Don't defend yourself about not finding a way for Trixie to win, we all know it's not realistic for her to have won her original season. In my mind, she could've never won because she just wasn't being herself, she toned down everything about herself and that's not winner behaviour. Also just saying I love Trixie to bits so don't get that twisted
100% this comment - there was an interview somewhere (with I think Michelle?) saying the Trixie they got on S7 was not the Trixie they expected from her audition tape. They even made a similar comment about her not showing up in AS3 at first - basically, Trixie is a powerhouse on her own terms, but doesn't fit a competition format (and I ADORE her, but we can all be honest; if Ben hadn't self eliminated, and the top 2 weren't chosen by jury, she wouldn't have won AS3 either for the same reason). And I'm also pretty sure Trixie said in a dragcon panel that her success outside of RPDR, with Unnhhhh specifically, was because she felt comfortable to just be herself and able to do whatever she (and Katya) wanted - which echoes why she didn't smash S7.
I really don't think Trixie could have won even if she did have the confidence to be herself. I don't think any of her looks were that amazing and her makeup skills were just...really not there yet. There's more to drag than looking pretty of course but with how many queens had such strong looks in her season I just don't see her beating them.
So out of curiosity, do you mean it like 1.: "The person who gets named the most gets send home" or 2.: "The two queens who get named the most have to lipsync"?
True, but they only do that to create untucked/ workroom drama. I always hate when the "who should go home..." line comes out because you know it roughly translates as "we need more conflama for the editing"
I mean, I wonder if Allstars 2 were made for Adore and Alaska was the second pick and that’s why a lot of the favoritism was so blatant because they had to scramble to attempt to win.
Well technically All stars one was meant for Sharon Needles to win. Chad wasn’t even in the top 10 for the votes for that season. But Mimi Imfirst was number 7 in the polls which raven couldn’t believe...
Trixie could have won season 7 like this: the producers get her star potential right away and favor her from the get go which leads in her having more confidence and getting to the finale Crystal Methyd style
Ian Guillermo Callejas Pearl was literally shocked that she was saved over Trixie, most people agree that she won the dreaming Lipsync, plus if she wasn’t a returning queen, she wouldn’t have been in the bottom 2 for the dance challenge
Which tbh runways at this point on drag race (besides design challenges) are just about money. The runway is about who can get the best garments made. So if Monét had say $2kish more in her bank she could’ve won
I think that trixie could win like this: She is saved over Pearl in the lipsinc. Then i think she would do well, she could even win the 'comedy, but giving queens throphies for random stuff' episode, if she was a pair with max. Then I think she would win the makeover episode, as she and pearl did in the original season. Then she would be just save, but winning mini-challenges. However, production would need to change the rules for the dancing challenge, so she would not be in the bottom two, or lets just say that trixie and katya are a pair, and they are save/winning the episode. Then i think trixie would have a chance to win season 7. It would be a great scenario of queen with a style that was not shown on the show win.
Season 7 all had a lot of acting challenges which Trixie who studied drama (i think) would be good at. Also she could have the underdog story line of kinda being a “poor queen”, as Trixie herself said she did not have a lot going into season 7. She is also a young quirky queen the production were looking for
I really don't get why he said Trixie's explanation was imposible and then basically re-wrote the entirety of season 10 into a fanfiction to make Monet the winner lol
I don't see how Trixie lost that lipsync to Pearl. That to me is one of the most obvious cases of production intervention in the show. And her losing a lipsync to such a bad lipsyncer meant she would never have a chance of winning a different one.
Fun fact: Peppermint said in an interview that her finale outfit was actually meant for Fighter by Christina Aguilera but production changed the song last minute but she kept the same dress.
I've always kinda wanted an eliminated queen to comeback into the competition and win the season. I just think it would be interesting. It always feels like when a queen comes back into the competition that it's just padding the season out.
Eureka came very close. If Shangela had come in on S4, there might have been a chance. Cynthia was never gonna win while Vanjie was somewhere in between
I think that Trixie would have had a better chance of winning season 7 if she was being herself. She really toned down her makeup in the season and her style wasn't received well by the judges or the other contestants which probably knocked her confidence a lot. I think this was partially due to production wanting a pretty girl winner for season 7 and some of the queens like Jasmine/Kennedy being more closed minded, pageant queens. So I think that if production was not looking for a pretty winner, the queens and judges accepted trixies intense makeup, and trixie didn't tone down her make-up, she would have had a much better shot at winning the crown. 💖
and in the realm of "being herself," I think that if trixie was as funny in her season as she is everywhere else, especially nowadays, she would have at least made it to the finals. part of the problem was that she was labeled the funny queen, but wasn't funny.. i agree with you though.. about the make up/fashion/pretty girl winner. ginger took the funny girl spot in the finale, rightfully so, imo.
She was robbed. They shouldn’t have eliminated her in the lipsync with Pearl and they also shouldn’t have eliminated her in the lipsync with Ginger Minj.
I had heard Sasha’s plan for Stronger was cutting her wig, but I never considered how making the connection to baldness could’ve been badly received by the fans 🤦🏻♂️ I’m glad it didn’t happen and Trinity and Shea got their crowns
8:29 a comet falls onto Earth and mysteriously kills all the season 7 queens after Trixie’s elimination, leaving her as the only cast member left and thus the only possible winner
Okay I know how trixie could’ve won season 7: lets say violet dies during the death becomes her runway, and her final dying wish is that trixie wins the season. ru would then crown trixie on the spot and the rest of the season would be a memorial to violet.
I think there was an even more obvious path to Trinity winning season 9 and that's Eureka not getting hurt, bc since they both were strong queens production would've forced a finale between them.
I think Chad also could've won, if Willam was never disqualified for what she did. The Lip-Sync between Sh*ron and Phi Phi was good, but Phi Phi was better. Sharon would've been eliminated and the top 3 would've been William, Phi Phi and Chad. Willam broke the rules so she lost the crown in that moment. Phi Phi was the villain so Chad was the only one to deserve the crown fairly.
Shea could've won Season 9 if Ru hadn't pulled the "hey so do you want to talk about the fact that your family died recently right before you have to perform and completely shatter your confidence", but you know...
@@elliesunshine6433 u. said recently that now he has no problem with he/his. But calling someone you don't know by they/them is not a mistake of course :)
I remember hearing from somewhere that Peppermint's Lip sync outfit was actually made for fighter by X-Tina. But the song was changed. I think i saw that on one of those fun fact ig-pages
Since they wanted a younger, more relatable fashion queen for season 7, there are three ways I can see Trixie winning 1: she beat Pearl in their lip sync 2: since she said she toned down her aesthetic, maybe if she had amped it up instead she could have been 3: she turned up her personality for the judges and for the camera so that she seemed more relatable and was even more liked by the audience However, if only one of these happened instead of two or three, the likelihood is that at most she’d probably just replace Pearl’s placement
I think that trixie's win would seem legitimate if she at least won 1 lipsync because no matter how much of a fan i am of her. Her win is pretty sketchy and too many variables that could've happened would lead to her not winning
all tea..I honestly think Trixie wouldn't have won AS without that bs jury vote..Trixie also bombed snatch game as Rupaul on AS..That being said, I knew Trixie was going to be the winner when they announced Kennedy as the other Top 2. There is no way Ru or production was gonna give Kennedy the win even though she literally danced circles around Trixie. The only queen who Ru/production would have given the crown to over Trixie was Shangela, but she got screwed by the jury vote. Shangela was another fan favorite unlike Kennedy.
@@kennethbepps i didnt know where i saw this, but bendela was being set up to win and after that the producers didnt know what to do. so they probably imagined trixie as a fan favorite, so they did everything for trixie to win, which includes shangela’s exclusion from the top 2.
I have no problem with Trixie winning, but the way that she did always will leave a bitter taste in my mouth. I think everyone knew Trixie was a lock to win as soon as Shangela was announced as not being in the Top 2..In fact, most assumed it would be Shangela/Trixie for the win once Top 4 was established..Bebe/Kenney didn't have a chance in hell at winning no matter what they did.
