Liam White "....if you knew what a failure I really am. Ask Annabeth...." I think he meant "ask Annabeth" as in "ask Annabeth because she knows what a failure I am" since Annabeth was there when Thalia died, but I could be wrong.
Liam White I mean, I say that even if I tell someone what happened. Usually, it's just a reassurance that if they don't believe me, they can ask someone else as proof.
This part kills me: Maybe if I've been a little bit braver Maybe if I stayed behind to fight But maybe doesn't let me go back and save her Maybe doesn't make it all right T-T
Wait a minute, in the last lines, Grover said "It's been reminding me of all I fail to be, the tree on the hill". And when satyrs die they are turned into plants/trees. Grover is seemingly saying that he should have died protecting Thalia, not the other way around. Now I'm getting emotional
I've thought about this for a long time, but not just him Like clearing thinks of his hatred for the gods when he sees it, what do you think Annabeth thinks about it?
Okay lemme just say traditional art is hard. But the fact you made such a beautiful storyboard that's clean,neat, and has such a fluid feel ON ACTUAL PAPER is extremely commendable.
He does it amazingly though.. I freakin cant, his voice just works perfectly Like how do you control your voice that well?? And do the emotion while singing perfectly normally and it's so on point and im just flipPIng oUt
The first movie (haven't seen the second) really took away the emotion from Grover's character, he's super playful in general that's true, but they removed the parts of him that made him vulnerable, the musical, especially this song does a great job at showing what the movie failed to express
Precious.Pidge it's hilarious though because it's not just Nico. I mean now there is Thalia, Bianca (r.i.p), Jason, Hazel. I mean like c'mon guys. At least Posideon only broke his vow once!
Precious.Pidge Your forgetting, Hazel's Dad is Pluto not Hades, and Nico and Bianca were stuck in the lotus hotel lasting around seventy years and that was before World War Two. Making Hades the one to never break a vow. *edit; thaila turned human again in the Sea of Monsters, making Posiden and Zeus to only break the vows once, and Hazel and Jason are the Roman counterparts of the gods/goddesses
I still get chills from this part, "When she died, he turned her into a tree, so she can stand protecting us forever, like what I couldn't do for her." Ah- i can-t
I always interpret the last two lines as: “...Of all I failed to be: The Tree on the Hill.” As in Grover was meant to keep the other half bloods safe. HE was supposed to protect them, and now one of them is dead and also holds the same responsibility. All because Grover didn’t take action. The Tree on the Hill, that is all Grover failed to be.
GROVER IS CRYING AND SO AM I (but in all seriousness I've been waiting for a full animatic of this song for so long and this is extremely well done and aaaa_aaaaaaaa_ keep up the good work)
IM??? IN LOVE??? THE ART STYLE IS GORGEOUS AND ITS SUCH A DYNAMIC ANIMATIC AND IM SO GLAD SEEING SOMEONE ELSE BE SO NOSTALGIC ABOUT THE SERIES THANKS TO THE MUSICAL AND AAAH BLES S YOU FOR THIS
“I thought I was the only kid of the big three gods” Nico, Bianca and Jason: “Hello my old friend” Also When Thalia comes back “Guess who’s back? Back again.”
Whoever did this did amazing. It captured how Grover is affected & how the guilt still hurts him each day. It's so sad. Grover is one of my favorite characters.
The one thing in the PJO series that really disappointed me was the fact that we never really got to see Thalia’s reaction to being brought back. Like in Titan’s Curse she mentions it being weird, plus she, Annabeth, and Grover are all friends, but their reunion happened off screen. (off page?) Why wasn’t that shown? I would have loved to have seen that! Like Uncle Rick could do a short story from Thalia’s perspective about what went down after she was revived. Like she’s confused as to what’s going on and everyone has to explain to her everything that she missed. It could focus on her getting used to Annabeth being a teenager, since the last time they saw each other Annabeth was seven, how she reacted to the news that Luke had betrayed her, she could have a talk with Grover, there’s just so many possibilities!
