank you for your dedication.
I've known the story of the Carpathia for many, many years, but you telling had me rooting for them to make it in time. That sir is the essence of EPIC storytelling!!!!!!
The best video of Carpathia's daring dash towards Titanic. So much amazing information and surviving statements in her journey before she raced towards Titanic. Amazingly done, Mike. You really make history come alive again. I salute you!
Rostron and his crew define heroism. Their single- minded determination to rescue the survivors regardless of their own peril, and to make them as physically and emotionally comfortable as possible, puts them among the best human beings that ever lived.
His passengers define heroism too. Captain Rostron initially ordered his passengers to just stay in their cabins to keep them safe, but once they learned about what was really going on, they refused to stay in them any longer and joined the crew in making the Carpathia’s very efficient hospitality preparations for the conduct of the Titanic’s survivors and selflessly gave up their warm clothes, blankets, and even cabins for them while providing as many comforting words for them as they could.
Already knowing how this ends, this still gave me so much anxiety. I couldn't imagine being a crewmember on the Carpathia, anticipating coming up on a sinking Titanic ready to help the survivors, just to get to the coordinates and the ship is nowhere to be found. Absolutely heartbreaking 💔 major props to the Captain though for not hesitating to go after them!! 💛
mike your ability to tell a story is truly unmatched. i love this channel so much. the titanic is a incredibly interesting story but i do wish there was more information/recognition for the carpathia's crew and their truly heroic effort on that night. rest in peace to all the souls lost that night
Honestly one of the most underrated stories in all of maritime history
Most famous ship rescue of all time, I think it's rated very well.
Haha it's like the most famous ever
@@erikheijden9828 I agree, in the sense that within the titanic community she’s very well known. But within the mainstream community not many people know about the hardships about the rescue
Had they received the SOS call earlier it would be an way smaller story, but an better outcome.
Guess radio watches would become an outcome anyway.
As I understand radio was used on warships earlier. Her they are obviously much more critical, having a ship reporting the position of the enemy fleet could easy turn an battle.
@@xergiok2322 because while some people might know her name, her actual story and the risks she took and the heroism of her crew are pretty much unknown to the general public.
"Carpathia will rise to the challenge." I love when, in stories like this, inanimate objects develop a personality. Well done.
Ships always are ascribed one, no matter the occasion. There's a reason we refer to _her_.
Anthropomorphism ftw.
I do too, but I think he was referring to his crew as much as his ship
Titanic
And the thing is, it's not the ships that truly make their stories heroic/tragic...but the people
They should've made a film (theatrical or television) based on the RMS Carpathia and her daring rescue of the Titanic survivors.
Christopher Nolan for me.
that would be a big hit considering its so many layers of the story and the plot they can think 😍😍😍
True
@@johnwalters4792
Cillian Murphy (the Oscar-winning star for *"Oppenheimer")* would make a great Captain Arthur Henry Rostron.
Was about to say this
When Rostron says “We may have to pick up 2000 passengers,” my stomach flipped over.
Bless Carpathia, the little ship that not only could, but did.
She could. She did. And for it, became immortal.
I love this brave little liner beyond words.
Sadly, they didn't pick anywhere near that amount.
@@jayive34 Of the 2240 persons aboard, 1480 died, and 760 survived.
The Carpathia earned big-time recognition for everything
@@jayive34 When the Carpathia arrived at the scene Rostron already sensed "with a sinking heart," according to Walter Lord, that the Titanic was already gone
The one moment in Rostron's story that really sticks with me is that upon getting the news he started organising his men, plotting his course and preparing his ship for a rescue, and THEN asks his wireless operator to confirm and get more details.
That speaks volumes about the man's proactive leadership and decisiveness. He must have been a metaphorical giant of a man.
That's the real seamanship
I had heard the same story, that Captain Rostron heard the news from his radioman & said to Number One, "turn us around", THEN got confirmation from Sparks: if they jam on the brakes and turn around, and the message was wrong, they might lose an hour resuming their previous course, BUT that hour might mean the difference between life & death if they delay in responding.
MAD props to Captain Rostron - bling him RIGHT TF up.
The one that stuck to me was how he did not abandon the survivors once they were on his ship. I mean they had no space for them, and he could have just called the Olympic and offloaded them to Titanic's sister. But the fact that he said it would be too much for them to see Olympic, so I will not let them relive their trauma.
@ispellitjustg Yeah. And his decision to not stay and pull bodies out, further traumatizing the passengers too.
@@PersephoneDaSilva Rostron wasn't just a great seaman he was a great humanitarian.
“Where is Titanic?” “She’s gone….” Must have been so chilling to hear. Great job, Mike! 👍🚢
This although Rostron had already sensed it when he got there
@@fmyoung Yea, he probably knew she was gone as he was dashing to the rescue…
Right I bet up until then they were still holding out hope but once an officer confirmed it they knew
@@MCreedon34 4th Officer Joseph Boxhall was the one who told Cpt Rostron what he had already sensed "with a sinking heart" (Walter Lord), namely that the Titanic was gone.