I think Trixie has winner potential but definetely did not show it on any of her seasons I think she is a great queen but doesn’t do well in competition format
the only way i could see trixie winning season 7 is if she had formed an alliance like rolaskatox with pearl and violet. they could’ve rode on the “we’re being hated just for being young but we’re actually very talented” and all three of them are very easily marketable as fan favorites so therefore the producers might be less likely to eliminate them. then maybe somehow trixie starts doing better towards the end and pulls off a win? idk
Shea has said that her some of her garments for the finale simply disappeared backstage, she had to found new ones last minute. Can't know if that affected her performance
I'd say an intersting way to give it to Monét is: your changes on Aquaria's storyline, the ball episode and the Eureka favoritism still stand. She not only gets Eureka's win from the panel challenge but also Aquaria's snatch game win (this is a massive hit to Aquaria's track record). Also, because Aquaria in makeovers did the "neglect your partner thing", she lip syncs against Kameron and they get double shantayed. This way Monét goes into the finale with 2 maxi challenge wins (Panel and Snatch game), and only one lip sync (Mayhem), on par with Aquaria and Asia. Becasue Asia has her butterfly situation and in this reality Aquaria only won fashion challenges and is unlikable and Kameron just can't win, it's Monét's season. PS: I think Sasha's "chop off the wig" thing could still have worked. It did for the S11 Britney group. Trinity could have won had she beat Peppermint (which some fans think she did) or been against Shea in the first round and beaten her. Shea could have won had she gone up against Trinity in the first round and beaten her. Sasha always makes the finals but her opponent's better track record takes her out.
how trixie could’ve won: she beats pearl in the dreaming lipsync. like u mentioned, that would propel trixie to do better in the competition for pearl. i think she would win the stand up challenge with max because she’s pretty funny, or at least place high. for ru hollywood stories, i think she would be safe, because her acting chops (or at least in the macbeth and rusical challenge) are better than fame, and kandy. for snatch game, i think she would’ve been safe or low, i don’t know who she would’ve done though because anne frank obviously would not work out. i think max, fame and jaidynn would have done worse than her anyways (max and jaidynn are still lipsynching though with max leaving). for conjoined queens, trixie would win and bring pearl back into the competition, only for pearl to get eliminated the next episode (she’s a returning queen). with fame in the next episode, i think she would end up in the bottom with ginger, and trixie would just be low. however, trixie would win the ball challenge the next episode, and have the most wins of the season (3). the top 4 would be her, violet, kennedy, and ginger. ginger and kennedy have both been in the bottom 2 twice, and trixie has more wins than violet, so trixie wins. *EDIT: Trixie needs to win the ball challenge because then she would have more wins than Violet (who would have 2 at the end of the competition in this storyline) and to the normal fan (not us watching u point out the flaws in the system), it would make sense for Trixie to win*
gioalmighty yeah i know, but in a season where trixie wins, she would have to win that challenge so that there wouldn’t be extreme uproar from the fans
doielovie i thought because of how well she made over people on her youtube channel that she would do well, and i feel like because of how strange the challenge was, she would excel even more (also storyline)
Ok so I tried to quickly imagine Trixie’s season 7 if she wins the lipsync against pearl: -awards challenge: I’m not redoing teams I don’t have time but if she is with max like pearl was she probably wins and would be great storyline to win after bottom 2 -acting challenge: she would probably do very good but depends on her teammate if she’s high or safe -snatch game: there were a lot of bad performances in that snatch game so I can see her being safe or low ig -makeover: brings back pearl and gives her a kind of winning storyline with her -John waters: she is safe like in the actual episode -dancing thing: the judging is done singularly, so she is saved from the bottom and ginger sends home pearl again -ball: I think she can do well enough to not be in the bottom -top 4: Kennedy probably has a better track record but they still eliminate her cause they clearly didn’t care about her At this point she has a very simular track record as pearl on the actual season 7, which is way worse then ginger and Violet so she’s probably still not winning Yeah Trixie doesn’t win. She probably doesn’t win in the top 7 queens leaving scenario because they would probably make max win then
Honestly, Monét could've won snatch game as a double win with aquaria. Her runway wasn't fashionable like Aquarian's, but it was unique and told a story. They let kennedy and ginger have a double for snatch game, so they could've done that too.
2024 here. Honestly, looking back at Season 7, Trixie had at least six girls to beat. But her aesthetic was THERE. Which is why she was a big success after her season. Her makeup was cute and it translated well. We watched her evolve
In my opinion Alaska should have never joined Rolaskatox. She seems on both of her seasons to want to disconnect from the alliance, but she never really did. One of the biggest annoyances of AS2 was her saying she was not part of Rolaskatox yet continued to save Roxxxy week AFTER WEEK!!!
I literally just finished rewatching season 7 with Untucked today so I feel like I'm pretty well placed to theory-craft this. I think Trixie would have at least had a shot at getting to the final if they had decided to give her a true underdog storyline, and also the Prancing Queens episode was judged individually. In that case, Ginger and Pearl would have likely been in the bottom as they objectively got the harshest critiques about their dancing. Trixie thought she would win as an individual, but the critiques during deliberation weren't complimentary enough, and they were loving both Violet and Katya. I think Katya or Violet would still likely win and Kennedy and Trixie would be safe. Let's officially say Katya wins to give Trixie the best shot at the crown (makes sense later). Ginger SHOULD beat Pearl, but there is the storyline possibility of Pearl being given the victory for the whole young vs old storyline, but then again, Trixie still exists as a young queen to take Pearl's place in the storyline. So assuming Ginger wins the lip sync, Trixie should in theory do well in the Hello Kitty challenge as someone who can sew that lives for toys, and could potentially beat Violet for the win, which would get her closer to the other queens. Let's say Trixie wins. Katya and Kennedy are still in the bottom because Katya was the one that psyched herself out in that challenge, so Katya still goes despite coming off a win. In the Born Naked video, having gained confidence from her win, and also being determined to show more of herself after being critiqued in the John Waters challenge, Trixie really hams up the acting parts and does decently well in the dancing segment, as while she is no Kennedy, she is capable of dancing better than Pearl or Ginger. In the closing speeches, Ginger attacks Trixie for having been kicked out before instead of attacking Pearl for being too flazéda, Trixie turns it on its head and says, "Yes I may have been kicked out, but I am the only person here that really knows what it means to lose this opportunity, and I never want that to happen again. I have earned my way back in here - I won last week, and I have consistently delivered since I have been back.". Ru likes the determination Trixie shows and Trixie gets into the final. As before, Ru sends Kennedy home. Going into the final, Ginger is still well in the lead with 3 wins, and Trixie and Violet are equal with 1 win each, which should mean Ginger gets the crown, but Trixie at this point is a fan favourite who has fought her way back after being, in the eyes of the fans, wrongly eliminated, and Ginger is the CLEAR villain after relentlessly shredding Trixie on the main stage in the previous episode. Violet is obviously not winning because Katya and Trixie each took one of her wins in this timeline, and she doesn't have the same fan following that Trixie has. People live for Trixie's Barbie themed country song, and she offers some extremely sassy answers in the Q&A which drive the crowd wild. In the end, Ru decides to give Trixie the win to appease the rabid fan base, and to gag people by having the first winner to have come back into the competition after being kicked out. This scenario ENTIRELY depends on the Prancing Queens episode being judged individually and Ru voting entirely against track record to serve storyline. In the real Season 7, Violet was on even footing with Ginger by the final, so purely based on wins, they both had equal right to win and as such Violet's victory over Ginger is relatively uncontroversial. In the alternate timeline, there would definitely be a lot more debate over the rightful winner of S7 with Trixie vs Ginger than there is irl with Violet vs Ginger. This scenario would have been extremely unlikely, because it would be hard to sell Trixie beating Ginger as legit given Ginger's 3 wins. The only way it really could have worked would have been if Trixie had somehow matched or outperformed Ginger in the John Waters sketch, and then things followed as I described. If they were given a joint win, Trixie would have 2 wins vs Ginger's 3, and if Trixie won outright it would be an even final and Trixie could be given the win without too much complaint, given that she would have won 2 of the 3 challenges she competed in after her return - a very strong "I'm back, bitch!" message, which combined with the young vs old storyline and the fan love for Trixie would have essentially forced Ru to crown her. Ironically, similarly to AS3 Trixie's win partially depends on the other front runners getting knocked out by factors outside of her control. (Unpopular opinion: Trixie deserved the win just as much as Shangela. Excluding Snatch Game, Trixie equalled Shangela in pretty much every challenge, and both actually had extremely similar storylines: both became fan favourites after a short premier run, came back and went out in 6th place, and then used Drag Race as a springboard to build massive mainstream careers before entering AS3. Also, both unintentionally caused friction with other queens due purely to their personalities - Shangela: too loud and confident, Trixie: too dry and clever for her own good, while also being extremely kind and caring people. Shangela was indeed robbed, but by the other queens - not Trixie, and Trixie still deserved the win as she beat Kennedy in the lip sync fair and square.) ===== It has to be said, while I do love Trixie and I do love an underdog storyline, I think it's a good thing this didn't happen, because Violet was a deserved winner who did a lot to push drag acceptance in the fashion world. Also, I feel like we would have missed out on all of the great Trixie and Katya stuff, because they likely wouldn't have been in the situation to start Unhhhh and bond as much because Trixie would have been busy doing solo gigs as a winner, and as a result in some ways I don't know if Trixie would have been as big. Her All Stars 3 run, while controversial, was where she showed off her proper drag instead of her toned down season 7 look, whereas if she had won season 7 with her toned down look, she would have likely kept it because it worked in that timeline. Also, she got three chances in two seasons to get people to know her and love her, plus Unhhhh, which led to The Trixie & Katya Show, which resulted in Moving Parts, while winner Trixie would only get season 7, plus any subsequent solo work.
