2019 BMW X5 50i vs Tesla Model X // Battle Of The X's
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ส.ค. 2019
- James and Thomas compare the NEW 2019 BMW X5 50i and the Tesla Model X. Both cars are all-wheel drive six-figure SUVs, but with one key difference. One goes vroom.
In an ever-changing market of emerging tech, does the BMW keep up? Exterior and interior styling comparisons help figure out which one takes it in the looks department, and the roads do the rest. Watch to see the outcome.
Thanks to Mr Regular for deciding to visit and feature in our intro!!
/ regularcars
Big thanks to Trev for allowing us to feature his Model X, visit his TH-cam page here! / @teslaownersonline5805
SUBSCRIBE FOR MORE THROTTLE HOUSE
/ @throttlehouse
Instagram!
/ thethrottlehouse
Check out the Throttle House website for lots more content!
thethrottlehouse.com/
Facebook!
/ thomashollandproductions
Music from Epidemicsound.com
#BMW #Tesla #ModelX - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
Throttle House is my NEW motortrend
Samesies
I remember Motortrend...
Is my new old top gear lol
Carwow and this
@@shravdoesstuff yup
That Doctor Strange effect for the Beemer gesture control that you added in is totally badass
And it actually works not just a gimmeck
@@davidlegkodukh6969 Matt from Carwow had a long term loaner 850i from BMW.. He said he actually used it more than the controls on the steering wheel.. So I guess people actually find it useful..
I saw the video pop up, tapped on the notification, heard the voice, tried to think what day of the week it is, and the checked what channel this is.
The Shawn Official you weren’t the only one 😂😂😂😂
Haha!
Did the same thing!!
@@RegularCars yo!
YES! Another TH-cam crossover with one of my favorites!
That RCR intro had me so confused, I had to double check what channel this was
I did the same
Why slam the doors on the x5 if it does have soft closing doors?🤔
Samuel Rogalski old habits die hard
Because it's sounds satisfying af
Yes and I I have an x5 and now hate when people slam the doors in mine, now that I have that option. Just one of those things that once you have it it's in your mind every time, if you're a perfectionist about maintenance / taking care of your sh*t etc. Just don't like my doors slammed
Samuel Rogalski because they’re probably broken. The soft close on my X5 have failed on 3 of the 4 doors in the last 4 years. All fixed under warranty thankfully.
@@Steve-ow7sd yeah but most people dont even know what soft closing doors are. Imagine being in someones car and closing the doors halfway without knowing if it has soft closing.
I absolutely love you guys. You deserve alot more followers than you guys have. You guys are (dare I say) better than motor trend.
The RCR intro was totally unexpected and i loved it! Made me wonder if i had clicked the wrong video.
Perfectly done. Keep doing what you guys do, I will spread the word to all I know
Oh o
Fun fact! BMW is the #1 American car producer for exports $ wise.
They built the X series in the USA and export more $ than any other American car company.
All of the BMW SUVs are designed for China and the US.
@@samthecar Even the ones that are only available in Europe ? X7 is for the US, the chinese have their own L models. Everything else works for the rest of the world.
@@zoyaspencer8025 fuck VW
Fuck China
@@Ramceism fuck hyundai
Love watching you guys review cars. Short and sweet but honest and straight forward.
I feel like I'm getting a dealer tour on a car. Yet am not pressured into thinking any sorta way on either.... Plus no pressure sales and car bias.
Could never own a Tesla because I would ruin the interior very quickly haha but maybe with the dark interior.
I like both though and would have little complaints with either.
Thanks for another great video!
Excellent review of 2 amazing vehicles I could never afford! Which by the way, makes it even more fun to watch!
I love these guys always make me smile! While still giving good informative reviews.
Disclaimer: I really like the BMW brand and I disagree with the complaint which Thomas repeats way too often when he says, “every BMW interior looks the same“, because all of the German luxury brands do this but in those vehicles, it’s looked at as a virtue. Example, when the C-class gets a similar looking and functioning interior as the E or even the S class, its a wonderful thing and The same is true when it happens in a BMW or an Audi.
So all of that said, I have to ask, why was there no mention of the safety rating? Most are probably aware, but it’s worth mentioning given primary function of this category is hauling around the family. Assuming safety would weigh heavily on the decision for most the buyers making this choice, the Tesla offers a massive leap forward in this respect. So much so, that in the event of any serious crash, it would likely be a matter of life or death for at least one member of the family and in some cases, it could be the difference between losing multiple members of your family vs losing none and that is only considering the results of an the actual impact, but the active safety and accident avoidance in Tesla represents another leap forward of almost equal proportion to the aforementioned structural benefit. I’ll leave it there but I think safety has a place in every car review even if it is just a couple minutes at the end for those who want to know.
