Is that the girl in pink? If so I think she’s getting better two and girl who sang first isant still sings very bad the one with deeper voice I don’t think this song suits her the other song she sang way better then this one I gotta say I like there other song more kinda like baby monster I hate there first song second one is ok but the main course drives me nuts 😅
Lmao, yall are saying improvement. This is clearly a more comfortable range for her. It's like how JYP always makes Momo sing in fucking baby voice when she can't. Ofc her sound is going to come out horrible. Hybe did the exact same thing to these girls. They came out with a baby pop song which forces the girls to do fucking baby voice when it's not within their comfort range.
They obviously need more vocal lessons, but I think the biggest problem is that the company wants them to sing in a tone that is not natural for them, if you compare Moka here with Magnetic you can see the difference, even more so if you compare with her vocals during the reality show, the tone she uses is completely different and sounds much better (same for Lesserafim, members like Yunjin and Chaewon regressed vocally after going to Hybe)
@dolliestdollyicn has caused they debuted doesnt mean anything. And if I may debuting would mean ur supposed to be GOOD. they've already had 3 horrible encores
@dolliestdollyicnif we apply your logic to all newly debuted groups, we won’t get a single good encore then. But Itzy,NCT Wish,Gidle and many others were so good at singing when they got their first wins. It’s all back to the yellow company. They just want profits.
@hwanghyunjin7757 serafim actually is getting better by the day! You can really tell the difference in their Coachella performances and that they are doing sooo much better than last week. The video and comments where never about lesserafim though soo😅
i hope people can see that they are trying!! they had no control over their debut date, but they have a choice to continue to improve and they are doing that.
i also feel like ppl forget to mention how theyre constantly singing live at their performances, despite the hate theyve been facing they still try their best in every performance which is super admirable
They sound FINE. Especially for a rookie group thats only a few months old.🧸 And Especially for a group that is being bashed, harassed and pretty much online bullied due to their lack of experience in live performance, wich is kinda hilarious when you take in the fact that theyre only just starting their careers. Im not a fan of them, but i would also never be a hater. Thats both sad and ridiculous. And also, STOP with all these comments about HYBE "forcing them to do something or not training them properly". HYBE is NOT managing them in ANY WAY. They have their own managment company, own CEO and own coaches for vocal and dance training, just like every other group that its signed into a company, that falls under the HYBE labels. And dont know why its Still so hard for people to understand how it works. If HYBE would be in charge of all the groups, and could make all the desicions, then why would they need any of these companies, their CEOs, trainers, managers ect. They could just rule with a iron fist. Use youre brains people and do some research, i understand that HYBE as a whole is the Perfect scapegoat when ever there is something that fans dont like, but blaiming a corporation that has nothing to do with the actual issue, is only shifting blame away from those who should take accountability and make the changes needed.
@@nozekangbae9427 Yeah, some low notes are just as difficult as high notes. Moka isn't suitable for low notes like that. In the Magnetic song, I saw many people cover that song. In Moka's part, those people couldn't sing well either. In my country there is a singer who says that he sings high notes more easily than low notes.
@@Merlina2004 I mean this song is more comfortable to sing for them. And post a video of you singing 😉 before saying things like that . It's kind of pathetic.
MOKA is improving and I know she should be a polished kpop idol by now but that won’t stop us from saying she has improved. I’m curious how much more improvement she can have overtime. She definitely owns the stage when she performs so I hope her vocals get better and better.
She can’t do low notes that’s why her encore isn’t that good on magnetic. hybe really struggles giving there idols comfortable vocal ranges for them proven in illit and lsfm
its cuz the vocal range suits her better if you hear a lot of Japanese singers too when they started to learn Korean there voice was very snazzy cuz of their accent
People are so ignorant. Its impossible to improve this fast... so this can only mean... OMG MOKA ISNT A BAD SINGER IN THE FIRST PLACE. None of them are. Look singing and dancing is very hard without proper breath support. This song is lower it seems os she isnt using that higher cutesy voice to sing. Even with auto tune in a song it wont FIX a bad singer. It just makes it sound smoother. Even with a shaky voice ot cant fully correct that. These girls are talented they just neednti build stamina and practice singing and dancing more often.
@@bbinngyou must sound better than all of them right? Because I highly doubt that. Please shut your mouth because I know for a fact you aren’t at Wendy’s level or even close to her.
so many people hating in the comments but these girls just seem like they haven’t gotten enough vocal training. they sound decent considering #1. their age, #2. their previous experience, and #3. their time to prepare (and lack thereof.) i’ve seen clips from both magnetic and lucky girl syndrome and i can tell that they seem to fit this song more vocally than magnetic, and that this is probably the company’s fault for not recognizing their strengths and weaknesses vocally in order to curate something that fits all of the girls.