Wow... I love the level of analysis on this comment... Thanks for all the work making it. I agree with your last statement, I can't imagine a world where Trixie is S7's winner but we don't have the projects she has done
Idea: What if the gymnastics challenge on season 9 never happened, as in the episode Cynthia comes in, she either doesn’t or one of the queens is eliminated for her place in the competition. It semi-favors she-who-shall-not-be-named, but also James and Charlie. Plus it doesn’t push Valentina towards the crown, which would be interesting to watch as a season. I don’t think the season would change drastically, but would have different outcomes for the top 6.
1:55 Let's be honest - if not for the storyline Chad would have won. All of them did great, but Chad had that Rupaul/Bebe aura. I would say, if Phi Phi had chilled out and Sharon wouldn't get as well received (often thanks to be the victim in the conversation - like with Giggly dissing Alaska or PhiPhi meltdown she would have only that alternative title to herself). Also Sharon is an awful person as we learned afterwards, so like - any moment that would resurfice, she would fall into obscurity. 5:15 Also she could have won if Rolaskatox didn't happen. And she would have to mess Jinx up in some other way too, considering Jinx was the underdog who grew so much from episode 1 to finale. Definitely the redemption for Sharon would have helped, assuming that Sharon didn't win All Stars. 7:40 Trixie could have won if meteorite hit the part of the hotel with all the winning queens, too... Unless they would give honorary crown to all of them... Or maybe if there was voting included? Um... Nah Kennedy or Ginger probably would have won that too... 8:25 To be honest I do disagree on that. Top 2 is a win in my eyes. Cause in normal season many of those queens would not even get opportunity to lipsync. Trixie often was the better one on episodes she was in top 2. 9:30 Trinity could have won it if she didn't pick Peppermint. I think like ultimately Sasha would slay first lipsync either way - and due to her mother storyline, she would always win. But bigger chance for Trinity would be to defeat the frontrunner - aka Shea (as Sasha even if in your ranking got a lot of point for being safe, ultimately had only two shared wins and was deemed as slightly better than Peppermint). So imagine that Trinity gets So Emotional against Shea, which was a really good chance for her to win, considering that Trinity as showed on AS4 could sing emotional songs as well as other songs. And Shea was not fully feeling it and her outfit fit Stronger more. Then of course let Sasha and Peppermint ls Stronger. Either way Sasha with her scizzor reveal wouldn't be as impactful as roses she prepared for Whitney. And her winning against Peppermint wouldn't mean as much as winning against frontrunner. Which would put Trinity on better track. All of it would really fall to what Trinity prepared for the final lipsync, but I feel like considering she would have better track record and just have beaten Shea - she would get the crown. 10:45 Oh yeah the breakdown - that would put Sasha in Asia's butterflies position. 11:05 Or Trinity would get double win... For messing up a cartwheel. But then again it was just after Bob's win so prejudice against having a white winner wouldn't be as much of an issue yet.
these queens should have won all stars: as1 - Raven as2 - katya / detox as3 - shangela / dela as4 - Trinity (if double crowning trinity/Monique ((if manila wasn't eliminated she would've won lol)) as5 - Miz Cracker (i'm not mad at shea winning tho)
Hey, I wanna tell you something. I was rewatching S5 on Netflix and in the makeover challenge, during some point in the judges deliberations, the thing in the corner where the text is when Ru says a hashtag appears with no text repeatedly until let’s say the lip sync. So if you could do a video on that and other errors that would be great. Not sure if you have down it tho (Also I clarified on Netflix cuz not sure if that happens when the episode aired)
I think there's another way Chad could have won season 4: If Willam had not been disqualified. That episode Phi Phi and Sharon were the bottom two and one of them would have gone home, thus ending that storyline of hero vs villain.
Trixie could've won the lip sync over Pearl, done good in Snatch game, reverse storyline with Pearl in makeover challenge, same performance in John Waters challenge, the rules in top 6 was her fate sealed tho. If her dance styles were different she could've performed better. Plus if they didn't judge in pairs. She could've won if they liked her more that's it.
What i am asking myself is. In Season 8 the Queens did that Photoshoot with the past winners. Everyone is there. Except the other All stars winners. Only Chad. Is it because the other All stars season haven' t aired back then or why didnt they show up
I think the closest we could have come is if she had beat pearl. Then she would have partnered with Max, and as Max won and Trixie is a comedy queen, she would have then won that challenge. Let's say she still bombed snatch game, I think it would have been a story to have Trixie Vs Max as they won the last challenge together. The producers set Max up as going crazy, so Trixie wins the lipsync for their story. Trixie and Pearl still do the makeover challenge together, but as Trixie is the original queen who remained, she gets the credit for that win instead. Violet wouldn't have called her out in the John Waters challenge, and I don't think they would have been as harsh that week, so she is still safe. Then in the dance they didn't judge as a group thing, maybe someone else would have taken her spot in the bottom. Then in the ball she would have either been in the top two or won the challenge (not to take away from Violets amazing outfit, but Trixie is a comedy queen who models herself after a toy, and she sews, so it isn't too far out of the realm of possibility that she is high or wins). Next challenge is tothe music video. Trixie sings, writes her own music and can pick up a choreo. Then Pearl has the worst track record of the top 4 is she is still there, and Trixie is in the top 3. If Pearl was the one who left instead of Trixie in the dance challenge though, Trixie in this has a comparable track record to Kennedy, but Kennedy was in the bottom the week before which would have been fresh on their minds, while Trixie was high/won the week before being fresh in their minds, so Trixie still makes top three instead. Trixie was a fan favourite, so Ru would give her the crown over the two girls (Ginger and Violet) for who their narrative was that they were kinda bitchy and not super liked yet.
Willam said on race chaser that during the episode where Willam was disqualified and Sharon and Phi Phi were in the bottom that the judges would've set Sharon home thus handing the win to Chad
AS6: If Kylie was allowed to be herself and in the top Ep 1 and had a better snatch game she might do good enough to beat Tyra. AS8: If they treated Jimbo right on Canada season 1 AS9: If they got rid of Willow in that lip sync.
I don't remember where I heard or read that, but the producers had told the girls to prepare big reveals for the whole lip-sync for the crown conflama so that they could sell the new format and Shea had a problem with her luggage and had been left without her big reveal a day or two before the finale. So she would win if she had access to her intended outifit I guess
But Sasha’s reveal was the reveal of all reveals. Even now, no one has topped it since. Whenever a wig was removed, there’s always some reference to Sasha either at the confessionals or in the comments section.
I don't get how anyone can argue the fact that Monét won only to appease the overly PC crowd that wanted a queen of color crowned. The fans on Reddit seem to think that not only is that false, but that Monét deserved a solo win.
@@aldricmartinez-olson7509 I think Monique deserved it much, much more than Monét flopped in the variety show, Jersey Justice, and Sex and the Kitty Girl.
i've heard wow only congratulated Monet on their socials, deleted it, then posted something congratulating both. i think thats why most people say monet was the intended winner of the season.
What if Monique know the words in her elimination lipsync against The Vixen on Season 10 ? I really think that maybe Monique could overperform The Vixen and continue in the competition
I think Trixie could’ve won her season if she had the Jinkx storyline and was played off as the underdog. She also could’ve gotten a few wins (2 or 3) with jinkx’s underdog storyline
ok but the way monet coulda won is if aquaria was in the bottom instead of her in the makeover. she does still lipsync in the ball and improve challenge episodes. she wins as a group alongside eureka and Kameron the next challenge, wins snatch game instead of aquaria, then she wins the acting challenge and cher the rusical. so she ends with 4 wins and 2 bottoms, eureka 2 wins two bottoms, aquaria 2 wins and 1 bottom, and asia 1 win and 1 bottom.
