Well, I wouldn't say it's his fault really, considering it was still Harry that caused her death, he tried to save her and maybe he could have done it a different way. If you notice, in this one he immediately uses his spider web not to catch MJ, which didn't work with Gwen, but to propel himself forward with more momentum, this way he catches MJ himself and then uses the web again to slow his fall and land on his feet. So he did learn from that experience because he couldn't save Gwen that way. That is in a way closure for sure, it's how at least something good came out of it. He could save this other Spider-Man's loved one, because he knew how *not* to do it from his own loss.
For us, it was never his fault, for him it absolutely still was and he still blamed himself and couldn’t forgive himself. But what this did do for him was give him closure. He just needed to know that he could do it. And now he knows he could have. It didn’t work out how he wanted to the first time, but he knows now that it was all circumstances, and that he always had it in him to save her.
My heart busted out of my chest when I watched this scene in the cinema. Those who remembered Gwen were hysterically screaming as MJ fell….followed by cheers after the save.
@@feldspar3858 not everyone has the time nor the drive to do so. Happy for u for having all the time in the world and the will to do it. Doesn't mean everyone "should". :)
@@trendreact415 - I MAKE time. There is a difference. Also, people shouldn’t be THAT emotional about something if they know NOTHING about it. Pretty simple. 🙂
I like the detail that the less experienced Peter reaches for her just like younger Amazing Spiderman did with Gwen, really showing how instinctive that mistake is; and how much Amazing Spiderman must have thought about it and retrained his response.
Begs the question would it have had more impact if Hollands shot a web and Goblin’s impact made it miss, leading this save, or would that make Holland seem less like the primary Spider-Man
@@conorbarnett6379Ooooooo, make Holland shoot the web, but show Garfield already stepping up and launching himself toward MJ, knowing that it wouldn't work... I don't know if it would have had the same impact though. Truly fearing for MJ's life or knowing that Spider Man has/had/will learn? I would expect movie makers to show this and 1000 different other things before actually releasing so they get the reaction they were hoping for. 😅 Pre-screenings. Answered my own question.
My favorite moment in the whole movie. You just know that he has replayed that moment a million times in his head since Gwen died. When it happened again, he was just... Still in that moment.
Dagnabit. This scene will forever make me cry. Every single time. Why did I watch a video where it repeated over and over. I'm gunna have friction burns under my eyes from constant rubbing.
The second it showed Andrews silently screaming NO!…I instantly lost my freaking mind y’all! Cause I realized where they were going with that “redemption for not being able to save Gwen” and I instantly started crying I mean like seriously tho…the tears were flowing way before they even landed ffs! But man, 😮💨 I gotta say that, even tho I was already crying at that point…the thing that really sent me over the edge and into the dreaded “Ugly Crying” territory, was a combination of both the look on his face when he asked if she was ok and then seeing the tears in his eyes when she affirmed that she really and truly was okay🥹👌 I think that one reason why I got so emotionally affected by it was that unlike most people I actually loved Andrew Garfield’s version of Spider-Man so freaking much! Even tho I “grew up” (16 yrs old when the first one came out and I watched all of Toby’s in theaters on opening night for each one as they came out…so yea, to say I’m a huge fan of those would be a massive understatement and yet I still stand by saying that I actually like Andrew’s version being my favorite Spider-man of them all 😅👍😉so…yea, seeing that redemption moment was extra impactful to me
I remember when they gave Andrew that brief moment after saving MJ my entire theater gave the most respectful applause. Outside all the cheering and shouting we did in other parts, we all recognized what happened here and instead chose to be respectfully congratulatory for this moment. First available showing in my area, biggest theater for many many miles, largest room/screen, best seat in the house. Hope I don’t forget that time for a good while
Gwen in heaven watching this unfold: NO! Oh my god, he can't lose her the way mine lsot me - wait! Yes .... yes baby, go! Go! Go go go go goooo YES! You caught her......she's gonna be okay .... you're gonna be okay, sweety, I love you so much even looking down on you. You're gonna be okay. :)
Aside from a few reactors, it seems like a grand majority (not only in this video) just don’t/can’t understand the gravity of Andrew’s Spider-Man pulling this off. Maybe that’s a good thing.
Andrew's ability to portray emotion is so unmatched. The way he can express the guilt of not being able to save Gwen through his facial features alone is absolutely worthy of all the praise in the world. It gets me teary eyed every single time I watch this scene. I also love that they gave him a second chance to redeem himself, and save another version of himself from falling into the dark path that he once walked after Gwen died. I adore the dynamic of these older and wiser Spider Men being able to pass along their knowledge and experience to this newer, younger Spider Man that is still learning.
imagine thinking for years and years, how you could have done it. should have done it. the mistake you made and what went wrong. the choice to make raimi save her was such a perfect touch.