Honestly if another group performed like this I feel like no one would be complaining. It’s normal for idols to sound out of breath when they’re dancing, most do. The problem with kpop Stan’s is they expect every group to have every member be a Beyoncé level performer, singer, dancer ect. When that’s just not realistic.
when they didn't doing it good, people are mad and a lot comments hating on them by hiding behind 'we aren't hate them, we just being critical'. But look they sing good now, where's your so called critical comment? I just know people more excited hate on things than being supportive, pathetic
@@tarmlktea4699 they said those hate comments written by them is not hating but critical. For me, use bad words is indeed bullying. If they were being critical before, they can be critical now. Criticism is not just about bad thing, you can be critical about good thing as well. But where are those people now? It just proving that they just want to hate rather than "being critical"
i dont get what the point of this comment is? people are being critical or 'hating' on magnetic encore stages because lets be honest, it was kinda all over the place. in this video, they are obviously better. thats why there are less 'hate' comments. what, do you want to see more? like bro?? they improved or sound better, theres not going to be as much critical comments...
@@areqqx.people who hate these girls won't admit they hating on them, that's why they said 'i don't hate them I just being critical, but girls sing so horrible they never improve. There were contestants who can sing better than them, they shouldn't debut in the first place.' And now they improve and i am questioning where are those people now? If they indeed being critical, they should come and say 'yeah they sing better now, they must be practice so hard after what happened last encor, good luck for them' That is critical, when you did bad, people give criticize so you can improve and do better next. And when you already did good, they should give you feedback. But what happened here is people just want to say something bad, they just simply hate these girls. Like look at the comments here and that encore video. Which one do you think have more comments? Which one do you think people will bring it back after five years later? I'm guessing it will be that encore video, why? Cus that's how bad people are, they just having fun by hating on things, they use their energy and time for hate rather than support. Don't you realize there are less people here for support these girls, even if they said bad words before then they came here to support, those people are indeed critical and want illit to improve. Not like people who just came when idols sing bad or made mistake.
They have improved so much!! I’m really proud of them! Though they do need more vocal lessons! They really did well on this one! And if u think they didn’t sound good, try singing, and dancing at the same time,
근데.... 직업이 아이돌인데.... 당연히 노래하면서 춤춰야하는거 아닌가...... ? 우리는 아이돌이 아니니까 당연히 춤실력도 부족하고 노래실력도 부족한데.... 아일릿은 최소한 직업을 잘해야.... 하지 않나? 의사가 수술을 못해도, 처방전을 못내려도 괜찮다는 말인가? 선생님이 학생 가르치는 것에 영 소질이 없어도 괜찮다고, 우쭈쭈해줘도 괜찮다는...... 건가? 라고 소신발언을 합니다.
I’m glad that people are seeing the improvement. The dance is still super energetic but their singing is more stable than in magnetic. They didn’t choose when to debut so the important part now is that they keep practising, improving and gaining more experience with dancing and singing live
Fr! I'm glad this video the comments are saying positive things but the other vids about the girls it's just a war zone and someone screaming about their vocals
I dont even stan illit but i never understand why they get so much hate .They srent as bad as yall make it seem Their vocals are average like 90% kpop ggs that yall hype. I feel like why yall are so focussed on them is because they are ending your faves on charts.
they aren’t really good at singing but some of these people are taking it too far and i’m also scared that it will become a huening bahiyyih-level hate train against moka in particular
I cant answer you under my comment bc f$$ yt algorithm ripped all my comment so I will answer here All YG artist goals will be world tour concert with live music and live performance! YG will never waste time and money to debut some girls who cant sing live and use pre-recorded. I think YG or BM knows these "pre-recorded" excuse, that's why they change all latest BM to perform with mic and live music without backing track.
@@nongnaphass8828 I have answered your other comment but nothing I have said is anti Babymonster. I like Babymonster, especially Asa. What I don't like it lying delulu fans like yourself who are toxic towards others groups while sincerely believing that very clearly pre-recorded performances are live. That is anti behaviour. I haven't said a single negative thing about Babymonster, only you guys AKA the delulu fans, the typical YG fans. I hate that the Babymonster fandom has become like the blinks. I'm an OG V.I.P, I think it's a disgrace what you guys have done to the reputation of YG groups fans.