I think that Trixie could POSSIBLY have won if in episode four they kept her over Pearl. Trixie isn’t terrible at comedy challenges and could win the DESPY awards, playing on the, ‘in the bottom one episode, winning the next’ storyline. In snatch game she would either be low, or in the bottom with Max, and production wouldn’t have kept Max regardless of who was in the bottom with her, though Trixie would then have two bottom two placements and be significantly less likely to win. She wins the conjoined twin episodes with Pearl same as before. After that, depending on where production would want to go, I think she would be high or safe for the rest of the season. Possibly winning the ball challenge. (She was in the top two for the AS3 ball so it’s possible). For the dance challenge they would either change the format or Trixie would have a new partner. If they changed the format she could win? Maybe? She seemed awfully confident in Untucked, so maybe the production would want to show her as talented and that the other queens shouldn’t have doubted her talents. It’s a stretch, but maybe. She would have two to four wins and have lip-synced once or twice. Not terrible statistics for a winner especially since every other placement is safe or high.
I think it would be interesting to do a video on the favoritism of Asia and The Vixen on season 10. (Not hate obviously because I really like Asia) But there were four challenges where Asia and The Vixen should have been bottom two and it only happened once and I think it’s kinda crazy that nobody talks about it
My opinions..... 1. Chad Michaels, if William didn't "break the rules", and if Phi Phi didn't take her wig off during the lip sync, Rupaul could eliminate Sharon, and Chad would easily won. 2. Alaska, if the judges favored Alaska and give Coco's win to her, and that Roxxxy didn't bully Jinkx so Jinkx didn't have the story line, Alaska would have three wins while never landed in the bottom 2, then Alaska could win. 3. Trixie, if she was never eliminated, and Violet and Ginger was dead or disqualified before finale. 4. Trinity the Tuck, aka Trinity Taylor, if she outshined Peppermint and Sasha during her lip sync. 5. Monet X Change, if she was never eliminated, won the finale lip sync against Asia due to butterflies incidents, and that Aquaria and Eureka was dead or disqualified before finale. 6. Shea Coulee, if there weren't lip sync for the crown format, and they crowned winner by statistics.
Because they basically were trying to force the queens to talk in live television about very personal stuff that they should not be forced to, shaming the queens that “didn’t show that much of their bad side in the evil twin”.
Tricks said she changed her makeup style for season 7 because she wanted to win. If she did her normal style and had a few better outfits I think she would have done better on season 7, but honestly I still don’t think she would have won
I love Trixie but she wasn't there yet in S7. I do think she should have won over Pearl in her 1st elimination but even so, I don't think she would have lasted that much longer. I haven't seen AS3 yet (I just started watching Drag Race this past month) but becoming a fan of hers and Katya before I even watched any Drag Race kind of made me realize some of the queens' talents don't really shine through in the particular DR format...
I think trixxie (maybe) could have won or at least make it to the top 3, could be if in the dancing challenge chapter, they're judged individually, so Ginger Minj and Violet Chachki (f.y.i. that's the way it should been). And maybe Violet lose and she doesn't win. ALSO, the next challenge is the hello kitty challenge, and I think that it's a very good challenge for Trixie (for obvious reasons)
Alaska could have won season 5 if that season would’ve had the lip sync for your legacy format, like that seen in All Stars 2, 3, and 4. In the top 4 episode, the top 2 would be Alaska and Roxxxy. If the lip sync song is still changed to Malambo No. 1 (in this case presumably to assure that Alaska’s track record is superior to Roxxxy’s), Alaska would clearly win the lip sync and (unfortunately) eliminate Jinkx. She may eliminate Detox, but I think it’s less likely. If the song isn’t changed, it would more likely be Roxxxy that eliminates her. Either way, Rolaskatox is the top 3, and thus Alaska wins as the most likable member and the one with the strongest storyline. This would also mean that AS2 would probably be made for Jinkx to win.
Although the concept is interesting, Jinx would have been in the top 2 5/6 times, she would have been able to send Roxxxy home in the Roast, Detox in the SG and kinda even Alaska in the Make over. The fact that Jknx was over them and she was in the top almost the entirety of the season makes it kinda inevitable that she doesn’t at least send 2 of them home.
How could u. be the best possible youtuber? Oh wait that's already true 😍😍 Ps. I hope you can watch Canada's DR in the future! The cast is way better than DRUK imo.
What if Manila had teleported us to Mars?
We’d all die by oxygen deprivation and manila by process of elimination of everyone including the judges wins all stars 1
This is the only question that matters.
lol
What if Rupaul, Merle and Santino had been out there walking children in nature?
HUH HUH
...no...no ending...nothing
shea wins if she hides sasha's petals
sasha takes her wig off and it's just empty air
Or if she put a shit ton of wig glue on the wig without Sasha knowing, and when Sasha pulls it off she peels off her scalp instead.
This caught me off gUArD
If shea did a grand-er reveal....would she have won
Shea wins: no lip sync for the crown 😂
@@knino7763 would’ve been a gag for sure
Don't defend yourself about not finding a way for Trixie to win, we all know it's not realistic for her to have won her original season. In my mind, she could've never won because she just wasn't being herself, she toned down everything about herself and that's not winner behaviour.
Also just saying I love Trixie to bits so don't get that twisted
Completely agree! As3 she was completely being herself
I agree I love Trixie but she just wasn’t Herself in her Season
I think that she could have won with the right motivation
100% this comment - there was an interview somewhere (with I think Michelle?) saying the Trixie they got on S7 was not the Trixie they expected from her audition tape. They even made a similar comment about her not showing up in AS3 at first - basically, Trixie is a powerhouse on her own terms, but doesn't fit a competition format (and I ADORE her, but we can all be honest; if Ben hadn't self eliminated, and the top 2 weren't chosen by jury, she wouldn't have won AS3 either for the same reason).
And I'm also pretty sure Trixie said in a dragcon panel that her success outside of RPDR, with Unnhhhh specifically, was because she felt comfortable to just be herself and able to do whatever she (and Katya) wanted - which echoes why she didn't smash S7.
I really don't think Trixie could have won even if she did have the confidence to be herself. I don't think any of her looks were that amazing and her makeup skills were just...really not there yet. There's more to drag than looking pretty of course but with how many queens had such strong looks in her season I just don't see her beating them.
What if RuPaul really listened to "who should go home tonight, and why?". Because he maybe did twice, or three times.
So out of curiosity, do you mean it like 1.: "The person who gets named the most gets send home" or 2.: "The two queens who get named the most have to lipsync"?
True, but they only do that to create untucked/ workroom drama. I always hate when the "who should go home..." line comes out because you know it roughly translates as "we need more conflama for the editing"
Tbh most Allstars winners are kinda meant to win. Like they made Allstars so Chad could win 😅 basically fan favorites
You know what they say "Chad is about to die so Ru probably wanted him to be happy"
😂what did that Chad Michael's bit come from, because I always hear that about Chad, but Chad stills looks the same from her season.
I mean, I wonder if Allstars 2 were made for Adore and Alaska was the second pick and that’s why a lot of the favoritism was so blatant because they had to scramble to attempt to win.
Well technically All stars one was meant for Sharon Needles to win. Chad wasn’t even in the top 10 for the votes for that season.
But Mimi Imfirst was number 7 in the polls which raven couldn’t believe...
@@kennethbepps It's from a video of Drag queens reading mean comments, but you can just look for CHAD ABOUT TO DIE here on TH-cam.
Trixie could have won season 7 like this: the producers get her star potential right away and favor her from the get go which leads in her having more confidence and getting to the finale Crystal Methyd style
same thing should’ve happened with katya
@@onekissallittakes8536 May the best woman win
Trixie would have still lost like Crystal Methyd as I see her not doing well like the others in the final number.
@@kennethbepps I think Trixie could win challenges if she's confident enough but yeah you're right
Ian Guillermo Callejas Pearl was literally shocked that she was saved over Trixie, most people agree that she won the dreaming Lipsync, plus if she wasn’t a returning queen, she wouldn’t have been in the bottom 2 for the dance challenge
a monet and kameron double shantay and then their rematch at the finale.... I can only dream.
