ranking 10 different versions of tinker bell ⏰🧚🏻✨
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ก.ค. 2024
- there's no arguing that the most famous fairy in the world is tinker bell, having made dozens of appearances in various forms of media since her introduction back in the 1904 play 'peter pan'. today we decided to rank some of the different versions of tinker bell that have appeared in film and tv over the last 100 or so years. which is your favorite?
intro 0:00
disney's tinker bell 3:36
the adventures of peter pan 9:01
fox's peter pan & the pirates 11:21
hook 13:09
peter pan 16:29
the disney fairies franchise 18:08
neverland 20:10
once upon a time 22:15
world of winx 24:32
peter pan & wendy 26:36
the rankings 30:00
follow us! 🌸
/ moderngurlz
/ moderngurlzz
/ moderngurlz
/ moderngurlz
get in touch 💌
moderngurlz@night.co
contact@moderngurlz.com
editor 🎬
aalyiah victoria
www.aalyiahv.com/
music! 🎶
/ future-james-pure-imag...
Music by Tarious Hill - Out Of Season - thmatc.co/?l=5A8754D3
Music by Brodie Love - Tall Glass Of Juice - thmatc.co/?l=651385D0
Music by Gil Wanders - By The River - thmatc.co/?l=69ABD9D5
intro/outro by
nicole w.b
/ cherryinferno
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. All the videos, songs, images, and graphics used in the video belong to their respective owners and this channel does not claim any right over them. - บันเทิง
Fun fact: when Peter Pan (the play) was first staged, Tinker Bell was a special effect to make it look like a little ball of light was flying around. As a joke, they listed a non-existent actress, Jenny Wren, as “playing” the role. But the Inspector of Taxes didn’t know that, and launched an investigation into “Jenny Wren”’s tax evasion.
As someone currently getting screwed by the tax department, this does not surprise me
@@ethansloanI am laughing so hard because 1) it's hilarious & 2) taxes are so absolutely ridiculous that I enjoy the wasting of the IRS' time 😂😂😂😂
That's so interesting! What's cool about that name they used "Jenny wren" is that during WW1 and 2 the British government started the "WRNS" or 'women's royal naval service' to give women a way to fight for their country. "Jenny wren" was what the male service members often used as a term of endearment (not the most welcome one I'm sure) when referring to female service members who worked for the WRNS. Considering that the story of Peter pan usually takes place during that time makes it really interesting that they put thought into a silly alias for an unvoiced character.
I wish the Disney Fairies Franchise would make a return one day. It was so much fun and such an interesting concept for Tinkerbell’s origins. Her fairies friends in the franchise were iconic too.
Not if they make lame and black. No thank you.
Yesss i also want them to come back, but i also want their series to end because disney only cares about money now a days instead of their storys
@cristalblackstar8177 ironic when the word black is in your username.
@@cristalblackstar8177💀💀💀
@Flyboy1953 and we shouldn't forget the friends from the books, Prilla, Rani, Becky, Bess, Fira as well Lily
“You know you’ve gotten old when Captain Hook becomes the movie’s eye-candy” 😂
Truth!
😂😂
OUAT Hook has entered the chat
@@alyssapinon9670 Yup, he was cute and more guys should try wearing eyeliner. It looks good
The Disney animated version, hands down. We get to see Tinkerbell and her home life aside of being Peter Pan's sidekick.🧚
Theres actually a lot of collection of movies (even a series) on the Life of Tinkerbell and her friends, and books (before the Tinkerbell and Peter Pan) You can check those out if you want, those were my fave when I was a kid.
@@Kamotea_kyutie oh yeah!! I remember those, I loved them as a kid, too. 🤩
@@ashlismith8596 I am so glad its your fave too, only a few know about the tinkerbell movie series where I am from sadly 😔, but glad to know that there are people out there loves and knows them!