@@vergil8833 sorry but you are really dishonest to yourself! You are typical hybe fandom who has always accept the low quality idol and always make excuse for hybe gg by sayin that other group is pre- recorded while baby monster clearly sing live. But STILL playing victims assss always. I saw your other comment only praising under illness gg lol
![“อ.เบียร์ คนตื่นธรรม” มาตามคำเรียกร้อง แหกศาสตร์ฮวงจุ้ย เตือนสติอย่างมงาย | แฉ 7 พ.ย. 67 [1/3]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5fc4S3xBNfc/mqdefault.jpg)
![[KPOP IN PUBLIC | SYDNEY | ONE TAKE] ILLIT (아일릿) ‘Cherish (My Love)’ DANCE COVER | AUSTRALIA](/img/n.gif)
I think this song fits them better than Magnetic. That's why they look more comfortable when singing it.
FACTS
both are the same type of song wdym
@@kyoukaiten3834vocal range
It doesn’t tbh. The ones who struggled on magnetic struggle with lucky girl syndrome too
that's what comfortable is to you?
Yay! This seems to be in a more comfortable part of Moka’s range!
Is that the girl in pink? If so I think she’s getting better two and girl who sang first isant still sings very bad the one with deeper voice I don’t think this song suits her the other song she sang way better then this one I gotta say I like there other song more kinda like baby monster I hate there first song second one is ok but the main course drives me nuts 😅
@@MichelleBorden1995 Moka is the first girl
@@MichelleBorden1995no the one in pink is wonhee
idc if u like that babymonads, stop out of topic@@MichelleBorden1995
@@MichelleBorden1995who is baby monster 💀
Moka is getting better ❤
No. But with that kind of avatar, we can't expect much common sense from you.
@@Goodmorning1221-how do you know she's not improving?
@@Goodmorning1221-
Oh guys, look! A proud Wonyoung repellant! :0
Don't worry, it's mutual! We don't expect much common sense from you either~ :((
@@yixueuxiyi Same type of avatar, same type of braincells
Why to bring wonyoung here? @@yixueuxiyi
Lmao, yall are saying improvement. This is clearly a more comfortable range for her. It's like how JYP always makes Momo sing in fucking baby voice when she can't. Ofc her sound is going to come out horrible. Hybe did the exact same thing to these girls. They came out with a baby pop song which forces the girls to do fucking baby voice when it's not within their comfort range.
THIS COMMENT IS SO REAL🔥
EXACTLY
FRRRR, FINALLY SOMEONE SAID IT
ily
ima give you a big fat sensual kisses omfg
I BEG, PLEASE LET ME REPOST THIS WITH CREDIT
베몬보다오니까 진짜 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ.. 하
아이돌 잘 안 챙겨보는데 베몬 실력 미쳤더라
@@슝슝-g3n 베몬 완전 실력파 3대기업은 역시 다르더라구요 가수가 그래야지 준비도 안된 애들 돈벌이용으로 급하게 나온게 참 안쓰럽네요 많이 연습하고 카피없이 정상적으로 데뷔했으면 좋았을텐데
아 연습생 5년이상 했다고 본거같은데
흠...사쿠라가 12년이라고 했던가...
그쪽은 아무래도 과유불급이 아닐지...
뭔 차력쇼도 아니고....이쁘지가 않음
블핑이랑 에스파 정도로 자제하는게 최적의 밸런스일 것 같다
아이브뉴진스도 지금와서는 못한다고 하기 어렵지만 조금 약한감은 아직 있음
@@djlipsum1526 컨셉의 차이죠
머가 더 좋고 나쁘고 가 아니라
개성이 없고 다 똑같으면 그건 양산형, 복제
가 되버리니까
@@슝슝-g3n 아니 나는 가창력 얘기한건데요......
They obviously need more vocal lessons, but I think the biggest problem is that the company wants them to sing in a tone that is not natural for them, if you compare Moka here with Magnetic you can see the difference, even more so if you compare with her vocals during the reality show, the tone she uses is completely different and sounds much better (same for Lesserafim, members like Yunjin and Chaewon regressed vocally after going to Hybe)
Its was also out of her range
I agree😢❤
@dolliestdollyicn has caused they debuted doesnt mean anything. And if I may debuting would mean ur supposed to be GOOD. they've already had 3 horrible encores
@dolliestdollyicn keep in mind that they were also part of a survival show...