I haven’t read the books yet but I will someday. But based on what you said, I agree. It’s annoying when stuff like this in books, movies, and TV shows where we don’t get to see certain things and they just happen off screen. Obviously they do this to help cut time so the audience doesn’t get bored and they can just get straight to the point, but it definitely leaves us wondering about the characters’ reactions. For example, with Stranger Things 4, I have been wondering what was Argyle’s reaction with learning about everything that had been going on in Hawkins with battling the stuff from the Upside Down in the first 3 seasons. Or see Max’s reaction to Lucas explaining everything in season 1. But yeah, based on what you were saying, I too wish Grover and Thalia had a talk together. Imagine if another Percy Jackson musical in which they both have a song together reflecting on what happened. But since Disney+ has that Percy Jackson TV series coming out soon, maybe someone will decide to write something similar to what you were hoping.
Second song I've really listened to from this musical and ITS OKAY I DIDNT NEED MY HEART But seriously, I started bawling listening to this. George Salazar is going to tear my heart out if he puts anymore emotion in his characters one of these days
I have a small headcannon that if percy died and no one was there not even the gods he decided to switch spots with thaila and let her live when he turned into the tree
Uh mega late but I feel like it could also be a cool au that instead of Grover running he saved Thalia and died himself and became the tree for his sacrifice
Livi that sounds fun, but what would happen? Thalia would have to join the Hunters sooner. Would they be looking for a female half blood and help Percy? Would they help Percy? Who would help Percy if not them, Coach? This would mean the age gap between Jason and Thalia would be more accurate so does that change their dynamic at all? How does Zeus act towards Thalia? Why can Zeus even turn anyone into a tree? Would Zeus turn Grover into a tree or is he reincarnated into it? So many questions!
@@fanofstuff1607 oops. Sorry, I was using that for something else because my friend only uses that acronym so I use that with them. *Stupid autocorrect*
i thought that it was so cruel of zeus to make thalia into a tree instead of sending her to elysium and using the tree to remind grover of his failure. but then i realized, zeus had killed nico and bianca’s mom, so he was probably scared of sending her to the underworld because hades might take it as a chance to get his revenge.
Grover has always been one of my all time favorite characters in the series. From listening to the soundtrack, he is still my favorite and i love how he is portrayed in this. And the emotion the actor put into this song is beautiful and exactly how i imagined grover being when he was talking about this. The emotion in the actual animation is just as powerful. This song is definitely my favorite in the soundtrack. Thank you for making such a beautiful animation for this song.
0/10 the tree isn't a pine tree (Okay but in all seriousness WOW THIS IS GORGEOUS? AND YOU DREW IT WITH PAPER AND PENCIL BUT ITS A BEAUTIFUL ANIMATIC? AND I'M SO SHOOK? This is absolutely beautiful and you drew everyone really well and there's so much emotion and it's just wonderful thank you so much)
Ok so when Grover is singing "maybe if I'd been a little but braver, maybe if I'd stayed behind to fight, but maybe doesn't let me go back to save her" I imagine percy singing about Bianca dying.
The tree was pointed in Sea of Monsters the second book. Titans Curse is book 3. By the end of the second book Thalia is revived and the fleece is acting as the new barrier guardian.
I'm like 200% sure I'm not the only one close to crying... right? This is beautiful! The way the characters are drawn and the way you conveyed the story I'd just brilliant!
oh my gods... the expressions, the detail... this must have taken you forever. this is an actual MASTERPIECE, i love EVERY SINGLE THING ABOUT IT. thank you so so so much, this is effing beautiful! you deserve so many more views im crying ahh
Addicted to the books since 2016, now I'm addicted to this musical as well along with Hamilton, Dear Evan Hansen, and The Hunger Games. Welp, I'm just going to sit in a corner and make up a crossover like the complete and utter trash I am. ;^;
Aw man, Satyrs reincarnate into plants when they die. Grover would have been 'the tree on the hill' if he hadn't run away. That's so heart breaking, he feels so guilty about what happened to her. Man.
This is so amazing! And to think this is all done with paper and pencil. I can't draw cause I would smear it all (leftie issues) but this was freaking incredible
Oh, Grover is my favorite character of the series, and especially with George Salazar reigniting my love for his character, I’ve been itching to see art of it! Thank you so much for all the work you put into this, it’s absolutely gorgeous and the words just hit so much harder with faces to put them too. 💛💙💚
I guess in a way, Zeus turned Thalia into a tree as a punishment for grover too. Everytime he sees that tree, he's reminded of his failure to save Zeus' daughter.
this evoked such feelings in my heart oh my gosh, the way you draw Grover is just so sweet and soft and your motions were so clean and nice and aaaa!!! so good!!!