@Anna O' Sullivan
This could happen
Monet win breastworld
Kameron win the lipsync and eureka go home
Monet was placed high 4 weeks in a row but lost each time cause of her runways. She prob could’ve won if she had better looks
So you are saying that Monet should've been on S13
@@damp8277 no?
@@damp8277 how people can't get the shade here hahahah
She should have won snatch game.
@@damp8277 omfg bdjekqnsk
Monet couldve won about 2 challenges if her runways were better on s10
AT LEAST! She did really well but the runways got her!
truly, the cher challenge and breastworld she could've won if not for her runway, and possibly even snatch game too
Her Snatch Game was also amazing! Maya Angelou ain’t no pink bitch
not really, just taking in consideration the challenge alone (as 98% of the times), Monét was never the very best on each episode.
Which tbh runways at this point on drag race (besides design challenges) are just about money. The runway is about who can get the best garments made. So if Monét had say $2kish more in her bank she could’ve won
Considering what they were looking for in Season 7, Trixie could have won if she was skinnier and had a better eye for fashion.
I have to laugh, but you're not wrong, sadly.
you cant take trixie away from those grant africa shaped pads
@@ErykhGoomakeep or as Latrice calls it The Homeland
Ginger had a strong chance of winning so ...
@@marcusmelancon3426 the fact that she had such a strong chance and didn't win is proof that she was never going to win.
I think that trixie could win like this: She is saved over Pearl in the lipsinc. Then i think she would do well, she could even win the 'comedy, but giving queens throphies for random stuff' episode, if she was a pair with max. Then I think she would win the makeover episode, as she and pearl did in the original season. Then she would be just save, but winning mini-challenges. However, production would need to change the rules for the dancing challenge, so she would not be in the bottom two, or lets just say that trixie and katya are a pair, and they are save/winning the episode. Then i think trixie would have a chance to win season 7. It would be a great scenario of queen with a style that was not shown on the show win.
Season 7 all had a lot of acting challenges which Trixie who studied drama (i think) would be good at. Also she could have the underdog story line of kinda being a “poor queen”, as Trixie herself said she did not have a lot going into season 7. She is also a young quirky queen the production were looking for
I think Trixie could even be a threat on Snatch Game! Mostly because she would have done Dolly and Ru loves Dolly I think as much as he loves Liza
I really don't get why he said Trixie's explanation was imposible and then basically re-wrote the entirety of season 10 into a fanfiction to make Monet the winner lol
I don't see how Trixie lost that lipsync to Pearl. That to me is one of the most obvious cases of production intervention in the show. And her losing a lipsync to such a bad lipsyncer meant she would never have a chance of winning a different one.
@@josep.alvarez2526 me too, Monet could never win season 10
Fun fact: Peppermint said in an interview that her finale outfit was actually meant for Fighter by Christina Aguilera but production changed the song last minute but she kept the same dress.
I've always kinda wanted an eliminated queen to comeback into the competition and win the season. I just think it would be interesting. It always feels like when a queen comes back into the competition that it's just padding the season out.
Eureka came very close. If Shangela had come in on S4, there might have been a chance. Cynthia was never gonna win while Vanjie was somewhere in between
I think that Trixie would have had a better chance of winning season 7 if she was being herself. She really toned down her makeup in the season and her style wasn't received well by the judges or the other contestants which probably knocked her confidence a lot. I think this was partially due to production wanting a pretty girl winner for season 7 and some of the queens like Jasmine/Kennedy being more closed minded, pageant queens. So I think that if production was not looking for a pretty winner, the queens and judges accepted trixies intense makeup, and trixie didn't tone down her make-up, she would have had a much better shot at winning the crown. 💖
and in the realm of "being herself," I think that if trixie was as funny in her season as she is everywhere else, especially nowadays, she would have at least made it to the finals. part of the problem was that she was labeled the funny queen, but wasn't funny.. i agree with you though.. about the make up/fashion/pretty girl winner. ginger took the funny girl spot in the finale, rightfully so, imo.
She was robbed. They shouldn’t have eliminated her in the lipsync with Pearl and they also shouldn’t have eliminated her in the lipsync with Ginger Minj.
I had heard Sasha’s plan for Stronger was cutting her wig, but I never considered how making the connection to baldness could’ve been badly received by the fans 🤦🏻♂️ I’m glad it didn’t happen and Trinity and Shea got their crowns
8:29 a comet falls onto Earth and mysteriously kills all the season 7 queens after Trixie’s elimination, leaving her as the only cast member left and thus the only possible winner
Okay I know how trixie could’ve won season 7: lets say violet dies during the death becomes her runway, and her final dying wish is that trixie wins the season. ru would then crown trixie on the spot and the rest of the season would be a memorial to violet.
I think there was an even more obvious path to Trinity winning season 9 and that's Eureka not getting hurt, bc since they both were strong queens production would've forced a finale between them.
if monet had stronger runways in season 10 i think she could’ve made final 4
I think Chad also could've won, if Willam was never disqualified for what she did. The Lip-Sync between Sh*ron and Phi Phi was good, but Phi Phi was better. Sharon would've been eliminated and the top 3 would've been William, Phi Phi and Chad. Willam broke the rules so she lost the crown in that moment. Phi Phi was the villain so Chad was the only one to deserve the crown fairly.
Shea could've won Season 9 if Ru hadn't pulled the "hey so do you want to talk about the fact that your family died recently right before you have to perform and completely shatter your confidence", but you know...
u is just feeding us this month with their content
U. Is helping me get through school
His content
Lana Del Gay they’ve mentioned before that they go by they/them, if they comment and correct the pronouns, i will change it
@@elliesunshine6433 u. said recently that now he has no problem with he/his. But calling someone you don't know by they/them is not a mistake of course :)
Ravy yup I remember him saying this as well. But he’s okay with any of the above pronouns:)
What if all judges would determine winner with eurovision scoring system.
What if AS3 final format would have been in other seasons.
I remember hearing from somewhere that Peppermint's Lip sync outfit was actually made for fighter by X-Tina. But the song was changed. I think i saw that on one of those fun fact ig-pages
Since they wanted a younger, more relatable fashion queen for season 7, there are three ways I can see Trixie winning
1: she beat Pearl in their lip sync
2: since she said she toned down her aesthetic, maybe if she had amped it up instead she could have been
3: she turned up her personality for the judges and for the camera so that she seemed more relatable and was even more liked by the audience
However, if only one of these happened instead of two or three, the likelihood is that at most she’d probably just replace Pearl’s placement
I think that trixie's win would seem legitimate if she at least won 1 lipsync because no matter how much of a fan i am of her. Her win is pretty sketchy and too many variables that could've happened would lead to her not winning
all tea..I honestly think Trixie wouldn't have won AS without that bs jury vote..Trixie also bombed snatch game as Rupaul on AS..That being said, I knew Trixie was going to be the winner when they announced Kennedy as the other Top 2. There is no way Ru or production was gonna give Kennedy the win even though she literally danced circles around Trixie. The only queen who Ru/production would have given the crown to over Trixie was Shangela, but she got screwed by the jury vote. Shangela was another fan favorite unlike Kennedy.
@@kennethbepps i didnt know where i saw this, but bendela was being set up to win and after that the producers didnt know what to do. so they probably imagined trixie as a fan favorite, so they did everything for trixie to win, which includes shangela’s exclusion from the top 2.
I have no problem with Trixie winning, but the way that she did always will leave a bitter taste in my mouth. I think everyone knew Trixie was a lock to win as soon as Shangela was announced as not being in the Top 2..In fact, most assumed it would be Shangela/Trixie for the win once Top 4 was established..Bebe/Kenney didn't have a chance in hell at winning no matter what they did.