I didn’t even know that Tinkerbell is from Peter Pan, movies were so good
@davidroberts1321 yea that's what really sad about it, Tinkerbell does have quite the temperment and can be moody at the heat of the moment (just like the fight she had with Terance from the move "The Lost Treasure", and I like that aspect of her as you could see that she still some flaws herself and is trying to work it through seeing how it effect people around her and her decision, nevertheless, maybe there is something more we didnt know why Tinkerbell acts like that towards Wendy.
It’s honestly scary how far Tinkerbell went to get rid of Wendy away from Peter. She’s like the jealous girl who’s been friend zoned by her crush and her motto is, “If I can’t have him, no one can.”
I really hated her in that movie I’m sorry but she sucked and I love tinker bell
That makes her more interesting
It's a story for children... things are obviously exaggerated
Narrator: Something changed that day inside Tink. Something snapped.
TinkerBell: He replaced us. Come on.
TinkerBell's Friends: No Tink. He only replaced y--
TinkerBell: HE REPLACED ALL OF US! Didn't he?! Now come on!!!
Narrator: They were lost. Cast off. Unwanted. Then they found Captain Hook and his crew....
Usually the "If I can't have him no one can" would result in Peter being the one who she tries to get rid of.
2003’s version of Tinker Bell really stands out for me because of how much personality the actress adds to the character through her facial expressions and movements. All of her energetic expressions are also a great contrast to Wendy, who is definitely more calm and collected.
I love the personality, but I hated this version of Tinker Bell mostly because she came off as mean-spirited to me as a kid.
@@anafano1613 As she was in the novel. Why do books always have to be messed with to make a film? Preserve the character as the author created them. That's Tink in the 2003 film. Peter himself is horribly unlikable as described in the book. He's a really nasty little piece of work and still has his baby teeth, too.
Yes, I think Tessa didn’t do her research… Peter and Wendy is based on the novel written by J.M Barrie which was the first literary iteration of Peter Pan other than his small feature in “The Little White Birds”. Tinker bell did not have a huge role in the novel… that’s probably why she lacks depth in the corresponding film.
@@hollygeorge4688and she also doesn't have "character development", neither does Peter really. That's not the point of the story, and them both being stuck in a childish, immature state contributes to the narrative
@@anafano1613she IS mean spirited. That’s the point
instead of disney making remakes why dont they make more fairy franchise movies? i'd love to see a conclusion at least! i loved the movie series so much!!!
Fr. Tbh they should've featured the fairies in the remake if they really want diversity. Casting a black actor as Tinkerbell doesn't do it justice because there's already another black fairy in the Disney Fairy universe.
Sadly, it probably won’t happen. The last Fairy franchise film was released in 2015 and the division of the company that made these films was shut down in 2018, so they likely won’t be making any more.
@@GreybellYup. At that point it is like Disney is thinking that being black is something coincidental. Which is just as bad as blackface according to me. It is like they don't have ideas how to make a good story. Well Black Spider-Man was a good movie. So you know you can write a good black character and people will like it.
OUAT’s Tinkerbell’s clothes were the absolute best. I would have liked to see more of her interacting with other Neverland characters. I would have liked more of her in general!
I agree! I also really like the actress
@@shortylove876 Absolutely! She’s really got that fairie/pixie look!
the casting in ouat in general is very good. I loved the actress as Tinkerbell
My nickname at school growing up was Tinker Bell because I was tiny, blonde, and I was known to have a short temper. I was also a creative kid, and I drew fairies quite a lot. Tinker Bell has a special place in my heart because of that 🧚🏻🔔✨
Lmaooo samee!! One time this dude called me tinkerbell and my boyfriend heard it and the name stuck 😂 its the cutest thing ever I love it
I grew up with Tinker Bell movies, and this may be nostalgia speaking but I think that they did a lot for Tinker Bell’s character, more than any other adaptation (besides the original movie, who gave her the iconic appearance she has today). I mean, that is by far the adaptation that gives her the most development, character, and agency.
the reason disney picked tinkerbell to be their mascot for the early disney world advertisements was because she was popular enough to be recognizable, but not so popular that if disney world failed, the company's whole branding would have to be redone
The Disney fairies franchise was literally my childhood, so yes, I would be very interested in seeing a video about it.