It's absolutely heart wrenching that the Broadway actors can capture such raw depth & realness in their emotions & tap into the characters. My honest opinion of what makes an amazing actor is putting a bit of thier own personality into thw roles they play.
I normally feel really sad listening to this song. Grover is my absolute favorite character from the original trio, and listening to him heart kills me. First time I listened to this song, I cried. I cried this time. Visualizing it like this. Oml
I haven't seen the musical but I love this song. It's so emotional. I felt so bad for Grover when he was telling Percy what happened to Thalia. I also really like Campfire Song. I always knew about this series but I didn't start reading them until my summer vacation and hearing about the Disney+ show. I'm so excited. I can't wait until we find out more news.
@@nikkiej.5875 th-cam.com/video/1bTWWgPbSsw/w-d-xo.html I don't know if this is entirely helpful since personally, I never actually watched the musical so idk what's legit or not, just the soundtrack, but I hope it's good enough.
I got sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo Choked up from this song!! it is amazing!! Keep up Le good work!!
When a nature spirit, like a satyr, dies, they are reborn as a plant. Zeus deciding to make Thalia into a tree suddenly makes the end so much sadder. As she died, he turned her into a tree So she could stand protecting us forever The way I couldn't do for her ... And it's been reminding me Of all I failed to be The Tree on the Hill
So is it just me, or dose Percy look like Keith from Voltron? As of season 7. Hes got the scar Keith eventually got, even though this was made way before that... Whoa.
I LOVE how when he says “go back” you did a flashback scene. And it’s timed perfectly. And TRADITIONAL ART?? And it still fits very well with the music and looks smooth? Incredible
Very touching song. It really gets to the heart of why Grover is always doubting himself. Just because he brought 3 demigods to the camp but couldn't save one doesn't make him a bad satyr/protector at all....sometimes bad things happen that we just have no control over and for that I commend Grover because his failure to protect Thalia didn't make him quit...it made him work harder to be the very best version of himself he can be.
It's my personal headcanon that Grover tried talking to Thalia at night because he was hoping she'd forgive him.
Stevie Jeebie that's a great head canon!
Did you stand too close to the fire, like a liar begging for forgiveness from a tree?
Now imma stop you right there before you break my heart
Aaaaaaaw my heart! This is beautiful
I improve on that headcanon by saying how Grover cried himself to sleep every night at the foot of Thalias tree asking for forgiveness
"I thought I was the only kid of the big three gods"
Jason, Nico, and Bianca: Hello
Thomas Bridges what about Bianca ;-;
Thomas Bridges replace Hazel with Bianca. Hazel was dead at this point in time but Bianca was alive.
Thomas Bridges Jason and Hazel shouldn't really count, because there roman gods, and the romans had a different view of the big three gods.
-Bianca-
Dylan Tennant
Well it said that the Greek gods moved around with their western civilization, so I bet they went to Rome too.
Ask Annabeth, she knows.
*tells him everything*
Liam White I died xD
I'm guessing there was like... an unspoken things that showed that she didn't want to talk about it.
Sassy Person you're probably right, still I find it so funny xD
Liam White "....if you knew what a failure I really am. Ask Annabeth...."
I think he meant "ask Annabeth" as in "ask Annabeth because she knows what a failure I am" since Annabeth was there when Thalia died, but I could be wrong.
Liam White
I mean, I say that even if I tell someone what happened. Usually, it's just a reassurance that if they don't believe me, they can ask someone else as proof.
This part kills me:
Maybe if I've been a little bit braver
Maybe if I stayed behind to fight
But maybe doesn't let me go back and save her
Maybe doesn't make it all right
T-T
Lycan Power12 I agree 😭😭😭😭💔💔💔
anything with George Salazar will kill me
I literally get chills on that part
Lycan Power12 man, what abou'
"And it's there reminding me
Of all I failed to be"
Lycan Power12 Same T_T
Percy: and saved her, right?