@@fmyoung I think we are in agreement
Carpathia's part in this historic event deserves it's own time in the limelight.
The efforts of her crew that cold night were nothing short of heroic.
Managing to push the vessel 3 to 4 knots past its designed top speed was testament to their skill and dedication.
The engine designer and the ship's designer must have been proud.
And, as a fact, to get that extra 3 to 4 knots, the engineers had to raise the steam pressure to double of what the boilers can handle.
@@quangtruongle7823 Safety valves would have limited pressure to the design maximum. Some early steam locomotives exploded when their safety valves were screwed down, so it was engineered that no such thing could be done. Would have been the same for ships too.
@@EllieMaes-Grandad Still, boilers aren't designed to withstand that much pressure for long. It's "emergency" speed setting, that supposed to be used only for short bursts of speed, not for many hours in a row. No doubt engineers in boiler rooms were sweating not only because of heat, but because nobody could tell, how long boilers will last being pushed to their limit.
As an HVAC tech, I am also really impressed by the boilers and the men that built them. I've seen boilers crack and burst in normal operation below their nameplate ratings, yet these held up for hours while being overloaded. In Germany, there is a test where you deliberately run boilers to their thermal limits to test the safety switches, and even that is honestly really scary every time you have to do it (every time you touched those switches). Hearing the burner roar, seeing all gauges rising far beyond what is considered acceptable, and just praying that switch actually trips before something bursts or catches fire is probably the scariest part of the job. Normally, old boilers run up to 90°C, with newer ones only going up to 75°C. The limit switches usually trip at 110°C, and you cancel the test at 115 or 120 if it didn't trip yet. If nothing bursts and causes major water damage or you have to put out a fire around the flue pipe. Now imagine doing a similar thing for hours on end, rather than just minutes, and constantly shoveling coal in an already overloaded boiler, knowing it could just leak or burst, releasing tons of boiling hot steam into the same room you are standing in.
It's sort of a mini miracle that the Carpathia's boilers or any other engine part didn't blow apart when going beyond it's limits for so long. I love this little ship like you wouldn't believe!
Shows the quality of the shipyard that built her( john browns of Glasgow)
@@chrisinnes2128 Agreed. They poured their souls into those ships!
On JC movie the scenes they showed w Rostern were very intense w his crew hoping they survived I'm sure😭😭
Oh - beyond its limits, you mean
Well I don't think anything would've blown apart; I think Rostron totally knew what he was doing
The Carpathia and the Île de France are what I think of when I think of ‘hero ships’. Their captains and crew didn’t just do their duty, they went above and beyond to rescue survivors and provide comfort and support to those in need. Carpathia especially set the tone for what an emergency response should look like.
The Carpathia, her captain, and her crew are unsung heroes of this tale. Thank you for highlighting their efforts.
They all did awesome on the Carpathia
Cpt Lord and his officers should've responded the very same way
@@fmyoung Nah! They just stayed in bed!
@@bobjohnson205 Cpt Lord did; he didn't feel like giving up on his nice and toasty warm bunk
The Carpathia is the only thing that went well that night
Catpathia was the right ship in the right place and with the right crew at the right time. God Bless this brave ship and her crew.
SS Californian though... Seemed like the right ship and at the right place, but with the wrong crew and timing unfortunately
@@trustweb99 If only Lord had been of the same kind as Rostron
@@trustweb99to be fair, the California wouldn’t have been able to help even if they tried. Unlike the Carpathia, here engines had been shut off for the night, by the time her engines were hot again, the Titanic would already be long gone
@@trustweb99 The Californian was presided over by a cautious captain and an uninspired watch
The Californian didn’t even know the titanic was sinking because the Marconi operator on titanic scolded the operator on the Californian for sending out signals when the titanic operator was busy, so the Californian operator went to bed.. had he stayed at his station for another half hour, the Californian could have helped the other 1500 passengers that didn’t have life boats, and given them enough time to survive for the Carpathia to reach them and save the rest sitting in the life boats.. the titanic Marconi operator essentially killed 1500 people because he was rude and impatient…
This is easily one of the most gripping and hard-hitting videos on TH-cam (or anywhere else for that matter). Mike, you’ve outdone yourself on this one!! Your penchant for story telling is second to none. I’ve watched it twice now and my hairs are still standing!!
How outstandingly kind of you! Thank you :)
I second that. This must be one of the best Mike's productions (because as his films are now done, we are talking of documentary production levels, not simply your average youtube fan video).
@@msarb Absolutely. These videos are truly great.
Agreed - top job!
"Balls of steel" is how I'd describe the Carpathia's crew.
Absolute damn heroes.
Can't believe Carpathia stayed afloat from the weight of them!
Good job too. Brass balls would have frozen.
@@thing_under_the_stairs I know, right?
I prefer, "Balls That Clank."
This was brilliant Mike. Thank you. After the rescue, Captain Rostrun said " A greater hand than mine steered the ship that night." An amazing man.