I think Trixie has winner potential but definetely did not show it on any of her seasons I think she is a great queen but doesn’t do well in competition format
shea win was strange, and alaska and Monet, anyways, trinity was the only winner that "deserved"
vi la notificación y vine corriendo, nunca había llegado tan temprano JAJA
siempre me alegras el día ;; muchas gracias U.
the only way i could see trixie winning season 7 is if she had formed an alliance like rolaskatox with pearl and violet. they could’ve rode on the “we’re being hated just for being young but we’re actually very talented” and all three of them are very easily marketable as fan favorites so therefore the producers might be less likely to eliminate them. then maybe somehow trixie starts doing better towards the end and pulls off a win? idk
Shea has said that her some of her garments for the finale simply disappeared backstage, she had to found new ones last minute. Can't know if that affected her performance
I'd say an intersting way to give it to Monét is: your changes on Aquaria's storyline, the ball episode and the Eureka favoritism still stand. She not only gets Eureka's win from the panel challenge but also Aquaria's snatch game win (this is a massive hit to Aquaria's track record). Also, because Aquaria in makeovers did the "neglect your partner thing", she lip syncs against Kameron and they get double shantayed. This way Monét goes into the finale with 2 maxi challenge wins (Panel and Snatch game), and only one lip sync (Mayhem), on par with Aquaria and Asia. Becasue Asia has her butterfly situation and in this reality Aquaria only won fashion challenges and is unlikable and Kameron just can't win, it's Monét's season.
PS: I think Sasha's "chop off the wig" thing could still have worked. It did for the S11 Britney group. Trinity could have won had she beat Peppermint (which some fans think she did) or been against Shea in the first round and beaten her. Shea could have won had she gone up against Trinity in the first round and beaten her. Sasha always makes the finals but her opponent's better track record takes her out.
how trixie could’ve won: she beats pearl in the dreaming lipsync. like u mentioned, that would propel trixie to do better in the competition for pearl. i think she would win the stand up challenge with max because she’s pretty funny, or at least place high. for ru hollywood stories, i think she would be safe, because her acting chops (or at least in the macbeth and rusical challenge) are better than fame, and kandy. for snatch game, i think she would’ve been safe or low, i don’t know who she would’ve done though because anne frank obviously would not work out. i think max, fame and jaidynn would have done worse than her anyways (max and jaidynn are still lipsynching though with max leaving). for conjoined queens, trixie would win and bring pearl back into the competition, only for pearl to get eliminated the next episode (she’s a returning queen). with fame in the next episode, i think she would end up in the bottom with ginger, and trixie would just be low. however, trixie would win the ball challenge the next episode, and have the most wins of the season (3). the top 4 would be her, violet, kennedy, and ginger. ginger and kennedy have both been in the bottom 2 twice, and trixie has more wins than violet, so trixie wins. *EDIT: Trixie needs to win the ball challenge because then she would have more wins than Violet (who would have 2 at the end of the competition in this storyline) and to the normal fan (not us watching u point out the flaws in the system), it would make sense for Trixie to win*
i agreed until the end 💀 trixie would NOT beat violet in the hello kitty ball. love her tho
gioalmighty yeah i know, but in a season where trixie wins, she would have to win that challenge so that there wouldn’t be extreme uproar from the fans
@@gio-ci1pz Looove Violet's Hello Kitty look but on the other hand Trixie is the impersonation of PINK. I could see either of them winning :D
im not confident about trixie bringing pearl back in the conjoined twin challenge💀
doielovie i thought because of how well she made over people on her youtube channel that she would do well, and i feel like because of how strange the challenge was, she would excel even more (also storyline)
Such a smart twist! Love your work a lot.
The thought of having Monet and Kameron doing the Final Final lip-sync is too powerful
We'd all die on the spot
I love your videos because they're all so realistic and unbiased !!!
The Season 10 revamped timeline is... cursed.
Kameron and Monét being top two?! That would’ve had the whole fandom upset lol
Monét's wins aren't that far of a reach
They’re really not a reach at all. If she had better runways I think she would have easily been in the finale!
So many winners from season 9, we are just missing peppermint for the top four to be winners lol
Ok so I tried to quickly imagine Trixie’s season 7 if she wins the lipsync against pearl:
-awards challenge: I’m not redoing teams I don’t have time but if she is with max like pearl was she probably wins and would be great storyline to win after bottom 2
-acting challenge: she would probably do very good but depends on her teammate if she’s high or safe
-snatch game: there were a lot of bad performances in that snatch game so I can see her being safe or low ig
-makeover: brings back pearl and gives her a kind of winning storyline with her
-John waters: she is safe like in the actual episode
-dancing thing: the judging is done singularly, so she is saved from the bottom and ginger sends home pearl again
-ball: I think she can do well enough to not be in the bottom
-top 4: Kennedy probably has a better track record but they still eliminate her cause they clearly didn’t care about her
At this point she has a very simular track record as pearl on the actual season 7, which is way worse then ginger and Violet so she’s probably still not winning
Yeah Trixie doesn’t win. She probably doesn’t win in the top 7 queens leaving scenario because they would probably make max win then
Honestly, Monét could've won snatch game as a double win with aquaria. Her runway wasn't fashionable like Aquarian's, but it was unique and told a story. They let kennedy and ginger have a double for snatch game, so they could've done that too.
Honestly I think that if season 9 was normal finale format then it would have been a double win between Sasha and Shea.
2024 here. Honestly, looking back at Season 7, Trixie had at least six girls to beat. But her aesthetic was THERE. Which is why she was a big success after her season. Her makeup was cute and it translated well. We watched her evolve
In my opinion Alaska should have never joined Rolaskatox. She seems on both of her seasons to want to disconnect from the alliance, but she never really did. One of the biggest annoyances of AS2 was her saying she was not part of Rolaskatox yet continued to save Roxxxy week AFTER WEEK!!!
I literally just finished rewatching season 7 with Untucked today so I feel like I'm pretty well placed to theory-craft this.
I think Trixie would have at least had a shot at getting to the final if they had decided to give her a true underdog storyline, and also the Prancing Queens episode was judged individually. In that case, Ginger and Pearl would have likely been in the bottom as they objectively got the harshest critiques about their dancing. Trixie thought she would win as an individual, but the critiques during deliberation weren't complimentary enough, and they were loving both Violet and Katya. I think Katya or Violet would still likely win and Kennedy and Trixie would be safe. Let's officially say Katya wins to give Trixie the best shot at the crown (makes sense later). Ginger SHOULD beat Pearl, but there is the storyline possibility of Pearl being given the victory for the whole young vs old storyline, but then again, Trixie still exists as a young queen to take Pearl's place in the storyline.
So assuming Ginger wins the lip sync, Trixie should in theory do well in the Hello Kitty challenge as someone who can sew that lives for toys, and could potentially beat Violet for the win, which would get her closer to the other queens. Let's say Trixie wins. Katya and Kennedy are still in the bottom because Katya was the one that psyched herself out in that challenge, so Katya still goes despite coming off a win.
In the Born Naked video, having gained confidence from her win, and also being determined to show more of herself after being critiqued in the John Waters challenge, Trixie really hams up the acting parts and does decently well in the dancing segment, as while she is no Kennedy, she is capable of dancing better than Pearl or Ginger. In the closing speeches, Ginger attacks Trixie for having been kicked out before instead of attacking Pearl for being too flazéda, Trixie turns it on its head and says, "Yes I may have been kicked out, but I am the only person here that really knows what it means to lose this opportunity, and I never want that to happen again. I have earned my way back in here - I won last week, and I have consistently delivered since I have been back.". Ru likes the determination Trixie shows and Trixie gets into the final. As before, Ru sends Kennedy home.
Going into the final, Ginger is still well in the lead with 3 wins, and Trixie and Violet are equal with 1 win each, which should mean Ginger gets the crown, but Trixie at this point is a fan favourite who has fought her way back after being, in the eyes of the fans, wrongly eliminated, and Ginger is the CLEAR villain after relentlessly shredding Trixie on the main stage in the previous episode. Violet is obviously not winning because Katya and Trixie each took one of her wins in this timeline, and she doesn't have the same fan following that Trixie has. People live for Trixie's Barbie themed country song, and she offers some extremely sassy answers in the Q&A which drive the crowd wild. In the end, Ru decides to give Trixie the win to appease the rabid fan base, and to gag people by having the first winner to have come back into the competition after being kicked out.
This scenario ENTIRELY depends on the Prancing Queens episode being judged individually and Ru voting entirely against track record to serve storyline. In the real Season 7, Violet was on even footing with Ginger by the final, so purely based on wins, they both had equal right to win and as such Violet's victory over Ginger is relatively uncontroversial. In the alternate timeline, there would definitely be a lot more debate over the rightful winner of S7 with Trixie vs Ginger than there is irl with Violet vs Ginger.