Disney animated (pixie hallow) tinkerbell is my favorite. We see how she is on her own.
I would kill for a ModernGurlz Disney Fairies video. Those movies were my entire childhood.
I was really into the Disney fairies franchise as a kid and teen despite the fact that I actually disliked Peter Pan ( as in the character, though the movie wasn't exactly my favorite either). I was so upset when they shut down the Pixie Hollow website. The Tinkerbell movies will always be my favorite depiction of the character.
The fact you considered Tink from World of Winx unique enough to place her in a ranking was really nice 💜
And as a Disney Fairies fan I'd definitely love to see a video about them 🧚♀
I was about 14 in 2003, and I had the HUGEST crush on the Peter in Peter Pan 2003. It prob ranks 3rd in my Peter Pan movie favorites but he was so cute when I was a kid.
He was about my age when I first saw that movie and was my sexual awakening
I mean, who didn't at the time
I was 11 and had SUCH a huge crush on him!
I was about 12 and I did ask my grandmother that movie for Christmas. But I believe by that time I had turned 13 and thought I was too old for it so I never watched it. A bit ironic to fell too old for Peter Pan!
I loved the Disney sequel Return to Neverland that had come out prior however (although I disliked most of the Disney sequels). That Tinkerbell has unlikable qualities too but not as much as the original so I think she is the best if these were ranked separately.
Third huh? I'm curious as to the rest of your ranking. As a big fan of the book, it's my #1.
I love Tinkerbell from OUAT, from all live actions she's the most identical to the cartoon, even her personality and story are so accurate, despite we never knowing her "true" origin story from the book or cartoon, the one the producers chose is very good.
Tinkerbell is such an interesting character, I think the dichotomy between her and Wendy has developed into a classic Jackie, Marilyn-esque, right up to Peter being unhappy with both options
I like this. A JFK Peter Pan movie would be so messed up, but so interesting.
6:38 "We could have forgiven the bosom but not the pony-tail!" 😭
What was the problem with the pony-tail? I was so confused at that!
If the books could count, Gail Carson Levine's Tink is iconic. Love her to bits
The World of Winx prequel gettingto shine is heartwarming tbh ☝🏾
I LOVE tinkerbell… I wish OUAT did a spin-off for the fairies… there was sooo much tension with blue and tinkerbell
Honestly yeah, I totally would have watched it. The way fairy society works was bizarrely interesting whenever it showed up. Blue has ultimate authority, fairies can't fall in love, they can lose and regain their wings, and they can become dark fairies. Definitely enough material to work off of.
I highly recommend the Disney Fairies novel trilogy by Gail Carson Levine (author of Ella Enchanted)! The writing and characterization are very in depth and engaging, and the artwork is beautiful 💗
Tinker bell launched my fairy obsession. The book series, Tales of Pixie Hollow had a major hand in making me the avid reader I am today. She’ll always have a special place in my heart 🥹 the fact that I still read fairy stories (smut 💀 where my ACOTAR stans at? 👀) to this day is a testament ! 😂😂😂
I’d love to see you ranking the adaptations of the little mermaid 🧜🏾♀️ ❤
we NEED a disney fairies franchise video!! I NEED IT! 💖😫 I am very much interested🥺
yes we need Disney Fairies Franchise video!!!!
I love these "ranking different versions of" videos, but they almost always somehow have an OUAT connection and I'm just dying for you to do a video on the show. Honestly, you could probably do several just on Regina's outfits! 😂
Bro the Disney Fairies movies were my SHIT as a kid!
If I'm not mistaken Disney's Pixie Hollows Series was a prequel to Tinkerbell meeting Peter Pan (each movie was leading up to her meeting him). In Fact I believe Captain Hook and Tick-Tock the Crocodile were shown in the series as well (The movie where they meet the pirate fairy). I remember seeing somewhere that the last intended movie for the Pixie Hollows series was her meeting Peter Pan (which would have been a prequel to the 1953 movie), but it's unfortunate that the series got cancelled so soon.