I've heard that same thing too
"A Hand other than mine must have been on the helm that night"
Three cheers for Mike!!!
Sad that the Carpathia would be lost during the war a little over 6 years after Titanic.
17 July 1918
I think it's a fitting end. She's known for saving Titanics survivors and she went down saving the lives of her crew. The only fatalities were the 5 firemen killed in the torpedo explosion, it took 3 torpedos to sink her.
Laid to rest with the ship whose passengers she saved.
@@jamie91995 3 Torpedos? That's actually impressive for its size.
@RegalCobra097 yup, 2 torpedos crippled it, but it didn't sink/took too long, so an hour and 45 minutes later the u-boat fired a third torpedo which sank her.
@@yamato6114...and the Titan submersible ❤🤢🤮🤬🤢🤮🤬
Harold Cottam literally helped save hundreds of lives by making that relay message from Cape Cod to Titanic 👏
I always get choked up at this story, how it hasn't been made into a movie yet I'll never know
Hollywood would kill it and make it a damn romantic! This needs to be shown as the fast action rescue operation it was!
we'd need an independent producer; they could do it justice i think @@mikeklinger1712
It was one of the few things the 1996 American TV miniseries did a good job with, and a major part of _A Night to Remember._
The Carpathia's rescue operation is the only thing that went well that night
One thing: that doctor wasnt a 'hungarian speaker', he was a hungarian physician. Named Arpad Lengyel. His epitaph says: ' Ship doctor of the Carpathia, who earned worldwide recognition for his rescue and medical work during the sinking of the Titanic. '
I can't imagine how many frostbitten injuries and gruesome injuries and broken bones he tended to, my goodness. there's another channel on here somewhere that has a video called "the physical toll on Titanic's passengers" or something like that that's very informative. he talks about years of aches and pains and this one woman in particular who said "the titanic is calling" (paraphrased) when hers acted up.
ETA: Legacy Liner is the channel.
This story always brings me to tears. Captain Rostron and the entire crew were true heroes.
They sure did their utmost on that comparatively little ship
They sure outdid themselves
Titanic food 2 class dinner
Captain Arthur Rostron was a hero for putting himself, his ship 'Carpathia', and his entire crew at the disposal of the stricken 'Titanic' that night.
Imagine the condemnation he'd have got, if they too had come to grief on the same treacherous North Atlantic icebergs as 'Titanic', and gone down with many more lives lost. But if the worst had happened, he would still have been a hero, and it would still have been the right decision.
Because that's precisely what made him a hero - he did not know the ultimate outcome for himself, his ship 'Carpathia', and his crew of men. Yet he and his team took the risk regardless, and went to 'Titanic's aid without a backward glance.
As the saying goes: 'No Guts - No Glory!' A fantastic documentary, which brought the historic events of that night - chilling in every sense - dramatically to life. Bravo, a great job by Mike Brady.
"No guts, no glory," except he wasn't in it for the glory. But still a hero with great intestinal fortitude.
The static at the outro was a haunting touch.
Fr
Fantastically done. So many don't acknowledge the danger Carpathia was put in to save those left.
My eyes were totally opened by this video, just astounding effort
@@Lt.Mingus69 The Carpathia's story should be told more often
Good thing Rostron was as thoughtful as to increase the number of lookouts during the dash to the scene
If there was ever a case of 'rising to the occasion', Captain Rostron and his crew (and passengers) are a prime example.
I wish I could say the very same thing about the Californian but no, that ship was, as Walter Lord put it so well, "presided over by a cautious captain and an uninspired watch."
Just prior to the Titanic's loss, my Grandma (who was 16 at the time) crossed from Europe alone on the Carpathia disembarking in New York. As a memento of her journey to the "new country" she saved a copy of the ship's menu, which we still have. How very tragic that just six years after her heroic rescue, the Carpathia became one of the many casualties of WWI thanks to a torpedo fired from a German submarine. This great ship that played such a pivotal role in the history of world events, succumbed to an act of war.
The captain of the Carpathia Arthur Rostron was from my hometown of Bolton, I would pass the house he was born in everyday when I was younger it has a blue plaque on the outside. It makes me quite proud. Bolton was also the birth place of Robert Whitehead who invented the first effective self Propelled torpedo, bit of an irony with Carpathia being sunk by Torpedo in ww1. Not sure why Bolton has such ties with the sea being inland, but there were factories in the town that produced naval guns, naval engines and presently there is a missile manufacturer that produces missiles used by the Royal navy.
And the ship's doctor, Arpad Lengyel is buried in about 10 minutes walk from my place. I just discovered that there was a soccer match held in Budapest, Hungary between the crew of Carpathia, and a better known local team, MTK, and the proceedings went to the orphans of Titanic. Captain Rostron and the mayor of Budapest were also present there.
@@csillagzoltan660 wow a crew that kept on rescuing! 👍
Is that Bolton, Lancashire, UK?