@dolliestdollyicnif we apply your logic to all newly debuted groups, we won’t get a single good encore then. But Itzy,NCT Wish,Gidle and many others were so good at singing when they got their first wins. It’s all back to the yellow company. They just want profits.
They’re improving so quickly!!
I guess they listen to their criticism unlike lessera
Real they are improving
no i feel like they were already like this, it’s just that lucky girl syndrome fits their tone of voices better than magnetic
@@graceclover8697 exactly
@hwanghyunjin7757 serafim actually is getting better by the day! You can really tell the difference in their Coachella performances and that they are doing sooo much better than last week. The video and comments where never about lesserafim though soo😅
i hope people can see that they are trying!! they had no control over their debut date, but they have a choice to continue to improve and they are doing that.
i also feel like ppl forget to mention how theyre constantly singing live at their performances, despite the hate theyve been facing they still try their best in every performance which is super admirable
yes they are improving @@s_a_l_v_a4
Trying is not enough if you get paid there should be a standard
@@angkas7479 need to give them time
@@s_a_l_v_a4
Huh!? 😂 they don't control if they sing live or lipsync
돌판은 하이브 이전과 이후로 나뉜다
I actually was longing for this type of concept in kpop for so long
Yunah really reminds me of Heeseung when he's in I-land so bright in all aspects love them so much
I thought it was only me
Yesss they look kinda similar too
yea and yunah and heeseung actually had interactions when in r u next!!
veneers...
I thought i was the only one 😅
데님페션 세련되지 못하고 너무 촌스럽게 스타일링 했음..
허세련이 세련되지 못해서 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
ㄹㅇ 2012년 감성
ㄹㅇ 나 유치원때 데일리룩같음
진짜 윤아는 무슨 소지섭 머리를 해놨어😮
@@EkfrlEbdhkfrl 아존나웃기네진짜
옷 진짜 디렉터 미감없다
ㅈㄴ 런닝맨 옷 같음
ㄹㅇ 핏이 너무 이상함 팔뚝 밖에 안 보인다
리폼해서 입혀야지 진짜 옛날 스타일로 입히면 어떡하냐 ㄹㅇ
귀여움 닥쳐라
진심 옷 핏 색깔 다 개별로임,,,
뉴진스 따라한답시고 깔별로 입혔나본데
어떻게 투자금 10배 그룹의 미감이 😂
데뷔 전에 기본기는 갖추는 게 당연한 거 아님? 같은 신인인 베몬은 뭐임 그럼 ㅋㅋㅋ걔넨 신인 아니냐 무대만 봐도 실력 자체가 다른데 기본 실력도 안 된 상태에서 데뷔하고 그 후에 성장해나가는 거면 연습생 땐 뭐 했단 건데ㅜ
아 ㅆ 인정ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
블핑같이 성장이 아니라고..90에서 100되는 성장이 아니라 20에서 50되는 성장이잖아..
@@user-yc4dy3ee7j 20에서 50이면 좀 낫겠죠..
10에서 20되는 성장 같은데요..
@@user-yc4dy3ee7j 무에서 유를 만들려고 하니 이 난리가 나지 ㅋㅋㅋ
라이브깔거면고함지르는졷돌년들부터까고오라고야돌한테만ㅈㄴ각박하네진심ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ느그들이국뻥에차올라서물고빠는방탄도라이브존나멋해ㅠㅠ
They sound FINE. Especially for a rookie group thats only a few months old.🧸 And Especially for a group that is being bashed, harassed and pretty much online bullied due to their lack of experience in live performance, wich is kinda hilarious when you take in the fact that theyre only just starting their careers. Im not a fan of them, but i would also never be a hater. Thats both sad and ridiculous. And also, STOP with all these comments about HYBE "forcing them to do something or not training them properly". HYBE is NOT managing them in ANY WAY. They have their own managment company, own CEO and own coaches for vocal and dance training, just like every other group that its signed into a company, that falls under the HYBE labels. And dont know why its Still so hard for people to understand how it works. If HYBE would be in charge of all the groups, and could make all the desicions, then why would they need any of these companies, their CEOs, trainers, managers ect. They could just rule with a iron fist. Use youre brains people and do some research, i understand that HYBE as a whole is the Perfect scapegoat when ever there is something that fans dont like, but blaiming a corporation that has nothing to do with the actual issue, is only shifting blame away from those who should take accountability and make the changes needed.
Thank you!!!!
IKR !