The thing is, Andrew was destined to do this. He had to lose Gwen, so the "main" Spider Man, could have his life. The first time, Andrew waited for the right moment to save Gwen. She died. He didn't wait for the right moment this time. He went through it and took his moment. I could see a lot of us having this regret. (Edit: Including me.)
I can only imagine andrews peter running through every possible thing he could have done differently to save gwen, and the regret of never getting to do things differently...until this happened, and he finally was able to let go
What would have been even more sweeter , if he was swinging into the action and this was happening he looked over jumping onto the debris and pushed himself to catch her. Perfect, but . This also was great
Out of all the awesome moments in the movie, this still remains my favourite scene. It just had so much more depth and emotion compared to the others. I'm so glad Andrew got his second chance are Sony screwed him over.
I enjoy watching Reaction videos but is it just me who thinks "if these are real fans and it seems they are....why didn't they see this movie in the theater?" I couldn't wait to buy my ticket for this movie
Out everything in this amazing film this scene was the big one for me. Andrew stole the show though this film so did Tobey to even though this film was meant for Tom Holland.
Less than a day after I watched this movie I realized I had problems with how they handled a majority of the film. But this scene? Genuinely the best scene in the film.
Gwen Falling: th-cam.com/video/h0vU3s0Kzng/w-d-xo.html
-----
0:03 Movies with Mary www.youtube.com/@MovieswithMary
0:33 Addie Counts www.youtube.com/@AddieCounts
0:56 Alex Hefner's TV & Movie Vault www.youtube.com/@alexhefnerstvmovievault
1:29 ItsAPrimate www.youtube.com/@ItsAPrimatee
2:07 Liala Naema www.youtube.com/@LialaNaema
2:37 Magic Magy www.youtube.com/@MagicMagy
3:08 Major Reacts www.youtube.com/@MajorReacts
3:39 Natalie Gold www.youtube.com/@NatalieGoldReacts
4:04 The Perfect Mix www.youtube.com/@theperfectmixx
4:25 sesskasays www.youtube.com/@sesskasays
4:51 Snoopers Gonna Snoop www.youtube.com/@snoopersgonnasnoop
5:05 Trixy Blue www.youtube.com/@TrixyBlue
5:42 CineBinge www.youtube.com/@CineBingeReact
6:01 The Octobers www.youtube.com/@TheOctobersReact
6:28 See Jane Go TV www.youtube.com/@SeeJaneGoTV
6:58 SebScreen www.youtube.com/@SebScreen
In an interview, Andrew said that this was the scene that made him accept the movie.
The redemption was so well-deserved and gave him the means to finally heal.
@@AdderTude I wouldn't call it redemption because he didn't do anything wrong with Gwen, that was the best he could've done.
@@americxnoperhaps it’s best to describe it as redemption in his own eyes
@@americxnoIt is because he blamed himself
Andrew's Peter never needed redemption, because it was never his fault. He needed closure, and he finally got it.
Well he finally happy again now and can be Spider Man for real again but I still think he need a 3rd movie for a proper closure for him.
It wasn't completely his fault but he does share atleast a bit.
For him deep inside it was his fault. It's like he could've done just a little better and it could change the whole outcome.
Well, I wouldn't say it's his fault really, considering it was still Harry that caused her death, he tried to save her and maybe he could have done it a different way. If you notice, in this one he immediately uses his spider web not to catch MJ, which didn't work with Gwen, but to propel himself forward with more momentum, this way he catches MJ himself and then uses the web again to slow his fall and land on his feet. So he did learn from that experience because he couldn't save Gwen that way. That is in a way closure for sure, it's how at least something good came out of it. He could save this other Spider-Man's loved one, because he knew how *not* to do it from his own loss.
For us, it was never his fault, for him it absolutely still was and he still blamed himself and couldn’t forgive himself. But what this did do for him was give him closure. He just needed to know that he could do it. And now he knows he could have. It didn’t work out how he wanted to the first time, but he knows now that it was all circumstances, and that he always had it in him to save her.
My heart busted out of my chest when I watched this scene in the cinema. Those who remembered Gwen were hysterically screaming as MJ fell….followed by cheers after the save.
I damn near lost my voice screaming
Followed up with the save from the one who couldn't save his own girl. That has GOT to be heart wrenching.
Redemption
The best redemption of spider-man ever, made me so emotional and so happy for the other Peter Parker
Gwen Stacy will be proud.
You mean Peter 3.
Man let me tell you, I finally felt closure after watching this. Gwen's death was so devastating.