Yes clearly Percy, THATS where this emotional story and the mass amounts of guilt lead to. She’s just invisible.
hes called seaweed brain for a reason
Optimism.
A tool to use in dire situations.
And a weakness that can blind you.
@@drewcantdraw7785 lol
he was invested in the story ok
Wait a minute, in the last lines, Grover said "It's been reminding me of all I fail to be, the tree on the hill". And when satyrs die they are turned into plants/trees. Grover is seemingly saying that he should have died protecting Thalia, not the other way around. Now I'm getting emotional
omg i never thought that way
Damn that hurts...
Grover: "Ask Annabeth, she knows"
Director: "actually Annabeth already got a solo song."
Grover: "Oh...okay."
Haha!
Just think…
Every time Grover sees the tree, all he can think about is how he couldn't save Thalia
Never mind. Don't think that. I'm crying.
Too late... Niagra Falls over here.
Random Name oh.. god... this video left me on the verge of tears, and then I saw this...🥺🥺😢😢😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
I've thought about this for a long time, but not just him Like clearing thinks of his hatred for the gods when he sees it, what do you think Annabeth thinks about it?
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 MY POOR LITTLE SON😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Too late!!😩😣😭
Okay lemme just say traditional art is hard. But the fact you made such a beautiful storyboard that's clean,neat, and has such a fluid feel ON ACTUAL PAPER is extremely commendable.
I
KNOW
RIGHT
I think George is cursed to sing a sad song every time
He does it amazingly though..
I freakin cant, his voice just works perfectly
Like how do you control your voice that well?? And do the emotion while singing perfectly normally and it's so on point and im just flipPIng oUt
True
cursed? sounds like blessing to me
I think he's just cursed to be the main character's best friend
George's little gasps... *Michael in the Bathroom flashbacks*
TheTotodile Takeover *_N O_*
TheTotodile Takeover is it the actor?
Dayza Draws yes, George Salazar
I'm going to sob even more, sToP-
@Amber Because he's always the soft soft sad character that kicks you in the heart.
I just love george salazar's voice❤
I wander if he's Related to Salazar Slytherin? Is this just me
Wait your joking.it’s him???
Hahah Why!! Fu you need to forgot Harry Potter! Dont think about Salazar Slytherin!! NoooO
SPOOPY SCARY TRASH WAIT LIKE FROM BMC
@@pissonmytoast Yeah, same dude
This is the best Grover I've seen if I'm honest! So true to the books!
I course the musical is better than that stupid 2 movies
Monique Belliveau Well obviously George is the best
The first movie (haven't seen the second) really took away the emotion from Grover's character, he's super playful in general that's true, but they removed the parts of him that made him vulnerable, the musical, especially this song does a great job at showing what the movie failed to express
@@kelseycarroll9090 which movies? The Peter Johnson ones?
@@catroyalty6360 hmm not sure I’ve heard of those before. More like the Potato Janitor ones
The last sentence kills me, and every time I hear Grover sings ,,tree on the Hill" I am crying.
Marta Sender So true his singing makes my heart cry with my face!!😣😥😢😢😢😭😭😭
Same.
"I thought I was the only kid of the big three gods?"
"You are now."
Jason, Hazel, Nico, Bianca, and Thalia: Hello there
GeNeRaL KeNoBi
I mean, Hazel wasnt technically alive at the time, unlike the others, and Thalia was only sort of alive.
Generals Threeobis
Loving the part when Percy just put his arms around Grover's shoulders~
Tsubaki [!] s h i p i t
Tsubaki [!] bro duet
Dats gey
@@amradz8122 you swer
Twas gay
"I thought I was the only kid of the big three gods?"
"You are now"
NO YOU AIN'T
Jk I know that this is the first book
Precious.Pidge it's hilarious though because it's not just Nico. I mean now there is Thalia, Bianca (r.i.p), Jason, Hazel. I mean like c'mon guys. At least Posideon only broke his vow once!
Jazmin Harris
Hades didn't break his vow at all, remember Hazel, Nico, and Bianca were born before the vow.