If you read this far, Thank you for your time and consideration, I offer my humble opinion purely as a little constructive criticism. Lastly, Thank you both for all the great content, I think I have watched and liked virtually every video.
Very important what you mentioned here!
Well that was a great remark 👍
Ah yes a wise one I see
Also I totally agree with all of the things you said as yes for what these cars are, safety is a very important aspect of buying a family hauler.
Yeah but...
I mean the BMW had almost all the autonomous driving stuff too
Great review guys! I loved that you had RCR with you in the intro! I laughed so hard!
I took a cab driving a Model X to come back from a party. It was right after a big snowstorm and there were big banks of snow making climbing in a car a bit complicated. Those gullwing doors were just so convenient that evening.
The intro made me so happy that I chuckled out loud.
Mr. Regular drops the mic every time with his Masters level knowledge.
Had to check that I wasn't watching RCR first. Awesome intro!
LOVE the RCR/throttle house cross over. 2 favourite car channels
Thank you so much for that start, I need that.
I literally threw my headphones when I heard Mr. Regular's voice because I was so surprised
That Mr. Regular intro made me crack up. 😂
OMG, Mr. Regular!
Clicked this video fully knowing what channel it was and then completely forgot when Mr. Regular came on. That was a trip
the comedy, style, script, editing, everything is perfect
Real Car Reviews intro 😅 Made my day.
Regular car reviews ^ you’re welcome
Need to try the new raven refresh. Heard the suspension update made a big difference. And the price in the US is 105k for the full out performance version. And the updated version of the model you have there is $92,400
Wesley Woodard what you said. The Raven isn’t as small an update as people think. Almost everything about the car is better compared to this version they reviewed.
@@stephan9487 Yep. AP HW3, faster MCU (screen).
Raven is the latest version that you can order online?
Jeb Johnston yes. If you order a new S or X right now it will be the updated raven one.
Is there a website (fine if fan made) that shows all revisions/refreshes/updates (hardware and software) with all their improvements for all Tesla Models?
You guys are awesome! I had to check the channel at the beginning to see if it was a Regular Car Reviews video!
Thank you for this very specific comparison.
YES IT IS.
I'm dead. How are you guys going to top this intro?
Throttle house x Doug DeMuro would top this, tbh
OMG! that intro. I'm dead. So good.
You back alive?
Best crossover intro ever!
When I first watched, I almost thought I clicked on the wrong video 😂😂 the RCR intro got me
You will have to remember and watch out as the rear swings out in the BMW at low speeds & full lock.
"It's not what it looks like"
....
"Yes it is" 😂
Great video! Fun to watch!!
🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
I heard Mr.Regular and was like wait check the channel !! And I thought my brain broke .. I love his content and the content you guys put out :)
6:36 That almost went over my head lol
Do one with the new model s and the bmw 5 series or e class
Great review guys
I totally get the conundrum car enthusiast have with electric because of the feel of a nice ICE car. That visceral feel my old AMG E63 wagon was awesome but the loud engine noise amplified by the wagon cabin got a bit warring after 6 months (the newer AMG has a quiet mode). But I had a chance to try a Tesla model X for 2 weeks week and after few days with Auto Pilot 2.0 it was just brought a smile to my face during my commutes. In reality, I’d just get a fun ICE car like my old and sadly sold 1994 300ZX twin turbo and daily drive with kid car seats in some sort of Tesla. Nice video guys!
You guys should test the new Model X Raven model with the new suspension. That thing is super smooth!
Yeah well thanks to Tesla you never know what model x you have
Johannes Raven models have the ”Dual Motor” sticker on the rear instead of old ”Model X 100D”. A red underline means ludicrous unlocked.
Top it off the Raven improves performance to 60 to 2.7 seconds and quarter to 10.9 pretty much the fastest quarter mile you can get in an SUV even faster then the Lamborgini SUV according to DragTimes. DragTimes at first tested the older generation and it was slightly slower by less the a .10 of second now it's like 2/10ths of a second faster.
0:02 the bug 🐜 like it to 😂😂💯
That was the best intro collab in history.
Awesome colab, can't wait for car wow😲
Was that the actual Regular Car Reviews Guy?!