It’s horrific, so many K-pop idols have committed due to bullying, please don’t let another idol go 💔🙏🏻
THANK YOU!! 😭❤️
I too think the same, neither a fan nor a hater of illit
Loving moka's improvement here
Who’s moka?
same
Moka can sing but not in lower notes just like her lines in Magnetic
@@nozekangbae9427 Yeah, some low notes are just as difficult as high notes. Moka isn't suitable for low notes like that. In the Magnetic song, I saw many people cover that song. In Moka's part, those people couldn't sing well either. In my country there is a singer who says that he sings high notes more easily than low notes.
Fr
바이럴이 또 시작되었다..
님네 뉴진스도 바이럴로 뜸
@@박준수-h5c 꾸진스나 꾸진스 그 아래 지하돌이나
@@박준수-h5c 허위사실 유포
@@박준수-h5c좀 알아보고 싸질러라 ㅋㅋ
@@박준수-h5c for being talented
Moka is the cutest. Why Japanese idols like her are so charismatic and cute. Sakura, Ruka, and Sana too.
Hikaru too
Rei too❤
Bcs they can only sell cute looks, what else?in this case the big 3 are not included
Kotoko too ❤
Tsuki also
하이브랑 단월드는 무슨 관계길래 고소를 안하죠??
아일릿 너무 이쁘고 잘하죠? ㅎㅎ
They denied any association with it.
@@sshim913illit*
고소할 이유가있나
@@Handsome_jjindda사이비가 자기들이랑 엮길려고 하는데 왜 내비둠
모카 너무 귀여운 것 같아요 🩷
언제부터 아이돌이 데뷔 후 성장해나가는 걸 보면서 칭찬하는 직업이 됐지 ㅋㅋㅋ 그럴거면 연습생은 뭐하러 함 경연 프로그램도 아니고? 예전보다는 나아졌지만 여전히 못하는 게 팩트고 이런 아이돌 소비하고 싶지가 않다
나아져도 난리야 그럼 소비하지 말든가 굳이 쇼츠 찾아와서 댓글다는거 보니까 시간 널널한 것 같은데 다른 일을 하세요
@@user-xy7vb8in2zㅇㅈ
완성형인 상태로 데뷔하던 원래 케이팝 판에선 노래 실력이 부족한 아일릿이라는 그룹 자체는 칭찬할 곳이 없지만 부족한 부분을 매꾸려고 노력하는건 대단한거 맞음..
충분히 비판 할 수 있는 댓글인데 저런 댓글도 못쓰나? 좋은 것만 보고 그럴거면 아이돌을 왜함? 대댓글들 진짜 대가리 총맞은것 같음 그러니 그 아이돌에 그 팬 수준이겠지ㅋㅋ
뉴진스 짝퉁 그룹🥵🥵
진짜 컨셉이 초중딩들 같다... 뉴진스보다 더 하네. 뉴진스는 어린건 알겠는데 추억을 건드려서 거부감이 안들었는데 이건 그냥 나 귀엽고 어린애에요 하는기분.
민주는 빼라 민주쟤는 뉴진스 전원 3배는 하는애다
@@RmemDkd 민주도 비숫함 그냥 이그룹이 못함 전체적으로 ㅇㅇ
@@RmemDkd 아일릿 짱 ㅎ
컨셉이 유아퇴행? 이라서 그런듯
싫으면 안 보면 됨… 댓글 남길 시간 아깝지도 않나ㅜㅜㅋㅋㅋ
진짜 르세라핌만큼 비호감됨
왜요? 방시혁이 문제지 얘네 문제는 아니잖아요
@@치이와레노래를 못해서
신인이니까
@@치이와레배후를 잘못둔죄
@@치이와레 실력도 안 되고 뉴진스 대체 그룹으로 비슷하게 만들었으니까 비호감이 될 수밖에...
Moka sounds sooo comfortable here! Go girl! But i cant get over Minju shes def my bias ❤
NAH I JUST NOTICED MOKA'S HAIRSTYLE LMAO SHE LOOKS LIKE A BABY 😂
sad to see these girls get hate when they actually sing live. Some people don't know how real voices sound like live anymore! They sound great !!
Love seeing some positive comments for the girls for once, they don’t deserve the immense hate they’ve been getting lately
Same
Samee
Fr. Can't click on a single post or video about them without some rat screaming. Like give it a rest.
im so proud of moka for improving!!! keep up the good work 💕💕
THE OUTFITS R SO GOOD⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
moka so cute ❤ your voice is amazing ❤
Moka is so pretty 🤩 ❤ she improved so much this reminds me of her runext performances this is definitely her comfortable range
Seems like its a more comfortable range for them, i hope they start releasing more songs that matches their skills and gain more confidence from it!