Why? It’s comic book lore for over 40 years.
@@feldspar3858 news flash, not everyone reads the comics, nor is everyone seeking to
@@trendreact415 - Maybe they SHOULD.
@@feldspar3858 not everyone has the time nor the drive to do so. Happy for u for having all the time in the world and the will to do it. Doesn't mean everyone "should". :)
@@trendreact415 - I MAKE time. There is a difference. Also, people shouldn’t be THAT emotional about something if they know NOTHING about it. Pretty simple. 🙂
We all knew it was coming. But, goddammit, it was still beautiful to see. Plus, the emotion on Andrew's face said it all.
*chef's kiss*
I like the detail that the less experienced Peter reaches for her just like younger Amazing Spiderman did with Gwen, really showing how instinctive that mistake is; and how much Amazing Spiderman must have thought about it and retrained his response.
Except he didn't reach his hand out with Gwen, he threw out a web.
Begs the question would it have had more impact if Hollands shot a web and Goblin’s impact made it miss, leading this save, or would that make Holland seem less like the primary Spider-Man
@@conorbarnett6379Ooooooo, make Holland shoot the web, but show Garfield already stepping up and launching himself toward MJ, knowing that it wouldn't work... I don't know if it would have had the same impact though. Truly fearing for MJ's life or knowing that Spider Man has/had/will learn? I would expect movie makers to show this and 1000 different other things before actually releasing so they get the reaction they were hoping for. 😅 Pre-screenings. Answered my own question.
@@Mrsplifferdoodle Pretty sure it was since it Andrew and Gwen were too far from each other ;-;
My favorite moment in the whole movie. You just know that he has replayed that moment a million times in his head since Gwen died. When it happened again, he was just... Still in that moment.
Dagnabit. This scene will forever make me cry. Every single time. Why did I watch a video where it repeated over and over. I'm gunna have friction burns under my eyes from constant rubbing.
Same.
Man, I already reacted to sad things yesterday, so now both my eyes hurt from friction burns lol
@@deathgod5372 I feel that lol. I don't know why I do it to myself either
The second it showed Andrews silently screaming NO!…I instantly lost my freaking mind y’all! Cause I realized where they were going with that “redemption for not being able to save Gwen” and I instantly started crying
I mean like seriously tho…the tears were flowing way before they even landed ffs! But man, 😮💨 I gotta say that, even tho I was already crying at that point…the thing that really sent me over the edge and into the dreaded “Ugly Crying” territory, was a combination of both the look on his face when he asked if she was ok and then seeing the tears in his eyes when she affirmed that she really and truly was okay🥹👌
I think that one reason why I got so emotionally affected by it was that unlike most people I actually loved Andrew Garfield’s version of Spider-Man so freaking much!
Even tho I “grew up” (16 yrs old when the first one came out and I watched all of Toby’s in theaters on opening night for each one as they came out…so yea, to say I’m a huge fan of those would be a massive understatement and yet I still stand by saying that I actually like Andrew’s version being my favorite Spider-man of them all 😅👍😉so…yea, seeing that redemption moment was extra impactful to me
I'm so freaking happy Andrew Garfield's Peter Parker/Spider-Man finally got his redemption arc after 7 years.
The reason Andrew came back in this movie above all was to get a second chance to save his Gwen, his MJ
I mean that's not his "mj"
@@Mrsplifferdoodle he means Gwen is his "MJ"
I remember when they gave Andrew that brief moment after saving MJ my entire theater gave the most respectful applause. Outside all the cheering and shouting we did in other parts, we all recognized what happened here and instead chose to be respectfully congratulatory for this moment. First available showing in my area, biggest theater for many many miles, largest room/screen, best seat in the house. Hope I don’t forget that time for a good while
LITERALLY one of the BEST scenes in this movie!
One of the best scenes in the whole movie!!
Not a single one of these reactions reached the necessary level of hype that this moment deserved. I can't with people not matching my energy. 😅
Damn. Got me in the feels all over again !
🥺😭❤️
omg Major reacts, bless that lad. There was something so pure about his reaction XD
All in favor of Andrew’s character given a second chance say, yes.
YES
Yes
Yes.
Yes
Yes 👍
Genuine heart in mouth moment in the cinema watching this moment, goodness gracious.
Gwen in heaven watching this unfold:
NO! Oh my god, he can't lose her the way mine lsot me - wait! Yes .... yes baby, go! Go! Go go go go goooo YES!
You caught her......she's gonna be okay .... you're gonna be okay, sweety, I love you so much even looking down on you. You're gonna be okay.
:)
This made me teary 😢
@@chestylarue475 ❤️
Same
@@blueroninstudiosGo fk yaself.... 😢 I didn't need this crap.