Precious.Pidge
Your forgetting, Hazel's Dad is Pluto not Hades, and Nico and Bianca were stuck in the lotus hotel lasting around seventy years and that was before World War Two. Making Hades the one to never break a vow.
*edit; thaila turned human again in the Sea of Monsters, making Posiden and Zeus to only break the vows once, and Hazel and Jason are the Roman counterparts of the gods/goddesses
HazelNut oh no I didn't forget
Precious.Pidge
Sorry! I didn't know because some are Roman and the others are Greek, I'm sorry again!
Annabeth is just chillin when Grover said “Ask Annabeth, she knows”
Yep. She just.. 3 minutes later he comes up to her and she’s like “ why are you craving?”
I still get chills from this part, "When she died, he turned her into a tree, so she can stand protecting us forever, like what I couldn't do for her." Ah- i can-t
I always interpret the last two lines as:
“...Of all I failed to be: The Tree on the Hill.”
As in Grover was meant to keep the other half bloods safe. HE was supposed to protect them, and now one of them is dead and also holds the same responsibility. All because Grover didn’t take action. The Tree on the Hill, that is all Grover failed to be.
Percy: "And he saved her, right?"
Grover: "DEIMORTALIS, PERCY! YOU THINK IF SHE WAS ALIVE I WOULD BE CRYING?"
I mean.. some people cry when their happy…
I cried. The part where she turns into the tree? The most tragic thing I have ever seen
GROVER IS CRYING AND SO AM I
(but in all seriousness I've been waiting for a full animatic of this song for so long and this is extremely well done and aaaa_aaaaaaaa_ keep up the good work)
AAAAH thank you!! Grover is the sweetest and deserves lots of quality hugs. I'm glad you liked it!
Honestly this is my favorite style of Grover and Thalia, you captured how i imagined them and their expressions are so heartreandering....
IM??? IN LOVE??? THE ART STYLE IS GORGEOUS AND ITS SUCH A DYNAMIC ANIMATIC AND IM SO GLAD SEEING SOMEONE ELSE BE SO NOSTALGIC ABOUT THE SERIES THANKS TO THE MUSICAL AND AAAH BLES S YOU FOR THIS
“I thought I was the only kid of the big three gods”
Nico, Bianca and Jason: “Hello my old friend”
Also When Thalia comes back
“Guess who’s back? Back again.”
Hazel: "Am i a joke to you?"
@@Chrischi3TutorialLPs I would have said, "laugh in Jason", but that'll be too soon.
Whoever did this did amazing. It captured how Grover is affected & how the guilt still hurts him each day. It's so sad. Grover is one of my favorite characters.
The one thing in the PJO series that really disappointed me was the fact that we never really got to see Thalia’s reaction to being brought back. Like in Titan’s Curse she mentions it being weird, plus she, Annabeth, and Grover are all friends, but their reunion happened off screen. (off page?) Why wasn’t that shown? I would have loved to have seen that! Like Uncle Rick could do a short story from Thalia’s perspective about what went down after she was revived. Like she’s confused as to what’s going on and everyone has to explain to her everything that she missed. It could focus on her getting used to Annabeth being a teenager, since the last time they saw each other Annabeth was seven, how she reacted to the news that Luke had betrayed her, she could have a talk with Grover, there’s just so many possibilities!
I agree
I haven’t read the books yet but I will someday. But based on what you said, I agree. It’s annoying when stuff like this in books, movies, and TV shows where we don’t get to see certain things and they just happen off screen. Obviously they do this to help cut time so the audience doesn’t get bored and they can just get straight to the point, but it definitely leaves us wondering about the characters’ reactions. For example, with Stranger Things 4, I have been wondering what was Argyle’s reaction with learning about everything that had been going on in Hawkins with battling the stuff from the Upside Down in the first 3 seasons. Or see Max’s reaction to Lucas explaining everything in season 1.
But yeah, based on what you were saying, I too wish Grover and Thalia had a talk together. Imagine if another Percy Jackson musical in which they both have a song together reflecting on what happened. But since Disney+ has that Percy Jackson TV series coming out soon, maybe someone will decide to write something similar to what you were hoping.
Anyone else think this is sadder than good kid
Mia Drake yep...
I would say they're 50/50. Equal sadness.