Brandon Knogler yes lol
Yep. I was over at James’ house for a bit while I was in Toronto this past week
I’ve had a Tesla Model X and although it is a very futuristic car, it really wasn’t worth the price I was paying. I got rid of it 2 years in. The handling, suspension and comfort of the seats were not at all worth the price. It’s a cool car to ride in, but would definitely never purchase it again. I can confidently say that Mercedes benz, BMW, Range Rover, Audi, and Porsche SUV’s are definitely better choices.
Thanks for this comment. I am looking for an SUV that would better suit me. I was thinking BMW X6 or Tesla model X. But I was concerned. You have given me a better perspective. Keep in mind i plan traveling to Mexico from Chicago and back.
@@chrisauriazul2203 take a flight ✈️ or train 🚂 bro…
I need Apple carplay!
And a used one for 40k ?
Very helpful as I am considering switching from X5M (E70) to X plaid and knowing these long term impressions are key.
Regular car reviews! I lost it in the intro 😂 I kinda wish he was there for the whole video tho
This channel truly is golden
Here a idea, i have never seen any of these cars being reviewed off-road. It would be appreciated if the throttle house was the first to do so.
Tesla cant handle off-road, just check Tesla Bjørn how it went for him.
TFL just picked up a Telsa X for that purpose I believe.
@@Landoram yep. And towing.
TFL is working on that now!
I can say that I agree with the way the future is going. I’ve had a BMW 3 series, Lexus RX, Infiniti M35 and a 350Z in the household. Loved them all, but still being gas, you have to deal with automatic transmission lag (manual in the 350z), not so instant torque and natural vibrations due to combustion of fuel. Not to mention maintenance costs to make a gas car survive. I have since experienced life with a model 3 and S and oh my goodness I was missing out. No vibration, instant torque, no pesky maintenance (oil, trans fluid, AC condenser, spark plugs, brake pads and rotors, exhaust components rusting) and it drives me to work mostly while saving 90 bucks a month in gas vs charging at home? Game over. Forgot to mention smoking M3s on the road. I can’t still appreciate gas cars but I highly prefer electric.
Electric cars still have brakes / brake pads, and I assume a condenser too for AC
@@edawg792 The condenser still needs to be replaced, but the brakes need to be replaced far less often on an electric car because of regenerative braking, usually not until you break 150,000 miles or more.
None of that maintenance stuff really matters to most ppl bec the majority - at least in USA - lease and get rid of it in 2-3 years.
Tesla have huge quality issues with every car, batteries degrade, they look like shit and teslas need maintenance too. And besides, the maintenance you leave for the workshop, so no need to do messy work on the BMW. Also, when electric cars increase in popularity (yes, people seems to be that stupid) the charging cost will fly through the roof
What an idiot! Teslas too have AC condenser , brakes, rotors etc. and a ton of battery related issues
The intros are amazing
James could use his spare hand to itch because the BMW steers very tight turning angles ;).. And you are listening to Aladdin! Nice review guys, as always, outstanding job!
Wow, Trevor's car on a mission :) The vibration issue on acceleration should have been fixed recently
Was that the best intro yet? Yes. Yes it was.
Subbed because of regular car reviews
thumbs up solely for the "magnets how do they work" reference. James is a juggalo
I'd take the x5 50i but the model x is enticing
That BMW looks great, for sure the X5.
2 seconds in and I recognized that voice. Mr. Regular!!!! You have a new subscriber! Y'all need to get some brown cars. More Mr. Regular please!
Missing light off-road test as the BMW X models have that design feature and I miss the towing comparision for towing campers or loads? What about usable flat bootspace?
The Tesla keeps upping the ante in terms of performance and its really hard to ignore but for me personally, I find the giant screen that does everything to be a bit of an adjustment and prefer a few buttons. I have an X3 and only test driven the Tesla so not sure if that argument really is valid, but i found navigating Tesla's system a bit distracting and lacking the luxury of the BMW
I expected the race
Woah woah wasn't ready for Mr. Regular
What a delightful episode
The x5 is very impressive
The exhaust tips are not fake. They are just surrounds. Nothing like what Audi and MB do.
Yeah I thought it was whack the called them fake, the sq5 now that's fake
I am highly entertained by these intros.
I was so confused when Mr. Regular started talking LOL
BMW 🔥🔥
It’s weird that half of the time they kept talking about the other BMW SUVs even though this is supposed to compare model X and X5
Are you ducking kidding!!!??? TH with Mr. Regular!!!??? Dudes, you guys rule!!!
I haven't seen a crossover this sweet since Iverson
Great video guys!
BMW X7 if I had the money!
But X5 out of these two :)
1969 : We gonna have flying cars by 2010.
2019 : let's talk about Tesla .