I can only assume it has something to do with Bolton being near and in fact a part of modern day greater Manchester as even if Manchester is no Liverpool in terms of shipping it does have the Manchester ship canal so it's not exactly a stranger to the maritime even if it's inland.
My bitthplace too and also of Captain Lord of Califotnian, one a hero the other vilified.
The competence, care, bravery and forethought of Captain Rostron is nothing short of amazing. Right down to realising the effect seeing Olympic would have on the survivors. That man was the exact right man to be in charge of this relief and rescue effort and it is a true shame there is not more movies, books and tv shows about him and his valiant crew. The world should know his name just as well as they know the name Titanic.
Thank you Mike for this stupendous recount. Your storytelling and clear respect for the people and ships involved in this tale of tragedy and heroism are fantastic as always.
Back then the Best & the Brightest were at the Helm. Hard to find Men of that Ilk today. "Too much Testosterone" for today's Society.
Yes only if Rostron was the captain of the Titanic that night the ship may not have had the collision but only in hindsight.Some of the quick thinking decisions he took was commendable.
Harold Cottam lived until May of 1984 (less than fifteen months before the wreck of Titanic was discovered). Imagine the technological changes he'd seen in his lifetime.
I have a great aunt that is 100 years old. Her mom (my g-grandmother), died at age 94.
She is still extremely sharp, and lives by herself.
I love visiting her. She tells me stories that she heard from her grandmother.
It is crazy how much has changed in such a short time. (Relatively).
My grandfather was one of the child that got to see the Titanic start her maiden voyage in 1912.
He lived until 2013 and I remembered how he told me about how he felt about seeing a Titanic wreckage footage in 1980s when it was discovered.
"We finally meet again." he said.
I've always been fascinated and awed by the nerve, discipline, and bravery of the Carpathia and its crew over the years - it's my favourite ship far surpassing the Titanic. Today, from your comment, I learned that Harold Cottom died in May 1984. Specifically, the 30th of May 1984, which is also the day I was born. Life is just weird that way sometimes.
It's a bit over 15mo actually the wreck was discovered in September .
@@letsdothis9063 You should go tell the Titanic Historical Society
One of my favourite stories. April 15th is my birthday. I never think of it as the day Lincoln died, Hillsborough disaster or the day Titanic sank, but the day the Carpathia rescued the survivors. Carpathia Day. It is the best movie never made.
A day of heroes. Belated best wishes on your latest Carpathia day!
Bro, that just blew my mind! Happy Belated Carpathia Day!
The birthday of a friend of mine is April 14th and April 11th was Jack Phillips's birthday
Them finding out that there was a whole ice field the entire time is a special kind of dread.
Rostron was quoted to say after light came up and he saw the ice field that he sure have not navigated through that maze, Gods hand must have steered all the way.
Now I'm just picturing the Titanic silently sailing full speed past iceberg after iceberg, completely unaware of their presence. How many close calls they might have had that night, before their luck ran out.
@@codboroks97 I was struck by how Titanic's reported location was about 40% of the way through the ice field, but their actual location wasn't very far from the edge of the ice field.
I'm caught between thinking they were dead the moment EJ Smith made the decision to enter the field, that if it wasn't that iceberg it would've been another. Or that the collision was optimally bad -- a second or two of reaction time either way would've led to missing the iceberg completely or to a heavier impact that would've damaged fewer compartments more substantially but within the ship's design parameters.
@@Jesse-qy6ur Probably, since EJ Smith violated main rule about icebergs - you supposed to reduce your speed in case of ice warning. So Titanic was doomed one way or another.
In a way it was luck, that they collided with iceberg so close to the edge of ice field - if they were only a little bit further, rescue would be much harder and Carpathia would suffer same fate.
@ceu160193 well actually quite a misinformation you got there. You see all of the ice warnings were passed carefully to the bridge. And smith heeded them properly.if you want to point out the one which Philips shouted shut up and didn't listen to californian, i support Philips as the day prior Harold and Philips were fixing the broken wireless and got no sleep, Therefore he was quite weary and tired but then as Californian blasted the warning Jack was irritated.And All of this aside back in 1912 the rudders and engines were separate unlike today where ship's propellers are fitted to
Pods. They work differently.In Titanic's (and other ships at the time) case lower speed meant lesser manuerability . Even in old naval textbooks they mention this fact.And also before smith retired to his cabin he checked on everything then approved that they were banking on clear conditions and had perfect visibility.But due to the cold mirage effect
the light was getting thrown off . This led to the crew not noticing until they came closer to the iceberg.Edward John smith was an amazing veteran captain. He did all that he needed to and followed the naval regulations. He had done all he could on the night of sinking But Alas he couldn't save his passengers and survive
Gotta give props to Captain Rostrand. Almost without question, immediately changing course to rescue survivors of a rival company, getting the ship ready, risking his own Passengers, crew, and ship to save as many souls as he could. That is what movies should be made of.
The Carpathia's heroic rush with her captain and crew deserves to be remembered and honored for all time. The fact that they pushed and damaged the ship's engines in their mission of mercy is all you need to know.