Mia Drake yeah except for the part where percy’s like, “And no friends, and no home, and no mom...”
after he says that i tear up every time.
this is sad but good kid as well
For me it's both it's just too much feels bro
This is incredible! I really hope you keep doing PJO animatics, you're an amazing artist!
:0 wow thank you!! this was fun to make, I'll probably try some more!
Emma Scribbles I hope you do this was GREAT!!!!
"There's a tree on the hill, on Half-blood hill, that protects us and always will."
UnTiL lUkE pOIsOneD iT.
Yeah i cant belive luke poisened his 14 year old crush.
Pfft
This is so good! I got chills and began to cry.
Aw! I'm glad you like it
Happy Ha-Ha, umm... Correct me if I'm wrong but is that a Voltron profile pic I spot?
It is a Voltron profile pic! It's my boy Lancey Lance.
Happy Ha-Ha, lol I knew it. And that Lancey Lance pic is cute.😁😉❤
u cried to
"Ask Annabeth, She knows-"
*Continues to sing*
Second song I've really listened to from this musical and ITS OKAY I DIDNT NEED MY HEART
But seriously, I started bawling listening to this.
George Salazar is going to tear my heart out if he puts anymore emotion in his characters one of these days
Was this drawn on paper? Ahhh this animatic is so amazing and wonderfully drawn, great job!!
Yeah all paper and pencil! Thank you sm!! :D
that's amazing
this was all paper and pencil??? thats flippin amazing !!!
Not the only one who does these with pencil and paper! XDD
Emma Scribbles YOU'RE A LEVEL 10 WIZARD
Amazing!!
Hayden Daviau Love your videos!
Ahhh even headcannon annabeth is here!!! But yea this video is incredible
I love you
I have a small headcannon that if percy died and no one was there not even the gods he decided to switch spots with thaila and let her live when he turned into the tree
Uh mega late but I feel like it could also be a cool au that instead of Grover running he saved Thalia and died himself and became the tree for his sacrifice
Livi that sounds fun, but what would happen? Thalia would have to join the Hunters sooner. Would they be looking for a female half blood and help Percy? Would they help Percy? Who would help Percy if not them, Coach? This would mean the age gap between Jason and Thalia would be more accurate so does that change their dynamic at all? How does Zeus act towards Thalia? Why can Zeus even turn anyone into a tree? Would Zeus turn Grover into a tree or is he reincarnated into it? So many questions!
Oh my gods this frankly amazhang
Apollo-ges for the puns
But this is awesome
Dam these puns are pure (imperial) gold.
These puns are celestial (bronze)!
I can sea these appearing in the million of other punny comments.
These are some of the gods dam best PJO and HoO puns to exist. Holy Hera my puns are complete Shist compared to yours.
Kirby Krazy Mads try to stick to PJO. PJatO made me feel like Percy!
@@fanofstuff1607 oops. Sorry, I was using that for something else because my friend only uses that acronym so I use that with them. *Stupid autocorrect*
i thought that it was so cruel of zeus to make thalia into a tree instead of sending her to elysium and using the tree to remind grover of his failure. but then i realized, zeus had killed nico and bianca’s mom, so he was probably scared of sending her to the underworld because hades might take it as a chance to get his revenge.
This song is so sad and beautiful
Grover has always been one of my all time favorite characters in the series. From listening to the soundtrack, he is still my favorite and i love how he is portrayed in this. And the emotion the actor put into this song is beautiful and exactly how i imagined grover being when he was talking about this. The emotion in the actual animation is just as powerful. This song is definitely my favorite in the soundtrack. Thank you for making such a beautiful animation for this song.
why do I always cry when my mascara is not waterproof awwww poor Grover😭😭😭😭😭
All the people who played the roles in this musicals soundtrack honestly sound exactly how i thought they would sound in the books
0/10 the tree isn't a pine tree
(Okay but in all seriousness WOW THIS IS GORGEOUS? AND YOU DREW IT WITH PAPER AND PENCIL BUT ITS A BEAUTIFUL ANIMATIC? AND I'M SO SHOOK? This is absolutely beautiful and you drew everyone really well and there's so much emotion and it's just wonderful thank you so much)
Master Lillyclaw What? I always thought it was a pine tree...