3:23 What tf was that reaction 😂😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
man got a little too excited 😂
@@lostastronaut8291 Exactly what I was thinking 😂😂😂😂
He came
I tear up at that part ever single goddamn time
peter couldnt let another of himself go through that pain.
If you watched this in cinema when it released
now those were epic reactions
One of the greatest moments for Spider man ever
Aside from a few reactors, it seems like a grand majority (not only in this video) just don’t/can’t understand the gravity of Andrew’s Spider-Man pulling this off. Maybe that’s a good thing.
2:17 “oh piss off” 😂😂😂😂😂
He redeemed himself
Tobey's Spider-Man: Spider-Man
Andrew's Spider-Man: Amazing Spider-Man
Tom's Spider-Man: Home...Slice?
Andrew's ability to portray emotion is so unmatched. The way he can express the guilt of not being able to save Gwen through his facial features alone is absolutely worthy of all the praise in the world. It gets me teary eyed every single time I watch this scene. I also love that they gave him a second chance to redeem himself, and save another version of himself from falling into the dark path that he once walked after Gwen died. I adore the dynamic of these older and wiser Spider Men being able to pass along their knowledge and experience to this newer, younger Spider Man that is still learning.
And the chemistry between Andrew and Gwen is so much more realistic and passionate compared to the others.
Another great touch andrew learned from his Mj dying that him diving and letting gravity do the work is much faster then tryna let his web catch her
imagine thinking for years and years, how you could have done it. should have done it. the mistake you made and what went wrong.
the choice to make raimi save her was such a perfect touch.
5:29 hey that was my reaction when the wound opened again...
This is why Andrew is the best in my opinion ❤❤❤
I haven't cried this much in my entire life 😭😭😭
The thing is, Andrew was destined to do this. He had to lose Gwen, so the "main" Spider Man, could have his life.
The first time, Andrew waited for the right moment to save Gwen. She died. He didn't wait for the right moment this time. He went through it and took his moment. I could see a lot of us having this regret.
(Edit: Including me.)
I can only imagine andrews peter running through every possible thing he could have done differently to save gwen, and the regret of never getting to do things differently...until this happened, and he finally was able to let go
the guys: "aww"
The girls:
What would have been even more sweeter , if he was swinging into the action and this was happening he looked over jumping onto the debris and pushed himself to catch her. Perfect, but . This also was great
this time peter learn how stop someone fall
Andrew garfield spider man got his second chance to save someone to his redemption to gwen.
i have yet to find someone that sobs as hard as i did during this scene.
Out of all the awesome moments in the movie, this still remains my favourite scene. It just had so much more depth and emotion compared to the others. I'm so glad Andrew got his second chance are Sony screwed him over.
wow i havent seen @sesskasays reaction in years
one of my faves of the Walking dead reactions
Hard to believe non of these people saw the movie in the theater
Andrew acted the shit out of this movie.
that scene broke me when i saw it in the theater.
Why TF is she saying Justin like he's gonna turn into Miles Morales and swing in?😂
04:26 dudee haHHAHAHAHAHHAA
I enjoy watching Reaction videos but is it just me who thinks "if these are real fans and it seems they are....why didn't they see this movie in the theater?" I couldn't wait to buy my ticket for this movie
PTSD...
I realized like half way through that mj’s scream kinda sounds like a hawk lol
If u have a girlfriend name gwen in a marvel universe better prepare for her funeral 😂
I got deja-vu… not in a good way.
(Showing Amazing Spider-Man 2 flashback about Gwen Stacy death)
Imagine in another timeline Andrew caught Gwen so he used his web here and got MJ killed instead
Out everything in this amazing film this scene was the big one for me. Andrew stole the show though this film so did Tobey to even though this film was meant for Tom Holland.
Why do half of these people act like they’ve never seen a Spider-Man film before, let alone AS2
Less than a day after I watched this movie I realized I had problems with how they handled a majority of the film. But this scene? Genuinely the best scene in the film.
The movie does have a lot of problems but this scene isn't one of this.
Yeah I just watch the film again and I agree with both of you but I still think it the best Spider-Man movie so far.
Where has @majorreacts gone?
沒人比Andrew更明白蛛絲救不了MJ 明白這件事的Andrew又怎麼可能失手
Infelt like I got punched in the gut when I first saw this
Suggestion: Stranger things
Running up that hill
Please & thank you ❤
100% agree!
I dare you to tell me that scene aint make you feel shit lol gtfo Andrew made a grown man cry
Why they reacting like this. When the movie is out already like 3 years
Trash movie ever
Trash comment ever