부르고 싶은 부분만 부르는데 이게.. 잘하는거라고...? 세상이 어떻게 돌아가는거임
케이팝을 제발 망치지마라 하이브야..
무슨 말을 하는 거야? 아이돌은 얼굴이 귀여운 것이 가장 중요하다.
@@gomoooku그럼 강아지 고양이가 아이돌 해여할듯
근데 생각보다 모카가 똑바로해서 놀랐음
@@ga-yeonBak자기 파트 부르기만 했지 잘 부르지는 못했잖아요..
Amazing song and great performance.
Moka is already improving..☆
Thats not called improvement shes just more comfortable singing LGS
Moka is getting so much better. I am so happy for them❤
She was always good she just can’t do low notes
Improved where? Even a 8 yr old kid can sing like that
@@Merlina2004 I mean this song is more comfortable to sing for them.
And post a video of you singing 😉 before saying things like that .
It's kind of pathetic.
@@Merlina2004girl an 8 year old? They can’t be exactly stable when dancing while singing
@@duongdanavirakbot-gz3hr this song sounds like a kids song it's not hard to sing while dancing
어쩜 이걸보고 라이브늘었다하지ㅋ다들 엉망인데ㅋㅋ얘들에 대한 기대치가 그리 낮은건가ㅎㅎ
앵콜보단 나은거 팩트잖아
발전하는 모습을 보여주니까 칭찬을 하지
얼마나 할 일이 없음 저 노래 실력을 옹호하냐@@play_game_like_oner
@@fiz5161 무지성으로 욕하는거보단 가치있다고 생각함
@@play_game_like_oner 저게 발전으로 보이냐 ㅋ 유치원 재롱잔치 수준 외모 목소리 키 진짜 어이없다 일본에서만 활동해라
MOKA is improving and I know she should be a polished kpop idol by now but that won’t stop us from saying she has improved. I’m curious how much more improvement she can have overtime. She definitely owns the stage when she performs so I hope her vocals get better and better.
The well-connected microphone made it possible to hear even your breathing
They fit in this song so well... The way they wrer stable i think tjis song comfortable for them to sing...!!!
Moka is so cute ❤😭
I’m really glad they’re now promoting songs that are actually in the girls’ range.
NO REALLLL
They have really improved !! So proud of them
THEY IMPROVED IM SAUR PROUD OF THEM!!
Moka had an amazing vocal improvement "Lucky Girl Syndrome" definitely fits them better
그냥 모카 보컬이 씹창인데 럭키걸 신드롬같은 개날먹 이지곡이니까 평타를 치는건데 발전은 ㅋㅋㅋ
If Moka sings like this it's acceptable!
She can’t do low notes that’s why her encore isn’t that good on magnetic. hybe really struggles giving there idols comfortable vocal ranges for them proven in illit and lsfm
@@illxlaceitEXACTLY
@@illxlaceitya fr but she’s definitely improving 😗
@@gjsfshsw i guess but honestly I think her improvement could just be her less nervous but just my opinion lols
its cuz the vocal range suits her better if you hear a lot of Japanese singers too when they started to learn Korean there voice was very snazzy cuz of their accent
omg they’ve improved so much and are doing very well especially for rookies!
People are so ignorant. Its impossible to improve this fast... so this can only mean... OMG
MOKA ISNT A BAD SINGER IN THE FIRST PLACE. None of them are.
Look singing and dancing is very hard without proper breath support. This song is lower it seems os she isnt using that higher cutesy voice to sing.
Even with auto tune in a song it wont FIX a bad singer. It just makes it sound smoother. Even with a shaky voice ot cant fully correct that. These girls are talented they just neednti build stamina and practice singing and dancing more often.
yes thankyou
I'VE BEEN SAYING!!
This is so good ❤
minju's vocals are out of this world.. 🤩😍
Im glad Moka is improving ❤😊
They improved so much omg
There is some improvement in their stability, but they really need to improve on their vocal ability and breath
не только им, всем k-pop артистам
true
@@bbinngyou must sound better than all of them right? Because I highly doubt that. Please shut your mouth because I know for a fact you aren’t at Wendy’s level or even close to her.
ILLIT CAN SING 🤧❤️ They're stable while dancing 🦋.... But magneis not comfortable for them hybe should give them this type of concept for their vocals
Moka’s outfit is soo cute!!
beautiful voice💗
Be so serious
Moka is getting better day by day!!❤️
Always good just can’t do low notes
Bro She's an idol who should be good before debuting and not wait to be good
@lyi6x she's also a child! hope this helps!