This scenario would have been extremely unlikely, because it would be hard to sell Trixie beating Ginger as legit given Ginger's 3 wins. The only way it really could have worked would have been if Trixie had somehow matched or outperformed Ginger in the John Waters sketch, and then things followed as I described. If they were given a joint win, Trixie would have 2 wins vs Ginger's 3, and if Trixie won outright it would be an even final and Trixie could be given the win without too much complaint, given that she would have won 2 of the 3 challenges she competed in after her return - a very strong "I'm back, bitch!" message, which combined with the young vs old storyline and the fan love for Trixie would have essentially forced Ru to crown her.
Ironically, similarly to AS3 Trixie's win partially depends on the other front runners getting knocked out by factors outside of her control. (Unpopular opinion: Trixie deserved the win just as much as Shangela. Excluding Snatch Game, Trixie equalled Shangela in pretty much every challenge, and both actually had extremely similar storylines: both became fan favourites after a short premier run, came back and went out in 6th place, and then used Drag Race as a springboard to build massive mainstream careers before entering AS3. Also, both unintentionally caused friction with other queens due purely to their personalities - Shangela: too loud and confident, Trixie: too dry and clever for her own good, while also being extremely kind and caring people. Shangela was indeed robbed, but by the other queens - not Trixie, and Trixie still deserved the win as she beat Kennedy in the lip sync fair and square.)
=====
It has to be said, while I do love Trixie and I do love an underdog storyline, I think it's a good thing this didn't happen, because Violet was a deserved winner who did a lot to push drag acceptance in the fashion world. Also, I feel like we would have missed out on all of the great Trixie and Katya stuff, because they likely wouldn't have been in the situation to start Unhhhh and bond as much because Trixie would have been busy doing solo gigs as a winner, and as a result in some ways I don't know if Trixie would have been as big. Her All Stars 3 run, while controversial, was where she showed off her proper drag instead of her toned down season 7 look, whereas if she had won season 7 with her toned down look, she would have likely kept it because it worked in that timeline. Also, she got three chances in two seasons to get people to know her and love her, plus Unhhhh, which led to The Trixie & Katya Show, which resulted in Moving Parts, while winner Trixie would only get season 7, plus any subsequent solo work.
Wow... I love the level of analysis on this comment... Thanks for all the work making it. I agree with your last statement, I can't imagine a world where Trixie is S7's winner but we don't have the projects she has done
Every Time you say "What of?" an alternate Universe is created 🤭
Idea: What if the gymnastics challenge on season 9 never happened, as in the episode Cynthia comes in, she either doesn’t or one of the queens is eliminated for her place in the competition. It semi-favors she-who-shall-not-be-named, but also James and Charlie. Plus it doesn’t push Valentina towards the crown, which would be interesting to watch as a season. I don’t think the season would change drastically, but would have different outcomes for the top 6.
Please do the same with miss cucus as well!!! I'd be interested to see you explain Cynthia winning season 8 lmao
Jinx would’ve never lost to detox… no matter the song.
1:55 Let's be honest - if not for the storyline Chad would have won. All of them did great, but Chad had that Rupaul/Bebe aura. I would say, if Phi Phi had chilled out and Sharon wouldn't get as well received (often thanks to be the victim in the conversation - like with Giggly dissing Alaska or PhiPhi meltdown she would have only that alternative title to herself). Also Sharon is an awful person as we learned afterwards, so like - any moment that would resurfice, she would fall into obscurity.
5:15 Also she could have won if Rolaskatox didn't happen. And she would have to mess Jinx up in some other way too, considering Jinx was the underdog who grew so much from episode 1 to finale. Definitely the redemption for Sharon would have helped, assuming that Sharon didn't win All Stars.
7:40 Trixie could have won if meteorite hit the part of the hotel with all the winning queens, too... Unless they would give honorary crown to all of them... Or maybe if there was voting included? Um... Nah Kennedy or Ginger probably would have won that too...
8:25 To be honest I do disagree on that. Top 2 is a win in my eyes. Cause in normal season many of those queens would not even get opportunity to lipsync. Trixie often was the better one on episodes she was in top 2.
9:30 Trinity could have won it if she didn't pick Peppermint. I think like ultimately Sasha would slay first lipsync either way - and due to her mother storyline, she would always win. But bigger chance for Trinity would be to defeat the frontrunner - aka Shea (as Sasha even if in your ranking got a lot of point for being safe, ultimately had only two shared wins and was deemed as slightly better than Peppermint).
So imagine that Trinity gets So Emotional against Shea, which was a really good chance for her to win, considering that Trinity as showed on AS4 could sing emotional songs as well as other songs. And Shea was not fully feeling it and her outfit fit Stronger more.
Then of course let Sasha and Peppermint ls Stronger. Either way Sasha with her scizzor reveal wouldn't be as impactful as roses she prepared for Whitney. And her winning against Peppermint wouldn't mean as much as winning against frontrunner. Which would put Trinity on better track.
All of it would really fall to what Trinity prepared for the final lipsync, but I feel like considering she would have better track record and just have beaten Shea - she would get the crown.
10:45 Oh yeah the breakdown - that would put Sasha in Asia's butterflies position.
11:05 Or Trinity would get double win... For messing up a cartwheel. But then again it was just after Bob's win so prejudice against having a white winner wouldn't be as much of an issue yet.
Such a cool idea, I love this
these queens should have won all stars:
as1 - Raven
as2 - katya / detox
as3 - shangela / dela
as4 - Trinity (if double crowning trinity/Monique ((if manila wasn't eliminated she would've won lol))
as5 - Miz Cracker (i'm not mad at shea winning tho)
LOL.Raven was....in the BOTTOM 2 3 TIMES IN A ROW?
No
13:56 I can't read Aquaria's PPE score.
I love this. We stan this
Peppermint was my favorite up until the final. Her winning over Trinity doesn’t make sense to me. Her reveal felt forced and like a nonsense
I have a question: didn't Trinity or Pep say that originally the lipsync was going to be Fighter but they switched it to Stronger? Great video btw
Could these videos be more random hahaha I love it
Hey, I wanna tell you something. I was rewatching S5 on Netflix and in the makeover challenge, during some point in the judges deliberations, the thing in the corner where the text is when Ru says a hashtag appears with no text repeatedly until let’s say the lip sync. So if you could do a video on that and other errors that would be great. Not sure if you have down it tho (Also I clarified on Netflix cuz not sure if that happens when the episode aired)
I think there's another way Chad could have won season 4: If Willam had not been disqualified. That episode Phi Phi and Sharon were the bottom two and one of them would have gone home, thus ending that storyline of hero vs villain.
I LOVE THIS VIDEO IDEA
5:44 WHY DOES DETOX LOOK SO CREEPY UM-
I always forget Trixie won All stars 3 😐
“Don’t want to do those because they are too what-if-y” is a hypothetical
I love this kind of videos of yours also I really wonder how could you Come up with this kind of video ideas they are so creative.
Can you make a video about which drag queen did the absolute worst on drag race
What if there was a premiere for S9
"excuse the heteronormative binary term: feminine " can we be friends?
Trixie could've won the lip sync over Pearl, done good in Snatch game, reverse storyline with Pearl in makeover challenge, same performance in John Waters challenge, the rules in top 6 was her fate sealed tho. If her dance styles were different she could've performed better. Plus if they didn't judge in pairs. She could've won if they liked her more that's it.
I do not have the same concerns done good in snatch game? Honey have you seen the show😂? Jk but I don’t think she would do great in the snatch game.
What if Chad Michaels had won and Sharon was on AS1
What if tammie wasnt acting?
The universe would collapse
What i am asking myself is. In Season 8 the Queens did that Photoshoot with the past winners. Everyone is there. Except the other All stars winners. Only Chad. Is it because the other All stars season haven' t aired back then or why didnt they show up
The way there's no realistic way Trixie would have won S7..... 💀
I think jinkx would still beat detox in the lipsync, back then in s5, she used to do splits and tricks.
I think the closest we could have come is if she had beat pearl. Then she would have partnered with Max, and as Max won and Trixie is a comedy queen, she would have then won that challenge. Let's say she still bombed snatch game, I think it would have been a story to have Trixie Vs Max as they won the last challenge together. The producers set Max up as going crazy, so Trixie wins the lipsync for their story. Trixie and Pearl still do the makeover challenge together, but as Trixie is the original queen who remained, she gets the credit for that win instead. Violet wouldn't have called her out in the John Waters challenge, and I don't think they would have been as harsh that week, so she is still safe. Then in the dance they didn't judge as a group thing, maybe someone else would have taken her spot in the bottom. Then in the ball she would have either been in the top two or won the challenge (not to take away from Violets amazing outfit, but Trixie is a comedy queen who models herself after a toy, and she sews, so it isn't too far out of the realm of possibility that she is high or wins). Next challenge is tothe music video. Trixie sings, writes her own music and can pick up a choreo. Then Pearl has the worst track record of the top 4 is she is still there, and Trixie is in the top 3. If Pearl was the one who left instead of Trixie in the dance challenge though, Trixie in this has a comparable track record to Kennedy, but Kennedy was in the bottom the week before which would have been fresh on their minds, while Trixie was high/won the week before being fresh in their minds, so Trixie still makes top three instead. Trixie was a fan favourite, so Ru would give her the crown over the two girls (Ginger and Violet) for who their narrative was that they were kinda bitchy and not super liked yet.