May be James Cameroon can do that
Great, moving presentation. It really touched me that Carpathia’s captain realized that bringing the Titanic’s survivors to the Olympic could mean more trauma for them. The same regarding picking up the dead. The Carpartia’s captain proved himself to be a thoughtful, kind man with great insight into the trauma these poor survivors were going through.
When I was a boy, I remember reading about the Titanic, and thinking what it must have been like to wake up at midnight on the Carpathia, and find everything changed from when you went to bed. One part that's never really been covered much was the sailing to NY of the survivors. Small snippets here and there, Ismay medicated in a private cabin, a child reunited with his mom, tons of messages sent. But little else. The grief had to have been soul-crushing on board. Great vid, Mike... thank you!
There's quite a bit about it in _A Night to Remember,_ as well as a lot of personal correspondences from survivors written after the fact-most of them addressed to Margaret Brown, who immediately set to work with Captain Rostron and some of the other First Class ladies organising a relief fund for the widows and orphans just hours after she herself was lifted from Boat 6.
@@DistractedGlobeGuy I remember reading it, the thing that stuck out was how White Star thinking Halifax was going to be the destination hired a private train to transport folks to NYC. The night they arrived, Mrs. Brown, the media feeding frenzy... I know it'd be virtually impossible, but for the steerage folks, maybe some 2nd class, after they got back, what happened to them? Where'd they end up, how'd they get there? First class, obviously we know, and many of the families of the lost crew we do too (White Star messed up there big time, public relation wise)... Just like to follow thru is all. Like, a steerage widow with two kids that was supposed to go to the midwest... did she get there? Did she go on to have a good life? That kind of thing...
At the Chelsea Piers in New York City, the Titanic’s original destination and where The Carpathia docked with the survivors, there are huge blown up photographs of Carpathia’s arrival. If you’re in Manhattan, it’s worth a visit. 18th street on the Hudson River.
@@DistractedGlobeGuythe unsinkable molly brown, love her 🩷
I am 62 years old and have been an ocean liner fan since childhood! I would never have imagined the realistic animation available in this day and age! I love your videos!
One of my favorite stories about Titanic happened on Carpathia. When they arrived in New York, Harold Bride was still in the wireless room sending messages. He didn't notice that Guglielmo Marconi, his employer, had arrived to meet his now-highest-profile worker. After a minute, Marconi took Bride's hand off the telegraph key and said "That's hardly worth sending now, son."
My favorite story from Walter Lord's book: The several Carpathia passengers who snuck out of their cabins, managed to evade stewards told to keep them in their rooms, and were huddled out of sight on the aft deck trying to figure out why there was so much commotion so late at night, and why a "poky little liner" on the Southern route was suddenly barreling through an ice field. "Gradually they realized their ship was not in danger, but no one had any idea why they were on this wild dash through the night." Oh, to have overheard those conversations!
Arthur Roston’s captaincy, situational and organisational skill that night I think are unparalleled in the history of maritime commerce, thank you for a video that finally captures the immensity of Carpathia’s efforts that night
"Carpathia's Run" needs to be the next great Titanic movie: the entire adventure, from the point of view of the rescuing ship.
It was interesting to see a video from the Carpathia's point of view. Captain Rostron and his crew were definitely heroes that night, no doubt about it. They steamed into an ice field that could easily have caused them to suffer the same fate as the Titanic, and were already organizing supplies and a rescue effort even before they knew how many extra passengers they might have. It's tragic that the Titanic had already gone down by the time the Carpathia arrived, and only a relatively small number of survivors were saved, in comparison to the 2000+ plus souls originally on board, but the Carpathia's crew did everything they could to help save as many people as they could, and I've heard that some of the passengers helped to take care of the Titanic survivors, too. IMO, the Carpathia deserves to have a movie of her own, since her story is just as intriguing in its own way as the Titanic. It's a shame that this wonderful boat ended up on the bottom of the North Atlantic herself only six years later!
Great story telling again as always. That's a good point near the end about meeting up with Olympic; from a modern PTSD perspective, that would have been horrific for many of the survivors. I think they made the best possible choice.
Listening to stories like this makes me want to join the coast guard. Hearing how people were able to put their gear aside to help those in need, truly heroic.
Truly humanitarian I call it
make sure you're a good swimmer
This is awesome, Mike . Love the story of the Carpathia . They were all heroes on Carpathia and they deserve to be honoured and remembered .
I’d never heard this story from Carpathia’s perspective before. Honestly, it’s just as exciting as the story from aboard Titanic! This is film material. Without a doubt I would watch this film.
The tasteful telling of this story by Mike Brady about a man of faith who sped through danger to save others, is done so well. Thank you Mike!
What have we as a society done to deserve Mike Brady? The dedication, the class, the charisma, the sartorial acumen. What a top-notch channel.