I thought the OUAT version was absolutely adorable! Her hair and clothes were pretty inspired and her actress is good too.
Fairies are my absolute favorite magical entities, sobseeing these videos about them make me so happy 🧚♀️ 🧚♂️
I actually grew up with the Disney fairies books, rather than the movies- but I grew to love the movies later in life. I’d love a video diving deeper into the franchise as a whole!!
watching peter pan (2003) as a kid and having a crush on both peter and wendy was eye opening to me at the time
my personal bias would've switched #3 and #1 around, mostly because I grew up with those movies and because I loved Pixie Hollow and playing the online game and everything. I wish there was some sort of conclusion, since asking for solo films for all of the fairies, like there was with Fawn, is too much to ask for. I agree that I think a segue into how she and Peter became acquainted would've been nice because we got Hook's origin story and yet nothing about Peter/how he got to know Tink and also anything about the Lost Boys. Having that conclusion of sorts would've been great but I'll take what we got
thinking more about this and her friendship with the other fairies is so strong that it makes me wonder how things would've turned out after she met Peter and chose to go adventuring with him. I know it would've made things super emotional amongst the fairies and Tink since they're so close, almost like sisters.
A video on Pixie Hollow/Disney Fairies would be great! I love your videos, they shed light onto things that I don't really think about a whole lot/don't have much time to look into, and you manage to put down a lot of info and history in a nice and succinct manner.
Damn imagine getting mom zoned by the guy you like 💀
😂
Happens more than you think. Think of men who use their wive as a mom; she cleans up after him, looks after him like a child etc
DEFINITELY INTERESTED IN A DISNEY FAIRIES FRANCHISE VIDEO THANK YOU QUEEN
i have so much nostalgia for the 2003 live action peter pan omg,, the "i do believe in fairies! i do! i do!" chant is so iconic, and that movie is the singular reason why i like thimbles so much and always choose it as my piece in monopoly lol
I know there are rumors of Jennifer Lawrence portraying Tinker Bell in a live action solo film and not only do I feel it would be a good role for her comedically, but since Tinker Bells story isn’t as known and clear to the general public it could be very interesting.
Loved this list and video! Thanks for sharing :)
Personally, as much as I love the pixie hollow fairies movies and books and computer game haha, I always always wished Tinkerbell would have been moodier/crankier/brattier in that series. She has her moments for sure, but I felt they held back a lot since she was the main character. I liked her flaws, they make her fun in the original movie and why I think she was so memorable along with her super cute design. And this is just me gushing now, but I love when she’s angry and her whole light turns red, so cute!
I didn’t even know Peter Pan was originally a play and then a novel. I thought the novel was the original
The 2023 tink looked more like Iridessa.
Something Disney could have done was have multiple fairies in the Peter and Wendy movie. Tie the fairy franchise with the petter pan movie.
My only gripe about the 2023 Peter and Wendy is that they had different actors portraying Mr. Darling and Captain Hook. Traditionally, they were always played by the same actoe
I love the tinkerbell movies that were made in the 2000's&2010's I agree that we should have gotten at least one more movie with that franchise they were all so creative and really knew how to scratch that fantasy itch for me as a child/teen
I would LOVE a Disney Fairies video. Would love to hear you talk about the character designs, particularly the seasonal designs.
Oh may god I'd die for a disney fairies video from you!
I’m still obsessed with the 2003 version. The best.
we NEED a disney fairies dedicated video
Please do that video about the Disney Fairies franchise 👀🙏💖🧚 I heard they had a final movie about her meeting Peter in the works before it was cancelled.
I wish they would bring the Disney Fairies franchise back, some of my favorite fairies only existed in the books like Rani, Dulcie, Prilla, Beck, Fira, Bess and Lily.
It would be nice if they were adapted to TV or a special.
I would've also liked a film centered around Iridessa considering she always felt like she was sidelined or just kinda there most of the time.
Maybe Rosetta or Silvermist too because Rosetta's funny and Silvermist I feel was underutilized.