I mean they're electric, connected, self driving cars powered by AI
We might have flying taxis, but probably not cars because everyone would basically have to train to be a pilot
Regular Car Reviews!! Yes!!!
so if you have the falcon wing doors open to get in and it is raining, does that mean the rain is going to pour in on your seat or is there someway the rain would be deflected that I cannot see on the video
BMW X5 is the winner! I like to hear and feel the launch of the combustion motor creating Hp over the higher priced plug in buzz box model X.
Top speed- Range - luxury and interior 2 classes above the X I would get the X5.
Nice Video...So Generally...which is quieter in Cabin? Lexus or BMW?
Can’t wait for the X5M
Long term: Tesla Model X - Drives longer mileages, better navigation and technology, and charging cost much less than premium. You'll save a few thousand dollar per year.
Not to mention the resale value after a few years will be significantly more than the BMW because of those reasons. Buying a new Tesla isn’t much different than buying a used one.
If we start speakomg economy then nothind beats a 99 corola for 500 buks
Between the two, I'd take the model x. Now, if you threw in the BMW X5M, the BMW take it 110%.
MaxSpeed It’s coming soon.
There is also an X5 M50i with 530hp.
@@jeandoute9902 trueeee it's a monster as well
@@MaxSpeedMike what about the X5M Vs the Model X P100D? 😂😝
@@zephyrrlt9425 still the X5M for me. Speed is amazing but when you have a lack of speed sensation, no noise, none of the exhilarating sensation that comes with going fast, it's almost numbing.
"A Whole New World by Lea Salonga" Nice!!!
Good information
I’ll take x5
owned 3 x5s, one was an M, thought Bmw for life... now I have a model x. No comparison in my opinion. X5 was the much loved blackberry, model x is the first iPhone. Still love the x5 but will most likely stick to Tesla for the next decade
Ditto. Sold the X3 and will never look back. The Tesla just has better power, better audio, more comfortable, handles extremely well, and needs nearly no maintenance. Hard to choose anything else at this point.
Haha, Tesla plastic cheap build toy..
In Europe, is Tesla big rubbish.
The worst car on the market.
Antonio Calimero if you actually owned or drove one, you wouldn’t think that. Nothing cheap about about it. First versions were a bit wonky due to build quality but that’s not the case anymore. Drive one for a week and go back to a normal car and you’ll see.
@@antoniocalimero1173 I get that it might be the "Cool" and "edgy" thing to hate on Tesla, but i really implore you to have a drive. Take it for a weekend and just drive it. Maybe you might still dislike it but maybe you wont.
Tesla is currently a test product, with too many problems for the price.
Tesla is not a car builder.
It is a $ 25,000 car, selling for $ 100,000.
It is the future, yes .. but cars, not made by tesla.
The future of tesla is probably batteries.
Are you sure you are listening to the engine or is it "enhanced" thru the speakers?
Looking at the dash on the BMW what year is it again? 2003?-2005? I can't tell
Mad that you didn’t consider the auto pilot on Tesla, for me it is a decisive factor
0:02 that bug tho
You guys should test the music systems in those vehicles too as they are high end and expensive and with lots of speakers.
BMW has done cooled cupholders for awhile! My E90 3 series has an air cooled cupholder
BMW X5 any day that V8 engine note is priceless its more fun at lower speeds plus you have more potential to tune up for more horse power.
Just get inside of a model x and you’ll change your mind instantly, this is coming from someone who used to own Italian prancing horses.
Testdrove a X5 and drove a model X yesterday. De Model X comes nowhere near the driving involvement of the X5. Whereas the Model X has some awkward side wing doors and white seats coming out of Star Trek, the X5 is a much better crafted and quality interior to sit in. Sure the model X is electric and goes faster to 60, but that's inherent to EV's. Just as it is inherent to BMW's to provide more involving to drive, go faster on the track and provide better range (less traveling time).
Ok princess
Sounds suspicious
Wtf! the Regular Car Review guy! :D
Mans legit mr.Dixon
Vegan leather? In the 80's we called it skai
Damn too bad the 80s were 40 years ago
Instead of full glass roof, i would rather have solar panels that charges the model X while it is parked under the sun while i am at work
This has been thought of before and you'd only get about three to four miles of range not really worth the price.
Yes but solar panels have come along way especially with micro inverters. Also at least if someone depletes the battery, the solar panel can come to the rescue
You can't get much with that surface. Just calculated, you gain 20miles on Sun in 1day.
Tag on the future proofing of autopilot and upgradeability and I'd pick the model X in addition to being green friendly.
Now that's a crossover