The CGI filming is not only lifelike dramatic but artistic, too. An aspect of the disaster often overlooked. Captain Rostron was one of those increasingly rare people who knew what he was doing and how to act. I’ve always thought his final reply to Titanic, ‘Tell him we’re coming along as quickly as we can,’ is one of the most poignant in maritime history. I read somewhere that Carpathia eventually worked up to just in excess of 17 knots at times that night.
The 17 knots claim is a myth, it was based on Titanic's incorrect position transmitted during the sinking, which wasn't known to be incorrect until the wreck was found. The real location of the wreck was closer to Carpathia's position when they turned around, so they didn't actually sail as far as they thought in just 3 and a half hours.
@@bungobaggins01 17 knots is probably not a myth, going 3 knots above service speed is not unusual, you wouldn't be able to do it for long but perfectly possible especially when the crew worked as hard as Carpathia's did.
Bungobaggins. Good point. Hadn’t considered that.
@@Alex-cw3rz 3 knots above service speed is unusual for a ship whose maximum speed ever reliably recorded was just over 15 knots. The simple fact of the matter is that the 17 knot calculation is based on the incorrect CQD position, which they didn't know was wrong at the time
And it could very easily have ended in disaster, as they, too, were in a field of ice.
Over 112 years later this story still hits hard! Mike, this animation is outstanding and your story is unparalleled!
Absolutely well done. The Carpathia's brave dash deserves to be told. Her captain and crew were truly heroic.
They were totally capable of handling it
No one can tell a story quite the way Mike can. I'm always enamored of the amount of information and passion you put into your narrations and without a doubt, you are my favourite channel Mike. Thank you from the bottom of my heart for such amazing content. Today is the day (April 18) Carpathia came into dock in New York after picking up Titanic's survivors. I do believe the upload date is a deliberate one.
Those wireless operators were heroes. They worked for the same company contracting to different lines but still chose to go above and beyond.
Everytime Oceanliner Designs uploads a new version of Carpathia's frenzied dash towards Titanic i ciick as soon as i get a notification cause the story is absolutely wild and every time he uploads a new version the ship animations get better and better!
Brilliantly done Mike! Carpathia deserves a movie of her own. The little ship that could
She not only could she did
In Carpatia’s homeport of Rijeka in Croatia I visited the museum dedicated to Titanic and Carpatia. This video tells the story even better.
Very well done sir!
I don't think Rijeka was the Carpathia's homeport I think that's where she was originally going before hearing about the Titanic
Ok, I had to check this. Turns out, I dont know about my country history... So, Carpathia and i think 9 other ships was a liner that brought people from Rijeka to New York. And on April 15, they were on a jurney to Rijeka, with 700 passangers. Apperently, when they came to Rijeka on may 6,they were greeted with a hero welcome
You have a knack of telling a story in such a way that when I close my eyes, I'm there, right in the midst of it.
25:47 Such a chilling shot. Really gives scale of how tiny and fragile the lifeboats looked compared to the ocean and Carpathia. Really brings home how long and scary the wait must have been between Titanic sinking and rescue arriving.
Agree, it's stunning. And 26:34 will be next wallpaper.
Thank you. Rostron and his crew are too often overlooked when the Titanic's story is told. They saved hundreds of lives and that should never be forgotten. Rostron's courage and decisiveness were absolutely exemplary.
The Captain and the Crew of the Carpathia, are without a doubt, the Heroes of the Survivors. The amount of sheer hard slog that they all put in is incredible.
It had also never occurred to me the Options faced by Captain Rostron were horrible in their own right. Wait for the Titanic's Twin and scare already overwrought people, look for Bodies with the same impact and turn and make for New York but that could make the Survivors feel like the Carpathia was abandoning their loved ones.
Thanks again Mike.
I believe the S.S. RMS Californian searched for bodies / survivors on the morning of the 15th , a case of too little too late .
You show such reverence and care with the Carpathia story, and truly honor Rostrom's legacy with these videos. We (and he) are lucky to have you as custodian of this special moment in history. Thanks, Mike!
The story of Titanic cant not be told without the story of the Carpathia. The true maritime heroism for all aboard that night and for the return trip is something remarkable.
Captain Rostron was a true hero....bless his memory. One of the bravest men (and crews) that ever lived!
What a night. Just almost unbelievable. Carpathia and her Captain and Crew went above and beyond. The survivors had to be exhausted and in complete shock. What a story.
Mike, your voice through this one carried a sombre tone of impending doom. I was on edge and the tears welling, just wanting a different result than the one we all knew was coming...the sinking and huge loss of life. This video is captivating and truly dramatic. What heroes the Captain and crew of the Carpathia!
That must've been a Beautiful sight to the Titanic survivors! The Carpathia approaching the scene! Many survivors must have thought "this is it! Our time is up"! A beautiful documentary! Thank You Captain Brady!
This channel is an addiction.
It's not addiction if you're visiting a friend.
VERY MUCH SO
A good one though.
I CAN STOP ANY TIME I WANT TO!!
....I just don't want to.
Until now I only knew that the Carpathia had been the first on the scene and picked up survivors. Thank you for telling this underappreciated facet of the Titanic story and doing so in such a compelling and detailed way.