Master Lillyclaw The tree is a pine tree...
@@ineedsleepbutschoolismorei2537 guys they meant that the animatic had an oak tree or something similar when it should have been a pine tree lol
cryptozoology exactly lol
Wow, this almost made me cry. It is so good how it is reflected in the video and in the song. Amazing💙
OMG THOSE HANDS ARE GORGEOUS
Grover in the bathroom looks great
Ok so when Grover is singing "maybe if I'd been a little but braver, maybe if I'd stayed behind to fight, but maybe doesn't let me go back to save her" I imagine percy singing about Bianca dying.
This legit made me cry
I mean
I'M IN TEARS
GROVER DESERVES ALL THE HUGS OH MY GOD THIS IS AMAZING
"It protects us all and always will"
The Titans Curse: I'm about to end this man's whole career
The tree was pointed in Sea of Monsters the second book. Titans Curse is book 3. By the end of the second book Thalia is revived and the fleece is acting as the new barrier guardian.
I'm like 200% sure I'm not the only one close to crying... right?
This is beautiful! The way the characters are drawn and the way you conveyed the story I'd just brilliant!
amazing i love this so much!!
:O thank you!!
oh my gods... the expressions, the detail... this must have taken you forever. this is an actual MASTERPIECE, i love EVERY SINGLE THING ABOUT IT. thank you so so so much, this is effing beautiful! you deserve so many more views im crying ahh
Addicted to the books since 2016, now I'm addicted to this musical as well along with Hamilton, Dear Evan Hansen, and The Hunger Games. Welp, I'm just going to sit in a corner and make up a crossover like the complete and utter trash I am. ;^;
This comment is a mood
Too true.
Are you my long lost twin?
The way George sings, and your art and expression fits so well! It really shows the emotions being conveyed by the characters
This is amazing! You made me cry! Incredible job!!!
Aw man, Satyrs reincarnate into plants when they die. Grover would have been 'the tree on the hill' if he hadn't run away. That's so heart breaking, he feels so guilty about what happened to her. Man.
I have absolutely no problem admitting that i have watched this way to many times than is normal..
But i don't care is amazing
The artwork is just beautiful. Especially Grover’s look of anguish
This is so amazing! And to think this is all done with paper and pencil. I can't draw cause I would smear it all (leftie issues) but this was freaking incredible
ThatOneTheatreKid 25 Just draw from right to left. This isn't writing.
ThatOneTheatreKid 25 Or get a hand guard.
I HAVE FOUND MY KIND OF LEFTIES. WE SHALL RISE UP ONE DAY (lmao jk)
I LOVE that Michael photo
Oh, Grover is my favorite character of the series, and especially with George Salazar reigniting my love for his character, I’ve been itching to see art of it! Thank you so much for all the work you put into this, it’s absolutely gorgeous and the words just hit so much harder with faces to put them too. 💛💙💚
I guess in a way, Zeus turned Thalia into a tree as a punishment for grover too. Everytime he sees that tree, he's reminded of his failure to save Zeus' daughter.
This song really makes me so cry so hard I love it so much the lyrics is perfect
okey, i'm crying. this is a beautiful masterpiece. love, youre an incredible artist
Ok this legitimately made me tear up. You really did this song justice, and you did a great job portraying Grover’s feelings on this T-T
Both this song and "Good Kid" make me want to hug Percy and Grover and just let them cry on my shoulder!
They need to give eachother a hug
This song never fails to give me chills, but your incredible animation just takes it to another level! This is incredible!
Great animatic, Great song. BUT ALL I CAN HEAR IS MICHAEL IN THE BATHROOM. BE MORE CHILL WHAT HAVE YOU DONE TO ME
this evoked such feelings in my heart oh my gosh, the way you draw Grover is just so sweet and soft and your motions were so clean and nice and aaaa!!! so good!!!
Well I'm crying just the tiniest bit. That was absolutely amazing, your art is wonderful!
It's absolutely heart wrenching that the Broadway actors can capture such raw depth & realness in their emotions & tap into the characters. My honest opinion of what makes an amazing actor is putting a bit of thier own personality into thw roles they play.