Fawn, Vidia and Tink especially have had their time to shine (not including new fairies like Periwinkle or Zarina)
I guess you could count the sequel as being Tink and Terrence's movie but I don't.
Especially considering Terrence never appeared again after the second movie, either Tink killed him or he moved away because he was tired of her s**t.
I also liked Terrence's friends too, they were so funny and iconic they deserve a spinoff honestly.
I would love to hear your take on the animated franchise:")) it's such a huge part of my childhood
"You know that place between sleep and awake, that place where you still remember dreaming? That’s where I’ll always love you. That’s where I’ll be waiting."
The 1924 Peter Pan movie is way more American than the Disney version, because the Darlings are literally from America. John and Michael say they would rather die Americans than become pirates, and they raise the American flag on the ship after defeating Hook.
is that the one anna may wong is in? haven't seen it but want too
@@heatherparisi8250 yes it is.
Yes yes yes! I'd love a full video on the Disney fairies
Have you already ranked Alice (in wonderland) versions, of the character?
I'd love a Disney fairies video!
From my understanding regarding the Tinker Bell and the Disney Fairies franchise, yes the franchise was meant to tell about Tinker Bell's origin story but also tell how Tink and Peter met on the franchise's finale. This never happened, most likely bc of the most current films from the franchise didn't quite perform as well compared to the previous counterparts. Is quite sad because it was basically one of the reasons why the franchise was made but also bc I am sure fans are eager to know how the two characters met and want to see the chemistry (whether romantic or platonic) between the two characters that we didn't get to see from the Peter Pan movies.
Also, I am not sure how invested you are in the lost media community but I wanted to mention that there is this lost piece of media of what the first Tinker Bell movie could have been before its official release. This TH-camr by the channel name of sarahserif made a very informative video about it so I recommend watching her video. You can also talk to members of the lost media community regarding the film.
It made me so happy to see World Of Winx's Tinker Bell on this list 🥺🥺
Please make a video on the Tinker Bell movies, especially the scrapped first one which was gonna be called "Ring of Belief"
Another vote for a video on the Disney Tinker Bell & Fairies franchise. Yes, please! 🧚♂️🧚🧚♀️
PLEASE make a fairies franchise video!! the movies, books, online game and DS game was my entire childhood!!!!
YESS PLEASE make a video about the Tinkerbell movies😭🙏🏼
I’m so happy you covered World of Winx!
Love this! And YES PLEASE do Tinker Bell fairy franchise! 😍😍😍
I would LOVE you to do a video on the Tinkerbell movies! ❤ Some of my childhood favourites, they're so underrated!
19:54 we actually almost get the origin story for PeterPan in the first Tinkerbell movie, but John Lasseter said that he "won't support the Tinkerbell movie if PeterPan would show up"
.
Fun fact, we also almost get PeterPan origin story in an upcoming Tinkerbell movie right after the Legend of The Neverbeast, but it got cancelled since the dvd sales are declining & Disney Toons studio closing.. There goes our PeterPan origin story 😭
@Flyboy1953 i think John Lasseter said that Peter would overshine over Tinkerbell, since this is her movie. But still, the original script (Tinkerbell and the Ring of Belief) WAS SO MUCH BETTER than the one we ended up getting.. And Peter's role was so minor also..
I really hate how John Lasseter cancelled that movie & make the writers rewrite 90% of the script 😭
Hook is so nostalgic, I love that movie!
I also love how Tinkerbell's movies give her more personality, and the first one is still my favorite because again = nostalgia.
“This is MY opinion…just don’t be an asshole about it.” preach!👌🏽
omg i would love if you did a deep dive video of the disney fairies lore. i was obsessed with the books, movies and the online game when i was a kid!
i really love your ranking videos, i always rewatching it because its super entertaining, can you make more of these type of videos please😄and yes i wanna see the video about disney fairies tinkerbell and friends version, that would be amazing
I’d love to se you do a video about the Disney Fairies franchise!