@@aneyoku Moka is already 18 years old. I don't think she's a child. You have to admit she's bad at singing
@@q-2xthey couldn't choose their debut date and besides 18 is bearly an adult let's be real
라이브 어쩌고 얘기하는것도 지친다 걍 가수들 전부 핸드마이크 들고 불렀음 좋겠다 아니면 90년대 가요톱텐으로 돌아가던지
so many people hating in the comments but these girls just seem like they haven’t gotten enough vocal training. they sound decent considering #1. their age, #2. their previous experience, and #3. their time to prepare (and lack thereof.) i’ve seen clips from both magnetic and lucky girl syndrome and i can tell that they seem to fit this song more vocally than magnetic, and that this is probably the company’s fault for not recognizing their strengths and weaknesses vocally in order to curate something that fits all of the girls.
Honestly if another group performed like this I feel like no one would be complaining. It’s normal for idols to sound out of breath when they’re dancing, most do. The problem with kpop Stan’s is they expect every group to have every member be a Beyoncé level performer, singer, dancer ect. When that’s just not realistic.
You are fearfully and wonderfully made💙✝️
와 ㄹㅇ나 초딩 때 입던 멜빵 청치마더
when they didn't doing it good, people are mad and a lot comments hating on them by hiding behind 'we aren't hate them, we just being critical'. But look they sing good now, where's your so called critical comment?
I just know people more excited hate on things than being supportive, pathetic
if they’re singing better in this video, why would people be critical…? that doesn’t make any sense😭😭
@@tarmlktea4699 they said those hate comments written by them is not hating but critical. For me, use bad words is indeed bullying. If they were being critical before, they can be critical now. Criticism is not just about bad thing, you can be critical about good thing as well. But where are those people now? It just proving that they just want to hate rather than "being critical"
i dont get what the point of this comment is? people are being critical or 'hating' on magnetic encore stages because lets be honest, it was kinda all over the place.
in this video, they are obviously better. thats why there are less 'hate' comments. what, do you want to see more? like bro?? they improved or sound better, theres not going to be as much critical comments...
@@areqqx.people who hate these girls won't admit they hating on them, that's why they said 'i don't hate them I just being critical, but girls sing so horrible they never improve. There were contestants who can sing better than them, they shouldn't debut in the first place.'
And now they improve and i am questioning where are those people now? If they indeed being critical, they should come and say 'yeah they sing better now, they must be practice so hard after what happened last encor, good luck for them'
That is critical, when you did bad, people give criticize so you can improve and do better next. And when you already did good, they should give you feedback.
But what happened here is people just want to say something bad, they just simply hate these girls. Like look at the comments here and that encore video. Which one do you think have more comments? Which one do you think people will bring it back after five years later? I'm guessing it will be that encore video, why? Cus that's how bad people are, they just having fun by hating on things, they use their energy and time for hate rather than support. Don't you realize there are less people here for support these girls, even if they said bad words before then they came here to support, those people are indeed critical and want illit to improve. Not like people who just came when idols sing bad or made mistake.
im so proud of them they got better ❤❤
They have improved I'm so happy 💗💗
This one sounds good actually ❤
Moka has been improved...and all of their vocals are very good and soon they'll be talented
네추럴 청순미를 생각했나본데 헤어밴드에서 기절ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 1차 클렌징하다 불나서 뛰쳐나온 내 모습인 줄
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
They have improved so much!! I’m really proud of them! Though they do need more vocal lessons! They really did well on this one! And if u think they didn’t sound good, try singing, and dancing at the same time,
Yes especially moka im so happy for them they will surely sing full live in performances,illit fighting!!
근데.... 직업이 아이돌인데.... 당연히 노래하면서 춤춰야하는거 아닌가...... ?
우리는 아이돌이 아니니까 당연히 춤실력도 부족하고 노래실력도 부족한데.... 아일릿은 최소한 직업을 잘해야.... 하지 않나?
의사가 수술을 못해도, 처방전을 못내려도 괜찮다는 말인가? 선생님이 학생 가르치는 것에 영 소질이 없어도 괜찮다고, 우쭈쭈해줘도 괜찮다는...... 건가?
라고 소신발언을 합니다.
they are so much more comfortable with this song! im glad ❤❤
Moka cutie, ❤️😍
.....