I was riveted the whole time. Hanging on to every word. Thank you Mike!!
Outstanding video. The Carpathia's crew truly were heroic. Sadly, despite their best efforts, they could not reach Titanic before she sank. Titanic's survivors in shock and grieving were nevertheless well cared for on Carpathia.
The dead radio at the end was absolutely haunting. Incredible storytelling as always, Mike.
Great video! A little addition: the head of the doctors was the Hungarian one during the rescue. (Dr. Árpád Lengyel. The man with the mustache on the right on the officers picture) Cpn. Rostron asked him specifically to led the operation, because he was the only doctor on the ship with actual field ambulance experience. After the Carpathia arrived back to Europe he immediately left the ship and never vent on the sea again. But he and his ancestors kept all the notes, pictures,documents and personal belongings from that night and the items are now displayed on the Ambulance museum in Budapest.
Since I was little boy, I became fascinated by the story of the Titanic.
I would visit our local library - they had a Saturday afternoon group book reading - and the librarian suggested ‘A Night to Remember’ I was hooked.
I would take the book out, several times.
Anyway, your narration of the Carpathia rescue journey was very moving.
Thanks for sharing the story.
Heroes, all. There should absolutely be a PBS TV film covering the Carpathia’s rescue mission.
Mike, this is by far the best video you’ve ever made. Beautifully animated and masterfully narrated. Thank you for providing us such a masterpiece.
A really well given take.
I read Sir George Bissits “of tramps and ladies” nearly 30 years ago. An absolutely brilliant book and it has always put the other titanic productions to shame as clearly no one has ever used or looked at this to produce a proper account of what happened.
It’s very clear that you have and for that I’m very grateful as this shows in your production.
For those that have read it, I throughly recommend it as it gives not only the only real true account by an eyewitness to the rescue but also a grounding on the marine practices of the time.
This for me is very well researched as so many fail to look at this. You’ve got my subscription!
His whole account also talks about the SS Californian ignoring distress flares due to companies wishing to let them off whenever competition was nearby as a show of bravado.
As of many other interesting information which is largely missed by so many so called experts.
I’m glad to see a production where someone clearly has read all of the resource.
I'm fascinated in the story of how Carpathia goes to Titanic's aid as quick as they can and picking the survivors up. I think that could make a good movie of the whole Carpathia crew and rescue.
As the Carpathia started to race towards the disaster scene Rostron being the pious man that he was had raised his cap about 2in and started to pray. Also, before leaving the scene in the morning of the 15th he had everyone assembled for a brief service in memory of those lost and in thanksgiving for those saved. He said after the rescue that a hand other than his must have been on the helm that night
They NEED to make a movie about this ship. Carpathia is a true Hero and her and her crew deserve the recognition and the limelight be casted on them for once. This was absolutely magnificent and poignant. Thank you! I loved it!
I agree with everything you said....except that I really don't trust hollywood or even netflix to cast an accurate and flattering limelight on anything or give anyone their well deserved recognition except themselves.
Can someone tell me why do captains call there ships female
@@lorrietsaoussis5168 I don't know why that is (they do that in Germany too)
I am in awe at this story, but I am so impressed that the captain had the added compassion to think of what seeing the Olympic could do to the survivors. Just amazing the lengths he went through to care for others.
Its funny, im really not interested in ocean liners in general, but i cant get enough of this channel, and of course, my friend, Mike Brady, from Oceanliner Designs.
I prefer Ocean Liners to Cruise Ships.
@@dmw1280 yeah .. cruse liners are kinda just gross
I first became interested in ships when my father and I used to go to the heads of Wellington harbour to watch ships come in such as the Southern Cross, etc. However, my interest increased when I bought a book on the history of the Union Company ships and their voyages. Mike’s channel is at a completely higher level!
Much has been said about Captain Smith's knowledge of ice warnings to be completely accurate for the time. That he was confident and calm knowing full well how to navigate such hazards as was standard in 1912. Yet here is Captain Rostron of Carpathia equally keen but having far greater respect for the ice. In my humble opinion Captain Smith is a scoundrel. He brought about the death of 1517 lives with his stunning arrogance. Captain Rostron is a hero in my book.
Now others will say J Bruce Ismay was the villain and he pushed for more speed.
At least he manned up and went down with his ship.
So he restored some of his honor there regardless of who you blame.
I do place partial blame on Captain Smith, because he was the head of the ship and was responsible for all decisions made. But then I see a series of misfortune that the Titanic encountered beyond his control.
@@Redslayer86 I think Cpt Smith went down with the ship out of guilt and shame. I believe other ship captains around that time said they wouldn't have gone with the ship, and it wasn't required for a captain to go down with his ship. However, I envision that when Smith saw no rescue ship was coming any time soon. And knew people would die, not just a few but many. Then he knew there would be headlines and hearings about how he messed up. His name in infamy, for sinking a state of the art ship that was supposed to be nearly unsinkable on its maiden voyage. Smith probably thought "Oh bloody Hell, I might as well join Titanic in Davy Jones' locker."