Willam said on race chaser that during the episode where Willam was disqualified and Sharon and Phi Phi were in the bottom that the judges would've set Sharon home thus handing the win to Chad
AS6: If Kylie was allowed to be herself and in the top Ep 1 and had a better snatch game she might do good enough to beat Tyra.
AS8: If they treated Jimbo right on Canada season 1
AS9: If they got rid of Willow in that lip sync.
I don't remember where I heard or read that, but the producers had told the girls to prepare big reveals for the whole lip-sync for the crown conflama so that they could sell the new format and Shea had a problem with her luggage and had been left without her big reveal a day or two before the finale. So she would win if she had access to her intended outifit I guess
But Sasha’s reveal was the reveal of all reveals. Even now, no one has topped it since. Whenever a wig was removed, there’s always some reference to Sasha either at the confessionals or in the comments section.
I don't get how anyone can argue the fact that Monét won only to appease the overly PC crowd that wanted a queen of color crowned. The fans on Reddit seem to think that not only is that false, but that Monét deserved a solo win.
I would have been happy with a Monique solo win (considering she didn't deserve her bottom placements)
@@aldricmartinez-olson7509 I think Monique deserved it much, much more than Monét flopped in the variety show, Jersey Justice, and Sex and the Kitty Girl.
i've heard wow only congratulated Monet on their socials, deleted it, then posted something congratulating both. i think thats why most people say monet was the intended winner of the season.
UCKEY IS THE SMARTEST TH-camR. PERIODT.
Genuine question, how was the evil twin challenge offensive? I don't mean the question in any harmful way, just genuinely want to be educated
What if Monique know the words in her elimination lipsync against The Vixen on Season 10 ?
I really think that maybe Monique could overperform The Vixen and continue in the competition
I do feel like monét did well on all stars, she could’ve been the only winner
Are the balck squares in the background moving or is it just me?
I think it's you mate
Omg I'm not the only one
@@taiyonnii lmao
I think Trixie could’ve won her season if she had the Jinkx storyline and was played off as the underdog. She also could’ve gotten a few wins (2 or 3) with jinkx’s underdog storyline
oh i dont remember the evil twin challenge he said its offensive, what happened?
ok but the way monet coulda won is if aquaria was in the bottom instead of her in the makeover.
she does still lipsync in the ball and improve challenge episodes.
she wins as a group alongside eureka and Kameron the next challenge, wins snatch game instead of aquaria, then she wins the acting challenge and cher the rusical.
so she ends with 4 wins and 2 bottoms, eureka 2 wins two bottoms, aquaria 2 wins and 1 bottom, and asia 1 win and 1 bottom.
I think that Trixie could POSSIBLY have won if in episode four they kept her over Pearl. Trixie isn’t terrible at comedy challenges and could win the DESPY awards, playing on the, ‘in the bottom one episode, winning the next’ storyline. In snatch game she would either be low, or in the bottom with Max, and production wouldn’t have kept Max regardless of who was in the bottom with her, though Trixie would then have two bottom two placements and be significantly less likely to win. She wins the conjoined twin episodes with Pearl same as before. After that, depending on where production would want to go, I think she would be high or safe for the rest of the season. Possibly winning the ball challenge. (She was in the top two for the AS3 ball so it’s possible). For the dance challenge they would either change the format or Trixie would have a new partner. If they changed the format she could win? Maybe? She seemed awfully confident in Untucked, so maybe the production would want to show her as talented and that the other queens shouldn’t have doubted her talents. It’s a stretch, but maybe. She would have two to four wins and have lip-synced once or twice. Not terrible statistics for a winner especially since every other placement is safe or high.
I believe alaska would have won if roxxxy would have been nicer. Because at the end, She and michelle visage were the ones who made jinkx an underdog
I think it would be interesting to do a video on the favoritism of Asia and The Vixen on season 10. (Not hate obviously because I really like Asia) But there were four challenges where Asia and The Vixen should have been bottom two and it only happened once and I think it’s kinda crazy that nobody talks about it
What if season 6 didnt have the split cast twist?
My opinions.....
1. Chad Michaels, if William didn't "break the rules", and if Phi Phi didn't take her wig off during the lip sync, Rupaul could eliminate Sharon, and Chad would easily won.
2. Alaska, if the judges favored Alaska and give Coco's win to her, and that Roxxxy didn't bully Jinkx so Jinkx didn't have the story line, Alaska would have three wins while never landed in the bottom 2, then Alaska could win.
3. Trixie, if she was never eliminated, and Violet and Ginger was dead or disqualified before finale.
4. Trinity the Tuck, aka Trinity Taylor, if she outshined Peppermint and Sasha during her lip sync.
5. Monet X Change, if she was never eliminated, won the finale lip sync against Asia due to butterflies incidents, and that Aquaria and Eureka was dead or disqualified before finale.
6. Shea Coulee, if there weren't lip sync for the crown format, and they crowned winner by statistics.
Sasha actually had a slightly better track record than Shea... but only if you count every win, high, safe, low and bottom 2 placement
There would have never been a way for Trixie or Monet to win
Wait could some please tell me how the evil twin challenge was offensive? I was trying to think of how and can’t really understand. Thank you!
Because they basically were trying to force the queens to talk in live television about very personal stuff that they should not be forced to, shaming the queens that “didn’t show that much of their bad side in the evil twin”.
Ohh gotcha. Thank you!
will yoi continue the villain/hero series??
Tricks said she changed her makeup style for season 7 because she wanted to win. If she did her normal style and had a few better outfits I think she would have done better on season 7, but honestly I still don’t think she would have won
I love Trixie but she wasn't there yet in S7. I do think she should have won over Pearl in her 1st elimination but even so, I don't think she would have lasted that much longer. I haven't seen AS3 yet (I just started watching Drag Race this past month) but becoming a fan of hers and Katya before I even watched any Drag Race kind of made me realize some of the queens' talents don't really shine through in the particular DR format...
What u. said before the outro though😳 k native language comment, انا مرة متحمس لدراغ ريس هولاند 💖
I think trixxie (maybe) could have won or at least make it to the top 3, could be if in the dancing challenge chapter, they're judged individually, so Ginger Minj and Violet Chachki (f.y.i. that's the way it should been). And maybe Violet lose and she doesn't win. ALSO, the next challenge is the hello kitty challenge, and I think that it's a very good challenge for Trixie (for obvious reasons)
Alaska could have won season 5 if that season would’ve had the lip sync for your legacy format, like that seen in All Stars 2, 3, and 4. In the top 4 episode, the top 2 would be Alaska and Roxxxy. If the lip sync song is still changed to Malambo No. 1 (in this case presumably to assure that Alaska’s track record is superior to Roxxxy’s), Alaska would clearly win the lip sync and (unfortunately) eliminate Jinkx. She may eliminate Detox, but I think it’s less likely. If the song isn’t changed, it would more likely be Roxxxy that eliminates her. Either way, Rolaskatox is the top 3, and thus Alaska wins as the most likable member and the one with the strongest storyline. This would also mean that AS2 would probably be made for Jinkx to win.
Although the concept is interesting, Jinx would have been in the top 2 5/6 times, she would have been able to send Roxxxy home in the Roast, Detox in the SG and kinda even Alaska in the Make over. The fact that Jknx was over them and she was in the top almost the entirety of the season makes it kinda inevitable that she doesn’t at least send 2 of them home.
Is mean to say Alaska won All Stars because the producers were scared of what would happen if she lost?
i feel like monet would’ve won if she simply had better runways she was a fierce competitor so her having better runways would’ve made her win
How could u. be the best possible youtuber? Oh wait that's already true 😍😍
Ps. I hope you can watch Canada's DR in the future! The cast is way better than DRUK imo.