Early gang!! So hype for this I've loved tinker since I was like 6 💚💚
My favourite Tink will still forever be Gail Carson Levine's version from the books. It properly ties in the Neverland fairies to Peter Pan's story and has him make a couple cameos without making him the focus of the story. The books portray Tink as passionate, confident, and brave while still being hotheaded, moody, and dramatic. Some of my favourite characters that don't appear in any movies are from these books.
Oh my gosh... the level of customization on the online game was UNREAL and I can't find screen grabs or playable versions anywhere. Does anyone have leads? ✨
Since Pixie Hollow was shut down by Disney for various reasons very little is left of the game. However there is a group of individually crowd funded artists who are working to recreate the game so it can exist again! They are called We The Pixies and I would highly recommend giving them a look! They are doing amazing work and if you were a fan of the game when it existed you will love what they are doing!!
@@300happybunny WHAT this is so cool!!!! I'm obsessed with projects like this, like what folks have done with Toontown and Club Penguin. You are fantastic, thank you so much!!!
YESSS IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS VIDEO! tink has been my favorite forever! 🥺 please please make a video about the tinkerbell movies/book series! its so dear to me and id watch it even if its hours long LOL
you should do one of these for thumbelina!!!
yes, I adore Thumbelina!!!
@@lilwinborneYES!! I just re-watched the 1994 version yesterday😄(an all time favourite 🥰)
That will be great idea but I would put that Barbie Version rank 1
Hook's Tinkerbell outfit was also like that because she was filmed on green screen and as it needed a lot of incrustation they needed an outfit that was, not to big, not to tight, not flowy, no reflection, no little pieces, no green/blue colour, no white for the wings etc... A nightmare for a good design.
Also they called her tinker nightmare or whatever but she was alone on green set for weeks sometime without Spielberg, her husband cheating on her was public, she was harassed by paparazzi, etc.. She said that Robin Williams was saving her time and moral during the production.
Loved thisss❤ hope u talk about tinker bells moviess
Love your ranking Tessa!
Tessa I think you know we would all be very very interested in a Disney Fairies video
I was obsessed with all of the Disney fairy books. I’m all for a video on the fairies!
I would love a video about The Disney Fairies! I love those movies I really thought we would get 1 more 😭
Love this type of content!
The actor who plays Peter in Neverland, was one of the lost boys in 2003 Peter Pan. He was also Golden Compass.
I’d love a video on the Tinkerbell movies!! I watched all of them so many times growing up 🥰
"Jane is a pretty unlikable protagonist" if tinkerbell (who i love) gets to get away with shitty behaviour cuz she is a child dealing with her emotions then jane, a child living during a war and having to be more mature, gets to be mean sometimes too
i actually think it's great how they clash with eachother and grow from it, they both did mean things but in the end have to apologize and work together
Here, yes, I would like a video all about Tinker Bell movies
I'd absolutely love a deep dive into the 2008-15 Tinkerbell films. They were my favourite.
I need a Disney fairies video!
Tinker bell remains forgotten by most I didn’t even know there were 10 versions lol
I don't think it's that she's forgotten so much as sidelined. There have been several versions of Peter Pan, which naturally means several versions of Tinkerbell, but because she's mute, small, and a side character she doesn't stand out. We know about her in theory but not in practice.
@@RoseEyed well said !
Great video, as per usual. This channel is awesome
I’d love a vid about Disney fairy franchise! I always felt like the content was hard to find but I remember loving the books and movies🧚🏿♀️
Good you mention these shows
when i was a kid i was OBSESSED with the disney fairies' movies and comics, i would love a video about the topic.
I would love a Disney Fairies video! Their worldbuilding and and animation are so good!
I was literally just thinking that now that I'm older I'm finding Captain Hook attractive in the 2003 movie right before you said it
Season 3 (first half) was my favorite one of once upon a time. I love the dark atmosphere of Neverland and that Peter Pan was a villain and Tinkerbell lived there in the woods and trying to survive. I wish she had more scenes with Peter, Hook and Wendy, maybe to show how she arrived in Neverland. But I wish there were more Neverland backstory-scenes in general
I like when tinkerbell was sassy
yes i would loveee to know more about the disney faries franchise pleaseeee