@@RTo-g7j shes adorable
I’m glad that people are seeing the improvement. The dance is still super energetic but their singing is more stable than in magnetic. They didn’t choose when to debut so the important part now is that they keep practising, improving and gaining more experience with dancing and singing live
Fr! I'm glad this video the comments are saying positive things but the other vids about the girls it's just a war zone and someone screaming about their vocals
They are finally singing live and you can hear their footsteps on the microphone if you listen closely
first one sung but the others werent singing much at all...Are you deaf?? you cant tell the difference? funny stuff
I love Moka’s voice so much
It reminds me of Go Won
REAL
Moka's vocal here is really good, this is really her song and she fits here(her vocal range too)
Moka improvment !!!
I love her voice ❤🎉
모카가 제일 열심히 노래 하는듯 하네
진짜 하도 이슈여서 오랜만에 아이돌 가수 이름을 다 외우게 되네요😂
suka banget sm idol yg kalo dikritik jadi makin improve
Their live singing slays ✨
MOKAS HW8R IS SOOO CUTEE😭😭
see when a song suits you..that's what happened to Moka here folks ..she's always been good coz i watched her R u next performances before.
활동을 이어가는게 애기들한테 과연 괜찮을까...ㅠ 우선 멈추고 소속사에서 애들케어 좀 신경써주고 재데뷔하면 안될까 너무 이쁘고 귀여운데... 악플때문에 멘탈관리 안될까봐 무섭다
they soounds better here holy shit these girls need to keep this pace up and they'll bloom more like a flower in a harsh winter
YESS I APPRECIATE THE CRITISIZM INSTEAD OF BLIND HATE!
Helppp 😭 im in love with Wonhee's outfit 🎀😭
love how eng cmts are 'Moka is gettin better' and Korean cmts are 'Why do they keep poppin up after uninterested them' 'are they school kids?'😂
HELPPP FR I'M SOBBING😭
pls, one dude said the concept is infantile regression 💀💀
@@melouromi HELPP
They are literally jobless
@@xxcardi-of7lm they're kind of.. right though? they DO look like school kids, it's obvious with moka.
Moka's hairstyle so cute ,how a doll😊
Moka improved a lot!!!!!!
There’s a lot of improvement so amazing 🤩
Moka seems so much better here. She doesn't sound perfect but she sounds GOOD. They are all doing great !
Wonhee’s voice is so pretty and breathy
The way moka sings so cute:)
I dont even stan illit but i never understand why they get so much hate .They srent as bad as yall make it seem
Their vocals are average like 90% kpop ggs that yall hype.
I feel like why yall are so focussed on them is because they are ending your faves on charts.
omg real😮
but moka and iroha are well below average
they aren’t really good at singing but some of these people are taking it too far and i’m also scared that it will become a huening bahiyyih-level hate train against moka in particular
@@chiisjyshe sounds fine here while doing foot work.. which mean SHE WASNT A BAD SINGER IN THE FIRST PLACE
Shocked that moka was actually the better one considering how much ppl were witch hunting her
Moka is one of the cuest 5th gen idols for sure
I cant answer you under my comment bc f$$ yt algorithm ripped all my comment so I will answer here
All YG artist goals will be world tour concert with live music and live performance!
YG will never waste time and money to debut some girls who cant sing live and use pre-recorded. I think YG or BM knows these "pre-recorded" excuse, that's why they change all latest BM to perform with mic and live music without backing track.
It is very clear that you are BM anti fan too
@@nongnaphass8828 I have answered your other comment but nothing I have said is anti Babymonster. I like Babymonster, especially Asa. What I don't like it lying delulu fans like yourself who are toxic towards others groups while sincerely believing that very clearly pre-recorded performances are live.
That is anti behaviour. I haven't said a single negative thing about Babymonster, only you guys AKA the delulu fans, the typical YG fans. I hate that the Babymonster fandom has become like the blinks.
I'm an OG V.I.P, I think it's a disgrace what you guys have done to the reputation of YG groups fans.
@@vergil8833 sorry but you are really dishonest to yourself! You are typical hybe fandom who has always accept the low quality idol and always make excuse for hybe gg by sayin that other group is pre- recorded while baby monster clearly sing live. But STILL playing victims assss always. I saw your other comment only praising under illness gg lol
@@vergil8833 disgrace is only for hybe fan, illness fan and illness gg🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I'm glad that they're slowly improving
Improved a lot!!!!❤❤
Moka sounds good here
Moka Improved her vocal 😍
Iroha and moka’s ponytails are so cuteee
Y una look it’s very CUTEEE i love it 😭😭
노래 잘하는 구만