Just imagine Luke singing this song
He'd probably laugh at the end
Thomas Bridges why?
Madison Jones bc he was evil...
Thanks Satan, I’m crying now
Oath Draws
George Salazar is a great singer, I'm fine (Thanks Satan)
Omg the way Percy hugs Grover at the end...someone get me a tissue I'm crying T_T
NOW IM JUST GROVER IN THE BATHROOM GROVER IN THE BATHROOM AT A PARTY IS THERE A SADDER SIGHT THAN!!!!!!!!!!MMMMMMMMM!!!!
I did not check myself before wrecking myself when I clicked on this animatic 😭 it was so good and you're super talented!
I'm dead this is so beautiful
I normally feel really sad listening to this song. Grover is my absolute favorite character from the original trio, and listening to him heart kills me. First time I listened to this song, I cried. I cried this time. Visualizing it like this. Oml
I haven't seen the musical but I love this song. It's so emotional. I felt so bad for Grover when he was telling Percy what happened to Thalia. I also really like Campfire Song. I always knew about this series but I didn't start reading them until my summer vacation and hearing about the Disney+ show. I'm so excited. I can't wait until we find out more news.
Me too! Because we were told about it really early, we have to wait around two to three years for any big news
@@midnightthoughts8519 Oh, I know. I can't wait that long. I would be getting very impatient.
@@midnightthoughts8519 I forgot to ask, do you know where I can watch the full musical? I really need to watch it.
@@nikkiej.5875 th-cam.com/video/1bTWWgPbSsw/w-d-xo.html
I don't know if this is entirely helpful since personally, I never actually watched the musical so idk what's legit or not, just the soundtrack, but I hope it's good enough.
@@midnightthoughts8519 Thanks for trying. 😁
I got sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo Choked up from this song!! it is amazing!! Keep up Le good work!!
When a nature spirit, like a satyr, dies, they are reborn as a plant. Zeus deciding to make Thalia into a tree suddenly makes the end so much sadder.
As she died, he turned her into a tree
So she could stand protecting us forever
The way I couldn't do for her
...
And it's been reminding me
Of all I failed to be
The Tree on the Hill
GROVER 😭😭😭
This animatic is so good!!!!!
Doesn't Percy Kinda Look Like Keith From Voltron?...
Oof My New Favorite Song
WHEN THALIA STARTS HARMONIZING IM SCREAMIGMFKG I GET CHILLS
So is it just me, or dose Percy look like Keith from Voltron? As of season 7. Hes got the scar Keith eventually got, even though this was made way before that...
Whoa.
OH MY GOD, THATS EXACTLY WHAT I SAID!!! Finally an agreement
I though it was just me 😅
Every time grover sings "it's there reminding me of who i failed to be" my hearth just breaks into a million pieces and i don't even cry fast
Grover: She protects us
Hades in the movies: aight imma head in
What movies? There are no movies?
I LOVE how when he says “go back” you did a flashback scene. And it’s timed perfectly. And TRADITIONAL ART?? And it still fits very well with the music and looks smooth? Incredible
This is amazing
I still get goosebumps watching this animatic!
Ahhhh I'm crying!! Amazhang animation!😭
This!!! Is!!!! So!!!! Great!!!
Ahhhh the amount of detail put into this is astonishing!! And I adore your art style!!! Kudos to you!!!
If your a true fan you cried
I CRIED
AND I GOT CHILLS AT “A COLD WIND BLEW”
alright i aint a true fan then
I've heard this song so many times but idk what was different I just sat and sobbed for the minutes straight
(Percy)Who's...Thalia?(Grover)Dead now!
ok but this is actually THE BEST ANIMATIC I THINK I'VE EVER SEEN YOUR A BLESSING THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOUUUUU
It was perfect
Very touching song. It really gets to the heart of why Grover is always doubting himself. Just because he brought 3 demigods to the camp but couldn't save one doesn't make him a bad satyr/protector at all....sometimes bad things happen that we just have no control over and for that I commend Grover because his failure to protect Thalia didn't make him quit...it made him work harder to be the very best version of himself he can be.
The ending 💙
This is so good! i go crazy over your Thalia design and the shot of them running with the fish eye lens on "I got nervous and we got lost" is so good!