Two captains faced with the same conditions, both apparently with experience of navigating near ice. One knows ice will be hard to spot and applies caution and extra lookouts. The other believes the ice will be easy to spot, goes to bed and gives the world a reason to remember Titanic.
The story about the RMS Carpathia, his role during the sinking of the Titanic until the actions and sinking in 1918 is really underrated.
Mike Brady's presentation and narration are utterly mesmerising. He totally brings it all to life. I wonder whether any of those involved in the rescue received commendations/honours. I know that's not what motivated them but it would be interesting to know
I cannot stress enough how much I love this channel. You told Carpathia's heroic story so captivating like I've never heard before. You gave us a glimpse at the emotions that those people must have felt. Titanic's story and how you tell it never seize to astonish me.
Goosebumps hearing this story. What a story❤ What a competent Captain and crew!
And passengers!
The Carpathia's rescue operation is the only thing that went well that night
The thumbnail is just Lovely. It should be a poster for an actual movie about the Carpathia herself, NGL.
I would love a two-parter - 'Carpathia: The mad dash' and 'Carpathia: her last voyage'
My friend Mike Brady told the story vividly and well. I can only imagine the somber mood aboard the vessels that went to comb the area of the sinking, retrieving bodies and flotsam.
Michael, one of your finest productions. Such a chilling and haunting narrative followed by detailed animation by your colleague, Jack Gibson. I often wondered what it was like on the Carpathaia. Her seasoned Captain and loyal crew could not have done more and any other delays en-route could have exposed the survivors to sickness and death. Thank you for this powerful video.
Mike your script and narration for this episode was gripping! The story from aboard The Carpathia is heart racing and heartbreaking. Well done. Cameron could have made Titanic a better film with more history than fiction. The story is so astounding. Well done sir, you had me in tears.
Thinking of the sounds, sights, and all around emotion of that morning on Carpathia with the survivors in their state had me crying for a bit there, man. I can only imagine how overwhelming it must have all been.
Im not a "Titanic buff" by any measure but I do enjoy history. Your channel is absolutely amazing and brings to life another era, Thank You.
Thank you for covering this horribly under-covered aspect of the Titanic disaster. Not enough is ever said about the heroes who came to the rescue of the Titanic's passengers.
Thanks for telling us about the story of the Carpathia that night. I always thought that Capt Rostrom and his crews stories were never truly told. You would hear tons about Titanic and the things her crew did or didn't do but the tale would always end with "Carpathia arriving, and rescuing the survivors". You would never really hear about each decision that Rostrom made and I believe that is a sin.
The narrator has the perfect voice for telling stories as well. I am truly glad to have found this channel.
Our friend Mike Brady is back with another great video! Can’t wait for the premiere!
Totally gripping episode. I can only imagine how difficult it must have been for all the crew of the Carpathia to process the information they were getting and the scene they witnessed when they arrived at the site of the sinking. Rostron and the men he commanded are under appreciated in the story of Titanic for sure. Great work Mike !
Mr. Brady, I could listen to you tell a fifteen minute story about a kid eating a bowl of raisin bran, and be just as engrossed. You have a gift. Thank you for your dedication.
I've known the story of the Carpathia for many, many years, but you telling had me rooting for them to make it in time.
That sir is the essence of EPIC storytelling!!!!!!
A wonderful tribute to a captain and crew acting in the very best tradition of seafaring!
Thank you, friend Brady!
The best video of Carpathia's daring dash towards Titanic. So much amazing information and surviving statements in her journey before she raced towards Titanic. Amazingly done, Mike. You really make history come alive again. I salute you!
Rostron and his crew define heroism. Their single- minded determination to rescue the survivors regardless of their own peril, and to make them as physically and emotionally comfortable as possible, puts them among the best human beings that ever lived.
His passengers define heroism too. Captain Rostron initially ordered his passengers to just stay in their cabins to keep them safe, but once they learned about what was really going on, they refused to stay in them any longer and joined the crew in making the Carpathia’s very efficient hospitality preparations for the conduct of the Titanic’s survivors and selflessly gave up their warm clothes, blankets, and even cabins for them while providing as many comforting words for them as they could.
@@DANIELLE_BREANNA_LACY That's wonderful, thanks for sharing.
What they did was respond promptly and effectively
Would you consider making a video on the sinking of the Carpathia? Or perhaps one about her career? Such a great and heroic ship
Already knowing how this ends, this still gave me so much anxiety. I couldn't imagine being a crewmember on the Carpathia, anticipating coming up on a sinking Titanic ready to help the survivors, just to get to the coordinates and the ship is nowhere to be found. Absolutely heartbreaking 💔 major props to the Captain though for not hesitating to go after them!! 💛
mike your ability to tell a story is truly unmatched. i love this channel so much. the titanic is a incredibly interesting story but i do wish there was more information/recognition for the carpathia's crew and their truly heroic effort on that night. rest in peace to all the souls lost that night